r/ValueInvesting • • 21m ago

Discussion Extremely bearish outlook I can't let go of

0 Upvotes

As a relatively new (1½ years) investor I've been trying to get an understanding of the stock market. How the multiples and earnings affect each other. Interest rates' role in valuations ect... And there was one thing I couldn't let go of. If the S&P 500 earned so much money in the latest couple of years and consistently trades at a ~23-27 P/E ratio (which honestly isn't THAT unheard of) why is the greatest investor of all time sitting in almost 50% treasuries?

Before lump summing all my money into this market I feel like this mystery need to be solved, and I'm not sure that I've figured it out yet but its the best guess I've got.

"Everything in valuation comes back to interest rates". That's the quote I can't let go of. And the more I think about it the more it makes sense. How much money enters the economy. The value of your house is based on what mortgages people buying it can afford to get. The risk free rate of return dictates the value of a companies cash flows/earnings. And so on...

The earnings yield on the S&P 500 is currently 4.25%. A 1 year treasury yields 4.5%. But does that mean a treasury is better? Not really right because the index grew earnings by 30% YoY and historically by ~8% right? a bond can't do that. But it's this scenario that makes Warren Buffett pile up on treasuries & the last time these numbers were this close was right before the Great Recession. Now I know toxic mortgages and credit rating fraud and blah blah blah... Maybe a coincidence.

Then I find this other graph. Excess CAPE yield & the following 10 year annual performance against bonds. Basically shows the P/E ratio of the 10 year average earnings (evening out busts & booms). & then whether the stock market performed better or worse than bonds. And this is what i can't let go of

Historically I think the evidence is pretty clear. 10 year annual excess returns USUALLY follow the risk premium investors pay for it (meaning cyclically adjusted earnings yield - bond yield). Now this model is by no means perfect either. if you look in the 80's stocks had a 10% risk premium but still only performed the same as bonds. thats still a great 14% annual return over 10 years but its not better than bonds. conversely, the s&p 500 annualized 15% higher returns than bonds since 2016 when the risk premium was only 4%. But that was also because treasuries yielded nothing. In 1990 we saw stocks outperform bonds by 10% while the risk premium was only 3%. And then the following 10 years they underperformed bonds by 10%. In 2016 stocks went on to outperform bonds by 15%. What will the next 10 years look like?

So my thought is... If CAPE sits at 36 while the standard P/E ratio sits at 23 are we seeing a potential bubble in earnings? In 1929 the S&P traded at a P/E ratio of 18. Cyclically adjust that number and it was 32. Historians note there was a temporary boost in profit margins. Interest rates had been dropping for years 10 years from 7% to 4%. After the fed finally hiked rates investor confidence disappeared and profits plumetted

From 2000 to today profit margins have nearly doubled relative to revenue. How much of this is created by the decades of low interest debt? And to those of you who say high margin tech explains it I can also see that perspective, but I see the same picture even in non-tech stocks.

I don't know. The more I read about this the more confused I am. I've got a good chunk of money I could lump sum into the market that I'm just DCA'ing right now. Everyone seems so bullish on AI & most of the investing influencers i follow and regard as intelligent people have bought the Nvidia dip. I'm not really buying it, i think the risk of falling semiconductor earnings is a real threat when the hyperscalers need to go FCF positive again. and whether that is in 1 year or 5 years i dont know enough so i just stay away

Anyway, genuinely confused. am i overthinking it?

Cyclically adjusted earnings vs bonds (spread & following 10 year returns)


r/ValueInvesting • • 2h ago

Discussion This is a correction, not a bear market.

54 Upvotes

I see several articles about AI bubble every day. Just recently Bloomberg had a essay on How

“AI Is Testing What Economists Know About Bubbles”

The author starts by saying “One of these days, the long, long upward run of US stock prices that began in 2009 will come to an end, not just with a temporary “rotation” or “drawdown” or “correction” but years of falling valuations and disappointed expectations.”

First of all, why do we presume that years of falling valuations and disappointing expectations have to exist? In 100s of years of market history even predating the stock market, zooming out there have rarely been periods of years of falling prices. Zooming out even events like 2008 and 1970s are corrections in what is a long term bull market. This idea is supported by the efficient market hypothesis which says that markets where flow of information is quick price in all negatives and positives of the underlying investment. This is especially true for stocks today where we have reached levels of transparency that was never seen in 1900 years of human history. In 1850 it would take a mail carried by a courier for you to get hold of a company’s earnings report. Now that’s available and priced in almost instantly.

Second, addressing the main argument of “AI bubble” the valuations in the market simply don’t support it. The PE multiples of the “bubble” stocks are not high enough to even call it a bubble. Even if we assume that earnings expectations are false and will not turn out to be accurate and look at trailing PE there’s still no bubble.

NVDA’s trailing PE that is actual report earning of TTM is 13.5. I do concede that AMD, AVGO, MRVL, etc trade at high multiples but I would argue that these stocks have actually earnings potential even without AI. AMD was already eating Intel’s lunch by offering better CPUs, Broadcom was already diversifying into recurring revenue and software(30% revenue from software) and Marvel was doing AISC’s before AI.

Not to mention that all of these companies sit on massive amounts of cash. Nvidia has 50bn in cash, MU has 40bn, even Anthropic has 100bn+ in cash. Talking about the hyperscalers ie those buying the hardware, MSFT, META, AMZN and GOOG are all seeing fastest pace of revenue growth in years. AMZN is growing cloud at 40%, GOOG at 90% and so on.. not to mention that the original business of these companies are still very sound. Even if we presume the worse case scenario that software has a demise and search is no longer used, their are still years before these businesses start contracting. And meantime they will generate enough cash for the hyperscalers to pivot. Google and Microsoft are already selling Gemini and Copilot to enterprises. Meta already has a successful app in the form of Muse.

The fundamental picture barring the neoclouds is actually very strong for the so called AI stocks.

Also, what exactly is the bear case?

  1. If data center build up does slow down or even stop, hyperscalers are bound to benefit as the supply of compute remains the same while the demand increases. These companies go back to being FCF positive and can do buybacks again. Even Anthropic which is already operating profitable, generates actual EPS as they get more pricing power. Sure the hardware stocks suffer but the overall market should be fine.

  2. If open source models become the norm, then hyperscalers win as they have the data centers and the hardware to run these open source models. And companies like NVDA win as they can sell more and more hardware to run open source models.

  3. If AI is truly the threat to traditional business and software as promised companies like Microsoft and Google should go down. But if that is indeed true Nvidia and Hardware stocks should go up!

Lastly, remember all I have written above doesn’t even take into account that AI is a revolutionary technology. OpenAI has solved one of the six millennium prize math problems and is on the verge of solving a second. As sad as it may sound to the mathematicians that dedicated their whole life to this stuff the fact is it’s a powerful technology. Anecdotally I don’t think anyone can claim that they don’t use AI in some form or another every day in their lives now. I was just talking to an accountant friend of mine who mentioned how much THEY are using copilot. I strongly disagree with people like Ed Zitron and others who think that AI is nothing more than a chatbot. This is a technology with real potential.

So what am I missing here? To me there doesn’t seem to be any fundamental justification for why this isn’t MORE than a correction. SPY is down 13% from its highs Nasdaq is doen 18% from its highs. SPY is now flat and Nasdaq negative on the year all while companies are delivering actual earnings and actual cash.

Even if we assume that somehow AI development stops right here, even at current capability there are so many places this tech can be used. Thomson Reuters is now using AI for its legal services businesses which is basically a digital library for lawyers, AI has sped up the lockup so much!

Sure the tech isn’t perfect, companies got way to greedy with data centers, they should never have asked for tax breaks from states, never have built these near residential areas and run them with Gas turbines. They are at fault here and should rectify.

But, that is the stuff of a correction not a years long bear market. The multiples aren’t high enough, euphoria not big enough and indiscipline not prevalent enough for there to be a major crash. Investors are NOT being indisciplined, they are infact being cautious. Remember, META, AMZN, GOOG, MSFT are flat or down on the year because the market is punishing them for going FCF negative compare that with dotcom era when markets rewarded such companies. AT&T, Walmart, Barnes and Noble, Toys r Us were rewarded for 100s of millions spending on internet. Today’s market punishes companies for investing in AI. It crashes Meta’s stock every time it announces capex, I don’t think we should even mention oracle which has HALVED for spending billions on AI.


r/ValueInvesting • • 4h ago

Stock Analysis $IREN has lost 72% in 3 months - What am I getting wrong here ?

0 Upvotes

For the past 3 months, $IREN has lost 72% of its valuation… I mean, what in the world is happening right now?!

So you’re telling me now that:
- owning the land, the infrastructure and the power is not “valuable”?
- building from zero to delivering a data centre in 14 months vs an 18-month benchmark (not including delivery) is not “valuable”?
- having 5GW of contracted power is not “valuable”?
- being backed by $MSFT and $NVDA is not “valuable”?
- having $5.8B in cash and equivalents (roughly $IREN’s market cap) is not “valuable”?

I mean, at some point this has got to make sense. This is not a Bitcoin miner anymore; it rents power and compute!

Maybe I’m biased; I’m aware of that, but even when I look at it with a step back, I still don’t get how it can be valued at $6B!


r/ValueInvesting • • 5h ago

Stock Analysis Mercado Libre ($MELI): down ~50% in 1.5 years. Is the discount justified?

37 Upvotes

Mercado Libre ($MELI) is an ecommerce and fintech company operating in 18 countries across Latin America. It was founded in 1999 by Marcos Galperin, who led the company for 26 years and is stepping back to Executive Chairman in 2026. The person replacing him is Ariel Szarfsztejn, who previously ran the Marketplace and built the logistics network.

For those that aren't as familiar with $MELI, think Amazon (without AWS) + PayPal + a bank in South America.

Revenue Segments:

  • Commerce: The Marketplace (mostly third-party sellers, but they also sell their own products equivalent to Amazon basics), Mercado Envios (logistics), Mercado Ads, and Classifieds (vehicles, real estate, services).

  • Fintech: Mercado Pago, which started as a way to make payments on the marketplace and is now a digital account, debit/credit cards, consumer and merchant loans, insurance, and investments.

By geography, ~55% of revenue is Brazil, ~23% Mexico, ~18% Argentina, and ~5% everything else.

Why Mercado Libre has been so successful historically is the flywheel --> Customers buy on the Marketplace, pay with Mercado Pago, get it delivered by Envios, and sellers advertise on Mercado Ads. Some segments naturally grow business in the other segments. An example is where a seller on the Marketplace gets paid through Pago, and Mercado Libre can see their sales and offer them a loan to grow more, but the loan gets repaid straight out of future sales, which keeps them selling (and paying for shipping and ads) on the platform.

They've also grown 30%+ for 31 straight quarters, which is something no company of this size has done.

Moat/Strengths:

  • Logistics: They started building their own network in 2016-2019 (fulfillment centers, sorting facilities, delivery fleet, even a cargo airline). It takes a lot of capital and planning to build this in a region with rough terrain and poor infrastructure. Management said on the Q3 2025 call that it's not easy to open a warehouse of this size from one quarter to the next (pretty obvious but it is just a testament to the important of building a moat through capex spend on logistics).

  • First Mover + Local Advantage: Founders are from Latin America but have a US-style entrepreneurial mindset. They were the go-to for ecommerce before Amazon showed up and have built a pretty recognizable brand name in the region.

  • Credit: They use their own data from the marketplace and Pago to build proprietary credit models, and they can collect loan payments directly from a merchant's sales on the platform, which lowers default risk. It costs them ~$1/month to service a loan vs. up to $10 for a legacy bank.

  • Vertical Integration: Most of the software is built in-house across development centers in Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay and Chile.

  • Contrarian/Culture: Known for the "garage culture," no quarterly guidance, very little M&A, and a distinct startup mentality. Galperin is a Bezos-like founder who reinvests everything.

Scaled Economies Shared: Management is willing to sacrifice margins to grow. They lower free shipping thresholds (in Brazil they cut the minimum from 79 to 19 reais) and pass the savings on to customers. Even though margins sacrifice, market share and growth benefit. Depends on what you look for as an investor, but this is HIGHLY reminiscent of Amazon's playbook in the later 2000s.

Profitability / Capital Allocation:

They run near breakeven on purpose to reinvest in warehouses, tech, and the credit book. True earning power is higher than GAAP shows. R&D has stayed at 8-12% of revenue for 10 years. Dividend was suspended in 2018, M&A is minimal, and debt is ~$2.5B on a ~$75B market cap. Galperin owns ~7% through a trust, and executive comp is mostly performance-based and paid in cash over 6 years tied to the stock price. Diluted share count is up ~15% over 10 years, which is a negative.

Growth Opportunities:

  • Low Ecommerce Penetration: 12-15% of retail in LATAM vs. ~27% in the US and ~45% in China. 85% of retail is still in physical stores. This one generally speaks for itself!

  • Fintech: 122M+ unbanked people (World Bank, 2021), low credit card penetration (31%), and Mercado Pago is working on a banking license in Mexico to become a primary account as well. Note that they are a little behind Nu here though.

  • Ads: Digital advertising is growing like a weed in LATAM!

  • Efficiency: They're rolling out robotics in warehouses and expect unit shipping costs to go down over time.

Risks:

  • LATAM Politics/Regulation: Governments in the region have a history of intervening in the economy. Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina are 95%+ of revenue. Mexican antitrust has already proposed rules that could force them to open up logistics, the outcome is TBD still though.

  • Currency/Inflation: Revenue is earned in reais, pesos, and Argentine pesos but reported in USD. If the Mexican peso falls 10%, Mexico revenue falls 10% in USD.

  • Credit: Credit portfolio grew 62% YoY to $17.9B in Q3 2026 and provisions for bad debt were up 65%. The obvious problem is that it is easy to issue loans but hard to do so while keeping default low and at scale. The key metrics to watch more closely are non performing loans (NPLs) each quarter.

  • Margin Compression: Market sentiment has been down recently in part because of worse margins. Q3 revenue was up 45% but nine-month operating income is down (~$1.97B vs. $2.31B). Part of the cause is the investment in logistics capacity, and part is credit costs. We need to watch if this is temporary or permanent!

  • Competition: Amazon, Shopee, Temu, AliExpress, and Nubank in fintech. PIX in Brazil is also taking share of everyday payments.

  • CEO Transition: Founder stepping back is always a risk, though he has publicly mentioned he will stay involved in capital allocation.

Valuation

A DCF is not very useful for Mercado Libre at face value, because the fintech segment distorts the cash flows. When they give out a loan, the cash leaving shows up as a negative in investing activities. When customers repay, the cash comes back in operating activities. On top of that, provisions for bad debt get deducted from net income but are added back in cash flow. So reported operating cash flow and FCF don't reflect what the business is actually earning, and any DCF built on them depends heavily on how you adjust for the loan book. This makes the business hard to value, so I'd rather keep it simple.

A historical valuation trend analysis will put us in the right ballpark. The P/E is a cleaner number here because the provision for doubtful accounts, R&D, and the logistics and shipping investments have already been taken out of it. The stock has averaged a P/E of about 68x since 2021 and is now around 36x, a 5 year low and roughly a 47% discount to its own average.

That discount is on a business that grew revenue 45% last quarter, is taking market share in ecommerce and ads, and has grown 30%+ for 31 straight quarters. The multiple has compressed even though the company has not slowed down.

My opinion - the market is clearly sour on the margin compression and economic uncertainty in LATAM right now, but the business is not showing any signs of slowing down. The cheapest multiple in a long time tells me this is likely a great opportunity to think about acquiring some shares.

Thoughts on MELI at these levels? Is the discount justified, or does it present a long-term opportunity?


r/ValueInvesting • • 5h ago

Discussion This selloff looks like 2018 with higher rates, and the Fed's loudest hawk may be bluffing

30 Upvotes

Been trying to make sense of the last two weeks and keep coming back to two threads that seem connected.

The first is how much this tape rhymes with the fourth quarter of 2018. A central bank tightening into a slowing economy, a market that kept trying to rebound and failing, volatility that stays bid instead of mean reverting in a day or two. The S&P 500 closed Friday at 6,910, down 8.6% on the week and about 11.5% below its high. The VIX closed at 35.89 and the MOVE index at 106, so bonds are stressed too, just less than equities. The difference from 2018 is the starting point. Rates are higher now, the 10 year sits near 4.9%, and there is less room for a quick policy rescue that does not reignite the inflation question.

The second thread is Christopher Waller. In London on November 10 and again on CNBC on November 18, he floated a 50 basis point hike in December unless the Fed can credibly signal 25 in December and another in January. That is a remarkable thing for a Fed governor to say into a falling market, and I think it is best read as expectations management rather than a genuine forecast. Look at the gap he is managing. Market based expectations look anchored, with the 10 year TIPS breakeven at 2.16%. Household expectations do not. The University of Michigan survey has one year expectations at 3.7% and five to ten year expectations at 3.3%. Bond traders do not set wages and prices. Households and workers do, and those are the expectations Waller is talking to. The signal works because it is costly. A governor willing to say hike into a selloff is hard to dismiss as cheap talk.

There is a wrinkle that cuts the other way. The November Michigan final, released Friday, showed one year expectations falling a full point from 4.7% in October to 3.7%, helped by cheaper gasoline, with AAA regular at $3.66. If the consumer leg of the expectations gap is closing on its own, the case for Waller's performance gets weaker heading into the December 8-9 meeting, and the November CPI print lands December 10, after the decision, so the committee votes without it.

For value investors the practical question is what this means for entry points. In 2018 the turn came when the policy rhetoric softened, not when the data did. If the same script holds, the signal to watch is language, not prints. Meanwhile the checklist of capitulation markers I follow sits at 16 of 21, which says stressed but not washed out.

Curious how others are weighing it. Are you treating this as a 2018 style multiple compression to buy into, or does the higher starting rate change the math on what a fair multiple even is?


r/ValueInvesting • • 5h ago

Discussion You should be glad when major stocks fall

29 Upvotes

If you are invested in the SPY this is a great opportunity to sell some SPY and transition to a major down sector in a bet to beat the market. If you are panicking and hurting you are simply taking too much risk at all time highs. Take risks by holding SPY and and then buying profitable tech on big drops has worked well for me. I'm buyer of NVDA all day right now. If a MAG7 is down big it's always a buy unless it's Tesla. I loaded up on Google and NVDA recently. Before that was Microsoft. It's too easy!


r/ValueInvesting • • 6h ago

Discussion Understanding extreme market movements (Why NVDA 13.5x vs. COST 50x)

8 Upvotes

For the record, I'm not an expert in this stuff, this is just my understanding and I think it's a decent framework for what happens during extreme market events. If it's not, feel free to let me know and let's discuss.

How are ultra short-term market movements relevant to value investing? Because it can have massive implications on price, and the price you pay is important for generating returns.

I wanted to make this post because a lot of people are confused how GOOG is trading at a 17x forward PE while COST is trading at ~50x forward. People will tie themselves in a knot trying to explain why this is rational. In my opinion, it isn't rational, and basically no one thinks it is.

I think many people have this fundamental assumption that stocks are bought because the buyer is bullish and sold because the seller is bearish. You see that everyone's bearish and you think "I oughta be bearish as well".

The problem is that in these extreme market movements, the sellers often times aren't bearish at all. Of course some people are, but a lot of the selling is truly forced, semi-forced, or algorithmic. Truly forced selling comes primarily from options expiring and margin calls. Quite literally, someone else is forcing them to sell the stock. You then have "semi-forced" selling, which includes general derisking, reducing leverage before a margin call hits, complying with certain requirements. And then you have algorithmic selling, think of a trend following system. The new trend is short equities, so trend followers close their longs and start piling into shorts. No one is deciding if that's the right decision, it's all rules-based.

What's important to remember about all of these sellers is the PE ratio is completely irrelevant to them. The earnings outlook is completely irrelevant. It's as relevant to them as whether you ate eggs or cereal for breakfast. Nothing is relevant besides mechanical and technical movements. Not saying there aren't any fundamental sellers, of course there are but a lot of selling pressure isn't fundamentally driven at all.

I think this sell-off has been especially extreme because of how much leverage was in the system. Margin calls trigger more margin calls which becomes this scary downward spiral. Is it over? I have no idea, but my point is simply that you shouldn't think there are rational people selling GOOG or NFLX or whatever else to buy COST right now. You're not crazy, it doesn't make any sense, but when you understand the amount of short-term money, options expiration, margin calls, and everything else, you at least understand why it's happening.

Not financial advice.

EDIT: To be clear, the point of this post is NOT to argue that NVDA or GOOG are good buys right now. I happen to believe that, but it's not the point of the post. The point is simply that market movements don't necessarily tell us what the market expects to happen over the next 1, 3, 6, 12 months.


r/ValueInvesting • • 6h ago

AI-Written Content Melrose(MRO.L) Investing Thesis

5 Upvotes

Disclaimer : this thesis was assisted with AI, mostly for the DCF and IRR calculations. I tried to make this thesis readable and understandable for someone who isn't familiar with finance or the aerospace industry. I hope these all align with the rules of the sub, I am a bit newer here, and I welcome feedback!

Models are IRR based with no macro weights.

Melrose owns GKN Aerospace, a British company that makes parts for jet engines and airplanes. Its best feature is a set of long-term deals on 19 jet-engine models. Melrose helped pay to develop those engines, and in return it gets a fixed slice of the money each engine earns for its whole working life, often 30 to 40 years, mostly from spare parts and repairs. Every new engine delivered adds decades of future income, and airlines can't easily switch suppliers once an engine is flying. Demand is strong: airlines have long waiting lists for new planes and are flying their older ones harder. The puzzle is that most of the profit Melrose reports today is money it has earned on paper but won't collect in cash for years. Investors are sceptical, so the shares are priced as if much of that cash may never fully arrive. If it arrives even roughly on the company's timetable, my model suggests the shares could return about 16% a year over the next decade.

The risks are real. The whole case depends on that promised cash showing up, and so far it hasn't. Last year Melrose generated only about £44 million of cash on its own, and a further £81 million came from selling its unpaid customer bills early(Free cash flow metrics after factoring). It has also borrowed money to buy back its own shares, at prices higher than today's. Growth has slowed recently, and plane makers keep missing their production targets. A recession or a fuel-price shock that grounds planes would cut both new engine orders and repair work. My model is most sensitive to growth: if the business grows 2.5 points a year slower than we assume, the expected return falls to roughly 11.5%, and 5 points slower drops it below 9%. There is also a court and insurance fight over a chemical leak at a California factory: Chubb filed a lawsuit asking a federal court to determine that it does not owe coverage, so Melrose may end up paying the roughly $125 million settlement itself. In a bad scenario the shares could be down about 28% five years from now.

In Summary, you don't need the bull case to come true to do well here: even if management hits its 2029 cash target several years late, you still beat the market. My model gets to roughly 16% a year over ten years just from cash catching up with reported profit. If it goes wrong, you're looking at maybe a 28% loss over five years, against about 2.5xing your money if it goes right.


r/ValueInvesting • • 7h ago

Discussion Constellation vs Topicus: which are you leaning to today?

6 Upvotes

These two get mentioned a lot together. Both are favorites here in this sub.

Since the March drops, CSU has bounced back a lot better. Tropicus stock is still dragging its feet.

If you were to start a position today, which would you allocate more to?

Cheers


r/ValueInvesting • • 7h ago

Investing Tools My adaptation of Peter Lynch's "earnings line"

2 Upvotes

Esteemed value investors - I've built a layer of checking the valuation of a company and I want to ask for your opinion - does it work and is it useful?

I am doing my valuation calculations before hand; so this method is just an extra validation step for the promising companies i find. It would work a bit easier with snapshots, but images are not allowed here so i will explain the method and then post the TradingView Pine Script.

The idea comes from Peter Lynch, in One Up on Wall Street: the prices follows the company's long term profit (earnings). On the chart, he was drawing a straight line following a P/E of 15. His idea was that when a company trades consistently below the P/E line, it is a sign of the company being undervalued.

The method in the book looks robust (and it probably is), the problem is it does not fit all companies; a software company has a different "normal" multiple compared to a, say, shipping company.

What I changed:

  • I used the 5 year average EPS instead of last year's EPS, to smoothen the cycles (you can change this to 2 or 3 years EPS if the analyzed company has less history on the market)

  • The multiple I used is the respective company's average P/E in the last 5 years - its own "normal"

  • The line then becomes: average EPS x company P/E. Below the line, I add a "safety margin line" - the same line minus a 30% discount (this can be tweaked as you see fit).

  • Explained in the text, as a stop light: price above line; price between line and safety margin; price below safety margin line

What does the script show, in addition. I thought these would be relevant:

  • PEG in Lynch's style: P/E divided by the real EPS growth

  • Warnings: incomplete median, unstable multiple, depressed base

What i found since i started using the script:

  • Value traps: a stock can become cheap for a good reason, and the line doesn't see why the profit has dropped.

  • Warnings are important: a "depressed base" warning pretty much makes the graphic useless

  • The multiple that is calibrated on its own history inherits the historical mistakes: a company that has always been expensive can remain "correct" if only looking at the earnings line.

  • Only to be used after the main analysis is done, as an additional validation layer.

The core of the script is this:

epsAuto      = array.avg(epsHistory) * 4     // average EPS over the last N years, annualized
dailyPE      = close / eps                   // P/E every day
multiple     = array.median(peHistory)       // median P/E over ~5 years = the company's own "normal"
earningsLine = eps * multiple                // the line
mosLevel     = earningsLine * (1 - mos)      // margin of safety level

I published the script here, if you want to test it: TradingView script - Open source


r/ValueInvesting • • 7h ago Bravo

Discussion This Is Just Fear

151 Upvotes

This market downturn is not a bubble busting. This is just a correction for a new technology with valuations that got a bit ahead of themselves.

For those doubting AI… and don’t truly understand it… This tech is REVOLUTIONARY… it will be more disruptive than the internet, nuclear tech, and the railroads combined.

I’m a staff software engineer at a big tech company and our ~1000 engineers have anual AI spend bills in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Each engineer’s output has 3x or 4x what it was pre-AI. In other words, this technology is here and it’s here to stay.

This is not the Dot com bubble, these companies, even NVDA are racking in real money… this isn’t pets.com.

The circular financing isn’t that weird either. NVDA was just acting like a bank, providing credit for the neoclouds to build out their infrastructure in exchange for buying their chips… same thing as a bank with just the middle man removed.

The only risk to AI is if the cost of inference (the act of answering your prompt) goes down dramatically (> 5x). If that happens then I would say yes, the hardware and neoclouds are in a bubble.

Of course there’s a political risk too. Americans are turning on AI tech mostly due to the insane velocity of the build out. However, besides the Bernie’s and AOCs of the world. Moderate Dems will not meaningfully slow the buildout. Building data centers means good blue collar jobs… think electricians making $400k per year… AI just needs better marketing.

I think the current market downturn is nearly over. NVDA at 50% off and neoclouds at 65% off means the sellout is likely overdone.

On Friday I started buying hand over fist… Growth funds, NVDA, Oracle, and VOO too. Do not fret this isn’t it… it’s just a market correction.


r/ValueInvesting • • 8h ago

Discussion Does anyone understand basic economics anymore? It’s a big reason why we’re selling off.

0 Upvotes

Does anyone really understand economics anymore?

The surprise and confusion underpinning the recent stock market sell-off demonstrate our collective economic illiteracy. Democrats swept into office on the backs of voters hoping to see policy initiatives to boost “affordability” without understanding the incentives such policies would create. Stoping the data center buildout, raising taxes, foisting fear-driven regulation on industries that would literally be the main source of meaningful growth and revenue for social programs, and just generally going after wealth and success all incentivize individuals, business, and corporations to change their behavior in response to UNFAVORABLE future market conditions. Anyone who expects government policy to improve market conditions, or their individual lot, is in for a rude awakening.

The same lack of awareness goes for our friends in the stock market. I keep seeing desperate posts by AI stock bag holders demanding answers for the sell-off, claiming it “makes no sense.” Well
Guess what, it makes plenty of sense for those who understand economics. Hyper-scaler investment, chip company earnings, and domestic regulations have all become subject to heaps of uncertainty that simply didn’t exist before the last election. Once probable hyper-investment investment by portions of the Mag 7 now looks in doubt, which throws into question the availability of compute and the future earnings of chip makers. The potential government response to the Nvidia scandal further mars the certainty and sustainability of the AI buildout. It’s now unclear when the company at the center of this buildout will be free and clear of any accountability. Not to mention, we don’t even really know the scale or extent of the scandal at this point. How can investors be certain about any chip makers’ earnings forecasts when those earnings may be subject to a macro/government-induced slowdown?

Collectively we need to return to a basic understanding that government policy can either create positive or negative incentives for market operators. Economies don’t exist in a vacuum and gaming out the second, third, and even fourth order effects of “policies/incentives” is often going to have more of an impact on the economy than the actual intent of any law or policy.


r/ValueInvesting • • 8h ago

Discussion "Buy the Dip" mentality

18 Upvotes

Posting for discussion and gathering opinions and data.

We have all been digesting the recent correction and reading various posts and opinions on Reddit. There are plenty of "is this the bottom?" posts or also "there's still a ways to go" posts.

There are also a lot of "what you are buying?" posts, and I feel that even the "is this the bottom?" posts are said with an eye toward finding the bottom to jump in and buy.

This leads me to my question. Is "buying the dip" so ingrained in the modern investing psychology that we can avoid some of the major crashes that might have taken place in the past?

I was an investor during the dot com crash and the GFC (and COVID and Tariff tantrum, etc), so I know there can be major, major drops. But none of the catalysts and macro horrors that happened then are really in place now. This might be a mild version of a dot com-style bubble, but not nearly to that extent.

I would throw a few more logs on the bonfire of discussion... a lot of financial media declared that retail investors were the savvy ones in recent dip-buying rebounds (I personally could hardly believe the rally from March to July). Passive investing is far more prominent than past corrections/crashes. Modern investors are generally more educated about the long-term "up and to the right" tendency of stocks.


r/ValueInvesting • • 8h ago

Buffett BRK beating FAANG + Microsoft over 5 yrs chart

7 Upvotes

I was watching a documentary about Warren Buffet which made me curious to check on the charts.

Last time I did the same chart was around 2022 when we were going through a similar drawdown in the market.

Whenever the markets are growing top right, I always wonder why are people still buying a dud like BRK, but always get humbled during times like these.


r/ValueInvesting • • 8h ago

Detailed Investment Analysis Option flows and ETF rotations, what you need to know to not get hooked into false narratives

0 Upvotes

I'm seeing a ton of Reddit posts complaining that their whatever stock is at 9 P/E while some other whatever stock is at 50 P/E. Other people comment with narratives of how "rational" or "irrational" the market is being on these stocks. This is not how the modern stock market works and knowing this is extremely important to not get hooked into value traps or make assumptions that aren't going to hold long term.

Futures and options control most of the flow of the market at the index level. What happens when a really heavy component of the QQQ like Nvidia gets aggressively sold off by institutional investors? The ETF mechanically rotates to maintain QQQ's price level at a certain price via puts closing and/or dealers and market makers hedging. If this did not occur, indexes would have extremely wild swings and the normal functioning of the market wouldn't be stable.

How does this rotation happen? Other components of QQQ, for example, are mechanically bought by arbitrage bots who exploit the spread created by the temporary dislocation between the ETF, the futures, and the options. This is why Walmart and Costco are trading at insanely high valuations. A lot of heavyweight components of QQQ are being sold off but the ETF itself must mechanically rebalance to keep the price at a certain level. Walmart and Costco are both in QQQ, therefore they are a pressure release valve for the money flowing out of tech and hardware.

If you need any clarification on any of this, run my post through AI. I don't use it myself. Just don't get trapped into thinking that stocks at 9 P/E are the market being irrational or rational or stocks at 50 P/E are the market being irrational or rational. The market is moving mechanically and index-level derivatives control almost the entire market and its components regardless of "fundamentals". Don't get suckered into buying either the stuff the market is unloading because it "looks cheap", or into buying the stuff the market looks like it's "buying" just because the price is going up.


r/ValueInvesting • • 10h ago

Discussion Anchoring Bias

4 Upvotes

You have $10,000 worth of a stock.

It falls 50%.

Does having a cost basis that is low make this better?

I notice a lot of people saying things like "My position dropped 50% but I don't care because my cost basis is low"

Is this not a form of anchoring bias?

I do not understand it. The decision to sell, take profits, buy or whatever else should surely just be based on whatever the EV of the decision is, no? Which is unaffected by cost basis.

Do people agree or disagree with my take on this? Is this valid to say "I don't care if it drops because I bought in low"?


r/ValueInvesting • • 10h ago

Discussion BRK: Feeding Frenzy?

0 Upvotes

The B stock has remained fairly resilient in this downturn, still significantly up from being under $500 for much of the year. Full disclosure, I averaged in around that price. In after hours Friday the price climbed a modest buck to $571, we're looking at trailing P/E just under 16, 52W low around $464.

Not looking at it as a value pick currently, but maybe as more as a hedge and a potential market mover/indicator of institutional intent.

Regardless of my opinion, the company is of some interest because of the current market uncertainty that has forced valuations down. Rising Fed rates/inflation issue, market manipulation scandals, foreign policy and post-midterm uncertainty, I don't think they are the only large cash position poised for buys considering the reports of institutions and big money going into capital defense mode. That said, most aren't sitting on, what, $360 billion as of last reports? We've been talking about it for over a year it seems, what do they do with their cash?

Alphabet is as cheap or cheaper now than any of their previous buys. I imagine a double-down may occur there, but I find myself interested in what else they may scoop up right now. They've maybe had one or two similar recent opportunities (maybe this one is better) but the previous tech-friendly buy of Alphabet may be a signal that they are more interested in tech than previous eras. Especially under this leadership transition, I don't imagine they sit out in the coming week or two completely.

What do you guys think? Enough cash and cachet to create momentum, or still no touchy stocky stock?


r/ValueInvesting • • 11h ago

Stock Analysis MU is down 51% since June and hasn't missed a number

48 Upvotes

AI took the world's memory wafers. An HBM stack (the memory next to every GPU) uses about three times the wafer of a normal chip, so every one made is fewer chips for phones, PCs and servers. Micron didn't ship five times as many bits. It shipped about 20% more and prices did the rest.

Quarterly revenue went from $11.3B to $54.2B in a year. Gross margin went from 45% to 87%. Next quarter is guided at $61.5B. Fiscal 2026 operating profit was $99B. The old record, in 2018, was $15B.

The customers confirm it. Tim Cook called it "a 100-year flood on the memory pricing". NVIDIA cut its own margin guide because of memory. Amazon raised 2026 capex by $20B and blamed memory.

Why the stock fell anyway

Three reasons, and none of them is dumb.

Memory stocks top when price increases slow down, not when prices fall. In September Micron said increases would continue "at a more moderate pace". SanDisk said "modest" a month later. The whole group peaked the same week in June.

Supply is coming. Lam expects chip tool spending above $200B in 2027, up from the mid-$150s, led by DRAM.

And everyone remembers how this ends. In 2018 Micron's gross margin was 61%. A year later it was 29%. In fiscal 2023 it was negative.

Then November happened: the AI buyers are borrowing to pay for capex, NVIDIA lost its CEO and picked up an SEC inquiry, and the whole chip group sold off. MU fell 14% on Friday alone with no news of its own.

Why I think it's overdone

It's the whole group, and Micron is the best of it. Western Digital is down 65% from its high, Seagate, Lam and Applied about 58%. Micron fell least, and it's the one with contracts.

The contracts are new. Micron has 26 five-year take-or-pay agreements. Customers can't cancel, they've put up $12.75B in cash deposits, and the 10-K says that even at the floor prices, gross margin would be "meaningfully above our peak quarterly margins in any past cycle". That peak was 61%. More than 75% of fiscal 2027 shipments are committed.

Supply is physically late. Tools need cleanrooms, and most of the new ones open in late 2028. SK hynix says its DRAM and HBM are sold out through 2029.

The cash is real. $90B of operating cash last year, more than net income. About $55B of net cash after counting the deposits as debt. And a $35B buyback becomes usable on December 9, which is about 5% of the company at this price. Micron has never bought back more than $2.7B in a year.

The price

Market cap is about $680B. That's 8x trailing earnings and about 4x the guided quarter annualized. Take out the net cash and you're paying for roughly three and a half years of earnings at the current rate, for a product that the biggest supplier says is sold out for three.

Where I could be wrong

  • The floors are a slice. Floor-priced commitments are about $33B for the next twelve months against a $246B revenue pace. They protect a margin on part of the output, not today's prices.

  • A 90% margin on phone memory is a shortage price. That part goes away when supply shows up, contracts or not.

  • "We'll add capacity with discipline" is what the industry said before every past bust.

  • Customers are already designing around it: shorter HBM stacks, less memory per PC.

  • Insiders sold $341M over the past year, nearly all on preset plans. One director bought, in January, at $337.

  • Even at this price you need "normal" after the boom to be far above anything before it. By my math, roughly $50B of operating profit a year, about three times the 2018 record.

Where I land

At $1,200 the stock needed memory to be a permanently different business. At $594 it needs the shortage to last about as long as the contracts and the cleanroom schedules already say, and then a normal that's about half of last year. I can't prove the second part until 2028. But the market is charging for the bust up front while the company is still raising guidance, and I think that's the better side of the bet to be on. Next test is the December quarter report in a few weeks, and what they do with the buyback.

Not advice. I have a position in MU.

Long version with the contract math, the supply timeline and the peer tables: "tickerbell.com/research/micron-ai-made-memory-scarce-what-contracts-lock-in"


r/ValueInvesting • • 11h ago

Stock Analysis Keep calm and consider NVDA

0 Upvotes

1. The business

NVIDIA doesn't sell chips anymore, it sells the rack: GPUs, CPU, networking and software as one system. By its own numbers it gets about $40B of every gigawatt of AI data center with Vera Rubin, up from $18B two generations ago. A whole gigawatt costs about $60B to build, so NVIDIA is two-thirds of it.

The custom-chip worry is real for the big clouds. But 45% of data center revenue now comes from AI clouds, governments and enterprises, who can't design their own chips, and that half grew 138% in a year.

The quarter reported on November 17, five days after the CEO left: revenue $115.8B (up 103%, $8B above guidance), Vera Rubin about $20B in its first quarter, and next year's outlook raised from about 70% growth to about 75%.

The real bear case was there before any of this news. NVIDIA has started financing its customers: $118B of guarantees (mostly OpenAI's leases), about $110B of equity stakes, and payment terms of up to a year. And the hyperscalers now borrow to pay for capex. Keep that in mind, because it comes back in part 3.

2. Jensen leaving

He resigned on November 12. The 8-K gives no reason. The press reporting centers on a Singapore customer that's reportedly under US investigation for moving chips to China.

That week NVDA fell 11% while AMD, Broadcom and Arista rose 21-30%. So that drop was all NVIDIA's own.

How much does it matter? For the next year, less than the headlines. Rubin is already ramping, supply is signed, and the interim CEO raised the outlook days later. I looked at earlier abrupt CEO exits (HP, Intel, McDonald's, BP, Apple). In each one, the following year tracked the business and the successor, not the exit. Where it matters is 2028 and after, when someone else picks the products and negotiates the deals. And the CFO is now also the CEO, which is fine for a few months and bad for longer.

The bigger issue is exports. Past export fines ran from $140M to $1.2B. NVIDIA made $43.8B of free cash flow last quarter, so a fine isn't the risk. Rules are. On November 16 Commerce started requiring licenses for advanced chips going to data centers in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil. That shrinks the market somewhat. China itself was already out of guidance.

3. The SEC probe

Nothing is in a filing. WSJ says the inquiry is about disclosures, Reuters says "potential accounting issues". Neither says which ones.

First thing I checked: since the resignation NVDA is down 24.5%. AMD is down 27.5%, Micron 25.5%, Marvell 25.6%. Most of the recent fall is the sector, not the probe.

Second: where would an accounting review look? In nine months, $60.6B of net income didn't show up as operating cash. $42.6B of that is receivables, $25.5B is paper gains on stakes, $18.4B is inventory for Rubin. That's the financing question from part 1 again. But customers are paying: $122.7B of operating cash in nine months, and free cash flow went from 41% of profit to 69% last quarter.

Third: I looked at eight past SEC and export cases. Leaving out ZTE, which broke the rules knowingly, fines were $5.5M to $300M and didn't matter. What hurt was a late filing, an auditor quitting, or a restatement. Super Micro's worst days were exactly those (-19% and -33%), and its stock is still 62% lower two years on even though revenue grew 2.6x. NVIDIA filed its last three 10-Qs on earnings day. This one isn't out yet and is due by December 4. That's the date I care about.

What the price assumes

About $3.0T market cap. Roughly 13x this fiscal year's earnings and under 8x next year's if they hit the guide. I ran a reverse DCF at a 9% discount rate with margins fading from 64% to 55%. For $125 to be fair, NVIDIA has to hit next year's number and then see revenue fall about 13% a year for five years. Put differently, if next year is the peak, revenue could halve the year after and the price would still be fair. If revenue just stays flat after next year, the return from here is about 14% a year.

Where I could be wrong

  • The 10-Q is late, or comes with a restatement or a control weakness. Then Super Micro is the right comparison and cheap can stay cheap for years.

  • Export rules spread beyond those five countries.

  • The buyers are borrowing. If credit tightens, capex stops fast, and NVIDIA has its own balance sheet behind some of those customers.

  • No permanent CEO, and insiders sold $1.87B in a year and bought nothing, including after the drop.

  • These inquiries take two to four years. The overhang won't lift quickly.

Where I land

The price assumes the AI build-out peaks next year and then unwinds by half. Nothing in the numbers says that yet. The CEO exit is mostly a 2028 problem, and the probe is a question about trust in the profit line more than about demand. So until the 10-Q is out I'm looking at cash flow, not EPS. If the 10-Q arrives on time with the accounting unchanged, I think the discount is too deep. If it doesn't, I'll change my mind.

Not advice. I have a position.

I wrote all three versions up with the filing sources, the case tables and the math here: "www.tickerbell.com/research/nvidia-sells-the-ai-factory-helps-pay-for-it"


r/ValueInvesting • • 11h ago

Discussion Real Talk - Micron (MU)

61 Upvotes

Market is pricing in a massive drop to their revenues in the near term, ostensibly caused by the supply gap closing for DRAM. My problem is that all of the memory suppliers are talking about long term strategic supply agreements and capacity booked out already beyond a year. This is unheard of in their industry! I did a quick review on their 10-Qs from their previous margin highs and this commentary was nowhere to be seen. These guys would get sued into oblivion if they were overstating their commentary, so I see it as credible.

At 3 Forward PE, Micron only needs a handful of years of earnings to literally buy itself off the market at this valuation. So, if we can credibly say 2027 will have the expected high earnings, and that the 26 take or pay agreements extend beyond 2027, buffering them from swings in their market, why would we value Micron for an imminent drop in margin?

For reference the market typically drops their price 1 to 2 quarters before the earnings fall off a cliff. Longest lag I saw was 2 quarters in the 2018 cycle.

For me, this drop is a massive over-reaction. What do you think?


r/ValueInvesting • • 12h ago

Discussion Mohnish Pabrai’s ETF - WAGN

1 Upvotes

Has anyone considered investing in value investor Mohnish Pabrai’s ETF, WAGN? Like his hedge fund it is concentrated into many natural resource and foreign companies. The annual return on his hedge fund is something like 12.5% since 1999, which is higher than the S&P at like 9%.


r/ValueInvesting • • 12h ago

Discussion The first number I check in any pharma annual report now isn't earnings

2 Upvotes

It's how much revenue loses patent protection in the next five years.

Most big drugmakers list expiration dates for their key products in the 10-K. Add up the revenue from everything expiring within five years, divide by total revenue, and you get a rough size for the hole they need to fill. Crude, but it reframes the stock fast. A company at a low P/E with 40% of revenue rolling off isn't necessarily cheap. The market may just be doing this math before you.

Two nuances that changed how I read it:

Pill drugs and biologics don't fall off the same way. Simple small-molecule drugs can lose most of their sales within a year or two of generics. Biologics tend to erode more slowly because biosimilars are harder to make and slower to be adopted.

Medicare negotiation stacks on top of this. Under the current rules, small-molecule drugs can face negotiated prices about 9 years after approval, versus 13 for biologics. So for some pill-based drugs, the pricing hit arrives before the patent cliff does.

Then I look at the other side: how much of the hole is covered by drugs that are already approved or in late-stage trials. Early-stage pipeline I mostly ignore, because I can't judge it.

Does anyone weight acquisitions differently here? Buying a pipeline fills the hole, but the premiums lately make me skeptical.


r/ValueInvesting • • 12h ago

Buffett Warren Buffett: Diversification is Protection Against Ignorance

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger discuss conventional advice about diversification.


r/ValueInvesting • • 13h ago

Discussion The stock market is currently experiencing a downturn, and I feel like this might be a good opportunity to start investing while prices are relatively low. Which sectors do you think are most likely to recover once this is all over?

64 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this is a bit of a basic question, but which sectors (technology, healthcare, oil and gas, etc.) do you think are most likely to recover and bounce back once the market stabilises?