r/ValueInvesting • u/mortismos • 21m ago
Discussion Extremely bearish outlook I can't let go of
As a relatively new (1½ years) investor I've been trying to get an understanding of the stock market. How the multiples and earnings affect each other. Interest rates' role in valuations ect... And there was one thing I couldn't let go of. If the S&P 500 earned so much money in the latest couple of years and consistently trades at a ~23-27 P/E ratio (which honestly isn't THAT unheard of) why is the greatest investor of all time sitting in almost 50% treasuries?
Before lump summing all my money into this market I feel like this mystery need to be solved, and I'm not sure that I've figured it out yet but its the best guess I've got.
"Everything in valuation comes back to interest rates". That's the quote I can't let go of. And the more I think about it the more it makes sense. How much money enters the economy. The value of your house is based on what mortgages people buying it can afford to get. The risk free rate of return dictates the value of a companies cash flows/earnings. And so on...
The earnings yield on the S&P 500 is currently 4.25%. A 1 year treasury yields 4.5%. But does that mean a treasury is better? Not really right because the index grew earnings by 30% YoY and historically by ~8% right? a bond can't do that. But it's this scenario that makes Warren Buffett pile up on treasuries & the last time these numbers were this close was right before the Great Recession. Now I know toxic mortgages and credit rating fraud and blah blah blah... Maybe a coincidence.
Then I find this other graph. Excess CAPE yield & the following 10 year annual performance against bonds. Basically shows the P/E ratio of the 10 year average earnings (evening out busts & booms). & then whether the stock market performed better or worse than bonds. And this is what i can't let go of
Historically I think the evidence is pretty clear. 10 year annual excess returns USUALLY follow the risk premium investors pay for it (meaning cyclically adjusted earnings yield - bond yield). Now this model is by no means perfect either. if you look in the 80's stocks had a 10% risk premium but still only performed the same as bonds. thats still a great 14% annual return over 10 years but its not better than bonds. conversely, the s&p 500 annualized 15% higher returns than bonds since 2016 when the risk premium was only 4%. But that was also because treasuries yielded nothing. In 1990 we saw stocks outperform bonds by 10% while the risk premium was only 3%. And then the following 10 years they underperformed bonds by 10%. In 2016 stocks went on to outperform bonds by 15%. What will the next 10 years look like?
So my thought is... If CAPE sits at 36 while the standard P/E ratio sits at 23 are we seeing a potential bubble in earnings? In 1929 the S&P traded at a P/E ratio of 18. Cyclically adjust that number and it was 32. Historians note there was a temporary boost in profit margins. Interest rates had been dropping for years 10 years from 7% to 4%. After the fed finally hiked rates investor confidence disappeared and profits plumetted
From 2000 to today profit margins have nearly doubled relative to revenue. How much of this is created by the decades of low interest debt? And to those of you who say high margin tech explains it I can also see that perspective, but I see the same picture even in non-tech stocks.
I don't know. The more I read about this the more confused I am. I've got a good chunk of money I could lump sum into the market that I'm just DCA'ing right now. Everyone seems so bullish on AI & most of the investing influencers i follow and regard as intelligent people have bought the Nvidia dip. I'm not really buying it, i think the risk of falling semiconductor earnings is a real threat when the hyperscalers need to go FCF positive again. and whether that is in 1 year or 5 years i dont know enough so i just stay away
Anyway, genuinely confused. am i overthinking it?
Cyclically adjusted earnings vs bonds (spread & following 10 year returns)