Recently, this was the sticky on the top of a controversial thread in r/neoliberal.
This ruling is bad, but acting like the world is gonna end or that we might as well give up is bad for both your own mental health and the mental health of the people who read your comments. No dooming; it actively worsens the quality of discussion and discourages action.
The excessive partisanship rule is being relaxed for obvious reasons-we're not going to ban people for justified anger at the Republican Party or GOP appointed judges. However, absolutely no calls for violence or authoritarianism will be tolerated. NO EXCEPTIONS.
Keep in mind that the vast majority of Pro-Lifers sincerely believe that all fetuses and embryos are literally children, and sincerely believe that this court decision will save millions of lives. By all means, report Pro-Lifers coming here to gloat or troll and we will ban them, but no matter how badly misguided these beliefs are, remember that they do not come from a place of malice. Treat those who support or are sympathetic to this ruling, and who are themselves respectful, with respect. DO NOT engage in personal attacks directed at other commenters. Also, DO NOT reply to trolls-just report and move on.
To assist lower-income women living in states where abortion is now prohibited access this healthcare resource, consider donating to abortion funds, which provide cash, lodging, and transportation, to women in need.
You can donate through ActBlue here. Alternatively, you can browse this article with links to abortion funds for individual states.
Even more importantly, remember to vote in November.
This post is actively antagonistic and accomplishes none of the the things it set out to do. Briefly perusing the comments in reply to this post will show that it provoked anger, mockery, and general disrepect for the mods.
In this post, I will break down each section of this sticky and point out where it is wrong. There will be a discussion on why it is wrong. Finally, I will construct a new crisis sticky that does none of those things as an example for the future.
1. "Calm down woman"
This ruling is bad, but acting like the world is gonna end or that we might as well give up is bad for both your own mental health and the mental health of the people who read your comments. No dooming; it actively worsens the quality of discussion and discourages action.
Telling someone to 'calm down' or 'relax' is an outward indicator of the mental state of the person saying it. People say these things when:
They do not understand the emotion behind why someone is upset.
They do not care that someone is upset.
This will make the person you are saying this to very angry because of a psychological response to being ignored. Primarily, using this type of language indicates to the listener that, in fact, you do not care or do not empathize with their position. This almost always has the opposite effect, and causes the person becomes less calm. If you say this often in your relationship, you may find that your wife has left you. 1
2. Lets be more vague
The excessive partisanship rule is being relaxed for obvious reasons-we're not going to ban people for justified anger at the Republican Party or GOP appointed judges.
Is anger now excessive partisanship? I have never seen anger banned as excessive partisanship. However, the real issue with this is that the excessive partisanship rule is already vague. Relaxing a vague rule is simply confusing! No one knows where the line is. In crisis situations you want clear communication. It's important to deliver information in a quick, clear, consise manner.
What is the above communicating? It's not communicating anything, at best, it is a needless digression. 2
3. What the hell?
Keep in mind that the vast majority of Pro-Lifers sincerely believe that all fetuses and embryos are literally children, and sincerely believe that this court decision will save millions of lives. By all means, report Pro-Lifers coming here to gloat or troll and we will ban them, but no matter how badly misguided these beliefs are, remember that they do not come from a place of malice. Treat those who support or are sympathetic to this ruling, and who are themselves respectful, with respect. DO NOT engage in personal attacks directed at other commenters. Also, DO NOT reply to trolls-just report and move on.
Posting pro-life talking points in the sticky of a thread kinda betrays the fact, doesn't it? Understandably, this became the biggest issue in the replies to the sticky. Taken as a whole this post says, "1) I dont understand why youre mad, 2) I'll ban you if you break the vague rules I decide on the spot 3) the pro-lifers have some good points."
The subtext speaks for itself. It takes sides with editorializing, and personal opinions should not be placed in crisis communication because it breaks all the rules of quick, clear, and consise.
When you are supposed to be a moderator, mediator, or someone tasked with fairly metering out rules, then you have a duty to stay out of the fray, at least in your official communications. If you don't, you may find yourself the topic of the discussion instead of the discussion. 3
4. Says who?
This sticky is unsigned. Is this is personal opinions and views of the author? Is it the combined view of the mod staff. Crisis communication should be followed with the signing of the exercising authority.
Frankly, the mod team as a whole has more credibility than one mod.
5. A template for the future
Let's now contruct a crisis sticky that effectively communicates:
Hey folks, hold onto your butts. There is a lot of anger at this issue, many on the mod team share it. However, we are going to continue enforcing all rules. This means no calls for violence, bigotry, insults, trolling, brigading, or bad-faith posting.
Please report any instances of these violations using the report feature.
-The mod team
First, establish understanding and empathy with the audience.
Hey folks, hold onto your butts. There is a lot of anger at this issue, many on the mod team share it.
This shows that you understand why people are mad and you validate that they are both stressed and angry without condeming or ignoring it.
Next, clearly communicate the rules.
However, we are going to continue enforcing all rules. This means no calls for violence, bigotry, insults, trolling, brigading, or bad-faith posting.
This is not vague and let's the audience, with fair warning, understand what is expected from them for posting in the thread and sub.
Don't forget the actionable item.
Please report any instances of these violations using the report feature.
This lets people know what you intend to do and what to do if they see someone ignoring the rules. This is an important part of 'crisis response', its the 'response' part.
Finally, sign it.
-The mod team
This lets everyone know its a united front and not whoever grabbed the sticky first.
6. The last part
Following these simple rules will help you communicate during crisis. It will calm, instead of inflame, and help everyone in the community. It will prevent mods from getting mercilessly dunked on and will increase respect for the mod staff. Ok, fine. Maybe that last sentence won't happen but its worth a shot. What do you have to lose?