r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 16 '21

[Mass Effect] What if Humanities first contact with aliens wasn't with the Turians, but with the Batarians?

0 Upvotes

So instead of the First Contact War happening because of the Turians, aggressively stopping Humans from activating a dormant Mass Relay, it's instead caused by Batarians attacking Shanxi for new Slaves? What changes to the stories would this cause?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 04 '22

[Big Bang Theory] What If the gang dressed as the Avengers for the Halloween Costume Contest?

0 Upvotes

This isn’t a if they would’ve won question more of who would they dress as obviously Penny would be Black Widow and her boyfriend (whose name I forgot I think it’s probably Steve) would be Captain America the others idk


r/WhatIfFiction • • Aug 06 '21

[DC Comics/Neon Genesis Evangelion] What if Dream of the Endless and Death of the Endless are in Japan they are chilling Dream is feeding the birds and Death is telling him movie references then appears Shinji, Asuka, Rei, Misato and Kaworu what conversation do they have?

0 Upvotes

Any special conversations


r/WhatIfFiction • • Nov 08 '24

[Star wars] what if anakin skywalker was gay?

1 Upvotes

What if anakin was homosexual? Would he have remained celibate or end up marrying a man?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 11 '21

[Marvel, DC, My Hero Academia] What if the Heroes from Marvel and DC found themselves in the My Hero Academia universe?

1 Upvotes

What would their opinion on the Hero System be? Which ones would want to stay and live in the MHA universe? How hard would it be for them to establish a similar system in their own respective universe?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Nov 17 '20

[Star War] What if Rey exists in Star War Legend Universe with her origined from Canon has been kept will Star War Legend Universe change or not

0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • Jul 09 '21

[MCU] What if Killmonger saved Tony Stark in Ironman 1?

0 Upvotes

A Stark Industry missile is about to hit Tony Stark but then Killmonger shows up and throws the missile away. What next?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Apr 28 '21

[DC/Naruto] What if Kal El pod crash land in Minato Namikaze house 3 minutes before Naruto Born.How this will change entire naruto story

0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • Aug 18 '22

[DC/Warhammer Age of Sigmar] What if Justice League or Justice Society existed in Warhammer Age of Sigmar Universe? How would their origin change?

0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • Jul 16 '22

[Shakespeare] What if Romeo was born with dwarfism, and at the opposite, Juliette was born with gigantism?

0 Upvotes

How would the plot change?

Would their relationship be EVEN MORE outrageous (couples composed by a little person and a tall person are EXTREMELY rare)?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Nov 04 '20

[Harry Potter/Honkai Impact 3rd] What would happen if Harry Potter and Honkai Impact are set in Same Universe will Harry Potter Trio think about Herrsher of The End and Schicksal

1 Upvotes

What would happen if Harry Potter and Honkai Impact are set in Same Universe will Harry Potter Trio think about Herrsher of The End and Schicksal


r/WhatIfFiction • • May 27 '21

[Ben 10] What if during Change of Face.Gwen didn't intervened and Ben is permanent in Body of Charmcaster but omnitrix is change user to Ben in Charmcaster Body.How event of Ben 10 to Omniverse change

2 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • 9d ago

[Lord of the rings] What if Frodo threw the ring into the pine barrens in New Jersey?

0 Upvotes

Assuming the jersey devil is real, how would it play out?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 05 '26

[DC Comics/My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic] What If Twilight Sparkle Joined The Red Lantern Corps. In "A Canterlot Wedding: Part 1"?

0 Upvotes

In an alternate universe, during the climax of "A Canterlot Wedding: Part 1", as Twilight Sparkle bursts into the halls of Canterlot Castle during Shining Armor and "Princess Cadence's" (secretly the queen of the changelings, Queen Chrysalis in disguise" wedding rehearsal, calling "Cadence" out for her terrible behavior towards her friends, doing something to her bridesmaids, and putting a spell on her brother with his eyes spinning, and calling "Cadence" evil, Chrysalis in disguise runs out the doors of the hall crying, asking why Twilight is doing this to her, like she did in the original MLP: FiM timeline. Shining Armor crashing out at Twilight for her terrible behavior toawrds "Cadence", and revoking her position as his best mare afterwards, and him, Rarity, Fluttershy, Applejack, Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Spike, and Princess Celestia would all leave the room as well, with Celestia telling Twilight that she has a lot to think about would play out like normal as well.

This time however, as she is left alone in the hall of the castle, Twilight, instead of being devastated by her own actions, and crying that she could've gained a sister, and lost her chance at it, and a brother as well, and "Cadence" going to comfort her only to trap her inside the caves beneath Canterlot along with the real Cadence, would begin to have her blood boil with absolute rage on how her friends, brother, and teacher were to blind to see the out-of-character behavior of "Cadence" and were acting like there was nothing wrong, and were to busy with their own activities for the wedding preparation to notice it, with her magic from her horn glowing a firey purple, gritted teeth, veins popping out of her head, and the room shaking in the process. And as this is happening, across the universe, on the planet Ysmault in Sector 666 of the galaxy, the home planet of the Red Lantern Corps., the leader of the corps., the Red Lantern known as Atrocitus, (who in this world is still a Ryutian, but instead of being humanoid, is in the form of a unicorn pony, with Ryutians being a form of unicorn ponies in this world) has sensed an immense amount of rage coming from the city of Canterlot on the planet Earth, and decides to go there to find the source of it.

After eventually arriving in Canterlot on Earth, and bypassing Shining Armor's protection spell with his intangibility via his lantern ring to get inside the city in the first place, Atrocitus arrives inside of the castle to where Twilight is, and goes towards her to meet up with her. Twilight, having taken notice of the Ryutian unicorn's arrival, asks who he is, and what he's doing here, and why that is. Atrocitus introduces himself to Twilight, and explains that he is here after he had sensed an incredible amount of rage imitating from her, and asks why Twilight is so angry. Twilight reluctantly explains to Atrocitus about the whole situation with the royal wedding, "Cadence" being evil and being horrible to everyone around her, and how her own brother, friends, and teacher all turned their backs on her after she called her out, and she's feeling betrayed by them because of that. Atrocitus, intrigued by this information, offers Twilight to join him and the Red Lantern Corps. to seek retribution on her former friends/allies for wronging her, giving out a red lantern power ring to her as a gift.

Twilight thinks about it for a while, and afterwards, seeing as how her so-called "allies" treated her after calling "Cadence" out, and turning their backs on her afterwards, especially after everything that they've been through up to this point, decides to take Atrocitus' offer, taking the ring, and putting in on her right front hoof, and afterwards, dons a red and black uniform with the Red Lantern Corps. logo on it, and a firey red aura surrounding her, with Twilight reveling in her new power, and Atrocitus donning a sinister grin on his face, gaining a new recruit in his corps., and with such a being wielding incredible magical power, they can all use it and her to conquer the entire universe for themselves and dye it with everlasting rage, and destroy the Guardians Of The Universe (who are alicorn ponies in this world) and their precious Green Lantern corps., and finally put an end to their long intergalactic war and take victory in it, starting with Earth, after he goes through Chrysalis and her changeling army first, as they are standing in the way of all of their goals.

How does such a dark change with Twilight joining Atrocitus and the Red Lantern Corps. to get retribution on her "friends" for abandoning her affect the rest of the "A Canterlot Wedding" 2 parter? How would the other Mane Six, Spike, Celestia, Luna, Shining Armor, the real Cadence, and Chrysalis and the changelings react to such an event? Would Twilight's friends be able to save her from Atrocitus and the ring's influence, and bring her back on the side of good? Would Twilight eventually realize that Atrocitus is just using her as nothing more than a tool for universal conquest? How would the Red Lantern Corps. invading Canterlot on Earth to conquer the planet interfere with Chrysalis' plans to feed off Shining Armor's love for Cadence to feed her subjects and conquer Equestria? How would an unlikely alliance between the Mane Six (minus Twilight), Spike, Celestia, Luna, Shining Armor, Cadence, the changelings, and the whole Green Lantern corps. being formed to take on Atrocitus, Red Lantern Twilight, and the rest of the Red Lantern Corps. to stop them from conquering Earth and taking them down go down? How would this scenario affect the rest of the timeline of FiM beyond the royal wedding in season 2 going from there to season 9 as a whole? How does such a crazy scenario play out, and why is that?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Oct 07 '21

[Harry Potter] What if everyone in Harry Potter was Magical?

0 Upvotes

Like if Muggles/Squibs didn't exist and they were instead Magical just like the Wizards and Witches?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Oct 23 '21

[Marvel/DC] What if Doctor Octopus had arms made of Vibranium?

0 Upvotes

Would this make him more deadly?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Sep 01 '22

[DC/Fallout 4] What if Joker was frozen and woke up after the great war?

0 Upvotes

How quickly would he take over the Commonwealth?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Dec 17 '24

[Harry Potter] What if James Potter had used a love potion to force Lily to marry him, as Harry briefly wonders in Order of the Phoenix after seeing Snape's worst memory? How would this revelation impact the story and its future events?

0 Upvotes

In Order of the Phoenix, Harry glimpses Snape’s worst memory and is troubled by what he sees, even briefly wondering if his father, James Potter, might have forced his mother, Lily, to marry him using a love potion. While this doubt is fleeting in the book, imagine if it were true for a moment. How would this revelation about James’ actions reshape the story in terms of Harry’s view of his parents and their relationship and its broader implications for the wizarding world? How might it alter Harry’s choices, his identity, and the dynamics with characters like Snape, Sirius and Lupin in the future?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 23 '22

[The Little Mermaid] What if Ariel the ex-mermaid and former Prime Minister of Israel Ariel Sharon met?

0 Upvotes

Would they get along since they have the same given name, but one is an effeminate tomboy, and the other a manly man?


r/WhatIfFiction • • Sep 04 '21

[Avatar] Avatar Aang(Appa and Momo) and Avatar Korra(with Naga) ends up in our world during the 20th century(WW2 and onwards), How would they change it?

1 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • Jun 18 '21

[General Cosplay] What if there was App that can transform you to your favourite character for cosplay by placing only your picture in gallery which character you would be could

0 Upvotes

Ps.you get only Character appearanced but not abillity of that character For me I would be Takao(Azur Lane),Ark Royal(Azur Lane),Boudica(Fate),Artoria Lancer(Fate) and Bismarck(Sid Story)


r/WhatIfFiction • • Mar 04 '22

[Mario] What if Princess Peach Toadstool was massively obese?

0 Upvotes

Would Mario even more love her because both would have more adipose tissue than the average human being?

Would King Bowser Koopa have difficulty to kidnap her?

Would Wario also have a crush on her?


r/WhatIfFiction • • May 18 '21

[DC] What if Kal-El pod crash land in Corsica Island and get adopted by Bonaparte Family.How will Justice League could be formed in this universe.

0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction • • Oct 27 '21

[DC comics] What would Clark' Kent's life have been like as a teenager I he was gay? how would that change his perspective on things and the events of his life. Would he still be superman?

3 Upvotes