r/asklinguistics • • 2h ago

Phonology Why is the Swedish sj-ljudet given its own letter in the IPA?

12 Upvotes

The IPA letter <ɧ> refers to the Swedish sj-ljudet, often realized as [xʷ], which contrasts with /ɕ/ (phonetically [ç]. Why does it have a distinct letter in the IPA if it doesn’t have a real distinct value? Does it have to do with the old phonetic alphabets used for Scandinavian languages?

Wikipedia describes the sound as either [ʃ͜x], [ç͡x], [w̥], [fˠʷ], or [x̟].


r/asklinguistics • • 9h ago

I am having trouble understanding what form copy and lower copy is in syntax

2 Upvotes

I came across this interesting paper about scrambling in japanese, but I just dont understand what form copy, lower copy, and the copy relationship is. It would be great if someone could give me places where i can learn more about these or explain these terms and phenomena


r/asklinguistics • • 12h ago

semitic-languages.

0 Upvotes

Title: Is this Semitic-like root-and-pattern linguistic description attested in any known language? I have a linguistic and morphological description of a language system that uses root-and-pattern morphology, tense/aspect prefixes, and multiple definiteness markers, and I would like to know whether this corresponds to an attested natural language

Linguistic and Morphological Description 1. Letters - The system consists of a set of letters, each with a specific sound. - Some letters perform morphological functions when added to roots. - There are letters that serve as components within words, while others function as independent particles. 2. Roots and Their Meanings Quadriliteral (Four-Consonant) Sound Roots Root | Meaning in Arabic z-l-z-l | z-l-z-l (to shake/quake) ḍ-ḥ-r-k | to roll b-‘-t-r | to scatter ṭ-m-’-n | to reassure/calm sh-‘-s-‘ | to spread/diffuse t-j-w-m | to translate ḥ-s-ḥ-s | to become clear/manifest k-r-k-r | to gurgle/chuckle s-m-s-m | to sprinkle/scatter q-r-k-b | to rumble/clatter Quadriliteral (Four-Consonant) Weak Roots Root | Meaning in Arabic w-s-w-s | to whisper y-m-m-m | to favor/bestow a blessing sh-w-w-sh | to disturb/confuse n-w-w-r | to illuminate h-w-w-d | to guide/return l-y-y-n | to soften w-‘-‘-r | to be rugged/difficult y-b-y-s | to dry out q-w-l-l | to speak/say b-y-m-m | to clarify/distinguish Triliteral (Three-Consonant) Weak Roots Root | Meaning in Arabic w-ṣ-l | to arrive/connect w-f-f | to stop/stand y-m-sh | to dry out q-w-q-l | to speak/say b-y-‘ | to sell sh-y-r | to move/proceed m-sh-w | to walk b-n-n | to build d-‘-y | to call/invite r-’-a | to see d-‘-w | to call/invite

Verb Conjugation - Past Tense: Add "k" to the beginning of the root. - Present Tense: Add "y" to the beginning of the root. - Future Tense: Add "s" to the present tense form. - Imperative: A form beginning with "alif," following a specific rule. Example: - Khlgh: The root. - Khlgh (with "k" prefix): Created (past tense). 4. Morphological Patterns (Wazn) Root Type | Active Participle | Passive Participle | Noun of Place Sound Triliteral | Fa‘‘āl | Maf‘ūl | Maf‘al Weak Triliteral | Fa‘ūl | Buf‘al | Mafa‘l Augmented Sound | — | Muf‘al | — Augmented Weak | Fa‘ūlil | Buf‘ūlil | — 5. Adjectives Adjective | Meaning in Arabic Saghur | Small Kabur | Large/Big Jamil | Beautiful Qabuh | Ugly Daki | Intelligent Ghabu | Stupid 6. Conjunctions - Wa (and) - Fa (so/then) - Tuwam (then/afterwards) - Ayu (or)

Definite Articles - a: A compound definite article associated with sacred entities. - l: A particle denoting exaltation or reverence. - am: The default definite article, used for general definiteness. 8. Selected Nouns - ʾ-s-m (Name) - ʾ-r-d (Spirit/Essence) - m-y-ʾ-h (Water) - n-b-y-ʾ (Prophet) - f-y-ʾ-r (Fire/Flame) - h-w-ʾ-r (Air/Wind) - m-ʿ-d-n (Metal/Mineral) - n-w-r (Light) - q-l-b (Heart) - y-d (Hand) - r-ʾ-š (Head) - w-ǧ-h (Face) - q-d-m (Foot) - š-ʾ-q-ʾ (leg) - k-m-w-l (camel) - ʾ-k-t-š (writer) - k-t-ʾ-š (book)


r/asklinguistics • • 14h ago

Orthography Was the polish letter Ą borrowed from the cyrilic Ѧ?

14 Upvotes

According to wikipedia, [here] there is a hypothesis that this letter was borrowed from the old church slavonic script, because it looked like an A with a third leg, and so scribes turned it into an A with a little tail in the latin alphabet, because they needed a way to write nasal vowels. If this is true, I find it INSANE, like this one letter in the polish alphabet is actually secretly cyrilic, that is soooo cool and I will tell that fact to everyone I meet for the rest of my life I love facts like this.

but idk if it's true. Can anyone confirm if this theory is widely believed and if it holds any water? Wikipedia only cites one source, which is some random article that doesn't give further sources, but it seems to be written by a historian


r/asklinguistics • • 14h ago

Morphology What determines the "dummy syllable" used for Mandarin's bisyllabic nouns (e.g. 豹子 vs 老虎). Are there any general rules of thumb?

8 Upvotes

I guess two questions:

  1. For nouns like this (e.g. 叉子), do linguists consider the underlying form considered as 叉 (+ a suffix 子 that has some grammatical function) or is the underlying form 叉子 (and the second syllable 子 is dropped in certain constructions).

  2. Are there any general trends on why certain prefixes/suffixes were chosen? For example, why do some animals get 老 (e.g. 老虎, 老鼠) others get 子 (e.g. 豹子, 狮子), and some no suffix at all (e.g. 虾, 猪). Why is "country" 国家 instead of something like 国子. Where did the 家 come from?


r/asklinguistics • • 15h ago

General Do accents become more pronounced as we age?

10 Upvotes

I’m from the southern US, where we have a strong pen-pin merger, among other idiosyncrasies.

For example, my mom says “warsh”, for “wash”, “fliers” for “flowers”, “ser-dee” for “Saturday” and “ung-yins” for onions.

Growing up I would always be asked where I was from because I didn’t have a local accent, people thought I was from “up north” like Ohio or something.

My friends don’t really have strong accents either and my personal theory is that because we grew up on more global media, that we don’t have a stronger accent, and the fact that we all moved away from home after college. When I go back home, everyone has such a pronounced accent, and grammar, it’s so fascinating.

But as I’ve gotten older, into my mid 30s, I’m noticing my southern accent is becoming more pronounced, especially the pen-pin merger, despite living in the western USA, and I’m wondering if this is something that can happen with age, and outside of consistent exposure to an accent as i haven’t been back home very much.

Even my wife says she’s noticing it more and more, and she (lovingly) makes fun of me everytime I let it slip lol.


r/asklinguistics • • 16h ago

Dialectology Is [oˈkɛɪ] instead of [ˌoʊˈkeɪ] a Southern feature?

0 Upvotes

Mia from Resident Evil 7 (Louisiana) pronounces it as [oˈkɛɪ], and so does a certain Youtube channel i know from Florida


r/asklinguistics • • 16h ago

Is there a field of metalinguistics that evaluates the development of language and and their common evolution?

5 Upvotes

I’m having some trouble finding something like a book.

Somehow, in under 200,000 years we moved from grunt or shriek noises into actual language that is breathtakingly efficient and effective. We communicate very complex stuff at like a few bytes per second at most.

Somehow we got started. And along the way languages fell into common patterns. For example, we know about how many sounds a human can make, but how we focus on on the minority in our own language and can’t form the others as an adult - giving us accents. Similarly, the idea of marking things with endings. In European languages, the case system can avoid many uses of propositions. In German, “mir” in the dative marks indirect objects clearly.

What is the study of that field called, and what are some good resources?


r/asklinguistics • • 18h ago

Historical What currently spoken language diverged from all others the longest time ago?

13 Upvotes

Is there a way to tell this, and if so, im curious as to what language and how we know.


r/asklinguistics • • 21h ago

Lexicography Questions on lose/loose spellings

1 Upvotes

(Hope lexicography is the right flair for this)

Some I have:

Are the spellings merges or swaps? As in are people using “loose” for both cases (They loose the game, the screw is loose), or are they swapping the cases (They loose the game, the screw is lose)? What does data show for this at the moment?

Any theories on what could lead to it? My theory is that because of allophonic vowel lengthening, ([lus] vs [lu:z]) people feel that there is a longer sound to the word “lose” so they feel that the spelling should have more vowels. Wonder what other theories have been formulated.

Last question: Is this a recent development, or was I just out of the loop. I don’t think lose/loose confusion was talked about when I was in school, at least to the same level as affect/effect, there/their etc. Is it because it’s new and started happening only after I finished elementary school, or was I just out of the loop?


r/asklinguistics • • 21h ago

The words for dependence

4 Upvotes

I came across these examples from different languages

to depend (English) - abhängen (German) - зависеть (Russian)

They don't share a root, but share an idea of a thing hanging down. This fact fascinates me. How come people across the world came to the same not so obvious figure of speech for idea of dependence? Did they borrow it from each other? Why not invent something original?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

General Why is there so much public surprise and misconception around how the ancient Egyptian language actually worked

55 Upvotes

Despite the massive progress of modern Egyptological philology and contemporary linguistics, there is still widespread public ignorance regarding ancient Egyptian as a functional language.

Most people still view hieroglyphs as mystical picture-puzzles and are completely surprised to learn we have reconstructed pronunciations and a solid grasp of its spoken grammar.

Not to mention modern Egyptological conventions being mistaken as historical pronunciation.


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Phonetics How do I know the distribution of each consonants?

1 Upvotes

Pls answer me if u know,because I tried to look up through the internet and books yet I find so little about the sounds distribution


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Historical Why does English use Germanic words for some bones instead of Latin?

0 Upvotes

According to etymonline:

  • "rib" comes from PGermanic *rebjan

  • "tooth" comes from PGermanic *tanthu-

  • "shin" comes from PGermanic *skino

  • "skull" comes from (probably) Old Norse *skalli

Why not use the Latin for these?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

General Is English syntax no longer West Germanic?

11 Upvotes

The do support, loss of V2 and SOV, shift to almost exclusively SVO, loaning "are" from Norse, it seems like the closest languages to English in syntax are either North Germanic languages or French, due to the shift to SVO. Even Frisian has very similar syntax to German and Dutch rather than English when V2 causes SOV sentences in those languages (doesn't appear to in North Germanic though), so English seems the outlier here in terms of West Germanic languages. Preposition stranding as well.


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

What is the earliest evidence we have of the Cockney dialect?

13 Upvotes

This is something that has interested me and puzzled me. I'm aware of the various discussions of how the "RP" accent did not exist in the past - These often overlap with discussions of what Shakespearean English sounded like. Incidentally, attempts to recreate Original Pronunciation seem to generally be West Country or some kind of Irish accent.

But I was curious about where the Cockney accent played into this.

In the Elizabethan comedy Eastward Ho, the upwardly mobile London merchant's daughter Gertrude refers several times to the "Bow Bell", including using that term as an insult towards her sister. I know proverbially, a "Cockney" is said to be born within the sound of the bells of St Mary-le-Bow.

Does that mean that Gertrude and her family (and their real life counterparts) would have had a Cockney accent and paradoxically talked more like contemporary English people than other Elizabethans?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Historical Did aspiration in Old Irish trigger gemination?

5 Upvotes

The epenthesis of /h-/ to vowel-initial words is often described as causing gemination in a following consonant-initial word, but is there any reason to believe it's not just a spelling device to indicate the following initial consonant isn't lenited?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Historical My questions about proto-indo european and what it is surrounded by

16 Upvotes

It's my first time on this sub reddit and I have a few questions about, like Said in the title, the proto-indo european language and what it surrounded by, and by "what it is surrounded by" I mean:

  1. Is it the oldest language we know of? If not, which one is the oldest?

  2. Is it even a language? (or just a collection of languages?)

  3. How did it look like?

  4. Where was it spoken and who spoke it?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

LOGOS Master's at Université Paris Cité

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm considering applying to the LOGOS Master's (Philosophy, Linguistics, Logic and Computer Science) at Université Paris Cité for September 2027, and I'd appreciate some advice from anyone familiar with the programme or computational linguistics in general.

My academic background is in modern languages, followed by a masters degree in international business. Most of my undergraduate studies focused on languages, literature and translation rather than formal linguistics.

I'm particularly interested in the intersection of linguistics, AI and natural language processing, especially multilingual language models and how computers process human language.

My main concern is that I have very little previous experience with mathematics, formal logic or programming. I'm willing to work on these areas before starting the programme, but I'm unsure how much of a disadvantage this would be.

I understand that LOGOS is interdisciplinary and seems to welcome applicants from different academic backgrounds, but I'd love to hear from people who have actually studied there.

A few questions:

  1. How mathematically and technically demanding is the programme, particularly during the first year?

  2. Have you encountered students who entered with humanities, modern languages or business backgrounds and little programming experience?

  3. Is the programme genuinely structured to teach the technical foundations from scratch, or is some prior knowledge effectively expected?

  4. What are the career prospects after graduation, particularly outside academia? Are graduates finding opportunities in AI, NLP and language technology?

  5. Would you recommend LOGOS to someone interested in working in AI and language technology without necessarily pursuing a career as a software developer?

Any experiences, advice or honest opinions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Doubt about Grimms and Vermers laws

7 Upvotes

Hello, and thanks for reading and answering in advance. I'm from Spain so i'll try my best to write in english.

I can´t seem to find (or understand) the way Verner's law is necessary following the Grimm one. I mean, i know that when Grimm publishes his works there's some kind of exceptions that would not be allowed by the more scientific view of neogrammatics and more modern linguistics of that age (some years later), and that's when Verner appears.

The thing is I find these series of words as an example:

- frater/brother/Bruder

-pater/father/Vater

(i think they are protogermanic, modern english and german)

I've read that the anormality in Grimm's prediction is that it anticipates the evolution of the (interior) dental consonant as it's seen in the first example, but that doesn't seem to work in words like the second series shows. I found in some articles and textbooks that is looking up to the indoeuropean or protogermanic origin of those words and looking at the consonant position in relation to the original accent that you find out that when it (the consonant) has a pretonic position, it results as the second series shows, with that 'not sonored' dental (I dont know where is the tonic vowel in 'pater', I suppose it is in 'patér'). The question is, why , having the same origin, does the german 'Vater' evolves the dental in that way and the english word doesn´t ? Is that something that only occurs to german? I think I'm not understanding anything (maybe even less!). I see the dental being in a post-tonic position in 'frater', and I'm assuming that's why it is sonored in modern german and english.

I'm also trying to learn how the 'th' ends up being sonored or not in relation to these laws (Grimm and Verner).

Sorry, I'm not that good of a researcher and it's driving me insane. I have some more doubts about it but they don't seem to come out as i write this so maybe with your answers I end up asking some more. It's also poorly explained but I'm struggling to find the words to explain myself, I just don't find a sentence to describe Verner's law in relation to the Grimm one.

Thanks!


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

General Haryanvi dialect diagnosis

3 Upvotes

I never knew what my dialect is called, not even my family members could name it somehow.

I'm from a village in Hisar, and my mother interestingly have the same dialect as mine, she's from Uklana side. Maybe cause my grandfather was raised there for several years and catched the dialect of that area. Although my grandma is from Fazilka pakistan punjab border and have a distinct bagri mixed with our dialect due to living here for many years, hence my father's dialect is also a bit of bagri-like but not really bagri. That was the context.

It isn't deswali for sure, it isn't bagri either but highly influenced by that ofcourse.

You can ask me to translate things in the comments in order to better understand the way I speak but I will drop some sentences anyways.
I've noticed I use different vocabulary depending on the context or mood.

Man to bero koni'o kaddi banri nai to baar'u na khake aanto mai.
Barai ganai log arya ar baat karan lagrya baingai baraim.
Tan to o bi koni bero, bo to ke i bero pavaigo.
Maro dimaag puro khalli ogyo ke bero ke likhan lagryou kimmi samaj koni avai.

I tend to use all these Adai/Urai/Innai, Badai/Binnai, Kadai/Kinnai, Jadai/Jinnai

but not Athai/It, Bathai/Bit, Kathai/Kit, Jathai/Jit. I may use the bagri ones sometimes if I'm talking to someone who speaks it.

Also,

I usually tend to cut short Mannai to Man, Tannai to Tan, Bainai to bain, etc etc... of course again depending on the context, it comes naturally to me.

But I tell you which one comes primarily to me and which ones due to changes in the people I talk to and the context.

Thaan ke laaggai'ai aingo ke naam'ai. Man laaggai koni man kadebi bero pattaigo ainai kavai ke ai.


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Semantics relative tense versus aspect

2 Upvotes

i am editing a paper i wrote on TAM in Plains Cree several years ago in undergrad where i state that the relative tense appears aspectual. i’m realizing i’m not fully sure i knew what i was talking about. what is the difference between relative tense and aspect? is this an ongoing question?


r/asklinguistics • • 1d ago

Phonology How many total tones are there in the world?

8 Upvotes

Cantonese has 6 tonemes (tones) and Wobé supposedly has 14. So how many total tonemes exist across all languages in the world? Is it a discrete number or is it a spectrum as to what a tone is across other languages

Thanks.


r/asklinguistics • • 2d ago

General Why does modern Japanese appear to have *so many* English loanwords?

0 Upvotes

I've been watching more short-form video lately than maybe is good for me and for some reason the algorithm sometimes shows me videos from Japan with Romanji and English subtitles. I can't remember good examples offhand but a lot of the words they show on screen are just... Japanese pronunciation of American English loanwords. It's frequently words that have to do with video games, especially online multiplayer or internationally famous games. It's also frequently hospitality and tourist industry related words, or online content and content creation related words.

Actually, that just reminded me of an example: apparently the Japanese word for internet influencers, tiktok creators and the like is pretty much just literally verbatim "content creator" but with Japanese spelling.

So like... What's the deal with this? Where are all these loanwords coming from? And like. I want an answer that's more specific than "the internet" and "the US," because i knew that. I just wanna know the specific mechanisms driving the adoption of these loanwords.