r/gamedev • • Sep 22 '24

Our Indie Game Was Mistaken for a Gacha - Here's What We Learned

0 Upvotes

So, 3 days ago, IGN showcased our WIP game "13Z" on both their YouTube English and Bilibili Chinese channels. It was great to see our game getting that kind of exposure and I am truly grateful for it.

But then we started seeing a large number of gamers commenting, comparing 13Z to a certain popular gacha game I shall not name. They were making these comparisons based on the graphics alone. Honestly at first I was flattered because their graphics are really topnotch in my opinion. But then many of the gamers who said 13Z looked like that game also thought it would be a gacha game.

The voices became so strong that it got me really worried and I wondered if we were heading in the wrong direction with our graphics. The last thing we wanted to do was to give players the wrong impression about the kind of game we are.

To make things worse, we are launching our first playtest on Steam 24 hours later, so this couldn't have gone worse for us.

Fast forward 24 hours later, we launched 13Z's first ever global playtest to great worry. Miraculously, we started seeing streamers and Youtubers play the game. Consistently, they praised the game for its smooth combat. Some even said that 13Z feels like Risk of Rain meets Hades and has combat like Devil May Cry. You cannot imagine our relief.

Right now, we've got 6K+ downloads so far.

20% of the playtesters completed the entire demo which would take about 3 hours. We've received at least a 4/5 rating for both gameplay and graphics from more than 80% of the 100+ playtesters who took our survey.

But that doesn't mean we're resting on our laurels yet.

We'll be working even harder to build upon the good foundation we've established for 13Z and make the game even better.

This whole experience taught us a few things:

  • First impressions based on visuals can be misleading. Players might make snap judgments based on art style alone. We need to figure out how to look less like 'that' game.

  • Gameplay can change perceptions. Once players got their hands on 13Z, they realized it's a completely different game. So the key is to work out having a solid gameplay and gameloop. Honestly, I think we are only 60% at where we want to be ultimately, but thankfully it was a good start.

  • Communication is key. We need to find ways to convey what our game is really about through the trailer and socials.

I wonder if any fellow game devs here have faced similar challenges with their game's art style being compared to another popular game? How did you handle it?


r/gamedev • • Apr 30 '18

Article How I made my own 2D game engine in under 2 months

Thumbnail
ssygen.com
34 Upvotes

r/gamedev • • Mar 30 '14

Putting your content on Gamasutra.com? What I wish I'd known.

0 Upvotes

Putting your content on Gamasutra.com? What I wish I'd known.

What I wish I'd known about Gamasutra.com, and its current management, is that even if you remain consistently civil and respectful and don't violate any of the posting guidelines, you can be banned without warning--and all your content erased from the site--for expressing a 'wrong' opinion. From what I can gather, the risk of this happening to you--despite being civil and sticking to the guidelines--seems to depend on:

  • How closely your views diverge from those of Kris Graft

  • Whether Kris Graft is in a particularly bad mood that day

I've recently been banned from Gamasutra after posting comments on this article (link). Incidentally it's an article that I'm in broad agreement with, and sympathetic towards. The banning also erased two articles I'd written that were previously featured on Gamasutra.

For my peace of mind, for anyone interested in attempting to derive the unwritten rules of the actual moderation policy at Gamasutra.com, or for anyone wanting to judge for themselves whether the mods at Gamasutra can be trusted, here are screen grabs of my comments before they were deleted. Bear in mind that at no point did Kris Graft address me to explain how I could avoid the deletions in future, even when I asked him directly (although he did refer disparagingly to my posts when replying to another user).

See link for message exchange screen caps.


r/gamedev • • Jul 03 '24 Heart of Silver

Am I allowed to say this? I kinda hate gamers

1.2k Upvotes

I'm a professional game designer and I'm worried that I'm starting to hate gamers. Watching the gaming events on YouTube last month with the chat on was an extremely disheartening experience. Every time a character that wasn't a cishet white man appeared on screen the chats would fill with messages calling the game woke or complaining about DEI. Every game that wasn't a shooter or a hyper casual competitive online game garnered "ZZZs" and "boring" comments.

And then I check twitter and it's just people complaining that the MGS3 remake is not yellow enough, people telling me there are right ways and wrong ways to beat Else Ring, and people hating on the new Dragon Age because the trailer doesn't match the tone they had imagined for it.

I've seen people implying that the MC in the Fable trailers is "ugly" because it's a self-insert of some random level designer working at Playground whom they have deemed not fuckable enough.

I don't know, it's just the internet magnifying negative voices I guess, doing what it does best. But it's making me real tired of gamers.


r/gamedev • • Nov 06 '18

Discussion I am a co-founder of grit game engine - it should be revived. It's still modern in a lot of ways...

12 Upvotes

And we're done here. For now.


r/gamedev • • Jul 10 '22

Postmortem I didn't market my game and it sold well

153 Upvotes

I had this theory that you only need to make a decent game and it will sell. That there's no secret market strategy that can decide either your game is a success or a failure. And now I've got another proof for my theory.

When I've been working on my first game I tried reaching out to press and letsplayers, I posted on forums, social media, had an indiedb blog, email subscription for updates and all other possible self-promotion tools available. I had very little success with most of that, except for two things which actually worked in a significant way: having your game played on youtube by someone big (by their own choice), and having your game released on Steam.

My first game is still in Early Access and sold over 100k copies since release in late 2017 and it still has its bright future ahead, but I came here to tell about my other game.

I know we all have this little side projects which we'd like to make but never have enough time to invest. So when my home town got shelled and I had to leave some of my development abilities behind, this little side project became something I can make while not able to work on my main game. It took nearly two months on laptop to bring it from a concept to a Steam release. And here's the fun part: my marketing strategy is basically 101 of how not to do marketing. I created a Steam page in April 26 and released the game in May 5. My laptop isn't very fast for video recording so I asked a friend to make a trailer (who never did game trailers and never played my game before), which came out a bit janky. The game's description on Steam is so minimal they hardly accepted it. The store artwork is something I frankly made without much love just to get it over with. The only thing close to marketing I made was briefly posting about this little side project on my main game's accounts.

Two months later the game sold over 14k copies, most of which from Steam traffic and two big youtubers I never reached out to.

So my summary is: making a game that people like is 99% of success. The other 1% is about just not being the only one who knows about the game so it can get started. Ignoring marketing just makes your sales tail bigger than launch sales: https://imgur.com/a/jd2eZ74

If your game is not a success, maybe what you actually need is to try making it a better game. Always listen to the feedback: people who give it are not trying to insult your masterpiece, most of the time they tell you the truth. And they'll never tell you they don't like your game because it hadn't enough marketing.

UPD: Don't get me wrong, I'm not calling for completely ignoring anything marketing-related. I'm not saying I wouldn't do pre-release marketing for my future projects (especially as I'm getting more means for that). Having a simple dev log is a good thing for building a community and I'd certainly do it again, but here's a list of things I would advice for an indie making their first game on a budget: Don't pay for ads/reviews, don't reach out to press and influencers, don't even think about exhibiting on events, don't spend too much effort on dramatic trailers, don't overdesign your store page or website, don't EVER give keys to "curators" and giveaways. Put all that effort into making the best game possible.

It's a hard truth, but most of the time when something is not successful it's because of what it is and not because of how it's marketed. Same goes for music, movies, books etc. Each time I compare something I made with something more successful it's because that something is either objectively better or appeals to wider audience, not because of luck. If you don't agree, please provide examples of really good games with <10 reviews on Steam that you actually played and loved.

UPD2: the game I'm talking about is https://store.steampowered.com/app/1957990/Tile_Cities/


r/gamedev • • Jun 26 '14

10 Tips To Avoid Creating Annoying Fetch Quests

0 Upvotes

http://daathgalaxy.com/10-tips-to-avoid-annoying-fetch-quests/

I'm a game developer like you fine folk here at /gamedev/ and I just finished writing my thoughts and tips on how to minimize crappy fetch quests when developing quests. Here's the summery of the 10 tips:

Rule #1 – Don’t Write Them
Rule #2 – Really, Don’t Write Them (Rewrite or Remove)
Rule #3 – Strangers Don’t Asks Strangers to Do Fetch Quests
Rule #4 – Don’t Multiply Fetch Quests
Rule #5 – Make Them Optional & Opt Out
Tip #1 – All Quest Production Pipelines Are Nearly As Easy As Fetch Quests
Tip #2 – Don’t Use Fetching As Tempo Control
Tip #3 – Never Use Filler, Always Use Value
Tip #4 – Use Natural Introductions & Well Disguised Fetch Quests
Tip #5 – Some Fetch Quests Are Fun!

You can read the full article here where I break those 10 tips down and explain my logic and reasoning. I'm always looking to improve my understanding of game design, so please feel free to rip me a new one or otherwise add your two cents. Thanks!


r/gamedev • • Dec 04 '25

Discussion If you're using free libraries to make your commercial projects you're ripping people off

0 Upvotes

It's not my take, but I was told this today. It's the most unhinged take I heard in 2025. I made a retro game using PSP SDK for PSP I'm selling for 3 dollars and my own game engine and was attacked for using free, enthusiasts built SDK published under free license (BSD I think) for none-free game. To be honest I'm just unable to process it. Are you often attacked for the reasons beyond your comprehension?


r/gamedev • • Jul 07 '26

Discussion Should Steam be more vigilant in stopping abuse of refund policy? There is recently an article going around from a dev who has 55K refunds with "dozens" leaving reviews saying they enjoyed it but refunded because they finished in less than 2 hours

0 Upvotes

Here is the article https://www.gamesradar.com/games/dev-tells-valve-to-fix-steams-exploitable-2-hour-refund-policy-as-over-55-000-players-refund-his-short-game-and-even-brag-about-it-in-reviews/

Steam refund policy is here https://store.steampowered.com/steam_refunds/

and it does have an abuse warning "Refunds are designed to remove the risk from purchasing titles on Steam—not as a way to get free games. If it appears to us that you are abusing refunds, we may stop offering them to you. We do not consider it abuse to request a refund on a title that was purchased just before a sale and then immediately rebuying that title for the sale price."

Myself I have a short game which is has almost 7K sales but only a refund rate of 5%(of which 1 in 5 of my refunds are chargebacks, fraud, payment issues). I have always been a believer in people refund bad games not short games, just so happens a lot of bad games are also short!

I also often read a lot of people saying they know people who are refunding a lot. I think in general the refund policy is great and lets you buy risk free, but I have only ever refunded 2 games with over 100 in my steam account. It seems like steam could start warning people a bit earlier which would reduce refunds in general and be good for all devs.

What should steam do if anything?

At a minimum I would like to be able to see how long people played before refunding, you would able to see clearly if they are abusing policy or not liking the game with that data.


r/gamedev • • Dec 31 '20

I was forced to make an equation, and I want to share it as it doesn't seem to exist...

29 Upvotes

Eh, I was trying to keep the title short. Basically I found myself needing something like invsqrt() but not super slow, not quadratic, and a drop in replacement for y=1/x or it's equivalent y=x^-1.

After much frustration, searching, headaches, bouts of depression, chain smoking and aggravated assault on a calculator I came up with this...

Y = Y * (-X * Y) * -1

I searched and searched and searched and could not find this, so I wanted to share it with ya'll as it may help you, or so I hope. The latest project I have been working on needs 5 different light attenuation (yes, Five) calculations as well as 3 direct linear inverse proportions. The little equation I posted is the exact equivalent to the normal ones I referenced in the first paragraph and you can graph it on Desmos and it does not deviate, and if you layer all 3 they all 3 look and react the same. y=1/x isn't expensive but it was starting to add up running it so many times because I am not using it on scalars, but rather full vec4 calculations (this project is OpenGL). Obviously, this can be used anywhere with anything and like I said, it doesn't seem to exist on any documentation on the internet or anywhere else that I know of.

Anyway, it is a drop in replacement for direct linear inverse (reciprocal) when the quadratic implementation is not appropriate or wouldn't provide the desired result. It also doesn't have the issues associated with raising things to negative powers nor does it have any extra FP error when I tested it. It doesn't have a noticeable difference when used on a scalar such as a single float compared to the regular y=1/x but had a measurable difference on the vec4 data sets. I did not however test it on double precision because 32bit FP was good enough for my use, but I doubt it would act differently in that case. As for performance, It Shaved 3ms off my Frame Render time just by itself. Your mileage may vary of course.

I know some of us got off on a rough start in another thread, and I apologize, so please accept this as a token of good will and I hope someone gets some use out of it as I did.

- CJsneed


r/gamedev • • Nov 25 '25

Discussion We tried giving players free coins for watching ads… and they bailed instead

0 Upvotes

Ran a 50/50 A/B test in Racing In Car to see if giving extra soft currency for watching rewarded ads would lift anything. Sounded like an easy win. Spoiler: it wasn’t.

Setup: iOS: Oct 16-29 Android: Oct 22-28 Control: old version Variant A: “Free Coins” after watching rewarded ads

What happened: On day one everything looked amazing. Players watched way more rewarded ads, D0 ad revenue jumped hard, and we were like “ok this might actually work.”

Then the honeymoon ended. Mid-term results:

  1. Ad ARPU: iOS +1.2%, Android +2.9% (basically flat)

  2. R1 dropped a bit

  3. R3 dropped on iOS, barely moved on Android

  4. By D3–D7 ad revenue actually started falling

Why? Because the reward wasn’t valuable enough to motivate players. It was basically “watch an ad to get a tiny amount of currency” - not exactly inspiring. So people watched a couple, got annoyed, and left faster.

Takeaway: Early positive spikes mean nothing if the long-term curve goes downhill. Low-value rewards don’t create engagement - they create frustration. We killed the feature on both platforms.

Anyone else had a “looks great on day one, falls apart by day three” kind of A/B test?


r/gamedev • • Aug 18 '26

Discussion Good game dev related subs

5 Upvotes

Given this sub's newly announced support for AI slop posts, some folks might be shopping around for another place to waste their internet time (reading and writing human-generated content).

I've found two game dev subs that explicitly forbid AI slop. ​Please add any more, for people who want to try and get a bit more internet before it's completely dead.

https://www.reddit.com/r/GameDevelopment/

https://www.reddit.com/r/IndieGameDevs/

EDIT: Apologies if I wasn't clear. I'm talking about free from AI generated posts that waste everyone's time, not the general debate.


r/gamedev • • May 01 '25

Discussion Do you use the forbidden AI to translate?

40 Upvotes

Hey everybody!

I am curious as to how many of you devs use AI to translate your game or store page to other languages?

I often see that AI translate is very easily detectable by native speakers and I believe that is true. However, at what point is AI translation better than no translation? It isn't necessarily cheap to have someone localize your game.

That being said I ran some tests with different AI translators. In my current job I am surrounded by people who come from all over, speaking many languages. SO, I ran a brief test.

I wanted to get their opinions on some translations, most were quite impressed and could hardly tell something was AI translated.

THE MOST SUCCESSFUL was GROK using "THINK" mode.

The prompt was very important..

I didn't just say "Translate this to Simplified Chinese"...no it was more like "Translate this to Simplified Chinese, while also translating to fit culturally, I need it to read fluently and make it so it is not apparent that AI was used"

The results were good. Not perfect, but good.

SO AGAIN MY QUESTION...

Is AI translation better than no translation for a small indie game?

Thank you!

EDIT: Seems like a good route to take would be to launch in English and then if comments roll in about wishing it was in a certain language, at that point I would consider paying someone to localize.


r/gamedev • • 3d ago

Question Experienced devs, how are you dealing with AI taking over the actual coding?

2 Upvotes

I'm a game developer with 2+ years of experience, and lately I've been feeling pretty lost about my growth as a programmer.

I've heard from developers whose companies provide Claude subscriptions that they haven't written a single line of code in months. They mostly prompt AI and review its output.

And with AI now capable of solving complex problems and designing entire architectures, I wonder where this is heading.

I genuinely love programming, especially the process of figuring things out and implementing solutions myself. But sometimes I feel demotivated learning DSA, system design, and improving my coding skills when AI is getting better at all of it so quickly.

I'd love to hear from experienced programmers, especially game devs:

- What's the AI coding culture like at your company? Are you still writing code yourself?

- Do you feel the same frustration, or have you adapted?

- How do you keep improving your own problem-solving skills without becoming AI-dependent?

- What would you advise a junior/mid-level developer to focus on for the future?

I'm not against AI. I just don't want to lose the part of programming I actually enjoy, or end up being someone who only knows how to prompt.


r/gamedev • • Mar 20 '26

Discussion I went to GDC 2026 so you didn't have to -- it was worth it.

9 Upvotes

GDC 2026 was a shift in presentation for Informa, as they themed this year around a Festival of Gaming. It will take several years to determine if this shift is right for the industry, but after having boots on the ground 2 years in a row I think it is fair to say the energy around the conference is at new heights. 

Bottom line up front, conference associates have never seen lines as long as what they had to wrangle during GDC. In-demand panels and programs stretched around the hall as hundreds lined up, willing to wait an hour to see topics they are passionate about or studios they admire. This is where the ‘real networking’ happens, according to many attendees. After 1 day of line networking I had already passed out more cards and made more connections than I did my entire trip last year with the expo pass. 

Speaking of the pass, let’s take a look at the pricing. It was a risky move cutting the expo pass and halving the cost of all access, but the indie pass still makes things affordable for new studios although at the end of the day the conference passes alone aren’t what is breaking the budget. Hotels and air fare remain the largest hurdle for many professionals and students trying to attend the conference, even with the partner discounts this is still outside GDC’s hands. There is not a central venue in the US which can support their AV demands, hotel accommodations, and be in close enough proximity to a majority of the studios which attend. Some influencers have suggested moving the conference to Europe, but that would be devastating for growing the audience especially when Gamescom Dev is already there. 

The biggest change this year was the evolution of the expo hall into a festival hall with themed neighborhoods. Let’s summarize the overhaul:

  • The Common Area

    • Last year it was hard finding a place to sit or even grab a bite to eat with everything being spread out across the expo hall.

    • This year all the festival hall dining options were in a readily available location with ample seating and common spaces to meet new developers. 

  • Indie Neighborhood

    • This is the biggest difference so far, giving Alt.CTRL booths actual space for their setups and letting crowds form to watch the gameplay. It was not cramped like last year and everyone enjoyed it. 

    • The indie stage and gaming areas also had plenty of room to move about and explore the games being demo’d without issue. 

  • Main Stage

    • The main stage taking up the north hall was good design wise, as people only had to focus on one of the halls instead of trekking back and forth across the expanse under them.

    • This also opened up the networking room in West hall, which was more advantageous for the 5-day layout. 

  • AI

    • I’ve seen an unsettingly large amount of posts saying ‘i hate how AI is everywhere at the expo’ while ignoring the massive decrease in AI booths. 

    • The handful of GenAI tech was relegated towards the backside of the modernization neighborhood, with the only major player left from last year that I remember was Meshy. 

    • AI has taken a massive L and while some panels and speakers tried to push it in their talks, it’s clear the conference is moving away from it and towards practical business solutions like Gemini going through Unreal logs or [redacted] digging through Unity documentation. This isn't based on this years volume, but the decrease from last years presence. Generative AI is taking the backseat against practical lightweight LLMs that solve specific tasks. The mood might feel soured to many who see AI in the taglines still, but genAI is not going to make the strides it once was making.

  • Networking

    • “Networking sucks at the festival hall” Have you tried talking to people? 

    • I’ve made the most connections in the indie neighborhood talking with indie devs or people watching the games being played. 

    • Just go up to someone and say ‘hey whats been your favorite booth?’ it isn’t that hard.

Overall, the Festival Hall was a more curated experience. You could get to the booths you wanted and talk with people easily. If I could make any changes it would be:

  • Putting stickers on the ground for navigation

  • Taking a loss and bringing in co-dev studios like Disbelief and Iron Galaxy for free to provide partnership opportunities for gamechangers and foster the ‘neighborhood’ feeling that this is a palace you can go to find someone to work on your next game with. 

  • Moving the crepe booth towards the beginning or end of the concession area so the line won’t interfere with the other vendors. 

  • Moving the giant GDC downstairs again just so it obstructs less traffic or bringing a smaller GDC in the beginning of the Festival Hall for the photo ops. 

In terms of GDC nights I did not go to any so nothing to write home about there. As always there were tons of events outside of the conference. 

One of the major downsides were cancelled talks. I was discussing this with a staff member who oversaw talk approvals and how it would be good to have backup speakers on hand, even though it was obviously massive prep work to have a presentation you might not even use. It also was rough having talks on similar topics at the same time. The lines were also a problem. It is unfortunate having to wait 20 - 45 minutes to guarantee you get in a high-demand talk. 

Overall the energy was high. Half of the people before me during hotel check-in had their passports out and this is the second year in a row the people behind me in line at the lobby were speaking French. The Festival hall made the international presence even more obvious, as current events have not deterred developers from other countries. The diversity of San Francisco is always a culture shock, but GDC continues to take it to the next level and prove the future of the industry lies in inclusivity. 

Almost every person I talked with was energized for the future. They were hopeful for the future of the games industry and I saw companies handing out internship flyers to the studio booths. XBOX had recruiters giving 15-minute mentorship talks to prospective developers and was soliciting for their hiring pipeline. The industry feels like it has finished constricting and is looking to begin growing again. 

The best part though was recognizing people. Recognizing names from badges or faces from LinkedIn, going “Wait I know you!” and striking up friendly chatter. Hearing, “Oh I heard about your team!” or “I recognize your mascot from Discord!” was a feeling of elation, that people see you and the work you have done. 

I would be remiss not to mention the union, UVW-CWA. After their debut last GDC they have rallied 550 paying members, but were in noticeably smaller force this year. They hyped up how GDC had ‘barricaded’ the gardens for their march, because vendor tents had fencing around them. When I asked the booth what the union brought to developers, they spent most of their time telling me how they are pushing studios to not allow ICE into the workplace and then discussing the due rates. 

They then handed me a flyer, 1/3rd of which was dedicated to ICE. Regardless of the fact that ICE is a horrible organization and part of why some developers were worried about safety this year, I felt the layoffs or their upcoming GWC conference were more relevant topics for the union to discuss to prospective members. I hope they can have actionable plans to grow and create change in the industry, but they have not published anything yet from their petition last year to their ‘bill of rights’ they unveiled during their protest march. 

The most promising thing coming out of UVW-CWA is the Game Workers Conference, a digital and free conference by workers for workers. Although I would rather see them partner with notGDC, which is already established in the indie scene for being an alternative to GDC. Or finding another indie organization to group with to make launching this event easier. Anyways, that’s 3 paragraphs on a single booth. 

So the big question, would I recommend GDC to you? Many influencers are adamant on boycotting GDC for various reasons and pressing young devs not to go. I think most of them do not understand the actual purpose is not to find a job, but to make lifelong connections and learn more about the games industry in a week than you could in 6 months on your own. While this still favors US-based devs and people who can split hotel costs or share a hostel, the experience is worthwhile. 

You can talk with hundreds of developers, seeing what projects they are working on, how they overcame challenges, while finding new communities to be a part of. There is a strong sense of community and everyone is helpful from the CA’s to random passerby. The talks are informative and if you apply to be a CA you get to land yourself vault access anyways, so not need to worry about missing one. It would be nice to see more digital content next year in the GDC Discord, but that’s a topic for another day. This was a successful GDC for me and I know I cannot wait to see everyone again next year.

Also thank you Amir for ensuring that hundreds of students could attend this year. Hopefully next year Informa can find a partnership to provide hotel blocks for students too. 

For those that also went to GDC this year, what did you think about your experience? Did I miss anything? Did you find David? Did you partake in the crepe pilgrimage?

Edit: Below are some quotes from people I asked in the GDC community.

Stefan:

Lots of highs. I really enjoyed my time with the ARG (What Is BRG), the increased presence of board games / tabletop, the "play with the board game designer" session, the complex balance workshop (the lead up was a bit long, but the exercises were great), the live music / outdoor tables, and a lot more.

Anonymous:

“Ribbons collecting!!!!! so many ribbons to collect!!!!!”

Howdy:

the gates n barricades around made it feel less welcoming. Also ai slop. High was meeting people and doing events/talks

Devon:

They wanted to move more towards a festival feel yet they failed to provide the feeling of a festival on alot of fronts.

Chumba:

The highs for me usually happened outside of GDC, rather than in GDC itself. Though, the expo had some really cool areas, and I was able to connect with some really amazing people [...] The lows for me revolve around the event itself. As mentioned before, the barricades around YBG were very confusing and made it feel less welcoming. The sheer amount of AI that bombarded me around every turn got old really fast.


r/gamedev • • Aug 18 '13

I am 34 years old, and 15 years ago, I started making an MMORPG by myself...

0 Upvotes

I've created a web game, written primarily in perl. The thing is, years ago I wanted to make my own mmorpg, just like everyone else. Thing is, I have actually gone a long way towards creating one. I am not ready to publicize it just yet, because I still have a long way to go. Word to the wise: don't expect to make an mmorpg of any kind by yourself in less than a decade.

Of course, the first m in mmorpg stands for "massively." That's where I'm getting to now with the project. It's been developed on an inexpensive, low-traffic server. Once I open it up, odds are quite good that just a few simultaneous players will crash it. And then there's the issue of my coding. There are dozens of scripts and systems that must work together flawlessly for this game to have any promise with an actual player base. That's where stress-testing comes into play. I have little experience with this aspect of development.

What can I expect? Let's say I support an average base of 100 players. Will my server needs be too unreasonable to assure a profitable venture? I just don't know too many people who actually created an mmorpg by themselves and got to this point to find out.


r/gamedev • • Sep 21 '23

Unity absolutely will survive this

0 Upvotes

I know we all love to rage at Unity for the ass hat monetization model they've proposed last week, but I think we need to come back to reality here.

While is seems like most Indies for some reason did not expect the evil corporation run by the former EA CEO to do evil corporation things, AA and AAA developers have. The reality is that using a non proprietary engine comes with risks, cost being one of them.

Most studios will honestly just increase pricing and pass the added expense on to the consumer. They will do this because they have no choice. Because while it's extremely easy for an Indie dev to throw their hands up and say they are switching engines forever, it's very difficult for a studio consisting of dozens to hundreds to retrain their staff on new tech. The costs outweigh the benefits.

Unity is hear to stay. I appreciate everyone doing their best to force Unity to walk some of this back, but we also need to remain logical about how far this will actually go, and act appropriately.


r/gamedev • • Sep 13 '22

Postmortem So I paid someone to make me our dream game for $7000 US.

0 Upvotes

Would anyone here believe that I can pay someone $7000 US to work for 250 hours and make a quality game for just the both of us? Further, this guy can't even write a single line of code - he is completely coding illiterate. Well - it got made and I have no regrets. I can't show off here sadly but I am happy to give out the game for free to anyone who wants to play.

When I mentioned this last time on here, the game was just getting built and most people mocked me when I said I could make it on this budget. So how did I do it? I used one of the many free game-making engines out there which had all the essential features already provided for free, including art. The person who I paid was simply a very good level designer and he used his talent to make an outstanding work of art.

Now the drawback from this is I can't ever sell my game in the normal way on steam to recover my costs. Plus there's a whole load of IP and copyright issues involved so it can't ever be sold to the masses. But this was a game about our combined passion and vision and given how most consumers react to it, it wouldn't have sold anyway. If you've ever heard about the Japanese version of Super Mario Brothers 2 coming to the US, you'll understand why.

So there you have it - custom games made for just one big paying player can be done and for relatively cheap compared to some of the prices I've been quoted. Just got to be smart about things.


r/gamedev • • Aug 25 '26

Discussion How can I verify an artist I hired isn't using AI?

0 Upvotes

I'm a bit concerned trying to hire freelance. If they are using some generator for assets, how can I confirm the user didn't use AI generated websites and do some post processing? It would put my game at risk of losing any copyright ability on any of the assets essentially making it all open-source and I'd be paying for it for everyone else. Is there any watermarking or things to verify what they used? Seems all recent court docs support this where even slight modifications still lose any copyright ability for a company to claim it.

*Edit*Thanks for all the responses. I'm not as familiar with the art field and wanted to get some good feedback.

*I have nothing against AI artists as well. It does take technique for prompting and knowing genres/styles and input like a historian who can recall facts and describe as well. It's just not a fit for a future game I'm making as the copyright law only gives credit for additional work done for your art. It doesn't give you copyright over the art itself which some seem to misinterpret. Read recent reviews and also visit a lawyer. There is some gray area but in general it gives a light protection to add your own work to AI. I'm okay with ethical AI if the artwork and background training was done with consent but I think the community knows the story behind this.


r/gamedev • • Jun 02 '23

Discussion "Ideas are cheap", "We can grind 100 ideas for games in an hour meeting", "No one cares about your crappy indie game idea". If these hold true why do the big game companies continue to make mediocre, creatively bankrupt and soulless games?

6 Upvotes

I'm going to be honest and admit straight up that I'm bitter about the difficulty in finding finance and investors for my small indie game project. That aside. Meanwhile the big gaming companies continue to mostly fail in making good games. Barfing out mediocre, uncreative and soulless games.

It has been a severe flip the last decade to now having to rely on other indie game developers succeeding to find enjoyable gaming experiences. Seeing the rise of indie games didn't come as a surprise at all to me. As someone who has had gaming as a hardcore hobby for 30 years - the rise of indie game projects saved my hobby. That's no overstatement. The majority of my favorite games are no longer produced by the industry giants.

Big gaming companies are basically surviving in the game industry mostly due to huge wallets and infrastructure, as well as their established brands working as a lifesupport keeping them afloat.

Now here's what I don't get.

  • Ideas are cheap

  • We can grind 100 game ideas and concepts during lunch

  • No one cares about your crappy indie game idea

If ideas are cheap why don't they start having them?

If they can grind 100 ideas in an hour meeting, why do they go for the worst one when making a new game?

If they don't care about investing in "crappy indie games", why are indie games plentiful and seeing more and more success, while they continue to disappoint?


TL;DR

If "ideas are so cheap" and devs in the larger gaming studios say they can come up with 100 good ideas in an hour. Why are they so incapable? Why so unwilling to integrate indie game pitches and projects under their wing as a side investment?

It's like being in an art gallery with paintings good and bad from many various artists. Then a big name artist comes in and vomits on his own canvas proclaiming "See? I've made a masterpiece! Why would I need input or ideas from you guys?".


r/gamedev • • Aug 26 '26

Discussion No its not marketing, your game just sucks

0 Upvotes

After reading about hundreds of releases here on game dev I realized its not marketing you should do but make better appealing games. so far from all the post on reddit i have never downloaded a single game here because litterally every single one is so boring and bad that no amount of marketing will fix this issue. Then i realize the games that I do buy and play are not marketed toward me but i find them interesting my self so i buy them.


r/gamedev • • Jun 19 '12

AMA about how to start a game development company without any start up money. It can be done!!!

0 Upvotes

My name is Alfonzo 'Zo' Burton Founder and Creative Director of Burton Design Group (www.burtondesigngroup.com) a Mobile and Social Game development company in Southern California.

7 years ago I was working as a Creative Director developing websites and casual flash games long before the iPhone. I developed a lot of cool flash games for AOL and other popular flash game sites at the time. The problem with working for a company that develops games is that I had to develop the games that the company wanted to develop and when you work for a company that makes games to make money those games can be pretty, how do I say this nicely... fricken lame.

One day and I mean one day finally "I got feed up with the whole can you make this wack game fun and while your at it put this lame logo we've designed into the crappy game we are destroying with our continual edits we'd like to make everyday" so I jumped out the airplane with no parachute, no destination and no support and all I knew was that I really wanted to build cool games.

I put together a simple plan to pay rent and build cool games. My Plan was to put together a portfolio of the games I had developed over the years and start approaching other interactive companies and agencies to help them develop flash games and websites. My package was looking good and the pitch was set, I sent out my link to everyone I could find on craigslist and presto chango... I landed more banner ad projects than the front page of yahoo. I hate banner ad development. I hate looking at banners ads, I even hate the word banner ad. I was a full fledged business owner of a fresh new game company that was developing banner ads. This was it, what I've always dreamed of... I can truly say I would of rather polished turds at some restaurant job as the janitor than to make one more change to another lame banner ad.

I literally worked 20 hours a day for the first 3 months making thousands of changes to banner ads. If you've never developed banners ads there is never one banner ad. There are 5 different sizes and 10 different sites they must "Live" on, each with their own specifications which means for one campaign you have 50 - 60 banner ads to create. One change means you have to make changes to every single one. Why don't they just approve one then make all the others from that one you say? Because that's not the way really smart people with MBA's who work at large companies and drink way too much coffee operate. It's much easier to just say can you make the color a little more orangyish like taupe meets periwinkle.

Anyways, after a few months of that I got a great opportunity through one of my clients to re-design a little know website called Famous Stars and Straps. See proof http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KH4dXlQEG8. I developed two different websites over the course of a year for Travis Barker's Famous Stars and Straps website and they were both a huge hit. After that I was able to land a lot of really cool website projects like the Kawasaki Live website http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWZA1SnAqjU and a few game micro sites like Smackdown vs. Raw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsQQEeWciqE. I was having a lot of fun but where were all the games. Didn't anybody want to make really cool games and bam! it hit me. An independent game development studio was really a website, banner ad, interface design, video editing and logo creation company that occasionally washed windows and mowed lawns, and made some small one off games to drive traffic to websites... this was awesome!!!

One thing you'll realize as a new business owner is that you have to do what you have to do to grow you business and if that means doing things that you might not exactly want to be doing at the time then quit your sniveling, grab a box of straws and suck it up. This isn't no money from daddy's trust fund venture in business, this is how are you going to pay your rent in 2 weeks get your grind on type of business? We'll after 2 years of paying dues and developing a lot of really cool websites and advergames a little known company called Apple released a device that had me sitting up a night trying to figure out just how much time I left in the flash development business since flash didn't and wouldn't run on it.

I decided to take my business I mean my freelance contractor job to the next level and completely abandon flash development and start developing mobile apps and games. Luckily the many years I spent with User Experience and interface design translated very seamlessly to mobile and my natural ability to figure out the most optimized experience for users was very easy for me. I rebranded my company geared towards mobile apps and game development and hit the road as a lone salesman and I was able to close several really cool apps and games that did incredibly well. By the end of the 2009 I built a small team of contract developers to help develop the apps and games I was closing and by the time 2011 rolled around it seemed like the entire world wanted a mobile game or app and boom! The Apple store gold rush was on and I was right in the middle of it. I closed almost $2 million of business through 2011 built a AAA game development team and launched several major games and apps for iPhone, iPad, Android and Facebook. Though business was doing well I found out it is almost impossible to develop your own games and develop games for customers because customers always come first and you can only do so much in a day. We started developing a new game call Knight Hunter at the end of 2010 and worked on the game off and on for about a year. At the beginning of 2012 I decided to dedicate more resources to Knight Hunter to try and get the game launched in the first quarter but, client projects took priority once again but we've managed to get a working version of Knight Hunter done thus far.

Now that we have a working demo after about a year we run into the same issues as before. It costs a lot of money to dedicate staffing resources to a pet project that won't generate any income for several months until it's the game is completed and then as an independent game company you have to pay for the marketing of the game or no one will be able to buy it because they don't know about it. We'll it's funny how business works because right about the same time I was strategizing on how to get our game to market I found out about a very cool and innovative solution called crowd funding. Which isn't all that new but it was made available via a little known site called Kickstarter. Finally a way to possible get Knight Hunter to market this year. So the whole team excited about the opportunity went to work planning out the strategy, creating content and marketing materials that we'd need to run a campaign on kickstarter and 4 weeks later... bam!!! Knight Hunter on Kickstarter was born http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/knighthuntergame/knight-hunter.

Now June 18, 2012 I have a game development company that has developed more than 20 iPhone/ iPad, Android and Facebook games and apps and have a multiplayer Driving Shooter game that I dreamed of creating 7 years ago finally on Kickstarter and ready for those who really love games to help make it even better than I could of ever imagined by being able to add their ideas and vision for a game they've always wanted to play too.

In conclusion, if you really want to own a game development studio never forget the reason that you play games and always fight to put those reasons into ever game, website, video, 3d animation and yes banner ad you create because true passion and desire will always figure out a way to manifest itself.

Alfonzo "Zo" Burton Creative Director Burton Design Group

"Passion endures long after talent has reached it's limit"


r/gamedev • • Dec 12 '24

Recommend me a Macbook for game dev. No, I don't have a choice.

0 Upvotes

We release games across multiple platforms including iOS. So here we are.

I've been getting by with a Mac Mini but the five minute boot times and endless rainbow spiral are testing my sanity. I need either a sturdy length of rope or a capable Macbook that doesn't cost the equivalent of an out of network heart transplant in the US.

Working in Unity, GameMaker, maybe Godot.

Edit for clarity: I'm specifying MacBook because I want something I can put somewhere I don't have to look at it the rest of the time. iMac or Mac mini aren't an option because my desk is already full of computers I like.

Edit: yes, I know I only have to compile on the Mac. But that inevitably entails a pilgrimage into the bowels of the project via the anus in order to figure out which polyps haven't correctly installed. And I prefer that process to be as speedy as practicable.

Shoot.


r/gamedev • • Feb 11 '24

Discussion Is Twitter (X) dead now?

1 Upvotes

I used to get a couple of bites at least by bot RT accounts, and now I’m getting absolutely nothing. I don’t have premium so I assume that’s the issue, but was wondering what other people had to say