r/Genealogy • • Sep 19 '23

Question How can genealogical societies be more LGBTQ friendly?

0 Upvotes

In my last post, I asked why young people may or may not be joining genealogical societies. One response was that they don't know if the societies are welcoming to LGBTQ folk.

I'm trying to brainstorm ways that my local society can be better about this, but not being LGBTQ myself, I'd like to crowdsource more ideas.

I've come up with two: list pronouns for officers on the website/email communications and teach seminars that focus on LGBTQ genealogy or local history.

Any other thoughts are appreciated! TIA!


r/Genealogy • • May 24 '23

Question LGBTQ+ ancestors?

2 Upvotes

Has anyone used ancestry to find more about if their ancestors were queer or LGBTQ+? I have a hunch my great aunt was (never married, had a longtime "best friend"), but wondering if anyone else has used ancestry to fill in some missing pieces. For context, I'm a lesbian and interested in learning more about my family history particularly as it relates to queerness, in addition to oral histories and word of mouth.


r/Genealogy • • Oct 04 '25

Question My Family History is Takes a Disturbing Turn Researching

0 Upvotes

I’ve been researching my family tree and recently discovered something surprising my grandparents are third cousins or maybe even closer. I got into my dad’s side, I noticed repeating last names and even first names. For example my ggg-grandfather on my grandpa’s side shares the same name as my gggg-grandfather on my grandma’s side.

The more I researched the clearer it became that they came from the same family both of my gggg-grandfathers were brothers. It’s been strange and a little unsettling to uncover this. I don’t know many relatives on my dad’s side, and when I hear stories about the family, the repeated names make the connections even more obvious.

I feel confused about whether to include this in my family tree. I want it to be accurate and informative, but it’s uncomfortable to see the Last Names. I help a lot of people with their own family trees, and I want mine to be accurate as possible but this is one detail that makes me Leave Their Names Blank and unfinished it irritates me but it’s kind of embarrassing.. Has anyone else gone through something similar? Did you leave it Blank


r/Genealogy • • Sep 05 '22

Question How to determine if an ancestor was transgender

0 Upvotes

SOLVED - see below edit #2.

I have had this happen a few times recently: I am using census records to help fill out details on members of a particular family and I notice that one family member has a different sex than what is otherwise documented (and just to note - I am going and looking at the census document itself, not just what reading is shown in the information 'read' or digitized by the computer). For example, I found an ancestor (not a direct ancestor - it would have been like a great-something uncle or 2nd cousin twice removed, etc.) where by all accounts they were documented as female on census records in their early life, and then later find a biography of them with male pronouns. Same name, same birth year, same family. This person also had a professional career as a lawyer, I think, which would have been challenging for women at that time, and they were not married.

I'm curious if other people have run into this situation and how you went about trying to tease out the accurate information. At the end of the day it doesn't matter - if that person truly is transgender, more power to them as I'm sure it would not have been an easy life. But it does make me question the accuracy of my research and documentation and want to make sure I am not incorrectly transcribing something or perhaps attributing information about one family members that is meant for another, or that I am inadvertently omitting someone else from the family.

EDIT: Edited to add that I did say that 'it doesn't matter', that was in reference to it not mattering as it isn't a direct ancestor. However, it DOES matter to me - there's so much erasure that occurs in genealogy. There are a lot of women that have been left off of transcribed histories in my family tree - in one case in particular, it was documented that there were daughters in a family but they were not recorded. No one bothered to write down their names. I also know I am not the only person where this has occurred - this is quite common. I want to be able to honor people for who they were, even if I'm the only one that is going to know and record this information.

EDIT #2: I'm considering this solved. Thank you so much to those who pointed out the errors in transcription from census takers - I think this person had a feminine sounding middle name and if that was used, it might have thrown the census taker (the census only has the first name recorded but I can easily see a parent saying both first and middle names). I appreciate all of your insight!


r/Genealogy • • Nov 02 '24

DNA Is it weird to identify with your mother’s side?

5 Upvotes

I (21m) have no idea who I am. My ancestry is mixed but I have my mother’s last name which is Italian and she is half Mexican on her mother’s side. I grew up only knowing my mother’s family and I have no idea who my father’s family is but they are from Mexico. I’ve never even met my paternal grandfather or his father (even though they are all alive)but I grew up with my maternal grandmother and her mother. I feel embarrassed identifying with my mom’s side and having her last name. I feel like most people identify with their paternal lineage where I could not care less. I wish I had a last name to be proud of and I feel like a fake having my mom’s surname. Is it weird to identify with your mother’s heritage?


r/Genealogy • • Mar 30 '23

Question A Question for Queer Genealogists

90 Upvotes

I am a gay genealogist. I don't mean I have an expertise in finding gay people in archives. I mean that I, me, am a gay man and I 'do' genealogy. I use a lot of sites, but the main ones are FMP, Ancestry and FamilySearch. I have been to RootsTech as a vendor and as a visitor and 'influencer'.

Obviously the Mormon Church is heavily involved (understatement) in Ancestry, FS and absolutely in RT. However, the Church is decidedly un-queer friendly, and Utah passed its statewide ban on gender-affirming surgery for young people, and to think the LDS have nothing to do with politics in Utah is naive at best.

The Church has expressed support of gay marriage, but stands firm that their marriage doctrine is one man + one woman, and condemns homosexuality as sinful. Admittedly they are not the only religion that does this. However, they are the only religious body that I am aware of that is so heavily involved in genealogy (for ... reasons).

Obviously I support gay marriage (or just ... marriage as we call it in my house) and am abhorred at the treatment of trans people at the moment in the US and here in the UK.

Consequently, am I hypocritical to continue to pay for an Ancestry account and using their services, and those of FS?

I am in a position of privilege. I'm white, I'm cis. Should I be complacent and until they come for me - which they will if left unchecked - ignore wider implications and continue using the sites?

Or maybe I'm overthinking things...? The records are already there so I should stop being daft?

Hugely interested in hearing from queer genealogists about your thoughts.

Shitty comments about trans rights will be reported.


r/Genealogy • • Sep 15 '24

Question Are DNA tests worth it for Pacific Islanders?

0 Upvotes

I have a majority of Samoan and Hawaiian ancestry that goes back quite a few generations on ancestry.com.

I want to know if it is truly worth it to pay for a DNA test with 23andMe in terms of them having accurate information about the islands? I've heard stories of inaccuracy and I worry about that because a lot of my family history has been erased from existence. Any other islanders here who've taken a DNA test find it to be true to your bloodline?


r/Genealogy • • Nov 05 '24

DNA My 1st Cousin 2xRemoved

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/Genealogy • • May 05 '24

DNA Don’t use ancestry.com

8 Upvotes

Good morning, I don’t recommend ancestry.com to anyone anymore because they took away my ability to see all my relatives. They only show maybe 4-5 close relatives. Now they charging for it for you to see all your relatives. I now recommend https://www.23andme.com. That’s not right what https://www.ancestry.com had done to their customers. Thank you.


r/Genealogy • • Apr 05 '26

Methodology Is it a boundary violation when someone researches another person's family history without asking?

68 Upvotes

Edit2: A few thoughts after reading through the discussion further. Original story below.

The underlying principle that I think matters here is this: professional communities that work with historical material about real people have developed ethical frameworks that go beyond legality, precisely because they recognised that access does not equal permission. That’s the conversation I think genealogy still needs to have, especially now that this kind of research is freely available to anyone online, regardless of training, experience or awareness of the impact it can have on living people.

This topic really makes me think. And I have the feeling that I have hit a real blind spot here, given the volume of responses to my question. The topic is not trivial.

Genealogy was historically a niche pursuit practiced by people with some level of expertise and a personal connection to their own family. My own family commissioned a professional researcher in the 1980s, who approached the work very conscientiously. Digitalisation and platforms like Ancestry, MyHeritage and various Facebook groups have democratised it, but the ethics haven’t kept pace with that development. The existing codes of conduct were written for a very different kind of practice. This is ultimately not even a genealogy problem specifically, but a digital ethics problem.

I did some research into academic literature on this question, and there is actually quite a lot out there.

Dr. Penny Walters has published both a paper and a book on this which is a good starting point. She writes: “We all think that we’re a ‘nice’ person, and aren’t involved in being unethical. As a relatively new discipline, however, ethical issues within genealogy are starting to become more visible, especially since DNA testing, and therefore many and varied ethical dilemmas will follow.” The full paper is available here: https://www.newyorkfamilyhistory.org/sites/default/files/EthicalDilemmasInGenealogy.pdf

For those interested in going deeper, I would also recommend:

Helen Nissenbaum, “Privacy in Context” (2010) - she develops the concept of contextual integrity, which argues that information is only ethically shared when the context of sharing matches the context in which it was originally given. This applies directly to genealogical research involving people you personally know.

Marya Schechtman, “The Constitution of Selves” (1996) and Paul Ricœur, “Oneself as Another” (1992) - both deal with narrative identity and the idea that the story of who we are is something we have a right to author ourselves.

This topic is clearly not new. And beyond my personal situation, I think it deserves far more discussion especially in this Reddit! than it currently gets.

My original Problem/Question:

A family acquaintance is a passionate hobby genealogist. I once asked him for help with a single, specific translation of an old document, with just ONE word on it. (Screenshot) That was it a one-time request.

Sometime later I googled my own last name and found posts in open translation Facebook groups where he had been asking about my ancestors names and their data, using names and details he had found on platforms, but I had never given him permission to share or research.

When I confronted him, his response was that I had "sent him data" meaning the translation request. He seemed genuinely unable to understand why I had a problem with it. He is super nosy, about everything about my family. When I was in Berlin he wanted to know about my research. I denied any knowledge.

A few years ago he showed me a photo of my grandmother’s grave (she had passed away not even 15 years prior) that he ‚had found in an online forum.‘ Without warning, without asking. That shook me deeply, so I told him, but he couldn’t understand why and said it’s legal, so it’s okay…

My issue isn't legal. I know old records are technically accessible. My issue is that my family history isn't neutral historical material to me. It's personal. It's mine. And I never invited anyone into it. He knows no one but me from this family branche! My father and his siblings are all traumatized by my grandfather and not very interested in the history, so it’s sensible. It feels like he crossed a line.

Does the genealogy community have ethical guidelines around this? And more broadly: do you think researching someone else's family without their knowledge or consent is a violation, even if the information is technically findable?

Edit:

Thank you all for your responses. I want to address something that keeps coming up: the distinction between what is legal and what is ethical. Most of you are pointing out that public records are public. I know that. That was never my question. My question was about ethics and I think there’s a real blind spot in this community around that.

Just because something is accessible doesn’t mean it’s appropriate to act on without asking. We live in a world where a lot of things are technically available, but we still expect people to exercise judgment about when and how they use that access, especially when it concerns someone else’s personal history.

I also want to add some context: I do genealogy research myself. This is my own family history, and I want to explore it on my own terms, in my own time. Having someone in my immediate circle dig into it without asking doesn’t feel like help. It feels like my story and my experience are being taken from me, and the control over sensitive information about my family is no longer in our hands.

Several of you mentioned that genealogists can get “over enthusiastic”, and one person noted that if a family has difficult recent history, it may be hard for others to understand why it feels sensitive. That’s exactly my point. I’m not asking anyone to stop researching public records in general. I’m saying: when it’s someone else’s family, someone you have no connection to whatsoever, and that person is right there, you ask first. And when some of you say this is a relationship problem . yes, that’s valid. But I think it’s also a genealogical problem of our time.

I’m from Germany. We have a particular relationship with the idea that data, even historical, even public, can be used in ways that cause real harm. Not everything that is publicly accessible is good, or neutral, or harmless. That’s a lesson we learned the hard way.

The ethical question isn’t “can he do it?” The answer to that is yes. The question is “should he have done it without asking me first?” And I think most reasonable people, outside of a genealogy forum, would say no.

What surprises me most is how little this discussion seems to exist in the genealogy community. I couldn’t find much that seriously engages with the ethics of researching someone else’s family without their knowledge, as opposed to just the legal framework around data. I think that’s a gap worth talking about.

I would appreciate a respectful discussion. “Get a grip and grow up” is not constructive criticism, it says more about the person writing it than about the topic at hand.

I’m also not sure why one of my responses (this edit text) was removed by a moderator. it was a genuine contribution to the discussion.


r/Genealogy • • Jan 26 '23

Brick Wall I’m so concerned… hoping it’s not incest.

0 Upvotes

EDIT: I’ve been informed that it literally doesn’t matter 😂 I’ll keep this post up to laugh at myself in the future, thank you to everyone for teaching me new things /gen 😅

Original post for anyone who wants to see my stress: I’ve been exploring my family tree, just found something pointing to some ancestors from the 1700s who ARE MARRIED AND SHARE GRANDPARENTS. I was hoping someone logged it wrong, but there is barely any info on the couple, however one of the grandparents has a book of their geneology, this is the only evidence of their existence at all almost. I think it could legitimately be incest. Basically grandparents had 2 sons that each had a son and daughter, that son and daughter married!?!? Hoping this is incorrect but uhhhh…


r/Genealogy • • Aug 31 '23

Question Whats the farthest you can directly trace your lineage?

1 Upvotes

On my mothers side only, I can trace one part back to the orange men of Ireland, and the other part back to the 800's because of royal lineages in Scotland. I also know that I'm descended from the Scottish "children of the mists" which was a clan that lived in the lowlands area. Big French, Irish, and Scottish bloodlines. The exact ancestor I can trace to is Alpin mac Echdach (King of DalRiata) born 778, died 834.


r/Genealogy • • Jun 13 '24

Question Does anyone disagree with the theory that white Americans are ancestrally more English than German or Irish?

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

If I look at Australians, New Zealanders of European stock, many of them easily identify with their English ancestry; possibly because the migration was more recent, another reason might be because the immigration from England was more steady compared to the Us.

Concerning the US: people in the public eye seldom cite their English ancestry- I could literally cite countless examples. Joe Biden’s ancestry in Sussex, the McMahon wrestling family have English ancestry, but identify as Irish. Moreover, some people claim German ancestry as the largest ancestry in the us.

As Americans, what is your take. Is English ancestry understated? Are many white Americans German and Irish?

Personally I think there are more people of English ancestry in the US than in England or certainly close to that number.

Edit: I think the majority of white southerners, excluding recent transplants, are at least predominantly British. Irish ancestry there whilst present, is definitely a minority - one only has to look at religiosity of the south - an overwhelmingly Protestant area. The only Protestants from Ireland, were the Scot’s Irish, themselves a mixture of southern Scot’s and northern English - stretching down to Yorkshire at least.


r/Genealogy • • Jun 17 '23

Question Slaves in My Family! What to do?

0 Upvotes

Genealogical research has recently uncovered documents in the archives of the Minisink Valley Historical Society in Port Jervis, New York verifying that the prominent early colonial Gumaer family of western Orange County were the owners of scores, if not hundreds, of black African slaves from the early 1700s through the mid 1800s. These oppressed and abused slaves were used for, among, many other projects, the construction of the mountainous and treacherous Guymard Turnpike and the perennially elite, private, upscale gated Guymard Lake community in western Orange County, New York. Guymard Lake was founded as an elite, all white, private Gumaer family compound. The laboring efforts of the Gumaer slaves also included the founding of a lead and zinc mining empire on "Gumaer Mountain" which created great wealth for the Gumaer family in the 19th century. Many Gumaer slaves died in the Gumaer mines as recounted by my grandmother, Lucile Gumaer Ogden who was horrified by her family's cruel slave owning legacy.

White privileged descendants of the Gumaer family who settled in the western Orange County hamlet of Peenpack [currently Godeffroy] in the late 1600s on land stolen form the Native American Lenape tribe still own valuable homes and lands at private, gated, exclusive Guymard Lake. The Gumaer family has sought assiduously to cover up and conceal the long history of their slave owning past. Among the black families enslaved by the Gumaers was the still living Cuffee family of western Orange County. Where are the reparations for the Cuffee family and other descendants of the brutally exploited Gumaer slaves? All black people with the surname Gumaer are descendants of Gumaer slaves because the name "Gumaer" was created soon after the French aristocratic Guimar family settled at Peenpack [aka Godeffroy], Orange County, NY, circa 1689 and changed the spelling of their surname to hide their African slave trading history in France and its colonies.

Members of the Gumaer family hold a discreet and invitation only annual summer family reunion at the ancient Gumaer family cemetery near Godeffroy, NY to celebrate their proud European slave holding family heritage. Scores, if not hundreds of Gumaer family slaves are buried in the old Gumaer cemetery in unmarked, unacknowleged ancient graves several yards away from the European slaveholding Gumaer family member monuments. This proud family also has a Gumaer family page / presence on Facebook.

The proud Gumaer Family heritage organization which continues to organize and promote it's elite colonial American legacy [minus it's brutal slaveholding heritage] and membership is headed by...well you can find that out easily enough for yourself with a little research based on the information in this article...or by contacting the Minisink Valley Historical Society.


r/Genealogy • • Dec 17 '23

DNA Scotts Irish? Why a big deal?

0 Upvotes

What's the big deal about being of Scott's Irish decent? My mother in law corrected me once when I said her family was Irish, oh no! Scott's Irish! Is it because Kennedy was Scott's Irish? Like the rest of us are just lowly dogs?!


r/Genealogy • • Jan 27 '24

Question Is genealogy research even a thing outside of America?

0 Upvotes

I'm, surprise surprise, an American. I love learning about my ancestry, although I'm well aware that there is a very strong culture of this in America, often unfortunately focusing less on the research side and more on blind pride. I don't consider myself to be any nationality other than American -- not German-American or Polish-American, and certainly not German or Polish.

Actually, because I also incorporate DNA into my research, at various times, I have been more interested in my more ancient ancestry -- being "German-American" says absolutely nothing about whether you have Saxon versus Bavarian versus Frisian or Danish Viking ancestors, for instance. Or even Celtic/Gaulish or Roman ancestors. So yeah, I'll be the first to admit that I know almost none of the German language except for the same few words that all Americans know, I've never been there in my life, and I'm not into their beer or cars or politics or local family customs or food. I find that stuff interesting, but it's all arbitrary, no more interesting than the same things to be found in China or anywhere else, and I don't associate it with my American identity in any way.

And yet I'm fascinated to know how people who lived in what is present-day Germany (and what at various times could have been in or outside the Holy Roman Empire, or parts of France, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Denmark) in some way contributed to my existence. It's the same as pushing aside any interest in being "proud to be French" in America while acknowledging that it's really cool that your "French" ancestors were actually Danes, Franks, Burgundians, Gauls, and/or Bretons.

So I'm curious what percentage of this subreddit is American versus being from anywhere else in the world. I can see Latin Americans also having a similar interest in tracing their ancestry, but in Europe, for example, is it just completely uninteresting, because if you actually live in Germany, you sort of assume that all your ancestors are German, and that's just boring to you?

I always roll my eyes when Americans go nuts with Saint Patrick's Day and talk about "Irish pride" while having never been to Ireland in their lives, thinking of it as some green paradise and having no knowledge of recent politics or history, basing their whole identity on two people in their family tree from the 1850's. I think the Irish are right to find it annoying and cringey. But then I think, if I were Irish born and raised, why wouldn't I still want to know more about how the Gaels, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Vikings, Romans, or ancient Paleolithic peoples contributed to my existence?

Do non-Americans want to learn more about themselves and their ancestry in this way, or is it mostly an American thing?


r/Genealogy • • Dec 13 '23

Question Where are blondes and blue eyed people native to?

0 Upvotes

Where are blondes and blue eyed people native to?


r/Genealogy • • Jul 02 '25

News Dodged a bullet with 23andMe… glad I went with Ancestry instead

0 Upvotes

I was seriously considering 23andMe a few months back, mostly for the health reports. But the price was kind of steep, and Ancestry had a discount at the time. So I went with Ancestry instead.

Now I just got an email (pic attached) confirming that 23andMe officially went bankrupt, and their assets are being sold to a nonprofit (TTAM Institute) founded by one of the original co-founders. The message says privacy policies will stay in place and your data won’t be moved, but honestly… the whole situation still feels unsettling.

It’s wild how a company that once felt like the future of personalized health collapsed like this. They say “no action is required,” but I can’t help but think: What happens to people’s DNA once it’s part of a bankruptcy process?

Kinda relieved I went with the cheaper option. Not saying Ancestry is perfect, but at least it wasn’t in court with my saliva.

Anyone else reconsidering keeping their genetic data in the cloud?


r/Genealogy • • Mar 17 '24

Question Queer Genealogy

48 Upvotes

It is widely recognized that LGBT individuals have existed throughout human history, although they have often been silenced or erased from historical records due to deep-rooted homophobia in many societies. While it is true that biologically we cannot conceive children with partners of the same sex, this does not invalidate our relationships or life experiences, many of which may have been lived parallel to a heterosexual context, sometimes in a forced way.

An intriguing question arises when we look at our own family trees: have we found evidence of homosexual relationships among our ancestors? And, if so, how were these relationships handled and manifested?

How do genealogy and historical perception deal with the inclusion of adopted children in families formed by homosexual couples?


r/Genealogy • • Oct 08 '25

Question If you've put your DNA results out there in cybetspace for all to see....

2 Upvotes

...have there been any negative repercussions? I am thinking of issues with insurance companies discovering that you have preexisting conditions. Is that a risk?


r/Genealogy • • Mar 13 '25

Question Have ever had an ancestor "swiped" or image uploads?

0 Upvotes

In my mom's case before she soured. She had been personally digitizing and uploading since Ancestry was Broderbound's Family Tree Maker. This and that.... she put a very large amount of work in year 2006 incl the beginning of uploading rare photos that were passed by family archivist. Paid half a paycheck in storage locket rent for 5 years to not lose media mixed in a bad jumbled move while still searching through former ar hivists bad mive storage incidenr. 2 fires layer. Carefully repaired photos with digital tools.tons of things soaked in retardant, mildewing. Hand blotting lysol and photo solution on boxes and boxes of photos, articles a letters. Whole yard covered on drying paper media.

Only to see her uploads being credited to late comers and even information changed by people who had no idea what these photo backs said. Since they indeed were not original media holders. Some of these photo rustlers were family feud drama I'll admit. The issue is worse when in 2012, I watermarked a new small batch using our business trademark as the copyright notice. Anything that it wasn't completely splatterd ugly and less transparent across, was also again wiped. I can magnify on PC screen and find all the lil the registey stamps.

Her tree is now private and she loathe to upload family Bible scans, letters and the like. Made most her trees private.

ANYONE ELSE have similar?

ie. shared father as child:: Orig on her secondary email tree I access 2012 Kiped with new upload credit 20q7

With the bitter age gapped older half sisters I can see them erasing her. (Like in the obituary of her father. His 3rd wife mentioned. Not his second wife and last child)

But why would randos who wouldnt even know who it is if not for profile match, want to screenshot or now download, instead of link to individuals. To take credit? And btw it's illegal. Is there a way to make money like that?

To a lessor extent and kinda funny are 2 family lines that said, no that's OUR great grandaddy, you get lost! and then even after DNA are only related and we tested direct line.... lol. It crazy family with a memorial name with one junior. And a grandson by that name from every child in 15 offspring, rinse and repeat.... but only our family had the wife who did NOT die. If you are a 5th generation only related via a marriage, does it matter that your ancestors husband's brother stole a farm from a widow and kids? And his famous preacher dad gave a wink? Dirty Irish catholic! Lol


r/Genealogy • • Jul 27 '25

News Mixed-Race Americans, you might be from America's lost race, the Sweetgum Kriyul people, which includes the Melungeons, Appalachia's "Lost Tribe"

0 Upvotes

In the early 1600s, Black, White, and Native American people sometimes had mixed race children together, way back before anti-misceganation laws banned interracial couples and mixed race marriages. These early colonial stock triracial Americans to descend from this community became a distinct racial class, Free People Of Color. Early own, they owned land. Some even owned slaves despite often appearing Black. But as time progresses, the One Drop Rule and other strict laws against race deemed these people non-White, but being multigenerationally mixed-race by that point, many could pass as White and had better conditions and privileges than Black Americans at the time. Sometimes, some of them didn't wanna identify as Black, because it wasn't easy being Black, so they kept marrying within their community, giving rise to a distinct race. Others passed as White and kept marrying White people, with subsequent generations getting lighter and lighter. These people are known as the Sweetgum Kriyul people, and are divided into different tribes or subgroups based on which community of Sweetgum Kriyul they came from, each developing distinct cultures in isolation, sometimes in a perpetual state of not being Black or White on legal documents and living in limbo for generations. Some managed to hold land and vote and others lost many of their rights.

The most famous of these Sweetgum Kriyul tribes is the Melungeons, often called The Lost Tribe of Appalachia. Abraham Lincoln may have very well been a Melungeon, and not actually fully White. He was most definitely related to them. Elvis Presley was related to then as well, and so is current Vice President, JD Vance. Melungeons primarily live in their traditional homeland, the Melungeon territory, located in Southern Appalachia and the Tennessee River Valley, although some live outside the traditional homeland of the Melungeons, which is centered primarily around Newman's Ridge and Blackwater Creek around the tri-state meeting point of Virginia, Tennessee, and North Carolina in the Southern Appalachian Mountains.

The Ramapough are another Sweetgum Kriyul group, also called the Ramapough Lenape Nation, a Native American tribe of mixed-race origins, with Native American ancestry from the Indigenous peoples of the mountainous areas on the border regions between New Jersey and New York, who descended from the mixed-race children produced in unions between the local Native American remnant populations that remained after "Indian" Removals and from Black and White people including potential ancestry from Hessian Revolutionary War deserters and Afro-Indigenous mixed Caribbean islanders that moved from NYC and married members of the community, having children. The Ramapough seek federal recognition and have preserved much their Native American traditions and culture and revived other practices nearly lost, a remarkable feat in the face of colonization and genocide.

The Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina is another Sweetgum Kriyul group, that also holds onto Indigenous American identity, much like the Ramapough people of the Ramapough Mountain Pass area. The Lumbees have sought federal recognition and fought for over a century, and only as of recently are close to getting it. Due to many having low blood quantum and appearing to be mixed with Black features, the Lumbees face constant slander and are rejected by many outsiders, although DNA tests prove they have Indigenous American haplogroups. Many are mostly of White or Black American ancestry, although some even have significant Indigenous American DNA. It all depends on the individual person.

The Ethnic Qarsherskiyan Tribe may identify as a tribe, but doesn't claim to be a Native American tribe like the Ramapough and Lumbee communities. The Qarsherskiyans have a unique blended culture of their own, much like the Melungeons, and celebrate diverse mixed heritages from many corners of the world, the American Melting Pot producing the most seemingly unlikely genetic mixtures in different Qarsherskiyan families. A fee Qarsherskiyan people individually kept connected to their Indigenous ancestry and are even enrolled in federally recognized tribes, but most aren't connected to their Native American ancestral tribes and a few don't even have ancestry from any Indigenous American tribe. Most Qarsherskiyan people are predominantly a mix of Black, White, and Native American ancestry with smaller or trace amounts of ancestry from Roma/Romani/"gypsy" people who lived in colonial America and from Malagasy enslaved and indentured servants and from Jews, usually Ashkenazi or Sephardic and less often Mizrahim. Groups of people considered non-White in colonial Virginia and North Carolina on the coastal plains all had similar socioeconomic statuses and when they intermarried it produced Qarsherskiyan people, who are distinct from Melungeons only because Melungeons went to Southern Appalachia and are largely assimilated into mainstream American society, and have developed a distinct separate culture and identity further West that was later partially erased to avoid discrimination. Qarsherskiyan people mostly live in the coastal plains of Virginia and North Carolina as well as across Ohio and Northern Appalachia from Maine and the Quebec border area around Lake Champlain all the way down to the mountains of Northern Virginia and Central West Virginia. What unites Qarsherskiyan people is a shared blended Creole culture, although different families have different lineages and the community is religiously diverse. Some Qarsherskiyan families may have more North African and Middle Eastern ancestry and less European ancestry, and others may have more White and less Black American ancestry.

Various other such communities exist.


r/Genealogy • • Feb 05 '26

Tools and Tech Wikitree bunch of bullies and thieves!

0 Upvotes

I loved wikitree until the admins became assholes. I have been researching my tree for years. All my research was stored on it. All of it. This was many many many years and dollars in the making trying to get my most comprehensive research on myself, just to understand who i am and where i am from - just all flushed down the drain because some asshole admin got a stick up where the sun doesnt shine. It decided i am no longer allowed to have access to my own information. Thats right, they completely blocked me - why you ask? Let me tell you.....

Like i stated i have done very thorough work and research and spent a pretty penny trying to trace my orgins, Wiki tree was my home base. Everything could be universally used on multiple platforms. All of a sudden i started having my family tree information changed without my consent. Not only changed but wrong so i would change it back. After a few rounds of this i left a comment on one particular family member that kept getting changed. So i said for whoever thinks they can change my info into wrong information better knock it the hell off . This did not go over well i got reported for bullying and for improperly citing some information that I had not entered. If it was wrong it could have been from getting changed over and over without my consent. Due to I guess the multiple violations for improper citing I was apparently required to take some sort of detention video or something, mind you i was not told that this is MANDATORY. Even if i had seen it was non negotionable, when i recieved the email it was already after the fact of the detention video or whatever it was. So i tried to log into my account to find it was unaccessible and the admins were just dick heads all the way around. I got heated after being unable to access my account after a few months, my father suddenly passed away from a DUI , i attempted to update my dads date of death, and unable to access. I made a new account from my sister cell phone and saw that my account had been total taken over by one of the people that like to steal peoples information. I no longer existed in the wikitree but wikitree deleted me but kept all my information for everyone else to use except me. I was pissed, i started contacting them just asking for my information back because wikitree was the my home base it was my only draft of my own information and these assholes still use it and i still do not exist on the page but all my research does. Fucc Wikitree. Bunch of damn thieves and bullies!


r/Genealogy • • Dec 07 '24

Question Ancestry - Ignore "School Yearbooks" as a Hint Source?

1 Upvotes

I have no interest seeing Yearbook info as a hint source.

Can I permanently ignore? How about other family trees that I ALWAYS ignore?

- Thx