r/ThreeLions • • 1h ago

Opinion Even if fit, Kane shouldn’t play against Norway

0 Upvotes

Obviously right now it’s looking like he will be back in time, but even if he is he should be rested. For one thing, it’s a long season and it’s a serious injury for a player of his age. I’d much rather he rested up and focussed on his long term recovery.

However there is another angle. All too often England have looked toothless in recent years without Kane on the pitch. I want to see what this team is made of without Kane - he won’t be around forever and even prior to retirement he could get injured. I want to see if they can beat a serious opponent in a competitive match without him being involved at all. The Nations League is important but if England don’t win it’s not the end of the world, the Euros are the real prize. We may not get another chance to properly test drive England without Kane beforehand


r/ThreeLions • • 8h ago

Question Harry Kane's replacement...

27 Upvotes

There is a probability that Harry Kane won't come back for the quarterfinals against Norway. In case he doesn't, who should play in his position?


r/ThreeLions • • 14h ago

Fitness Update Harry Kane: England and Bayern Munich striker set to miss three months with ankle injury | Football News

Thumbnail
skysports.com
59 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 16h ago

England News Harry Kane out for three months

Thumbnail
sport.sky.de
419 Upvotes

Article is in German

"Bayern sporting director Max Eberl confirms Harry Kane has suffered a syndesmosis ligament tear and is expected to be sidelined for around three months, with Vincent Kompany also confirming a lengthy absence."


r/ThreeLions • • 23h ago

England News Dates and times for Quarter-Finals confirmed

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

Discussion Should we start treating the Nations League like the EFL Cup/FA Cup?

0 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

Analysis A statistical comparison of the leading candidates to be England's Goalkeeper

4 Upvotes

Last week James Trafford starting for England against the world champions set off a huge debate about who should be England's #1 with a fairly even split between Jordan Pickford (32) and James Trafford (24). The other candidates are Coventry's Carl Rushworth (25) and Palace's Dean Henderson (29). I wanted to help inform that debate by highlighting some stats.

Note that this post is going to be very limited in scope, a modern goalkeeper needs many skills from sweeping through distribution to leading the defence amongst others, most of these can't be usefully examined statistically as they are so context specific or abstract in their impact but there is one stat that is fundamentally useful to this debate, expected Goals on Target (referred to as xGoT). xGoT measures, based on the actual shot taken, how likely that shot is to result in a goal, it has been tracked since 2020. We can take the cumulative score of those shots and compare it to the actual goals conceded by a goalkeeper to create a 'goals prevented' stat, I take this stat from Fotmob. We're not quite done though, a goalkeeper who prevented 2 goals from an expected 80 conceded is not better than a goalkeeper who prevented 1 from an expected 30 conceded so we need to turn the stat into a percentage where 100% means the goalkeeper lets in as many as they are expected to and the smaller the percentage the better, that's what I'll be using today.

Carl Rushworth

England's latest #3 has spent most of his career in the lower leagues, between 2022 and 2026 he played 136 games in League One and the Championship and was expected to concede 165.03 goals but prevented 14.03 giving him a score of 91.5% over the period. However the PL is a step up and, whilst he's only played 10 games so far (giving him a very small sample size) he's conceded 19 goals against an expected 13.81 giving him a PL score of 137.6%.

Dean Henderson

Henderson spent his formative years at Utd but never really got his chance at regular football until he joined Forrest on loan when he was 25. Over the following four seasons he's played 98 PL games and has conceded 145 goals against an expected 145.5 giving him a score of 99.7%. His best season was the 24/25 season palace where his score was 96%.

Jordan Pickford

Pickford has been a starting keeper in the PL for longer than the XGoT stat has been recorded so any difficult early years are not included. Since 2020 however he's played 124 games in the PL conceding 155 goals from an expected 167.3 for a score of 92.7%. His best season was 24/25 where he achieved 88%.

James Trafford

Trafford's history is a bit convoluted, technically his PL score 100.7% but there's a lot of context. That score doesn't include his 45 games in the Championship where he scored an incredible 56.2% but it does include his disastrous year with Burnley when he was 22 and conceded 7 more goals than he was expected to. Since the start of last season he has only played 14 PL games but, in that admittedly small sample size, his score is 66.8%. If we expand the data to all games he has played in since the start of last season, for England, Man City and Leeds and in every competition he's played 31 games for a score of 71.9%.

Conclusion

This is an important but only partial insight into the goalkeeper debate, Jordan Pickford has been a high level shot stopper for 4 or 5 seasons consistently scoring in the low 90s or better, his young rival has not got that history of consistency to fall back on, what Trafford does have however is evidence that he may be an extraordinary shot stopper and, if the pattern of his limited game time since he moved to City continues, then he could be a generational talent.

But Goalkeeping isn't just about preventing goals, it's about controlling the area, claiming high balls, sweeping and distribution and stats aren't great at understanding those skills so the debate is far from over.


r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

Discussion England will face Norway in the Nations League Quarter Finals.

Post image
739 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

England News England will face Norway. Revenge or repeat?

77 Upvotes

England have drawn Norway.

Portugal vs. Netherlands

Germany vs Belgium

France vs Spain!!!

If England win, they will play Germany or Belgium. No France, Spain, Portugal or Netherlands until the final!

All the best three lions.


r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

Discussion Was this England’s greatest year in your lifetime?

Post image
336 Upvotes

Now the dust has settled, and we close another chapter for a few months. Where do you rank it?

This just pipped 2018 for me.


r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

England News Reminder: The Nation's League Quarter Finals Draw is at 11 am on uefa.tv/live

Thumbnail
uefa.tv
13 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 1d ago

England News FA fined, handed suspended ban after England fans’ ‘racist and/or discriminatory’ chanting in Spain

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
99 Upvotes

The Football Association has been fined €15,000 (£12,500) and threatened with a ban on selling away tickets after “racist and/or discriminatory behaviour” from travelling fans during Sunday’s Nations League win over Spain in Madrid.

The ban, which is suspended, would see the FA barred from selling tickets for one away game in UEFA competitions if an incident of a similar nature occurs again within the next two years.


r/ThreeLions • • 2d ago

Social Media Jude on his little brother Jobe 💙

Thumbnail
gallery
485 Upvotes

hope his dream of playing on England’s national team together comes true

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿


r/ThreeLions • • 2d ago

Question What ever happened with Adam Wharton?

Post image
162 Upvotes

With the likes of MLS, Garner, Anderson, and Scott, is he out of the picture now? Thought he would be a mainstay in the England squad for the future, also thought he’d have a move to a big club too.


r/ThreeLions • • 2d ago

Analysis Unemotionally analysing Spain 2-3 England and where we lie

0 Upvotes

As the title says, this will be an en-emotional analysis based on the match, a few days have passed and the high has calmed.

I do believe that we were quite fortunate <in context> to win against Spain away. The 2-3 win we had was mainly down to Spain’s lack of defensive structure and press resistance as they are missing their captain; Rodri who will be back for the Nation’s League knockout stages. (I read his injury will have him out for a few months?) Spain started with a midfield three of Zubimendi - Ruiz - Merino, which is a step down compared to to their usual Rodri - Ruiz - Olmo trio. They struggled to create as many chances from the midfield to their front line, thanks to the help of Rice’s prescence supporting the back line and lack of control/ball progression from Spain as they could not beat our aggressive press well enough. You just have to look back at our 2-3 loss at Wembley to see the amount of chances created that exposed our backline. I do believe that if you put us up against Spain in a knockout game with their midfield fully fit and starting, they probably have a slightly better chance of winning because of De La Fuente’s incredible system that he has built around those players.

However, I do not want to be all “doom and gloom” and take some positives from this Nation’s League and it has displayed that I would say we are probably the second strongest team in the world. Before the World Cup, I would have labelled us as fourth or third however France look a bit disjointed, struggling against a poor Italy side and Zidane’s trying to figure out his squad. Messi has also retired from the Argentinian National team, they are now a bit of an unknown with how they will play without such a strong empathis on Messi. Pretty much our only weakness is ironing out our mistakes at the back, which come from various individuals. (Not just Quansah!) e.g. Konsa’s poor clearance that led to Quinones goal against us, Quansah getting easily dispossessed against Spain, Guehi and O’Reilly making panicked decisions against Spain in Wembley, Stones almost letting Haaland have a free shot on goal etc.


r/ThreeLions • • 2d ago

Discussion Is Pickford-Trafford-Henderson the best depth England have had since Seaman-Flowers-Martyn?

36 Upvotes

i was just considering the long bleak spells where the first choice was Hart, Robinson or James, all of whom were decent keepers but with huge potential for a screw up and their various backups that all got a few caps but never inspired huge confidence.

I would say this current trio of options (Steele =\= Walker but it’s a unique position he’s in) is better than the 90s trio, and arguably better than prime Shilton/Clemence too but interested to hear thoughts on that.


r/ThreeLions • • 2d ago

Discussion Weaknesses

9 Upvotes

We are fortunate that at this time, England’s squad depth gives us (or at least me) confidence that we will be in a great spot across most areas of the pitch come the Euros. In fact, it’s more of a case of who will be left out rather than included.

But there are two areas that feel like glaring issues for Tuchel to solve: one is how to replace Kane in the event of an injury, and the other is the centre half pairing.

How would you solve these issues?

Jude at the 9 or a like for like replacement striker in the event Kane goes down?

Invest in youth (Branthwaite, etc), rely on the older guard (Konsa/Guehi/Stones/Burn) to reestablish a reliable partnership? Move someone (White, etc) out of position?


r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Throwback [Name this lineup] On this day, England 2-1 Croatia - 18 November 2018

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Article Peak England for Thomas Tuchel — but don’t let Cole Palmer stew like Jude

Thumbnail thetimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Discussion tuchel really failed us

0 Upvotes

just look at bellingham pushing foward man with no one up


r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Discussion England could face Belgium, Norway or the Netherlands in the Quarter Finals. Which one would you want to face?

131 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Discussion England Player Pools

2 Upvotes

England victory versus Spain was great, but it got me thinking if we are still going to be competitive for years to come, because once again, we haven't won any trophies since forever. Granted if we can win the Euro on home soil, but if not, then are we completely fucked up the chance? I just feel like we don't have that many depth, hope I'm wrong

I just want to share my daydreaming and have a fun discussion.

STRIKER/CENTRAL FORWARD

- Harry Kane (hopefully still fit)

- Liam Delap?

- Calvert Lewin?

- Dominic Solanke (not sure, better call Delap instead)

- Will Lankshear (literally our hope)

- Brian Madjo (our second hope)

- Marcus Tavernier (why is he never considered?)

- who else?

LEFT WINGERS

- Anthony Gordon (still need to improve 1v1)

- Marcus Rashford (serviceable)

- Morgan Rogers (although could play anywhere)

- Rio Ngumoha

- Tyrique George

- Luca Williams Barnett (his cameo with Spurs was electric)

- Jesse Derry?

- Mickey Moore (what is his position?)

- who else?

RIGHT WINGERS

- Bukayo Saka (what happened to him? Bit concerned)

- Noni Madueke (can he improve?)

- Cole Palmer (could play anywhere)

- Shea Lacey (hopefully United doesn't ruin him)

- Tyler Dibling

- who else?

ATTACKING MIDFIELD

- Jude Bellingham (absolute maverick)

- Morgan Gibbs White (still never been starting)

- Josh King

- Dewsburry Hall

- Max Dowman

- Eberechi Eze?

- Phil Foden (is he finished?)

- James McAtee?

- who else??

CENTRAL MIDFIELD

- Declan Rice (staple)

- Alex Scott

- Jobe Bellingham

- Kobbie Mainoo

- Curtis Jones

- Harrison Armstrong

- Chris Rigg?

- who else??

DEFENSIVE MIDFIELD

- Elliott Anderson

- James Garner

- Hayden Hackney

  • Archie Gray

- Trey Nyoni

- Lewis Miley?

- Jack Hinshelwood?

- who else?

LEFT BACK

- Lewis Hall (why didn't we take him to America?)

- Djed Spence (luckily can play both side)

  • Myles Lewis Skelly

- Tyrick Mitchell?

- Keane Lewis Potter?

- Harry Amass?

- who else?

RIGHT BACK

- Ben White (could be a lock)

- Reece James (fitness issue)

- Trent Alexander (bit hard to play him)

- Tino Livramento (always injured)

- who else?

CENTER BACK

- Ezri Konsa (absolute a lock, right? )

- Marc Guehi (shaky with City)

- Dan Burn (pass 30s)

- Lewis Dunk (likewise)

- James Hill (should always be called up, no?)

- Jarrad Branthwaite (still never start)

- Levi Colwill (surely must be included, or not?)

- Josh Acheampong (good development in Chelsea)

- Ayden Heaven (talented but raw and inexperienced)

- Harwood Bellis?

- Charlie Creswell (can he still somewhat be considered?)

- who else?

GOALKEEPER

- James Trafford (surely no. 1)

- Jordan Pickford

- Dean Henderson

- no one else


r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago

Euros Euro Qualification Pots

31 Upvotes

r/ThreeLions • • 3d ago Bravo

Discussion We have to petition to get our national football anthem changed from God Save the King to Jerusalem.

536 Upvotes

Our anthem is trash. It stirs nothing in the soul. It's literally just all about a King, and most of us don't give a half-penny shit about him.

That last minute of Jerusalem is so powerful. 'Bring me my bow of burning gold, bring me my arrows of desire, bring me my spear o clouds unfold, bring me my chariots of fire, I will not cease, from mental fight'.

How can our lads get fired up when they have to sing such an uninspiring dirge as God Save the King?

By all means keep that as the national anthem but our football anthem cannot be such a terrible boring inapplicable song as God Save the King. We have an absolute banger that stirs the soul and commits the mind, but instead our lads are singing about how much they love the King. It's such a shit boring song. It's putting our lads to sleep before they even start playing.

What do you all think?

EDIT: Most of you are sound, a few of you are legitimately mental and need to seek support from mental health services, standard Reddit I guess. I will offer a secondary option beyond all the other great suggestions here...Squeeze 'Up The Junction'.