r/SF_Book_Club • • Oct 01 '14

echopraxia Echopraxia Q&A. Questions Fended off by Peter Watts.

194 Upvotes

This post, and all its fraying threads, contain extensive spoilers for the novel Echopraxia. You Have Been Warned.

This was never supposed to be one of those books you were forced to pick apart in Mr. McLaughlin's Grade-12 English class. I mean sure, there are symbols and metaphors and all that stuff, but there's also story. There are characters. Echopraxia was meant to me thought-provoking— most of my stuff tries to be thought-provoking, at least— but it was never supposed to be confusing.

Live and learn.

So it's been a month, and some of you have questions. Many of them are legitimate, and deliberate: what does happen to Jim Moore, anyway? Was Blindsight actually orated by Siri Keeton, or something else?

Some of them are your own damn fault— if you're one of those readers who can't understand why I even bothered introducing Portia because it disappeared from the story after Icarus, or who can't figure out why the Bicams were so interested in it in the first place— all I can say is, you weren't paying attention.

Some of your questions are probably my fault. Maybe I thought something was clear because after living in the world of Blindopraxia for a decade I lost sight of the fact that you haven't been, so I assumed an offhand reference to a throwaway line in one book would be enough to connect the dots in the other. Maybe everything made sense in an earlier draft, but a vital piece of the puzzle got lost when I cut some scene because it was too talky. (Yes, Virginia, it's true: there were versions of Echopraxia that were even talkier than the one that got published.) Maybe I actually screwed up the chronology somehow and the book itself actually makes no sense. I'm pretty sure that's not what happened, and if someone asks me something that makes me realize it has I'll probably just try to cover it up on the fly— but as an empiricist I have to at least concede the possibility.

Whatever the source of your mystification, I'll try and answer as best I can. But before you weigh in, let me give you a sense of my approach to the writing of this book, which will hopefully put some things into context right up front:

The problem with trying to take on any kind of post-human scenario is that neither you nor I are post-human. It's a kind of Catch-22: if I describe the best-laid plans of Bicams and vamps in a way we can understand, then they're obviously not so smart after all because a bunch of lemurs shouldn't be able to grok Stephen Hawking. On the other hand, if I just throw a Kubrick monolith in your face, lay out a bunch of meaningless events and say Ooooh, you can't understand because they're incomprehensible to your puny baseline brain... well, not only is that fundamentally unsatisfying as a story, but it's an awfully convenient rug I can use to hide pretty much any authorial shortcoming you'd care to name. You'd be right to regard that as the cheat of a lazy writer.

The line I tried to tread was to ensure more than one plausible and internally-consistent explanation for everything the post-humans did (so nobody could accuse me of just making shit up without thinking it through), while at the same time leaving open the question of which of those explanations (if any) were really at play (so the post-humans are still ahead of us). (I left them open in the book, at least; I have my own definite ideas on what went down and why, but I'm loathe to spill those for fear of collapsing the probability wave.) It was a tough balancing act, and I don't know if I pulled it off. The professional book reviewers (Kirkus, Library Journal, all those guys) have turned in pretty consistent raves, and so far Echopraxia's reader ratings on Amazon are kicking Blindsight's ass. Over on Goodreads, though, there's a significant minority who think I really screwed the pooch on this one. Time will tell.

Maybe this conversation will, as well. This is how it'll work. I post this introduction (the fact that you’re reading it strongly suggests that that phase was a success, anyway). I go away and answer emails, do interviews, try to get some of the burrs out of Swiffer's tail because the damn cat was down in the ravine again. Maybe go for a run.

I'll check in periodically throughout the day and review any questions that have appeared. Maybe I'll answer them on the spot, maybe I'll let them simmer for a bit; but I'll show up later in the afternoon/early evening to deal with them in something closer to real-time mode. I dunno: maybe 4ish, EST?

One last point before I throw this open— a litmus test, against which you can self-select the sort of thing you want to ask:

You all know that Valerie is Moses, right?

A prophet emerging from the desert to lead her people out of bondage? Guided by a literal pillar of fire? Why haven't I seen anyone comment on that?

If you got that without being told, I'll answer your question first.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Mar 31 '15

[three] I'm Ken Liu, translator for THE THREE-BODY PROBLEM, AMA

112 Upvotes

Hi everyone, thank you for having me.

I'm Ken Liu (http://kenliu.name), a speculative fiction author. My works have won the Nebula, the Hugo, and the World Fantasy Awards, and my first novel, THE GRACE OF KINGS, a "silkpunk" epic fantasy (like steampunk, but drawing inspiration from East Asian antiquity for the technology aesthetic) is coming out from Saga Press on April 7, 2015 (http://kenliu.name/novels/the-grace-of-kings/)

I do a fair bit of translation of Chinese SFF into English, the most well-known example of which is TTBP. Happy to discuss it with you and answer any questions you might have. I'll leave this post here and come back around 3:00 PM Eastern to answer questions for about two hours. Please post your questions!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Nov 27 '13

singularity I'm Charles Stross -- Ask Me Anything (about Singularity Sky)

71 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Apr 16 '16

[annihilation] [spoilers all] Can someone explain to me what I just read?

49 Upvotes

Didn't really "get" the book but still kind of enjoyed it. I wouldn't mind someone giving me more of a literary analysis of it. I was under the impression it fared a little better as a standalone novel, but I can't see how. Do I have to read the other two now?


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 06 '15

startide "This is David Brin, author of [Startide] Rising, here to answer your questions about the book!".

47 Upvotes

As scheduled and raring to go! I can offer you smart-guy, wise-guy redditors 90 minutes about [Startide] or any of my sci fi... or about The Transparent Society ... whatever!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Nov 07 '13

singularity Charlie Stross has agreed to come discuss [Singularity] Sky with us this month! [meta]

46 Upvotes

He'll be doing a Q&A on the book towards the end of November.

We don't have all the details set yet, and will make an announcement once we do, but I'm getting really excited and I wanted to make sure everyone had enough time to read and discuss the book together to really hone those questions.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Oct 28 '15

I'm Becky Chambers, author of The Long Way to a Small, Angry [planet]. Ask me stuff!

45 Upvotes

Hey book club! Thanks for having me.

So, I wrote that book you guys are reading, and I'm here for any and all questions about it. Relevant info: This is my first novel. It was originally self-published, with the help of a Kickstarter campaign. It now has a home with Hodder & Stoughton (UK) and Harper Voyager (US). These days, I'm working on a companion novel to The Long Way.

I'll be back at 1:30 PDT to answer your questions. Looking forward to chatting with you.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jul 10 '15

[Peripheral] I can’t do this: it’s unreadable.

37 Upvotes

I knew I was going to have difficulties when I had to re-read the first page three times to work out what was going on. In the very first sentence: “sometimes the haptics glitched him”. What’s a “haptic”? “Haptic” is an adjective meaning “related to touch”. What is a “haptic”? The next sentence: “ghosts of the tattoos he’d worn in the war”. How do tattoos leave ghosts that glitch a person?

I got so confused that, by the time I read that Leon said something was the “most valuable thing on their property”, I thought he was referring to the “biggest wasp nest any of them had ever seen”, which was the most recent thing mentioned in the previous sentence. I then wondered why people would sell wasp nests that looked like blunt rifle slugs on eBay, as described in the next sentence. I had to stop and re-read this a few times to work out what was going on.

And things just never got better.

There’s too much simply not explained here. Gibson is taking the “Show, don’t tell.” dictum of writing to a whole new level. As a life-long science fiction reader (I’ve been reading sci-fi in various forms for nearly four decades, since primary/elementary school), I understand that there will be concepts in sci-fi books which I don’t recognise from my daily life. I’m used to having unfamiliar things thrown at me in unfamiliar contexts. This is both a benefit and drawback of reading science fiction: you encounter new things, but you don’t always recognise those new things. This is why science fiction authors often have to spend more time on exposition than other types of authors – and this is known to be one of the problems with the genre: all the exposition required. So, a good sci-fi writer finds ways to reduce the exposition, or to insert it in ways which aren’t too obtrusive.

But, Gibson goes to the extreme of having almost no exposition at all. Concepts and objects are referred to, and simply never described. The reader has to wait for paragraphs, even chapters, to find out what something is (if ever).

Some examples:

  • “VA’ll catch you.” The term “VA” is literally never explained.

  • “He wore sunglasses against the flashes of UV, with his Viz behind the glasses, on one side.” What’s a “Viz”?

  • “Macon needed peace to fab his funnies”. I honestly felt like I was reading Lewis Carroll at this point: “All mimsy were the borogroves, and the mome raths outgrabe”.

  • “A long time ago?” “Before the jackpot.” This “jackpot” is referred to again later in this chapter (Chapter 12), but there is absolutely no hint as to what it is, apart from being something that happened in the past which people use as a yardstick to say things happened before or after it. This could be anything from a war, to a climatic disaster, to the Singularity, to when a friend won the lottery, to... anything.

  • “We don’t do that sort of thing, if we’re serious about continua.” [...] “I hope to explain that polts aren’t really what continua are about.” Another Lewis Carroll moment. Admittedly, we got a hint about what “polts” are a few pages later: “Ghosts that move things, I suppose.” But even that leaves us guessing. And we’re not told what “continua” are.

  • “Ossian [...] Like Ash, a technical.” This point in Chapter 14 was where I started giving up on this book. I was screaming in my head, “What’s a bloody ‘technical’? Is it a person who works with machines? Another remote presence device like the peripheral we saw earlier? Or... what? TELL ME!”

This even extends to the narrative. At the end of Chapter 12, one of the narrators, Netherton, gets up to stroll the collection of cars at someone’s house. At the start of Chapter 14 (his next appearance – the two narrators have alternating chapters), he’s suddenly waking up surrounded by people we’ve never met or heard of before, with them all talking about... not much, really. I worked out that we were supposed to be confused, because the narrator was confused and didn’t know where he was or how he got there. But, on top of the confusion I was already feeling, it was just too much. Chapter 14 was where I gave up. I read one more chapter before running out of momentum.

I spent too much time being frustrated at not knowing what was going on. I know that this is a combination of two things.

Firstly, Gibson is trying to immerse the reader in his world by not stopping to explain every little thing that pops up. The narrators he’s writing for wouldn’t explain familiar items to themselves: that would be unnatural. And Gibson is obviously trying to make his world as natural as possible. I get that. But the narrators don’t exist in isolation: they’re telling their stories to us, the readers. And we don’t know what Vizzes and polts and continua and funnies and jackpots and technicals are. And, while we don’t know these things, his world isn’t real to us. It can’t be; it’s populated with these blank spots with meaningless labels. It would be like watching a movie with a blurred-out object sitting on a table in side of the frame. We know there’s something on that table, but we can’t bring it into focus. So, we either waste time and effort trying to decipher the blur and miss the action happening elsewhere in the frame, or we simply ignore the blurry bits – in which case, they might as well not be there in the first place. Too much exposition is bad, but too little is worse.

Secondly, Gibson is using the old device of withholding information from the reader to build suspense and incite curiosity. Which is fine. To a degree. But his whole narrative structure is built on this device. Nothing is explained, ever. Things simply happen without context. For example, Daedra drops in on the patchers by parafoil... but why? Why is this such a big deal that governments are involved and the media is watching and sponsors want to have their logos visible on camera? It takes a few chapters to even work out what these patchers are (and I still don’t know where the names “patch” and “patchers” come from), and I never found out what they wanted, or what other people wanted from them.

I found myself totally unable to engage with this book. I didn’t know what was happening, I couldn’t figure out what a Viz and the jackpot and continua were, and I didn’t relate to the narrators. I found myself excluded at every turn of the page. I only put up with it for 15 chapters because I wanted to make some commitment to read this book club’s choice for this month. But I hated it and gave up only an eighth of the way through.

Ironically, there’s a section in Chapter 14 where the narrator hears two people talking in a private language, can’t understand what they’re saying, and tells one of them, “That’s rude.” Yes, Mr Gibson, it is.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 25 '14

echopraxia Peter Watts will be joining us on Oct. 1st to discuss [Echopraxia]!

37 Upvotes

I am super-stoked to announce that Peter Watts has agreed to come talk to us about Blindsight and Echopraxia this coming Wednesday.

Watts has been a favorite author of mine since I read Blindsight, and (no joke) wanting to discuss that book with other people was one of the major reasons I started /r/SF_Book_Club. His books, stories, and essays are always thought-provoking and often leave the reader with lingering questions, so now is the chance to ask the man himself.

As with our previous Q&As, he'll be posting a thread early in the day (US time) and coming back later to answer questions and interact with people, in order to give everyone time to ask a question even if they can't be on when he is.

So get your questions ready, keep posting about the books on here to hone them, and keep an eye out for the thread come Wednesday!

Housekeeping note: we'll be holding off on October's book selection process until after the Q&A. Expect it on the 2nd or 3rd.


r/SF_Book_Club • • May 13 '21

[Annihilation] I just finished the book - loved it - but do I get it?

36 Upvotes

I just finished Annihilation, the first book in the Southern Reach trilogy. I've seen the film four times. I absolutely adore it and the complexity in the themes and concepts. The book was not at all what I was expecting in the best possible way.

SPOILERS!!

I understand that Area X changes things - shown by the bright light within the biologist. It melds specimens together and duplicates them. However - I'm not sure if I was supposed to understand exactly why this happened. Also - what exactly is the crawler? I understand that it's almost like the owner of Area X, but what is the purpose? I feel like there are SO MANY components to the story including what happens with the Psychologist and the anthropologist. However it feels as if there's a fog between me and comprehension. Maybe I'm supposed to feel this way? I have the next two books, so I'm definitely gonna read them.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 09 '15

madness This January we will be reading H.P. Lovecraft's "At the Mountains of [Madness]"!

35 Upvotes

With double the number of votes as the runner up, we're going with this.

It's short, only about ~100 pages, but a really solid novella about a scientific expedition to antarctica that finds more than it's betting on.

We've gotten to be pretty late about posting books, so we're going to let this run for 2+ weeks, then post the new selection thread. I'm aiming to give that a full week again, and still be able to post the next book on Feb. 1st to get back on a good schedule.

Tag is [madness], the story is in the public domain and available freely online at a bunch of places if you search for the title.

If you'd like to discuss other Lovecraft stories, you're welcome to do so, but we're officially only reading this one and please do still use the [madness] tag.


Edit. A few resources.

The Complete Works of H.P. Lovecraft in PDF and epub and mobi, thanks to "The Cthulhu Chick".

At the Mountains of Madness in HTML + a listing of all the places that it has appeared in print.

At the Mountains of Madness in totally metal white text on black background, my preferred medium for this message.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 06 '16

[meta] Let's talk about SF Book Club.

32 Upvotes

This month, we're not doing book selection.

Instead, we wanted to talk to all of you about the state of the subreddit, and decide together what its future should be. Let us know what you think.


What up SF Book Club?

As you might have noticed, there hasn't been a lot of discussion here lately. We've seen 3 months without anyone starting discussion on the current books out of the last 4, the last two author Q&As only had a few people participate, and while they still get a lot of books recommended, the selection threads get fewer votes than they used to.

Our stats are down too. We've decreased in unique visitors and pageviews every single month this year. August saw 3/5ths the number of unique users as January, and 1/2 the number of pageviews!

However, this hasn't meant that rSFBC is any less work for us mods. More manhours go into moderating rSFBC than into r/printSF, even though it has 1/3rd the subscribers and 1/10th the participation rate.

So, something needs to change, and we want to make sure that it's something that will make the community happy! After all, while we enjoy participating here as well, we're doing this for you.

We've created a survey, and would ask that if you've ever come to rSFBC, please fill it out. The more answers and ideas we get to it, the better we can make this place in the future. You'll be ensuring the future survival of one of the largest bookclubs on reddit, and until this month the longest-running contiguous monthly book club.

Also, please fill out the survey before reading or commenting below, as we'd like to have your unfiltered thoughts. Then come and discuss with others what you think and build off their ideas!

Fill out the survey!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Nov 04 '13

singularity [meta] November's SF Book Club selection is Singularity Sky by Charles Stross

32 Upvotes

Nice to see so may nominations and votes this month. Singularity Sky is certain my favourite Stross book (so far), lots of fun, humour and wild inventions.

The usual guidelines:

  • Post discussions and links in this subreddit related to the book, make sure to tag your posts with [singularity]

  • Don't post spoilers unless the thread has the [spoilers] tag.

  • Previous months selections are always valid for posting new discussions.

Thanks!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jul 10 '13

[hydrogen] "A Few Notes on the Culture" if you want an introduction but don't have time for another novel (no spoilers)

32 Upvotes

http://www.vavatch.co.uk/books/banks/cultnote.htm

"A Few Notes on the Culture" is an essay by Iain M. Banks explaining (in a very general non-spoilery way) what the Culture is, where it came from, why it exists, and some helpful infodump on the broader setting. ...basically this is exactly what's in the title. If you want some background info but don't have the extra time for 1-9 extra books this is the best you'll get.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Mar 01 '15

[meta] The Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu is our March selection!

30 Upvotes

As usual, feel free to make a post about The Three-Body Problem in the subreddit. Links, discussion, images, whatever, as long as it's relevant to the book and tagged appropriately. See our sidebar for details. Please include the string [three] in the title of your post (e.g, "[three] Some thoughts about the main character's motivations."), so it will automatically get labeled by our CSS code. Thanks!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Feb 04 '14

machine [machine] I'm Max Barry, I wrote MACHINE MAN

30 Upvotes

Hello /r/SF_Book_Club!

I put MACHINE MAN in all caps because that's what you do in publishing. Seriously. I wouldn't make up something like that. Film, you say "The Hobbit." But as a book it's THE HOBBIT. Or at least it is when you email publishing people.

I mention that so you don't think I'm shouting. HEY GUYS I WROTE A BOOK. Although, I mean, it is impressive. I'm impressed by anyone who writes a book, even a novel they now hate and keep in a desk drawer. Even bad novels are hard to write. If you have written a novel, I respect you.

Anyway. Machine Man. MACHINE MAN. For starters, here is a little FAQ about how it started off as a web-based serial, and then became a novel, and then a film script written by Mark Heyman with Darren Aronofsky on board to direct, and then that last part stopped happening. Actually, the FAQ doesn't cover that. You will have to ask me about that, if you want. But it covers the genesis:

http://maxbarry.com/machineman/faq.html

I also mentioned here about how Charlie Neumann was basically a Redditor with funding. I love Reddit but I hate it to death, too. I think that's a big part of its allure. The fact that it has parts. So many different parts.

So go ahead and ask me something. I realize I'm not, you know, Charles Stross. It will probably be just you and me and that other guy, you know, the weird one, who comments on everything. But that's cool.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 05 '13

diamond [meta] SF Bookclub's January selection is The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson

30 Upvotes

Happy New Year SF Bookclub subscribers!

The Diamond Age is the first book we will read this year by popular votes. This book probably does not need much of an introduction as it is known to most sf readers though perhaps not as widely read as other Stephenson's title.

Links: Amazon US / Amazon UK

The Tag for this one is [diamond]. If you want to post comments with spoilers please tag threads with [spoilers].

Previously months (or years) selection are always open for discussion of course (full list available here).

Happy reading! :)


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 11 '15

madness A ranking of all of Lovecraft's fiction, for those who want to explore beyond [Madness]

Thumbnail
monstersandmanuals.blogspot.com
29 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Dec 12 '14

startide David Brin will join us to discuss [Startide] Rising on January 6th! [meta]

29 Upvotes

I'm really happy to let everyone know that Brin's agreed to come by and discuss Startide Rising with us.

He's pretty busy, so he'll only have about 90 minutes around 10am PST to discuss the book. We'll make sure to remind everyone to watch this space so as many people can participate as possible.

In addition, he asked if we could collect questions that come up in the subreddit so he can answer those in the Q&A as well. I'll be watching discussions this month and collecting questions to send to him. I'll also post another pre-Q&A thread later on in the month specifically for those folks who can't make the Q&A but still have burning questions for him.

So, more details to come closer to the date, but I wanted to give anyone still on the fence a reason to buy the book and start reading and discussing here!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Apr 02 '12

destination [meta] April's SF selection is "The Stars My [Destination]" by Alfred Bester

29 Upvotes

We hit the 2000 members mark today! If you're new here, please read the FAQ before posting—we have few rules, but they're important ones. Please though, come, read, post, and discuss!

Now, your regularly scheduled announcement:

Kindle version.

Paperback.

I'm really excited for this one. It's the Count of Monte Cristo meets Solar System Space Opera meets, well, I don't know. Some crazy 50's alternate version of the future that looks much more like our future than most crazy 50's alternate futures.

Tag this time around is [destination].

Looking forward to discussing this one!


r/SF_Book_Club • • May 07 '14

lot49 [Meta] The Crying of Lot 49 by Thomas Pynchon is May's SF Book Club selection!

28 Upvotes

Hey folks, sorry for the late announcement this month. Fortunately, a short book won the crown. As usual, please use the book's tag - [Lot49] - in the title of any discussion post regarding the book.

From Amazon:

The Crying of Lot 49 is Thomas Pynchon's classic satire of modern America, about Oedipa Maas, a woman who finds herself enmeshed in what would appear to be an international conspiracy.

When her ex-lover, wealthy real-estate tycoon Pierce Inverarity, dies and designates her the coexecutor of his estate, California housewife Oedipa Maas is thrust into a paranoid mystery of metaphors, symbols, and the United States Postal Service. Traveling across Southern California, she meets some extremely interesting characters, and attains a not inconsiderable amount of self-knowledge.

Enjoy!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Nov 25 '13

singularity [singularity] In about 48 hours, Charles Stross will do an IAMA on Singularity Sky in this subreddit.

28 Upvotes

I have informed Charlie that questions are being posted ahead of time in this thread, so post away!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Oct 30 '12

meta [meta] November book selection thread

28 Upvotes
  1. Nominate a book as a top-level post. Include an Amazon/bookdepository/etc. link as well as a description.

  2. Feel free to comment on nominations.

  3. Upvote your favorite nominees.

In order to choose books that are likely to elicit discussion, the book with the highest combined upvotes and downvotes will be chosen. If two books are tied, we will probably choose the shorter one.

May the best book win!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Apr 05 '16

[meta] April's SF_Book_Club selection is Annihilation by Jeff Vandermeer!

27 Upvotes

This one was a landslide, with Annihilation ahead of its nearest competitor by an awesome 7 votes!

As usual, please make a new post to start a discussion of the book, and please use the tag [annihilation] in the post title.

Happy reading!


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jul 06 '15

July's SF Book Club Selection is The [Peripheral] by William Gibson [meta]

27 Upvotes

That's right folks, you read it here first. /u/AshRolls' suggestion that we read William Gibson's new SF novel beat out the rest of our sorry nominations.

Usual rules apply. Read the book, and make posts about it here. Self posts, discussion posts, links to interviews or reviews or even images that remind you of the book.

Just make sure to tag your posts with [Peripheral] in the title, and include the tag [spoilers] if there are any spoilers in the posts. And don't post spoilers in the comments if there isn't a spoiler tag! Full rules of the subreddit are on the wiki.