r/metaNL • • Jul 03 '24

OPEN Perma everyone in that Biden thread

1 Upvotes

We have had a problem with annoying low-IQ median Redditors leaking into the sub, along with brigaders, that has hit critical mass.

I know I like to do bits and say that it's not a bit, but this actually isn't a bit. Just start banning everyone in there. Start with the most upvoted and egregious stupidity and panic and work your way down. "Don't be fucking stupid" is an unwritten rule.


r/metaNL • • Oct 18 '25

RESOLVED Mods I wasn't kidding about Goth AOC being the main reason you have no cis women. Like it's well-known the DT is a separate culture that dislikes birthrate threads; women should thrive there, but they don't because, like the rest of Reddit, any "attractive" woman is automatically sexualized.

0 Upvotes

See comment for highly upvoted example of this disgusting rubbish.


r/metaNL • • Jan 10 '23

RESOLVED This sub too has fallen to Islamic bootlicking

0 Upvotes

On the post about the teacher being fired for showing a picture of Muhammad, in response to the stickied mod comment about bigoted comments warranting removal, I commented that Islam was fundamentally horrible for supporting eternal torture and that therefore I wanted the ideology eradicated wholesale.

That comment got deleted and earned me a ban without my being informed of it. I then posted another comment on my other account mentioning this and that comment got shadow-deleted and likely my whole account shadow-banned too.

All this is not just unjustified but deceitful, and of course very ironic given the subject of the original post.

Presumably if I said I wanted to see fascism eradicated that wouldn't get deleted and earn me a ban, but people bend over backwards for Islam despite it being the most fundamentally horrible of all major ideologies owing to the fact that it most vehemently supports infinite suffering. Of all people, the users here should appreciate the utilitarian logic for hating Islam. And of course other religions that worship the same concept.

Now I realize that many if not most users of this sub would in fact be sympathetic to me, but this particular mod filipe_mdsr is absolutely misguided and misusing power.


r/metaNL • • Oct 09 '26

OPEN Why was my comment suggesting that there can be differences between trans and cis women removed for bigotry?

0 Upvotes

My comment:

I think it matters to any reasonable conception of justice. All potentially relevant facts should be available to a jury. XXs and XYs are different. Pretending they aren’t is silly. I do not think it should change the outcome, but that is irrelevant. Suppressing any information that could even remotely exonerated someone seems like a clear grounds for a mistrial.

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1x1nyso/killing_of_woman_may_have_been_justifiable/pewinrw/

This was removed due to "bigotry." It's neither bigoted nor is it wrong. We can be very supportive of our trans communities without pretending there zero differences between the sexes. There are plenty of trans women out there who have not undergone any hormone therapy, nor should they need to. We can support each other's rights to live their life in the way they see fit without pretending there can't be differences between the sexes. I'm really not sure why we would.

This was a discussion about a decision to declare a mistrial in a criminal court. Not exactly a place for uncomfortable discussions to be left unsaid. Perhaps I worded the statement poorly, and I suspected I'd be downvoted for having a potentially heterodox opinion on the subject, but it's not bigotry. I consider myself a trans ally after all, even if I may not see perfectly eye-to-eye with every trans person on every issue.


r/metaNL • • Dec 06 '24

OPEN Creation of a Brian Thompson/UHC flair

2 Upvotes

This might be spur of the moment but as another poster said, the amount of people who seem to be defending murder on the subreddit is antithetical to liberal democracy.

Yes, the US healthcare system is terrible (terrible is probably an understatement), and UHC itself has some part in that, but at no point should the conclusion thusly be "therefore this man deserves to be shot and killed"

As such, I'd like the mods to create a flair of one or both of these for a short period as a proverbial "middle finger" to some of the people brigading posts and otherwise condoning murder. The flair can be removed a bit after the killer is caught and brought to justice.


r/metaNL • • Jul 09 '24

OPEN Why is the Biden thread not even being remotely being moderated

0 Upvotes

you think this shit makes us look good, its garbage. That's when it isn't just pulling a Miami-Dade and calling every racial group that says they don't support replacing Biden stupid people that don't know what they want. Either moderate these threads or burn it. I don't care which but I'm tired of having to go in there and try to tamp down on this nonsense. Everytime I'm gone for more than an hour it flares up into another round of toxicity


r/metaNL • • Jul 11 '26

OPEN Clearly racist comments highly upvoted. No action. What is going wrong?

3 Upvotes

Around two weeks ago, I saw u/n00bi3pjs post here about the significant volume of racist content against Arabs and Indians going unaddressed on this subreddit.

I was scrolling around looking for something on Saudi Arabia today when I saw this comment:

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/s/K2nqtVrb5l

A comment saying no one with an IQ of 85 lives in Saudi Arabia with +243 upvotes and it remains up?

Yes, Saudi has an issue with human rights, but the rhetoric being used here is obscene. It is, without a doubt, hate speech.

Somehow, I can't imagine a comment about Israel saying that people who live there have a low IQ because of the country's record on human rights would stay up, much less get +243 upvotes. It gives me the impression that some forms of racism are defacto endorsed, or at least, tolerated on this sub.

This is a serious problem. I think the mods need to take more decisive action about racism targeted to certain groups that is clearly going unaddressed.

It should be instant perma bans for this kind of stuff. There's no room for racism in a liberal subreddit.


r/metaNL • • 9d ago

OPEN Are trans rights negotiable now?

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1xozx3a/post_election_i_want_to_litigate_this_trans/?sort=top

A couple comments were removed in the first hour, but after that, it's just a hundred heavily upvoted comments arguing that obviously trans rights are unpopular and should be taken away to appease the bigots, and that it's unreasonable to not want to meet the bigots halfway.

Are the mods still just too hungover to do their jobs right now? Tag me in for a day so I can ban every upvoted comment in that thread.


r/metaNL • • May 27 '25

OPEN Rampant double standards and bigotry on this sub

13 Upvotes

I for one am sick and tired of being accused of “whataboutism” when I point out obvious hypocrisy and double standards when thousands of Israelis chant “death to Arabs” and nobody on this sub feels moved to comment. I am sick and tired of “minimising antisemitism” when I point out that random protestors in Columbia are treated as representatives of the Palestinians and their national determinations, but literal government ministers like Ben Gvir and their appointed mobs are not given the same attention. Most of all I am sick and tired of hearing about the umpteenth Gazan family being wiped out in a declared war of extermination and ethnic cleansing and having people defend this.


r/metaNL • • Aug 15 '26

RESPONDED The "VJ Day celebration" post glorifies violence and must be removed.

2 Upvotes

Original thread here: https://old.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1vp04bq/vj_day_celebration_a_true_man_delivers_democracy/

Describing the intentional and wanton killing of more than a hundred thousand civilians as "deliver[ing] democracy with the power of a thousand suns" is an unequivocal statement of support for these killings and that their having occurred should be celebrated. This is a clear rule V violation.

N.B. I did report the post as well, however seeing as a mod made a statement in support it feels worth posting here.


r/metaNL • • Oct 12 '25

OPEN If you truly want to improve the subreddit, you have to get rid of the DT.

3 Upvotes

There are way too many chronically online and sad people in the DT and that misery seeps out into the rest of the subreddit. If you want to improve the sub, you have to first get rid of the hangout spot for the worst users so they'll move on.


r/metaNL • • Jun 04 '25

OPEN Posts wishing for economic downturns should not be allowed

1 Upvotes

Wishing for economic downturns (especially for partisan reasons) goes against the ideals of neoliberalism. A core tenet of the ideology is that people thrive in periods of healthy economic growth. Promoting the downfall of good economic conditions is incredibly misanthropic. Wanting it to happen so your favorite team can do better in the next election is possibly even worse.

I would like to propose these types of posts be removed under the Rule 3: "Unconstructive Engagement." I see them pretty much everyday here now with a great deal of upvotes. Doesn't feel right for the sub to turn into a force promoting negativity and decline.

Additionally, I would like more memes involving 80s movies.


r/metaNL • • Oct 22 '25

OPEN Is it the official position of the Neoliberal mod team that Nazi tattoos are not disqualifying for public office?

3 Upvotes

r/metaNL • • Jul 08 '25

RESOLVED Why are comments that endorse progressive antisemitsm still up a day after being reported for bigotry?

0 Upvotes

Why is your shithole userbase up voting comments celebrating progressive antisemitism?

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1lucb69/irs_says_churches_can_endorse_candidates_from_the/n1x23u2/

Why was a different comment in the same thread bigoted against a different minority removed yet this one stayed up? Why do those oopsies keep happening?


r/metaNL • • Jul 30 '25

OPEN Why is a comment deflecting from antisemitism to whine about Israel still up while the rest of the chain was removed?

4 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1mc4mkw/discussion_thread/n5sqic6/

And yes before a mod asks I did report it, and since I'm not a user who is currently permanently banned I believe it's perfectly fine for me to make this post.


Edit: Mods have removed the comment BUT ONCE AGAIN DIDN'T ISSUE A BAN

Seriously what's up with this constant calling out for fucked up comments and then only ever removing and not banning antisemitic people?


r/metaNL • • Dec 15 '25

OPEN The sub is too censorious and ban-happy when it comes to Israel related topics. Here’s my solution.

0 Upvotes

I am a longtime lurker and formerly a longtime poster in the main sub (until I got permabanned two months ago) who feels that the way in which the sub handles Israel related discourse to be counterproductive to its overall mission. Before I start, I just want to disclaim three things:

  1. ⁠I’m not using this thread as a vehicle to appeal my ban. Yes, my ban (and all of my previous infractions) were due to Israel related comments, that could be perceived by some as provocative despite me not having ill intentions. I am not looking to appeal my ban right now and I respect the mods’ decision.

  2. ⁠I’m not using this thread to trash the subreddit as a whole. Despite my ban, I still have much respect for the sub and its mods, as the sub is one of the few places online where I can reliably find nuanced and civil discussion about politics.

  3. ⁠I’m not going to argue that the mods should be more permissive of antisemitism or give it a free pass. This post does not apply to antisemitic, troll/flamebait, or grossly offensive comments in general.

That being said, I can say that I’m far from alone in feeling (and having firsthand experience) that the sub takes too much of a heavy handed approach when it comes to moderating Israel related discourse. It’s very common to see posts/comments on this topic to be deleted by the mods and met with an infraction, despite the user who posted them doing so in good faith as opposed to stir the pot or be offensive. Many times, these posts are met with a “Rule II: antisemitism” response from the mods, which is to explain that antisemitic posts are not allowed and reaffirms the sub’s support for Israel’s right to exist. I would also say that I’ve seen posts deleted and flagged that are both pro Israel and anti-Israel, so I’m not insinuating that the mods are clearly taking one side over the other.

The issue I have is that it seems very difficult to gauge what is and what isn’t an appropriate post when it comes to Israel. The Rule II auto response does not do a very good job in clarifying this. Obviously, post Oct. 7, there’s going to be very strong feelings about Israel (NOT Jewish people, but the state of Israel), coming from all sides. And I’m sure the mods would agree that people should not simply refuse to discuss the topic because it is inherently controversial.

The reason why it is hard to gauge what type of posts about Israel are acceptable versus breaking breaking rule II is because all comments which violate Rule II are immediately deleted by the mods. This thread from a week ago is a prime example, as large swaths of the discussion (and most of these comments were upvoted) were deleted by mods. This includes comments in which the original poster was clearly striving for nuance. In last week’s thread, “Allies abandoned Jews as antisemitism surges”, there was a lengthy comment with 127 upvotes that got deleted for a Rule II violation. Most of its replies (also heavily upvoted) also got deleted. I have the screenshot of this if anyone would like to see, but unfortunately I cannot post screenshots here.

Given that comment’s (and many others in the thread) high amount of upvotes, it just doesn’t seem reasonable that it was deleted with no explanation. If it were truly such an antisemitic or offensive comment, there’s no way in which it would have been one of the most upvoted in the thread. I don’t even remember what that comment was, but I trust the members of the sub’s judgement in upvoting it since the vast majority of people here are not antisemites or trolls.

So the solution is: stop deleting comments that violate Rule II en masse! When you do this, it is hard to see what is acceptable discourse. Keeping these comments and posts up would allow the community to better gauge what is appropriate when it comes to Israel discourse, and ultimately lessen the amount of Rule II infractions the mods have to give out. Deleting these comments in masse goes against the sub’s very mission of nuance and thoughtful discussion. This should not apply, however, to obviously antisemitic or troll comments; those absolutely should be deleted. But the vast majority of comments that get deleted for Rule II violations are not that.

It just seems to me that the standard protocol for moderating Israel related comments in the sub is: if someone reports the comment, then it should be deleted and an infraction would apply. This seems like a reasonable policy at face value. However, it is clear that there are a group of users (many of which are Deep State Centrism and other splinter sub regulars) who are effectively brigading the main sub. They immediately downvote and report all comments that are critical of Israel, even if that criticism is legitimate and widely shared amongst the sub. The mods should instead use a “reasonable persons test” rather than assuming that all reports are warranted and any comment that could be considered offensive, actually is offensive and thus done so with offensive intent.

Thank you for reading. Let me know if there’s anything I’ve missed or anything I should add!


r/metaNL • • Sep 13 '24

RESPONDED Request that the sub stop singling out minority groups for different treatment

4 Upvotes

I've recently become aware that this sub has filters in place that prevent posting stories about antisemitism, which were apparently put in place because singling out minorities is easier than enforcing a clear and consistent set of rules about what content should or should not be posted to the sub. Apparently, based on this post, it is my job as a user to know about these filters and request that you guys enforce your rules the same way regardless of race, ethnicity, religion, or any other sort of background. As you apparently did in the past by removing the filter on stories about attacks on Asian people, would you kindly enforce your rules in a consistent manner that isn't apparently based on some sort of race based "out of sight, out of mind" mentality?

The argument made in favor of this filter has been that it is used to prevent the sub from becoming a news aggregator for stories such as attacks on Jews. This argument falls flat, and frankly reminds me of broad overzealous discriminatory practices like the WW2 internment camps. If you want to enforce rules to protect the character of the sub, enforcing those rules by singling out specific minorities is already far, far worse than the alternative.


r/metaNL • • Jul 09 '25

OPEN Ban paywalled news articles

0 Upvotes

If users can't read the article how the hell do you expect any sort of real discussion

You can pick ethics or sub quality. Not both


r/metaNL • • Apr 15 '24

OPEN Why no Piketty flair?

0 Upvotes

Wealth inequality is one of the most pressing challenges of our times. They can be a cause of polarisation [1], harm democratic institutions [2], are a leading indicator of populism [3], and impact aggregate demand in the economy [4]

Piketty and World Inequality Lab's work is rigorous, insightful, and his best seller is 700 pages long . Even my nephew knows r>g is big bad. If we talk so much about defending liberal democracy, Piketty flair is no brainer

WANT!!


r/metaNL • • Oct 25 '24

OPEN The "anti-doomer" circlejerk

0 Upvotes

Sure, being a sad sack can annoy others.

However, the tone of some people who are fed up with the people worrying about what Trump winning could mean for their lives, worrying about how well Trump is polling (& what it means for the future of America that he pulls those numbers), and worrying about post election violence is not up to what the sub purports to represent.

Consider this comment:

"If you’re a doomer, I want you to know that when I reply to you I am actually imagining you crying and convulsing"

Does this make people worrying about the very reasonable fear of being put into camps feel welcome?

Does this make people worrying about the very reasonable fear of their friends and family being put into camps feel welcome?

Does this comment comment and those like it meet the standards of civility and constructive engagement?

If it does, wow gosh I guess I disagree.


r/metaNL • • Oct 12 '25

OPEN "Goth AOC" posting is disgusting fetishism and a prime example of why your sub has so few women.

0 Upvotes

Please ban.


r/metaNL • • Aug 26 '26

OPEN Demisexual Flair

0 Upvotes

One of our most eminent DTers wants a DEMISEXUAL flair. I propose we add it!


r/metaNL • • Feb 10 '21

RESPONDED What happened to "Woke Capitalism?"

0 Upvotes

So the subreddit tagline of this is Woke Capitialism and it has been for most of my time here. However lately i've really been noticing the anti-woke, anti-SJW side of this subreddit, grevenice subreddits that I can't name which is when the problem really started to occur to constantly complain about stuff like "woke culture" and "identity politics" making this place feel like a time machine back to 2014 just before the alt right really took off, any time I bring this up in the main sub I am immediately shut down. Is this change in the userbase going to be permanent and i'm not going to be welcomed anymore or what is going to happen?


r/metaNL • • Nov 06 '24

OPEN Transphobia

0 Upvotes

There's going to be a massive uptick in transphobia these next few days maybe mods should private the sub for a week?


r/metaNL • • Jul 01 '25

OPEN Israel arrests several people in Syria

1 Upvotes

The Israeli army announced that it had launched search operations and arrested several people in southern Syria and taken them to Israel.

Who wants to bet they won't be treated with the same media coverage as the Israeli hostages Hamas took.

"arrested several people in southern Syria"

Probably this part. Arresting people in other countries isn't something that most nations typically do.

Y'all would be less critical if they executed people in Syria instead of arresting them?

How is that unconstructive????????

Y'all are reacting quickly without thought. I realize you're overloaded, but this is bullshit.

Israel used pagers to slaughter hundreds of Hezbollah members in Lebanon. Praised by this subreddit, as well it should've been.

But Israel arrests people in Syria, and people are upset? "Arresting people in other countries isn't something that most nations typically do"

To which my honest question was, is killing preferable????

I'm not being hyperbolic. I'm not exaggerating, I honestly want to know.

Israel has bombed souther syria. Israel has killed people across that border. But arresting members is taboo??

Thats the PREFERRED pathway no?

Maybe I'm missing something. But this bullshit where my comment is removed as being unconstructive engagement is thoughtless.

We should prefer israel arrest rogue actors in a parts of a State that isn't under direct control of their government, instead of Israel bombing them. This is a valid point of discussion.

context

https://old.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1lo0xtz/discussion_thread/n0oe0wk/?context=3