r/icecream • • 2h ago

Mcconnells gingerbread cheesecake!

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

got this at Whole Foods

it is so so good, so worth it 100%! the cheesecake base is amazing just like a regular ny cheesecake slice

the gingerbread bits are all thru the pint and there is lots of them, lots of molasses and ginger flavor as well I highly recommend


r/icecream • • 15h ago

Comparing Van Leeuwan and Private Selection Pumpkin Cheesecake

Thumbnail
gallery
277 Upvotes

I visited my local Fred Meyer (aka Kroger) fully intending to purchase some Van Leeuwan Limited Edition Dr. Seuss™ Grinchmas Peppermint with Chocolate Hearts I had seen in an end case on a prior visit. Next to it was Pumpkin Cheesecake with Graham Cracker Crust. Well. OK. I guess I can get both. The end case selection was not a complete collection, so a visit to the main ice cream case was next. Then it happened, I was reminded of the “Weekly Digital Deal” $1.99 a pint for Private Selection ice cream, a digital coupon I had dropped into my account. Then I heard the siren call. PS New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream! Hard to skip $1.99 for a flavor you have not tried, and being able to do a side by side with another “more premium” (more expensive) ice cream. So here we are.

The details of each ice cream.

Van Leeuwen Pumpkin Cheesecake: A French-style ice cream made with extra egg yolks, pumpkin puree, cinnamon, nutmeg, cream cheese, and a honey graham cracker crust.

Private Selection New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream is a seasonal flavor from Kroger's store brand featuring spiced pumpkin ice cream mixed with cheesecake pieces.

From the images, the Private Selection ice cream has the deeper pumpkin color. That makes it very pumpkin forward and with the pie spices almost like frozen pumpkin pie. The Van Leeuwen has a rich base that seems sweeter to me and not as spicy. Or maybe different spicy. Both present ginger, nutmeg, and cinnamon. The VL has crumbs that are more gingerbread than graham crust. Less so with PS. For both, any cheese cake must be fully blended into the final product because neither seem to present larger sections of cheesecake. Takeaway, PS more pumpkin forward. VL slightly richer. Both have about the same amount of edible and visible add-ins. 

People may question which one I like better. They are both great ice creams. I would not hesitate to purchase either. I am a fan of pumpkin pie so having pumpkin more forward in the flavor makes me lean towards the Private Selection.


r/icecream • • 2h ago

Currently eating That's Life!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Have been eating "That's Life." Ghirardelli Salty caramel, Tj's chocolate ice cream and Life cereal, has lil sugar bits that go well with the salty caramel! Ps you have to play the Frank Sinatra song while you eat it. Greens for health!


r/icecream • • 6h ago

Review Jeni’s Miso Butterscotch Brownie

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I picked this up at the same time as the McConnell’s Gingerbread Cheesecake, and I was excited to try it after hearing some mixed reviews.

First off, there were some issues with iciness, it seems this Whole Foods might have issues with pints melting and refreezing. This stinks because I actually really liked this!

As a big fan of savory sweet flavors, I felt like the miso really added an interesting note of umami underneath the sweetness from the base and the brownies. To me, while I definitely tasted the miso it wasn’t overpowering, and this pint’s strongest flavor was the brownies which I thought worked well. The brownies were sweet, but rich and very chocolatey. I didn’t even realize they were gluten free! Of course, if it works for you will definitely depend on how much you like miso. I love both miso and salty-sweet flavors, so if you prefer mostly sweet or don’t like miso at all this won’t do it for you.


r/icecream • • 7h ago

I bought one of these at Braum's last night and when I got home I found out they're actually made in the USA by Zeroll but at half the price and I get the Braum's logo on it.

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

$12.99 and you can find them inside at the Braum's market. I already tested it with their peppermint ice cream and I'm loving it. The liquid center really does work well.


r/icecream • • 13h ago

Flavours New jenis?

Post image
65 Upvotes

Saw these at lowes has anyone tried them


r/icecream • • 6h ago

Talenti Salted Caramel Truffle

5 Upvotes

Y'all. Y'ALL. This ice cream is fucking amazing. How have I lived not trying this before??? It's so hard not to want to scoop down to get all the layers knowing there's only so much. Fantastical. ✨


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Review Jeni’s red pepper jelly

Thumbnail
gallery
230 Upvotes

People must be very interested in this flavor because multiple scoop shops around me didn’t have any pints left and I had to beg for a hand packed pint. But I just knew this was going to be a good one.

The cream cheese base is rich, creamy, and sweet. Not a surprise to say it’s very cream cheesy, so if you have an aversion to it (weirdos, imo), this is not for you.

The cracker swirl works super well with the base. It was buttery and salty. The texture surprised me a little, it was much sandier than I expected, reminiscent of a graham cracker crust texture. There was plenty of swirl as well, which made me happy as I really liked it.

The red pepper jelly is exactly that. It’s sweet, and tart, with that slight pepper flavor right at the end of the bite. Again, plenty of jelly swirled into the base, but not overwhelming like the high five candy can be sometimes.

I never would have imagined this flavor in ice cream for, but I’m so happy it exists! It’s these unique flavors that make me love this brand. I think I’ll stock up on at least one more pint while I can!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Currently eating Caffe Panna - Carrot Cake Affogato Sundae

Thumbnail
gallery
327 Upvotes

Ingredients: Double Carrot Cake ice cream, graham crunch, frosted carrot cake, panna,
cinnamon caramel, espresso


r/icecream • • 9h ago

something fun to do when your alone and craving ice cream but its midday

5 Upvotes

recipe for healthy yumilicious ice cream-

ingredients: milk, cinnamon, whipped cream

Steps:

  1. take a flat container, remove the lid and pour some milk about a third of the way (depends on how much you want), about 2-3 cups.

  2. set in freezer for 9 minutes

  3. after nine minutes, take it out and mash up the crunchy milk with a spoon

  4. repeat about 3-5 times

  5. once it is all mushy (you don't want a solid block), scoop it into a cup or bowl, add your whipped cream and sprinkle cinnamon over

  6. enjoy!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Another banger from the walboy

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

r/icecream • • 1d ago

Review Graeter’s Black Rasberry Chip :/

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

I had my first Graeter’s pint tonight. As a black raspberry, chocolate, ice cream lover and maker, I was so excited to finally try the famous Graeter’s!

I did not enjoy it. It was almost inedible to me. I will be trying black cherry chip next in case it was a fluke. (Pls don’t be mean, blame my buds. This is my personal opinion.)

Black Raspberry base: Nondescript, faint berry flavor. Colored a deep purple to psychologically convince you of what it’s branded as. Classic grossly sweet, almost cheap, aftertaste. Gave me a small yogurty note too a little.

Texture: in between pillowy and dense, on softer side. Decent, but didn’t blow me away, as I prefer a little “chewier”,’ but hard to judge bc temp little too hot.

Chocolate chunks: Taste is reminiscent of the cheap advent calendar chocolate that comes in cardboard— and tastes like it too. Not too dark or milky. The texture is chewy not hard, which means it is untempered, and I do not like that. The ginormous chunks of chocolate do not harmonize. Again, that weird sweet aftertaste.

Conclusion: Get a different ice cream. I wouldn’t buy it if it was cheap either.


r/icecream • • 15h ago

best raspberry and dark chocolate ice cream?

2 Upvotes

I love the Haagen-Dazs white chocolate raspberry truffle but I crave more raspberry. What other brands and flavors should I try? the raspberry must be tart and tangy and there has to be dark chocolate!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Don't waste your money on Private selection (Kroger) moose tracks

Post image
16 Upvotes

I use to love this ice cream. Recently bought 5 containers for a party and it was like eating vanilla ice cream.

This was one of the containers. We had to get half way down just to get anything good.

There was minimal fudge and very little mix ins in every container. It was so bad I called Kroger and got a full refund. Very disappointing.


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Currently eating The coconut is pretty subtle

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

Office references aside this is the PERFECT coconut ice cream for me. Just enough coconut but not too much and no weird artificial coconut flavor. Another simple yet perfect Graeter's flavor!


r/icecream • • 16h ago

favorite jeni’s flavor?

Post image
0 Upvotes

What is your favorite flavor? (Besides gooey butter cake)

I’ve tried
- peanut butter with chocolate specs
- watermelon taffy
- gooey butter cake
- miso butterscotch brownie (my favorite… so far)


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Currently eating I'm on my 3rd pint, it needs to stay!

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

Completely fallen in love with Blue Bell's Chocolate Lava Cake. It has been consistently densely packed with fudge and cake pieces every time I purchase it. I hope "New!" means it's staying around and not just limited


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Christmas Cookies

Thumbnail
gallery
316 Upvotes

It’s so good! Finally, a Christmas themed ice cream with no peppermint.


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Frozen Yoghurt New Yasso flavors >>>>

Post image
10 Upvotes

Phenomenal. The strawberry cheesecake Yasso is the best store-bought froyo I’ve had and a contender for one of my top store-bought frozen treats PERIOD!! Key Lime Pie is also great. The natural tanginess of the greek yogurt just works so well with the cream cheese flavor profile in both the strawberry cheesecake and key lime pie.


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Betty Jo’s (NYC) November flavor: pumpkin pie

Post image
17 Upvotes

this is my second order from them and i’m genuinely mad I didn’t order 2 pints of this, it’s absolutely phenomenal. that layer of graham cracker crust is THICK and is present throughout!


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Flavours Easily some of the best rum ice cream I’ve ever had!!

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Rum Bisque from Leopolds in Savannah!


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Rant My mistake

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

I was anticipating a pretty decent amount of chocolate sea salt caramel mini melts....but I had to DIG to get to ONE piece. I feel pretty deceived by the picture on the container. And I have had Gifford's before....not my favorite, but this definitely makes it run lower. The texture isn't creamy, and the ice cream flavor isn't a true caramel sea salt taste besides the chocolate sea salt caramel mini melts, lol. I have been emotional these days and was hoping ice cream would pick me up, but it made me a lil grumpy. I should have just picked up the Haagen Dasz Sea Salt Caramel ice cream.. live and learn, I guess!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Bro im made ice cream of chocolate milk

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hmmmmm


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Review Peppermint Dreams by Bettergoods

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

Found this at Walmart. Ice cream is just creamy vanilla. The peppermint comes from the pink swirls, also not crunchy it's soft. Mint flavor is subtle not strong. Instead of ribbons of chocolate it's thick chunks here and there. Everyone loved it. Would def recommend if you like peppermint bark.