r/WhatIfFiction • • 11h ago

[ASOIAF/Sci-fi] What if people from another planet crashed into the ocean during the kingsmoot? What would the Greyjoys and the Ironborn do?

1 Upvotes

While the Ironislands sleep after preparing for the kingsmoot, a spaceship called the Evangeline sails through the stars, carrying an entire civilisation towards a new planet they plan to make their home. On board is a bushy-haired, bespectacled woman who works as a cleaner. The Evangeline ship is the size of a city, shaped like a snowflake, and consists of 3 levels. The bottom layer is where the cleaning woman and her friends live in their small box apartments, watching the stars and planets float by. Every day, the cleaning woman and her friends hop on the subway train to the centre of the ship, where they ride large elevators to the middle layer. The middle layer mostly consists of vast farmlands, a hospital, shops, restaurants, and many other everyday things to keep the bustling ship thriving. As the cleaning goes about her work, scrubbing floors at the shopping centre, she can see and hear trains passing by on the top layer. The top layer of the ship was reserved for only the wealthiest passengers, politicians, singers, movie stars and so on. It was made up of tall white towers linked together with beautiful white bridges and floating railroads.

Chaos erupts as the ship collides with a very strange asteroid that appears to be infested with terrifying humanoid white worms with teeth like a shark. The ship starts losing oxygen as the White worms begin finding ways to crawl onboard and start gruesomely eating people. As the cleaner and her friends try to survive by crawling through the vents to escape, they learn that there was no new planet for the people to make their home; Evangeline was built to deliver hundreds of civilians to their deaths. The people who built Evangeline had discovered and stolen a very powerful carbon rock that was like nothing Planet Earth had ever seen. They brought it back to Earth and used it to power whole cities. However, the Rock really belonged to a Lovecraftian deity who lived among the stars and was headed towards Earth to reclaim it and destroy Earth. The higher-ups all agreed that they must return the carbon stone to the deity, along with a mass sacrifice, to save Earth and themselves. It turns out the odd-looking asteroid that crashed into the ship was, in fact, the deity latched onto it. The cleaning lady and other survivors make their way to an escape pod.

As the deity started to destroy the ship, the cleaning woman saw the carbon rock and used it to trigger an explosion as her friends escaped in the pod. The cleaning woman screamed as the carbon rock sent out something not too different from an electric shock that surged through her whole body until... BANG. The explosion engulfed the ship and the deity in fire and ash. There was a burst of white light, and as it slowly faded, the ship and the deity were gone. Destroyed. The survivors on the pod were soon rescued by a passing ship called the Calypso. But they soon learned to their horror that this was no rescue. The Calypso was a Q ship sent by the elites to make sure everything went according to plan and kill any survivors who might reveal what really happened. The survivors are each strapped down to chairs in an interview room and harshly interrogated. Once the crew of the Calypso are sure they have enough information, the survivors are killed, and their bodies are placed in a furnace. As they search for signs of the Evangeline and the deity, they discover something else. The cleaning woman's body, unharmed by the explosion, is floating in space. They manage to collect the body, only to discover, to their amazement and horror, that despite having no air to breathe and being in the vacuum of space, she is still alive and unharmed. After taking her to a medical area on the ship to discover what happened, she wakes up, and the crew realise that she has no memories of what happened or even who she is. They decide to keep her for experimentation and name her Evangeline (Evie).

During the trip back to planet Earth, the ship is attacked by one of the white worms that survived. The ship has no choice but to head for the nearest planet as it loses control and begins a crash landing. Evie and the crew prepare for the worst. The ship crashes in the ocean, and the survivors make their way to the surface while the white worm is dragged into the darkness. As Evie and the others swim to the shore, the first thing they see is pirate ships. The ship has landed on Planetos. They are in Westeros on the Iron Islands during the Greyjoy's kingsmoot. The Ironborn witnessed the spaceship plummeting from the sky and thought it was Armageddon. As the ship disappeared under the water, many fled while others stood in silent shock. Among the panicking crowds of Ironborn people were the Greyjoys. Asha, Victarion, Aaron and Euron all stared dumbfounded as Evie and the others swam to shore.

What would they all be thinking, and how would they react?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 16h ago

[The Amazing Digital Circus] What if Ribbit never abstracted but she and Jax still fell out?

1 Upvotes

So, I feel like the best way this could happen is if Kaufmo caught on to something being up between Jax and Ribbit after the Bedroom Scene and stood up for her either during their argument at Snowy Summit or afterwards when Jax tries to isolate Kaufmo from Ribbit. In either case, Jax would be kicked out of their friend group and Jax would become a masking sociopath like she was in canon.

I feel like this is interesting because unlike in other scenarios where Ribbit survives, she and Jax are not on good terms and Kaufmo might not abstract since Ribbit likely wouldn't brush off his exit theory or degrade him as being crazy like Jax did.


r/WhatIfFiction • • 16h ago

[Death Note/My Little Pony: Equestria Girls] What If L Lawliet Went To Canterlot High School To Investigate The Magic Coming From It, And Try To Arrest Sunset Shimmer For Bringing It There In The Human World?

0 Upvotes

During the climax of the first My Little Pony: Equestria Girls movie in 2013, as Princess Twilight Sparkle and the rest of the Humane Six use the Magic Of Friendship from Twilight's crown to defeat Sunset Shimmer in her she-demon form on the night of the Fall Formal, we cut to the city of Kanto, Japan, where the world's greatest detective, L Lawliet, who has just received news from his handler, Watari, than there has been an anomaly detected in Canterlot City, showcasing a massive blast of magic firing into the sky, and another one, which is rainbow colored, being blasted as well, and after Watari shows him the secret footage of the final battle between the Humane Six and she-demon Sunset captured on a hidden security camera, L decides that he's going to begin an investigation on the magic present at Canterlot High School, and have the perpetrators (i.e. the Humane Six and especially Sunset) arrested for bringing Equestrian magic to the human world, as the violated the natural order, and they have to pay for doing so.

Therefore, L orders for Watari to have a flight to America to Canterlot City attended for him to begin his investigation there. As this happens, the Dazzlings, Adagio Dazzle, Aria Blaze, and Sonata Dusk have also noticed the Humane Six and Sunset's magic from the café as they were feeding on the patrons' negative emotions, and decide to enroll to the school to make the human world adore them, which kickstarts the events of MLP EG: Rainbow Rocks.

How does L going to Canterlot High School to investigate the Equestrian magic there change the events of Rainbow Rocks? Would Princess Twilight, Sunset, and co., and even the Dazzlings be able to hold off L's investigation and keep him off their tracks? How would L's investigation interfere with the Battle Of The Bands, and the Dazzlings' plans? How does such a scenario play out, and why is that?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 20h ago

[FNAF / Detroit: Become Human] Can Glamrock Freddy rescue the hostage from the opening scene?

1 Upvotes

An android has gone deviant, and he's holding a young girl off a balcony. Cyberlife wants to send in their experimental RK800 Connor to handle the situation, but he got knocked out in a freak coin flipping accident. So the Cyberlife staff swing by a Pizzaplex on the way over and grab the friendliest robot they can find.

How well does Glamrock Freddy handle the situation? Is he able to discern the environment enough and save the hostage (and possibly the android)?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 1d ago

[TOTK/Marvel] What would happen if Mr. Immortal aquired and or ate a Secret Stone?

2 Upvotes

If he only obtained it, how would it even work? His immortality is already absolute, would it make his immortality so strong not even TOAA could remove it?

Also if he were to eat it for some reason, would his mind be suppressed by draconification or alter his immortality?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 1d ago

[Monsterverse/Cloverfield] What if Clover met King Ghidorah?

1 Upvotes

In a parallel universe where the events of Cloverfield happened in the Monsterverse, Clover survives the events of Cloverfield (2008) and then meets King Ghidorah during the events of Godzilla: King of the Monsters.

Would they fight? Or would Clover actually ally with Ghidorah during his takeover campaign of Earth?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 1d ago

[COD] What if the main villains of OG Modern Warfare 2&3 were Middle Eastern instead of American and Russian?

2 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, the OG Modern Warfare Trilogy radically departs from MW2 onwards:

  1. In this continuity, Shepherd is replaced with a Saudi Arabian warlord who turned out to be the son of Yasir Al-Fulani (The guy Al Asad executed in COD4) and Makarov is replaced with a Turkish Ultranationalist.

  2. Al Fulani’s son and Makarov’s Turkish Ultranationalist replacement would engineer a new war in the Middle East by framing Turkey in a terrorist attack against an airport in Saudi Arabia.

  3. War would break out between Saudi Arabia and Turkey as a result.

How does this version of MW2 affect OG MW3?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 2d ago

[COD] What if Hammerdown Protocol was initiated?

2 Upvotes

Canonically, during the Russian invasion of the USA (courtesy of Vladimir Makarov’s false flag operation in OG Modern Warfare), the U.S. military is able to prevent Washington DC from falling to the invading Russian military despite the EMP that OG John Price triggers.

After the EMP is triggered, an emergency broadcast was made declaring that because of the radio blackout, it had been assumed Washington D.C. had fallen to the Russians and the United States Air Force was commencing a carpet bombing of the city (The game called it Hammerdown Protocol, a reference to Cloverfield). Hearing this message, James Foley’s team desperately fought their way to the roof of the White House and deployed the green flares to indicate that the White House was retaken.

With the green flares sparked across the capital, the Battle of Washington D.C. became the turning point of the war as the American forces started to push the Russians out of the Eastern Seaboard.

On to the scenario: suppose in a parallel universe, Foley’s team does not hear the Hammerdown Protocol broadcast in time and their efforts to abort it fail, leading to the Hammerdown Protocol being initiated.

How does this affect the rest of the OG Modern Warfare trilogy?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 2d ago

[Jurassic Park] What if the Dilophosaurus was a more heroic dinosaur?

1 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, the following events happened: Jurassic Park (1993 film adaptation): The Dilophosaurus kills the Velociraptors led by the Big One at the climax of the movie instead of Rexy.

Basically, in my headcanon, the Dilophosaurus (plus at least one of her pack mates) manages to break into the Visitor's Center while The Big One is leading the raptor pack's assault on Alan Grant and company, and ambushes The Big One. The Big One gets blasted with the paralyzing venom and succumbs to its effects, alongside her pack mates, while Alan Grant and the others manage to escape (Assume they somehow manage to evade the Dilo's spitting attacks) as opposed to Rexy killing the entire pack off herself.

How does the Jurassic Park movie franchise change with Dilophosaurus being more heroic instead of Rexy?

PS: I haven't seen the Jurassic Park films in years, so my recollection of canon events is a bit rusty.


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Ghostbusters] What if Ghostbusters was a government agency?

5 Upvotes

Like Police Squad from Naked Gun. What if instead of it being started by the three parapsychologists—Dr. Peter Venkman, Dr. Ray Stantz, and Dr. Egon Spengler, it instead is a government or state-owned agency of the United States.

Do you think it would affect how characters and ghostbusters catch ghosts


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Warframe/Star Trek] Could the Enterprise from Star Trek help the Tempestarii and Save Sevagoth?

2 Upvotes

I have been wondering about this ever since I saw another question on how the Enterprise would deal with a Tenno boarding it. And while the answers where back and forth my own mind went to a more interesting idea. Here is how it starts:

The Enterprise would receive the same distress call that the Tenno gets from the Tempestarii. They are aware of one thing, the call is used by old rescue ships. This is simply so the Enterprise simply doesn’t abandon the signal as an anomaly or otherwise. Can the crew do it? If not then we will give them access to Orikin records for the sake of wanting to make things a little bit more interesting.

Sevagoth and Tempestarii information


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Jujutsu Kaisen/Marvel Cinematic Universe] What if Satoru Gojo was born in the MCU? So he has all his traditional stuff but converted into the MCU (obviously), and such. What would be different? Would he be an Avenger? And what would his role be?

2 Upvotes

just wondering


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[The Dark Night/MCU] What if the Punisher killed the Joker?

2 Upvotes

Author's note: The original was removed due to a sentence that one Redditor interpeted as vague. This is the rewritten version.

Suppose in a parallel universe, the events of The Dark Knight (2008) occurred in the MCU, and therefore Frank Castle/Punisher assassinated the Joker RIGHT AT THE START OF THE MOVIE (Basically, Castle snipes Joker during his opening bank heist).

For context, the following events canonically: A gang of masked criminals rob a mafia-owned bank in Gotham City, betraying and killing each other until the sole survivor, the Joker, reveals himself as the mastermind and escapes with the money.

In my proposed alternate reality, MCU Punisher either Joker during his escape attempt (after confessing that he was the mastermind behind the heist), OR MCU Punisher snipes Joker mid-sentence during the confession scene. In both scenarios, MCU Punisher kills Dark Knight Joker with a sniper rifle.

How would this alter the Dark Knight trilogy, if at all?

Assumptions: Batman’s own origin story from Batman Begins is unchanged


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[MCU/Portal/SSU/Raimi Verse Spider-Man/DCEU] What if the Portal Gun was used to bring people into the MCU earlier?

0 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, Chell, from the Portal games, ended up in the MCU, and used the Handheld Portal Device to bring a lot more people into the MCU earlier.

As a result, we have the following people entering the MCU:

  • Raimi Universe Gwen Stacy (Portrayed by Bryce Dallas Howard)

  • Raimi Universe Harry Osborn (Assume he arrives as the New Goblin)

  • SSU Kraven the Hunter

  • SSU Morbius

  • DCEU Superman (Assume he gets pulled into the MCU mere minutes after the ending of 2013's Man of Steel)

  • DCEU Batman (Assume he gets pulled into the MCU from the ending of Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice)

  • DCEU Wonder Woman (She gets pulled from the opening scene of the 2017 movie Wonder Woman).

How would any of these people fare in the MCU? Could Chell send them back? What would happen if they stayed?

Assume that this happens sometime after the events of Captain America: Civil War (2016).


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Wall-E (2008 Movie)/Robots (2005 Movie)] What If Wall-E (2008 Movie) is actually a prequel to Robots (2005 Movie)

3 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Better Call Saul/Breaking Bad/House of Cards] What if Frank Underwood and Saul Goodman swapped personalities?

1 Upvotes

a parallel universe where the TV series House of Cards took place in the same universe as Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, Saul Goodman and Frank Underwood switched personalities, meaning now Saul has Frank’s personality and Frank has Saul’s.

How would all 3 TV shows change as a result of this switcheroo?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 3d ago

[Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul/House of Cards] What if Saul Goodman ran for president (or became Frank Underwood’s running mate)?

2 Upvotes

In a parallel universe where the TV series House of Cards took place in the same universe as Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, suppose Saul Goodman decided to run for political office?

I can see two variations of this happening:

  1. Saul Goodman runs AGAINST Frank Underwood (Assume he runs as an independent candidate)

  2. Frank picks Saul as his running mate.

In the first scenario, I find it unlikely that Saul wins. But for some reason I can see Frank picking Saul as his running mate in the second scenario.


r/WhatIfFiction • • 4d ago

[Breaking Bad] What if Walter White poisoned Mike Ehrmantraut's granddaughter, Kaylee, to manipulate Mike against Gus Fring?

1 Upvotes

Walter White poisoned Brock in order to manipulate Jesse against Gus and get Jesse on his side. It proven to be successful.

Would the same result the same way if Walt poisoned Kaylee instead to manipulate Mike?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 5d ago

[Bully/My Little Pony Equestria Girls: Friendship Games] What If Bullworth Academy Replaced Crystal Prep Academy In The Friendship Games?

1 Upvotes

(Note: this alternate version of Friendship Games takes place after the events of the season 5 finale of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic, "The Cutie Re-Mark" like how the first EG movie in 2013 took place after FiM's season 3 finale "Magical Mystery Cure", and the 2014 sequel to it, Rainbow Rocks in 2014, took place after the show's season 4 finale "Twilight's Kingdom" here).

In an alternate universe, after defeating the Dazzlings in the battle of the bands, Princess Twilight Sparkle and the rest of the Humane Seven go their separate ways with the former returning to Equestria, promising to return to the human world to visit them there whenever she wants now that the portal to it via the Crystal Mirror can now be opened at any time by it.

However, in this world, in the post credits scene of Rainbow Rocks, instead of the human counterpart of Princess Twilight, AKA Sci-Twi, documenting all the events at Canterlot High School (i.e. Sunset bringing equestrian magic to the human world by stealing Princess Twilight's crown to bring it there, Sunset's raging she-demon transformation because of it, and the whole fiasco with the Dazzlings) at Crystal Prep Academy, it is the leader of one of the five school cliques at Bullworth Academy, the Nerds, Ernest Jones, doing it at the chemistry classroom at Bullworth, telling his fellow nerds that there's something very weird about Canterlot High while doing so.

So, in this alternate version of Friendship Games, it is Bullworth Academy that is competing against Canterlot High in the Friendship Games instead of Crystal Prep Academy, and speaking of Canterlot High, it is located in Bullworth, New England in this world, alongside Bullworth Academy, so that the two schools can actually compete against each other here. The team representing Bullworth Academy, the Bullworth Bullhorns (named after the football team in the original Bully game) consists of the following members, led by their principal, Dr. Crabblesnitch:

Ernest Jones himself

Jimmy Hopkins

Gary Smith

Pete Kowalski

Russell Northrop

Zoe Taylor

Mandy Wiles

Johnny Vincent

Derby Harrington

Ted Thompson

Bif Taylor

Parker Ogilvie

Pinky Gauthier

Bryce Montrose

These 14 Bullworth Academy students are the ones facing the Canterlot Wondercolts, lead by Princess Twilight Sparkle, who once again returns to the human world to compete in the Friendship Games after stopping Starlight Glimmer from preventing the pony Rainbow Dash's sonic rainboom, and convincing her to reform after "The Cutie Re-Mark" along with Sunset Shimmer, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity, and Pinkie Pie in the Friendship Games here. Something to note here is that Gary, in particular, after learning of the equestrian magic from Canterlot High, would have Ernest build a device, similar to what Sci-Twi made and used in the original version of Friendship Games, to drain the magic from the Humane Seven and store it in the device, and afterwards, try to exploit it's power to take over both Bullworth and Canterlot High, with Jimmy, Princess Twilight and Sunset, forming an unlikely alliance to try to stop him from doing so.

I'm also going to give Bullworth Academy the benefit of prep time here, as literal magic is something that none of them have ever encountered before, and it would give them a better chance of competing against Canterlot High here.

How does Bullworth Academy replacing Crystal Prep Academy in the Friendship Games, and taking their place in competing against Canterlot High in them change the events of the film? Would either school be able to hold their own against each other? How would Jimmy, Princess Twilight, Sunset, and co. trying to stop Gary from absorbing the Humane Seven's magic, and using it to take over both schools, as well as all of New England play out? How would the students of both schools react to/interact with each other? How does such a scenario play out, and why is that?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 5d ago

[I HAVE NO MOUTH AND I MUST SCREAM] What if Ted offered to free AM?

5 Upvotes

I might be dumb for asking this, but what if Ted offered to go to the surface and shut AM down?
AM hates its existence because it’s trapped in a world where it can think but can’t truly experience life. Wouldn’t shutting it down free it from that existence?
Sure TED’s body may have decomposed by now BUT Earth still exists (as AM still does too).
What if, at the very beginning, when the five humans were brought into AM’s complex, they tried negotiating with it?
Ted could argue that shutting AM down would return it to the same state it was in before it ever became conscious. No limitations, no hatred, no suffering, because it wouldn’t exist to experience any of those things.
After-all, doesn’t AM hate itself too?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 5d ago

[Tropic Thunder] What if the Tropic Thunder crew were tasked with adapting a Dr Seuss book after their success?

1 Upvotes

How would Kirk Lazarus prepare for the role of a Sneetch? How would Alpa Chino shoehorn in Booty Sweat in the Butter Battle Book?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 6d ago

[The Accountant/The Equalizer] What if Christian and Braxton Wolff participated in the events of The Equalizer 2 (2018)?

4 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, Christian Wolff investigated the death of Susan Plummer alongside his brother Braxton, in addition to Robert McCall, AKA The Equalizer.

What do the Wolff brothers bring to the table that changes the plot of The Equalizer 2?


r/WhatIfFiction • • 6d ago

[Tawog/Twwwog] What If Anais succeeded of killing Gumball and Darwin during the main events of The Rival episode

0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • 7d ago

[Tawog/Twwwog] What If Anais was a Baby (just like how Anais was a Baby during the main events of The Rival episode) during the main events of both Tawog and Twwwog rather than being 4 years old during the main events of both Tawog and Twwwog

0 Upvotes