I love the value investing approach. However, this sub, and a lot of other investing subs, are too focused on the fundamentals of stocks while ignoring macro events. If you only look at balance sheets, forward P/Es, earnings projections etc, then you will miss the fundamental macro events that create crashes like we are in right now.
Stop "buying the dip." This isn't a dip. It's a crash.
What is happening is that there is a lot of debt in the economy. The US financial system is essentially operating as a Ponzi Scheme. The US government is borrowing more money than it is bringing in. The system only works if we can borrow more money to pay off old loans. That is the definition of a Ponzi Scheme. The problem is that there is only but so much appetite for American debt and American dollars. Because of this, when we have weak bond auctions, interest rates go up because investors demand a higher rate of return for taking on more debt. Great. So what?
It's not just government debt that is the problem. It's all of the debt. Corporate debt, household debt, and non-debt instruments that act like debt (social security, Medicare, annuities, pensions, insurance, etc) are all part of the debt equation. Since 2008, companies, people, and governments, have been able to borrow cheaply and push the bill down the road. But when interest rates go up, it becomes more expensive to borrow additional money. So the overall effect of higher rates is less money in the system. Less money is available to go into stocks, bonds, and other financial assets.
None of that matters until you have a catalyst event, like the CEO of the largest and fastest growing company in the world being caught up in an international sex/spy scandal. When that happens and asset prices are driven lower, suddenly people who have been relying on continued market growth to pay their bills need cash fast. They must raise cash from wherever they can get it to pay their bills. This is why the sell off happens across the board and isn't contained to just one stock or asset class. Liquidity seeking happens everywhere.
In the beginning stages of the bubble popping, investors who have been getting great returns in the final year or two of the bubble inflating, they see lower P/Es and rush in to buy the dip. Revenues haven't fallen YET, so P/Es look more attractive. This creates a false rally. People start to believe that the fears and panic that led to the sell off were over blown and let their guard down as the market comes marching back. However, the fundamental issues are still at play. Rates are still high compared to recent history, and debt levels are still high. A second wave of the crash ensues and the market plunges to the bottom.
Think about what debt looks like on balance sheets. For the person borrowing, they have a liability on one side, and cash for their project on the other side. For the lender, they have a debt instrument (typically in the form of a bond or note) on the asset side, and a subtraction of cash, also on the asset side. So what happens if the person borrowing can't pay back their loan? The lender will need to "write down" the loan. This means accepting less for the loan than what was previously agreed upon. So if I have a balance sheet that has $100 of assets, and $50 of debt, I have a net worth of $50. But if half of my assets was in the form of loans to others and I have to write off 30% of it, my net worth just dropped to $20. And if my ability to borrow is based on the assets I own, my ability to borrow just got decimated.
Now think about how much leverage banks use. They are typically leveraged somewhere between 12:1 and 15:1. There will need to be a lot of write downs.
This means that revenues will have to come down across the board. But it happens at a lag. But when it does happen, those attractive P/Es that made you want to buy the dip will be gone.
Those who are saying, "Yeah, but AI isn't going anywhere," aren't wrong about that statement. AI will still be here, but the returns that were once generated from AI will be gone. The people who bought at the top, the people who bought on margin, or the people who had never been invested before and decided to get in on the upswing, those people will feel burned and aren't coming back to the market.
I'm not saying to sell everything and go away. I'm just saying that there is a price to pay for the 20% returns we saw in '24 and '25. And I'm also saying that buying the dip isn't the strategy you want right now. It's not a dip.
*I do expect to get eaten alive for this post because these sorts of economic mechanics aren't taught in schools. This sort of macro view point goes against the EMH views that are taught as dogma in b-schools.