r/icecream • • Aug 22 '26 Regret

Brands Found this bad boy and had to bring it home. Breyers is awesome.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Oct 25 '25

Review Disappointing B&J

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Ben & Jerry’s larger “scoopables” were BOGO so I got two flavors. This one, Vanilla and Fudge Brownie, is a big disappointment! The vanilla is so mid! It doesn’t taste at all rich. It is smooth, though. Looking at the label I see they have cream, skim milk, and liquid sugar. I think that’s a basic recipe to protect the texture from having ice crystals form? Result- very average, even less than average taste. And the brownie chunks are dry and not super flavorful. By contrast, the Jenni’s I also have is a true delight, and its first three ingredients are milk, cream, and cane sugar.


r/icecream • • 23d ago

Review i ordered icecream and this is too much

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Mar 21 '26

I feel like people have a favorite ice cream flavour based on their mental strength

0 Upvotes

What I mean is, literally everyone I know falls into a category corresponding to how they respond to pressure, stress etc. here’s my list so you can decide what you are 👍

Chocolate- The strongest

Strawberry- intelligent and persistent

Vanilla- cunning

Mint chocolate- potential chocolate lover in training

Fruity flavour: smart


r/icecream • • Jun 08 '26

Chocolate being the worst part of icecream.

Post image
0 Upvotes

So yeah, if everyone has proper taste buds, we would agree that out of vanilla strawberry and chocolate, chocolate is definitely the worse.

But there is a catch

The "chocolate" flavor usually depends what chocolate it is.

If we are talking about the default ones such as the first on the image, then yeah in my opinion these taste horrible, I don't know about y'all taste buds but it doesn't taste good.

But there is a catch

There is ones like mars KitKat and others chocolate types that are actually not that good

It's just that this type of chocolate tastes horrible, I don't know if it's every brand but almost everytime I get a box like this it just doesn't taste good, ofc not everyone's taste buds is the same so I'm just sharing my opinion.


r/icecream • • May 22 '25

Toppings Confession😋

Post image
5 Upvotes

I pick out all inclusion, especially the ones that are the crunchy chocolate pieces 😋 I do this to every tub of ice cream. And no, I’m not the only one eating from this tub, but my boyfriend doesn’t mind😆 can we still be friends?


r/icecream • • Jul 19 '24

Review This sucks

Post image
5 Upvotes

I got a bone to pick with this sub lol. Not really cuz I know it’s all about what flavor you get, but tillamook is so highly praised in this sub that I was disappointed to try this flavor. The chocolate is not as creamy as the base in their other flavors like vanilla and strawberry. But the worst part is the filling - described as a “swirl” of peanut butter, it’s more like long, hard chunks that appear way too often in the ice cream, making it way too sweet to eat. It’s foul. Ugh. Some of the chunks even congeal into a huge carbuncle of hardened peanut butter. They should take this off the market


r/icecream • • 6d ago

ben and jerry’s not melting??!

Post image
1 Upvotes

i bought the fudge brownie popsicle flavor and left it on my table overnight and it didn’t melt…the room was warm too. yall what’s happening


r/icecream • • Feb 22 '26

Currently eating Thoughts on Ben and Jerry’s Half Baked?

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Oct 15 '25

Ice cream tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

Rate me and my friends tier list


r/icecream • • Sep 23 '24

Food Safety Found this in some Bluebell, I have no idea what it is, any ideas?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

It's hard and flaky, it seems like a nail of some kind


r/icecream • • May 17 '26

Trying new things first time trying Jeni's, not too impressed

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm gonna blame my local Albertsons for this being sucky because every pint was kinda banged up, and when I opened it half of it was melted and refrozen with ice crystals caked on top. it was also kinda icy tasting and melted so quickly, and the texture was just not as creamy as I wanted it to be!

next time I'll just pick up my Ben and Jerry's (tonight dough my beloved)


r/icecream • • Feb 27 '25

Flavours Doritos and ice cream

1 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Sep 12 '26

Review creamy tierlist curated by three very unique people

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/icecream • • May 06 '24

Ice Cream! My current fave ice-cream

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Apr 14 '26

Rant GOD PLEASE WHY HAVE YOU LET DUBAI CHOCOLATE MAKE ICE CREAM

Post image
0 Upvotes

I am so sick of this chocolate from dubai crap from spouting about why have you beseeched me what I have done wrong? well at least this is more affordable then the chocolate bars themselves

would you all try this?.


r/icecream • • Mar 08 '25

Question Anyone else find Ben and Jerry’s overrated

62 Upvotes

Very partial to Perry’s ice cream

I feel Ben and Jerry’s just stuffs the ice cream with the good stuff, but the actual ice cream is not creamy and lacks flavor. It is also too expensive for the amount you get


r/icecream • • Feb 19 '24

Ice Cream! All y’all getting your Jeni’s at Walmart while I’m here getting it from the business itself😂

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Dec 31 '23

Question How do y’all eat your ice cream?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/icecream • • Oct 26 '25

Rant I love frozen dairy dessert.

0 Upvotes

I like my ice cream cheap and full of air, gums, and chemicals. I actually loathe the texture of rock hard real ice cream, especially chocolate ice cream, it's literally crumbly.

Real ice cream is loaded with cholestrol, especially with so much of it being stuffed unnecessarily with eggs these days to make it "premium", which, I might add, technically makes it into custard and not ice cream. I may be eating coconut oil, which is high in saturated fat, and xanthan gum, but at least I'm not eating 300 grams of cholestrol per bowl, especially since if ice cream is in my house I'm basically guaranteed to eat the whole tub. If there's 9 servings per container, that means I'm basically eating almost 3,000 grams of cholestrol. No, thank you.

Blue Bunny Soft is the best ice cream I've ever had, and for some reason it's becoming increasingly hard to find in my area, when last year it was everywhere.

That's all. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.


r/icecream • • Mar 03 '24

Food Safety Why is there ice cream missing along the side? Did it melt and then refreeze? Can I eat this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Why isn't it flat across the top?


r/icecream • • Jul 19 '26

Brands Aldi vs. Haagen Daaz

0 Upvotes

Hey guys just want to share that the Aldi ice cream tastes way better than the last time I recently got Haagen Daaz. I was really disappointed when I got Haagen Daaz and it was foamy instead of creamy.

What are your thoughts?


r/icecream • • Aug 03 '26

Why do ice cream shops not allow splitting flavors in single "scoop"?

0 Upvotes

I personally prefer small amounts of ice cream, but love to try at least two flavors, when possible. Seems like the "single" scoop at most shops I go to is actually 2 physical scoops, so it should be easy enough to put two flavors in.

Is there an economic or other reason that most shops I've been to don't allow putting two flavors in one scoop?


r/icecream • • Jan 06 '24

Rant I HATE SPUMONI!!!

0 Upvotes

I HATE IT SO MUCH!!