r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 1d ago

Discussion Physics questions weekly thread! - (November 15, 2026-November 21, 2026)

4 Upvotes

This weekly thread is dedicated for questions about physics and physical mathematics.

Some questions do not require advanced knowledge in physics to be answered. Please, before asking a question, try r/askscience and r/AskPhysics instead. Homework problems or specific calculations may be removed by the moderators if it is not related to theoretical physics, try r/HomeworkHelp instead.

If your question does not break any rules, yet it does not get any replies, you may try your luck again during next week's thread. The moderators are under no obligation to answer any of the questions. Wait for a volunteer from the community to answer your question.

LaTeX rendering for equations is allowed through u/LaTeX4Reddit. Write a comment with your LaTeX equation enclosed with backticks (`) (you may write it using inline code feature instead), followed by the name of the bot in the comment. For more informations and examples check our guide: how to write math in this sub.

This thread should not be used to bypass the avoid self-theories rule. If you want to discuss hypothetical scenarios try r/HypotheticalPhysics.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 1h ago

Discussion Why the nature makes neutrinos oscillate

0 Upvotes

What purpose do only neutrino fulfill by oscillating between the flavors


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 3d ago

Question How to be good at physics

20 Upvotes

I wish to pursue a career as a searcher in theoretical physics. I'm not good at mathematics nor physics but my grades are still around a 3.5+ in US GPA. I know a lot of people's advice is to train again and again, read books and be curious but I was wondering if anyone has unhinged advice that helped them uplift their mathematical and physics skills, niche ways?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 3d ago

Resources Lesser-known cosmology podcasts worth following?

4 Upvotes

Which smaller podcasts on cosmology, physics or the nature of time do you recommend? I'm looking for ones that are still active, with episodes in the last few months, and that aren't run by a big network or a university.
Thanks!


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 6d ago

Question How would a bubble universe’s wall behave?

3 Upvotes

I’m writing fiction for fun: to save themselves from a dying universe, the elite of the universe make a bubble universe, encapsulating a galaxy, where it’s then severed from our world.
I know very little about physics and astrophysics and stuff, but I’m trying to think of what seems most realistic.
My idea is that: over time, the galaxy’s outer stars drift off and fly into the bubble universe’s wall… but what would happen? Wouldn’t that wall be the boundary where spacetime (which allows reality to function) meets nothing (the 4D bulk), so, if a star slammed into it… it would just, smash and bounce off? Or, if a human touched the wall… you would feel nothing, and see nothing past it, as thats all there is, so you physically couldn’t touch anything past it… cause there’s no spacetime to keep your hand functioning physically? Or could you stick your hand past it, and instantly your matter would deconstruct outside of the spacetime that lets it work, and when you try to pull your arm back out… it’s gone, but then how could a bubble universe hold anything?

Idk, sorry if I’m terribly wrong in my guess.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 8d ago

Discussion Physics questions weekly thread! - (November 08, 2026-November 14, 2026)

1 Upvotes

This weekly thread is dedicated for questions about physics and physical mathematics.

Some questions do not require advanced knowledge in physics to be answered. Please, before asking a question, try r/askscience and r/AskPhysics instead. Homework problems or specific calculations may be removed by the moderators if it is not related to theoretical physics, try r/HomeworkHelp instead.

If your question does not break any rules, yet it does not get any replies, you may try your luck again during next week's thread. The moderators are under no obligation to answer any of the questions. Wait for a volunteer from the community to answer your question.

LaTeX rendering for equations is allowed through u/LaTeX4Reddit. Write a comment with your LaTeX equation enclosed with backticks (`) (you may write it using inline code feature instead), followed by the name of the bot in the comment. For more informations and examples check our guide: how to write math in this sub.

This thread should not be used to bypass the avoid self-theories rule. If you want to discuss hypothetical scenarios try r/HypotheticalPhysics.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 9d ago

Question Are there any pathways to study theoretical physics without making it my life's primary pursuit?

5 Upvotes

I'm quite young and have always been fascinated by many subjects, particularly Humanities and Social Sciences but Theoretical Physics has always stuck out to me as my one favourite stem subject (alongside cosmology). I've recently started wondering what I want to do when I'm older, and I mean lots of things, but I've always wanted to be able to become a credentialed theoretical physicist, and I recognise that self-study will hardly be enough and I don't want to end up being one of those annoying crackpots that annoy your guys' community with stupid claims. Is there any formal pathway to allow me to get a credential in theoretical physics OR a related subject while being able to pursue something different. For context, I'm in the UK, not yet in university but I'm preparing, and I'm primarily associated by my peers for my knowledge on history, politics, philosophy, and other more social subjects, but I've, for the past few years now, developed a real desire to understand the mathematical components of academia, weirdly stemming from my obsession with natural philosophy which drove me towards science.

All you really need to know is that I don't want to be entirely self-taught and wouldn't mind having to be a few years behind in getting any credentials if it means I can be at least half-decent at this amazing subject, I completely recognise I could never be the next Einstein or Fermi as they were Theoretical Physicists first and other stuff second and that's fine, that's never been an issue. Much info would be appreciated, thank you.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 11d ago

Question Since white holes are predicted by general relativity, is there an equivalent for gravastars?

0 Upvotes

From what ive researched, the gravastar hypothesis has an infinitely dense vacuum with negative infinite pressure, surrounded by an infinately thin layer of plasma with infinite pressure. With white holes the main theory ive seen is a black hole who's singularity rebounded or bounced and began growing again to beyond the event horizon. Since gravastars were originally proposed as an alternative to black holes since they "dont work" with quantum gravity (from what ive heard), so a "white hole" equivalent would make sense, however i cant make any idea on what it would be like or how the physics of it would function. Ive also seen the idea that gravastars are the dark energy making the universe expand quicker, and primordial black holes are the dark matter holding galaxies together, and that it was found that gravastars and black holes arent mutually exclusive so would black holes be the "white hole" equivalent to a gravastar?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 15d ago

Question Questions from a newbie: what is theoretical physics?

29 Upvotes

Hi im in grade 11 and im wondering whether i should take physics or theoretical physics as my major, but i have some questions

No matter where i search, it seems really hard to understand what you guys all do, so here i am

  • Is theoretical physics mostly using computers and solving problems all day?

  • Is there a lot of free time?

  • What does a week in university look like for theoretical physics majors?

  • Is there a lot of demand for theoretical physicists?

  • What jobs do theoretical physicists often take?

  • Is there a lot of social interaction?

  • Is it very stressful?

  • Will i lose my hair/grow white hair?

  • Should i enter math competitions? (but most of them relies on remembering formulas, i thought theoretical physics is about first principles or something like that?)

  • What should i study beforehand to make life easier? (python and what other math topics?)

  • What does studying it look like? Is it like you're behind a computer all day or understanding stuff? Is it like 10 hrs a time or 3 hrs a time?

  • What made you take theoretical physics? Do you love it? What do you love about it?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 15d ago

Discussion Physics questions weekly thread! - (November 01, 2026-November 07, 2026)

2 Upvotes

This weekly thread is dedicated for questions about physics and physical mathematics.

Some questions do not require advanced knowledge in physics to be answered. Please, before asking a question, try r/askscience and r/AskPhysics instead. Homework problems or specific calculations may be removed by the moderators if it is not related to theoretical physics, try r/HomeworkHelp instead.

If your question does not break any rules, yet it does not get any replies, you may try your luck again during next week's thread. The moderators are under no obligation to answer any of the questions. Wait for a volunteer from the community to answer your question.

LaTeX rendering for equations is allowed through u/LaTeX4Reddit. Write a comment with your LaTeX equation enclosed with backticks (`) (you may write it using inline code feature instead), followed by the name of the bot in the comment. For more informations and examples check our guide: how to write math in this sub.

This thread should not be used to bypass the avoid self-theories rule. If you want to discuss hypothetical scenarios try r/HypotheticalPhysics.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 15d ago

Question Advice on whether is should pursue research

11 Upvotes

For some context I'm a final year theoretical physics student in the UK. This is the point where I ultimately make the decision on if I should pursue a masters, leading to a PHD etc. or if I should just go into industry (still deciding between something physics/software/finance related). My main concern is the landscape of research right now, with AI supposedly 'solving' naiver stokes and proving the existence of yang mills, I'm worried that pursuing research in anything theoretical would be a mistake. And even if its not, would it ultimately be worth it? Physics funding in the UK is getting cut seemingly every year and grad prospects seem to be at an all time low while competition is at an all time high . I am aware that this ultimately is a very personal choice but I think some perspective might help me make a decision.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 18d ago

Question Anti-Plasma vs Quark Gluon Plasma

9 Upvotes

I am writing some science fiction material for a few people, and I would like to try and base it on reality if possible. I recently learned it is hypothetically possible to have antimatter take the form of a plasma. It seems like something like that would be obvious to appear in a science fiction setting, but I can't even find much in the way of fictional sources either. However, I have seen Quark Gluon Plasma brought up as a theoretical end point for the development of plasma weapons, since by its nature it exceeds 3 trillion degrees.

My question is, if a far-future weapons designer were to try and make a space borne plasma-based superweapon, such as a very explodey beam gun, would antimatter-plasma have more destructive power than "regular" plasma? Would it even matter if the ionized antimatter was hotter? Would it just be easier at that point to launch solid-masses of antimatter as projectiles instead?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 18d ago

Question Why is the 4th dimension time?

0 Upvotes

Is the dimension treated as physical? Because I don’t believe time is physical because its treated separately from a spatial axis but if its a temporal axis then why are we only considered 3-D beings because we all undergo time because our body experience change and we can move from one point to another and have length, width, and height what does a being with this temporal axis gain?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 21d ago

"Theory" Is math really necessary for understanding physics?

0 Upvotes

I feel as though mathematics limits the potential of what physics is capable of showing us. Physics confined to a framework of mathematics limits its interpretation of reality to a mere assembly of mathematical equations which then reinforces an binary, numeral interpretation of reality. I also feel as though mathematics tends to summarize an experience rather than allowing it to be open ended for a variety of interpretations. What are peoples thoughts on this?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 22d ago

Discussion Physics questions weekly thread! - (October 25, 2026-October 31, 2026)

6 Upvotes

This weekly thread is dedicated for questions about physics and physical mathematics.

Some questions do not require advanced knowledge in physics to be answered. Please, before asking a question, try r/askscience and r/AskPhysics instead. Homework problems or specific calculations may be removed by the moderators if it is not related to theoretical physics, try r/HomeworkHelp instead.

If your question does not break any rules, yet it does not get any replies, you may try your luck again during next week's thread. The moderators are under no obligation to answer any of the questions. Wait for a volunteer from the community to answer your question.

LaTeX rendering for equations is allowed through u/LaTeX4Reddit. Write a comment with your LaTeX equation enclosed with backticks (`) (you may write it using inline code feature instead), followed by the name of the bot in the comment. For more informations and examples check our guide: how to write math in this sub.

This thread should not be used to bypass the avoid self-theories rule. If you want to discuss hypothetical scenarios try r/HypotheticalPhysics.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 22d ago

Question Can a black hole split into two in accordance with Einstein’s general relativity?

Thumbnail
thebrighterside.news
13 Upvotes

Black holes merge, but reversing that process presents obstacles that go far beyond running a collision backward. A single black hole cannot ordinarily divide into two smaller ones under the usual assumptions of Einstein’s gravity. A theoretical study examines those restrictions and asks what would need to change for fragmentation to become possible.

Published in Physical Review D, the work brings together researchers affiliated with the University of Southern Denmark, the University of Naples Federico II and the CNRS–Sorbonne Université laboratory LPTHE. Its title, “When black holes admit pair-of-pants topologies,” describes a hypothetical horizon branching through time. The analysis maps possible conditions for fragmentation without calculating a complete splitting process.

“In our study, we investigate which physical laws normally prevent a black hole from splitting into two,” said co-author Francesco Sannino, a professor affiliated with Naples and Southern Denmark. “We also investigate if certain circumstances may allow a split to happen.” His collaborators are Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano and Vania Vellucci.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 23d ago

"Theory" I made a video asking Julian Barbour why entropy maximization (and heat death) is not the universe's real goal, how he calculates probabilities without wavefunctions and his doubts about quantum gravity

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Julian Barbour is a theoretical physicist and emeritus visiting professor of physics at the University of Oxford. He is well known for proposing that time does not actually exist. For decades, he has worked outside an academic environment. He financially supported himself for many years by translating Russian. Professor Barbour is author of the following books: The Discovery of Dynamics, The End of Time and The Janus Point.

In this episode, we go over:
- Topos theory, set theory and Zermelo's beef with Boltzmann
- Algebraic varieties and monads in category theory
- Why physicists are wrong about the 2nd law of thermodynamics (because the universe is not a closed system) and maybe there is no heat death of the universe
- The real goal of the universe is complexity and variation, not entropy
- Hawking and Penrose's outrageous arguments
- Why we don't need wavefunctions, photons, bosons or gauge fields
- Why there is no quantum gravity
- Von Neumann's hilarious advice to Claude Shannon
- The intrinsic derivative
- Combining art and science


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 23d ago

Discussion Do we correctly understand how mass warps spacetime? Why?

0 Upvotes

As someone who holds Einstein in high regard and deeply admires his scientific theories, I believe that the concept of mass curving spacetime is not properly understood.

There is a very popular analogy—frequently used in university textbooks and other scientific sources—to explain how mass curves spacetime: spheres are placed on a taut, flexible fabric, creating depressions proportional to their weight and drawing smaller marbles toward them. However, this is not an accurate analogy; in fact, it is a very poor one. Space is not a two-dimensional, taut, flexible fabric, nor is there a "downward" gravitational pull acting within it. Consequently, this analogy should be discarded and, if possible, replaced with a correct one. Personally, I suspect that no such accurate analogy can be provided, as I do not believe we have truly grasped the nature of how spacetime is curved. To those who might accuse me of ignorance, I say: fine, I am ignorant—but if you want me to be quiet, then provide the correct explanation for how mass curves spacetime and silence me.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 24d ago

Question Query on the Holographic Principle

5 Upvotes

In ordinary holography, laser light is used to generate the 3D image of a 3D  object which has been recorded on a special 2D surface.  Which leads to my naive question:

In the context of string theory’s holographic principle, is there something analogous to the laser, which then projects a D-dimensional boundary’s coded QFT information into a (D+1)-dimensional bulk universe?  Or is no such action needed? Thanks, Gene


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 25d ago

Question What are the Ramifications of Using Charged Dilatons Instead of Negative Mass/Energy for Superluminal Travel?

Thumbnail sciencedirect.com
1 Upvotes

There are a few articles out there that claim that charged dilatons can be used instead of negative mass/energy for Alcubierre Drives and wormholes. I'm curious about the ramifications of that, however.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • 29d ago

Discussion Physics questions weekly thread! - (October 18, 2026-October 24, 2026)

2 Upvotes

This weekly thread is dedicated for questions about physics and physical mathematics.

Some questions do not require advanced knowledge in physics to be answered. Please, before asking a question, try r/askscience and r/AskPhysics instead. Homework problems or specific calculations may be removed by the moderators if it is not related to theoretical physics, try r/HomeworkHelp instead.

If your question does not break any rules, yet it does not get any replies, you may try your luck again during next week's thread. The moderators are under no obligation to answer any of the questions. Wait for a volunteer from the community to answer your question.

LaTeX rendering for equations is allowed through u/LaTeX4Reddit. Write a comment with your LaTeX equation enclosed with backticks (`) (you may write it using inline code feature instead), followed by the name of the bot in the comment. For more informations and examples check our guide: how to write math in this sub.

This thread should not be used to bypass the avoid self-theories rule. If you want to discuss hypothetical scenarios try r/HypotheticalPhysics.


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 17 '26

"Theory" Invariant Gauge in knot

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am currently studying knot equivalence in

\\(S\^{4}\\) (which is a compact 4-dimensional manifold). Based on \[A gauge theoretic invariant of embedded surfaces in 4-manifolds and exotic 𝑃2-knot cite you the paiper .\], I understand that any knot in \\(S\^{4}\\) is connected in a \\(P\^{2}\\)-knot space; these are tubular neighborhoods of the form \\(\\nu(S\^4, P\+)\\) such that for some neighborhood \\(\\nu \{n}\\) with a non-zero integer, it is not a diffeomorphic pair of \\(S\^{1}\\). Consequently, any knot in \\(S\^{4}\\) has crossings if and only if it admits topological isotopies (meaning it is not smoothly isotopic to \\(S\^{1}\\)). My question is: do these \\(P\^{2}\\)-knot invariants have a purely gauge-theoretic—that is, local—nature, rather than a global one on \\(S\^{1}\\)?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 14 '26

Question TheoPhysEval: Assessing AI agents at autonomous theoretical physics problem solving

26 Upvotes

What are your takes and overall concerns on this recent preprint (https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.16733)?

I am especially wondering how AI impacts will affect prospective grad students and early-career researchers in theoretical physics.


Recalling Dr. Schwartz (u/VibePhysics) saying in his Anthropic post Vibe Physics:

It is worth it, however, to consider the role of education going forward. In the deep future (~10 years), when AI is truly smarter than all of us and capable of outperforming us in every domain, what will be the role of higher education? I think some things will persist—those things that are essentially human. I can easily imagine theoretical physics becoming like music theory or French literature: an academic discipline appealing to people who just enjoy thinking through a certain lens. It's a bit ironic that the last 30 years have seen the growth of STEM fields, displacing the humanities, and in the end it may be the humanities are all that survive.

Do you agree with his thoughts? And what concerns or hopes do you have about where our fields in theoretical physics are heading?


r/TheoreticalPhysics • • Oct 12 '26

Question I need advice for a mathematical physics master's project - which topic?

15 Upvotes

Hello! I'm currently doing a masters and reached out to a few supervisors. I'm really interested in lots of different areas of physics, and I'm confused about which ones to pick... I have some prior experience with quiver gauge theories, which is why one of the options is to work on super Lie algebras, but also I don't really see myself working in string theory in the future since it's way too abstract (and I'm a little pessimistic?). I also have an option to work on BMS group, and I really enjoyed my general relativity course, so that really excites me. And another more pure-math option related to non-commutative structures.

I'm so confused and indecisive, what would you recommend? Also quiver gauge may be more publishable than the other options due to computation being possible but also I'm really interested in black holes, and I was thinking about how it would seem for PhDs. Thanks!