r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 01 '11

[rp1]FFFUUUUUUUUUUU

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Jun 21 '15

[seveneves] Am I the only one who wasn't able to complete the book? (possible [spoiler])

4 Upvotes

I have been reading it on and off for about two weeks already, often almost "dragging" myself to it. Yesterday, in the middle of Part Two, I just felt that I can't do it anymore. The books seems to me horribly overextended and slow-paced; and, dare I add, unimaginative. I skimmed through remaining parts of the book... and there were nothing surprising there. Nothing that thrilled my imagination, like other recently read books did ("Diaspora" & "Quarantine" by G.Egan, and "Blindsight" & "Echopraxia" by P.Watts).

On a side note, Tekla? Seriously, what kind of a Russian name is it?


r/SF_Book_Club • • Aug 06 '11

rule 34 [Rule 34] Edinburgh

1 Upvotes

I think you should read a travel guide for Edinburgh before reading this book because it made too many references to the city's geography. I'm sure you would enjoy the book more if you were familiar with Edinburgh.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jun 22 '15

[seveneves] Am I the only one that had a problem with the ... um.. "imagery" (spoilers)

0 Upvotes

Was it really necessary to have black science man ram it into the giant vagina shaped rock? I was completely engaged in the story until the whole sperm/egg thing came together as the endurance and went off to gestate in the cleft. I mean, it was a great story, with lots of great speculation about technology, and basic physics lessons (I learned so much about chains), and I think this crap just totally takes away any credibility. It would have stood on its own perfectly well without this garbage.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Mar 18 '18

[Peripheral] I can’t do this: it’s unreadable.

Thumbnail
self.sf_book_club
5 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • May 26 '12

meta [meta]Optional title every month?

5 Upvotes

Would you be interested in having a second title as an optional book to read and discuss every month? I usually enjoy the tiles we select each month here but one book a month is not really enough in my opinion. For example last months Roadside Picnic I've finished by the 5th of May. And it seems to me that most other people did too. We had a few discussions going in the first half of the month and then nothing. Maybe another title will bring a bit more discussion in this subreddit. My proposal is the most voted book to be the month selection and the second one the optional read for the month.

Please feel free to discuss this idea and let's see what comes out of it.

Edit: Also there is the possibility that some people might not like the selected book or find it too hard to go trough, thus they would not be able to participate in discussions if there's only one book. A second book offers more diversity.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jul 26 '12

cloud atlas [Cloud Atlas] is getting turned into a movie, and it looks phenomenal.

Thumbnail
io9.com
17 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Feb 26 '12

windup [Windup] Ghosts (phii) - Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I was going to write something about this but it completely slipped my mind. A lot of readers are likely to dismiss the ghosts in The Windup Girl as imaginary, especially of Jaidee. The thing is a huge proportion of Thais believe in ghosts and other spirits, may be 50% or more. This may make us seem like silly bastards but it's a highly ingrained cultural thing I guess.

Personally I don't believe in no ghosts but I am used to being around people who do. Any way, I am not sure whether Bacigalupi intends that Jaidee is an actual ghost or a manifestation of Kanya's conscience. It's not as obvious as it seems.

There is a Thai idiom about superstition that translates as "if you don't believe it, don't disrespect it". What it actually means is "Think you are so modern and sophisticated eh? If some weird supernatural shit happen to you don't come crying to me!"

(Related link)


r/SF_Book_Club • • May 05 '15

[Pocket] jayjaywalker3's extremely brief thoughts while reading Stars in My Pocket like Grains of Sand (will edit as I read) [spoiler]

4 Upvotes

Pg. 85 (towards the end of part 2, section 2) Did Marq Dyeth just rape someone who was sleeping?

Pg. 91 (halfway through part 2, section 2) I'm finally putting some pieces together about how the beginning of the book fits in with Part 1 and 2. I still don't understand much of what I'm reading though.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 20 '12

[china] Maureen McHugh is doing an IAMA on general topics, China Mountain Zhang included.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Feb 19 '16

[spoilers] Racism is [seveneves]

0 Upvotes

... So the book says, & I quote "She must have slept for something like ten hours. Moirans were notorious for it."

... And the character Kate Two just happens to be black. Wouldn't you agree that Neil Stephenson has some very negative stereotypical views?


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 06 '15

startide In [Startide] Rising, which perspective did you find most engaging: the humans, the dolphins, or the galactics?

2 Upvotes

Nearly finished with the book now, but have noticed that I find the dolphin sections of the book most engaging. Personally, while the human and galactic sections were alright, the dolphin sections really kept my attention.

I'm talking mostly about the early and middle parts of the book, as the ending climax is great regardless of perspective. The dolphin characters felt so much richer to me than the humans and galactics. It really felt like their story, more than anyone else's.

I found the perspectives of the humans (Gillian, Tom, and Dennie) somewhat disengaging. Not quite as fun to read as a Creideiki or Takkata-Jim chapter. I'm not entirely sure why I felt this way--shouldn't we relate better to the humans in this story? Was it intentional on the writer's part that we, or at least I, were more drawn to the dolphins?

As for the galactics, they seemed to be around more for flavour and plot than anything else. Nothing interesting going on character-wise.

I'm reminded of a similar experience in watching Dawn of the Planet of the Apes. I found the ape side of the story far more engaging than the human side of the story. Film Crit Hulk breaks it down as a reflection of differences in storytelling and character arcs. http://badassdigest.com/2014/07/23/film-crit-hulk-smash-story-vs.-character-the-two-movies-within-dawn-of-the/

I ask this question about the relative engagingness of the different perspectives because I think it reveals an important kernel about the story--and about storytelling, broadly construed--in finding the dolphin perspective most compelling. However, I have no clue what that kernel is. My literarily untrained mind just can't seem to grok it. Hopefully one of you may have a better take on it.

Just to rule out some cheap alternative explanations, I'm not at all into dolphins or animals generally speaking. I generally don't relate well to "alien" races in other sci-fi, so it's not simply a matter of the dolphins speaking to my Sci-Fi sensibilities. My sense is it's something about the characters and conflicts of the dolphins in the story, rather than the book's appeal to some personal idiosyncrasy towards animals or alien things.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Aug 22 '12

[mote] I know this is way passed due, but here's a Motie in Maxis' Spore Sporepedia

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 26 '14

echopraxia From Watts' blog: Who would you have play in a Blindsight or [Echopraxia] movie? [spoilers]

Thumbnail
rifters.com
6 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Sep 12 '14

echopraxia [Echopraxia] Science Fiction Book Review Podcast - Echopraxia review

Thumbnail
sfbrp.com
6 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • Jun 03 '15

[spoilers] Racism is [seveneves] ?

10 Upvotes

Anyone as bothered as I am with the pretty ingrained racism is the last third of the book? I realize a lot of it is so the author can get a lot of information to us easily about the 7 Eve races and the society that has built up around them but I was really put off mostly by how the author made it seem inevitable.

Even a couple of generations in, and even with Moira fixing the heterozygosity problem it also seems really dangerous to not mix genes between them...

I guess humans will always find something to create "us" and "them", but this rubbed me the wrong way.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jan 16 '15

madness Was I the only one who didn't like At the Mountains of Madness?

20 Upvotes

So, At the Mountains of Madness was the first Lovecraft story I ever read, just about a year ago, and I still remember it clearly. What I remember even more clearly was trying hard--and failing miserably--to like it!

It seemed to me that the narrator spent most of the book

  1. throwing around scientific jargon unnecessarily,

  2. describing sights with enough detail for a movie's set design team,

  3. telling me how things felt, rather than showing me so that I felt that way myself, and of course

  4. delaying the actual story because he didn't want to tell it.

I understand that this book is strongly loved by many, and I just don't see it; the only emotion this story inspired in me was impatience.

I want to like it! /r/SF_Book_Club, help me to wrap my head around what I'm missing!

Note: I asked /r/books this question last year, and while they tried to be helpful, I was still left with no love for Lovecraft's writing.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Apr 13 '15

[Pocket] Subscript?

3 Upvotes

I'm not quite sure what to make of the subscript on some words (work, job, profession), and a quick search doesn't show me anything. Do any of you have ideas on what they mean?

EDIT: Nevermind. A quick trip to wikipedia would have told me the answer.

Words relating to work and occupations are subscripted (for example, job1, job2, job3) to indicate whether the work involved is one's central "life's work", a different work that one still habitually performs, or an occupation taken up temporarily. Marq Dyeth is consistently called an industrial diplomat1, as that is his job1, but at home he works2 as a docent2 for visitors to his famous residence; in his youth, he worked3 for a time as a tracer3, a Velmian occupation tracking the flow of resources through the economy. (This usage derives from Alfred Korzybski's general semantics; the three categories correspond to Delany's classification of literary characters' actions into the necessary, the habitual, and the gratuitous.)


r/SF_Book_Club • • Dec 24 '18

In Rupetta, a young girl goes on an academic hunt to discover that the history she's been told isn't the real truth. Listen to the [spectology] [spoiler] episode of the wonderful book today! Spoiler

Thumbnail
spectology.com
3 Upvotes

r/SF_Book_Club • • May 11 '15

[Forest] A disappointment

7 Upvotes

Did anybody else have a problem with the "preachy" nature of this book?

I do realize that when this book was written (1972), the times were very different. The draft, the Vietnam war, etc. The book also seems to have mild misandrist themes, although I do agree the world might be improved by having more grannies running it :)

My bottom line is that the relentless moralizing kept pulling me out of the story, and that this ruined the book for me.

Thank goodness it was a short book.

[ EDIT: for bad grammar ]


r/SF_Book_Club • • May 15 '15

[Forest]

8 Upvotes

I found the idea of someone being a god, that is a translator of the new into reality to be the most interesting part of the book. Not a chosen role, but one that does seem to require a certain depth of character to enact. That this role of the fire bringer as it were being one of translation seems important and perhaps as an idea lasts beyond the specific politics of the book.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Nov 28 '14

peace [Peace] What I thought. [spoilers]

8 Upvotes

I didn't quite know what to make of this book. I had actually randomly ordered it before I saw that it was selected here, in a piece of synchronicity.

I have previously read the first part of the Book of the New Sun by Gene Wolfe, so I knew his multi-layered, circuitous style. But my first impressions of "Peace" were that it was over-written and didn't seem to contain much of a fantasy element.

It's not fantasy at all, I thought. It's magical realism, or midwest noir, or something. There were times, as well, when my attention lapsed and I didn't know what was going on in the plot. I knew that this book was a puzzle, like The Book of the New Sun, with recurring motifs in it that you were supposed to pay attention to, and layers of meaning and allusion, but I fear I may have missed a lot of the subtleties. I realised eventually that the narrator was immortal, or a ghost, or something.

I still don't know whether I liked it or not, but it was interesting. And I think it's the sort of book that will leave an impression behind.

The part of the book which I really did enjoy and find interesting was the part, which begins around page 144, when stories are told, stories within the main story. Before this part I found the novel tedious in parts. But the Chinese story and the longer story about the pharmacist and the haunted house and the carnival people, and so on, are really the highlight of the book. A sort of magical realist ghost story, with an incremental feeling of unease building up, detail on detail, creepy yet subtle, almost like Edgar Poe.

I found the rest of the book, where Weer finds a love interest of sorts and gets involved with a bookseller, less satisfying, though that too contains extraordinary passages, such as the description of "Morryster's Marvells of Science" on pages 255-256, and the excerpt from "The Book That Binds the Dead" on pages 280-282 of this edition, which reminded me of Clark Ashton Smith.

I thought the character of the bookseller's daughter who comes and randomly offers sex to the narrator to be a very improbable creature. There is still so much in the book that I don't understand the significance of, the china egg, that long incoherent letter from a carnie, the story of the factory worker trapped in the freezer, the motif of the orange. But there's lots of things in the Book of the New Sun I don't understand the significance of either, and I still enjoyed it, like one can enjoy trying to figure out the meaning of a weird myth or even of a dream.


r/SF_Book_Club • • Aug 06 '11

rule 34 [Rule 34] How do you feel about 2nd Person narration?

8 Upvotes

I'm enjoying Rule 34 so far, and I was a big fan of Halting State. In fact, the 2nd person narration was one of the selling points of the previous book for me because its not very common and I thought it would make it a lot more interesting.

That said, whenever I read the books I always imagine the characters' lives being narrated by the guy from the old neo-noir Blast of Silence: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVXRNLu055k in a sort of dark taunting style. Why do you think Stross chose this device, and how do you feel about it?


r/SF_Book_Club • • Feb 12 '13

carbon [carbon][possible spoilers] Does it get better? Is it worth finishing?

13 Upvotes

I really enjoyed the first ~10% of this book, but I'm about 40-45% in and it just seems weak and I'm not enjoying it.

The concept is interesting (the part I enjoyed), but the storyline seems weak to me and doesn't flow. He keeps talking about situations and people that haven't been mentioned before as though I'm supposed to know who they are, but he also drops names once or twice a few chapters earlier and some of them are supposedly relevant.

His links are unexplained (unless I'm mistaken, he never explained how he knew to go to [spoiler]that angry father's house or the whorehouse, just he found them on a map or they were vaguely mentioned in plot directions early[/spoiler]).

He seems to throw in "shock" words or sentences to try and force my attention again (cunt, twice in a page, really?) (another example [spoiler]'have you ever cum on a girl's face' which is then brushed off as exactly the kind of thing you'd say to someone after 300 years of fetishes building up, but it's okay because he was just trying Culture Shock[/spoiler], which isn't explained).

The strong female character he initially hates but no doubt ends up with by the end of the book. The [spoiler]perfect neurochem body he ends up in which is no match for anything else on Earth (despite it being a normal cop's body before that)[/spoiler], the loosely explained but in no real detail scifi concepts, the technical sounding buzzwords thrown into every sentence.

To me it's starting to read like a Dan Brown book, except hard to read.

Should I pursue it or am I wasting my time? [spoiler]I'm fairly sure his wife sent those guys after him anyway[/spoiler]


r/SF_Book_Club • • Jul 10 '15

[Peripheral] I can’t do this: it’s unreadable.

37 Upvotes

I knew I was going to have difficulties when I had to re-read the first page three times to work out what was going on. In the very first sentence: “sometimes the haptics glitched him”. What’s a “haptic”? “Haptic” is an adjective meaning “related to touch”. What is a “haptic”? The next sentence: “ghosts of the tattoos he’d worn in the war”. How do tattoos leave ghosts that glitch a person?

I got so confused that, by the time I read that Leon said something was the “most valuable thing on their property”, I thought he was referring to the “biggest wasp nest any of them had ever seen”, which was the most recent thing mentioned in the previous sentence. I then wondered why people would sell wasp nests that looked like blunt rifle slugs on eBay, as described in the next sentence. I had to stop and re-read this a few times to work out what was going on.

And things just never got better.

There’s too much simply not explained here. Gibson is taking the “Show, don’t tell.” dictum of writing to a whole new level. As a life-long science fiction reader (I’ve been reading sci-fi in various forms for nearly four decades, since primary/elementary school), I understand that there will be concepts in sci-fi books which I don’t recognise from my daily life. I’m used to having unfamiliar things thrown at me in unfamiliar contexts. This is both a benefit and drawback of reading science fiction: you encounter new things, but you don’t always recognise those new things. This is why science fiction authors often have to spend more time on exposition than other types of authors – and this is known to be one of the problems with the genre: all the exposition required. So, a good sci-fi writer finds ways to reduce the exposition, or to insert it in ways which aren’t too obtrusive.

But, Gibson goes to the extreme of having almost no exposition at all. Concepts and objects are referred to, and simply never described. The reader has to wait for paragraphs, even chapters, to find out what something is (if ever).

Some examples:

  • “VA’ll catch you.” The term “VA” is literally never explained.

  • “He wore sunglasses against the flashes of UV, with his Viz behind the glasses, on one side.” What’s a “Viz”?

  • “Macon needed peace to fab his funnies”. I honestly felt like I was reading Lewis Carroll at this point: “All mimsy were the borogroves, and the mome raths outgrabe”.

  • “A long time ago?” “Before the jackpot.” This “jackpot” is referred to again later in this chapter (Chapter 12), but there is absolutely no hint as to what it is, apart from being something that happened in the past which people use as a yardstick to say things happened before or after it. This could be anything from a war, to a climatic disaster, to the Singularity, to when a friend won the lottery, to... anything.

  • “We don’t do that sort of thing, if we’re serious about continua.” [...] “I hope to explain that polts aren’t really what continua are about.” Another Lewis Carroll moment. Admittedly, we got a hint about what “polts” are a few pages later: “Ghosts that move things, I suppose.” But even that leaves us guessing. And we’re not told what “continua” are.

  • “Ossian [...] Like Ash, a technical.” This point in Chapter 14 was where I started giving up on this book. I was screaming in my head, “What’s a bloody ‘technical’? Is it a person who works with machines? Another remote presence device like the peripheral we saw earlier? Or... what? TELL ME!”

This even extends to the narrative. At the end of Chapter 12, one of the narrators, Netherton, gets up to stroll the collection of cars at someone’s house. At the start of Chapter 14 (his next appearance – the two narrators have alternating chapters), he’s suddenly waking up surrounded by people we’ve never met or heard of before, with them all talking about... not much, really. I worked out that we were supposed to be confused, because the narrator was confused and didn’t know where he was or how he got there. But, on top of the confusion I was already feeling, it was just too much. Chapter 14 was where I gave up. I read one more chapter before running out of momentum.

I spent too much time being frustrated at not knowing what was going on. I know that this is a combination of two things.

Firstly, Gibson is trying to immerse the reader in his world by not stopping to explain every little thing that pops up. The narrators he’s writing for wouldn’t explain familiar items to themselves: that would be unnatural. And Gibson is obviously trying to make his world as natural as possible. I get that. But the narrators don’t exist in isolation: they’re telling their stories to us, the readers. And we don’t know what Vizzes and polts and continua and funnies and jackpots and technicals are. And, while we don’t know these things, his world isn’t real to us. It can’t be; it’s populated with these blank spots with meaningless labels. It would be like watching a movie with a blurred-out object sitting on a table in side of the frame. We know there’s something on that table, but we can’t bring it into focus. So, we either waste time and effort trying to decipher the blur and miss the action happening elsewhere in the frame, or we simply ignore the blurry bits – in which case, they might as well not be there in the first place. Too much exposition is bad, but too little is worse.

Secondly, Gibson is using the old device of withholding information from the reader to build suspense and incite curiosity. Which is fine. To a degree. But his whole narrative structure is built on this device. Nothing is explained, ever. Things simply happen without context. For example, Daedra drops in on the patchers by parafoil... but why? Why is this such a big deal that governments are involved and the media is watching and sponsors want to have their logos visible on camera? It takes a few chapters to even work out what these patchers are (and I still don’t know where the names “patch” and “patchers” come from), and I never found out what they wanted, or what other people wanted from them.

I found myself totally unable to engage with this book. I didn’t know what was happening, I couldn’t figure out what a Viz and the jackpot and continua were, and I didn’t relate to the narrators. I found myself excluded at every turn of the page. I only put up with it for 15 chapters because I wanted to make some commitment to read this book club’s choice for this month. But I hated it and gave up only an eighth of the way through.

Ironically, there’s a section in Chapter 14 where the narrator hears two people talking in a private language, can’t understand what they’re saying, and tells one of them, “That’s rude.” Yes, Mr Gibson, it is.