r/metaNL • • Jul 17 '21 This Popcorn

Ban Appeal Ban Appeal Thread

204 Upvotes

Rules:

Don't complain. Contest or appeal.

Appeals require time + evidence of good behavior + a statement of what your future behavior will look like. Convince us you'll add value to our community.

If you spam us we'll ban you

Don't ask about getting temp bans removed 1 hour early. Reddit timer is weird but you will be unbanned when it's over.


r/metaNL • • Aug 23 '20

you first can we ban politics

149 Upvotes

i understand some people want to talk about politics but like, there's subs specifically for that. people are just spamming political talk on this sub and i really am annoyed by it. i don't want to talk about politics of economics, post that stuff somewhere else please

only allow non political posts on /r/neoliberal


r/metaNL • • May 15 '26

OPEN Ban Jared Polis

127 Upvotes

Tina Peters attempted to subvert democracy and should remain in prison. Pardoning her because the President bullied you is the type of action that emboldens tyrants to take more power. As a community dedicated to the principles of liberal democracy I don’t think we should condone that sort of behavior.


r/metaNL • • Feb 05 '21

OPEN Increasingly hostile environment for non-american users

122 Upvotes

I've been putting making a post like this off for a bit, but after the Macron thread today I think it's time.

Since the american presidential election I've seen r/NL become less and less hospitable to anyone who is not american, but it's really gone off the deep end in the last couple of weeks.

Today there's this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/ld5kgq/macron_eu_shouldnt_gang_up_on_china_with_us/

But I've seen these direct quotes in the last week:

Nuke france

The french have never really been happier than they were under Pétain, for all their talk of republicanism

and numerous takes about how the EU should be abolished, europeans are worthless, etc. I fear that we're on the edge of a vicious cycle where european users start to be driven away or not want to engage on european politics which will only make it worse as an echo chamber forms. I'm personally very put off and I'm just an american who's lived in France, I can't imagine what actual french people feel like when someone say they were happier under Pétain.

So, I want to talk about what we can do to not go down that very ugly path. I have a few ideas, but I wanted to see what we could brainstorm and what might have support from the mods.

  1. We need to do something to try to get more europeans on the sub, and get the ratio of americans to non-americans closer to what it was prior to the presidential election. Any ideas here would be quite helpful.

  2. If we can get more effortposts around european politics, that would be great. Something that will hopefull trigger more good faith discussion than clickbaity news articles or editorials.

  3. Possible non-US only posting days? I'm not sure if the mods would be on board here, but I think this could be a good idea, I'm pretty sure a case can be made at this point that we need to pull out the big guns.

  4. I've started using the report button, and this is something everybody can do. The two comments above about france had been up for a long time but got removed shortly after I reported them, so hopefully nobody else had to see them.

If you have anything else to suggest, I'm all ears, and please let me know what you think about the ideas I've put forth here.

Edit: Spelling


r/metaNL • • Feb 20 '25

OPEN Add an "insufficient partisanship" rule

121 Upvotes

My main concern is people not hating rightoids enough.


r/metaNL • • Jul 19 '25

OPEN Please do something about Israel and Palestine

114 Upvotes

It's been nearly 2 years since Oct. 7, /r/neoliberal has been full of non-stop argument and I haven't seen the mods do a single thing addressing the underlying causes of the conflict, absolutely nothing that could prevent such schisms in the future. No serious attempt at implementing a two state solution, no serious attempt at freeing the hostages, dismantling Hamas, demolishing the settlements. They're just standing on the sidelines letting the war happen, just 'talking about it', and it's pathetic.

I'm sick of all the empty talk with no action. Upvote if you think the /r/neoliberal mods need to put their money where their mouth is and actually do something to stop the war.


r/metaNL • • Feb 10 '21

OPEN The Star-Spangled Banner should be played before each Discussion Thread 🇺🇲

103 Upvotes

The recent Mark Cuban/ Dallas Mavericks news about no longer playing the US national anthem, and today's decision by the NBA mandating that it be played before games, got me thinking about whether or not it should be played at the start of each DT. I think it should be, and I hope you all agree.

Obviously at a basketball game, you don't have much choice but to listen. Even if away from the court and in the restroom, you have to hear the anthem (unless you are hard of hearing, I suppose). You unfortunately have more choice and control online; for example, not clicking links or leaving it muted.

To ensure compliance with the mandatory playing of the national anthem before DT participation, I propose a separate website that plays a recording of the national anthem as well as some additional tidbit of information that each user will have to correctly answer a short quiz on before being able to post in that day's DT. The recording should not allow the user to have playback control and should not advance unless audio is unmuted. The quiz should only be 1-2 questions, maybe over a small clip of text-to-audio scraped from a random Wikipedia page for each user each day.

Thoughts?


r/metaNL • • Feb 09 '26

OPEN The main sub really seems to have become totally overrun with progressives such that discourse from a calm evidence based angle is getting challenging. There may be nothing that can be done but...is there anything that can be done? Reinstitute contractionary policy?

98 Upvotes

Hi there,

Long time participant in the neoliberal subreddit. Maybe for god 10 years at this point (originally I was a lurker).

I don't think I'm the only neoliberal who has noticed that the sub has become..completely overrun with r slash politics style vibes and people. They're ok people but the ability to engage in deeper dialogue on the sub has really really diminished over the years and moved away from the subs main original purpose.

Is there anything that can be done? Perhaps this has already been discussed before.

Once upon a time, the sub had contractionary and expansionary phases a la a central bank, where during contractionary weeks meme posts were banned and only effortposts and quality articles posts were allowed.

I'm of the opinion that this was really effective as a strategy to bring the tone of the sub back to where the mods (seemingly) wanted it to be. And then after a few weeks when the worst of the memers moved on reopening expansionary policy for a time, until things got kinda whack again and then contracting.

I move that the mod teams reinstitute this policy and become a kind of r slash neoliberal FOMC

Anyway, thank you for your time.


r/metaNL • • Aug 19 '21

RESPONDED Make the sub private NOW

98 Upvotes

Holy shit. My mom came into my room to bring me a plate of chicken nuggets and I literally screamed at her and hit the plate of chicken nuggets out of her hand. She started yelling and swearing at me and I slammed the door on her. I'm so distressed right now I don't know what to do. I didn't mean to do that to my mom but I'm literally in shock from the top post in /r/neoliberal today. I feel like I'm going to explode. Why the fucking fuck do regulars not know who Mr. Bernke is? This can't be happening. I'm having a fucking breakdown. I don't want to believe the world is so corrupt. I want a future to believe in. I want Bernke to be president and fix this broken country. I cannot fucking deal with this right now. It wasn't supposed to be like this, I thought he was the whole reason the sub existed???? This is so fucked.

The top post on the sub is from someone who has posted in /r/neoliberal at least 100 times over at least 6 months, and yet say this in the post:

Edit: I want to say this while it’s at the top of hot, I don’t know who Ben Bernanke is I just didn’t want to be a NATO flair

They don't know who the dank bank man is? Who have they been thanking every day? Do they think my shrine is a joke?

How does someone post 100 times on a sub for half a year and not even know what the subreddit is about?

/r/neoliberal is dead. Mandatory Bernke flairs for everyone for several months is the minimum we need to pull out of this crisis


r/metaNL • • Apr 09 '22

OPEN Heinz Doofenshmirtz flair

89 Upvotes

Dr. Heniz Doofenshmirtz should be available as a flair option.

He is a hard working immigrant success story, business leader, and a prolific inventor.

He lives in a skyscraper in a dense urban center.

His nemesis lives in the suburbs.

He is a active political figure and philosopher.

His wife left him.

Dr. Heinz Doofenshmirtz is a pillar of neoliberalism and should be added as a flair option.

Also Malarkey bot supports a Doofenshmirtz flair


r/metaNL • • Mar 09 '25

OPEN Regarding the attempted deportation of a Palestinian activist

85 Upvotes

Let me get something straight.

After a concerted public harassment campaign by Shai Davidai, who is currently banned from Columbia's campus because of a history of harassing students, DHS interrupts the iftar dinner of Mahmoud Khalil, an Algerian activist of Palestinian origin. Without providing a warrant, they barge past his pregnant wife on the presumption that his student visa is to be revoked. They discover that he has a green card, not a student visa, but take him into custody anyway, again without a warrant. Without providing the slightest proof, this individual has been slurred as being a terrorist, a Hamas member or sympathizer, without the slightest proof or criminal charge to that effect.

Now imagine my surprise when members of this community, a supposedly liberal one, are defending what is obviously an attack on free expression, on unfounded allegations of his involvement in harassing students, or saying that he was being stupid for expressing his opinion as a non-citizen, as if non-citizens are not equally entitled to have thoughts of their own.

If this were a Mexican green-card holder protesting against the deportation of undocumented immigrants were subjected to the same treatment, nobody here would think to justify an authoritarian crackdown, and anyone doing so would be banned. But I guess because he's Palestinian, all bets are off? Sorry, this is just sick, and I would like the moderators to take action on what is clearly a rampant bigotry on this subreddit.


r/metaNL • • Jan 21 '25

OPEN Okay *now* can we ban twitter links?

85 Upvotes

And if not, we should unban RT for the sake of fairness.


r/metaNL • • Jan 25 '22

RESOLVED Inflation Automod

85 Upvotes

Add an automod response to the word inflation that says "What a stupid son of a bitch."


r/metaNL • • Dec 18 '20

RESPONDED I make a post in r/Drama criticizing neoliberal and I get banned from the sub?

80 Upvotes

You mods always end up ruining every good community.

I basically pointed out that you barely know the meaning of neoliberal and you ban me for some benign criticism, exactly proving my point. Besides, I took the initiative to participate on your fundraiser through “loveforlandlorfs”. Just for you banning every mention of us.

If neoliberal is somewhat a good subreddit it’s precisely in spite of you, not thanks to you.

This is not a ban appeal btw. Just wanted you to know the state of your sub 😉

To the internet janitor that smugly replied and locked the post: Unironically dilate


r/metaNL • • Jun 23 '25

OPEN Stop using Israeli war crimes as an occasion to dunk on leftists

79 Upvotes

So in this thread about the EU finding Israel guilty of human rights violations, all of the comments are about Western leftists.

Some times I get the impression that people on this subreddit are more offended by slogans people shout at protests than by innocent people being deliberately and needlessly murdered. You can find leftists to be annoying or counter-productive or racist as you want, but for once can we show some empathy to people who have had their homes destroyed and families decimated? Is it too much to ask that people reflect on how their countries' unconditional support for Israel has led us to this moment?

Honestly I am tired of seeing Palestinians being butchered and people's respond be "yes, but those darn lefties haha." There is nothing wrong with pointing out antisemitism on the left, but when Palestinians' suffering becomes an excuse to talk about Zohran Mamdani it just comes off as so insensitive. For heaven's sake I wonder where people's humanity has gone.


r/metaNL • • Nov 06 '24

OPEN Request: Remove Kamala take automod

78 Upvotes

This is just gonna make us sad when we see it


r/metaNL • • May 22 '25

RESPONDED I'm tired pretending the mods aren't the problem

77 Upvotes

I've worked with several mods about the antisemitism problem here but it became more obvious over time that the remaining mods didn't care, and now it's clear that some of the mods I was working with don't even get it.

I'm tired of pretending I don't know what goes on behind closed doors.

Like when a mod said we should leave up antisemitic Josh Shapiro posts.

Like when a mod said "November 6 (when Trump was reelected) was October 7 for trans people."

Like when a mod said there's a lot of cover for antisemitism (which has existed for thousands of years, btw) because of Israel.

Like when a mod said an antisemitic poster shouldn't be banned because the subreddit needs "Muslim voices."

Like when a mod felt like they had to hide being Jewish because of how fucking bad it is, but you all still don't get it.

Oh and I'm tired of pretending I don't have all the screenshots.

You have all failed to give a shit about Jewish users in an attempt to appear even handed. And now almost all the Jewish users are gone.

Now more Jews are dead and the lies spread across the internet, including the lies you let spread on this subreddit, are to blame.

Great job.


r/metaNL • • Aug 06 '25

OPEN Banned for bigotry

76 Upvotes

I guess the mods probably know this post is coming.

I was banned for this post

https://imgur.com/a/pP3LvZ1

https://reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1mjga2r/updated_jewish_lgbtq_organization_that_was/n7b8468/

Because I pointed out that the organizers of Montreal Pride did not ban a specific advocacy group for being Jewish, but because they're anti-two-state solution political advocacy group.

That is literally not bigotry. The two state solution is literally the official policy of pretty much every developed European and North American country. That position (edit: anti-two-state position) is, and should be considered, radioactive. But I guess not on Neoliberal? It's the position of the mod team that representation of such an advocacy group needs to be included in a pride parade, why?


r/metaNL • • May 16 '26

OPEN Banning /u/jaredpolis isn't enough, we should dox him, too

75 Upvotes

Given his egregious behaviour, I am calling on the mod team to not ban /u/jaredpolis, but dox him, by publically disclosing and exposing:

  • His real name,

  • His employer and position, and

  • The address of his mansion


r/metaNL • • Jul 01 '26

RESPONDED Ban Governor Jared Polis

74 Upvotes

He has now fired multiple members of the Colorado Clemency board for saying they disagreed with the Tina Peters pardon

It’s ridiculous he is still unbanned.


r/metaNL • • Jan 07 '26

RESOLVED Do the right thing for once: retire the excessive partisanship rule

74 Upvotes

Republicans elected a fascist who uses ICE to kill innocent people

Not only that, when this happens, Republicans celebrate

They love it, they say everyone who dies to ICE deserves it and they will say it if it happens to you or I

This rule is bullshit during a fascist takeover of the country that is now threatening to take on Greenland and Canada with it

The Republican Party is behind this bullshit, they support it, they love it

Retire this bullshit rule


r/metaNL • • Jun 10 '25 This

OPEN Kiwi as a mod

73 Upvotes

I want to start this post by saying I have nothing personally against kiwi, but their behavior this year has been horrible for someone on the mod team. For a sub that promotes protections for immigrants and minorities (especially trans people), it’s insane allowing a mod to attack members of those communities because they had the audacity to complain about what they see as wrong with the country. The two big incidents include calling a trans person privileged for wishing to move out of Florida and telling American citizens to “go back to Mexico if America is the oppressor”.

“This take is so privileged it calls cocaine ‘stardust’.”

A few months ago, this post was made in metaNL. A trans poster in the DT vented about the future of them in America, which led to kiwi responding with the above comment. The poster then clarified that they were trans, living in Florida, and must leave the state to receive their healthcare. Very thoughtfully, kiwi said “You still have that option, or you can pay out of pocket, or move”. This exchange went on until she told the poster “It’s just insufferable how you Americans will do everything in the world to deny the suffering of people outside your borders.” In the aftermath, kiwi hopped on to give an “apology” that amounted to “I’m sorry you felt this way. Here’s some context and why you should be more cognizant in the future.”

“go back to Mexico”

The most recent incident was within the past day or so. Kiwi posted a fucked up comment telling American citizens to go back to Mexico if they view the government as oppressive. Plants comes in to run interference and say it’s due to being an ESL immigrant not understanding racial tropes. However, this isn’t using the words “articulate” or “well-spoken” to describe a black person and missing the subtlety of the racial connotation. This is plain text telling a group to go back to where they came from even though they are citizens. Any immigrant should know how harmful this phrasing is and how it’s used by nationalists worldwide. Again, kiwi comes in and gives an “apology” that is “I’m sorry you felt that way. Here’s context and justification for why I said what I said”.

Why I’m posting this

These statements fly in the face of the sub’s values and would have earned a normal poster some slap bans. I’m not asking for her to be banned, but I do think there should be a serious discussion on her future as a mod. She, at the very least, should apologize with no caveats, no explanation/justification of why she said what she said, and no deflection. It should be a clean "I recognize what I did was bad, and I'm sorry for it. I will do better in the future."


r/metaNL • • Jun 24 '22

RESOLVED Dont let p00bix write crisis stickies anymore: or how i learned how crisis management works

73 Upvotes

Recently, this was the sticky on the top of a controversial thread in r/neoliberal.

This ruling is bad, but acting like the world is gonna end or that we might as well give up is bad for both your own mental health and the mental health of the people who read your comments. No dooming; it actively worsens the quality of discussion and discourages action.

The excessive partisanship rule is being relaxed for obvious reasons-we're not going to ban people for justified anger at the Republican Party or GOP appointed judges. However, absolutely no calls for violence or authoritarianism will be tolerated. NO EXCEPTIONS.

Keep in mind that the vast majority of Pro-Lifers sincerely believe that all fetuses and embryos are literally children, and sincerely believe that this court decision will save millions of lives. By all means, report Pro-Lifers coming here to gloat or troll and we will ban them, but no matter how badly misguided these beliefs are, remember that they do not come from a place of malice. Treat those who support or are sympathetic to this ruling, and who are themselves respectful, with respect. DO NOT engage in personal attacks directed at other commenters. Also, DO NOT reply to trolls-just report and move on.

To assist lower-income women living in states where abortion is now prohibited access this healthcare resource, consider donating to abortion funds, which provide cash, lodging, and transportation, to women in need.

You can donate through ActBlue here. Alternatively, you can browse this article with links to abortion funds for individual states.

Even more importantly, remember to vote in November.

This post is actively antagonistic and accomplishes none of the the things it set out to do. Briefly perusing the comments in reply to this post will show that it provoked anger, mockery, and general disrepect for the mods.

In this post, I will break down each section of this sticky and point out where it is wrong. There will be a discussion on why it is wrong. Finally, I will construct a new crisis sticky that does none of those things as an example for the future.

1. "Calm down woman"

This ruling is bad, but acting like the world is gonna end or that we might as well give up is bad for both your own mental health and the mental health of the people who read your comments. No dooming; it actively worsens the quality of discussion and discourages action.

Telling someone to 'calm down' or 'relax' is an outward indicator of the mental state of the person saying it. People say these things when:

  1. They do not understand the emotion behind why someone is upset.

  2. They do not care that someone is upset.

This will make the person you are saying this to very angry because of a psychological response to being ignored. Primarily, using this type of language indicates to the listener that, in fact, you do not care or do not empathize with their position. This almost always has the opposite effect, and causes the person becomes less calm. If you say this often in your relationship, you may find that your wife has left you. 1

2. Lets be more vague

The excessive partisanship rule is being relaxed for obvious reasons-we're not going to ban people for justified anger at the Republican Party or GOP appointed judges.

Is anger now excessive partisanship? I have never seen anger banned as excessive partisanship. However, the real issue with this is that the excessive partisanship rule is already vague. Relaxing a vague rule is simply confusing! No one knows where the line is. In crisis situations you want clear communication. It's important to deliver information in a quick, clear, consise manner.

What is the above communicating? It's not communicating anything, at best, it is a needless digression. 2

3. What the hell?

Keep in mind that the vast majority of Pro-Lifers sincerely believe that all fetuses and embryos are literally children, and sincerely believe that this court decision will save millions of lives. By all means, report Pro-Lifers coming here to gloat or troll and we will ban them, but no matter how badly misguided these beliefs are, remember that they do not come from a place of malice. Treat those who support or are sympathetic to this ruling, and who are themselves respectful, with respect. DO NOT engage in personal attacks directed at other commenters. Also, DO NOT reply to trolls-just report and move on.

Posting pro-life talking points in the sticky of a thread kinda betrays the fact, doesn't it? Understandably, this became the biggest issue in the replies to the sticky. Taken as a whole this post says, "1) I dont understand why youre mad, 2) I'll ban you if you break the vague rules I decide on the spot 3) the pro-lifers have some good points."

The subtext speaks for itself. It takes sides with editorializing, and personal opinions should not be placed in crisis communication because it breaks all the rules of quick, clear, and consise.

When you are supposed to be a moderator, mediator, or someone tasked with fairly metering out rules, then you have a duty to stay out of the fray, at least in your official communications. If you don't, you may find yourself the topic of the discussion instead of the discussion. 3

4. Says who?

This sticky is unsigned. Is this is personal opinions and views of the author? Is it the combined view of the mod staff. Crisis communication should be followed with the signing of the exercising authority.

Frankly, the mod team as a whole has more credibility than one mod.

5. A template for the future

Let's now contruct a crisis sticky that effectively communicates:

Hey folks, hold onto your butts. There is a lot of anger at this issue, many on the mod team share it. However, we are going to continue enforcing all rules. This means no calls for violence, bigotry, insults, trolling, brigading, or bad-faith posting.

Please report any instances of these violations using the report feature.

-The mod team

First, establish understanding and empathy with the audience.

Hey folks, hold onto your butts. There is a lot of anger at this issue, many on the mod team share it.

This shows that you understand why people are mad and you validate that they are both stressed and angry without condeming or ignoring it.

Next, clearly communicate the rules.

However, we are going to continue enforcing all rules. This means no calls for violence, bigotry, insults, trolling, brigading, or bad-faith posting.

This is not vague and let's the audience, with fair warning, understand what is expected from them for posting in the thread and sub.

Don't forget the actionable item.

Please report any instances of these violations using the report feature.

This lets people know what you intend to do and what to do if they see someone ignoring the rules. This is an important part of 'crisis response', its the 'response' part.

Finally, sign it.

-The mod team

This lets everyone know its a united front and not whoever grabbed the sticky first.

6. The last part

Following these simple rules will help you communicate during crisis. It will calm, instead of inflame, and help everyone in the community. It will prevent mods from getting mercilessly dunked on and will increase respect for the mod staff. Ok, fine. Maybe that last sentence won't happen but its worth a shot. What do you have to lose?


r/metaNL • • Aug 15 '21

RESPONDED There needs to be a crackdown on anti-Afghan racism.

73 Upvotes

Will we see the mods crack down on the anti-Afghan racism, implying that Afghans don't want or don't deserve civil rights, or ones that paint the Afghan population as a whole as backward?

Mind you, I'm not talking about "ANA was bad", "ANA was unpopular", "Kabul government was unpopular" or even "the Islamic Republic was unpopular". But there is increasingly many comments suggesting that because the ANA collapsed, this indicated that actually Afghans love Taliban and hate women, and worse - that this is proof Afghans don't deserve rights.


r/metaNL • • Sep 19 '25

RESOLVED We should be allowed to criticise/make fun of hyper-progressive language like 'birthing people'

72 Upvotes

Back in August, I got a warning for a reply I made in a thread about overly progressive language. Since the post is deleted (https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1mxdgzf/was_it_something_i_said/naaplf5/) I will copy paste my exact post for transparency:


"And also, it is dehumanizing (ironically) more often than not.

If saying "Birthing people" instead of mothers or "people with vaginas" instead of women is someone's idea of being inclusive, that someone needs to have their head checked because they are effing insa....sorry, I mean "neurodivergent"."


The reason I am posting about it now is because I just got a confirmation from my modmail that it is, indeed, against the bigotry rules to make fun of this type of language.

Simply put, this is an absurd stance, the vast majority of people, including users in this sub, do not support this type of language. If you want to support it, go ahead, it's why the comments exist. But it's not bigotry.