r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 10 '26

Discussion I’ve never understood mathematicians’ obsession with rigour of 19th century physics

0 Upvotes

Given the recent hype of Navier Stokes equation blow up solution, set aside the OpenAI snatch debacle, I really want to understand why math communities are obsessed with singular solutions to the equations that we know do not apply to any fluid, simply because the in compressible assumption breaks down.

As a working theoretical physicists I’ve never understood the hype around these ‘solutions’ and ‘proofs’, it has been long established Newton’s theory breaks down badly either relativistically or at atomic scale (or larger than that), when your solution exceeds your validity of your model, it doesn’t mean we reach a singularity and the world gets sucked in but simply imply your model breaks down.

In fact one of the central theme of physics is to determine when the effective description breaks down, for instance GR breaks down at Planck scale, Fermi theory breaks down at electroweak scale etc. And that limit for classical fluid is at high energy where relativity and quantum mechanics kicks in.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 23 '26

Question Question on publishing a black hole model (gr-qc)

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m working on a regular black hole interior model that preserves an exact Schwarzschild exterior while replacing the singularity with a regular core.

I’ve completed a full series of papers and I’m currently trying to understand the best way to make the work accessible to the community.

What would be the recommended path for independent researchers to get work into arXiv (gr-qc), especially regarding endorsement?

Any advice would be appreciated.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Mar 07 '26

Question Is my understanding of dimensions correct?

0 Upvotes

The fourth dimension is only "time" to us in the three-dimensional space. To a one-dimensional creature, a two-dimensional plane would be "time" (Continuity). There are infinite spaces stacked on top of each other (metaphorically), to form the fourth dimension. If you move from point A to B in space, every point that you move forwards, you're moving one point upwards in time, creating a four-dimensional shape of before and after. For a first-dimensional creature, every point that they moved forwards, their 1d line is moving upwards in a two-dimensional Plane, creating continuity for them in the form of a diagonal line through the second dimension, which represents before and after for a one-dimensional creature (continuity). The fourth dimension is only conceptually "time" to the one dimension below it (The third), same way that the second dimension is "time" to the first dimension below it.

Edit: Since I am seeing disagreement, I would like to ask, how would continuity work for a one-dimensional being, in theory, if at all?

Elaboration: What I mean is that continuity, or what we loosely call time, is not something separate from motion, but the structure that makes motion possible as ordered change. A thing cannot move unless it was somewhere, is somewhere now, and can be somewhere else after. Without that succession, you do not really have motion, only isolated positions. My idea is that for any dimension, that succession is naturally represented by the next dimension above it. For example, imagine a long strip of paper continuously moving forward, while a pen can only move left and right across it. The pen’s sideways movement represents motion in a lower dimension, while the paper’s forward movement represents continuity. As the pen moves, its path is traced onto the paper as a line. That line becomes a full record of where the pen has been, where it is, where it is going, and how fast it moved. The steepness of that line depends on how fast the pen moves relative to the paper. If the pen moves slowly sideways, the line has one slope; if it moves faster, the slope changes. In that way, the higher-dimensional trace captures not just position, but the relation between movement and continuity itself. This is also why the steepness matters. In the paper example, if the pen moved sideways at exactly the same rate as the paper moved forward, the line would reach a perfect diagonal. In the limit where the sideways motion completely matches the paper’s progression, that represents the extreme case of motion through the lower dimension relative to continuity. And if, purely theoretically, the pen were to move even beyond that relation, then the direction of the trace would flip the other way across the paper’s history. In the analogy, that would correspond to moving backward through continuity rather than forward. That is why I relate it to the idea that if a three-dimensional being could theoretically exceed the normal limit of motion through space, its path through the fourth-dimensional structure would no longer progress the same way, but could instead reverse in relation to what we call time. That is why I see the relationship between the first and second dimension as structurally equivalent to the relationship between the third and fourth. A one-dimensional object can occupy positions along a line, but its movement becomes fully mappable only in the second dimension. In the same way, a three-dimensional being can occupy positions in space, but its motion through space becomes fully mappable in the fourth dimension as a larger continuous structure. In layman’s terms, the second dimension functions like continuity for the first, just as the fourth functions like continuity for the third. So to speak in Blunt terms, the second dimension functions as "time" for the first the same way that the fourth functions as "time" for the third.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 11 '23

Question How far off is GPT-4

0 Upvotes

Can you unify relativity with quantum mechanics

As an AI language model, I cannot create new scientific breakthroughs or develop theories on my own. The unification of general relativity and quantum mechanics remains one of the most significant open questions in theoretical physics.

Several approaches have been pursued to develop a consistent quantum theory of gravity that would unify these two pillars of modern physics. Some of the most promising approaches include string theory, loop quantum gravity, and other related research programs. However, a complete and experimentally verified theory that unifies general relativity and quantum mechanics has not been developed yet.

The pursuit of a unified theory is ongoing, and researchers worldwide continue to explore new ideas and insights. It is important to note that breakthroughs in science often come from years of dedicated research and collaboration among experts in the field.

If you had to try could you come up with something

As an AI language model, I can provide you with a speculative idea that combines elements of general relativity and quantum mechanics. However, please remember that I am not capable of creating new scientific breakthroughs, and any ideas I present should be taken as purely speculative and not an actual unification of the two theories.

One possible approach could be to consider spacetime as a dynamic, quantized entity. In this framework, spacetime would be composed of discrete, fundamental units, much like how matter is composed of atoms and particles. This would require a new understanding of the structure of spacetime and its interactions with matter and energy.

For example, one could imagine a "spacetime foam" made up of tiny, interacting units, which could be described by a quantum field theory. These units might be responsible for transmitting gravitational forces, similar to how particles like photons and gluons transmit the electromagnetic and strong nuclear forces, respectively.

In this scenario, we would need to develop a new set of equations that accurately describe the behavior of this quantized spacetime, and these equations would have to reduce to the equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics in their respective regimes (i.e., at large scales and small scales).

Again, this idea is speculative, and developing a complete, consistent, and experimentally verifiable theory is a significant challenge that remains at the forefront of theoretical physics research.

Give me these equations

As an AI language model, I am unable to create new scientific equations that would successfully unify general relativity and quantum mechanics. This task is beyond the scope of my capabilities, as it requires original research and breakthroughs in theoretical physics.

Scientists are actively working on this problem, and some approaches to unifying the two theories, such as string theory and loop quantum gravity, involve complex mathematical frameworks. However, a complete and experimentally verified set of equations has not been discovered yet.

Please keep in mind that my purpose is to assist with answering questions, providing information, and generating ideas based on existing knowledge, rather than creating new scientific theories or equations.

But if you had to try

As an AI language model, I must emphasize that I cannot create new scientific equations or theories. However, I can attempt to provide a highly speculative and simplified toy model as an illustration, but please remember that this is not a real unification of general relativity and quantum mechanics.

Suppose we consider a quantized version of the gravitational field, which we could call a "graviton field." Let's denote the field strength by G(x), where x represents spacetime coordinates. A toy model equation for this field could look like:

ΔG(x) + m2 * G(x) = κ * T(x) In this equation:

Δ represents the d'Alembertian operator, which accounts for the spacetime curvature in a way similar to the Laplacian operator in Euclidean space. m represents a hypothetical mass scale that determines the "quantum" nature of the graviton field. This term is purely speculative and doesn't have any experimental basis. κ is the gravitational coupling constant, which sets the strength of the interaction between the graviton field and the source of the field (matter and energy). T(x) represents the energy-momentum tensor, which describes the distribution of matter and energy in spacetime. This equation is highly speculative and should not be taken as a real unification of general relativity and quantum mechanics. It is simply an illustration of what a hypothetical quantized gravitational field equation might look like, and it would require substantial development and modification to become a consistent and experimentally testable theory.

Developing a true unification of general relativity and quantum mechanics is a complex task that requires deep insights and understanding of the fundamental principles of physics, which is beyond the scope of my capabilities as an AI language model.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 26 '25

Question Thought experiment on faster than light objects for a layman

0 Upvotes

Okay. I am not offended if this is taken down, as I am not a physicist, only one at heart. I appreciate there are mathematical reasons that we discern that the speed of light is the max limit of the universe, which supports our intuitions that you can’t really travel beyond the speed of light because reality/time is at the speed of light essentially.

I just want someone to humor me here. Suspend disbelief that something can travel beyond the speed of light. This is one of a slew of things that tends to be unintuitive in physics and so I like to challenge it mentally.

So if we imagine an orb of gas and energy like a mini theoretical ‘super’ star (for simplicity), that was moving at 2x the speed of light in a direction generally toward you. Not at you because it would hit you. But toward where you could observe it coming and going.

How would that look to you as an observer? In front of the object, it would be invisible, as it was outrunning the light that you could see. My thought is that at the moment when it has past you (by the difference between how far it has passed you and the speed of light), you will see it ‘magically’ appear. After that, you will see a forward trail of the orb as the light of it moving will reach you like normal, making it appear that the orb is moving at the speed of light even thought it’s moving twice that.

Simultaneously, the trail of light that had not yet caught up to the object would begin to reach you, in reverse intervals that would make it appear that it was ‘expanding’ backward. This effect would tail it as it moves forward (maybe, this is where my thought gets unclear) but it would essentially appear to be expanding in both directions (more than just that since it’s an orb emitting light in all directions I suppose, but again, for simplicity’s sake).

Tell me what about this makes sense. At this late hour, this thought seems to jive with questions about universe ‘bangs’ and omni directional expansions and so I want someone smarter than me to quell that or contemplate it with me. I don’t know any other smart people who would talk to me about this, let alone at this hour.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 03 '26

Question If nothing can escape a black hole nothing should be able to fall into it

0 Upvotes

https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0509007

https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.07839

According to this paper the black hole should evaporate while you’re falling into it because of hawking radiation and time dilation and make it impossible for you to cross the event horizon since the black hole will evaporate faster than you can fall into it

collapsing matter halts at a tiny, "sub-Planckian" distance from the would be horizon. As the matter hovers there and the black hole evaporates

How to black hole consume stars then?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Dec 26 '25

Discussion What do you think constitutes the maximum extent of physics once we have “figured it all out”?

0 Upvotes

If our universe is an emergent excitation of a deeper substrate, then the Standard Model may be explainable only as a self-consistent effective description, not derivable from deeper causes that are expressible within our physical language, making the pursuit of its origin noble but potentially fundamentally limited.

It may be fundamentally impossible to discover why the Standard Model has the structure it does, if that structure is an emergent effective description of a deeper substrate whose degrees of freedom, symmetries, or organizing principles are not expressible within spacetime-based physics. In such a case, the Standard Model would be explainable only up to consistency and stability constraints, not derivable from deeper causes accessible to experiment or calculation.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Mar 17 '20

Einstein's concept of simultaneity directly contradicts his theory

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Sep 05 '26

Question Can you fully derive the Lagrangian equations from first principles without having to look it up?

0 Upvotes
463 votes, Sep 08 '26
158 Yes.
118 No, but I used to.
112 No, never.
75 Results

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jan 21 '26

Question Physicists have proposed tests for whether spacetime is discrete (pixelated) as a way to probe the simulation hypothesis. What is the current state of this research, and how seriously is it taken?

7 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 17 '20

A little more more refined...

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jun 24 '24

Question Could merging black holes travel backwards in time?

1 Upvotes

What do we know:

We can observe stellar black holes and supermassive black holes, but intermediate black holes, the theoretical result of two stellar black holes merging, seemingly aren’t in our observable universe.

A stellar black hole (or stellar-mass black hole) is a black hole formed by the gravitational collapse of a star.[1] They have masses ranging from about 5 to several tens of solar masses.

A supermassive black hole (SMBH or sometimes SBH)[a] is the largest type of black hole, with its mass being on the order of hundreds of thousands, or millions to billions, of times the mass of the Sun(M☉).

An intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) is a class of black hole with mass in the range 102–105solar masses: significantly higher than stellar black holes but lower than the 105–109 solar mass supermassive black holes

Time is relative and space and time are one. For example. If I could instantly teleport to the moon I could observe myself back on earth because light takes time to travel to the moon. If I again teleported back to earth I could watch myself on the mood observing myself on earth. My position in space changed my position in time relative to myself on the Earth and Moon. Teleporting/ traveling faster than light sent me back in time.

We only have “candidates” for IMBH. We have never “observed” two black holes merge. We have only observed gravitational wave GW190521 as our strongest evidence of intermediate black holes Gravitational waves move forward and backward through time Black holes are created when stars die. Supermassive black holes exist too early in the universe for stars to have formed and collapsed. When observed an object entering a black holes event horizon will seemingly stop in time. We don’t know what happens when you cross an event horizon. We don’t know what happens when two black holes cross each other’s event horizon. The only way we can imagine time travel is by faster than light travel which is impossible for anything with mass. Black holes can travel at 1/10 the speed of light and can rotate at 95% the speed of the light. Quasars or active galactic nuclei are/ were at the center of every galaxy.

My questions:

what if the rotation of two black holes merging creates friction in the fabric of space time that breaks the speed limit of the universe. This friction wouldn’t be an object with mass but more like a force. Like rubbing your hands together creates heat. That heat is not an object with mass. What if this “black hole friction”“heats” space time making is more malleable.

Could this friction send the black holes to the primordial universe soup where they have plenty of mass to feed them. This could explain why stellar black holes are not observed merging BUT somehow supermassive black holes (which could only be created by the merging of two stellar black holes) only exist in our early early universe creating active galactic nuclei-creating galaxies

If you combine this with the idea that black holes are wormholes to new universes then it could be imagined that a black hole is the equal and opposite reaction to a “big bang type scenario” in another universe. I know that the Big Bang is no longer relevant but it is the closest concept I can relate this to.

I am not a physicist. I just love to learn about the universe. Please don’t harshly criticize me in the comments. I am not saying that I am right. I’m just asking a genuine question because I know that I’m not smart enough to claim I am correct.

Thank you for taking the time to read this as crazy as it may sound :) I really appreciate any constructive criticism. Please don’t bully me if you think I’m stupid :)


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jul 02 '20

"Theory" Idea about the Lightspeed limit

1 Upvotes

So I had this idea the other day.

Gravity itself acts at the speed of light as it travels through the fabric of space-time. I understand that the fabric of space-time is not made of matter, however, if the fabric of space time were a form of matter in a higher dimension that we had not yet discovered. If gravity acts on the fabric of space-time like normal matter then since the speed that matter can be distorted is directly linked to the speed of sound in that material could it be conceived that the speed of light in our dimension is the speed of sound through the fabric of space-time in the fourth dimension?

My issues with this idea are that if this were the case would this concept act as a connection between a dimension and that above it. So if for example the same scenario can be seen from the 5th dimension into the 4th dimension then it would travel up the dimensions ladder until it reached the highest dimension (if there is one) but once it reaches the highest level it would have no law governing the highest dimension as there's no higher level to determine it. This could cause a domino effect deleting the law from the lower dimensions. I would like to hear opinions on this concept in the case that it doesn't destroy itself or to confirm my original thought. Thank you


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Apr 13 '19

Someone help me to find this result

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Aug 04 '26

Question A question about down quarks

1 Upvotes

I have a serious question - what proof is there that a down quark is a seperate and unique particle as opposed to an electron hard bound to an up quark?

Let us look at a number of things. First is that when an electron hits a proton with enough force an up quark is changed to a down quark. Note that no energy is released, the extinction event of a negative charge hitting a positive charge does not happen.

Second we look at the fact that a proton plus an electron creates a neutron and a neutron minus an electron produces a proton. This is an identity relationship and very strongly implies the electron was there all along unchanged.

Third if there were an electron at the core of a proton, in spliting the proton into component quarks, the electron would remain bound to one if the up quarks. The only way to separate the two is to instantly accelerate the electron, the up quark being much more massive could not keep up.

Fourth if an electron was bound to an up quark at the macro level it would look like a -1/3 charge but at a subatomic level it would be two seperate charges, which explains a lot about fusion.

Fifth fusion generates a huge amount of gamma rays. Gamma rays are photons. Only electrons generate photons so electrons must be present in the fusing nucleus.

Sixth quantum particles are fields, an electron bound to an up quark is very much a quantum structure.

Seventh this would explain why neutrons decay. We know because of Plank's constant that electrons can not tolerate being close to each other. The one of the two electrons in a neutron eventually due to vibration, pushes the othe out.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Feb 07 '20

Second Lesson on Special Relativity

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 11 '25

Question Matter vs. anti-matter -- not quite symmetrical? (And the instability of an anti-matter universe)

0 Upvotes

I understand that anti-matter is a form of matter in which all the constituent particles are the electrically polar opposites of their counterparts in normal matter.

This suggests that an anti-particle universe could exists, identical to our own, but composed of anti-matter where we have matter, and vice versa.

BUT... I recall reading somewhere once that even though this idea (of an anti-matter universe) seems to be a direct corollary of the definition of anti-matter, it actually isn't so, because the relation between matter and anti-matter isn't quite symmetrical. There is "something" a little off about anti-matter that would make an anti-matter universe extremely unstable, and prone to collapse or disintegrate almost immediately.

Is anyone familiar with this? I'd like to know why that is, i.e. why an anti-matter universe could in fact not be stable the way our universe is.

Thanks all.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 23 '25

Question What would happen if a Quasar star, Black hole and Neutron Star collided with eachother?

0 Upvotes

(I'm thinking either the black hole would be strong enough to try and devour everything but I'm also thinking some kinda cosmic force would happen with all that colliding energy but idk, I wanna hear your thoughts)


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Jul 01 '24

Question What’s the purpose of creating a theory of everything

0 Upvotes

As an aspiring physics major I would like to know the reasoning behind trying to find a theory of everything.

How would such a theory contribute to modern advances in technology?

Technology in the realms of nanotechnology, materials science or even mechanical engineering.

Isn’t quantum mechanics already very precise at describing how molecules interact and move along the universe.

I suppose such a theory would be useful for explaining unknown phenomena in this world but that’s about it.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 10 '26

Question I published in a Q1, what next?

2 Upvotes

Dear all,

Im an undergrad student of physics in Germany. I studied a bit of theoretical physics before starting my bachelor studies, and let's say I already knew what I wanted to do in terms of research lines and how to do research from my previous studies.

I submitted a manuscript this summer which has just been accepted to a Q1 journal in particles and fields, at the level of CQG, EPJC, PRD, JCAP... (I do not want to disclose).

Since I know no one publishing at the student level, and I have no supervisor, I wanted to ask what are my possibilities now in terms of getting my publication read. I am not interested in pursuing an academic career, but I humbly think my work may be relevant to the field. Is there any association helping young researchers? Maybe the DPG in Germany does? I plan on sending the article to one of my Professors, but I don't know what else could I do. It is of course on ArXiv.

Thanks!


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 04 '24

Question Is there a paper or proof that deals with how dimension is created?

0 Upvotes

In math, if we multiply 2 certain algebraic objects(e.g set, space, vector space)

* : R x R -> R^2 , we get an object in higher dimension(i.e in R^2 here)

=> which implies that if you multiply low dimension spaces => higher dimension. (e.g R^3, R^4 ..)

Same goes for In the space-time continuum: Let R^3 be a 3-dimension space and S be an arbitrary time space, then * : R^3 x S^1 => R^4

I wonder if there is a paper which *proves* that this also works in our world. ( I am not interested in the uniqueness or existence of higher dimension, like Kant's work on conceptualizing 4th dimension or Cayley and grassman's analytical (vector) method to prove its existence.

But i would like to read a paper explicitly about if creating dimension in our physical world is based on multiplying lower dimensional spaces/

What I have found is that according to the curvature of Hermann Minkowski’s flat four-dimensional space-time, space by itself, and time by itself, are doomed to fade away into mere shadows, and only a kind of union of the two will preserve independent reality => which implies that creating dimension is union of different spaces, which is what i am looking at but it doesn't really show a proof correspondent to the physical world.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Nov 23 '25

Question What does it mean that a Black Hole has infinite density?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Feb 11 '25

Question How can we describe singularities beyond the spacetime model?

0 Upvotes

Relativity predicts that singularities occur where spacetime curvature becomes infinite. But since spacetime itself is just a model rather than a fundamental entity, what approach do we take to describe singularities beyond this framework? Most explanations I’ve found stay within the spacetime model rather than addressing the core issue directly.

I’m new to this, so if I’m missing something obvious, feel free to correct me, just ignore any ignorance on my part.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Mar 20 '20

Here's an argument for the many-worlds hypoethesis NOT being true in real life:

0 Upvotes

The many worlds theory goes that, if I wake up in the morning and have a choice between Fruit Loops and Frosted Flakes for breakfast, regardless of which choice I make, another universe's version of me will make the opposite choice anyway. I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume that no universe exists where I make an impossible choice (e.g. where I choose to eat Captain Crunch despite not having nay Captain Crunch on hand), just to simplify things.

However, if this hypothesis were in fact true, you would think that people would act inconsistently with past actions all the time. However, we typically observe some consistency in people's behavior. Obviously, every person is different, but if I know a person well enough, I can usually predict their actions with reasonable certainty.

For example, if I'm a security guard at a store, and one of my regular customers consistently pays for his items without stealing them, I will eventually start monitoring him with only casual supervision, as I trust him to not steal.

But if the many-worlds theory is true, then there should be just as many instances where a person - who had previously paid for his items 100% of the time - suddenly decides to start stealing, for no other reason than because ... it turns out there has always been a universe where he stole instead of paid, and this time, I just got unlucky and got dumped into the wrong universe, after getting lucky the previous 500 times.

But that doesn't happen. While people don't behave nearly as consistently as the laws of physics (again, I'm ruling out impossible alternatives), we can indeed predict a person's actions relatively consistently. If this guy suddenly starts stealing, it's usually because of one of two things: (1) he has always been a thief, and I just haven't caught him until now, or (2) something serious must have happened to him (such as unemployment or a sudden surge in family expenses, e.g. a sick child) that would drive an otherwise decent person to a life of crime. And in 99.99999% of cases, it will indeed be one of those two things, not simply that I drew the short straw in the many-worlds hypothesis this time around. If that were the case, then these sorts of out-of-character actions would be happening all the time!

That alone, in my opinion, presents a very compelling argument for the many worlds hypothesis not being true in real life.

What are your thoughts?