r/Genealogy • • Feb 02 '25 This This Regret

News Elon Deleted the US Census and Archives References

47.2k Upvotes

Every page that I need to reference schedules is giving a 503 error now.

This is disastrous to my personal research, which is nothing compared to the massive amounts of critical projects that are relying on all of the public data across all sectors that's being deleted.


r/Genealogy • • Apr 15 '25 Love Heartwarming

Solved To the person who posted on a genealogy forum on January 15, 2000...

6.8k Upvotes

You got no responses in 25 years, but you were looking for my wife's family who had ended up in a different part of the world. You were able to name almost all of them, even down to my wife's aunt. But nobody ever replied.

I tried to find a way to create an account to reply, but first I decided to check the obituaries... you died in 2022.

I just wanted to tell you your post wasn't in vain. The information you gave helped me find multiple branches of the family. So thank you.

R.I.P. Anita Fischer (1931–2022)


r/Genealogy • • May 12 '26 WOW Hooray Heartwarming Popcorn Mindblown Bravo

DNA Testing A Random DNA Test Solved a 75-Year-Old Family Mystery

5.2k Upvotes

A couple of months ago, my wife and I bought DNA ancestry tests just for fun because they were on discount. We’re both Moroccan, so we joked that we were basically paying money to confirm we were Moroccan 😂

A few weeks later, the results came back: my wife was apparently 100% Moroccan, while I was “only” 80%. We laughed about it and forgot the whole thing. We also found out that me and her have the highest Shared DNA percentage (1.3%) with each other since we are from the same small city/tribe which was interesting.

Then about a month later, I got an email from MyHeritage saying someone had sent me a message.

It was a guy from Austria .

He explained that he and his mother had recently taken DNA tests too, and they were shocked to discover that his mother was only 50% European… the other 50% was North African. Then he mentioned something that instantly gave me chills: his grandmother met his grandfather in Vienna in 1947 while he was serving with the French army in postwar Europe.

I later found out that France actually had thousands of soldiers stationed in Austria after WWII and jointly occupied part of Vienna at the time, so the timeline suddenly became very real.

Growing up, my mom and aunts always told us stories about my grandfather (1914-1984), a Moroccan soldier who fought with the French army during WWII and in the Indochina wars. They also told us that when he came back from Europe, he had a picture of himself with a white European woman that he kept hidden in his safe for years (even after he married my grandmother). On the back of the picture was a European address written in Germany.

For decades, my family believed we probably had relatives somewhere in Europe.

So after reading his message, I checked my DNA matches again.

His mother was listed as my “Half Aunt.”: Shared DNA (14.2%)

And he was listed as my “First Cousin.” Shared DNA (6.2%)

At that moment, it honestly felt like a movie.

The craziest part is that his mother grew up her entire life never knowing who her father was. She had never seen his face, never knew his name, nothing. He told me that his grandmother never spoke about the father of her only child.

Meanwhile, my family had spent decades wondering what happened to the woman in that old photograph my grandfather kept hidden in his safe. One of my aunts, who lives in France, even took the picture with her years ago and tried searching for the woman and any possible half-sisters or half-brothers, but she never succeeded.

When I told my family about the DNA match, everyone went crazy in our WhatsApp group. We were all shocked and excited. We started sending him pictures of my mom, my five aunts, my 14 cousins, and even some of their kids.

He later told me that he and his mother were crying after the discovery. After 74 years, she finally learned her father’s name, saw his picture for the first time, and discovered that she had sisters all along. Overnight, because of a random DNA test, their family suddenly grew by 400%.

Some people in my family were still skeptical, so we decided to test my aunt who lives in the Netherlands.

Today, the results came back, and I got another notification: “You have a new DNA match.” It was my aunt’s test result showing a 24.8% shared DNA match. From her point of view, I and the Austrian guy (my cousin now) appeared as her nephews, while his mother appeared as her half-sister.

That was the final confirmation.

After all these years, my aunts finally found their sister.

Honestly, this was huge for my family, but even bigger for his mother, who discovered an entire side of her family she never knew existed because of a random discounted DNA test.

And the wildest part? She looks IDENTICAL to one of my aunts. Side by side, you honestly wouldn’t even need a DNA test to believe they were sisters.

Now they are planning to visit Morocco for the first time to meet her sisters, nephews, nieces, and finally visit her father’s grave after spending an entire lifetime not even knowing his name.

It’s honestly hard to believe that all of this happened because of a discounted DNA test we originally bought as a joke.


r/Genealogy • • Jan 02 '25

DNA Police have informed me that my DNA was connected to the unidentified victim of a historic homicide

4.9k Upvotes

Yesterday I was contacted by the police in a province I am not from (I’m Canadian), informing me that my DNA has been found to be connected to the victim of a very old cold case in Canada. Not exactly how I thought my day was going to go at all but very interesting.

When speaking with the detective, I was informed of the individuals presumed heritage and which side of my family the link was made from. But the catch…

My grandma knew very minimal about her father, and a relative of mine has been working on a family tree for years but struggled.

So here I am, with nothing to go off of, no idea where to begin… and in 24 hours I’ve now learned that that entire side of my family was extremely well documented with multiple records of our entire ancestry tracing all the way back to 1500.

Turns out we have been living with a completely unnecessary mystery all of these years regarding our history.

So how far back on this family tree should I be handing over? Who should I include? Any help would be appreciated!

**please note that I have taken all proper precautions to ensure that this is legitimate and it truly was the police not a scammer


r/Genealogy • • Mar 26 '21

Solved I contacted the descendants of my ancestor’s slave owners today and I've never felt so much peace

3.6k Upvotes

I've always been fascinated with history because it tells a story that transcends every genre. Consequently, I became very intrigued to learn about the history of my own family. I've heard all of the stories of African Americans being unable to track their ancestry past the year 1900 or the very late 1800s, but I was determined. I wanted to know if we were slaves, who we were enslaved by, what county they lived in, and what the plantation looked like - among other things. I would google:"[my maiden last name] [slavery] [last known county family settled in] [1800s]" and was never able to find a slave owner that shared my family's name. After 2 years of searching, I had my first breakthrough.

Using Ancestry.com, I was able to trace back to my 4th great grandfather who was born in 1815 in a county that I never knew my family was associated with. And unsurprisingly enough, there were no documents or records of anyone before him. I didn't have much hope; but out of curiosity I searched the usual attributes but with the new county name and lo and behold...I looked at an 1850 slave schedule and saw what was the first (and only) documented slave owner that shared my family's name. Below him were the ages, sexes, and races of 9 slaves.

My sister found the plantation they worked on in less than 5 minutes. It's still active with the current owners using it as a farm to sell seasonal fruit. I found out by their "about us" section of the farm's website that they had, in fact, descended from my family's slave owners. I contemplated very hard on whether to call the number posted. I didn't know these people and they didn't know me. How would I even go about starting this conversation?

I decided to text the number. I introduced myself as someone who wanted to learn more about their family's history; stating that we share the same family name. The descendant was very eager, and somewhat excited, to help. He immediately sent me photos of records, books, and photos that he had in storage. He even asked if I could give him a call so that he could go into greater detail. I was very reluctant to do this because I hadn't yet disclosed that I was Black, and I knew he would be able to discern it the minute I spoke. But I eventually agreed to call him. Before we got into any of the family history, I went ahead and disclosed that I am African American and that my ancestors were possibly enslaved by his. He responded with a mere, "that's alright!" I was instantly relieved.

He was very willing and open to talk about his family's history - to include the parts about slavery. He was an older guy so he definitely talked my head off; but it only made me feel more comfortable. We were able to confirm that, yes, his ancestors did enslave mine and that 4 of their babies were born on his 3rd great grandfather's plantation. He even mentioned my 3rd great uncle by name! He confirmed that all of the slaves left after the war and that they relocated in the county I thought they had originally been in. As he described their life, he referred to them as "the Black side of the family", and that made it so much easier to hear. His family kept their records very organized and kept what they called the "Black Book" floating throughout these generations. This Black Book contains everything they know about my ancestors (names, ages, DOB, work performed, etc.). He offered to email me a copy of the book and invited me to visit the plantation.

I'm holding back tears as I write this post because this encounter has brought me so much closure. As an African American, finding and locating our ancestors post-Africa is a facet of our existence that is greatly desired, yet terribly challenging. I am fulfilled. Reaching out to the descendants of my ancestors' slave owners is probably one of the best things that I've done for myself and my family.


r/Genealogy • • Jan 12 '25

Question Shocking DNA results

2.7k Upvotes

My sister and I got ancestry kits. We thought it would be interesting as our father was adopted and maybe we can learn more about that side of our gene pool. My sister took the test first and then I sent my almost 6 months later. I got my results and it said my sister is actually my half sister. We have the same parents so I was sure this was an error. My sister was upset and I decided to reach out to our mother. Our mother immediately started crying and on a three way call she let us know that my sister was not my fathers daughter. This is obviously devastating to us on so many levels. My parents are divorced and have been for decades but they still maintain a great relationship. I assume my father does not know since the first words out of my mothers mouth were "does your dad know?"
I'm incredibly hurt by my mothers actions and the lies she kept up for our whole lives, claiming she didn't know. Mostly I hurt for my sister, I am not sure how to help her besides being there for her whenever she needs me. Is it wrong to be upset with my mom? How does a family move forward from this?


r/Genealogy • • Jun 23 '23 Thanks

News OceanGate CEO Stockton Rush kept reminding me of an obscure historical figure, Captain Richard F. Stockton, who in 1844 was responsible for a similar maritime disaster that killed 6, including U.S. Secretary of State Abel Upshur. I looked into their family tree, and they're actually related.

2.7k Upvotes

EDIT: Despite all my proofreading I somehow still typo'd the title, which should say "Robert F. Stockton" instead of Richard. Too many dang Richards in this family so I didn't realize I'd put the wrong name, but it wouldn't be a proper reddit post without a mistaken and unfixable title. Thank you to /u/toadog for noticing.

I can't post this in r/history because it involves events from the past 20 years, and I can't post this in r/todayilearned because there's not a single specific source to link to, as I had to do the research myself, so hopefully you guys will welcome this here in r/genealogy, as r/findareddit suggested.

So, uh, I'm a naval history nerd. And I kept hearing all this stuff about the "Titan" submersible disaster online, the poorly tested new design without responsible engineering to back it up, and the careless safety attitude towards experimental equipment, and when I heard the guy in charge was named "Stockton Rush" I was like "Wow... that's gotta be the most ironic name ever for a guy that puts some experimental poorly tested device out to sea without due diligence, invites a bunch of very rich and influential people to go on a pleasure cruise with him to show it off, and then gets them killed when it fails catastrophically." The whole incident seemed really weirdly reminiscent of a historical disaster I have a personal fascination with, the explosion on the U.S.S. Princeton in 1844, which involved a certain "Robert F. Stockton." And I didn't think anything of it beyond that for a couple days because of course it had to be my nerd brain making silly nerd connections and finding meaningless coincidences funny.

But of course everybody has continued to talk about the disaster, and eventually I came across some reddit commenters talking about how "Stockton Rush" is actually named Richard Stockton Rush III and comes from old money and is super privileged... and I was like 'wait, wait... they can't actually be related, can they?' So I started doing some searches with both their names, and got nothing about it in the news or on pages about either individual. And Wikipedia has articles for both people and some of their relatives, but doesn't have a complete family tree. But they were both repeatedly claimed by reputable looking sources to be descended from U.S. founding father and signer of the Declaration of Independence Richard Stockton. So I found a dang gravesite locator and a U.S. history genealogy map and manually sketched out their relations and corroborated it with multiple sources, and holy carp they are in fact cousins! First cousins five times removed, meaning Robert F. Stockton was the first cousin of Stockton Rush's Great Great Great Grandfather.

So what happened in 1844 on the U.S.S. Princeton involving Robert F. Stockton? Well, the U.S.S. Princeton was a state of the art vessel, the United States Navy's first major screw-driven warship, designed and constructed by Swedish engineer John Ericsson, inventor of the marine propeller and future ironclad pioneer, with the political backing of the powerful Stockton family, due to the personal attention of Captain Robert F. Stockton, who was very interested in cutting edge naval technologies. Not to be outdone by Ericsson, Captain Stockton used his wealth and influence to design and construct an oversized cannon- named the "Peacemaker"- to overshadow Ericsson's other armaments for the Princeton, not understanding the principles that Ericsson's advanced weapons were built with, and without properly test firing the cannon before mounting it. Captain Stockton then invited a large party of Washington D.C. dignitaries, including President John Tyler and his cabinet, on a Potomac river pleasure cruise to tour the vessel. During the tour the Peacemaker was repeatedly test fired as a demonstration, and on the last firing the cannon exploded, showering the deck in burning metal and killing six men:

  • Secretary of State Abel Upshur

  • Secretary of the Navy Thomas Walker Gilmer (A cabinet level position at the time)

  • Captain Beverley Kennon, Chief of the Bureau of Construction, Equipment and Repairs (Later called the Bureau of Ships)

  • Armistead, a slave who was President Tyler's valet

  • David Gardiner, a New York lawyer and politician

  • Virgil Maxcy, a Maryland attorney and politician

Accounts of other injuries range from 16 to 20 people. President Tyler was below deck when the explosion happened and was unharmed. Tyler was a widower and had been courting David Gardiner's daughter, Julia, who was present on the cruise and collapsed at her father's death. Tyler's comfort to her in her time of mourning ended up being decisive in him winning her acceptance of his marriage proposal, and Tyler became the first U.S. President to marry while in office. The disaster ended up having numerous after effects that rippled through U.S. politics for decades.

Captain Robert F. Stockton escaped injury, but his pet ship project had become a political disaster and he was now the subject of an official inquiry. Using the influence of his family, he was able to shift blame onto Ericsson, saving his own career at the cost of destroying Ericsson's relationship with the U.S. Navy and denying Ericsson payment for most of his work on the Princeton. Nearly twenty years later during the Civil War, when the Union was desperate for an Ironclad to counter the Confederacy's Ironclad project, it became a very difficult matter to convince Ericsson and the U.S. Navy to be willing to work together again, but the feat was managed and the U.S.S. Monitor was the result.

So if I had a nickel for every time a descendant of Declaration of Independence signer Richard Stockton irresponsibly took a bunch of very wealthy and influential people on a cruise to show off some experimental technology they had designed themselves and not tested properly and then got those wealthy people killed, I'd have ten cents, which wouldn't make me wealthy, but it's really damn weird that it happened twice.


r/Genealogy • • Apr 23 '25

Question UPDATE to Would it be inappropriate to reach out to this relative

2.1k Upvotes

A few weeks ago I posted asking for opinions on whether it would be inappropriate to reach out to an 84-year old woman whose grandfather was my great grandmother's brother. I was concerned because her mother died 10 days after she was born and her father remarried, and I wasn't certain how much of her own history she knew.

I got mixed feedback but I decided to write her. I explained what I thought our connection was but acknowledged that given how common our surname is that I could be wrong. I included my phone number and email address on the letter in case she was interested in reaching out.

She called me yesterday and it was AMAZING. Not only was she thrilled to have received my letter but (and I still cannot believe this) she is a genealogist who has been working on the family history since the 1970's!!! She said that since she is 84 and doesn't have any children she had begun to wonder what would happen to her binders full of documentation. And then she received my letter and know exactly where they would go.

I have been literally tingling with excitement since our call. I am sending her the history story that I have pulled together and then in a month or two I am going to visit her (she lives only about 3 hours away from me). Already she has filled in some gaps that I had and solved some puzzles that I had been working on.

I am just beyond thrilled that I reached out and I am so excited to get to meet her and learn from her and keep her story alive, too.

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Genealogy/comments/1jywwma/would_it_be_inappropriate_to_reach_out_to_this/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button


r/Genealogy • • Apr 05 '26 Obsessed Heartwarming

Studies and Stories My Great Grandmother Just Helped Me Break Down a Brick Wall, Over 50 Years After Her Death.

2.0k Upvotes

I had a big discovery yesterday that I need to share with folks that'll understand. In 1971, my great grandparents' house burned down. My great grandfather managed to throw a heavy trunk out of a second story window and jump out to escape, but my great grandmother, Della Wylie Simpson, was sleeping in a separate room and was trapped. She died in the fire, and much less importantly, all the family pictures and documents in house were burned up. During the cleanup afterwards, someone discovered a metal tin that survived the blaze and it got tucked away into my grandparents' storage.

A few years ago, my mother and her siblings were going through my grandparents things, cleaning up after they had passed away. They found the tin and opened it, finding mostly coins, but also two very burned pictures and a fire damaged small notepad. The pictures and notepad were passed on to myself since I am the family member interested in genealogy. I scanned the pictures, but was not willing to go through the notepad, as the damaged pages were stuck together and very fragile and I knew I only had one chance to look through them as separating them wound cause irreversible damage. I finally went through the notepad last night, taking pictures of each page for preservation. I was astounded at the information that was inside.

The notepad had belonged to my great grandmother and she recorded a plethora of information in it. The first page was an envelope she had tucked inside that detailed her mother's institutionalization at the Georgia State Hospital, her death, and her burial. The first proper half of the notepad was a log of family trips her family had taken between their home in Augusta, Georgia and relatives in Chester County, South Carolina. The second half of the notepad was the most important, and unexpected. During one trip to see her relatives in Chester County, Della began copying information. There are four pages of birth, marriage, and death dates for my 3rd great grandparents, their children, and my 4th great grandmother and her children (presumably from a family bible). There are four pages regarding the tragic deaths of three of my 3rd great grandparents children that occurred in the span of eight days (presumably copied from a journal or letter). Finally she copied three obituaries, one for my 3rd great grandfather and two for my 3rd great grandmother (one of which I did not know existed and cannot find digitized). She ended these pages with the statement "Copied July 28, 1925 by Della Simpson"

The information she copied is invaluable. Some of the dates she provided aren't captured in any primary documents, including my 3rd great grandparents marriage date. Some of the individuals listed died as youths between censuses and are not reflected in any primary sources at all. The most important find was the information regarding my 3rd great grandmother's mother and siblings. There are no primary documents directly stating my 3rd great grandmother, Eliza Jane Cherry's, parents. Many people online believe her father was Jamieson Cherry since he has a daughter of similar age named Jane and Eliza named one of her sons Jamieson Cherry Simpson. When recording the births, Della specifically noted under Debborah G. Cherry that "she was my great grandmother. Dad's grandmother." I found Debborah G. Cherry in the 1850 and 1860 censuses with a daughter named Eliza Jane Cherry and Debborah is most certainly not married to that Jamieson Cherry, barring a pre-1850 divorce.

All together, Della recorded 24 pages of information, then conveniently stored her writings in a metal tin that was able to withstand the fire. It's wild to me that think of the chain of events where this knowledge could have been permanently lost: she could have not copied it in the first place, lost it in the intervening 50 years, not placed it in a tin and it be destroyed in the fire, it could not have been found in the clean-up, and then my grandparents have choose to not keep the partially burnt notepad.


r/Genealogy • • Mar 14 '26 Wholesome Seal Bravo Heartwarming

Studies and Stories How A 100 Year Old Family Mystery Was Solved, Thanks to Reddit!

1.8k Upvotes

Hi all! Thanks to this community, I unlocked a mystery that my family has been pondered for over a hundred years.

My mom’s, mom’s parents family comes from orphans. Her father was born an orphan and ended up working as a janitor at a New York Retirement Home, where he met my great grandmother, who was working there and also an orphan. This obviously has created a significant family roadblock. They have long since passed, and they refused to discuss their childhoods, other than expressing that they were highly traumatic. Their children would ask what their lives looked like as kids. They would never answer, until the mother finally said “it was bad”, and left it at that. Everything, from where they came from, to how they lived before they had children, was a mystery. But, after years of research and some help from the friendly neighbors at r/Genealogy, I was able to figure out the origins of my family.

One of the biggest mysteries was the origin of my great-grandfather’s name, “Hyzdu” (pronounced ˈhɪzduː or Hi-Z-Doo). According to all records I could find, the name Hyzdu originated with Stephen; there were no records prior to him showing this name. Thus, I spent a lot of time searching their names, using variations of Hyzdu that I had heard, including Hajdu. I’m not sure who first hypothesized that Hajdu was where the name originated from, but this was a popular theory in my family due to the similarity of pronunciation.

For years, I had no luck finding any information about Stephen’s parents. As my experience in genealogical research deepened, I joined several genealogy research communities, including r/Genealogy. I did this in order to learn more advanced research methods, and to read the stories of what people found in their past. A while ago, I decided to request support in figuring out the origins of Hyzdu. An individual I spoke to took an ingenious approach. They searched the online birth records of New York State for all boys born on December 24th, 1907. During this search, they found the birth certificate for one Stephen Hoidu, parents Deshe Hoidu and Susan Hoidu (Maiden Name: Bik), both natives of Hungary.

This led me on a long genealogical journey. I found out that Deshe Hoidu was actually Dezső Hajdu, an immigrant from a small village in Hungary. This was a birth out of wedlock, and Dezso ended up remarrying and having several children with two other wives. I could find no information about Susan.

I started to build a family tree; I found his children, then their children. I looked at obituaries, old newspaper articles, anything that I could to find any relatives from this family. I sent out Instagram and Facebook Messages to people I thought could be my distant relatives, where I explained my far fetched story. I even wrote an article (available on request) detailing my findings to my family.

Months passed. Finally, I received a response from the wife of someone who I hoped to be my relative. She was skeptical, asking for more information. I sent her the article and my Ancestry.com tree, and she confirmed that I was related to her husband!

I got to share information with them and send them pictures of their long lost relatives. There was even a distant resemblance. The most rewarding of all was to speak to my 86 year old great uncle. Because both of his parents were orphans, he never had any uncles or cousins. He was delighted to hear that he had cousins, and got to see their faces. It was truly a rewarding experience, and why I got into genealogy in the first place.

If people are interested, I’d be happy to share what else I found. My great-grandmother was mixed race, and what I found out about her early life is a fascinating look into identity and race during early 1900s America. Thanks for reading!

Edit: Part Two due to popular demand, I wrote this up!


r/Genealogy • • Jul 11 '26 WOW Bravo

Studies and Stories I solved a multi-generational mystery! Yay me!

1.7k Upvotes

Forgive me for tooting my own horn, but I've been working on finding the lineage of one particular ancestor for more than 20 years, and today I decisively solved the mystery.

My father's ggg grandfather had no parentage in any of the assembled genealogies (including the old school, hand-written ones!). Folks recited various origin stories, like he was raised by Native American Indians, or that he was born in Holland. I've spent many years gathering the documents (census data, marriage records, tax rolls, property deeds, death records, and probate/estate records) but never found his birth record. I suspected he was related to a particular surname patrilineage, but the paper trail was dead. I slowly assembled a genealogy for this surname's history in the US. I located a book that listed all the relationships from the 1600s to the 1800s and entered them into tree form. It was a lot of work. It involved hundreds of people--and I tried to fit him into various places in the genealogy. But my hypotheses were all speculative and without any evidence.

Recently someone contacted me on Ancestry trying to figure out how we are related because she had seen that we shared DNA. After digging through her tree, I found a name I'd never encountered with the same surname as my gggg grandfather. I spent months searching for documents and completing that person's genealogy while modeling different scenarios for how we might be related. After months of this work I concluded her ancestor was a sibling or a niece to my gggg grandfather.

After officially adding that person to my tree (along with her discovered genealogy) with an assumed uncle/niece relationship, I started getting many matches through that lineage showing up in Ancestry. By comparing the degree of our DNA matches today, I found that the math worked out for an unforeseen option: my ancestor was a HALF sibling to the added person. It took a lot of scenario-building, but it finally made sense of the people I was matching.

As soon as I figured that out, I started comparing DNA segments against new potential relatives I had through this theoretical lineage, searching all my DNA matches for this surname. I assembled them all and ran an analysis: they all matched for a half-sibling relationship. Wow. I was blown away. (I used AI and Ancestry's algorhythms to do the math, as I had done for so many scenarios before that came back less than ideal!)

I still don't know my ancestor's mother, but today I decisively confirmed his father, and now I have found DNA matches to that person as well--as well as HIS father. I was so happy I cried. I solved the mystery after 20 years.

All the folks who cared about this mystery are dead, except my elderly dad and my great uncle. So I feel kind of joyful that I was able to figure things out, but sad that there are not many people left who care about it. So here I am, tooting my own horn to strangers on Reddit.

Thank you for reading.

Edits:

Wow, this is an amazingly supportive and wholesome sub. I am overwhelmed with gratitude for all your kindness! Thank you all so much.

Also, when I went back to my Ancestry tree this morning, I realized that this is my ggg grandfather (3gs, not 4), and my father's gg grandfather. So not quite as impressive, I think, but I now have the gggg and ggggg grandfathers' names--in fact the whole lineage all the way back to England since all I had to do was plug this new ancestor into the surname tree I built over the last few years. :D Now I can move on to another ancestor mystery.


r/Genealogy • • Aug 05 '25

Question Great Grandma thought she was a twin, dig some digging and found out she wasn’t. How often does this happen?

1.7k Upvotes

My great grandmother and her sister thought they were twins, and it turns out their mother lied to everyone.

The girls were born very close in age (9-10 months apart), had twin names (Ona Fae and Osa Mae), were born within the same year, and looked a lot a like, so I guess everyone believed their mom.

The girls were separated at 5 yrs old when their father died, and their mother was sent to an asylum. Ona was sent to live with her father’s other wife down the road, and Osa was sent out West to work with their older brother on a ranch as a maid.

Osa returned to her hometown at 17, when she fell pregnant with her married boss’s baby, but by that point Ona was long gone further south working in a factory.

Osa lived her whole life talking about her twin sister that she missed so much, but she died in 1999. In 2007 my grandmother had tracked down Ona in Virginia who was deeply saddened to learn that her twin sister had died. Ona also thought she was a twin.

In 2014 while making a family tree I stumbled upon their birth certificates, and found out they weren’t twins at all. Just born within the same year. I know that it wasn’t a mess up in dates either, because Ona was born at home, and Osa was born at a hospital due to their mothering laboring for 2 straight days.

I have no clue why their mom lied, but both women died longing for their twin sister, when they weren’t even twins.


r/Genealogy • • Mar 18 '25

News Trump's 3/14 executive order hurts genealogists

1.6k Upvotes

On March 14, Preident Trump issued an executive order to eliminate the federal Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS), a small federal agency serving libraries and museums nationwide. A great deal of the digitization of historical resources performed by cultural heritage organizations in the U.S. is done with grant funding from the IMLS. Resources digitized with these grants must always be made freely available to the general public, and include things like historical newspapers, government records, local history documents, photographs, film and sound recordings, etc.

If funding for the IMLS is eliminated, not only will digitization of these resources be severely impacted/stopped, but many of these resources may no longer be available online (hosting large databases is costly).

Please take five minutes and contact your federal representatives and ask them to protect the Institute of Museum and Library Services. The work they fund is widely supported across the political spectrum and is greatly valued by genealogists and historical researchers. Several of the programs of the IMLS are protected by statute, such as the Grants to States program which funds quite a bit of history digitization.

You can also learn more and sign a petition here: https://www.everylibrary.org/statementimls2025


r/Genealogy • • Dec 31 '24 I’ll Drink to That Hooray Heart of Silver Polished Silver Turd

News Genealogy has been my hobby for 50 years, and I have some advice.

1.6k Upvotes

When I started out, I was focused on "finding my roots", and spent all of my effort trying to extend my ancestry into the distant past. When I connected to lines that had already been researched, I made sure to copy all of it (this was pre-computer, so it was all on paper). I bought a wide-carriage typewriter so I could fill out those legal-sized pedigree and family group sheets that were in use then, and they ultimately filled several large binders.

After a while, I realized that this pile of information was impressive, but not terribly interesting. What was interesting was the biographical information left by my closer relatives- journals, diaries, photos, documents- things that make them real people.

By the time I got around to documenting the descendants of my great-grandparents, I saw that many of them were still alive when I started doing genealogy, but now were passed on. I contacted cousins who let me look through their old, unlabeled photo albums (remember photo albums?), and regretted that the people who could have told me who these people were had been around at one time and would have loved to tell me all about these people.

So here is my advice- once you identify your great-grandparents, work your way back down the cousin lines- your grand aunts and uncles and their children. Find out who is still alive and arrange to meet or correspond with them. Invite yourself over to look through their photo albums and make copies of photos of your extended family members (you can do this in their home with a camera and downward-facing tripod- no need to go to Kinko's).

(Aside- most people tell me they have an old album of photos in a closet, but they doubt there is anything interesting in them. They are always wrong- I have never failed to find at least one gobsmacking treasure of a photo in there.)

Bottom line- your ancestors will always be there, and the information you need to find them will continue to become more available, but your cousins are getting older, and when they pass, they will take whole encyclopedias of valuable family information with them. Go find your oldest distant relatives and arrange to talk to them about their families and histories. You will find that one page of family history, even if it's about farmers and shoe salesmen, is more valuable than an entire volume of royal ancestors.


r/Genealogy • • Apr 22 '25 Wholesome Seal

DNA My great-grandmother disappeared in 1932. A DNA match cracked the case 90 years later

1.6k Upvotes

My family spent nearly two decades searching for Estrella Suarez, who vanished from southern Illinois in the early 1930s. There were no records, no grave, no explanation—until a DNA match led us to someone with a different name … and a second life. I’ve started writing about the search and what I’ve uncovered —DNA surprises, hidden siblings, adoption files, and more. Here’s chapter 1 if you’re curious or walking a similar path. I’d also love to hear if anyone’s had similar experiences reconnecting lost relatives through DNA. https://substack.com/@buriedthreads/note/p-161903561?r=vup5z&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action


r/Genealogy • • Mar 25 '26

Studies and Stories Mapping my ancestors' addresses changed my whole approach to research

1.5k Upvotes

Like most people, I started my family history research by just building a standard tree, plugging in names, dates, and marriages. It was cool, but it always felt a bit flat, like I was just looking at data rather than real people.

Recently I was looking at a couple in my tree from Kent who got married in 1909. I noticed their addresses on the marriage certificate (94 Albemarle Rd and 67 Osborne Rd) and decided to map them just for fun. Turns out, they lived literally 150 feet apart. Less than a minute's walk.

It made me realize that these weren't just two random people who happened to meet; they probably grew up seeing each other every day. It totally shifted my perspective. I stopped just looking at direct lineage and started paying attention to their neighbors.

Honestly, it cleared up so many dead ends. Common surnames started to make sense once I saw who lived next to whom. I realized that a lot of the "random" witnesses on documents were actually just the folks living next door. I even found out that different branches of my family lived in the exact same small settlements way before they actually intermarried.

Now, whenever I look at a census, I always check a few pages before and after my ancestors to see who else is around. It’s been such a game-changer for me that I actually started building a visual tool to map these households out over time (it's called The Settlement Project if anyone's curious to check it out).

I feel like we're not just researching families, we're researching whole communities. Has anyone else stumbled into this? Has looking at the neighbors ever helped you break down a brick wall?


r/Genealogy • • Jan 13 '25 Helpful

News Can you read cursive? It's a superpower the National Archives is looking for.

1.4k Upvotes

USA Today article:

Can you read cursive? It's a superpower the National Archives is looking for.

The National Archives is looking for volunteers with an increasingly rare skill: Reading cursive.

If you can read cursive, the National Archives would like a word.

Or a few million. More than 200 years worth of U.S. documents need transcribing (or at least classifying) and the vast majority from the Revolutionary War era are handwritten in cursive – requiring people who know the flowing, looped form of penmanship.

“Reading cursive is a superpower,” said Suzanne Isaacs, a community manager with the National Archives Catalog in Washington, D.C.

She is part of the team that coordinates the more than 5,000 Citizen Archivists helping the Archive read and transcribe some of the more than 300 million digitized objects in its catalog. And they're looking for volunteers with an increasingly rare skill.

These records range from Revolutionary War pension records to the field notes of Charles Mason of the Mason-Dixon Line to immigration documents from the 1890s to Japanese evacuation records to the 1950 Census.

An application for a Revolutionary War Pension by Innit Hollister, written in August of 1832. The National Archives uses Citizen Archivists who volunteer to help transcribe such materials. The ability to read cursive handwriting is helpful but not essential.

“We create missions where we ask volunteers to help us transcribe or tag records in our catalog,” Isaacs said.

To volunteer, all that’s required is to sign up online and then launch in. “There's no application,” she said. “You just pick a record that hasn't been done and read the instructions. It's easy to do for a half hour a day or a week.”

Being able to read the longhand script is a huge help because so many of the documents are written using it.

“It’s not just a matter of whether you learned cursive in school, it’s how much you use cursive today,” she said.

An application for a Revolutionary War Pension for written on April 29, 1852. The National Archives uses Citizen Archivists who volunteer to help transcribe such materials. The ability to read cursive handwriting is helpful.

Cursive has fallen out of use

American’s skill with this connected form of script has been slowly waning for decades.

Schoolchildren were once taught impeccable copperplate handwriting and penmanship was something they were graded on.

That began to change when typewriters first came into common use in the business world in the 1890s and was further supplanted in the 1980s by computers.

Still, handwriting continued to be considered a necessary skill until the 1990s when many people shifted to email and then in the 2000s to texting.

By 2010, the Common Core teaching standards emphasized keyboard skills (once taught as “typewriting”) and no longer required handwriting on the presumption that most of the writing students would do would be on computers.

That led to a pushback and today at least 14 states require that cursive handwriting be taught, including California in 2023. But it doesn’t mean that they actually use it in real life.

In the past, most American students began learning to write in cursive in third grade, making it a rite of passage, said Jaime Cantrell, a professor of English at Texas A&M University - Texarkana whose students take part in the Citizen Archivist work, putting their skills reading old documents to work.

A student at Orangethorpe Elementary School practices writing cursive as California grade school students are being required to learn cursive handwriting this year, in Fullerton, California, U.S. January 23, 2024.

For her generation, “cursive was a coming-of-age part of literacy in the 1980s. We learned cursive and then we could write like adults wrote,” she said.

While many of her students today learned cursive in school, they never use it and seldom read it, she said. She can tell because she writes feedback on their papers in cursive.

Some of her students aren’t even typing anymore. Instead, they’re just using talk-to-text technology or even artificial intelligence. “I know that because there’s no punctuation, it reads like a stream of consciousness.”

It’s an uphill – but by no means impossible – battle to become comfortable with reading and writing the conjoined script. And it opens up access to a wealth of older documents.

Cursive is still a skill for some

California passed a law in 2023 requiring that “cursive or joined italics” be taught for first through sixth grades. The law’s author said it was so students could read primary source historical documents.

That’s exactly how Cantrell’s students use it. One of the classes she teaches involves deciphering documents written in the 18th and 19th centuries – and one of their projects is to get involved in the National Archive’s transcription work.

“There is certainly a learning curve,” said Cantrell. “But my students stick it out. They feel like they have a duty, they feel like they’re making a difference.”

Being able to read cursive is just the start of deciphering older documents, said the National Archive’s Nancy Sullivan. The handwriting of the 18th and 19th centuries isn’t what today’s third graders are taught.

Though sometimes the oldest writing is the easiest to read, said Cantrell.

“If you look at Abigail Adams' letters to her husband (President John Adams) and his responses, the cursive is an art form, it’s so uniform,” she said.

AI can only go so far with cursive

AI is starting to be able to read cursive but only with human help, said the National Archive’s Sullivan.

The Archives has been working with FamilySearch, a genealogical nonprofit operated by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints that offers free genealogical software, searching and access to historical documents.

FamilySearch developed an AI program that reads handwritten documents. However, a person is still required to do the final edit.

“There’s usually some mistakes,” she said. “So we call it ‘extracted text’ and our volunteers have to look it over and compare it to the original.” Only once a volunteer has looked the document over is it considered an actual transcription.

And AI can’t always decipher the often problematic documents their volunteers deal with, said Isaacs. Sometimes they’ve been torn, smudged, folded, or dog-eared. In the case of Revolutionary War pension applications, widows had to prove they were married so they often included handwritten family tree pages torn from the family Bible.

Not to mention simple poor penmanship. “Some of the Justices of the Peace, their handwriting is atrocious,” said volunteer Christine Ritter, 70, who lives in Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania.

There are cross-outs, things written on the other side that bleed through, strange and inventive spellings, old forms of letters (a double S was sometimes written as a “long s” and looked like an F) and even children’s doodles over top. And many obsolete terms and legal words that can flummox even the most erudite readers.

“It feels like solving a puzzle. I really enjoy it,” said volunteer Tiffany Meeks, 37. She started volunteering as a transcriber in June and learned a new word – paleography, deciphering historical manuscripts.

“I felt like I was learning a different language. Not only was I brushing up on my cursive, but my old English as well,” she said.

No cursive? No problem

The Archive’s Isaacs is clear that volunteers don’t have to start out knowing cursive, you can learn along the way. “It helps – but it’s not necessary.”

For example, there’s a “no cursive required” option for those reading Revolutionary War pension records. Instead of reading and transcribing the records, volunteers can also help append “tags” to records that have already been transcribed by other Citizen Archivists so that they’re easier to search.

You can also pick it up as you go along, Ritter said.

“When they first sent me a document I thought, ‘Oh my gosh, I can’t read this. I got nervous. But the longer you do them the easier it gets,” she said.

Ritter’s working on Revolutionary War pension files for soldiers who served at the Battle of Guildford Courthouse on March 15, 1781. As she works, she imagines how much it will mean to families to find something so old about one of their relatives.

She says she once prided herself on her perfect penmanship but today says her handwriting is “atrocious.” Still, she can read cursive with the best of them and it’s become a wonderful hobby.

“I wake up in the morning and have my breakfast with my husband, then he goes off to go fishing and I come in my work room, I have my computer and I put on my radio station with oldies and I just start transcribing,” she said. “I just love it so much.”


r/Genealogy • • Mar 05 '22

Solved The “Cherokee Princess” in my family

1.2k Upvotes

Growing up I would hear occasional whispers that there was a “Cherokee Princess” in the lineage of my paternal grandfather. I mostly ignored it as at the time I wasn’t much interested in genealogy. More recently I have come to understand that this is common among many white families in the US, especially those who migrated out of the South to the Midwest.

Fast forward to a few years ago when several people did a DNA test that showed zero indigenous ancestry. Some members of my family were heartbroken, as they had formed some identity from this family myth.

Now here I am, casually researching genealogy in my spare time, and come across my paternal grandfather’s great x grandmother, whose middle name is Cinderella and who lived in, wait for it, Cherokee, Iowa.

I’m now pretty sure the whole “Cherokee Princess” thing was just a joke or a pet name that lost its context as it passed through the generations, and I am still laughing about it weeks later.


r/Genealogy • • Feb 05 '26

Community Festivus I'm the first woman in 10 generations and 200 years to not be a teen mother

1.2k Upvotes

As the title says, I'm the first woman as far back as I've made it on my mother's side that hasn't been a teen mother. My father's side averages 22-30 for women's first births in the same span, surprisingly only one teen mom. Granted, my mother's side were all in poverty and I'm sure that plays a part. Does anyone else find interesting patterns in their research?


r/Genealogy • • Nov 20 '24

Question Dark Family Secret Uncovered while Researching - What to do next?

1.2k Upvotes

Burner account

In 2022, I began diving into genealogical research, piecing together my family tree bit by bit. My family has always been fractured and spread across several states, though primarily rooted in Louisiana. On my dad’s side, things are especially messy. He was his mom’s only child, but he had siblings on his dad’s side. My grandparents married in 1960, separated by 1964, and divorced in 1970. I can’t help but wonder if their marriage was strained in part by a tragedy that occurred during that time—the death of their infant daughter.

Before she passed away in 2006, my grandma briefly mentioned this baby, who died when my dad was 4 years old. The family story was that the baby died of SIDS or “crib death.” Other versions told by other family members suggested hydrocephaly or that she was stillborn. I didn't think much of the inconsistencies because it happened such a long time ago. I was only searching digital newspaper archives for her obituary. Typed in baby's name and what I found was not what I expected.

The baby didn’t die a natural death AT ALL. She was murdered.

According to the articles I found, the baby, only seven days old, was suffocated with a plastic bag while she slept. The article stated that the baby's 4-year-old sister suffocated her. This "sister" could only be my dad (misgendered in the article) or one of my grandma’s two younger sisters—both of whom were preschool-aged at the time. Based on family dynamics, I suspect it was one of my grandma’s little sisters.

My grandma always had a strained relationship with her youngest sister, who was 4 years old when the baby died. This great-aunt often wondered why my grandma seemed to prefer their middle sister over her. They argued frequently and never seemed to see eye-to-eye on things. If my great-aunt was indeed the one responsible, I doubt she would even remember the event, given her age at the time. My dad, on the other hand, has no idea about this version of events. He firmly believes his sister died of SIDS.

Most of the elders in my family who could clarify this have passed away, but a few of my grandma’s first cousins are still alive. They’re in their 80s now, and I find myself questioning whether I should even ask them to rehash this painful chapter of the past. Should I risk reopening old wounds just to get answers? Does this qualify as an old wound???

My grandparents carried this secret to their graves. I’m left wondering: Do I tell my dad what I’ve learned? Potentially risking his relationship with his aunt who is like a sister to him? Is it important for him to know the truth, or is it better to let sleeping dogs lie?

EDIT/UPDATE: I'm not saying anything to my dad, his aunt, or any of the remaining elders. I will let the secret remain buried. I read through every comment here, each offering very unique perspectives and insight. Questions about what I hoped to gain really stood out to me. I thought about it long. There really would be nothing to gain by telling my dad. It would just hurt him and change his relationship with his aunt. As many of you have suggested, I do think seeking counseling for managing the weight of knowing something alone will be helpful.


r/Genealogy • • Sep 16 '20

Solved Last month I came on here looking for help to identify the family of a WWI veteran who’s ashes were left abandoned in a garage...

1.0k Upvotes

Yesterday, thanks to the help of everyone here, PFC Lewis Hamilton was finally laid to rest.

Although his family was never found, as he doesn’t have one to be found, he has hopefully found peace, 54 years after his passing.

Thank you again for everything you’ve done, this subreddit has a great community of sharp minded people; none of this would have been possible without it!


r/Genealogy • • Feb 16 '25

News PSA for all our new genealogists: do not trust ANY information in other people's family trees

1.0k Upvotes

Most of us have been there. Brand new, excited about what we're finding on family trees, and how much we're discovering about our family.

You will find out later just how unreliable most of that is. Other people's trees are copied and pasted, misinformation abounds all too often. And then later, when you try to actually get accurate, it creates a huge mess which is a pain to cleanup and may even lead you to just start over.

Realize now most of what you're going to see on other people's family trees is inaccurate- especially when you get to older trees, it often may as well be mythology.

Learn now early on, don't trust a tree. Look for the records! You actually want to look for the marriage, birth, and Death Certificates. Learn to find and read census records. Government registers and indexes and things like that.

Get the information from the actual records and only records. And if there is no record or source, treat it as baloney. (Or at best perhaps a hint to dig in and search for actual records later)


r/Genealogy • • Dec 27 '21

Solved Ancestry said JK!!

1.0k Upvotes

My entire life I was told my father was murdered when I was 18 months old. I never once questioned it. I supposedly looked like him. I could see it in his picture. My nose seemed to match. His entire family knew of me and welcomed me into it with open arms. (I didn't meet them until I was 18)

My husband and I got DNA tests just to find out our heritage in 2018 and didn't think too much of it besides seeing the cool map. I started getting new matches on my tree for people I had never heard about. They were listed as first cousins, aunts and uncles. I reached out to one in particular that was a first cousin. We messaged back and forth a few times over about two years when I got a notification I'd never seen before.

"You have a new parent-child match"

Ummm WHAT THE FUCK!?

I immediately started googling this person, asked my mother, my grandma and anyone who could even possibly have answers. Nobody believed this. My mother denied any possibility because she said she hadn't been with anyone else even close to the time I was conceived. I reached out to my supposed father on ancestry and after introducing myself, it seemed he had blocked me. I was upset, I was hurt, I was angry. So I did what most pissed off women do. I researched better than the FBI 😂

I found his wife, his step daughter and even his address and military info. SCOOOOOORE. I messaged his wife on FB and she informed me that she had been with him for 25 years and she'd never seen him like this. He's in shock she stated. She advised for me to give him time and he'll come around. Because "That's just the kind of man he is."

I talked to my mother about it again and tried to talk logically about the events surrounding my conception, pregnancy and birth.

I reminded her that she said I was 6 weeks early. If we went off the time frame that she claims happened (for original man to be my father) my date of conception would have been end of July. If I was 6 weeks early, my birthday should have been around March 1st.

My birthday is April 25th. So either A- I was not conceived around July 20th, or B- I was not premie.

I knew from having the same pediatrician my entire life and knowing my medical history, I was 100% premie.

I was conceived around late August/early September 1987.

Guess who was in the same town the fall before my birth (military records), remembers my mother, and who my mother suddenly remembered the name of and their one night stand!? (Without coaching or hints)

My biological father.

HOLY SHIT ANCESTRY!

My father isn't dead. I have a dad now! This has thrown me for a crazy loop... But I feel that this hole I never knew needed filled is full and it's the weirdest feeling. Great, but weird!

It's been a little over a year now and so far it's been a crazy ride! I haven't met him in person, but we text and sometimes call.

Any others have a story similar?


r/Genealogy • • Nov 22 '22

Request A gentle reminder to those who exclude unmarried, childless partners in family trees:

1.0k Upvotes

We’re in: family photos, census reports, obituaries, property records, death certificates, probate records, city listings and newspaper clippings. We’re aunts and uncles in holiday cards and baby books. Our signatures are in church registers, wedding books and legal documents. We’re insurance beneficiaries, health care agents. We’re in your family stories, relative’s memories, and gossip. We break down brick walls. We’re not in: birth and marriage records.