I worked in indie game publishing for PC, console, and mobile for over eight years. Since then, I still do a lot of free pitch deck reviews for folks, and I keep seeing people making the same mistakes. I figured I could do a list of some of the most common red flags that developers typically put in their pitch decks to hopefully help devs looking for a publisher avoid some of the most common pitfalls, and stand a better chance of starting a conversation that can lead to a deal. (Also maybe I should do a post about red flags to watch out for as an indie dev when talking to publishers because WOWEE I have heard some horror stories and seen some bad deals??)
DISCLAIMER: Every publisher is different, and not every project is a fit for every publisher, and vice-versa. There will always be exceptions to rules, and I do not guarantee that following any of this advice will land you a publishing deal.
Opening too slow.
Your first pitch page should be a compelling asset (key art, video, gif, splashy art), a simple paragraph that explains the concept and gameplay in the first breath ("Link to the Past is a 2D action adventure about a young boy on a quest across a fantastical word filled with dungeons and massive bosses to rescue a princess. Players will..."), and a bullet list of up-front pertinent details: engine, launch window/production timeline in months, budget, genre, and target platforms. Don't make me have to sift through a bunch of slides trying to parse together basic facts that will help me understand whether this is a fit for my needs, budget, and portfolio calendar.
Details are too vague.
If you tell me that "players will solve a variety of puzzles", I don't know what that means. How frequent are they? How complex are they? Do you have experience designing puzzles? What about those "unlockable upgrades". Are we talking a +5 to damage? A cool new mechanic that would completely change combat that I'll never know about when I'm evaluating your pitch because you didn't tell me? You don't need to exhaustively detail every single component, but don't leave me thinking you haven't planned your project out, OR have me miss out on something that might immediately sell me on talking to you!
Production timeline doesn't make sense.
The reality of game development is that games almost always change or slide to some extent, but you still need a solid production plan that keeps track of major features, planned testing, first playable, demos, feature complete, etc. If I see you've at least made the effort to account for the things you need, and aren't being completely unrealistic about your timeline, I'm much more willing to take a chance on you for publishing.
You don't understand your costs.
Making the money make sense is so incredibly crucial, and yet it's consistently one of the most common things devs fumble. (You don't REALLY think you're going to be able to localize your 300k word RPG into EFIGs for $15,000, do you?) Do your research, plan out your costs and burn rate, account for potential buffer, and remember: the cost to MAKE the game is not the same as the final cost to the publisher to SHIP the game, so make sure you can justify accordingly.
Comps don't make sense.
You are a small indie studio making your first survival horror game. Your comps are not Silent Hill f and Resident Evil Requiem. Having accurate comps that fit the scope and scale of the game you're making shows publishers that you are being realistic with your ambitions, you understand what you're making, and also sets the right publisher expectations for how it will perform on the market. (Publishers *will* do their own comps, but yours will set the tone and make sure you're not putting all of your eggs into the basket of an overworked biz dev reviewer who may not find the right comps to sell your project to them on their own.)
Shoot for one low end, one mid tier, and one high end comp, ideally released within the last 1-2 years, at an equivalent price point to what you're targeting.
Team doesn't show the skills.
If you tell me you are making some sort of sweeping emotional narrative epic but your team consists of two programmers, a concept artist, and a voiceover artist, I am going to doubt that you can actually execute and deliver on what you're trying to sell me. If you're planning to hire someone to handle what is a key selling point and feature of your project, you need to at least have started some conversations with some likely candidates that you can share as on board with signing so that I can believe you have the right people for the job.
Too obsessed with DLC/merch.
Hey, I get it. It's exciting to think about plushies and graphic novel spin-offs and movies and big DLC campaigns and all that juicy stuff. But the reality is that your game has to be made, and be finished, and be a success, for any of this to matter 99% of the time. It's okay to say you have ideas and hopes for these things, but if I look at your pitch and you have whole pages devoted to animated series spin-offs that realistically may never see the light of day, and only half a paragraph devoted to, say, your plot or your core gameplay loop, I am going to have doubts about your focus and priorities.
Pitch too long.
10-12 slides is the sweet spot for a pitch, with additional supplementary details (in-depth narrative documents, more visuals, GDD, etc) included as links. If I open your pitch and see that it is 30-75 pages (and I *have* seen this), my eyes are going to glaze over and there is a very good chance that I will move on to something else. Publishers see so. MANY. pitches every single week. It's rough out there. There is simply not enough time to exhaustively read every single pitch you get sent, and most publishers will decide in the first 30 seconds if they're interested enough to read further. Keep things tidy, punchy, and digestible, and your supporting materials in a handy set of links for when I'm intrigued enough to want to dig into them. (And definitely *do* include them, because showing you've planned your game out is a good way to make me feel like you're a solid bet!)
Playable too rough.
I do not expect you to have a feature-complete polished vertical with every pitch. I *do* expect anything you want me to play to demonstrate that the fundamentals of your gameplay and core features are strong. If, for instance, you tell me you're making a platformer and you hand me a prototype that has beautiful art but controls like a car with bald tires on an ice pond, I am going to be much less confident in you than I am the platformer pitch with a bunch of greyboxes and placeholders that feels fun and snappy and exciting to move around with.
ETA 11/20/26: I forgot one.
Pitch too ambitious.
If you have never released anything before, or worked on a team that has shipped a project, and your pitch says you are going to make an MMO, or a farming sim, or a 100 hour RPG, then you are going to have an uphill battle convincing a publisher that you can deliver. "Good" or cool ideas are a dime a dozen. A developer that can actually finish what they promise, in the time frame they budgeted and planned out, to the degree of polish necessary, is much more important. I'm not saying I've never signed a project from a new team/developer, but it's usually from someone who comes with a pitch that has a reasonably scoped project that was well planned out AND was already looking to bring on more experienced team members to help ensure the project shipped.
Pitch too early.
Look: I know you need money to make the game. It is unrealistic for publishers to expect every team to be able to financially support a bunch of production up front, and I am not telling you to only speak to a publisher when your game is 90% complete.
However. You do need to be able to demonstrate that you have planned and accounted for the content and production of your game, and that you can deliver on what you want to do, to a degree that makes me feel like if I give you a large sum of money you are actually going to be able to make what you're selling me, within a reasonable time frame, to the degree of quality you are promising on. If you are at a place where you haven't figured out all your mechanics, or you don't know how your story is going to end up, or you don't have the right team for the job, or 100% of the art you can provide is only concept art, then you are not ready to pitch.
It can be hard to come back from a bad first impression with a publisher, especially if that impression makes it look like you're unprepared and unable to deliver. It is much better for your chances of success to defer pitching than it is to rush it.
Okay that's it. I love you. Good luck. Bye.