r/gamedev • • 1h ago

Question Vetting Playtesters

3 Upvotes

I’m assuming (hoping) that once I make a discord there will be people clamoring to be playtesters of the game (ideally for free). How does one go about “vetting” who would and would not make a great play tester (and also weed out potential bad actors)?


r/gamedev • • 2h ago

Question How to write a good game design doc?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm not exactly new to game development, having used Game Maker several years ago, and I have some programming knowledge, but what I really want to know about is how to write a good game design document. Like, I have a couple of video game ideas I would like to bring to life, and I know I couldn't possibly bring them all to life by myself without spending several years' worth of effort, so I want to be able to write a solid game design doc to explain the features of the game and how to implement them to ensure that anyone working on the game with me knows what's expected.


r/gamedev • • 3h ago

Question Rendering 1000s of spaceships

5 Upvotes

I'm making a space management sim (x4 inspiration) using Godot engine. I have implemented multi threading and many other optimizations so the game will run above or at 60fps. I'v been studying how eve online handles 1000s of ships and they run calculations at 1hz cycle. Client interpolates them and smooths out. Is it possible to implement such system in Godot without major code change?


r/gamedev • • 3h ago

Discussion Soulslike without respawning enemies

0 Upvotes

I'm brainstorming this. The cost of letting enemies stay dead is that the player can run back to the last checkpoint and get freebie heals, thus removing all tension. So my idea was that enemies respawn if you use a checkpoint already checked. Problem is, that only works in linear design. So instead, you could "bank" kills and cache them in at the checkpoint, so approaching it from a different direction doesn't change that. It doesn't solve the free healthcare issue. Thoughts?


r/gamedev • • 3h ago

Question What do I do with my completed game?

1 Upvotes

Hello all!

A friend and I developed a board game over the course of a few years and finished it around 6 or 7 years ago. We have played it thousands of times with tons of different people and can firmly say it is a complete and finished game. We enjoy it immensely and still play it whenever we get a chance away from our busy lives. There is only one fully finished and complete copy of our game that we had made by thegamecrafter.com. It has a very finished look and all the box art and everything on the cards and boards was done by me over the course of the years long process of the game and I think it looks very professional and I'm very proud of it.

Although we made the game just for fun and as a challenge to ourselves, we inevitably started to think about publishing. But when it came down to it, we realized selling something like this is just as much a full time job as anything else. We realized that to sell the game would require no small amount of either time or money. Too much time or money for us to personally feel like it was worth the investment. It's a great game, and we'd love for more people to play it, but the upfront cost of buying a ton of product and shipping it and dealing with manufacturers just to get our game into an incredibly competitive space seems like a nightmare. So we shelved the idea of selling it and still just enjoy having the game to play together and with friends.

Well now some time has passed, and I still think about how I could get the game out to more people, just because I would love for it to be played and to hear feedback. I don't really care or believe I'll make money off it because I know I don't have the correct amount of desire to push it as much as I would need to with marketing and crowdfunding and all that.

I thought about learning to code so I could make it into a video game so people anywhere could try it, but again I struggle to find time in my busy life to set aside for learning a new skill like coding. A friend suggested I use AI to make a playable HTML version of the game, so I did. It works great and is as fun as the board game but obviously underpolished because it's crappy AI. Also AI is gross and the last thing the gaming industry is going to need in the years ahead is sloppy AI-made games.

So to my longwinded point: what the hell should I do with this game? Should I continue to just be satisfied that my friend and I made a game together we can always enjoy? Or, should I still try to produce it and find some other kind of avenue, like selling just the idea to a company to rebrand as whatever they want? Should I keep trying to make it as a video game? If so, should I contact a freelancer to develop it? A company? Sell the idea to a studio? Suck it up and learn to code? What would you do in my shoes? HELP ME DECIDE. Please settle my thoughts. Thanks.


r/gamedev • • 4h ago

Discussion Myst Like Game Engine

5 Upvotes

Hi

I am not a Game Dev but i want to experiment making a Myst like Game.

I am searching for a open source Game Engine that is capable to make Games in the Style of Myst. I mean the Original Version with the Prerendered Images and FMVs.

There is Adventure Game Studio ao i figured that there is maybe some free Engine for Myst like Games too.

In my Opinon these kind of Games needs to come back again.

Can someone here tell me if such an Engine exists?


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Question Improving on Markov-Chain name generator.

2 Upvotes

Hello guys,

Im a little bit of a newbie so bear with me if im asking the most obvious question here im genuinly quute sguck right now.

Im working on a Simulation Game in Godot in which alot of Characters of different Fantasy Races and evetually also Cultures need ro be generated. The goal is also to make the player attached to the characters which is why the naming system is somewhat important.

For now i have limited my game to 3 races the classic human dwarf and elf triangle and made a list per race. with 100 male and female names each. These are then used by a Markov-Chain to generate names should the List eventually run out.

So the name generation algorithim is more of a backup.

Ive tested a bit around and a chain lenght of 3 worked well for me. The generated names of elfs and dwarfs are sometimes odd but overall sound somewhat sensible and id guess the remaininh kinks would iron out with a larger data base then just 100.

The humans names though are somewhat of an issue and around 70% just sound weird probably becouse they are actually used names so weird combos feel espacially weird.

I know i could some sort of phonetic or lingustic type system to improve generation but that would be alot of manual work considering that i want to add more races and perhaps culturrs in the future.

Overall i kinda desigend the foundation im building to be as far as my knowledge tells me as modular as i can , what i mean by that(sorry if modular is the wrong word ebglish isnt my first language) is that i have rather systematic and "tidy" approach i tried to not use crutched where i can avoid them and pretty much nothing is hard coded if you feed the system a differnt dataset you would have a different game.

My idea behind that was to make balancing and content addidtions far less work.

This is alo the design i would prefer for the name generator, but without lingusitic details i have no idea how to improve on it so it still works genericllay or rather that the upgrades also work generically.

Does anyone perhaps has an idea or somethibg i could look into? The only concept i came up with was to make "naming profiles" which i would also just store as data which would essentally give the generator different paramters for each race without it all beeing one messy script but iid appreicate any idea on how to make the thing work better overall.


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Question I released my first “game”

4 Upvotes

So I’m in college for game programming and I released a super super short simple game that I made for a project and I want people to try it but I have no idea how to showcase it or anything


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Question Should I use my 2D game to practice for 3D?

0 Upvotes

I’m a newbie and I’m working on my first real game. It happens to involve alot of common guns like 1911s, M4s, etc.

I’ve already finish a few of the arts for them but I wanted advice on the idea of using my current art to help me learn how to make 3D models that I can then use for games I’m alot more excited for.

Would it cause any problems or be counterproductive?
I doubt it would do much any other than help me learn blender but I want 100% sure if it’d make the games preform lesser.


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Discussion Trying to balance 12 stages of my roguelite

2 Upvotes

Balance: the number

My roguelite has 12 stages, some of which can be two or three waves of enemies.

I had no idea how to balance a game, so I came up with an estimated "threat" measurement for each enemy based on some player data, and used that for estimating each stage difficulty

It worked well until... a playtester went from battling three waves of 1 enemy to battling a single wave of 4 enemies at the same time, in it's first playthrough

And the problem was that with my system, a stage with three waves of 2 enemies and a stage with one wave of 6 enemies is considered the same difficulty, but it's not.

So, what's better than a number? Two numbers!

I split the number in two:

  • Peak difficulty is the threat score of the wave with highest threat score in that stage. So if the stage waves looks like 2-2-3, the wave with more threat determines peak difficulty: 3

  • Attrition is the total threat score across the room, including later waves and replacements. So out 2-2-3 stage attrition is 7.

That distinction gave me a better way to tune a stage. Say three enemies are alive and one replacement arrives every time one dies. Adding more replacements makes the fight last longer, increasing attrition, while the peak stays at three enemies, mantaining peak difficulty.

New enemies vs new players

Players got overwhelmed when they've entered a stage and there was 4 unfamiliar faces of unkown attack patterns.

Si now I gradually introduce new enemies instead of making stages full random.

I've divided my stages internally intro introduction stages and challenge stages, by cycles of 4.

During introduction stages (the first three), the player can meet at most one new enemy type per stage, and both difficulty and attrition increase gradually.

The fourth stage of each cycle is to challenge the learnt lessons: It's a spike in difficulty and attrition, but guarantees no new enemies: you always fight known foes. More of them.

So now the campaign of my demo looks like this:

---First cycle---
Stages
1–3    Introductions     Learn new enemies as difficulty rises gradually
  4    Familiar spike    Face tougher combinations of enemies already seen

---Second cycle---
5–7    Introductions     Learn new threats alongside familiar ones
  8    Familiar spike    Handle more pressure with a wider set of known enemies

---Final cycle---
  9    Last introduction  Prioritize advanced enemies the player hasn’t seen yet
 10    Miniboss           The miniboss is the new threat; any escorts are familiar
 11    Themed test        One enemy family, drawn from enemies already seen
 12    Final boss         The Boss closes the run

I think now the challenge relies on validating this approach, as well as introducing succesfully a new variable: estimated player power, to know not only the raw increase in difficulty, but the net difficulty increase accounting for the player increase in power

Anyone has experience balancing pve roguelikes or RPGs? How do yoy balanced your game?


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Discussion My thoughts on Queens Domain

0 Upvotes

disclaimer: this post will include mild spoilers - you've been warned

I'm about to finish the game, and I have some thoughts and insights that goes beyond game review and are bit more about game design in general, and this might be the place to share them.

I've been playing games since '87 and I can't remember when I had so much fun playing a single player game the last time. The game obviously plays on nostalgia, but it genuinely made me feel like I was teenager again, playing Eye of the Beholder or Morrowind for the first time. It's filled to the brim with secrets, but it does an extremely good job with design language, leaving small breadcrumbs that leads careful player in the right direction. Between skeletons pointing at secret doors, eggs glowing in the dark, and all of these little hints where you can spot a secret room or collectible way ahead of time, so you make a mental note and get the a-ha moment when you realize something you saw couple minutes ago must be behind this wall - it's a masterclass in level design.

Despite having a semi open world, there's even a hidden hint that points the player into the right direction - when you enter a new area and kill your first enemy in that region, it's get added to your bestiary. If you're careful enough, you can spot the index number of the enemy, and if there's a gap in your bestiary the game gives you a very clear indication that you skipped something in designed linear progression.

Areas, albeit overwhelming at first, have a clear linear progression - even the dreaded Ancient World, if you just follow the initial route, leads you to an NPC in a straight line, and then, offers you a convenient teleporter device that allows you to quickly navigate between three major landmarks in the area. A pattern that has been set in the very first area of the game.

Sure, the game falls victim to it's visual choice here and there - I've lost probably 2 or 3 hours running around clueless, just to realize I missed a lever that blended with the environment, or didn't realize I had to interact with an NPC to get a key item. But overall the progression was pretty clear.

However this all falls apart once you finish the "final" area and kill the boss.

I say "final" because up to that point there are three optional areas that are somehow hidden from the player, and doesn't add anything particular to that natural progression.

I'm still torn on what would be the correct move here, but I'm leaning to having credits roll after defeating the boss at this stage, giving a closure to the player and leaving these optional areas and secret endings for those who are really dedicated to playing the game for the second time.

Instead the game doesn't finish, the player is teleported to the starting location, now equipped with additional tools, but there's no clear path forward.

If you're keen and look around the internet you'll find that the game has optional secret endings that require you to... gather all collectibles that are scattered across the whole game in most obnoxious places.

The second ending requires you to visit these optional areas and tie couple lose ends, but the third requires you to gather these collectibles and kill every type of monster in the game. For those the game at least provide you with progression bar in the Challenges menu, but couple of monsters are one-ofs and are hidden in extremely obscure places (one requires you to fly or spend an hour glitching extremely tedious platformer section that doesn't even feel intentional).

And if you want the last ending you need to collect skull items that are placed in the most ridiculous fuck-you places you could imagine.

Overall the last section of the game feels like a chore.

This leads me to two conclusions.

One one hand, I feel like the game would be much better product without explicit achievements which judgmentally tells the player that he finished only 40% of the game, leaving them with feeling that they missed something important and take away the sense of achievement for what they accomplished so far. Like Blow intentionally opted for not having achievements in Braid. Sure, there was at least one fuck-you puzzle, with a cloud platform that took an hour of real time to move the the right position, but at least the game didn't scold on you for missing it.

On the other hand I often fantasize about the sense of exploration we had before the internet. Animal Well is a great example that this is the thing of the past, and even the most obscure and hidden secrets will be revealed on reddit few days after the game release.

But somehow I missed the times when I played Morrowind, finished it, and some time later I saw a friend playing it, and I realized he reached a region that's so distinct I was absolutely sure I have never seen it before. And it was totally fine, because there was no Steam achievements, no online walkthroughs, and my journey was my own, however incomplete.

When I played Fallout for the first time, when I reached the Military Base, out of curiosity I picked the dialog option to join the Master. I watched the cutscene in awe and decided that's a fabulous conclusion to my journey. And I left it at that. Took me 10 years to come back and finish the game "the right way".


r/gamedev • • 6h ago

Discussion Not to brag but I just learned how to make a button click

153 Upvotes

But seriously I’m addicted to this. I’ve never coded (/programmed? I still don’t understand the difference) in my life but I’m learning from the ground up and it’s so so so rewarding. I’m avoiding AI entirely because I want to fully understand what I’m doing, and honestly I don’t know if I’ll ever use it because it’s so fun to solve problems and figure things out on my own!

This is the best hobby ever!


r/gamedev • • 8h ago

Question Making a mobile game, it might take me some time to set up a company for an app store dev account. Anyway I can get people to test my game meanwhile?

1 Upvotes

I’m afraid I’m spending so much time building when I haven’t established people would enjoy it :(


r/gamedev • • 8h ago

Question Help finding THE Low Poly Character models

0 Upvotes

Right what it says on the tin, i want to try and make some animations and such, to train myself, but i want to use THE low poly, generic, free, overused models, you know the ones, games like West Hunt use them (Only game off the top of my mind that uses them, shameful i know) and i've been searching for them for like a couple of days now and i can't find them! I searched on the Unity Asset Store, on other websites but no luck so far, if anyone has a link or even just the files straight up would be doing me a HUGE favor.


r/gamedev • • 9h ago

Discussion How do you interpret negative Steam reviews from players who keep playing for dozens more hours?

28 Upvotes

I released my first game on Steam last week and reading reviews has been an emotional roller coaster.

One odd pattern is players leaving negative reviews and then seemingly continuing to play for dozens more hours.

A few examples:
- Negative review at 16 hours → 68 hours total
- Negative review at 34 hours → 96 hours total
- Negative review at 82 hours → 112 hours total
And there are quite a few more like these.

I understand that playtime doesn’t necessarily equal enjoyment and some of the criticism is perfectly valid. But I feel like I’d stop playing a game long before 20 hours if I wasn’t enjoying it.

I’m struggling to interpret this feedback. Are these players enjoying the game despite its flaws? Are they invested enough to keep going but frustrated with certain mechanics? Do players like this ever go back to modify their reviews? I’m taking the actual criticism seriously, but it’s hard not to feel discouraged seeing this pattern.


r/gamedev • • 9h ago

AMA I built a VR game engine from scratch in C++ (no Unity/Unreal/Godot) where AI agents write the gameplay code and fix their own compile errors — open sourced, public domain

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I built something called a Prompt to VR Engine and just open-sourced it. Two parts to it, and for this sub I think the second part is the interesting one.

Part one: the engine. It's a hand-written C++ VR engine — Vulkan rendering, OpenXR, a real physics engine. The things every VR game needs are already in the core: teleport and smooth locomotion, snap/smooth turning, grabbing, throwing, weapon recoil, finger posing, a full-body avatar or hands-only play, NPC follow and melee, encounter waves, health, objectives, game-over flow, doors, switches, holsters. No Unity, Unreal, or Godot anywhere in the path.

Part two: the pipeline. You describe a game in plain text and a local orchestrator on your PC turns that into a native Quest APK. The prompt first becomes a set of structured, validated plans — objects, characters, behaviors, rules, scene layout — and each stage writes files the next stage reads instead of reinterpreting the prompt. Gemini generates a reference image per object, Tripo turns those into textured 3D models, characters that need to move get rigged through Tripo or Uthana, and a generated C++ world builder constructs the environment.

Then the part I keep finding wild: the gameplay code is written by OpenAI agents, one bounded C++ module per mechanic the engine doesn't already have. The modules are compiled, and when there are compiler errors, those errors go back to the agent that owns the file and it rewrites until it builds. On a Quest target the code is checked with the Android compiler too, because a file can compile on Windows and still fail the Quest build. Modules that survive get promoted into a reuse catalog later games can draw from.

I want to be clear about what this is and isn't. It is not a finished product that reliably turns any prompt into a polished commercial game. A large prompt costs more and takes longer than a small one (roughly $70 in API usage for a small game). It is a foundation, released into the public domain with no license restrictions, meant for people to build on. Some ways I can see it being used:

  • A real prompt-to-VR solution that creates high-quality games anyone can take and play on the Quest 3.

  • A totally new AI-assisted VR game creation engine that rivals Unity and Unreal for VR game creation.

  • A prompt-to-VR solution that not only creates the game, but lets developers export the game, including everything about it, into other engines like Unity and Godot.

Repo: https://github.com/FriimanTech/Prompt-To-VR
Site with gameplay footage and setup paths: https://friiman-tech.vercel.app/products/prompt-to-vr-engine

Happy to go deep on any part of the architecture in the comments.


r/gamedev • • 9h ago

Discussion To Developers Worried About More Competition: Welcome to Art!

79 Upvotes

I keep seeing things about the low chance of success for indie developers due to the greater number of games being produced and it just seems funny because do they know how many songs, paintings, sculptures, videos, or books are made every month?

Video games are just the latest art to lower the technical barrier to entry. Fortunately people keep practicing all the arts despite low chance of “success” (I.e. significant monetary gain) because of the joy of creation.


r/gamedev • • 9h ago

Discussion Just realized how hard it is for a player to understand my game

3 Upvotes

Few days ago a 2nd youtuber played my demo, I was happy because I saw he played 1 hour ! Little did I know the 15 first minutes he was trying to figure out how to play the game! That's crazy how a lot of things in my game are not intuitive at all.

I'm happy he loved the game but damn most of the players would have gave up. I am planning to treat it as a priority as for me the "Tutorial box full of text" is just borring and not even clear enough.

I have 2 options:

  1. A play by play tutorial where I guide the player during the first couple of battles

  2. A "How to play" at the start with videos and stuff playing

  3. Do both

How do you make your game easy to access? I don't know why I feel awful about that, for those 15 minutes I felt like I forgor about players that are new to Autobattlers...


r/gamedev • • 10h ago

Question Would a "sprite -> 3D model you can paint pixel-by-pixel" tool be useful to you?

0 Upvotes

Hi! I'm working on a small Windows tool (working name: Pictor) and before I go further I'd like to know if this is something you'd actually use. Screenshots attached.

What it does right now:

- You give it a character sprite (front, and side/back/top if you have them).

- Shape mode: you mark the sprite's pixels with body-part brushes (head, torso, arms, legs), press Inflate, and it builds a 3D shape that matches the sprite from every view. A red/blue guide shows where the model and the sprite don't match.

- Skin mode: the model gets a texture you paint pixel by pixel, while a pixel-art view of the model sits next to the sprite, so you can match them exactly. You can also "spray" the sprite's colors onto the model.

- The model can then be turned to any angle and still looks like pixel art (outlines, cel-style highlights).

- Optional AI helpers: an AI agent that fixes the shape or paints the texture, PixelLab for extra views of the sprite, and "Skins": write a prompt and it re-textures the model into variants you pick from a grid.

- Assets are grouped in projects (characters, furniture, tiles, hair).

What I'd like to know:

  1. Would this be useful in your workflow? For what (more directions, animation, consistent characters…)?

  2. What's missing that would make you actually use it?

  3. Would you prefer it as a standalone app or as a plugin (Aseprite, Godot, Blender…)?

It's still early and rough. Honest opinions welcome, including "I wouldn't use this".

/preview/pre/would-a-sprite-3d-model-you-can-paint-pixel-by-pixel-tool-v0-fm10no50c12i1.png?width=1080&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=cacf8a70dfa5516b41106f530322545cfc8a836e

/preview/pre/would-a-sprite-3d-model-you-can-paint-pixel-by-pixel-tool-v0-1z0zzy54c12i1.png?width=1080&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=06a505930027d053701fb57ffcb1b6d23de9ddd7


r/gamedev • • 10h ago

Discussion Anyone else not think about their game idea to avoid manifesting it be made by someone else? A discussion on "Someone else made my game faster"

0 Upvotes

I swear to god every time i start a project (And not something everyone else thinks like "A boomer shooter with destructible environments"), a couple of months later the exact game i planned and been working at, pops up on a reddit post or wherever.

How do you deal with this? I still dont stop developing my idea, but cant shake a feel of "People will think im ripping off X"


r/gamedev • • 11h ago

Question Whats a simple method to plot out a plot outline for a possible game?

4 Upvotes

Just wondering as i struggle with creative writing and normal writing due to have dyslexia and school failing me for the most part. Ive wanted to make a game for a bit now, so im thinking of trying rpg maker to learn from, but most games made in said rpg maker require a plot or story of sorts?

Im just not sure how to plot out a story in a simple manner without overthinking things or getting bored, but i still want to try im just not sure how to start?


r/gamedev • • 11h ago

Discussion How I made $14,000 in my first Play Test

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, little background about me. I am a glass artist, and I build agentic workflows for law firms for my main income. I made a glassblowing simulator in my free time and decided to open a small alpha for people to play. I posted it on my instagram @mortonglassworks and it went viral with 650k views. It’s the first of its kind so I believe it helped my exposure.

I hosted it on vercel, had no domain purchased yet, just an idea. In the first 24 hours, i have over 10,000 visitors. After noticing a huge influx of attention, I decided that I needed to start monetizing and scaling my databases.

I started selling Ad Sponsorships on my game for $50-200 a month depending on location.

In 1 week, I received $14,000 in sponsorships from Artists, collectors, museums, color companies, tool companies. I paid $0 for marketing, it just happened to be a missing piece to the industry.

Now how did this work? At first I was scared to ask for $50 a month, but within 1 day i raised different areas from $50-200 and people still were not flinching. I create their logo in game, and people can click and interact inside of the game. Lots of people have never been inside a game, so incorporating them was a new experience for them to be apart of. Everyone wants to be inside of a game, and you can make this happen.

Im now in talks with a company who wants to invest in the production, they already gave sponsorship money prior. You never know who is ready until you throw yourself out there.

Our first competition worth $2,200 for players ends today. I am now working on setting up a steam and itch pages.

I would say find a niche you care about and are knowledgable about, for example you’re an electrician make a game involving that skill that you have the upper hand in. Its hard to translate a vision between developers

Happy to help anyone with any questions of how this worked, and their approach. I am by no means an expert, just sharing my experience so others can learn.

If i could go back id change a bunch of things.


r/gamedev • • 12h ago

Question Game Designers: How are you finding jobs in 2026?

29 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm a game designer with around 4 years of professional experience, and I'd like to hear about your experiences navigating the current job market.

Over the past few years, I've had the opportunity to work with several studios on projects with engagements ranging from a few months to multiple years. At one point, I was managing up to three projects simultaneously.

Unfortunately, due to circumstances beyond my control, two of those projects eventually shut down. I've been working on a single project for the past few weeks, but the income from this role alone isn't enough to sustain me financially, so I'm actively looking for additional opportunities.

I've been updating my portfolio and looking through job boards and industry forums. However, I've been hearing increasingly negative things from colleagues about the current state of the industry, with many saying that finding a job in game development has become extremely difficult.

I'd love to hear from other game designers:

  • How has your experience been finding work in 2026?

  • Have you managed to land new opportunities recently? If so, what worked for you?

  • Are there any particular platforms, communities, or strategies you'd recommend?

Any advice or personal experiences would be greatly appreciated. I'd really like to hear how others are navigating the current situation. Thanks!

Edit: typo


r/gamedev • • 12h ago

Discussion People Say the Nemesis System Patent Is Narrow - But Is It Really?

65 Upvotes

I've just now opened the Nemesis System patent (US10926179B2) to have a look for myself.

In broad terms, you should never legally be able to patent an abstract idea or a game design philosophy-only a concrete technical implementation. Yet looking at the prosecution history, Warner Bros. spent roughly five years battling rejections focused almost entirely on prior art rather than having the claims thrown out as an "abstract idea". Given how strictly software patents are supposed to be scrutinized for abstractness, seeing this one clear the Patent Office with wording this sweeping is surprising.

Under 35 U.S.C. § 112, a patent is supposed to clearly define the boundaries of the invention and explain how to build and use it without undue experimentation. Even after reading through the specification, though, the document leans heavily on high-level abstractions rather than locking down a rigid software architecture. Warner Bros. obviously had top-tier patent counsel and the resources to push through years of back-and-forth until they secured exceptionally broad claim language.

I'm not a lawyer, and this isn't legal advice-just a developer reading the public text. People often claim this patent is tightly narrowed down and specific, but reading through it, that does not appear to be the case. In patent structure, independent claims (like Claim 1) set the broadest baseline footprint of the patent, because every listed step must be met together for the claim to apply, while later dependent claims add narrower details on top.

NOTE: This is a technical and game-design breakdown of the public patent text (US10926179B2) for educational discussion, not legal advice.

So let's skim over the steps of Claim 1:

Step 1:
controlling, by a processor, game events in a computer-implemented game, the game events involving an avatar that is operated in response to input from a player, and a first non-player character that is controlled by the processor to respond to and automatically oppose avatars based on first character parameters defined in a computer memory;

Note (Editorial Commentary - Not Legal Advice): Taken in isolation, Step 1 describes the baseline loop of almost every single-player game built since Space Invaders: a CPU runs a game loop, reads player input to move an avatar, and updates an AI entity using variables stored in RAM. Notice also how broadly the patent uses the word "oppose" - without restricting it to combat, the phrasing technically reads on everything from an enemy soldier to a rival racer or a chess AI. In patent law, introductory steps like this are just foundational scaffolding, they establish the setting rather than the actual invention.

Step 2:
detecting, by the processor, occurrence of a predefined one of the game events involving an interaction between the avatar and the first non-player character;

Note (Editorial Commentary - Not Legal Advice): Like Step 1, Step 2 recites standard event-driven programming rather than a novel technical mechanism - detecting an interaction and triggering a programmed response is simply how event listeners work in any interactive software. The catch, however, is that because Claim 1 requires every step to be met together, a developer can't easily "design around" the patent at Steps 1 or 2. Since almost any interactive game naturally satisfies these baseline conditions, they act as free checkmarks for the patent - pushing the entire burden of avoiding the claim onto the later, more specific steps.

Step 3:
changing, by the processor, second character parameters defined in at least one of the computer memory or a second computer memory for control of a second non-player character in the game based on the detecting, wherein the second non-player character is controlled by the processor to respond to and automatically oppose avatars based on the second character parameters defined in the at least one of the computer memory or the second computer memory; 

Note (Editorial Commentary - Not Legal Advice):Making a game world feel genuinely "breathing" relies on systemic ripple effects - an interaction with one character altering another - yet US10926179B2 claims that abstract design idea rather than a genuine technical mechanism or invention. Claim 1 defines the "first" and "second" NPCs in the exact same broad, generic terms as opposing AI entities driven by stored parameters, while the description relies on permissive lawyer-speak ("may," "in the alternative") to treat concrete implementation details as optional flavors. The catch, however, is that by claiming a high-level conceptual outcome instead of an actual engineering solution, the patent functions as predatory gatekeeping - a greedy attempt to monopolize a foundational game design philosophy rather than protect a specific invention.

Step 4:
outputting, to an output device, an indication of the second character parameters that are changed by the changing.

Note (Editorial Commentary - Not Legal Advice): Step 4 closes Claim 1 with "outputting, to an output device, an indication of the second character parameters that are changed by the changing," using undefined terms that leave the actual scope of the requirement entirely ambiguous. On its face, the text of step 4 seemingly does not specify whether "an output device" and "an indication" are limited to a dedicated UI screen or are an attempt to stretch toward any generic audio or visual feedback. The catch, however, is that communicating state changes to a player is a baseline necessity of all interactive software. Rather than defining a concrete display mechanism or genuine technical invention, this phrasing reads like a greedy effort to claim the abstract concept of player feedback itself - creating deliberate uncertainty instead of a clear engineering boundary.

With that breakdown as context, I'm curious to hear from other developers and anyone familiar with software patents:

- From a game design perspective, has any game truly captured that kind of systemic ripple effect - where how you treat one character automatically reshapes how other autonomous NPCs (even initially friendly or neutral ones in a social group) react to or oppose you based on shifting internal parameters?

- In practice, what architectural approaches are developers using to build reactive, "breathing" NPC ecosystems like this?

- Am I reading too extensively into the broad phrasing here, and what do you think the steps of Claim 1 actually mean in practice?