r/Urbanism • u/FogCity-Iside415 • 20m ago
"Urban Inversion: The Search for American Soul."
Greetings, tall building fans!
I’d like to kick off a conversation for those inclined to participate about a concept known as “Urban Inversion.” Whereas many are familiar with the flight from major city centers in the mid-to-late 20th century in America, the term Urban Inversion captures a fairly new phenomenon in society where people are returning to urban areas for the pursuit of a variety of life interests, careers, travel, and new experiences. The flow of citizens back into the major city centers has simultaneously occurred with an outward movement of many leaving, predominantly those in the lower classes of society. To draw from Brookings’ The Suburbanization of Poverty —
“Between 2000 and 2008, the low-income population in the suburbs of major metropolitan areas grew by roughly 25%—expanding at nearly five times the pace of primary central cities.”
A core driver for this shift was, of course, the Financial Crisis of 2008, but a result is that in the year 2008, for the first time in modern American history, more of the poor of this country lived in the suburbs than the city core. A pretty profound change!
In 2012, Alan Ehrenhalt popularized the structural term "Urban Inversion" in his book The Great Inversion and the Future of the American City, which describes this flip in greater detail; he specifically covers Atlanta, Chicago, Houston, and Denver. Ehrenhalt discusses how this transfer is creating a European feel to many American cities. For any soccer fans in the reading audience, you may remember during the World Cup the great Thierry Henry proudly telling his story growing up in the rugged “suburbs” of Paris. Whereas, such a story in the American context sounds peculiar, laughable, and is often portrayed as a cliché in movies such as Malibu’s Most Wanted. What a contrast, and yet, this is what is happening in America today.
As this flip continues to take place, the transfer of these different groups into the cities and out of the cities seems to create a tragic passage of silence. Those that move into city centers join their cohorts in their careers, companies, and areas of interest. Those that move out find their families/relatives in their newfound homes in the exterior of the metro area. Little direct intersection of these two groups seemingly takes place as the transformation cements into the reality of the 21st century. Is there a societal loss from this transfer, this Urban Inversion? One loss I’d argue is taking place is empathy. When cities embody a wide array of economic diversity, the contrast between classes can be seen quite clearly. Just bearing witness can shed insight into the different types of paths walked across the human experience and create empathy for those getting by with less or being born into environments defined by being ingrained with a degree of adversity. In most cities, these different worlds used to be across town or on the other side of the tracks—but what happens when cities are defined by an economic monoculture? How does this shared experience of humanity remain? If it doesn't remain, how can we strive to ensure the wealth generated by today’s urban economies creates bridges to the suburbs that allows an optional path back for those who have left?
What say you, city seekers? Do you agree with the research laid out by Brookings and Alan Ehrenhalt? Have we lost a piece of the American Soul during this Urban Inversion? Are we as a country better or worse for it? Thanks for reading!