r/Urbanism • • Jun 19 '26

Why can’t USA have great cities in tropical climates like the rest of the world?

0 Upvotes

I love cities in subtropical/tropical climates where it’s 70F+ year round. People are always out in the streets all year and it’s such a chill vibe to be in a bustling city but people are a bit more relaxed compared to northerners. There are so many great ones around the world. I go to Asia often and love Shenzhen, Guangzhou, Hong Kong, Bangkok, Ho Chi Minh, Kuala Lumpur, etc.

In USA we also have subtropical climates but the cities in them suck. People would probably consider Miami and NOLA the best. They’re fine little cities. Miami is vapid and weird. NOLA is cool for like a 2 mile radius. Then it becomes sad with lots of violent crime. Houston is meh with also tons of violent crime. Orlando and Tampa are meh. Florida is one big nursing home. If you go a little outside Tampa, Orlando, Miami it‘s strange how many senior citizens there are everywhere.

Yes, it’s my subjective opinion, but why do USA cities in subtropical/tropical climates suck in comparison?


r/Urbanism • • Apr 18 '26

We need to ban personal use cars in cities.

38 Upvotes

There is no reason why a city can't have trams, metro and light rail. Only emergency vehicles should be on roads.

The Netherlands have proved the concept of walkable cities but alas public transportation initiatives consistently fail.

For delivery they can operate 10pm-6am when people are asleep.


r/Urbanism • • Nov 18 '25

Spain seems to have achieved a fairly good balanced national development.

Post image
3 Upvotes

It feels like the entire country has been developed evenly.


r/Urbanism • • May 09 '24

Americans FLEE Cities For "Small Town USA"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • Jul 21 '25

Why trying to address housing affordability without addressing wealth inequality won't work

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • Mar 11 '25

The suburban renaissance has, once again, returned to the US

11 Upvotes

Here is why:

  1. Work from home arrangements, which are here to stay, have fundamentally altered the indispensable nature of city living for millions of people. While many people will continue to commute regularly to the closest city for work, a great many others can work fully from home or head into the office 2x per week. WFH, at the same time, makes cities less essential and creates the desire for more indoor space, both of which stimulate demand for a suburban lifestyle.

  2. Advances in technology have improved the quality of leisure activities that can be enjoyed indoors - e.g., large flat screen TVs, video games, on-demand streaming services. The internet, social media, texting, etc. have made proximity less critical in interacting with other people. This again reduces the essential nature of cities in bringing people together for social activities.

  3. Taken together, (1) and (2) create a set of cascading problems for cities. The people leaving cities are more affluent than those who are coming in. Tax dollars escape, city services suffer and the cities become shabbier thus further eroding their desirability. The economic engine that generates unique draws like fashionable boutiques and restaurants in urban areas slowly shifts to the suburbs as restauranteurs and business owners begin to pursue suburban opportunities.

The demand for cities has always depended on technology. Factories, powered by electricity and other technological improvements, brought people from the farms into the cities in Europe at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution. Highways sent people to the suburbs after WW2. Information technology seeded the expansion of the financial sector in the 1980s and the tech sector in the 1990s, drawing people back to cities over the next several decades. Now IT has created a new opportunity for the suburbs, making cities less essential than they used to be.

Note that I am not forecasting the end of cities, simply the beginning of a slow shift in which the economic and social center of gravity moves towards the suburbs. One trend that will tend to benefit cities and protect them from a gloomy outcome are lower marriage and fertility rates.

My post is US-specific but will apply equally to a number of other industrial economies.

Edit: The relevant data showing that rents and home prices in the cities vs. the suburbs have diverged markedly since 2020 is here: https://www.pnas.org/cms/10.1073/pnas.2408930121/asset/cd29ded7-f30f-43e9-8c59-c8a96ddb1e20/assets/images/large/pnas.2408930121fig04.jpg

Source: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2408930121


r/Urbanism • • Feb 20 '24

How Israel Turned Homeowners Into YIMBYs

Thumbnail
worksinprogress.co
114 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • Apr 10 '26

NIMBYist resentment shows a huge blind side in urbanist activism IMO

9 Upvotes

One of the most common post themes I see here is kind of along the vein of "what places need to urbanize". My response to that is "do the people who already live there get to have a say in that? lol"

I feel like there are kind of 2 blind spots here. 1 I do feel like urbanism advocates might live and think in a bubble. The sense I get is yall feel like the benefits of urbanism are universal and obvious, and thus don't get why people might resist.

Which gets to the 2nd blind spot, which is that for better or worse, everyone is self interested. Yes, even urbanists. I dont deny the benefits of urbanism at all. More efficient land use. Lower energy usage. Manifold improved health outcomes. Etc. I have lived and traveled across the density gamut so I get it. But theres also 1000000000% an element of wanting to make the world in your image, which is selfish IMO. Urbanism and densification tend to have a certain look, and anything that deviates from it gets demonized. Thats pushing an aesthetic, not improving people's lives.

And even with all that in mind, I dont think it's fair for someone to ask, "OK but why should I care? I'm happy where I'm at." Not having a good response to that is not them being unreasonably selfish or closed minded or whatever, it's kind of a shortcoming of urbanism advocacy. If a town is already struggling with stuff like traffic and crowded schools, why should they be excited for more housing? Same for someone who likes having space and quiet. Urbanism has upsides but it also has some downsides that kind of center around quality of life which matters. It's up to its advocates to address those downsides either by addressing them or at least showing that the upsides more than make up for them.

I am pro urbanization/transportation optionality/densification but I think I'm also pragmatic and try to see things from all perspectives. And sometimes it seems like urbanists get in their own way by not making a good faith effort to see things from their "opponents" perspectives. You see this in the pejoratives and disdain around sprawl. This post was partially motivated by another post I saw calling people who want SFH "closed minded". This is not how you convince people to move away from SFH lol.


r/Urbanism • • Apr 04 '24

How are people okay with this??

Post image
0 Upvotes

It is absolutely insane to me that it is so widely accepted to put newly licensed (usually 16 year olds) in ~4,500lbs vehicles. Would literally just crush another car in an accident.


r/Urbanism • • Aug 14 '24

Hear me out: San francisco(+oaklad) is peak urbanism

0 Upvotes

Lets see, we have one the highest population density in the us, infinite townhomes/row houses, an AMAZING downtown, the center one of the biggest industries in THE WORLD(Tech companies) and an GREAT streetcar and trolleybus system, and an S-bahn style metro where most people DRIVE to the BART station, and then ride the train the rest of the way there. and much, much more.

*all for the fine price of $2500/mo


r/Urbanism • • Oct 15 '26

Serious questions about the validity of the anti-gentrification movement

0 Upvotes

Ever since I have joined the “pro-urbanism” community that embodies this subreddit, I have grown ever more distant with a subset of the community that has shown to have different values to me: those concerned about gentrification. Where a neighborhood goes from being bad to good, and the newer, higher income people move in and the long time residents move out through economic forces. I won’t offer an explicit defense of the phenomena, but I will defend it if as a side effect if broader good urbanist policy. Bolded statements indicate critical questions.

Individual level: should it be restricted?

Let’s imagine gentrification acting on an individual level. A high person sees a property for sale/rent, they determine that they either like/tolerate the neighborhood, they decide they want to live there, and decide to move in later. Where in this process was there behavior that should be restricted?

should the freedom of movement be restricted, and only “correct” people are allowed to live in certain places? That sounds a lot like that regimes that people here would reject. If racial immigration quotas are bad, redlining is bad (creating whites only areas), and apartheid era neighborhood restrictions are bad, why should I be convinced that restricting any other freedom of movement is a goal? Will this time be different?

Overly simplistic view of humanity

The anti-gentrification debate seems to have inherited a Marxist view of the world due to its left wing influence. There are the rich who make things bad, and the poor who have some virtues due to their condition. Given that the only thing anti-gentrification activists see are incomes, this causes a problem when locals try to improve from within. As an example, say a local resident defies the odds, they get a great education, become talented at their profession, make lots of money, and decide to move back in their community. What is a rags to riches story could be another case of the rich displacing the poor. Since, according to Marxist tradition, money is the real deciding influence, the recently rich local has become of an upper class, and it doesn’t matter if they once lived their before, as they are changing the character of the neighborhood with their money.

Can individual activists make exceptions for individual cases of local success, yes! The problem is that it makes the rich newcomer guilty before proven innocent. Discouraging the locals that make it big to move back in.

Historical perspective: cities change

Cities, as understood in an industrial society, are places of change. Companies rise and fall, industries change, and demographics change. What is the majority black neighborhood today most likely had a very small black population until 1900 when huge internal migrations occurred in the U.S.. The poor Hispanic neighborhood only became majority Hispanic after immigration changes happening in the late 1980’s. The process of neighborhood change is not foreign to the anti-gentrification crowd. Most understand that before the existing community there was a different community and then a different community and then farmland before the city grew into the region. What makes the current neighborhood worthy of glazing in amber, but past neighborhood changes seen as acceptable ?

Shouldn’t rich people moving into good urbanist regions be seen as a success to the movement?

If urbanists were correct, and that certain ways of managing human settlements were fundamentally more desirable, then this appeal would extend beyond class boundaries. Rich and poor would all desire to live in multi story buildings with shops below and cycle paths on the street. Shouldn’t rich people liking good urbanism be seen as a great compliment? It could be worse, they could all leave to low density suburbs, but the fact that people with money and could live in a verity of environments choose to live how urbanists think humans should live should be seen as a success to modern urbanist ideology.

What if gentrification is a response to a less racist and more tolerant society?

The story of suburbanization is tied in with racism, that certain people should are “undesirable” and moving away from them is good. The current generation of suburban youth that are ready to live on their own do not appear to have these tendencies. The fact that a rich suburban person is moving into a poorer, denser region could show that they are more tolerant to those that are different from them. If an individual who doesn’t fear someone who is racially different, they would be more likely to move to place with more of them than a racist person. Does anti-gentrification justify the racist segregation that plagued so many cities?

Imagine two people both from a wealthy suburb and earning above average income. Person A is racist, and, noticing a potential apartment is in a majority black neighborhood, decides to not lease it. Person B sees the same apartment, doesn’t mind the racial differences, and moves in. According to anti-gentrification logic, person B is doing something wrong. Person A’s racism is not immediately scrutinized as it helps maintain the historic demographics of the community.

Are the victims of gentrification the people that society should aspire to be?

Let’s say the points anti-gentrification activists make are all true: rich people move in to a poorer region, the poor cannot afford to live there, and they are forced to live somewhere. This raises an important question, Why can’t these inner city resident be the ones that have the wealth? Why can’t inner city people get dedicated to their education, stay in tune with the most modern industries and trends, and put aside petty differences to make profitable businesses that employs the region and become the wealthy outsiders that current anti-gentrification activists dislike? What I’m saying is that, by defending poor, inner city neighborhoods as holding aspiring characteristics, we might be defending the rationale that makes these regions poor: low educational attainment, gang behavior, limited worldview, and staying attached to dying industries for employment. For every noble savage from these communities exists someone who fully embodies the society around them. Many would argue that those traits are due to bad government. You are correct, but I fear that anti-gentrification activists romanticize poverty and dysfunction. Such that having nice things (cleanliness, popular chain restaurants, good public transport, etc.) is being less authentic and therefore undesirable.

Conclusion

Perhaps I am unsympathetic, too cold, and blind to externalities, but I come from a family that has taught universal human dignity. To hate someone or a group of people based on traits or perceived traits has never been something I have strongly considered. My dream is that everyone can live in a charming neighborhood with close access to necessities and density worthy of great public transport. Throwing boundaries about who can use these benefits seriously hinders the movement by making the activists worry about “worthy” and “unworthy” beneficiaries of good urbanism. In attempting to restrict it, the movement way follow the trends in history of attempting to make two wrongs into a right. The Jacobins executed the King, but then who was of the second estate become broader, and at some point even Maximilien Robespierre lost his own life to the guillotine. Anti-gentrification activists may find a truly wealthy person attempting to move in, but then innocent bystanders can quickly come in the crossfire.

I do not hate all of the anti-gentrification movement. I personally feel like I have the ability to find bits of common ground. I would have sympathy for those who have to moved if displaced as violently as described, but the current movement has shown its fangs to me. Is the movement nothing but another expression of envy against the rich or perceived rich? I hope I am proven wrong on that aspect.


r/Urbanism • • Jul 22 '25

Get over the idea of a Downtown

Thumbnail
yimbymanifesto.substack.com
7 Upvotes

I tend to think that we focus way too much of our energy in the urban policy landscape on downtowns. They're important, but we cannot forget about the potential in the rest of the city. We have much work to do, especially outside of the urban core, to make our cities better.


r/Urbanism • • Nov 27 '19

Why Rent Control Works

Thumbnail
jacobinmag.com
2 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • Dec 24 '24

I hate how every "new walkable" neighborhold is the same

0 Upvotes

Like wow it's all shitty apt buildings made out of cardboard and everything is overpriced.


r/Urbanism • • Aug 12 '25

The same site in Israel before and after the Tama 38 scheme

Post image
0 Upvotes

Israel’s Pinui Binui and Tama 38 schemes allow apartment owners to vote to redevelop their building or their area, adding new properties whose sale pays for the existing residents to get newer, nicer units. They now provide a third of all new homes in the country.

Source: https://worksinprogress.co/issue/how-to-redraw-a-city/


r/Urbanism • • Oct 13 '24

Arrogance of Social Media Urbanists

0 Upvotes

https://www.planetizen.com/features/125997-opinion-arrogance-social-media-urbanists?amp

“No amount of snarky memes and condescension from an armchair urbanist will change that. If anything, it strengthens the idea that the urbanists are out of touch and have no interest in recognizing any values but their own. People choose where they live for a host of reasons, and simplifying it to being ‘car-pilled’ is not helpful.”


r/Urbanism • • Mar 30 '24

What’s the urbanist solution for throwing house parties and playing loud music?

4 Upvotes

Living very densely means you need to limit the amount of guests you can have and can’t play music loud or the cops will be called to break it up. How can we, as urbanists, address this? There is an innate human instinct to play music and entertain large amounts of guests and not everyone wants to go to a nightclub and wants a house party


r/Urbanism • • Nov 03 '25

The enshittification of the World Trade Center

Thumbnail
jasonsaidwhat.substack.com
4 Upvotes

TLDR: We could have had a much better World Trade Center replacement. Not just a better building, but a better urban space at ground level. The cultural forces behind the enshittification of the WTC are the same behind the enshittification of movies, music, cars, and even AI.


r/Urbanism • • Sep 22 '25

Is caring about property value NIMBYism?

1 Upvotes

The title seems pretty self-explanatory. In order to not be affiliated with "Not In My Backyard" do you have to completely lose interest in your property value?


r/Urbanism • • Aug 19 '26

Feeling the link between density & isolation

1 Upvotes

Quick background- spent maybe 2/3 of my life in/around NYC, moved to Sun Belt suburbs for the latest 1/3, recently visited NYC with my kids

Biggest thing that jumped out at me......... it seemed extremely lonely and isolated. People don't smile or look each other in the eye. It was weird to adjust the other way when I left NYC, but Im realizing I like it, even as somewhat of a loner/misanthrope

Studies seem to indicate it's kind of a fight or flight response from just being around too many people all the time. I think we know the clear environmental benefits of density but I feel like the quality of life & psychological aspects get glossed over. Is that just a NYC thing? I have been to other big cities and feel like it was kind of the same. Def was the case in California

I feel like there's a sweet spot of density that is dense enough to be walkable while still enabling people to have privacy/quiet/personal space. Places like NYC seem like too much IMO


r/Urbanism • • Jan 09 '26

Honestly, if it weren’t for the anti-immigrant and anti-trans stuff, Texas is not half-bad

0 Upvotes

Specifically Dallas, Austin and Houston can go fuck themselves. I genuinely have no idea how those two cities have a more liberal reputation, because every single time I’ve been to any of them, DFW always feels infinitely more queer-friendly (and urbanist!) to me. I mean, I’ve literally met on the same rails here a gay engineer and a nonbinary train robber.

Sure, it has hella problems, like effectively no intercity rail to speak of (I just got in to Dallas 10 hours late, so I’m still bitter), but the humongous investment in rail transit and TOD is honestly commendable. Just use the DMUs and Light Rail to hopscotch between islands of walkability, and, if I were a different person with family in the area and this were a different era where the state-level politics weren’t overtly dangerous, I wouldn’t have any qualms about living here car-free. And while suburbs are all awful, I’ve encountered worse suburbs in California and Oregon than I have in Texas. So, yeah, don’t sleep on the Metroplex.

And to those interested, I’m at Urban Crust’s third-story rooftop in Plano, having bicycled about 2/3rds of the recently-opened Silver Line (it’s actually pretty great, too, if only it stayed half-hourly all day).


r/Urbanism • • Mar 06 '26

Are public busses always better than private busses?

1 Upvotes

Title


r/Urbanism • • Nov 14 '25

Hi I've come up witha derogatory term for suburbanites. (Burbarians)

0 Upvotes

I have been calling suburbanites burbarians for years now and I just want to claim that I have coined this term before someone else does. In case you haven't figured it out it's a play on the short version of suburbanites ('burbanites) and barbarians mostly because I find the strange urban design choices quite barbaric. Generally this isn't meant for people but the specific type of barbarianism that exists in the suburbs ie no sidewalks for pedestrians. They would be called burbaric

Edit: this isn't meant to be an actual suggestion it is mostly a joke (obviously) I just wanted to claim it before someone else did and couldn't be bothered to find a better sub honestly. This term would also only apply to those who live in bad suburbs and act like it.

Idk know how to end this.


r/Urbanism • • Oct 13 '25

I like the size of American suburb houses. But I wish the suburbs they were in more walkable.so where DONT we make suburbs that give the best of both worlds and makes both parties on this matter happy.

7 Upvotes

Im a 14m and I live in a north Texas suburb and love it. My house is a decant size and the backyard while not being the biggest is a pretty neat place to play or relax. But I wish the suburbs it is in was more walkable. That’s why I think when it comes to suburbs yeah density is fine and cool but I’m not the biggest fan of connected townhomes and flats (Maybe because I have had bad experiences in them and similar buildings like apartments). When I think of making suburbs better I think we should keep the home sizes but no bigger than 3k square feet but keep the walkability and proximity to amenities and shopping. This could work at least in my opinion by placing transit connections like BRT and light rail outside or near the entrances to neighborhoods or in a central placement between neighborhoods with local stores and main streets around said transit generating business and money for local stores. I think we should also make most main roads and local streets 2 lanes (1 for each direction maybe 2 if needed) reducing traffic but still allowing people to safely and replace intersections with roundabouts. I think a design like this would suit the wants and needs of both parties. People who like walkability, transit, and proximity to stores and amenities get all these benefits while those who like the home sizes still keep their home sizes and drive ways. Overall this is just my thoughts on this. Let me know what you all think.