r/ValueInvesting • • Jun 04 '26

Discussion If you stripped the ticker name off GME's balance sheet, this sub would be calling it a textbook value play

18 Upvotes

I know even typing those three letters is basically a felony here, but hear me out before the mods ban my account.

We spend all day on this sub complaining that we can’t find any real deep value plays, but the ultimate value turnaround setup might literally be staring us in the face under the most hated ticker on Earth. If you ignore the Reddit hype and just look at the actual math from the latest full-year numbers, it’s honestly hilarious how well it fits the classic value checklist.

First of all, the balance sheet is wild. They have $9.01 billion in cash and marketable securities. Yes, they raised about $4.16 billion in long-term debt to secure it, but they locked it in at a ridiculous 0% coupon rate. Even factoring in the debt, their net liquidity floor is massive. With the market cap sitting around $10 billion, you are buying a fortress asset base at an absurdly close ratio, with the actual operating business thrown in on the cheap.

Second, the "dying brick and mortar" isn’t even dying anymore. Net income shot up 219% to $418.4 million for the year. EPS scaled from $0.02, to $0.33, and is now at $0.93. Trailing P/E is sitting around 17x-23x. If any other company put up triple-digit net income growth with a massive net cash cushion like that, this sub would be writing 4,000-word love letters to management.

Speaking of management, the board just authorized a $2 billion share buyback through 2029. Ryan Cohen takes zero salary and is entirely paid in equity, so unless he hates money, authorizing billions for a buyback heavily implies they think the shares are insanely mispriced.

Everyone's big bear case is that nobody buys plastic discs in malls anymore. Sure. But with that massive pile of dry powder, they don't even need to sell video games. They can just buy a bunch of boring, cash-flowing businesses and turn GME into a glorified holding company.

When Warren Buffett bought Berkshire Hathaway, it was literally a failing textile mill. He just used the carcass of a dying business to fund an insurance empire. Is Ryan Cohen about to pull off the ultimate boomer value play?

So, what do you say? Are you ready to finally become an ape?


r/ValueInvesting • • Dec 11 '25

Discussion Is THIS the cheapest AI play in the entire market?

0 Upvotes

ADOBE! Yes, I know, it has been discussed a lot here and guess what? I’ve personally pulled the trigger on this stock just a few minutes ago buying at $353. The fears of this company being disrupted by AI are not panning out which have set up a GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY! As far as valuation goes we are looking at a forward PE of around 15 with a YoY revenue growth of 11%. That is CHEAP!

Looking for a VALUE in the tech sector that is participating in AI? Look no further than ADOBE IN MY OPINION!

What do yall think? Was buying ADBE at $353 a smart move or stupid?


r/ValueInvesting • • Oct 05 '25

Discussion Thanks for mentioning GOOG, UNH and Now KSPI kind of stocks.

1 Upvotes

Some people were saying , don’t take advice from this subreddit.

Well it’s true and not true at the same time.

These days UPS and overseas stocks like KSPI getting attention in this sub, which is good as those are good fundamentally strong companies.

But also, there are some people trying to pump AMC kind of stocks.

Now it’s up to you which ones fits in your portfolio.

I took advice from this subreddit and brought GOOG, UNH.

And hey, thanks for your attention to this matter 😂.


r/ValueInvesting • • Jul 02 '25

Discussion “I’d never touch that company.”

5 Upvotes

I am constantly seeing "investors" saying, “I’d never touch that company.”

That mindset tells me one thing: they’re emotional, not rational. Real investing has nothing to do with what you like. It’s all about what you pay vs. what it’s worth.

Take Coinbase. I don’t believe in cr*pto long term. I think most of it is hype. But if you offered me the whole company for a dollar, I’d take it instantly. They’re profitable. I’d make my money back fast and let the rest ride.

I don’t need to like the business. I just need the math to work.

Even Buffett has bought junk companies before. Not because he loved them, but because the price made sense. That’s what real investors do.


r/ValueInvesting • • Jul 07 '25

Discussion Why you are losing if you don’t invest at all-time-highs

0 Upvotes

A study of the S&P 500 shows that investing at all-time-highs beat investing on any other day.

In fact, the outperformance over the next 1-year, 3-year and 5-year periods are 0.3%, 1.8% and 1.7%.

https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2025/07/investing-a-lump-sum-at-all-time-highs-2/

This counterintuitive result debunks the popular myth of “buying high and selling low” when trading at ATHs.

This effect is even more pronounced as many of the best days of gains cluster around ATHs.

As studies have shown that missing just the top 10 best days cuts your 10-year return in half, not investing around ATHs becomes an even greater opportunity cost.

With both the S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 trading at ATHs now, will you be making that same mistake again?


r/ValueInvesting • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion META - strongest moat amongst MAG7

0 Upvotes

At what point do people agree that Mark Zuckerberg might be one of the greatest CEOs in history?

Reminder that he has never held a job other than at Meta his entire life. Started the business from a college dorm and continues to run it to this day at the age of 42

Completely changed his entire branding for the sake of saving the business. Pivoted a bunch of times when necessary.

Copied every last thing that was good about any of his competitors (Snapchat stories, acquired Instagram, Reels)

On top of that, he is one of the only founders of a business that scale who hasn't gotten a second wife or a divorce.


r/ValueInvesting • • Nov 24 '24

Discussion Not seeing any discussion of Milei/Argentina

0 Upvotes

For those of you who have been living under a rock, Argentina elected a new President last year who has been gutting their bloated/corrupt government (sound familiar?) and has rapidly turned their country around, stripping out regulations, reducing poverty, and reducing inflation.

Since elected, ARGT is up 100%, yet there are no posts on it on this supposed value sub. Would love to hear your thoughts.

UPDATE: ITT, a bunch of pitchforks who don’t understand what’s actually happening in Argentina and a small group of people citing on-the-ground observations and statistics and quietly explaining that what I’m positing is accurate.


r/ValueInvesting • • Mar 10 '23

Stock Analysis Is SVB a value play?

45 Upvotes

Hi

Banks are a little out of my circle of competence, but not so much that I won't invest in them.

SVB is THE headline now, and I'm wondering if it might be a value play, trading under BV.

From my short research it seems the current BV doesn't mean a lot, since if SVB has to sell it's bonds at current prices it will lose it's entire positive BV.

I'll be glad if we can open a discussion here, the risk factors for SVB, and how to evaluate it's IV.

It's important to figure out the risk vs. the uncertainty.

Thanks

Edit - I'm bewildered at how many people will downvote the most simple discussion. And more important aren't willing to discuss something open minded.

I remember all the people downvoting and ripping anyone suggesting that META was a good play when it crashed. Well that didn't play out good for them.

C'mon people, just because you think an investment isn't a good one, that doesn't mean you need to discourage the conversation, and besides you can always be wrong.


r/ValueInvesting • • Mar 04 '25

Value Article Wall Street is WRONG about artificial intelligence: the Bull Case for Google and NVIDIA

24 Upvotes

I originally posted this on Medium but wanted to share it here.

Yesterday, I called a local Mexican joint to inquire about the status of my order.

“Who” picked up my order isn’t the right question. “What” is more appropriate.

She sounded beautiful. She was articulate, didn’t frustrate me with her limited understanding, and talked in ordinary, human natural language.

Once I needed a representative, she naturally transitioned me to one. It was a seamless experience for both me and the business.

Wall Street is WRONG about the AI revolution.

Understanding NVIDIA’s price drop and the AI picture in Wall Street’s Closed Mind

With massive investments in artificial intelligence, much of Wall Street now sees it as a fad because large corporations are having trouble monetizing AI models.

They think that just because Claude 3.7 Sonnet can’t and will never replace a $200,000/year software engineer, that AI has no value.

This is illustrated with NVIDIA’s stock price.

Pic: NVIDIA is down 14% this week

After blockbuster earnings, NVIDIA dropped like a tower in the middle of September. Even after:

  • Providing strong guidance for next year – Rueters

  • Exceptional revenue in their automotive industry, making them poised to become their next “billion-dollar” business – CNBC

  • A lower PE ratio than most of its peers while having double the revenue growth – NexusTrade

Their stock STILL dropped. Partially because of economic factors like Trump’s war on our biggest allies, but also because of Wall Street’s lack of faith in AI.

Want to create a detailed stock report for ANY of your favorite stock? Just click the “Deep Dive” button in NexusTrade to create a report like this one!

They think that because most companies are failing to monetize AI, that it’s a “bubble” like cryptocurrency.

But with cryptocurrency, even the most evangelistic supporters fail to articulate a use-case that a PostgresSQL database and Cash App can’t replicate. With AI, there are literally thousands.

Not “literally” as in “figuratively”. “Literally” as in “literally.

And the biggest beneficiaries aren’t billion-dollar tech giants.

It’s the average working class American.

The AI Revolution is about empowering small businesses

Thanks to AI, a plethora of new-aged companies have emerged with the fastest revenue growth that we have ever seen. Take Cursor for example.

In less than 12 months, they reached over $100 million in annual recurring revenue. This is a not a business with 1,000 employees; this is a business with 30.

I’m the same way. Thanks solely due to AI, I could build a fully-feature algorithmic trading and financial research platform in just under 3 years.

Without AI, this would’ve cost me millions. I would’ve had to raise money to hire developers that may not have been able to bring my vision to life.

AI has enabled me, a solo dev, to make my dream come true. And SaaS companies like me and Cursor are not the only beneficiaries.

All small business owners benefit. Even right now, you can cheaply implement AI to:

  • Automate customer support

  • Find leads that are interested in your business

  • Write code faster than ever before possible

  • Analyze vast quantities of data that would’ve needed a senior-level data scientist

This isn’t just speculation. Small business owners are incorporating AI at an alarming rate.

Pic: A table comparing AI adopting for small businesses to large businesses from 2018 to 2023

In fact, studies show that AI adoption for small businesses was as low as 3% in 2023. Now, that number has increased not by 40% in 2024…

It has increased to 40% in 2024.

Wall Street discounts the value of this, because we’re not multi-billion dollar companies or desperate entrepreneurs begging oligarchical venture capitalists to take us seriously. We’re average, everyday folks just trying to live life.

But they are wrong and NVIDIA’s earnings prove it. The AI race isn’t slowing down; it’s just getting started. Companies like DeepSeek, which trained their R1 model using significantly less computational resources than OpenAI, demonstrate that AI technology is becoming more efficient and accessible to a wider range of businesses and individuals.

So the next time you see a post about how “AI is dying” look at the post’s author. Are they a small business? Or a multi-million dollar commentator for the stock market.

You won’t be surprised by the answer.


r/ValueInvesting • • Oct 27 '25

Stock Analysis Wendy's Is a 3x+ Bagger From Current Prices

3 Upvotes

Wendy's is trading at a 9 PE, and has superior burgers to all the other QSR burgers. With how expensive fast food has gotten, people will expect higher quality from their fast food, and this is where Wendy's never frozen beef shines. Average QSR pe right now is 27. Wendy's has a massive amount of branding and stores, and recently is working with the man who managed to turn Taco Bell around from the gutter with his Dorito Taco Bell offering. I see Wendy's as a minimum 2x bagger from here, and if sentiment turns around for Wendy's we'll see it going 3-4x. If Wendy's cuts their dividend they'll be able to get their P/E even lower by paying down debt.

People thought UNH was dead at a 15 P/E just a few months ago, I believe Wendy's will triple people's money with their Project Fresh initiative that they announced 2 weeks ago. The stock has put in a bottom since that announcement, and management seems extremely focused on turning sentiment around with new marketing and branding. American Eagle's stock price doubled just from a Sidney Sweeney ad; the market is extremely pessimistic on Wendy's. Moreover, a moonshot could happen if Trump decides to have the government invest in Wendy's, we have seen Trump serve Wendy's at the White House in the past.

I full ported into AMD and UNH this year when sentiment was at absolute lows, and it is clear that WEN is currently at eye watering lows, and is definitely an acquisition target. Warren Buffet has publicly stated that he eats Wendy's as well. If Buffet buys in the stock will do a 50% move just like UNH did, just food for thought.

TLDR:
WEN MOON & WENDY'S WILL PRINT TENDY'S are not just memes


r/ValueInvesting • • May 28 '26

Discussion 99% of people here aren’t Value Investors at all

0 Upvotes

A lot of people online call themselves “value investors,” but honestly most portfolios I see are nowhere near diversified enough and often not focused enough on actual cash flow.

Owning 5-10 tech stocks and calling it value investing because some has a low P/E isn’t diversification.

In my opinion, long-term investing should include at least 30 different stocks across multiple sectors and countries. On top of that, broad index funds are important too - exposure to the US, Europe, Asia, and emerging markets helps reduce single-country risk and captures global growth.

Personally I own around 80 different stocks, mostly in Sweden, Norway, and the US, plus about 15 funds/ETFs including index funds, bonds, and a few niche funds.

Current portfolio yield is around 5,5 % with a YOC close to 8 %. Mostly dividend growers and quality cash-flow businesses, but also some higher-yield names with slower or a bit more unpredictable dividend growth like PFE, VZ, DX, HTGC and BWLPG to strengthen the income side.

Performance-wise, I’m roughly on par with my broad home index in Sweden, outperforming the Dow, and about even with the S&P 500 if you exclude dividends, with dividends I can expect (as of now) around 14% YTD performance.

The goal isn’t to get rich from one or a couple of hype stocks that may have low forward P/E.

The goal is building a portfolio that can survive crashes, generate cash flow, compound over decades, and still let you sleep at night.

The goal is a cash-flow machine.


r/ValueInvesting • • Aug 02 '24

Discussion Please stop telling people to Invest in ETFs and Index Funds

3 Upvotes

Index funds and ETFs are fantastic for new and experienced investors alike as a low risk investment. BUT every single time I see a post that even slightly hints at the fact that OP is new to investing, every other comment is "if you don't know what you are doing then just stick it in the S&P and come back in 20 years." Which is ironically counter productive to the entire purpose of value investing. Should new individuals lean on index funds and ETFs as they learn more? Yes. Should they just not even bother to learn more as 99% of these comments suggest and just give up on value investing with ETFs and index funds as an alternative? No. Proper value investing provides you with the opportunity to outperform leading ETFs, THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT. So please, stop quickly dismissing newcomers as if you've somehow obtained a body of knowledge they could never learn themselves. We were all new to this at some point and we all started in a similar place. You should be willing to give real advice on value investing, if you can't do that then head over to r/ETFs where you can recommend ETFs to people all day and you'd actually be doing it in a sub that is meant for that. Peace.


r/ValueInvesting • • Dec 14 '24

Discussion Is it time to sell TSLA?

0 Upvotes

Basically the title. I bought after the 10% dip at the beginning of October. Entry price ~$211 PE ~60x. I was really happy to get a decent entry price given the multiples the stock has historically traded at. I love Elon, autonomous driving, the tsla semis, the new Q model I believe it is ($25k car), the robots, and his future thinking view of the company.

Unfortunately / fortunately the stock has doubled in the last 2 months mostly due to non-fundamental reasons. Financially, I want to split with the stock (sold half my holdings around $360), but I am too much of a fanboy to do it yet.

Would love to hear everyone’s thoughts. Thanks!


r/ValueInvesting • • Mar 11 '22

Discussion Buying $BABA is pure speculation for 90% of you.

0 Upvotes

the $BABA saga is just proof that people are desperate for a bargain.

most people here don’t understand geopolitics, logistics, international trade, the VIE structure, AliBaba’s competition, or the chinese government enough to even have an informed opinion on $BABA or it’s future cash flows, yet they’re bagholding. that’s not value investing, that’s speculation. it’s kinda disappointing to see so many people in this sub buying into this type of hype.

i’m not saying there isn’t money to be made in $BABA, but every investment is the present value of all future cash flows. if you can’t understand how geopolitics, logistics, international trade, the VIE structure, AliBaba’s competition, and the chinese government can all have a drastic impact on the future cash flows of $BABA, then you shouldn’t be buying the stock.


r/ValueInvesting • • Nov 27 '22

Stock Analysis What has Apple done in last 2 years to become 3X its stock price ?

2 Upvotes

Personally a fan of Apple and all good quality cash cow stocks, however I admit to not understand why the increased stock price of Apple over last 2 years is justified or not, given that its price has about doubled since 2019, but its sales has not doubled, so how can its account books justify present multiples to earnings of Apples price ? Are their recent stock buy backs so large as to double the stock price ? I can't help but think that its all because all pension funds are piling into index funds causing Appl to bubble. Open to all discussions on this

Thanks to all your valuable input

Edit : post title should be 2x not 3x


r/ValueInvesting • • May 20 '26

Stock Analysis Intuit is about to surge on earnings. This is why.

2 Upvotes

Intuit might not ring a bell to many, however it’s likely its products like Quickbooks and Mailchimp will.

The SaaS giant, whose portfolio also includes Turbotax and CreditKarma generates 20 billion dollars in Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) with traditional 80% gross and 20% net margins.

Even at this scale, Intuit posted 17% revenue growth last quarter, cementing its position as an elite SaaS company. Yet its stock is down 50% and cheaper than it was 5 years ago (despite the business having grown multiples in size since then).

Reasons for this downtrend are obvious. Fears that AI will make it cheaper for companies to ship code, lowering the cost of entry and lowering margins as well as SMBs building their own software in house.

This is what’s currently holding down Intuit stock, however it is already confirmed to be wrong by 2 factors.

First, all SaaS companies reporting have shown strong revenue growth, profitability and outlook - Monday, Atlassian, amongst others. For some stock has gone down even on good numbers like ServiceNow and Hubspot but all metrics were good signaling the market is strong.

Second, and perhaps most important, is the signal in the other direction. Both Anthropic and OpenAI have created divisions funded with billions to upsell their services to enterprise and when these systems are implementing on enterprise they actually integrate with both Quickbooks products and Salesforce products, making these two companies actual beneficiaries of the AI age for all of the data they sit on.

We’ll likely see a 15-20% surge around earnings, however as CRM and Adobe report within the next 30 days, it should be fairly certain soon that SaaS is here to stay and the market is going to rerate.


r/ValueInvesting • • Nov 10 '25

Discussion UNH - Why I am so bullish on this health insurance stock

0 Upvotes

UNH and other health insurance companies are extremely undervalued right now, even though there is a high possibility their earnings will grow exponentially in the future.

They have already started using AI to approve or deny claims, which has proven to increase their earnings by at least 15% by denying more insurance claims than before. This AI algorithm can be tweaked anytime on the go to increase earnings further.

This technique has caused a lot of hatred towards the company, which led to the death of the CEO, and the crash of the stock price earlier this year.

Once all the uncertainty settles down, the stock price will start going up again.

There is a very low chance the future denied patients will fight back, because 99% of them have no time and/or financial resources to afford it.

These are the ideal circumstances for healthcare insurance to thrive in the future and for us to make huge profits!


r/ValueInvesting • • 23d ago

Stock Analysis Google Is Still Expensive Despite a Nearly 10% Drop After Q3 Earnings.

Thumbnail
silentvalueinvestor.substack.com
178 Upvotes

Google is undoubtedly one of the best businesses in the world, but a great business does not necessarily make a great investment at any price.

Back in 2016, Buffett bought Apple traded at roughly 11.3x P/E. Forbes: Buffett's Apple Investment

Following its Q3 earnings release on October 28, Alphabet fell nearly 10% in after-hours trading, wiping out almost $400 billion in market value. Market reaction.

There are a few things that concern me:

  1. Valuation: Headline earnings are distorted by investment gains and losses from SpaceX and Anthropic. I prefer valuing Google based on its underlying operating incomes rather than relying on its reported P/E.

  2. AI spending: Q3 capex reached $51.4 billion, contributing to negative free cash flow of $9.1 billion. Management also expects capital spending to increase significantly in 2027.

  3. Search growth: Google Search revenue growth slowed to 12%, down from 17% in Q2, while AI continues to change how users search and how Google monetizes them.

At approximately $3.6 trillion in market cap after the selloff, I still don't see enough margin of safety. My preferred entry price is around $235 per share. I could be wrong or overly pessimistic about Google.

My view is bearish on valuation, not on Google's business.

I've written a more detailed analysis here:

Google Is Still Expensive Despite a Nearly 10% Drop After Q3 Earnings.

Thanks for reading! This post is public so feel free to share it.


r/ValueInvesting • • Jan 13 '26

Discussion What are your hot/controversial takes for massively overvalued / soon to die companies?

0 Upvotes

For me it is AAPL is the next Blackberry/Intel.

The plans for Siri relying on Gemini seems contradictory to their privacy moat and basically admittance of defeat. Their sexy design moat is also gone.

Their product innovation is stale AF - they used to drop fire every presentation now they just show the same phone with a new screen. The design is boring. Risk averse and ripe to be disrupted - you even look at small British companies like Nothing and think well at least they are trying to drop some new design or features with the AMOLED and lights all over it even though it is a minor tweak. Apple has no tweaks. I don't see or hear anything in their product pipeline that is particularly exciting. When is the last time Apple dropped something revolutionary where you are like 'damn I am gonna buy that'? What is even the growth part of their business, they don't even do AWS type shit as far as I know?


r/ValueInvesting • • Dec 12 '24

Discussion This sub is broken

0 Upvotes

People in this sub seem to dislike the idea of investing in China and are instead pouring their money into highly speculative and overvalued tech stocks. How is that considered value investing? It seems to me like most of you are simply speculating on market trends.

Companies in China are trading close to their Net Current Asset Value (NCAV), with the market seemingly pricing in a scenario where Chinese companies will consistently shrink over the next 10 years. Yet, the e-commerce market in China is projected to grow around 10% annually until 2030, the cloud market is expected to triple in just three years, and the car market is forecasted to grow at 7.5% per year until 2030 — just to name a few industries.

Are you seriously suggesting that the world’s second-largest economy is on the verge of collapse? Because that’s essentially what the market is pricing in right now. Isn’t it ironic that every other article in the Wall Street Journal claims the Chinese economy is collapsing, while the next one highlights how much of a global threat China poses?

If the Chinese economy is truly collapsing, why does the U.S. still see them as such a significant threat?

There are some fantastic companies in China — Alibaba, Tencent, JD.com, and Baidu, to name the most prominent ones. These companies are trading at incredibly cheap valuations. However that does not seem reasonable for ”Value Investors” to consider because ”Media say China Bad”. Instead they are pitching and buying US tech companies growing revenue at 3% a year at 40x P/E.

Chinese workers are some of the hardest working in the world. They are becoming increasingly educated, work for lower wages compared to many developed nations, and benefit from access to cheaper production in neighboring Asian countries due to geographic proximity and strong regional relationships. The second biggest economy in the world will not collapse, but I suppose most of you will wait for the media to shift your consensus instead of thinking critically on your own. Then in some years time start investing at absurd valuations because it’s suddenly "trendy" to invest in China again.

China is here to stay and those who are able to think critically will benefit in the long-term.

EDIT: I understand that people are not comfortable investing in China because it does not fall within their circle of competense. But to disregard Chinese equities for their fundamentals is crazy. It’s a great value play and hedge against the inevitable downturn in US equities.

EDIT 2: My thesis is this: In the long term, stock prices will reflect the fundamentals of the business. The fundamentals are strong and are likely to remain so in the future. If the market is right, you won’t lose much money, but if your thesis is correct, there’s potential for significant returns. And what’s the current alternative? US equities are significantly overvalued, leaving cash or bonds as the other options. I would rather put my money in distressed securities that offer little downside and huge potential upside, than investing in the current US market frenzy or holding cash.

EDIT 3: It’s likely that the market will not realise the value before there are more attractive opportunities in the market. Then it might be reasonable to sell and reallocate capital to those companies. If there’s a catalyst- great! If there’s not, atleast I’m protected from overvalued tech stocks in the US and can buy companies in the US for a bargain. Meanwhile, I’m holding a company that have the potential to increase a lot in value. Just think about when the CCP announced a stimulus. JD went up 80% in two weeks.


r/ValueInvesting • • Mar 09 '25

Discussion Why bother?

0 Upvotes

Why value investing?

Why stock analysis?

Why even start?

We know the stats behind it. It’s like opening a restaurant, more than 80% chances of failing, so why even bother?

What we know is, instead, that Bogle was right, in the long term, nobody can beat the market. Even Buffett has been having a hard time, mainly due to its size. Just think at the efficiency he could gain by simply popping up with a passive index.

I truly believe that most here start investing simply because it’s their passion, and they get a thrill. Which, to be perfectly honest, is even more important than beating the market.

Good luck boys.


r/ValueInvesting • • Jun 22 '26 Popcorn

Discussion $RDDT is not undervalued. Don't fall for the trap.

54 Upvotes

Edit: For those asking for numbers, I have already done a detailed calculation on Reddit's FV months earlier. See link below:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1qyltqm/enough_with_the_opinions_here_is_the_actual_math/ (calculation error here)

https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1qz3twp/correction_to_my_previously_very_flawed_analysis/ (this post corrected the error)

I am seeing a lot of $RDDT bulls in this sub lately.

The main bull case for $RDDT is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the business.

$RDDT bulls mistakenly assume Reddit users are the main customers of Reddit. That's not true, advertisers are the main customers of Reddit.

Even if Reddit feels like a much better social media than Twitter, advertisers do not care.

It doesn't matter what you feel as a user of the platform. The Twitter/X user can be a right wing dimwit who votes Trump and the Redditor a highly educated tech executive. Both are just eyeballs for ads.

So we should focus on the ad quality. The fact is Reddit's ad quality is not any better than Twitter/X. 99% of the ads on Reddit are irrelevant. Most of the ads look and feel spammy. Even high end brands like Iphone ads look spammy af, almost the same as Google adsense ads.

Advertisers have reported abysmal results and inability to scale good results because the available audience is very limited. Not surprised as Reddit only has 50 million DAU in USA and most niche subreddits (where the real commercial value is) are tiny.

Reddit has terrible ad targeting. Reddit's ad targeting capabilities are similar or worse than that of Twitter/X's. That's because both Reddit and Twitter do not have user data, Reddit even less so as users are not logged in.

Reddit can target interest and gather user data based on subreddit visits, which is the main and biggest draw for advertisers. However, this has not proven to be effective even after 3 years since IPO. This disappointing result can be explained quite simply. Subreddit visits do not equate to purchase intent. Subreddit visits CANNOT substitute actual user data for purchase intent. To get the kind of user data, you need to know everything about a user, not just what subreddit he visits. In this world, only Google and META has that kind of user data depth. Unfortunately, people will never let Reddit know their real identity.

What about the data licensing business? Reddit may have great data but its data is NOT valuable because everyone can access its data. To illustrate how bad this is, in 2021, Twitter actually had $500 million revenue from data licensing, that was Pre-AI. Why do people pay Twitter? Because they will have no other way to access Twitter's data. The fact that nobody, except for AI companies, pay for Reddit's data is VERY jarring and shows how indefensible is Reddit of its data.

Worse, AI companies like Anthropic and Perplexity actively scrapes Reddit's data through 3rd parties and there's nothing Reddit can do to stop that. The reason why Reddit allows this is it has no other choice as it needs to be visible on Google Search, which contributes more 50% of its user traffic. The fact that Reddit needs to sue Anthropic to enforce its right proves that Reddit cannot protect its data other than through legal avenues, which is a very fragile kind of protection.

I haven't even touch on the risks to Reddit's business, which are pretty serious:

- Very high dependence on Google Search

- Comments/posts by bots that are becoming and may eventually become Indistinguishable from humans

- Uncontrolled SBC and weak shareholder rights (majority of voting power held by management) causing it to end up like SNAP.

For those who think $RDDT is a $100 billion company, rethink again from the perspective of an advertiser and not the user. Pre-Elon Twitter has higher DAU and yet was valued at $44 billion at its peak (during Elon's acquisition). Reddit is now valued at $33 billion despite having lower DAU than Twitter, giving it very limited upside. Yes, Reddit is profitable and Twitter is not. But the future returns from here is just too low. At current share price, $RDDT is at best a 10% growth/year compounder stock. I would rather just own $MSFT or $META as their risk to return are way better than $RDDT.


r/ValueInvesting • • Feb 23 '23

Stock Analysis Why Nvidia is the most overvalued stock in the market

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
7 Upvotes

r/ValueInvesting • • Jul 04 '26

Buffett Buffett on killing Wright Brothers - source: 2007 Berkshire Annual Letter

0 Upvotes

Buffett’s most violent investing quote: The best thing anyone could have done for investors was to shoot Orville Wright out of the sky.

That was actually in his 2007 letter, and he wasn’t kidding. Aviation changed the world and paid its investors less than nothing through all its history.

That flight was important, sure. It mattered a lot. But “mattered” isn’t the same as “paid.”

Every AI bull argument today is an argument that the technology matters. So were all the pro-aviation, telecomm, fiber and solar arguments. All four of them were capital graveyards.

Never was the question “will AI change the world?" that separated the winners. It’s a question of where the spread lives.

More in-depth explanation: https://open.substack.com/pub/sharmakshit/p/growth-was-the-accelerant?r=2upvyp&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=post%20viewer