r/WhatIfFiction • u/Lwmons • Oct 19 '20
[Star Wars] What if Luke and Leia had been switched at birth? Luke was raised a noble and Leia on Tattoine?
Let's start things off with a classic, shall we?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Lwmons • Oct 19 '20
Let's start things off with a classic, shall we?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/almighty_smiley • Oct 29 '20
For the uninitiated, DC's Act of God was a brief series where everyone's powers - regardless of origin - simply shut off. Alien biology, magical prowess, radiation, Atlantean physiology, whatever; if you were not a baseline human, you were immediately made one. The only heroes left unscathed were those that utilized technology and training in their crimefighting (read: only a certain pointy-eared Gothamite could still operate)
If this same event were to happen with Marvel characters - again, regardless of origin - how would things play out?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/FingerBangYourFears • Oct 28 '20
Assume that he becomes the champion successfully and can now use the power word Shazam and all that comes with that. Since it turns you into the person you want to be, saying Shazam turns him into a caped crusader who strikes fear into criminals.
What does the young Bruce do with this power? How does the DC universe look?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/SleepDeprivedUserUK • Apr 26 '21
I saw this in another reddit and had a brain fart.
Provided that the mirror used silver (as it's silver-backed mirrors which don't reflect Vampires, the regular ones today would work fine), would they be able to see behind themselves?
Or would their bodies block the photons meaning that the mirror itself would just appear to be a black dark void like their eternally damned souls?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Lorix_In_Oz • Nov 24 '20
A weird question I realize but let's say this version of Thanos took the view that every planet in the universe needed to be put to the same test as his own homeworld with respect to overpopulation and under-resourcing. How would the Infinity Stones interpret and then make real a wish to *double* the population of the universe?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Djehuty93 • Oct 24 '20
How would someone with his potential change the course of the galaxy's history? We presume he would fight for the Rebellion given his earthly ideals, but what if he fought for the Empire instead? And depending on what world he was raised on, would he even know he was "special?"
r/WhatIfFiction • u/curvysquares • Jan 06 '21
Somehow during the time heist something goes wrong and Tony Stark disappears into the quantum realm. He wakes up in a Middle Eastern cave with a car battery hooked up to his heart and no suit. His consciousness has been sent back into the body of himself immediately after being kidnapped. Assuming Stark doesn’t mind changing the timeline, how does him having knowledge of the next 15 years affect the MCU?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/curvysquares • Feb 12 '21
During the scene where Zeno impersonates a therapist and breaks Bucky out of his cell, there’s a little exchange between Natasha and Tony
“Tell me you brought a suit”
“Sure did it’s a lovely Tom Ford three-piece two button”
That got me thinking, what if Tony did bring an Iron-Man suit with him? It could be like an upgraded version of the briefcase suit or some early nanotech or something. However he gets it, Tony Stark has an Iron-Man suit on hand during Bucky’s break out. How does this affect the rest of the film and potentially the rest of the MCU?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/HA64e • Nov 17 '20
Would Tony Iron Man up some Iron Jaeger suits? Can he easily have built some for himself and the others without the Drift-Compatible weakness?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/[deleted] • Mar 08 '21
In the 40s he had an a affair with Hugh Jones' wife, Hugh Jones being the head of Roxxon Corp. leading to lifelong enmity between them. Which likely prevented numerous future opportunities for cooperation.
in that same period he also had an issue with many of his inventions and developments being stolen and sold worldwide, in the process of recovering them he kept many of his inventions and discoveries to himself, specifically withholding them from the Strategic Scientific Reserve, the organization which would become S.H.I.E.L.D. This likely led to S.H.I.E.L.D. being decades behind in the tech race once augmented and metahumans started emerging.
In the 60s/70s, Howard Stark had Anton Vanko, co-creator of the original Arc Reactor, framed for espionage and deported in order to avoid sharing credit. This conceivably is contributory to the Arc Reactor tech hitting a plateau Howard was unable to move past by himself. At the very least it was the causal event that decades later led to Ivan Vanko recreating Tony Starks miniaturized Arc Reactor tech and using it to try and kill him.
In the late 80s, he tried unsuccessfully to recreate the Pym Particle invented by Hank Pym, which infuriated Pym and was one of the main reasons Pym left S.H.I.E.L.D. Pym being an incredibly talented scientist and engineer in his own right, this was a significant loss for S.H.I.E.L.D.
In the early 90s he was then killed by James Buchanan "Bucky" Barnes aka the "Winter Soldier" and 5 doses of his recreation of the Super Soldier serum that had been used to create Captain America were stolen. It's unclear to what degree he'd kept his efforts to replicate Erskine's formula to himself, but judging by the lack of knowledge of it from S.H.I.E.L.D. and the DoD, his paranoia seems to have kept him from sharing it anywhere else as well.
r/WhatIfFiction • u/WippitGuud • Oct 21 '20
You can reference either the MCU versions of each or the 616 versions. Would Absorbing Man be able to absorb one or more stones at once, and if he absorbed all five could he Snap?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Coffeeman314 • Oct 19 '20
The bomb lands a few metres to the right and the wounds are just a bit more... fatal. No more plot armour for you Iron Man.
r/WhatIfFiction • u/FGHIK • Dec 12 '21
Marv dies after being hit on the head with an iron, and a little later Harry dies from being hit in the face with a paint can. What happens? Does Kevin face any criminal charges? How does it effect him growing up having killed two people?
Would it make any difference if they were killed during the events of 2?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Spidey007 • Dec 15 '20
SCENARIO: Imagine this: Peter is sticking around the Stark house after the funeral. Instead of handing the shield down to Sam, old man Steve decides to hand the shield down to him. On the merits that he's a powerful being, proven his meddle in the battle with Thanos, and has many more years ahead of him, and is strong enough to fully utilize it.
How would everyone have reacted to this? How would Peter react with this mantle passed down to him? How would this affect his character and Far rom Home?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/ImTheAverageJoe • Nov 09 '20
In this timeline, let's say Zuko allowed Katara to heal Iroh from Azula's sneak attack, made peace with the group immediately after, and both men agreed to travel with Team Avatar from there. I'm sure with Toph's conversation with Iroh beforehand, and the Ba Sing Se betrayal out of the picture, there would be an easier time forgiving. But how would the story play out with these circumstances in mind?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/Cryogisdead • May 06 '21
How would Thanos react?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/ImportantHamster6 • Dec 22 '20
I only say Life Day cause that is the Star Wars equivalent of Christmas. Otherwise refer to the title for the what if.
r/WhatIfFiction • u/curvysquares • Dec 03 '20
As the jet leaves Germany carrying the Avengers and their new prisoner Loki, a storm begins brewing. Loki is visibly nervous.
“What’s the matter?” Stark asks. “Scared of a little thunder?”
Loki responds, “I’m not particularly fond of what follows.”
And then... nothing. Nobody enters the plane and nobody takes Loki. For the rest of the film, Thor has no way of getting to Earth.
What happens?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/InsertCoinForCredit • Oct 22 '20
Based on the discussion in this thread...
After enjoying a night at the movies with his parents, young Bruce Wayne is traumatized when Joe Chill tries to rob his parents and ends up killing them instead. In a fit of rage and shock, the child manages to jump on the mugger, bludgeon him with some discarded scrap wood, and subdue him long enough for the police to arrive. With the emotional support of his caretaker Alfred Pennyworth, the young Wayne then testifies at Chill's trial, where the jury sentences the man to 50 years in prison for robbing Gotham of one of their beloved families.
Having gotten justice for the murder of his parents, how does Bruce Wayne's life change? Is he still driven to skulk around rooftops at night and beat up criminals? Or does he become a normal, healthy adult (or as close as one can get in Gotham) instead? And what happens to Gotham City as a result?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/AEWMarksSuck • Nov 26 '20
r/WhatIfFiction • u/arkhamsaber • Feb 07 '21
Assumptions:
Asgard has a yellow sun therefore allowing Superman or whatever his name will be in this hypothetical scenario to gain his powers.
He lands while Thor and Loki are still children. This is so the traditional Thor and Loki relationship hasn’t been established and we can see how much of an effect Kal has on their characters.
r/WhatIfFiction • u/bhamv • Nov 10 '20
What would the authorities' reaction be?
What would Superman's trial be like?
How would the League react?
What would happen next?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/MortStrudel • Jan 28 '21
In the film version of Lord of the Rings (can't recall if this detail was in the books), Wormtongue leans over Saruman's bomb with a candle, and approaches within a foot or two of lighting up all the black powder directly in Saruman's face. Saruman catches him approaching and slowly pushes the candle away before this happens. But let's say Saruman is being slightly more inattentive, or Wormtail is being slightly more excited and leans in too fast. From an errant spark or a dropped candle, the black powder lights up and that particular room of the Tower bursts into flame.
Question 1: Does Saruman survive? He's like a wizard/angel thing, incarnated into a (sort of) mortal body, right? Is he durable enough to survive using magic? He seems to die pretty easily to a stab from Wormtongue, though perhaps it was the fall several hundred feet onto a spike that did him in. If he didn't see it coming (because when he does see it coming he just grabs the candle before it happens), does Saruman even survive this?
If Saruman does die, how does this effect the future events of Middle Earth? What happens to his army of Uruk-hai? They're right outside when this scene is happening. Were they being directly manipulated by Saruman, like how Sauron controls his armies? Without Saruman's control/leadership, would they just dissolve as a single fighting force, and just fight amongst themselves, go on minor raids against nearby settlements, and do independent orc things? Would they immediately go directly under Sauron's control and head off to Mordor? How much easier does Saruman's demise make things for Frodo and the rest of Middle Earth?
Basically, at this point in the story, how important was Saruman to Sauron's plans?
Or, if Saruman survives, what are the consequences of this explosion? Is he maimed? Does he have to seriously delay his attack on Helm's Deep in order to amass more black powder? How hard to make/acquire is that stuff anyway? Is it possible that the delay here could totally screw over his plans for Rohan anyway? Is the tower destroyed?
Basically, how close does Wormtongue come to utterly ruining Saruman's plans, or even Sauron's plans, by waving around an open flame next to an actual bomb next to one of Sauron's most important assets?
r/WhatIfFiction • u/NothingWillImprove6 • Oct 25 '20
Assume the following:
The Joker's backstory from The Killing Joke is accurate
He made this discovery well into his criminal career
Jeannie and her son child have no knowledge of their husband and father's identity as the Joker, believing him (the civilian that the Joker once was) to be dead