r/functionalprint • • Feb 04 '20

Easy model optimization

Post image
21.5k Upvotes

398 comments sorted by

939

u/NanoBoostedRoadhog Feb 04 '20

This type of FEA is only accurate for isotropic materials/processes such as machined billet. Unfortunately it's of limited use for 3D printing due to the extreme number of variables involved (material, flowrate, temperature, orientation, infill, ambient temperature, cooling, humidity etc etc).

If you're designing anything structural, be aware FEA is not yet a reliable way to predict the behaviour and stress characteristics of a 3D printed part.

I've yet to see a dedicated FEA software for FDM 3D printing; that would be one hell of a package to code. However specialist software packages do exist for more controlled processes, for example composite hand layups such as fibreglass and carbon fibre.

295

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

You are right. This can be a useful tool but the limitations for 3D printing have to be taken into account.

For this part (printed laying on the back) I did not notice any differences in functionality. Both the original and optimized part (printed with 20% gyroid infill, 3 perimeters) were able to hold 10 kg. This is much more than required for the part.

96

u/NanoBoostedRoadhog Feb 04 '20

Nice job! Good to hear you are testing them and considering safety factor too.

38

u/Rumbuck_274 Feb 04 '20

Just for reference, I've found that the Slic3r/PrusaSlicer 3D honeycomb to be stronger than the Cura Gyroid, though this was by no means an extreme test, I printed lightbar mounts for my roof racks, the 2 pairs I printed in Cura snapped easily at road speed, the pair I printed in PrusaSlicer held up for about 5 weeks, the Cura ones broke in 2 days.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/mr_d0gMa Feb 05 '20

For most applications you want to reduce infill and increase perimeters because most loading conditions under tensions or compression work at the material that’s furthest from the neutral axis

13

u/insomniac-55 Feb 05 '20

Pedantic correction, but it's bending loads where you want material to be far from the neutral axis. For pure tension and compression, it doesn't really matter where the material is (although increasing the cross-section of your part will usually improve buckling performance).

In a shear loaded part, the highest stress actually occurs near the middle of the cross-section (from memory it's at the neutral axis but I might be wrong here).

Often, bending loads are what dominates so it still makes sense to put more material at the perimeters.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/crackeddryice Feb 04 '20

It also seems like a good learning tool to teach general concepts, at least.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/mrfixit226 Feb 04 '20

In solidworks topology optimization they have 3d printed material as an option such as ABS that can get you a little closer. Plus orienting the print so your Z lines are loaded in compression, some higher safety factors for loading and you can get a decent part. I printed a coffee coaster that has an overhang and it looks neat, saved material, and works like a charm!

It would be cool if you could take the sliced model and simulate that with the layer lines and some sort of coefficient to describe how well the layers adhere and that could get you closer, but would take so much processing power.

Disclaimer: I would definitely do test prints and make sure you dial in all settings for anything holding a major structural load (like a shelf) as you mentioned there are a lot of variables that can throw it off.

6

u/sanjibukai Feb 05 '20

Would you mind to share the part (even a picture).. I can't get how it might be a hanging part for a coaster... Unless it's really tall..

→ More replies (4)

26

u/ShadowRam Feb 04 '20

I mean, you're not wrong.

But when people are just doing basic parts for at home, they don't need to go into that depth.

It's not like people on here are using this to actually design aircraft components.

25

u/the_mgp Feb 04 '20

Hey man, some people actually are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvs3yvEcARA

Not me though. I print doohickies. And thingamajigs.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Kitsyfluff Feb 04 '20

I work at an experimental aircraft factory and do actually

But only for metal parts. We only use 3d printing for aesthetics.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/IAmBJ Feb 04 '20

That's not true.

FEA software can handle anisotropic materials just fine and I work with anisotropic materials all the time. Maybe not the specifics of FDM you mentioned (flowrate, cooling, etc), but all you really need to do to model the behavior of fdm parts is to have a different strength in the z axis.

Measurements exist for stiffness and failure stresses in fdm for X/Y and Z directions (I don't have them handy, I'm ok my phone) and coding the FEA is not really complicated, the only thing that changes is the stiffness matrix generation. Just because fusion360 doesn't currently do it doesn't mean it's not widely available elsewhere.

9

u/inu-no-policemen Feb 04 '20

all you really need to do to model the behavior of fdm parts is to have a different strength in the z axis.

You can vary the number of top layers, bottom layers, and walls/perimeters. There are various infill patterns with vastly different strengths and weaknesses. E.g. one of the selling points of gyroid is that it's fairly uniform. And you can of course also vary the infill ratio.

It's definitely more complicated than wood grain.

9

u/IAmBJ Feb 04 '20

Those are handled by regions of different densities. Could model the individual infill lines if you really wanted but it's simpler to just 'smear' the infill and pretend it's a region of constant density (that's lower than the solid areas) with anisotropic properties. This sort of approximation is extremely common in engineering.

Don't get me wrong, it's more complicated than modelling a part made from billet, but none of these issues are showstoppers and are unlikely to be the hardest part of a given simulation problem

→ More replies (1)

12

u/I_Forge_KC Feb 04 '20

Check out the work done by Teton Simulation. They are the core of the old Firehole Composites team (they all left Autodesk).

5

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Wouldn't this still give you an idea of how the forces will behave on a structure?

Seems a bit useful, at least for basic shapes.

4

u/mxzf Feb 04 '20

Yeah, it's still very useful, it's just worth bearing in mind that it's just a general idea rather than a perfect representation.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BamJr90 Feb 04 '20

This! Plus, I've yet to see clarifications on whether this kinda of optimization takes buckling into account or not (I suspect the latter, at least in Fusion 360). They usually seem to produce a lot of slender beam-like structures, which usually have a local buckling load quite lower than the material yeld load.

11

u/DaKakeIsALie Feb 05 '20

No, it is only looking at a pure downwards input. No torsion, or sideways forces considered either. The problem with using FEA at all is garbage in = garbage out. Removing material because it doesn't contribute to an input load case can be misleading, as unless that load case is very precisely calculated (and never deviates), the final geometry is just as unoptomized as the base shape.

This can be dangerous because you at least know the base shape is unoptimized, but the new model gives you false confidence.

9

u/ThompsonBoy Feb 04 '20

In this specific case, it's clearly not considering any kind of dynamic performance, or it would care about the middle screw anchor point. The generated part is just as stiff, but its only failure mode is spectacularly and completely.

9

u/BamJr90 Feb 04 '20

Thing is, buckling is not necessary related to dynamic loading (think of Euler buckling for beams under pure compression). I agree the resulting piece is likely just as stiff, but in many cases I suspect even while being so it's limit load is lower than expected since failure mode is buckling instead of pure material yeld as accounted by this kind of simulation

→ More replies (1)

15

u/DanielDC88 Feb 04 '20

This is correct

4

u/sanjibukai Feb 05 '20

Do you know if there are some kind of benchmarks (or stress tests) about the same exact piece tested four times: in a material where FEA is proven to be efficient (I guess like subtractive metal using milling etc.), for both the raw part and the optimized part, and then the same with a 3D printed part...

It might be interesting to see how the optimized part varies against the raw one relatively to the material (and the effectiveness of FEA for that material).

I hope I'm clear and this makes sense..

4

u/PaintballerCA Feb 05 '20

I'd imagine that orthotropic material properties could "work", but there's at least 2 factors that might be important:

  1. Polymers typically exhibit creep. If the part is expected to support a load for a "long" period of time, then the failure stress from a quasi-static tensile/compression test can be significantly higher than the failure stress for the use case.

  2. Residual stresses might be very important.

4

u/Loofie Feb 05 '20

Altair's OptiStruct now supports topology optimization for lattice structures that can only be created via 3D printing. https://altairhyperworks.com/solution/Additive-Manufacturing

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GreenFox1505 Feb 06 '20

If this is a huge concern for a part you need, you could print the part and then cast a mold for it. Cast resin would have much more consistent material properties.

2

u/pedantic_cheesewheel Feb 04 '20

That’s what a safety factor can be used for though. If this material removal was based on loads 2-3 times what it will actually experience then there should be no issue with using it this way.

→ More replies (14)

180

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

That doesn't take side deflection and torsion into account though, right?

30

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

That doesn't take side deflection and torsion into account though, right? So it's essentially a 2D model for the load calculation (like seen from the side)

I am no expert in this field. But the load calculation is done in 3D space. I am sure you can somehow also simulate side deflection and torsion

24

u/ModernSisyphus Feb 04 '20

A big part of design is creating constraints for other potential loading situations that would have a greater effect.

11

u/Waggles_ Feb 05 '20

A big part of design is also looking at the intended use case and designing for probability.

A house in Florida *could* be built to withstand a blizzard, but it's not because it's not a likely or intended use case for the house, and there is a very low probability of a blizzard in Florida.

→ More replies (1)

336

u/na3than Feb 04 '20

Or sharks

56

u/s1ckopsycho Feb 04 '20

Or the inevitable laser beams.

20

u/KnuckleKong Feb 04 '20

Or one of those strapped to the others freakin head

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/ender4171 Feb 04 '20

I think you have to add in the load vectors and "amounts" to run these calculations, so it would depend on what you put in for lateral loads (if anything).

→ More replies (1)

11

u/LABeav Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20

It depends if the cad simulation had those loads applied. It's up to the designer to set the constraints, loads, boundary conditions, etc. Typically engineers would freehand calc loads applied in each direction on the part or they'd come from other simulations or empirically through testing with instrumentation, load cells strain gauges, etc. You have to know what the load applied is and in which direction it's applied otherwise you might overload the part.

5

u/hellochase Feb 04 '20

It looks like it’s constrained to gravity only, but for a part like this using a rigid shelf connecting two or more brackets you would control those loads in typical use

5

u/thehero262 Feb 04 '20

When I had a play around with it, you could add forces against any face and change the angle and size of the force as well

5

u/hellochase Feb 04 '20

Right, I meant the example shown looks like it’s only calculating for gravity

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Or print direction/layers right?

2

u/starkiller_bass Feb 04 '20

It can only take into account the loads and constraints you apply to the analysis.

→ More replies (4)

67

u/PhilMeUp1 Feb 04 '20

Did Fusion360 change the model? Or did you based off of the load simulation?

34

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

You can generate a model based on the simulation.

Based on that model I improved the original one :)

4

u/Schlick7 Feb 04 '20

Did you happen to run the simulation on the new model?

64

u/ixoniq Feb 04 '20

Fusion 360 can alter the model automatically based on there the load will be.

→ More replies (3)

2.1k

u/kf4zht Feb 04 '20

This part of fusion I need to learn. If just for material savings

15

u/ThunderKicks Feb 04 '20

Yeah me too. Where do I do this in fusion ?

33

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

In the top left corner where you can select the Workspace (usually a big button saying "DESIGN") you can select "Simulation"

15

u/selflesslyselfish Feb 04 '20

Setting up the Sim is what I’d need assistance with lol

What material did you use for the settings?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)

558

u/ElderFormori Feb 04 '20

Was thinking the same thing and now I need to go find a tutorial on how to do some of this and may try to apply it to some of my current designs.

Might show issues or just reduce print time.

287

u/Roompje Feb 04 '20

I believe CNCKitchen or Thomas Sanladerer on youtube did a video about this exact thing

111

u/notinsanescientist Feb 04 '20

It was Thomas, with bookshelves.

51

u/hobbyhoarder Feb 04 '20

Stefan as well, well before Tom if I remember correctly.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/johnny_apples Feb 04 '20

3

u/sanjibukai Feb 05 '20

Worth it! Needs more subs though!

5

u/pug_nuts Feb 04 '20

You can do this yourself by just keeping the cross sectional area roughly constant across the length of the model (in the direction of bending you are concerned with).

4

u/Cptn_Awesome Feb 04 '20

Unless your doing this through additive, there really isn’t any material savings.

2

u/inspired_apathy Feb 05 '20

Only if the part is cast/molded. If machined, the material cost is the same.

→ More replies (26)

4

u/kutukutu1 Feb 04 '20

Very cool. Whats the part for? What material? Any specifics to put into fusion for material property to more accurately represent a 3D printed model? Account for later adhesion, print direction, etc.

7

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

The part is for mounting a peg board (one holder left, one right).
Although I printed the part in PLA I used ABS in Fusion 360 because it was already available.

Sadly I don't know about any option that takes later adhesion in account :/

9

u/DanielDC88 Feb 04 '20

This assumes the model is a homogenous material, which a 3D print is not. I don’t think this method is particularly accurate unless you use very high infill.

5

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

You are right. This can be a useful tool but the limitations for 3D printing have to be taken into account.

For this part (printed laying on the back) I did not notice any differences in functionality. Both the original and optimized part (printed with 20% gyroid infill, 3 perimeters) were able to hold 10 kg. This is much more than required for the part.

→ More replies (1)

426

u/Glurak Feb 04 '20

Just a quick note to anyone going to use it: It may produce worse results if used without thinking.

Like, you think it will save you material to drill a small hole in your model? Think again, the original print wasn't solid, the new walls of that hole may add more material, then you substracted! And more printtime and model difficulty increasing chance of print failure.

88

u/WellEndowedWizard Feb 04 '20

Yep, plus now you have to print it in a specific orientation where the load will be pulling layers apart in use.

Edit: maybe not in this case but with other parts

43

u/TheBlacktom Feb 04 '20

3D printed weight is not simply a function of volume, but also surface area.
More specifically it's also the function of those few hundred numbers you set in the slicer and the filament material :)

15

u/mxzf Feb 05 '20

It also depends a lot on perimeter, in addition to area, because of how much material perimeters add compared to infill.

36

u/skinnedpineapple Nov 01 '21

Why did I see among us on the bottom one. Help. Me.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '21

among

when the imposter is sus

20

u/hillna Feb 04 '20

Is anyone familiar with a Linux application (preferably FOSS) that can handle this kind of work?

14

u/Dogeek Feb 04 '20

I think FreeCAD can do it, if you use this library with it : https://github.com/fandaL/beso

I've never tried it though, I went back to Windows + Solidworks before I really got into 3D printing.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/DarthElevator Feb 04 '20

8

u/Chemmy Feb 04 '20

ANSYS is like $30k plus a recurring annual maintenance fee.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/skmagiik Feb 04 '20

Following... I wish I knew some analysis tools

3

u/mxzf Feb 05 '20

I use FreeCAD for my CAD stuff. I suspect it can probably do this kind of analysis, it's fairly fully featured, but I'm not experienced enough with it to know where exactly to look.

→ More replies (7)

48

u/Ikarian Feb 04 '20

This almost makes me want to go back to Fusion, despite cursing it non stop every time I'd use it. Does Solidworks have an analysis feature like this?

23

u/koopaduo Feb 04 '20

Yes they have structural, CFD, electrical and some other sim tools. Though I never used em

18

u/Charlie2k00 Feb 04 '20

Yes, it's Topology Optimization

5

u/damn_jexy Feb 04 '20

..... Im still using tinkercad

→ More replies (5)

2

u/cooka1067 Feb 04 '20

Yes. It's called topology optimization.

6

u/OwenTheTyley Feb 04 '20

Technically speaking, Solidworks' topology optimisation is a slightly different process to generative design in F360 - generative design takes into account the manufacturing process (not necessarily additive - it can also deal with 3-axis milling) to ensure all designs generated are manufacturable.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Syscrush Feb 04 '20

This is super cool. I would like to see the load calcs on the optimized model, too. Is there any risk that the new shape would introduce problematic stress risers?

That middle screw hole is like "OK, I think you guys can handle this without me - I'm just gonna jet."

2

u/bnelson333 Feb 05 '20

That's what I was thinking, but no absolutely zero about any of this (just here via /all). It seems like in the first model, a third of the stress is being taken in by the middle bolt (again, I'm not an engineer). Shouldn't the original model/simulation have been done without a middle hole?

8

u/Jacobcbab Nov 01 '21

When the optimized model is sus

3

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '22

Top kek

7

u/Ottawa_Railway_Fan Jul 17 '22

Don’t say it

7

u/Chespln Jul 17 '22

among us has ruined my life

6

u/OoglieBooglie93 Feb 05 '20

I'd like to see the simulation of the optimized model in the end too.

6

u/YusiP Nov 11 '21

AMOGUS

6

u/HoaiBao0906 Nov 12 '21

GETOUTOFMYHEAD

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '21

amogus

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '21

Amogus

4

u/nopantspaul Feb 05 '20

If this particular bracket is going to be statically loaded for 100% of its life, then this is fine.

This "optimization" reduced the stiffness in the major and minor axes tremendously. If those get loaded at all during service, the part could fail. Also, I'm having a tough time understanding why such a small region was removed near the eyelet- couldn't a very small amount of material been left as a strut between the upper and lower members, and then repurposed to stiffen the part against other loads?

4

u/tcdoey Feb 05 '20

Please note that this is not real.

Clearly there is load applied in a very simple fashion.

For example, if this were to have loads applied horizontally (let's figure that's the Y axis) then the resulting 'optimized' model is very weak. And what happened to the middle bolt-hole?

Generative Design is great stuff and extremely interesting, but you have to be very careful about how you apply this type of technology.

1

u/chubbyzook Feb 04 '20

Did this actually reduce print time? I ask because you have added more walls which usually print much slower than just infill.

5

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

Did this actually reduce print time? I ask because you have added more walls which usually print much slower than just infill.

Yeah it did! I printed both with 20% gyroid infill and 3 perimeters laying on the back. The original took about 3 hours while the optimized one was done in under 2 hours.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/x_Carlos_Danger_x Feb 04 '20

Does fusion actually do the optimization for 3d printed parts? Or is the optimization done for a metal or common material?

4

u/dotCookie Feb 04 '20

I did it for solid ABS. As mentioned in many other comments the information value for 3D printing is only limited.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

I love this! Did you rerun the analysis after the redesign? I'm wondering 1) how one less bolt hole in the redesign affected the shear at the base and 2) how much torsion strength applied to the original design and how it has changed.

3

u/MontaNelas1945 Feb 04 '20

Isn't this possible to do in Solidworks ?! I think that I learned this back in college but I dont remember it anymore

4

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

If you have Simulation then yes, there is topology optimization.

3

u/t3rm3y Feb 04 '20

What about that middle screw point? Surely that carried some load which affects the calculations?

3

u/Schlick7 Feb 04 '20

It actually probably didn't carry any load or at least very little. The biggest issue this might have is the removal of the back bar that was touching the wall. Especially considering it will be 3d printed

→ More replies (1)

3

u/trowayit Feb 04 '20

Check out PTC Creo's new capabilities in this area. It automatically constructs the most material-efficient design based on constraints using machine learning and you can specify it's for a 3dp. It's super cool. It's saved companies like Volvo huge chunks of money while improving their products. Yes I'm an employee but I don't work on Creo. And yes Creo's expensive, but for production, it can save you money on this type of stuff.

3

u/TimX24968B Feb 05 '20

but solidworks does this too and its actually not (nearly as much of) a pain in the ass to learn and use.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Horsecowsheep Feb 05 '20

Now the load diagram based on the cut out one?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

And then run the test after you cut it up.. It does change how it reacts after hacking all that material out despite the initial load distribution

3

u/PaintballerCA Feb 05 '20

Looks great. Other's have made some great points, so hopefully I don't repeat too many.

  1. Consider other loading conditions. If your load is only downwards, then this is a good start. Run (if you haven't already) the optimized shape. If a lateral load is possible, then this might not be the best approach.

  2. Check for mesh convergence (if you haven't). I'm not sure what diagnostics tools Fusion has, but generally speaking make sure your strain energy converges, then focus on your stresses. Elements nears constraints and point loads are likely to have singularity (the stresses will continue to rise as you refine your mesh). Keep this in mind when evaluating your results.

  3. The material properties might be direction dependent (orthotropic means that it varies in all three directions).

  4. The material might also be different in tension compared to compression.

  5. I assume the material is a polymer, which typically exhibit creep (i.e. the material will continue to deform over time while under load). If so, then it's "failure" stress can be significantly lower than what you'd get off of something like matweb (they will likely give quasi-static failure stresses).

  6. I know that, at least for SLM AM, residual stresses from the build process can be significant and important to consider. Not sure on the plastics side.

3

u/Bearguchev Feb 05 '20

Assuming this is used in pairs to hold something like a roll of paper or a shelf, does the simulation shown account for that load too when optimizing the part? If not, is it possible to run a simulation on multiple parts like that? I’m brand new to this stuff and I work on people not material so eli5 please.

3

u/-_Clay_- Jan 13 '22

DONT YOU FUCKING SAY IT

3

u/JordanIII Feb 17 '22

Don't say it don't think it

3

u/Spiritual_Race_1874 Feb 21 '22

Optimized into Amogus

2

u/NicroHobak Feb 04 '20

Does Blender happen to have any way to achieve something like this? Possibly an add-on somewhere or lesser-known use for another feature?... I'm assuming not, but this seems helpful enough that I figured I'd ask anyway.

7

u/justacec Feb 04 '20

You might want to check out Freecad

→ More replies (1)

2

u/time_fo_that Feb 04 '20

Can't wait to get into topological optimization! My company doesn't do anything cool like this.

2

u/Black--Snow Feb 04 '20

That’s how these designs are calculated! Holy shit TIL. That’s so cool

2

u/stug45 Feb 04 '20

Read about triangles

2

u/Nebakanezzer Feb 04 '20

what happens when you run the optimized design through?

i wonder if it would show more red areas now that the other areas are not there to support it. just because something isn't baring the stress directly, doesn't mean it isn't supporting the pieces that are with rigidity.

2

u/sanjibukai Feb 05 '20

Now I need someone to test both version and actually see it for real!

Please!

2

u/MundaneDivide Feb 05 '20

This isn't a dynamic model though. Does the stress change based on movement? What about shifting the weight on it? You might find some of those deleted sections have a significant reason to exist.

Also, what about in the case of failure? Do the deleted sections take up the weight in some capacity? Does deleting them lead to a total and instant catastrophic failure?

2

u/rw3iss Feb 05 '20

Forgive my ignorance, but does 360 re-topo the mesh for you, or just show you where you should edit and you do the work?

2

u/I_Forge_KC Feb 05 '20

If using the topology optimization then you get a nasty jagged mesh out of it.

If you use generative design, you get a smooth BRep.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/codylilley Feb 05 '20

Is there a subreddit for that kind of stress simulation?

2

u/I_Forge_KC Feb 05 '20

There is a generative design sub but no one is active (much to my sadness).

2

u/IAmSpadeAndIDoStuff Feb 05 '20

Reducing the plastic consumption through the use of better technology. Good job.

2

u/EndlessEden2015 Feb 05 '20

Except from a practical engineering standpoint, you have lost all that rigidity and changed your stress points.

The top, near the hinge is now supporting 78% of the mass of what ever object it's connected to.

Using three in a typical door hinge design, maximising the potential mass distribution still puts about 40-60% of the mass on the top hinge, due to its design not incorporating any form of material for stress relief. Tension applied is never as linear as predicted by these models. Twisting tension isn't considered once most of the material is removed at all and predictability relies on expected characteristics of material that doesn't take into account it's bio-degradability potentially effecting the later adhesion when exposed to moisture or heat.

2

u/tallest_chris Feb 05 '20

Did you run a new fea after making the new model?

2

u/pk-branded Feb 05 '20

I used to do these calculations by hand in 1988. Then programming in Fortran using finite element analysis on a Cyber Supercomputer by 1990.

2

u/i_love_piracy Nov 11 '21

When the pain is immeasurable

2

u/ItsDavidz Nov 12 '21

rotate the image 90 degrees counter clockwise for a surprise

2

u/Thorgraum Apr 14 '22

No, this is fucked up, they only simulated force applied in one axis, any torque and that shit aint worth anything. You need to know how to use the tools you have, or youre better off with the original

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NoLuBr Jul 11 '24

Too bad fusion made this a paid feature (I wish whoever made this decision stubs their toe, and whenever it almost heals, they stub it again for eternity)

2

u/BlasterTheBurro Feb 04 '20

What about the load in the center(on the left)?

2

u/Chennessee Feb 04 '20

You mean the center fasteners? I was wondering the same. It seems to carry at least some load and with that removed, I would think that load would get transferred somewhere else.

I don’t know why you got downvoted?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/zeta3d Feb 04 '20

If you use an student account you can access the Generative Design module.

You can define forces, select material, technology that will produce it and get multiple solutions (with weight, cost, properties,...) that are calculated in the cloud. You can even modify the result

2

u/IAmDotorg Feb 04 '20

Have they added support for materials with asymmetric strength profiles? The problem, last time I looked at F360, was that you couldn't do that, so the "optimization" was really a cosmetic thing, and the actual calculations didn't mean anything. (Because 3D prints have different strength and deflection profiles in X/Y vs Z)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Does it do this optimization automatically?

1

u/beemandan Feb 04 '20

Very nice, similar thing can be done in solid works as well but I haven’t applied it to my 3D printing yet. Looks like I can save some filament as well.

1

u/Gordomperdomper Feb 04 '20

Easy way to do this in onshape?

1

u/Kenblu24 Feb 04 '20

I tried this for a bed plate (The piece under the bed that connects it to the rails) in Inventor and it didn't really work.

1

u/justnoise4fun Feb 04 '20

Love this...

1

u/Lasse_landmand Feb 04 '20

Is solidworks 2020 able to do the same? I am asking because i have acces to a license from my school

2

u/TimX24968B Feb 05 '20

yes. topology optimization in their simulation add-in.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Dear god I just found out about this sub... and I’m addicted already.

I never knew this existed!

1

u/Santibag Feb 04 '20

The middle hole appeared to have no effect and removed. But I guess it had at least a redundancy purpose. So I'm not sure if it's good you remove it.

And if the part is not rigid, the middle hole may have load when the part is deformed.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Is this kind of simulation also possible in Autocad?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/the_opester Feb 04 '20

I’ve been trying to do a mass reduction without stiffness loss too.

1

u/krevdditn Feb 04 '20

three screws still better than 2 though

1

u/ibj2theB Feb 04 '20

That is spiffy. Thanks for sharing

1

u/javiermex Feb 05 '20

What about the middle screw? So less screws but same strength?

1

u/nemohearttaco Feb 05 '20

It's beautiful.

1

u/stinkycheese010 Feb 05 '20

This is so cool

1

u/Neo1331 Feb 05 '20

Yeah except the first one is cheaper and easier to make....bit still awesome feature!

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Ahh yes! Thanks for showing everyone here what is actually good practice. I see far too many "functional prints" here that comprise of 70% unnecessary material.

Good stuff!

1

u/Norse_By_North_West Feb 05 '20

Jebus, how heavy is your toilet paper?!

1

u/atmsk90 Feb 05 '20

One of the things I love about structural optimization is that 99% of the time the optimizer spits out something that looks an awful lot like a truss.

1

u/BobTheAstronaut Feb 05 '20

You can't do this type of stuff with the hobbyist license anymore, can you? Mine keeps saying that I don't have enough cloud credits.

1

u/Pistolero921 Feb 05 '20

Should’ve kept the third hole

1

u/GaySpaceCommunist420 Feb 05 '20

Is this the same thing as finite element analysis?

1

u/I_Forge_KC Feb 05 '20

Hey OP, would you be open to a collaboration? I'd love to run this through Generative for you with some secret sauce.

1

u/cubanjew Feb 05 '20

Is this functionality included with the hobbyist free subscription?

1

u/67mustangguy Feb 05 '20

Is the fea included in the hobbyists/ free 360?

1

u/Odatas Feb 05 '20

With what kind of load was this simulated?

1

u/svermaak Feb 05 '20

What about middle bolt? Won't calculations be wrong without it?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Then if you put that model through ParaMatter CogniCAD...

1

u/Ghost_Assassin_Zero Feb 05 '20

Optimization... Amazing!

1

u/Ryuuken24 Feb 05 '20

This can't be right, the fail points have less material, steel will do fine, some plastics won't stand too much weight.

1

u/Insults_In_A_Bottle Feb 05 '20

That's so Bauhaus, I'm currently ejaculating squares, circles and triangles.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

!remindMe 8 hours

1

u/Firewolf420 Feb 05 '20

Fusion is pretty fucking amazing

1

u/S00rabh Feb 05 '20

I don't think that particular model would have any benefit in printing time. I see a lot of support in any orientation.

But mass is definably reduced.

1

u/evilspyboy Feb 05 '20

I just did this on one of my models before uploading it to thingiverse because of this post. I didn't take away though more added for strain but I wouldn't have tried to figure it out without this post

1

u/Patricx5 Feb 05 '20

I did this to optimise a 3D printed drone frame. It doesn't use the load values to calculate how much it can reduce, but rather looks at the stress concentrations in the part and removes the material with less than 10% of the maximum stress (or whatever percentage you set it to). Often you can remove 90% of the material while decreasing the strength by 10%. However it will not show you if the part will fail

1

u/AddictedRedditorGuy Feb 22 '20

Saves 50% material and a few minutes of printing. Costs hours of prepping fea, running fea, remodeling, re slicing.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/numbski Apr 07 '24

I installed Fusion a few days ago to use a part generator, and the experience was incredibly off-putting. Like, register to get a registration link to download a downloader that installs the software, all while mining you for every piece of personal information they can get.

One the one hand, it may be super powerful stuff, but on the other the first 15 minutes is all invasive. Kinda hate it.

1

u/bigwalsh55 Oct 22 '21

Can you do something similar using Solidworks?

1

u/Flares19 Dec 03 '21

How is the load being applied and in which direction?

1

u/Thorgraum Dec 08 '21

Yup, this technology goes hand in hand with both CNC and 3d printing. Funny to see how computers are MUCH better than humans at making organic looking designs. Cool stuff bud

1

u/NateGreat1000 Dec 18 '21

I think you should still have 3 holes or beef up the top wall mount location because there was definitely stress concentration on the middle one which you removed.

1

u/reinraus00 Dec 21 '21

Fantastic!

1

u/LuppyLuptonium Apr 14 '22

Looking at this and the comments am I literally the only person who spots this print has no way to attach to a wall anymore making it no longer functional?

1

u/RicePrestigious Apr 18 '22

As others have mentioned, there’s a few things I’d change:

  • Align the mounting holes with the centre line of the material.

  • Leave a flat strip connecting the two mounting points. A cut out with radii in the corners or just a straight circle would remove a lot of material and retain rigidity.

  • if you’re printing this on FDM you’ll need to account for weakness between layer lines in any orientation that you chose to print it, the FEA will assume whatever material you’ve told it you’re using and likely not be accounting for the quirks of FDM manufacturing.

→ More replies (1)