r/mobydick • • 19h ago

After almost a year, I finally finished it

34 Upvotes

I started reading around December last year, and I never thought it would take me this long. It was quite a difficult read for me because English is my third language and I'm only 18, but still, I persevered.

I don't even really know how to feel about this. I'm quite happy that I finally finished it after so long, but like, damn, this book has and will leave such a mark on me. I just genuinely don't know what to say right now, but I just felt like making a post


r/mobydick • • 12h ago

How old do you think the characters are?

8 Upvotes

If Ahab is 58, what about everyone else? Here’s my guesses:
Ishmael: 26
Queequeg: 25
Flask: 25
Stubb: 37
Starbuck: 35
Pip: 14


r/mobydick • • 16h ago

A few questions to discuss on Moby Dick

9 Upvotes

Just finished the book, had a few questions I was interested in hearing some opinions on. Happy to share my own thoughts as well, but curious to hear how others interpreted these parts of the story and the symbolism behind them. One of things I found funny about Ishmael's narration is he will often go into exhaustive detail on what he thinks elements of the tale symbolize, almost like he is analyzing the text next to the reader. There are parts of his concrete world that he is not afforded the ability to do this with, and these three questions revolve around those parts.

What is your interpretation of Ishmael being the one to pick out the ship?

Queequeg tells Ishmael that Yojo has chosen him to choose the boat. In the Patrick Stewart adaptation they make a bigger deal out of this, Ishmael is an inexperienced landlubber who actually tries to get out of making the choice, which is what made me think of the question. Ishmael's choice effectively dooms them, why does Yojo direct Queequeg to give Ishmael power over the choice of vessel, any other thoughts on this?

What do Ahab's wife and child symbolize?

I am sure there has been commentary on this before. I found the young wife and child to be the most incongruous part of Ahab's nature, more so than the two wills battling within him, or the other dualisms contained in the captain. I think part of this stems from it being hard to picture the man in any sort of passion unrelated to whaling or the whale. My favorite part of the book is that moment of lucidity towards the end where he clearly regrets his marriage and what he has inflicted on his family. But apart from that, the wife and especially the child so rarely come up in the book. Why, and what do they mean?

The Crew

This is less of a question and more something I'd like to hear thoughts on. For such an iconic literary character I was surprised how few references to Queequeg were present in the later stages of the book (obviously ignoring the bulk of the middle part where he just talks about cetology without much reference to individual crew-members). This got me thinking about how Ishmael chooses who he describes and gives identity to. I was also thinking how abruptly the carpenter and the blacksmith are introduced pretty late in the book. I understand of course that not every crewman can be described in exhaustive detail, but we hardly know the goings about of any but the most prominent sailors, and even some of the most integral characters we only know a few things about. Modern authors want you to hear the interplay of discussion/opinion amongst casts of characters, even to the detriment of the plot sometimes, and in contrast Melville does this only very deliberately. But as a consequence you never know much about, say, the rest of Fedallah's men, who you can imagine as having a fascinating relationship to the other sailors. Or even something so consequential as the only man who dies on the voyage before the final hunt (the guy who falls off the ship)- this guy never even gets a name. So if it was a question I guess it would be, when and why does Ishmael choose to immortalize a crew member in his story, versus when he doesn't?

There are truly so many questions that would be great discussion topics. I would also appreciate it if anyone could link some contemporary readings of the book, for I be but a tyro in the literary seas.


r/mobydick • • 22h ago

The Harrowing Ordeal of the Essex, the Ship That Was Sunk by a Whale

Thumbnail
explorethearchive.com
17 Upvotes

It sank on this day, in 1820.


r/mobydick • • 1d ago

Just got this and am so excited

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

Started the audio book earlier this week and was so taken by the book decided to actually physically read it, i find it helps me really appreciate books more. Chapter 32 sold me on buying a physical copy!


r/mobydick • • 1d ago

Typee (Ch. IV)

30 Upvotes

Reading Typee and it’s amazing how good he was from the jump, but wanted to share this passage from early on because I almost spit out my coffee laughing at the end so unexpectedly.

“At what an immeasurable distance, thought I, are these two beings removed from each other. In the one is shown the result of long centuries of progressive Civilization and refinement, which have gradually converted the mere creature into the semblance of all that is elevated and grand; while the other, after the lapse of the same period, has not advanced one step in the career of improvement, “Yet, after all,” quoth I to myself, “insensible as he is to a thousand wants, and removed from harassing cares, may not the savage be the happier man of the two?” Such were the thoughts that arose in my mind as I gazed upon the novel spectacle before me. In truth it was an impressive one, and little likely to be effaced. I can recall even now with vivid distinctness every feature of the scene. The umbrageous shades where the interview took place⁠—the glorious tropical vegetation around⁠—the picturesque grouping of the mingled throng of soldiery and natives⁠—and even the golden-hued bunch of bananas that I held in my hand at the time, and of which I occasionally partook while making the aforesaid philosophical reflections.”


r/mobydick • • 2d ago

When you come to sit down before a meat-pie nearly one hundred feet long, it takes away your appetite.

Post image
30 Upvotes

The Whale As A Dish


r/mobydick • • 2d ago

my art 🥺

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

But do I look very old, so very, very old, Starbuck? I feel deadly faint, bowed, and humped, as though I were Adam, staggering beneath the piled centuries since Paradise.


r/mobydick • • 2d ago

Nihilist? Me? Ishmael? Who told you? Just my mind rambling a lot.

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • 3d ago

Is the Bantam Classic edition with an introduction by Charles Child Walcutt a good unabridged copy of Moby Dick for a beginner? (Please no spoilers).

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

I bought this used book at a thrift store and I'm wondering if this is a good copy to use to read Moby Dick for the first time. It appears to be unabridged (the first page says it contains the complete text of the novel). Should I read the introduction or anything else before beginning with chapter I? Are the etymology and extracts a standard part of reading Moby Dick and should I read them first? Please avoid giving anything away that will be revealed in the book later on. I'm hesitant to read the introduction because that has happened to me before.


r/mobydick • • 4d ago

What’s your favorite chapter in Moby-Dick?

41 Upvotes

Mine has got to be The Symphony. Not only is it an incredibly moving part of the book, but it is in my opinion one of the most important ones for understanding who Ahab is as a character.


r/mobydick • • 5d ago

What (specifically) gets abridged?

11 Upvotes

Finishing my first read of Moby Dick (currently at Chap. 108, "Ahab and the Carpenter"), which I started reading for fun over the summer and was totally blown away by how A) totally hilarious it is and B) genuinely profound and expertly-written the prose is. I'm a PhD student (not in literary studies) and I learned my university was offering a PhD-level course on the topic, so I jumped to join. I'm expected to present an argument on the book, and I feel my argument is pretty well-formulated, but I want to discuss the novel's history as a text that is frequently abridged, and what the abridging process removes.

I already know that generally, "what gets abridged" boils down to the ""non-plot"" chapters, the ones which mostly discuss the history / practice / culture of whales and whaling.

But to be more specific, does anyone happen to know:

- Generally, is there an article / resource which covers the print history of Moby Dick?

- What the more popular abridged editions of Moby Dick are

- Which chapters are the most frequently omitted

- If there are historical periods in which certain portions are abridged (i.e. "in the 1940s, the pre-sailing chapters in Massachusetts were often omitted, but by the 1960s, the Massachusetts chapters were retained, while the chapters covering the interior of the whale were removed." [This example statement is something I just made up--no factual veracity, but just the type of information I'm looking for!])

I know that if I were an English PhD student, this is precisely the type of research I should be spending a lot of time doing myself! But I'm not a literary scholar nor am I working on a significant project on Moby Dick for my own scholarship. Just looking to see if there are any Moby Dick afficianados out there who know where I can find this type of information.


r/mobydick • • 6d ago

Moby Dick First Published ( 14 Nov 1851)

Post image
125 Upvotes

Moby-Dick is now considered a great classic of American literature and contains one of the most famous opening lines in fiction: “Call me Ishmael.” Initially, though, the book about Captain Ahab and his quest to catch a giant white whale was a flop.

Its author, Herman Melville was born in New York City in 1819. As a young man, he spent time in the merchant marines, the U.S. Navy and on a whaling ship in the South Seas. In 1846, he published his first novel, Typee, a romantic adventure based on his experiences in Polynesia. The book was a success and a sequel, Omoo, was published in 1847. Three more novels followed, with mixed critical and commercial results. Melville’s sixth book, Moby-Dick, was first published in October 1851 in London, in three volumes titled The Whale, and then in the U.S. a month later. Melville had promised his publisher an adventure story similar to his popular earlier works, but instead, Moby-Dick was a tragic epic, influenced in part by Melville’s friend and Pittsfield, Massachusetts, neighbor, Nathaniel Hawthorne, whose novels include The Scarlet Letter.

Read the complete article on History.com: https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/moby-dick-published

Notable maritime and folk musician A.L. "Bert" Lloyd (https://seashanties4all.com/groups-artists/a-l-bert-lloyd/) helped arrange and popularize traditional maritime working songs for the 1956 film adaptation of the book, notably popularizing the iconic chorus line "blood red roses" in the traditional shanty "Blood Red Roses". Lloyd appeared in the film acting as a shantyman (sea-shanty leader) during the early sequence when the whaling ship Pequod is warped out of the harbor to begin its hunt.


r/mobydick • • 6d ago

Ahab’s Wife?

Post image
37 Upvotes

Has anyone else read this? It was my wife’s book club read (which she read BEFORE reading MB 😂🤦🏻‍♂️). I enjoyed it and it dovetailed nicely into MD.

There are a few other “companion” books to MD that I liked -

In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex by Nathaniel Philbrick

Why Read Moby Dick? by Nathaniel Philbrick (maybe unnecessary, for this crowd)

Ahab's Rolling Sea: A Natural History of “Moby-Dick” by Richard J. King (really interesting)


r/mobydick • • 6d ago

Avast! Bring Your Dog-Eared Melvilles to the ‘Moby-Dick’ Bar.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
24 Upvotes

As Herman Melville wrote, “Yes, there is death in this business of whaling — a speechlessly quick chaotic bundling of a man into Eternity.”

Not everyone would read these words and think: cocktail bar. But for Bryan Schneider, the connection was obvious from the first time he read “Moby-Dick.”

“I’m always reading from the bartender’s perspective,” he said.

Schneider spent years tending bar for some of New York’s premier hospitality luminaries, Toby Cecchini, Julie Reiner and Daniel Boulud among them. All the while, he was thinking about Melville’s novel, which turns 175 this year.

Particularly inspiring was a description of a whalers’ watering hole called the Spouter-Inn, where the narrator, Ishmael, casts in his lot with the damned crew of the Pequod:

Crossing this dusky entry, and on through yon low-arched way — cut through what in old times must have been a great central chimney with fireplaces all round — you enter the public room. A still duskier place is this, with such low ponderous beams above, and such old wrinkled planks beneath, that you would almost fancy you trod some old craft’s cockpits, especially of such a howling night, when this corner-anchored old ark rocked so furiously.

“I’d never read a vivid description like that before — so poetic,” Schneider said. “There were just so many cues for a bar! Yes,” he admits, “you could call it my white whale.”

Access full gift article, NO PAYWALL.


r/mobydick • • 6d ago

New Moby-Dick bar for the Manhattoes!

28 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • 7d ago

Rereading Moby Dick via Handcopying

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

I read Moby Dick for the first and last time over ten years ago to begin my literary journey.

It left an impression for a number of reasons (one of the larger ones being its size), and ever since I have wanted to reread it.

Many obstacles have convinced me to put off rereading it, mostly because there is so much else to read (and, again, its size comes to mind).

But now enough time has passed, and I have changed sufficiently as a person (to say nothing of society), that I have increasingly come to feel this behemoth worth the effort of revisiting. Yet, I still could not find it in me to give it a serious try.

Well, now I may have outsmarted myself: why not combine my newfound passion for penmanship with my obsession with reading and autodidaticism?

I have begun to handcopy the novel beginning from the first chapter. I'm not sure if I will continue the project to the end of the book, but I think kt will be fun to try, even if it becomes moreso a project to augment my handwriting and get me started on rereading this great text!

Bonus: the style of handwriting I use (which I'd either Spencerian or Business Penmanship, depending on who you ask) dates from around the time Melville was alive.


r/mobydick • • 6d ago

Moby Dick. Came for the whale, stayed for the philosophy Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
15 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • 7d ago

How many years between forecastle and narrator Ishmael?

17 Upvotes

Is it possible to know how many years elapsed between forecastle Ishmael and narrator Ishmael? “I make no doubt it is Moby Dick himself for there is no account of his capture after the sad fate of the Pequod about fourteen years ago.—Ye Gods! What a Commentator is this Ann Alexander whale. What he has to say is short & pithy & very much to the point. I wonder if my evil art has raised this monster.” Herman Melville Letter to Evert A. Duyckinck of November 7, 1851. Reprinted in NCE, pp. 544–45.


r/mobydick • • 7d ago

MB wine

Post image
13 Upvotes

Saw this on offer at the LA Philharmonic. Love the reference of course. “Folly of the Beast”


r/mobydick • • 7d ago

That feel, when you finish the last of the epilogue, and close the book

Post image
70 Upvotes

You feel… fulfilled


r/mobydick • • 8d ago

ahab stirner Spoiler

Post image
27 Upvotes

And we saw, shuddering, that he was standing surrounded by five dark ghosts that seemed to have just materialized out of thin air


r/mobydick • • 7d ago

Pequod vs. Samuel Enderby

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • 8d ago

Herman Melville praising Cervantes in Moby Dick, Ch. 25

Post image
15 Upvotes