I visited my local Fred Meyer (aka Kroger) fully intending to purchase some Van Leeuwan Limited Edition Dr. Seuss™ Grinchmas Peppermint with Chocolate Hearts I had seen in an end case on a prior visit. Next to it was Pumpkin Cheesecake with Graham Cracker Crust. Well. OK. I guess I can get both. The end case selection was not a complete collection, so a visit to the main ice cream case was next. Then it happened, I was reminded of the “Weekly Digital Deal” $1.99 a pint for Private Selection ice cream, a digital coupon I had dropped into my account. Then I heard the siren call. PS New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream! Hard to skip $1.99 for a flavor you have not tried, and being able to do a side by side with another “more premium” (more expensive) ice cream. So here we are.
The details of each ice cream.
Van Leeuwen Pumpkin Cheesecake: A French-style ice cream made with extra egg yolks, pumpkin puree, cinnamon, nutmeg, cream cheese, and a honey graham cracker crust.
Private Selection New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream is a seasonal flavor from Kroger's store brand featuring spiced pumpkin ice cream mixed with cheesecake pieces.
From the images, the Private Selection ice cream has the deeper pumpkin color. That makes it very pumpkin forward and with the pie spices almost like frozen pumpkin pie. The Van Leeuwen has a rich base that seems sweeter to me and not as spicy. Or maybe different spicy. Both present ginger, nutmeg, and cinnamon. The VL has crumbs that are more gingerbread than graham crust. Less so with PS. For both, any cheese cake must be fully blended into the final product because neither seem to present larger sections of cheesecake. Takeaway, PS more pumpkin forward. VL slightly richer. Both have about the same amount of edible and visible add-ins.
People may question which one I like better. They are both great ice creams. I would not hesitate to purchase either. I am a fan of pumpkin pie so having pumpkin more forward in the flavor makes me lean towards the Private Selection.