Hello, I speak from a small city in Brazil that suffered (and still suffers) from the effects of the dismantling of a major oil refinery at the time of the "Operação Lava-Jato". My city went through an economic and demographic boom during the construction of the refinery, which brought the speculative real estate capital to a mostly rural city.
The result of the refinery's discontinuity caused several buildings to be abandoned. They remain abandoned, with their construction not completed for decades.
A standing building without function, useless. This almost infuriates me, buildings must have a social function.
I wanted help from you to think about community projects that can organize the population around repurposing some abandoned buildings in my city.
Over the past decade, a growing number of mid-sized American cities have embraced cultural development as a way to attract talent, investment, and visitors. Some have hired international consultancies to help build music ecosystems, creative districts, and more vibrant urban identities.
There's a lot to like about this approach. Cultural investment can support local artists, strengthen businesses, create gathering places, and make cities more interesting places to live.
But it raises an interesting question for urbanists: What happens when a city's success at developing and marketing the visible trappings of cultural vibrancy outpaces its progress on the deeper conditions that make urban life genuinely vibrant and inclusive?
Huntsville, Alabama, and its partnership with London-based consultancy Sound Diplomacy offer an interesting case study.
Huntsville's Cultural Development Experiment
Huntsville is a rapidly growing aerospace and defense hub that has increasingly emphasized quality of life and cultural amenities in its economic development strategy.
In 2018, the city hired Sound Diplomacy for a $150,000 music audit. The resulting study produced 47 recommendations for strengthening Huntsville's music economy. The city subsequently established a dedicated Music Office, appointed a Music Officer, expanded music programming, and invested in major entertainment infrastructure.
The most prominent investments include the approximately $55 million Orion Amphitheater, which opened in 2022 at the MidCity District, and the South Star Music Festival at John Hunt Park, launched in partnership with Austin-based promoter C3 Presents.
Alongside these large-scale entertainment initiatives, the city has expanded support for local musicians and independent venues.
In July 2026, Sound Diplomacy released a follow-up audit reporting $278.2 million in annual music-related economic output and 3,047 jobs.
Sound Diplomacy promotes Huntsville as an example of successful cultural investment, while city leadership points to the initiative as evidence of Huntsville's growing cultural stature.
There's evidence of progress. What's less clear is how broadly that progress extends into everyday urban life.
Cultural Vibrancy Versus Institutional Inclusion
One of the broader benefits of Huntsville's music initiative is the image it helps cultivate: a modern, culturally dynamic city that is a forward-thinking outlier in the deep south.
But how closely does that image align with the city's broader commitment to inclusion?
The Human Rights Campaign's 2025 Municipal Equality Index (MEI), which evaluates municipal policies and practices affecting LGBTQ+ residents, offers an interesting counterpoint. Huntsville received a score of just 26 out of 100, substantially below peer cities in Alabama and the surrounding region.
For comparison:
Birmingham, AL: 100
Knoxville, TN: 64
Chattanooga, TN: 41
Montgomery, AL: 37
Mobile, AL: 36
Huntsville, AL: 26
Huntsville received zero points in categories relating to local nondiscrimination laws, municipal services, and LGBTQ+ leadership.
The MEI doesn't measure residents' attitudes or the inclusivity of local cultural institutions. But Birmingham, Montgomery, Mobile, and Huntsville operate under the same Alabama state laws, yet have substantially different municipal scores. State restrictions alone cannot explain the disparity.
Can a city cultivate a reputation as an open, cosmopolitan creative hub without making comparable progress on municipal inclusion?
When Cultural Development Becomes Reputational Cover
Sound Diplomacy promotes Huntsville as evidence that its cultural-development model works. City leadership points to the partnership, a growing music economy, and major entertainment investments as evidence of Huntsville's transformation.
These achievements are real. But they can also create an impression of broader urban progress that the city's municipal policies don't necessarily support.
A city can attract performers, host major festivals, and develop fashionable entertainment districts while offering comparatively limited protections or recognition to marginalized residents who would contribute to organic cultural growth.
If cultural investment delivers the economic and reputational benefits associated with a cosmopolitan city, could it reduce the political pressure for deeper reforms?
Huntsville doesn't establish that causal relationship, but it raises the question.
Why This Matters for Urbanism
The same tension extends beyond LGBTQ+ policies to the built environment.
MidCity, a mixed-use redevelopment of a former suburban shopping mall, represents an improvement over conventional suburban development. But it remains largely a drive-to destination in a sprawling metropolitan area. Its internal walkability doesn't necessarily address regional car dependence or the lack of comprehensive, frequent transit.
Similarly, an amphitheater can attract major touring acts without making it easier for local musicians to afford to live in the area. A successful festival can create a weekend of activity without generating everyday street life.
The visible infrastructure of vibrancy and the underlying conditions that sustain it are different things.
Cities can invest in entertainment districts, festivals, walkable developments, and cultural branding without making comparable progress on housing affordability, transportation, independent cultural spaces, or institutional inclusion.
Cultural consultancies aren't responsible for solving every municipal problem. But their work raises questions about how cities define success and how elected officials use that success to shape their broader reputations.
Discussion
Huntsville's partnership with Sound Diplomacy has produced tangible investments and measurable economic activity.
But its broader significance is less straightforward.
Can successful cultural placemaking become a substitute for deeper urban reform in the public imagination?
I'm curious whether other cities have seen similar dynamics, or whether there are examples where consultant-led cultural development has helped catalyze broader improvements in urban life.
NIMBYism is fundamentally an aesthetic and cultural problem.
This study has a significant implication for YIMBY policy: affordability arguments, property-value arguments and traffic arguments may not persuade voters whose fundamental objection is that the development looks out of place.
This suggests that architecture, urban design, contextual integration and changing people's expectations about what density looks like could be important political strategies alongside zoning reform.
Fifteen years ago, I made a decision that a lot of people around the country thought was absolutely crazy. I moved back home to Cincinnati after spending years living in places like San Francisco, New York, Portland, and Seattle.
People questioned my decision. Why would anyone leave San Francisco for Cincinnati? Why move back to the Midwest when everyone seemed to be heading in the opposite direction?
Fast-forward to today, and I find myself saying something very different: I think Ohio is going to be one of the most interesting places to watch in America over the next decade.
And I'm not just talking about Cincinnati. I'm talking about Columbus, Cleveland, Dayton, Akron, Toledo, and the smaller communities throughout the Buckeye State.
I genuinely believe the stage is being set for a new chapter of growth and opportunity across Ohio.
Let's be honest about what's happening elsewhere. Housing costs in major coastal markets have become astronomical. In places like San Francisco, New York, and other expensive metropolitan areas, the cost of simply maintaining a comfortable lifestyle can be overwhelming. Families are reconsidering where they want to live, businesses are looking at operating costs, and people are beginning to ask whether they really need to pay a premium just to live in a particular ZIP code.
Meanwhile, Ohio has something increasingly valuable to offer: affordability, established infrastructure, major metropolitan markets, universities, healthcare systems, manufacturing, logistics, transportation, and room to grow.
Geography matters, too. Ohio is strategically positioned in the heart of the country, within a day's drive of a tremendous portion of the North American population. That's an enormous advantage for businesses.
And here's something else worth considering: the Midwest is getting renewed attention. Recent population and migration reports are beginning to show signs of a reversal in a decades-long pattern of people leaving the region.
Ohio itself has recorded population growth, and some of its metropolitan areas are attracting new residents. Cincinnati and Columbus continue to expand, and Dayton has shown particularly interesting domestic migration numbers.
I also think we need to reconsider our perception of Ohio's weather. People who haven't lived here in years sometimes imagine endless gray skies and brutal winters. That's not my experience. Our winters are manageable compared with what many people imagine, and we certainly have beautiful sunny days throughout the year. We also need to be realistic about changing weather patterns and the increasing challenges communities face with extreme rainfall and flooding. No region is immune to those challenges.
But my bigger point isn't about weather. It's about opportunity.
I believe we're entering a period when people will increasingly prioritize quality of life, housing affordability, access to employment, family connections, and the ability to build something without spending their entire paycheck just to survive.
And that's where Ohio deserves a much closer look.
I feel a genuine civic responsibility to spread this message. If you're an entrepreneur, a business owner, a family considering relocation, or someone simply looking for a fresh start, I want you to take a serious look at what Ohio has to offer.
Bring your family here. Bring your business here. Invest here. Explore our neighborhoods, our downtowns, our small towns, and our communities.
I'm not suggesting Ohio is without challenges. We have plenty of work to do. But I see tremendous potential, and I think sometimes the people who have lived here the longest are the last to recognize what others may soon discover.
For decades, people left the heartland chasing opportunity elsewhere.
What if the next chapter is about people finding their way back home?
I made that decision a few years ago, and I haven't stopped believing in the potential of this state.
Pay attention to the Buckeye State. I have a feeling the next decade is going to be very interesting.
I've been developing a concept for an aerial gondola system along Rochester, New York's Genesee River corridor. I'm interested in getting perspectives from people who think about cities, urban design, transportation, tourism, and economic development.
I've previously raised the idea in r/transit and shared it in r/urbanplanning. Those conversations have raised some interesting questions, and I'd like to bring the discussion here from a broader creative cities perspective.
Rochester has an unusual urban landscape: a river running through the heart of the city, dramatic waterfalls and gorges, historic bridges, parks, neighborhoods, and major destinations along the corridor. These features create both transportation challenges and an underutilized tourism opportunity.
I see two potentially compelling reasons to explore an aerial gondola system:
Transportation and connectivity
Create more direct connections between neighborhoods, employment centers, parks, and attractions that are geographically close but separated by the Genesee River, gorge, and existing street network. The system could complement existing bus service and provide connections that are difficult to achieve through conventional transportation infrastructure.
2. Tourism and economic development
Create a distinctive attraction that showcases Rochester's waterfalls, gorge, river, and historic landscape. The gondola could connect existing destinations while offering an experience that could become a reason for people to visit Rochester, stay longer, and explore more of the city.
I don't see these as competing objectives. The opportunity is to create a transportation system that is also a destination in its own right.
Phase 1: Downtown to Lower Falls and back
Rather than immediately committing to the entire corridor, I envision starting with a more manageable first phase connecting downtown Rochester to Lower Falls.
The preliminary alignment would be approximately 2 miles one way, with three proposed stations:
Downtown terminal: In the vicinity of either the Main Street Bridge or Broad Street Bridge, providing access to downtown, the central business district, and existing transit connections.
High Falls station: In the vicinity of High Falls Terrace Park and the Pont de Rennes pedestrian bridge, connecting visitors to High Falls and the surrounding historic district.
Lower Falls terminal: In the vicinity of Driving Park Bridge and Lower Falls Park, providing access to the gorge and the Lower Falls experience.
At a typical aerial gondola operating speed, the approximately 2-mile trip could take roughly 10–12 minutes each way. A round trip would be approximately 4 miles and 20–25 minutes of riding time, excluding time spent exploring the destinations.
These are preliminary planning estimates, not established engineering specifications. Exact alignments, station locations, and travel times would need to be evaluated.
Why Downtown?
Downtown is the natural starting point for the system. It is Rochester's primary business and employment center, with existing transit connections, hotels, restaurants, cultural destinations, and other attractions. A downtown terminal could make the gondola accessible to residents, workers, and visitors while connecting the system to the broader transportation network.
Starting downtown also creates an opportunity to make the river and gorge a more visible part of the city's identity. Rather than treating the river as something to pass over or drive around, the gondola could make it a central part of the downtown experience.
Why High Falls?
High Falls is one of Rochester's defining natural and historic landmarks. The waterfall, gorge, Pont de Rennes pedestrian bridge, and surrounding historic district offer a combination of scenery, industrial history, and cultural significance that is unusual for an urban center.
The area also connects to several important destinations, including Innovative Field, home of the Rochester Red Wings, and the former Kodak headquarters. A station near High Falls Terrace Park and the Pont de Rennes bridge could provide access to these destinations while creating a connection between downtown and Lower Falls.
High Falls would serve as both a major attraction and an important intermediate connection along the river corridor, offering visitors and residents another reason to use the system beyond the scenic ride itself.
Why Lower Falls?
Lower Falls is arguably the most dramatic section of Rochester's urban gorge. A gondola would provide a perspective of the waterfall, cliffs, wooded gorge, and surrounding landscape that is difficult to experience today.
It could also provide an accessible connection to the interior of the gorge, potentially opening up an area that is challenging for many people to reach. There may even be opportunities to coordinate with private boat operators and river excursions, creating connections between aerial and water-based experiences.
The initial phase could provide an opportunity to evaluate actual visitor demand, ridership, weather conditions, winter operations, and operating costs before considering extensions to other destinations.
The larger vision
The downtown-to-Lower Falls segment could be the starting point for a much larger transportation and recreational corridor along the Genesee River. While an aerial gondola is one possibility, future connections could take different forms, including bus rapid transit or light rail, etc.
A potential northern expansion could continue along the river to Maplewood Park and Kodak Park, Seneca Park Zoo, and Charlotte Beach and Lake Ontario.
A potential southern expansion could connect downtown with the University of Rochester, Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT), and the Greater Rochester International Airport.
Together, these extensions could create a broader network connecting major destinations, parks, educational institutions, employment centers, and recreational areas along the river corridor.
The goal would be to develop the system incrementally, with each phase providing value while building toward a larger regional connection.
Some questions I'd like to explore
Could an aerial gondola become an integral part of a city's transportation network?
Could tourism be an equally important justification for the investment?
Could the system provide practical transportation while becoming an attraction in its own right?
Does starting with a downtown-to-Lower Falls segment make sense?
How should it complement existing public transportation?
What examples from other cities could help evaluate the concept?
What challenges or considerations am I overlooking?
I'm not suggesting this should replace investment in conventional public transportation. I see it as a potentially complementary investment that offers a different combination of transportation, accessibility, recreation, and tourism benefits.
Rochester has an extraordinary geographic asset running through its urban center. Could aerial transportation turn that geography from something that separates destinations into something that connects them, while making the journey itself part of the attraction?
I'd appreciate honest feedback, including reasons why the idea might not work.
I am doing a research project about urban interventions/planning and had a few questions regarding Superkilen park in Copenhagen, specifically about the boxing ring in the red square:
- We noticed that most of the park has an aestetic value but lacks usability by the community. There is a boxing ring used only couple of times per year.
- If not used, would you consider positive to intervene the space for a space of playfulness that can be used by the community?
- What would you think about utilizing the space for physical games similar to the likes of Twister?
- Would you consider the intervention, a form of vandalism or a form of making the city more habitable and joyful?
Hi everyone! I'm looking to try for international fellowships/internships for urban design and planning or placemaking for post-grad (I graduated in Spring this past year). I know the UN has some but I was wondering if anyone knew of any that were lesser known. I am looking for anything in South/Latin America, Europe (preferably Southern but anywhere works), or Africa. Or if you know of any ways to look for these as well, that would be great!!!
Hi! I'm writing a report for my English 7 class (swedish advanced high school course) and need help to get started! The idea is that i want to write a comparative study between a city having problems with urbansprawl and a city that has effectively densified and counteracted the sprawling.
I dont know if this is a realistic report to make but I am having problems finding sources for this topic and have basically not even started writing anything except for the introduction.
Im open to all suggestions, if it's studies, figures in these spaces or recommendations on changing my topic to something similiar in the "Urbanism" category.
What if the nine-county San Francisco Bay Area had economic autonomy within the United States?
Imagine a regional economic powerhouse with greater control over its own tax revenues, infrastructure investments, transportation systems and economic development, while remaining entirely part of the United States.
"One Country, Two Systems"
Similar to the current relationship of The People's Republic of China to Hong Kong: Sort of.
Thenine counties would remain fully American, under the U.S. Constitution, with federal citizenship, national defense, currency and federallaw.
However, the region would potentially enjoy substantially greater authority over:
Taxation: Retaining a greater share of locally generated tax revenue.
Economicpolicy: Greater regional control over business incentives, investment, education, health care and development.
Transportation: Coordinated regional control over major highways, rail systems, airports and ports.
Infrastructure: More locally directed investment in housing, utilities and public works.
Internationalcommerce: Greater regional flexibility in attracting international businesses and investment.
Estimated annual tax contributions to the state, federal government
Here is a reasonable working estimate, including individual, payroll, business and consumption taxes.
Government recipient Estimated annual contribution
California state government $45–60 billion
U.S. federal government $200–240 billion
Combined $245–300 billion!
Save for continued federal tax contributions for national defense purposes, imagine $200+ billion annually staying at home in the Bay Area?
How would an autonomous Bay Area compare internationally?
Illustrative comparison of economic scale, using approximate recent nominal GDP figures.
Economy Approximate annual GDP
Nine-county Bay Area $1.4–1.6 trillion
South Korea $1.9 trillion
Spain $1.7 trillion
Australia $1.8 trillion
Mexico $1.8 trillion
This is not a suggestion of violent revolutionary secession from the United States!
Far from it! This is simply an idea of greater economic autonomy for the 9-County SF Bay Area within the existing United States of America.
I’d like to kick off a conversation for those inclined to participate about a concept known as “Urban Inversion.” Whereas many are familiar with the flight from major city centers in the mid-to-late 20th century in America, the term Urban Inversion captures a fairly new phenomenon in society where people are returning to urban areas for the pursuit of a variety of life interests, careers, travel, and new experiences. The flow of citizens back into the major city centers has simultaneously occurred with an outward movement of many leaving, predominantly those in the lower classes of society. To draw from Brookings’ The Suburbanization of Poverty —
“Between 2000 and 2008, the low-income population in the suburbs of major metropolitan areas grew by roughly 25%—expanding at nearly five times the pace of primary central cities.”
A core driver for this shift was, of course, the Financial Crisis of 2008, but a result is that in the year 2008, for the first time in modern American history, more of the poor of this country lived in the suburbs than the city core. A pretty profound change!
In 2012, Alan Ehrenhalt popularized the structural term "Urban Inversion" in his book The Great Inversion and the Future of the American City, which describes this flip in greater detail; he specifically covers Atlanta, Chicago, Houston, and Denver. Ehrenhalt discusses how this transfer is creating a European feel to many American cities. For any soccer fans in the reading audience, you may remember during the World Cup the great Thierry Henry proudly telling his story growing up in the rugged “suburbs” of Paris. Whereas, such a story in the American context sounds peculiar, laughable, and is often portrayed as a cliché in movies such as Malibu’s Most Wanted. What a contrast, and yet, this is what is happening in America today.
As this flip continues to take place, the transfer of these different groups into the cities and out of the cities seems to create a tragic passage of silence. Those that move into city centers join their cohorts in their careers, companies, and areas of interest. Those that move out find their families/relatives in their newfound homes in the exterior of the metro area. Little direct intersection of these two groups seemingly takes place as the transformation cements into the reality of the 21st century. Is there a societal loss from this transfer, this Urban Inversion? One loss I’d argue is taking place is empathy. When cities embody a wide array of economic diversity, the contrast between classes can be seen quite clearly. Just bearing witness can shed insight into the different types of paths walked across the human experience and create empathy for those getting by with less or being born into environments defined by being ingrained with a degree of adversity. In most cities, these different worlds used to be across town or on the other side of the tracks—but what happens when cities are defined by an economic monoculture? How does this shared experience of humanity remain? If it doesn't remain, how can we strive to ensure the wealth generated by today’s urban economies creates bridges to the suburbs that allows an optional path back for those who have left?
What say you, city seekers? Do you agree with the research laid out by Brookings and Alan Ehrenhalt? Have we lost a piece of the American Soul during this Urban Inversion? Are we as a country better or worse for it? Thanks for reading!
I've spent more than a few hours looking at Japanese cities on Google Earth, and this morning I've realised something: there is a total lack of Parisian city-planning aspects despite how widespread Parisian elements are around the world. I'd wager that the majority of countries have at least one city with some Parisian inflence. But Japan isn't one of them.
It's not like the Japanese weren't aware of Parisian planning, because they planned and built Changchun in 1906, which has some very heavy Parisian influences.
But despite having many large cities, including at least 2 master planned cities (Sendai and Sapporo) and rebuilding most of them post WW2, Japan has no big boulevards, roundabouts, or, heck, even that much in the way of monumental planning. Sure, they have the samurai castles, but the way they shape the city around them is totally different depending on the castle in question.
Yes, there is the occasional element like Kishu-Kaido St Saki or Odori Park Yokohama (if you are being generous), but on the whole there really isn't that much.
Hi everyone. I'm a Colombian-American young physician currently in the process of establishing a public policy and research initiative/think tank focused on the intersection of urban design, public health, and data science.
I'll be attending the World Architecture Festival here in Fort Lauderdale on November 18, 19 and 20, and I wanted to see if anyone else from the community is planning on going or has attended in previous years.
I have never participated in these type of events, all conferences I know about are about medicine. I'm particularly interested in connecting with people exploring how built environments (walkability, density, public spaces, and urban planning) directly impact population health outcomes and preventive medicine. I'm also highly interested in seeing art, prepared for awe.
If you're heading there or work at the crossroads of architecture and public health/policy, let's connect or have a quick chat during the event!
Currently working on a research paper for one of my classes and looking for a pdf copy of the Under the Elevated March 2015 report by Design Trust for Public Space.
Help a broke college student out if you can please!