As per the title.
The goal of any football tournament is to win the tournament.
Yes, Southgate has brought us some great memories, leading us to a World Cup semi final, and a euro final, but also equally irritating memories of frustrating bottle jobs.
The reality is, from 1966 to 2018, with the exception of 1990 and 1996, England failed colossally.
They had all the bites at the cherry, and no result.
Since 1966, every other Major nation has won a trophy (either European Championship or World Cup):
Brazil: 3 World Cup wins.
Argentina: 3 World Cup wins.
Italy: 2 World Cup wins, 2 Euro wins.
France: 2 World Cup wins, 2 Euro wins.
Germany: 3 World Cup wins, 3 Euro wins.
Spain: 1 World Cup win, 2 Euro wins.
Portugal: 1 Euro win.
Netherlands: 1 Euro win.
Greece (lol): 1 Euro win.
Denmark (lol): 1 Euro win.
Czech Republic (lol): 1 Euro win.
Belgium, England and Croatia: 0 wins.
England, since 1966 have had 27 attempts, to win a tournament, have won none.
In other words, England are now in a category with teams such as Croatia, Belgium, Russia, Switzerland, Austria and Poland.
For Croatia, consistently making the World Cup semi finals, and a nations league final, is at least respectful given the lack of talent outside of ModriÄ, they have definitely over performed rather than under performed.
The point I'm making here is that the goal of a tournament isn't to reach the semi final, score a goal and park the bus, it's to actually win the tournament.
Southgate will have had 4 attempts, I can understand 2018 being his first tournament, with a mediocre side, but 2020,2022 and 2024 will be legitimate attempts with a top 3 squad.
It's now "acceptable" to make the semi final and final and lose valiantly in the same way we have previously.
Southgate versus other major European nations in tournaments:
2018: 2 Losses to Belgium, and a loss to Croatia if you want to count them as a major European nation.
2020: 1 win against Germany, 1 loss against Italy.
2022: 1 loss against France.
In other words we are 1/5 (or 1/4 at best) which is a 20% win rate against other major teams, of which I'd argue that Croatia and Italy weren't the better team on paper at the time.
Southgate's "success" is predicated upon England NOT winning before. Had England won a tournament, at any point between 1990 and now, I think he wouldn't get the same lenience he has now.
Yes, if you move from rural Malawi into a very cheap Indian apartment with no air conditioning, it is considered an upgrade, you may even live a comfortable life, you may appreciate it for a while, then realise you want to upgrade your living space. Same applies to England here.
The only scenario I see where I could validate keeping Southgate is if we consecutively beat 2 good teams in a row, and then lose after playing well in the final.
If you need to be ruthless, commit intentional fouls at the expense of a yellow card to win a tournament then you do it, fuck playing nice if it gets you second place. The goal is to win the tournament.