r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 29 '25

Question Can a dyson sphere be built using all resources of our solar system

Post image
597 Upvotes

Can it be built using all the resources from Mars,pluto,jupiter,mercury etc and wouldn't it effect the sun light coming to earth


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 03 '25 Bravo

Discussion I owe the people of this group a heartfelt apology.

594 Upvotes

An apology owed.

I spent the weekend deep in thought over my "theories" and I had an awakening of sorts.

I realized that because of my lack of training in physics, (or any academia for that matter), my language didn't match those who are trained. I found myself angry at being brushed off.

I realized that what I should have done was stated that my idea was just something I wanted to talk about with someone who actually knows and understands what it means.

Im not going to get into the idea, as it is just an idea that I find interesting.

I just wanted to apologize for blaming those with the training for being elitist gatekeepers, when in reality, it was my own lack of understanding that put me in the situation to begin with.

So, accept it or not, I do sincerely apologize for my hubris. I was not trying to tell anyone I was smart enough to make some ground breaking discovery. Though, I see how it would have come across that way.

Thank you for your time. James


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 13 '26

Meta Too many people are just pretending right now

561 Upvotes

As you have certainly noticed, there have been tons of posts recently about major problems being solved by AI, or by actual researchers being assisted by AI. What shocked me, in particular, is how everyone is posting about visualising stuff like the Navier-Stokes forced blowup solution, or about the Yang–Mills existence and mass gap problem being the next target for AI companies.

Seriously, how many people even understand the Navier-Stokes equations ? How many people actually studied anything about partial differential equations or fluid mechanics? Why aren't we having more posts on book recommendations on PDEs, or even ODEs, or even simply newbie questions about how to approach a PDE, which are honest attempts at understanding? I literally get second-hand embarassment when some redditors, who clearly aren't researchers on PDEs, discuss the details of OpenAI's solutions to Navier-Stokes.

Math and physics are not a spectator sport, studying these subjects is a serious activity that takes years of diligent practice to get good at, and most people, sometimes even with a lot of effort, never get past the undergraduate level, or even high school level. Please, let's stop pretending we know anything about research-frontiere problems, respect the fact that expert-level mathematics and physics should be discussed by experts, and go back to actually learning.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Dec 04 '21

Scientific news/commentary Leonard Susskind having problems with the giant blackboard at the IAS; Ahmed Almheiri offers his help

468 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 09 '26

Discussion Honestly, I am sad about Open AI announcement

456 Upvotes

I just read the article where Open AI claimed that it's internal model solve one of the millennial problems. It proved that Navier- Stokes equation produces a singularity in a finite time in a 3D incompressible fluid. I am excited for AI and developments but solving the millennial problems was far too much. if it gets peer reviewed then it would mean in a very little time AI has actually bet human capabilities. We human researchers will only have a job of verifying the proofs.

Any significant advancements can only be done by writing the prompts for AI to research and write papers. Maybe that's how it is supposed to be today or tomorrow. However I am sad because I DIDN'T JOIN PHYSICS TO TELL AI TO DO PHYSICS!


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • May 11 '25

Meta Meta: why do crackpots never use LaTeX?

409 Upvotes

Something I've notice many years ago, but still holds: every single crackpot "paper" I've seen uses word (or a similar software) for presenting the... let's call them "interesting" ideas. Ive never, not once, saw a physics crackpot theory presented as a LaTeX-typeset document.

I'm not saying that it would make any meaningful difference (one can typeset bullshit in LaTeX too, of course, and rather easily) - but it's a thumb rule I have that had yet to fail me even once: if I see a word-like document claiming to have some breakthrough-physics in it, that's the first red flag. Ok, the second - the first is obviously the claim of a breakthrough. Sometimes the fact it is even posted online on public forums.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 21 '26

Resources Gauge Fields, Knots & Gravity

Post image
325 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I recently completed an MSc in physics, and I would now like to develop a deeper understanding of the geometric structures underlying general relativity and gauge theories.

In particular, I am interested in understanding how gauge interactions can be formulated geometrically, and how this compares with the description of gravity in terms of spacetime geometry. I am looking for a book that will give me a solid foundation in these ideas before moving on to more advanced material related to the structure of spacetime and quantum gravity.

I came across Gauge Fields, Knots and Gravity by John Baez and Javier P. Muniain, and I would be interested to hear from people who have studied it.

Does the book cover these subjects in enough depth for that purpose? At what mathematical and technical level does it treat them? Is it a solid introduction for someone with a background in GR and QFT, or is it mainly an intuitive overview?

I would also appreciate any other recommendations.

Thanks!


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jul 01 '21

Experimental Result Visualization of the quantum eigenstates of an electron confined in a box immersed in a magnetic field

315 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 27 '21

Scientific news/commentary Juan Maldacena picks up notes he had forgotten after his lecture; Ahmed Almheiri was quick to make a joke out of it

281 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 10 '25

Meta Why does every discovery in math end up being used in physics?

247 Upvotes

Is nature really a mathematician?

Calculus and algebra were the only basis of mechanics until general relativity came along. Then the “useless” tensor calculus developed by Ricci, Levi Civita, Riemann etc suddenly described, say, celestial mechanics to untold decimal places.

There’s the famous story of Hugh Montgomery presenting the Riemann Zeta Function to Freeman Dyson where the latter made a connection between the function’s zeroes and nuclear energy levels.

Why does nature “hide” its use of advanced math? Why are Chern classes, cohomology, sheafs, category theory used in physics?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jul 24 '21

Today, Steven Weinberg passed away. It truly is a sad for physics. RIP Weinberg 1933-2021

Post image
226 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 29 '22

Question Apple in a box for infinity

217 Upvotes

I watched a documentary on Netflix, "A Trip to Infinity" which explore the idea of infinity. One thought experiment got stuck in my mind (and as a non-physicist, I paraphrase from the show):

An apple is placed in a closed box (in theory nothing can come out or in the box). Over time the apple decays, after more time the apple has become dust, years and years later the remaining chemicals get very hot, a long long time later the particles start to nuclear fuse together, eventually the box contains just ion nuclei and photons, and then billions and billions of years later the neutrons decay into protons and fundamental particles and after a very very very long time all particles in the apple have experienced all possible states. Then, those states have to be revisited. At some point therefore the apple reappears in its original state.

I have found nothing online but wanted to know if there is a name for this theory? Anthony Aguirre is the person who works through the idea on the show.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 22 '25

Question Why the Universe didn't collapse into a black hole right after the Big Bang?

214 Upvotes

So we know that the density of the Universe was very high after the Big Bang. And shortly after the birth the forces and matter formed.

Is there any theory today which explains, why all the matter didn't collapse into a black hole right after birth, if gravity was present?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jan 01 '21

Meta Are memes allowed here?

Post image
199 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 05 '21

Scientific news/commentary The Nobel Prize in Physics 2021

Post image
187 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Feb 12 '25

Meta New members disclaimer: there is a BAN on self-theories

177 Upvotes

If you want to participate in this sub please abstain from posting content focused on ANY physics-related research that you have done yourself. Repeated attempts to try to publish so will result in a ban. Any content that you post on original research will be removed immediately.

This includes self-theories in the form of questions. We invite you to read the rules first.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Dec 01 '25

Question Why does theoretical physics attract a lot of... crackpots?

158 Upvotes

Why do so many people want to revolutionize theoretical physics without the proper knowledge of the underlying theories? What is the hype? I'm really curious what motivates people to come up with theories on subreddits like the r/HypotheticalPhysics.

I've personally never seen this phenomenon in other fields like experimental physics. I'm sure they exist, but I've not seen people trying to come up with experiments to prove or disprove the current theories. it would be really interesting to see people talking about various experiments that can be performed with machines like LHC or RHIC. Instead, I've seen countless "toy models," various hypothesis, and the overuse of the word "quantum" hypercharged (pun intended) by multitudes of LLMs.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Feb 20 '26

Question How did the matter that formed the universe get here in the first place?

154 Upvotes

Hoping this is the right place to ask this. I’m autistic and have been on theories about the universe kick. Basically what I’m wondering is- why is there matter at all in the universe?

So it all started with very compressed matter that then created the big bang and the expansion of the universe right?

So where did the matter come from? The previous universe? What about before that? Why is there something rather than nothing? What put it there?

Sorry if this is a dumb question! Layman here


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 09 '25

Discussion This Scientific American article on the quantum reality debate is fascinating

Thumbnail
nature.com
153 Upvotes

Scientific American recently ran the linked article exploring why physicists still can’t agree on what quantum mechanics says about reality.

The divide often gets framed as “interpretation wars”; Copenhagen, Many Worlds, etc. but I think there’s an even deeper layer worth considering: what if these disagreements stem from the way we formalize logical admissibility in physical theories?

In other words, before we even get to probabilities and wavefunctions, we’ve already made assumptions about which informational structures count as physically realizable. The article’s examples of “weird” vs “reasonable” interpretations might actually be symptoms of a shared but unexamined filter at the pre-mathematical level.

Curious if others see merit in looking below the Hilbert space itself to the logical criteria that shape it. Could that be the real source of the divide?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Dec 15 '25

Discussion If space exists even without matter, what is the ontological status of space itself?

150 Upvotes

is space fundamental? is space emergent? is space… relative?

I know this is an incredibly stupidly high level of theoretics, uncertainty and the unknown, but thoughts/opinions on one or all?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • May 14 '25

Discussion Why AI can’t do Physics

143 Upvotes

With the growing use of language models like ChatGPT in scientific contexts, it’s important to clarify what it does.

  1. ⁠⁠It does not create new knowledge. Everything it generates is based on:

• Published physics,

• Recognized models,

• Formalized mathematical structures. In other words, it does not formulate new axioms or discover physical laws on its own.

2. ⁠⁠It lacks intuition and consciousness. It has no:

• Creative insight,

• Physical intuition,

• Conceptual sensitivity. What it does is recombine, generalize, simulate — but it doesn’t “have ideas” like a human does.

3. ⁠⁠It does not break paradigms.

Even its boldest suggestions remain anchored in existing thought.

It doesn’t take the risks of a Faraday, the abstractions of a Dirac, or the iconoclasm of a Feynman.

A language model is not a discoverer of new laws of nature.

Discovery is human.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 03 '21

History/review Not sure if allowed, but I thought you all would appreciate this (source with references in the comments)

Post image
142 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 31 '25

History/review This is how Heisenberg created quantum mechanics - a step-by-step guide

140 Upvotes

This year the physics community celebrates 100 years of the publication of Werner Heisenberg's groundbreaking paper introducing the first consistent theory of quantum mechanics. Published in Sep. 1925, the paper is hard to read, even for experts. For this reason I created a step-by-step guide decoding Heisenberg's legendary "Umdeutung paper" including the main ideas of the paper and all the relevant calculations. I thought that members of this active community might find it of interest: https://youtu.be/oVzzIkkYGY8


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 02 '24

Discussion Self-Study: Quantum Field Theory Books

Post image
139 Upvotes

In preparation for my university modules next year in Quantum Fields (QFT, QED, and the like), I have acquired three texts so I can start wrapping my head around the subject. I feel like I should focus on one and was wondering if anyone had any insights on which one would better serve as a self-study introduction. Any additional comments on these books (or others) are most welcome.

Many thanks in advance :)