Last week James Trafford starting for England against the world champions set off a huge debate about who should be England's #1 with a fairly even split between Jordan Pickford (32) and James Trafford (24). The other candidates are Coventry's Carl Rushworth (25) and Palace's Dean Henderson (29). I wanted to help inform that debate by highlighting some stats.
Note that this post is going to be very limited in scope, a modern goalkeeper needs many skills from sweeping through distribution to leading the defence amongst others, most of these can't be usefully examined statistically as they are so context specific or abstract in their impact but there is one stat that is fundamentally useful to this debate, expected Goals on Target (referred to as xGoT). xGoT measures, based on the actual shot taken, how likely that shot is to result in a goal, it has been tracked since 2020. We can take the cumulative score of those shots and compare it to the actual goals conceded by a goalkeeper to create a 'goals prevented' stat, I take this stat from Fotmob. We're not quite done though, a goalkeeper who prevented 2 goals from an expected 80 conceded is not better than a goalkeeper who prevented 1 from an expected 30 conceded so we need to turn the stat into a percentage where 100% means the goalkeeper lets in as many as they are expected to and the smaller the percentage the better, that's what I'll be using today.
Carl Rushworth
England's latest #3 has spent most of his career in the lower leagues, between 2022 and 2026 he played 136 games in League One and the Championship and was expected to concede 165.03 goals but prevented 14.03 giving him a score of 91.5% over the period. However the PL is a step up and, whilst he's only played 10 games so far (giving him a very small sample size) he's conceded 19 goals against an expected 13.81 giving him a PL score of 137.6%.
Dean Henderson
Henderson spent his formative years at Utd but never really got his chance at regular football until he joined Forrest on loan when he was 25. Over the following four seasons he's played 98 PL games and has conceded 145 goals against an expected 145.5 giving him a score of 99.7%. His best season was the 24/25 season palace where his score was 96%.
Jordan Pickford
Pickford has been a starting keeper in the PL for longer than the XGoT stat has been recorded so any difficult early years are not included. Since 2020 however he's played 124 games in the PL conceding 155 goals from an expected 167.3 for a score of 92.7%. His best season was 24/25 where he achieved 88%.
James Trafford
Trafford's history is a bit convoluted, technically his PL score 100.7% but there's a lot of context. That score doesn't include his 45 games in the Championship where he scored an incredible 56.2% but it does include his disastrous year with Burnley when he was 22 and conceded 7 more goals than he was expected to. Since the start of last season he has only played 14 PL games but, in that admittedly small sample size, his score is 66.8%. If we expand the data to all games he has played in since the start of last season, for England, Man City and Leeds and in every competition he's played 31 games for a score of 71.9%.
Conclusion
This is an important but only partial insight into the goalkeeper debate, Jordan Pickford has been a high level shot stopper for 4 or 5 seasons consistently scoring in the low 90s or better, his young rival has not got that history of consistency to fall back on, what Trafford does have however is evidence that he may be an extraordinary shot stopper and, if the pattern of his limited game time since he moved to City continues, then he could be a generational talent.
But Goalkeeping isn't just about preventing goals, it's about controlling the area, claiming high balls, sweeping and distribution and stats aren't great at understanding those skills so the debate is far from over.