I have an ancestor, Stephen Covey (born 1826 or 1827 or 1828 in Canada, died 1892 in Little Falls, Herkimer County, New York) who I am trying to prove, or as close to prove as possible, who his parents were.
All that I know of him so far, come from the notes a cousin made some years ago. Those notes are as follows:
"I have been to the Lowville (New York) library, they have no newspapers from that time. I have been to the Lewis County (New York) court house, and found a deed. My next step will be to see if churches in Greig or Harrisburg, Lewis County, NY have any records. There are very few Stephen Coveys in upstate NY during the 1800s, and only one that fits his age and family lore about where he was born. My father and his siblings, along with my father's first cousin have said they believe their grandfather was born in Canada, that he came from or near Covey Hill (in Quebec), and that Stephen's grandfather was named Samuel. Stephen also had relatives in Gananoque, Canada. With those facts in mind, I tend to think his father was Daniel Miles Covey, of who Daniel's father was Samuel Covey. Both (Daniel and Samuel) went back and forth between Canada and Vermont."
My cousin in her notes said that she couldn't find a death record for Stephen, but I was able to find a death index for him, which has his death date and location as May 1, 1892 in Little Falls, New York.
I sent off for a death record transcript for Stephen, but unfortunately Stephen's parents were not listed on the transcript. The death transcript says "Birth place Canada, 67 years old when he passed, Laborer for employment". Placing his birth year as about 1825 according to that.
(I am confident that Stephen dying in Little Falls is my Stephen, because my grandma visited his grave location once. I found a photo that my grandma took, of the same gravesite location that is currently on FindaGrave for Stephen at Lowville Rural Cemetery. The death transcript has a place of burial listed of Lowville)
Some of the "facts" so far on Ancestry .com, I'd had to try to parse through, would suggest that Daniel Miles Covey's son Stephen Covey, died in Vermont in 1867, but I have seen no sources for that year of death.
A number of documents list that Stephen Covey was born in Vermont, namely (some of?) the vital records of Stephen's children. But an equal amount of records, seemingly a greater number, have Stephen being born in Canada. For instance, I've only seen 1 census record for Stephen list Vermont, all the other census records list Canada. It seems the children mistakenly thought their father was born in Vermont? (This would track if the family frequently went between Vermont and Canada)
In fact, I believe I was able to find the source of that claimed year of death (1866/1867), a single family tree created on RootsWeb by a Pam Wood Waugh.
I emailed Pam, and she said that she "made a tree 20 years ago, and most everyone copied mine". And, "I came up with that he died about 1866 many years ago, and everyone on Ancestry jumped on it. I wrongly assumed that he died, as he just vanished, and his wife remarried. I just never found a death record. I joined Ancestry in 1999". And, "I'm beginning to think that the two Stephens are one and the same. By Sep 1867, his wife (Eliza) Jane was marrying John Vosburgh as her 2nd marriage, neither widowed or divorced was circled. It would seem Stephen didn't care that he had a wife and seven kids, and wanted a new start (and so moved to New York). Right about 1866, your Stephen Covey shows up". And finally, "The tree was just a working tree, I have always had my own site and RootWeb, until they stopped letting us update", explaining why the old over-copied tree has not yet since been amended.
It seems this is quite the tangled web weaved.
Something that I think would possibly "prove" the connection would be to find the marriage record between Stephen and Elizabeth "Eliza" Jane Partlow (perhaps his parents are listed on the marriage record), Pam's RootWeb tree lists that Stephen and Eliza married on 1 January 1850 at Alburgh, Grand Isle Co, Vermont. (but I guess even in the case of finding the marriage record, I would still have to prove that "both" Stephens are one and the same).
Online trees list a birth location of Clarenceville, Quebec, Canada as the birth location for Stephen. But as I've not been able to find any birth records for Stephen (nor do I expect to, as I don't think Canada vital records go back to 1827 (nor was Canada yet a county in that year), I suspect that people have simply copied the declared birth location of Stephen's father of Clarenceville.
There seems to be a lot of copying and assumption surronding Stephen Covey. Much of which has proven a headache to try to solve.
I have not been able to find an obituary for Stephen Covey, or for Daniel Miles Covey (died 1873, in Quebec?)