r/fea • u/oskiflesh • Apr 23 '26
Finite Elephant Method
Tried out ChatGPTs new image generation model
r/fea • u/oskiflesh • Apr 23 '26
Tried out ChatGPTs new image generation model
r/fea • u/fsfarimani • 19d ago
Hi all,
I've been building a desktop front end for Elmer, the open-source multiphysics FEM solver from CSC. Elmer is very capable, but setting up a case still means writing .sif files by hand or using ElmerGUI, which is showing its age. I wanted the workflow I knew from COMSOL: a model tree, settings windows, parameters with units, and results you can explore without exporting to ParaView first.
What it does today:
Geometry (gmsh/OpenCASCADE): primitives, work planes, extrude/revolve, booleans, fillets, STEP/IGES import
Mesh: gmsh, or ElmerGrid for structured block layouts; size controls, mapped meshes, 2D boundary layers
Physics: heat transfer, solid mechanics (static, transient, eigenfrequency, frequency response with Rayleigh damping), electrostatics, electric currents, 2D magnetic fields, laminar flow, pressure acoustics, diluted species transport, secondary/tertiary current distribution, coefficient-form PDE. Couplings for Joule heating, thermal expansion and non-isothermal flow
Studies: stationary, time dependent, eigenfrequency, frequency domain, parametric sweeps
Results: surface/slice/isosurface/streamline/arrow plots, line graphs, integrals and averages, probes that update while a transient runs, GIF animation, CSV/VTU export
A Python scripting API under the GUI, and you can always look at or export the .sif it generates
An optional OpenFOAM backend for laminar flow and conduction on simple block geometries
Each physics interface is checked against closed-form solutions in the test suite (Poiseuille flow, Lamé's rotating disc, Newman's disc electrode, a rod driven through its first resonance, and more). CI runs on all three platforms.
Elmer itself isn't bundled; the docs explain how to install it on each platform.
Not there yet: 3D magnetics, turbulence, contact, adaptive meshing, and plenty of smaller things. The docs have a known-limitations page so you know before you try.
Where I'd love help:
Try it on a problem you know the answer to, and tell me where it's wrong or awkward
Open issues for bugs, crashes or features you actually need
PRs are very welcome: new physics features, packaging, tutorials, docs
The best place to start is the documentation (installation, quick start, tutorials, full settings reference): https://altelmer.github.io/ElmerStudio/
Source and issue tracker: https://github.com/AltElmer/ElmerStudio
It's an independent project, not affiliated with COMSOL.
Hello, I am trying to do simple static linear torsion of bicycle hub due to braking and I am not sure how to interpret these stress concentrations next to the brake bolt holes at the flange. Should I ignore it, do stress linearization, apply stress concentration factor or read 3-5 elements from the spot? Spoke holes inner surfaces are connected with RBE2 to reference point and fixed. Brake bolt holes are connected with RBE3 to reference point and moment is applied to this point. I am using PrePoMax (CalculiX solver). Thank you all.
r/fea • u/pieindaface • Jan 26 '20
r/fea
•
u/Ocean33r
•
Jun 02 '26
I work in structural analysis and kept running into the same situation, where I had a screenshot of an old result in a report, powerpoint, or just an email but no access to the original model file or output results. I built this tool to help with getting real data from just the screenshots of FEA contour plots. Give it a try on your workflows, I've even found it super useful for just doing quick checks on non-conformances without having to load the whole model.
What's your current workaround when you only have the screenshot?
r/fea • u/Sorry_Foundation_272 • Jun 16 '25
Will these kind of stress will be considered or will ignore this? These stresses are over the weld region.
r/fea • u/UnpopularMechanics • Jan 29 '20
r/fea • u/Spr_Alex • Feb 16 '22
r/fea • u/imitation_squash_pro • Jan 10 '26
Three that come to mind:
Not understanding in linear static analysis the results are directly proportional to the forces. Double the force = double the stress. Had a manger once ask me to re-run a simulation with more load and didn't understand the results just scale.
Inability to recognize small numbers as basically same as zero. Had a PhD coworker present results comparing two FEA packages. He said one package was off by 50% . But the numbers he was comparing were like 1e-7 and 2e-8 ! Basically zero!
Not understanding that iterative solvers like for Abaqus Explicit or CFD you do not have to run the entire simulation to benchmark performance. You can run for something like 10 or 100 iterations and compare solution times. Had a coworker who insisted on running the full blown 100,000 iteration model to completion to benchmark performance vs. # of cpus.
r/fea • u/_deez_nuts_69 • Jul 25 '25
Hi Guys, how can I compute an average value for the axial load within any of the brace members. They are modeled as S4R elements.
r/fea • u/Toobrish • Sep 25 '25
I’m designing a reclining office chair. The backrest is fixed to the seat with an 8 mm carbon-steel bracket. To check strength I ran FEA in Fusion:
Load: 500 N·m moment (100 kg leaning back at 0.5 m).
One end fixed, moment at the other.
Result: FoS = 0.079 (!).
That feels way off.
Questions:
Is 500 N·m a realistic backrest load?
Any Fusion gotchas that make FoS look absurd?
Thanks!
Heyho to all FE enthusiasts!
I’m a mechanical engineering graduate from RWTH Aachen University and have also worked as a software developer alongside my studies. During the last two years, I dived deep into the world of Finite Element Analysis, especially for structural mechanics, which ultimately led me to develop my own FEM solver. Today, I’m excited to share my project with you all!
Open Source: Free to use and modify.
Syntax Similarity: Familiar syntax for elements, nodes, sets, and surfaces, inspired by Abaqus.
Solid Elements Only: Supports C3D4/5/6/8/10/15/20/20R elements.
Linear Load Cases: Focus on linear static, linear static topology optimization, and linear frequency analysis.
Custom Coordinate Systems: Support for various coordinate system definitions.
Constraint Types: Includes Kinematic Coupling, Tie Constraints, and Connector Elements.
Visualization: Compatible with ParaView for visualization.
Multithreading Support: Efficient handling of multiple cores for parallel computations.
I used it at my institute to simulate systems with >5 Million DOFs in less than 10 minutes which I consider to be very solid. Running the solver, after having it compiled is as simple as:
./bin/FEMaster.exe path/to/file.inp --ncpus 4
Running my solver on an .inp will yield a .res. Using the tovtk.py python script which is also present in the project, one can visualise the .res files in vtk:
python -m python.solution.tovtk path/to/inp
I’d love to hear your thoughts on the project and would greatly appreciate any feedback or suggestions! Feel free to check out the repository, try it out, and let me know what you think!
P.S. I’ve also put together some slides that I presented at my institute. I’ll share them here as well:


r/fea • u/_spolanski_ • Jun 27 '24