r/printSF • • Feb 27 '26

Dan Simmons, author of the Hyperion Cantos, has passed away

1.8k Upvotes

r/printSF • • May 23 '25

I read all Hugo Award winners from 1953 - here are my best, worst and themes

1.5k Upvotes

Over the past few years I have been reading all Hugo Award winners (excluding retros, so back to 1953) and wanted to share some of my best / worst picks and thoughts.

I’ve seen people rank the full list as well as post reviews of each book before, so thought I’d do something different:

Favourite books (broadly following the crowd here):

  • 2005 Johnathan Strange and Mr Norell by Susanna Clarke – A big read but so well written and great characters, I’ve seen it recommended in lots of places and for good reason

  • 1985 Neuromancer by William Gibson – As others have said before I am sure, shaped the whole cyberpunk genre and very cool to have been written when it was (more or less pre-internet writing about the internet / hacking)

  • 1966 Dune by Frank Herbert – Goes without saying, went on to read the series whilst tackling the list (God Emperor of Dune is completely mad but enjoyed it a lot)

  • 1978 Gateway by Frederik Pohl – Engaging characters and not your usual space exploration story, good twists

  • 1990 Hyperion by Dan Simmons – Recommended by so many and for good reason, excellent short stories blended together. I have since finished the series which I would also really recommend

Unexpected great reads

  • 1953 The Demolished Man by Alfred Bester – Excellent short read, from 1953 and I hadn’t heard it mentioned anywhere else so had no expectations going in

  • 1961 A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter Miller – As someone who isn’t religious I really enjoyed the tongue in cheek nature of how religion might develop over time

  • 1989 Cyteen by C J Cheeryh – Richness to the world and the charaters and a great plot, unfortunately didn’t enjoy The Downbelow Station quite as much (although still good)

Best concepts

  • 1976 The Forever War by Joe Halderman – Really enjoyed the “practicalities” of interstellar war rather than just coming up with jump drives like most others

  • 2000 The Deepness in the Sky and A Fire in the Deep by Vernor Vinge – Totally wacky concepts of the structure of the universe which when you read he was a computer programmer make more sense

Themes

I thought it was interesting that winners seemed to reflect the trends in the world at the time. To me it felt like there was a slow shift between some themes:

  • Imaging future technology in early science fiction and more of “what would the world be like in the future” as technology developed so quickly IRL;

  • Inspiration taken from unpopular global conflicts (cold war / Vietnam etc.) of the time;

  • Cloning as the technology developed and it was at the front of debate IRL; and

  • Environmental collapse reflecting the shift to concerns around climate change (more recent focus)

Obviously there are books that go against these themes, but these are some that jumped out to me as I moved through the past 70+ years.

I’d also highlight there has been a clear and obvious shift from male to female protagonists since 2010 (women barely getting a mention in early books except as a passing love interest)

One shout out in particular to Stand on Zanzibar by John Brunner which had the “crazy” concept of two well paid characters in New York having to live together as they couldn’t afford the rent individually due to overcrowding – I enjoyed that.

Best decade

Probably the 1980s for me. They haven’t had mentions above but Fountains of Paradise, The Snow Queen, Foundations Edge, Enders Game, Speaker for the Dead and The Uplift War are all very good from the 1980s

Least favourite books

  • 1958 The Big Time by Fritz Leiber – I read somewhere that it may have originally been written as a play? Which would maybe make more sense but not that enjoyable in my opinion

  • Anything by Connie Willis (and she won 3 unfortunately for me) – Very detailed, I realised I don’t particularly enjoy any time travel books and don’t enjoy her style of writing

  • Mars Trilogy by Kim Robinson – More classic “Hard SciFi” and the detail was just too much for me at times, I don't need to know about 50 types of lichen on a terraformed Mars

  • 1963 The Man in the High Castle by Philip K Dick – Overrated in my view

What I’m reading next

  • More of the Murderbot Diaries by Martha Wells – easy, fun and engaging reads (good holiday reads

  • Count Zero by William Gibson as a follow up to Neuromancer which I loved

  • The Culture series by Iain Banks

  • Old Mans War by Joe Scalzi

  • More of the Riverworld series by Philip Jose Farmer to see where that goes, really enjoyed the first

  • Perhaps the Nebula winners…


r/printSF • • Apr 14 '26 Hehehe This Bravo

Dungeon Crawler Carl has absolutely horrific prose.

1.3k Upvotes

I saw plenty of discussion about the characters and plot of this series, but not really much at all about how it's written. Does it get any better?

Let me first preface this: I'm a snob. I can't help it. Whenever I develop an interest, I devour whatever the snobbiest, most pretentious stuff available even if the hobby doesn't typically lend itself to snobbery. Pro wrestling, comic books, sci-fi, sitcoms, etc. I've been savoring Gene Wolfe's Solar Cycle over the course of several years because I don't want it to be done. Even a snob like myself sometimes gets a craving for pablum, if only to pad out my enjoyment of the good stuff. I'm in the middle of Long Sun right now and want to let it sit and read something light during my break. Dungeon Crawler Carl caught my eye mostly by being on the recommended shelf at a bookstore but also because I've never read or even really heard of LitRPG.

I'm about 75 pages in. I went in expecting a breezy read. Instead I've made an audible groan an average of once every 3 pages, so 25 groans so far. I don't normally notice prose quality, good or bad, but this book is exceptionally poorly written. Here are some lowlights:

*"*The smooth, rocky ceiling of this tunnel was much lower than the long, main hallway leading off the stairs. When I stood to my full height, I could reach up and touch it. Barely."

He's trying to illustrate how small the tunnel is, but instead he emphasizes that Carl can barely reach the ceiling. That's the opposite of what you want to emphasize! Also "smooth" and "rocky" are near antonyms. It should be something like "The ceiling was so low that I could reach it with the tips of my fingers."

"This hall was only as wide a regular road with a smooth, fifteen-foot ceiling. Green, lichen-like growths glowed on the brick walls and ceilings, giving the tunnel an odd glow."

Just hideous sentence construction here and the entire second half of the second sentence is completely unnecessary. Also not sure why we keep describing ceiling textures. I don't think I've ever read a book and wondered to myself "What does the ceiling in this room feel like?"

"Up close, the goblins looked much like they did in movies and videogames. Short, green, mostly bald with pointed ears, angular faces, and sharp teeth. I briefly wondered on that. It seemed the aliens, or whatever, knew a whole lot about earth mythology and lore."

"Hey, you know those goblins you've spent the last 5 pages picturing mentally? They look like goblins. If you weren't picturing goblins when I previously described them as green and small and called them goblins, please begin picturing goblins now." Awful! Also, "earth mythology and lore" is such grating, gamer-brained wording. Just call it pop culture.

"This was a new voice. It was male, sounding overly enthusiastic, almost like a game show host. It wasn’t the same person or speaker from the original announcement. The words appeared floating before me and were simultaneously spoken in my mind. Unlike the tool-tip like box, I wasn’t able to close it out. This was more like subtitles."

The new voice wasn't the same as the old voice. It was a different voice, and we need two sentences to emphasize that. The words were *almost like* a game show host and *more like* subtitles. Once you notice that nearly everything Carl encounters is described in half-committed simile, you won't be able to stop seeing it. "Almost like", "more like", "lichen-like", "rat-like", "reminded me of Master Splinter the rat sensei from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles", "dusk-like dimness", "it was like I was in a game", "there seemed to be a sign", "almost Asian-looking carvings", etc etc etc. Just describe stuff directly sometimes!

I'm really surprised I haven't seen this discussed more. I've seen conversations about the millennial humor but not the straight-up writing. Was anyone else thrown by this? I kind of want to stick it out, but my wife keeps getting annoyed by me interrupting her book to read the worst passages out loud.


r/printSF • • Jun 02 '25 Hehehe

A few days ago, I asked r/printsf what they consider the single best sci-fi novel. I made a ranked list with the top 50 novels

1.3k Upvotes

A few days ago I made a thread asking users to post the all-time, single best sci-fi book they've read. The post blew up way more than I expected, and there was a huge amount of unique, diverse picks (that I'll be adding to my ever-growing TBR). I thought it would be fun to count the number of votes each individual book received and rank the top 50 to see what books this sub generally consider to be the "best".

Obviously this is not a consensus of any kind or a definitive ranking list by any means - it's really just a fun survey at a given point in time, determined by a very specific demographic. And hey, who doesn't love arguing about ranked lists online with strangers?

Some factors I considered while counting votes:

  • I looked at upvotes for only parent/original comments when counting the votes for a specific book. Sub-comments were not counted

  • Any subsequent posts with that book posted again would get the upvote count added to their total

  • if a post contained multiple selections, I just went with the one that the user typed out first. So for example if your post was "Either Dune or Hyperion" or "Hard choice between Neuromancer, Dune and Foundation", I would count the votes towards Dune and Neuromancer respectively

  • I only counted single books. If an entire series was posted (e.g. The Expanse), it wasn't counted. I did make one exception though, and that's for The Book of the New Sun, since it's considered as one novel made up of 4 volumes. If a single book from a series was posted, then that was counted

  • There are some books that received the same number of votes - these will be considered tied at their respective ranking #s

I've ranked the top 50 books based on number of total upvotes received below:

(If anyone is interested in the list in table format, u/FriedrichKekule has very kindly put one together here: https://pastebin.com/pM9YAQvA)

#50-41:

50. Consider Phlebas (Culture #1) - Iain M. Banks - 6 votes

49. TIE with 7 votes each:

  • 2001 A Space Odyssey (Space Odyssey #1) - Arthur C. Clarke

  • 1984 - George Orwell

  • Rendezvous with Rama (Rama #1) - Arthur C. Clarke

  • Ready Player One (Ready Player One #1) - Ernest Cline

48. TIE with 8 votes each:

  • Permutation City - Greg Egan

  • The Gone World - Tom Sweterlisch

  • Dying Inside - Robert Silverberg

47. TIE with 9 votes each:

  • Look to Windward (Culture #7) - Iain M. Banks

  • Solaris - Stanislaw Lem

  • Startide Rising (Uplift Saga #2) - David Brin

  • Ringworld (Ringworld #1) - Larry Niven

46. The Martian Chronicles - Ray Bradbury - 10 votes

45. TIE with 11 votes each:

  • Altered Carbon (Takeshi Kovacs #1) - Richard Morgan

  • Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir

44. The Dark Forest (Remembrance of Earth's Past #2) - Cixin Liu - 12 votes

43. More Than Human - Theodore Sturgeon - 13 votes

42. TIE with 14 votes each:

  • Ubik - Philip K. Dick

  • Schismatrix Plus - Bruce Sterling

41. TIE with 16 votes each:

  • The Sirens of Titan - Kurt Vonnegut

  • Excession (Culture #5) - Iain M. Banks

#40-31:

40. TIE with 17 votes each:

  • The Last Question - Isaac Asimov

  • Aurora - Kim Stanley Robinson

  • Roadside Picnic - Arkady and Boris Strugatsky

  • Stranger in a Strange Land - Robert Heinlein

39. Star Maker - Olaf Stapledon - 18 votes

38. Accelerando - Charles Stross - 20 votes

37. Foundation (Foundation #1) - Isaac Asimov - 23 votes

36. Stars in My Pocket Like Grains of Sand - Samuel Delany - 24 votes

35. God Emperor of Dune (Dune #4) - Frank Herbert - 26 votes

34. TIE with 29 votes each:

  • The Quantum Thief (Jean Le Flambeur #1) - Hannu Rajaniemi

  • A Scanner Darkly - Philip K. Dick

33. Earth Abides - George R. Stewart - 33 votes

32. 2312 - Kim Stanley Robinson - 37 votes

31. Speaker for the Dead (Ender's Saga #2) - Orson Scott Card - 38 votes

#30-21:

30. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? - Philip K. Dick - 48 votes

29. TIE with 50 votes each:

  • A Fire Upon the Deep (Zones of Thought #1) - Vernor Vinge

  • Flowers for Algernon - Daniel Keyes

28. Snow Crash - Neal Stephenson - 56 votes

27. Jurassic Park - Michael Crichton - 60 votes

26. The Sparrow (The Sparrow #1) - Mary Doria Russell - 63 votes

25. The Mote in God's Eye (Moties #1) - Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle - 64 votes

24. TIE with 65 votes each:

  • The Diamond Age - Neal Stephenson

  • Ancillary Justice (Imperial Radch #1) - Ann Leckie

23. The Forever War (The Forever War #1) - Joe Haldeman - 67 votes

22. Childhood's End - Arthur C. Clarke - 73 votes

21. Have Space Suit - Will Travel - Robert Heinlein - 82 votes

#20-11:

20. The Left Hand of Darkness (Hainish Cycle #4) - Ursula K. Le Guin - 93 votes

19. Lord of Light - Roger Zelazny - 95 votes

18. Cat's Cradle - Kurt Vonnegut - 98 votes

17. Dawn (Xenogenesis #1) - Octavia E. Butle - 105 votes

16. Anathem - Neal Stephenson - 109 votes

15. The Moon is a Harsh Mistress - 117 votes

14. Diaspora - Greg Egan - 127 votes

13. A Deepness in the Sky (Zones of Thought #2) - Vernor Vinge - 129 votes

12. Ender's Game (Ender's Saga #1) - Orson Scott Card - 147 votes

11. Neuromancer (Sprawl #1) - William Gibson - 163 votes

#10-6:

10. The Stars My Destination - Alfred Bester - 165 votes

9. The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy #1) - Douglas Adams - 171 votes

8. Spin (Spin #1) - Robert Charles Wilson - 176 votes

7. Use of Weapons (Culture #3) - Iain M. Banks - 180 votes

6. Children of Time (Children of Time #1) - Adrian Tchaikovsky - 182 votes

AND NOW...GRAND FINALE...DRUM ROLL...HERE IS OUR TOP 5:

5. House of Suns - Alastair Reynolds - 185 votes

4. Book of the New Sun - Gene Wolfe - 196 votes

3. Hyperion (Hyperion Cantos #1) - Dan Simmons - 262 votes

2. Dune (Dune #1) - Frank Herbert - 297 votes

1. THE DISPOSSESSED (HAINISH CYCLE #6) - URSULA K. LE GUIN - 449 VOTES

With ~450 votes, the novel with the most votes for BEST by r/printSF is The Dispossessed! Honestly not that much of a surprise - it is by and large considered one of the THE best books in the genre but I definitely didn't expect it to have this kind of a lead over the #2 book, especially when a lot of the rankings have been very close to each other. Honestly the top 3 of The Dispossessed/Dune/Hyperion are really on another tier as far as votes go.

The crazies part though? I did a similar survey for r/Fantasy as well and guess what the #1 novel voted BEST there was? Ursula K. Le Guin's A Wizard of Earthsea lol. I'm thinking she might be kinda good at this whole SFF thing, guys.

The biggest shocker for me here is the complete lack of one of r/printSF's perennial darlings - Peter Watts' Blindsight. This may be hard to believe but from my deep dive into all the comments, Blindsight was mentioned as the best book only once, and the post only had a total of 2 upvotes lol. Crazy considering what an outsized presence (almost meme/circlejerk level) it has on this sub.

What do you think? Is the ranked list about what you would expect? Any surprises or omissions?


r/printSF • • Aug 04 '25

A reading list for science fiction must reads/ best novels.

Thumbnail
gallery
960 Upvotes

Inspired by this and this. I have these images and I will strike out the movies that I have watched. I thought will be fun to have something like this for science fiction books, so I made two based on the list in these books, Science Fiction: The 100 Best Novels, An English-Language Selection, 1949–1984 by David Pringle and 100 Must-read Science Fiction Novels by Stephen E. Andrews. I hope some people can use it as a guide for a better reading experience. Please tell me if there’s any formatting or spelling mistakes and I will correct it.

Note: Pringle lists the books in publication year order while Andrews in last name alphabetically. I decided to list it like Andrews did for both lists because I feel it gives a better view. Books with 2 authors is listed with the last name of the first author listed. Books from the same author is listed by publication year. Pringle lists some books as a series as whole (e.g. The Book of the New Sun) while Andrews lists one single book (e.g. The Shadow of the Torturer) so I just left it as it is.


r/printSF • • May 30 '25

What's the #1, single best sci-fi novel you've ever read?

898 Upvotes

Think about all the sci-fi novels you've read over the years. If someone were to ask you, gun to your head, to pick just the one that you would absolutely consider to be the best, which one would it be? No subgenres need to be considered, it just needs to broadly fall under the sf umbrella.

For me, probably a pretty popular choice, but it would be Hyperion. Completely blew me away and I haven't read that good since in the genre.


r/printSF • • Oct 05 '25

I've seen a lot of weird titles skimming through old sci-fi books but this one takes the cake

Thumbnail
gallery
879 Upvotes

r/printSF • • Apr 18 '26

The Strange Case of the recent (possibly AI) Le Guin posts in the last month.

788 Upvotes

In the last month or so, there have been several weird posts on this subreddit about Ursula Le Guin. The fact that they are about Le Guin is not the odd part, for of course she is commonly regarded as one of the greatest Science Fiction and Fantasy writers of the 20th century.

But what IS weird is the commonalities between these posts, and the fact that they are potentially all written by AI.

Here are four of the posts. I believe there may be more, but these are the ones I found:

https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/1rz6i5x/le_guins_the_dispossessed_made_me_realize_i_had/?ref=share&ref_source=link

https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/1snz3qm/i_keep_accidentally_reading_le_guin_in_the_wrong/?ref=share&ref_source=link

https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/1s7tr4e/the_left_hand_of_darkness_is_50_years_old_and/?ref=share&ref_source=link

https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/1sdtzw7/ursula_k_le_guin_wrote_a_short_story_in_1973_that/?ref=share&ref_source=link

All of the posts share some commonalities. Even if they are not AI, they are similar. These posts all follow the same template. They have a title in a similar form. They all open with a bit of a personal hook, claim that Le Guin was ahead of her time, and close with an invitation for others to share/read/post. They all compliment her in a similar way, for example praising her restraint, intelligence, and her relevance, without anyone having a messy, different, or surprising reaction. They are all equally polite in their phrasing, to the point of awkwardness. While the posts seem like they want to say something controversial they actually aren’t saying anything new at all, an hallmark of AI use. The prose is also uniformly smooth, there are no awkward sentences, no tangents, not really any typos beyond maybe some that seem to be strategically placed in the writing. They all read like variations on a prompt to AI asking for an enthusiastic but thoughtful post on /r/printSF about Ursula Le Guin.

In addition to the posts themselves, the users share similarities too. They are all fairly new at the time they made the posts. They also don’t post a lot. They also overlap in two kinda obscure subreddits, resume services and pet peeves. This most definitely is not a coincidence. It lends credence to the view this is the same person posting these things.

So the question is, why is someone or something doing this? Why are they writing these posts? Furthermore, is it an AI bot, a single person using AI, or multiple people with some very strange coincidences?

I am curious to know what other people think of this very strange case of recent Le Guin posts.


r/printSF • • Dec 15 '20

Before you recommend Hyperion

770 Upvotes

Stop. Take a deep breath. Ask yourself, "Does recommending Hyperion actually make sense given what the original poster has asked for?"

I know, Hyperion is pretty good, no doubt. But no matter what people are asking for - weird sci-fi, hard sci-fi, 19th century sci-fi, accountant sci-fi, '90s swing revival sci fi - at least 12 people rush into the comments to say "Hyperion! Hyperion!"

Pause. Collect yourself. Think about if Hyperion really is the right thing to recommend in this particular case.

Thanks!


r/printSF • • Jan 23 '18

Ursula K. Le Guin, Acclaimed for Her Fantasy Fiction, Is Dead at 88

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
757 Upvotes

r/printSF • • Mar 28 '26

Great haul tonight

Thumbnail
gallery
743 Upvotes

Checked out a local shop tonight that I thought only sold comics and they're sitting on an absolute gold mine. Tons of Ballard, Dick, Lafferty, Vance, even some Strugatsky brothers. Not proud of the noise I made when I saw The Instrumentality of Mankind... But man I've been looking for a copy for so long. 4 bucks and it looks brand new like it's never even been read. I can't wait to go back when I have more time.


r/printSF • • Nov 19 '22

Sad news about Greg Bear.

728 Upvotes

Just read a tweet from cstross. Appears that Greg experienced a series of strokes, and will be taken off of life support very soon. A sad loss. One of the first sf authors that I read.


r/printSF • • Dec 15 '25 WOW Bravo

I finished all the hugos...

692 Upvotes

I'm not the first or the last here to say it, but perhaps the most recent! I just finished the last of the 74 Hugo winners for best novel. Here's my unsolicited thoughts and lists for your bemusement, criticism, and reflection!

If seeing my list makes you think, "wow, I bet they'd love _____"- please let me know! Always looking for new recommendations!

EDIT: idk how that wild formatting happened. Copied from google docs. Sorry about that!

My absolute favorites (in no order): 

The Left Hand of Darkness (1970) and The Dispossessed (1975) by Ursula le Guin.

In my opinion the best writer and the best written novels of the whole lot. The worldbuilding is excellent, the character development in engrossing, the societal commentary is timeless, and the stories are just downright entertaining. 

The Three Body Problem (2015) (and the following two books of the trilogy that didn’t win Hugos) by Cixin Liu.

The epitome of “hard sci-fi”. Somehow, Liu pairs the most imaginative ideas with the most “based-in-science” writing out there. Probably the only books to make me say “woah” out loud while reading. The closest a book can take your mind to a mushroom trip- these books genuinely changed the way I think.

The Broken Earth trilogy (The Fifth Season (2016), The Obelisk Gate (2017), and The Stone Sky(2018)) by N.K. Jemisin.

For me these books were right on time. An illuminating commentary of injustice, identity, and moral philosophy HIDDEN within an absolutely captivating set of page-turners. On the very short list of books I have read more than once. Also, for what it’s worth, Jemisin is the only person to win three Hugos in a row, the only Black woman (and maybe Black person?) to win, and the only trilogy to have all three books win. For added praise, her three wins put her only one behind the record of four by any author.

The Forever War (1976) by Joe Haldeman

For me, it’s the best war novel (historical, fiction, or SF) I have read. As a Vietnam War veteran, Haldeman draws on his experience to spin a commentary on society, war, and violence while engaging an incredibly imaginative story. A combination of fun and important that’s hard to match. 

Dune (1966) by Frank Herbert

The masterclass in worldbuilding and character development. I don’t think I can say anything profound or new about *Dune* that's not been said 1000 times. 

Hyperion (1990) by Dan Simmons

I think the only novel in here that could also be classified as “horror”. Enthralling and captivating are the words that come to mind. Through vignettes and shorter stories, this one tells an epic tale that fascinates and terrifies. One that I cannot wait to be brave enough to read again. 

The City and The City (2010) by China Mieville

I can’t think of another author who can describe a literally impossible setting, build an unfathomable world then bring readers into it without confusion. I mean, the story is super fun and very thoughtful. His writing is superb. And yet, as I remember reading this book I am most struck by the importance and meaning of the setting(s) where the story unfolds- not the story itself. 

Speaker for the Dead (1987) by Orson Scott Card

I’ll start by disavowing the author’s politics as a matter of order. That said, this is one of those stories that’s so good and so well written, despite being one of the first on the list that I actually read- its scenes and characters remain so fresh in my mind. Important commentary on science, communication, and colonization.

The Zones of Thought winners (Fire Upon the Deep (1993) and A Deepness in the Sky(2000)) by Vernor Vinge

Vinge has an ability to tell a space opera that spans thousands of years and vast stretches of the universe in a way that keeps you invested and entertained. He’s unchained from conventional ideas of how other civilizations and organisms may have evolved elsewhere bringing us the wildest and most fun alien representations including the unforgettable skroderiders and tines. 

Honorable mentions (in no order)

  1. The Tainted Cup (2024)- Robert Jackson Bennett

  2. Ringworld (1971)- Larry Niven

  3. Some Desperate Glory (2023)- Emily Tesh

  4. Stranger in a Strange Land (1962)- Robert Heinlein 

  5. Rendezvous with Rama (1974)- Arthur C. Clarke

  6. Uplift series: The Uplift War (1988) and Startide Rising (1984)- David Brin

  7. Foundations Edge (1983)- Isaac Asimov

  8. The Mars Trilogy, Hugo winners being Green Mars (1993) and Blue Mars (1997)- Kim Stanley Robinson

  9. Fountains of Paradise (1980)- Arthur C. Clarke

  10. The Graveyard Book (2009)- Neil Gaiman

  11. American Gods (2002)- Neil Gaiman

  12. Johnathan Strange and Mr. Norrell (2005)- Susanna Clark

More honorable mentions that are specifically underrated, under appreciated (in no order)

  1. The Gods Themselves (1973)- Isaac Asimov

  2. Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang (1977)- Katie Wilhelm

  3. Canticle for Liebowitz (1961)- Walter M. Miller Jr.

  4. Downbelow Station (1982)- C.J. Cherryh

  5. Waystation (1964)- Clifford D. Simak

  6. Teixcalaan Duology: A Memory Called Empire (2020) and  A Desolation Called Peace (2022)- Arkady Martine

Other good ones

  1. Network Effect (2021)- Martha Wells

  2. Redshirts (2013)- John Scalzi 

  3. All the Vorkosigan Saga winners: Mirror Dance (1995), The Vor Game (1991), Barrayar (1992)- Lois McMaster Bujold

  4. The Snow Queen (1981)- Joan D. Vinge

  5. Forever Peace (1998)- Joe Haldeman

Wonderful idea/ premise, wanted more from the story

  1. The Windup Girl (2010)- Paolo Bacigalupi

  2. To Your Scattered Bodies Go (1972)- Philip Jose Farmer

  3. Case of Conscience (1959)- James A. Blish

  4. The Wanderer (1965)- Fritz Leiber

  5. The Big Time (1958)- Fritz Leiber

  6. This Immortal (1966)- Roger Zelazny

  7. Spin (2006)- Robert Charles Wilson

  8. The Moon is a Harsh Mistress (1967)- Robert Heinlein 

Disappointments/ Overhyped/ Overrated

  1. Doomsday Book (1993)- Connie Willis

  2.  Neuromancer (1985)- William Gibson

  3. The Calculating Stars (2019)- Mary Robinette Kowal

  4. The Man in the High Castle (1963)- Phillip K. Dick

  5. Rainbows End (2007)- Vernor Vinge (Otherwise one of my favorite authors!)

The bad and the ugly

  1. Blackout/ All Clear (2011)- Connie Willis

  2. Double Star (1956)- Robert Heinlein 

  3. The Diamond Age (1996)- Neal Stephenson

  4. Stand on Zanzibar (1969)- John Brunner

  5. They’d Rather Be Right/ The Forever Machine (1955)- Mark Clifton and Frank Riley 

Outliers. For a variety of reasons, Hugo winners I can’t judge against the rest:

  1. Among Others (2012)- Jo Walton

While I really enjoyed this one, I just didn’t find it to be science fiction or fantasy. 

  1. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2001)- J.K. Rowling

Mostly because I read it as a teenager but also because I refuse to give accolades to a person who can imagine a school for wizards and not imagine gender outside binary confines. 

  1. The Yiddish Policeman’s Union (2008)- Michael Chabon

Again, just didn’t feel like SF or fantasy to me. A really great fiction book written in a world where only one historical detail had changed. 

Other science fiction books I have loved in these last 7 years that didn’t win (in no particular order)

  1. The Mountain in the Sea- Ray Nailor

  2. The Wayfarer series and the Monk and Robot novellas by Becky Chambers

  3. The parable novels by Octavia Butler

  4. The Lilith’s Brood novels by Octavia Butler

  5. The other books in the Foundation series by Issac Asimov

  6. To Be Taught if Fortunate by Becky Chambers (novella)

  7. The Dark Forest and Deaths End by Cixin Liu

  8. The Binti novellas by Nnedi Okorafor 

  9. The Maddadam trilogy by Margaret Atwood

  10. Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir

  11. Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel

  12. Slaughterhouse 5 by Kurt Vonnegut

  13. The Wandering Earth collection of short stories by Cixin Liu

  14. After Dachau by Daniel Quinn

  15. The Power by Naomi Alderman

  16. The Redemption of Time by Baoshu

  17. The Dog Stars by Peter Heller

  18. The Hainish Cycle novels and novellas by Ursula le Guin

  19. The Gunslinger by Steven King

  20. The Inheritance trilogy by N. K Jemisin

  21. The Moon and the Other by John Kessel

  22. The Kaiju Preservation Society by John Scalzi

EDIT/ REACTION: Wow! I never thought this post would generate so much interest and interaction! Thanks for all your thoughts and feedback! It was overwhelming to even keep up with the comments, which were so fun and interesting to read!

Top takeaways (in no order but numbered anyway):

  1. I'll be ordering and reading The Sparrow soon. I am already started on Children of Time (which I'd been psyched about for a while!

  2. I should really give The Diamond Age another try.

  3. "Hard Sci-Fi" is a triggering term to many people. I guess I got it wrong calling Three Body "hard sci-fi". Thanks for checking me and educating me.

  4. Related...? There are some very serious Liu Cixin haters out there.

  5. Connie Willis is deeply polarizing within this community.

  6. This community is super fun, smart and kind overall. Glad to be more involved in it!


r/printSF • • Aug 15 '24

I'm really disappointed with the end of the Children of Time trilogy

667 Upvotes

The first book in the trilogy, Children of Time, was amazing! I loved it! So flipping good!

The second book, Children of Ruin was also good. It wasn't as outstanding as the first one, but it was still a good sci-fi book, and it built on top of the first one like a sequel should.

But then I read the third book, Children of Dune and wow, it just abandons everything the first two books set up to go do its own thing. It was a total letdown. And it was super weird, giving completely different vibes from the first two. Like seriously, sandworms? What was the author thinking?! Not what I was hoping for in the conclusion of the trilogy. Super disappointed.


r/printSF • • Apr 09 '26

Reading Diaspora by Greg Egan and I cannot process that someone just invented working physics for a six dimensional universe as a side note

666 Upvotes

I'm about 200 pages in and I had to put it down yesterday because I hit the section where Egan describes the geometry of a universe with six spatial dimensions and I made the mistake of trying to follow the actual math and now I'm just here.

So like this isn't "and then the ship went through hyperspace" handwaving, like usually in ither books and shows, but there are actual equations like the way physics works in a six dimensional space is different in specific ways that Egan works out properly, the way gravity falls off, the way atomic structures would or wouldn't be stable, the way light behaves and he's not using these as decoration, the plot depends on characters understanding and navigating these differences and if the math were wrong the story wouldn't work. I went down a rabbit hole two days ago trying to verify some of it and the parts I could check against real physics papers actually hold up and the parts that go beyond current physics are extrapolated consistently from real principles rather than just invented for convenience and I don't know what to do with the fact that someone sat down and worked this out.

And the thing that's breaking my brain specifically is the orbital mechanics section, because in three dimensions orbits are stable in a specific way that we take for granted and Egan works out that in higher dimensions stable orbits basically don't exist in the same way and uses this as an actual plot point and I had to read it three times because I kept expecting him to hand wave past it and he just....doesn't.

So has anyone else read this and actually tried to follow the physics or did you just let it wash over you because I genuinely cannot tell which approach is the right one, or maybe there are other books that describe in such detail how the world of the book works?


r/printSF • • Jan 13 '25

There Is No Safe Word

Thumbnail
vulture.com
659 Upvotes

r/printSF • • 28d ago

Very disappointed in The Three Body Problem

646 Upvotes

I just finished The Three Body Problem and I’m mystified how it won the Hugo. It’s not even close to the quality of other winners like Dune and Hyperion.

I knew the characterization would be weak going into it, but the ideas “explored” didn’t make up for it at all. I thought the author would try to explain stuff like the complexity of the three body problem, nanomaterials, computing, etc so laypeople could understand them better, but he didn’t really try. Just seemed like he threw in half baked concepts he thought sounded cool.

It also felt like it was written without an editor. The main character’s wife and child show up for a few pages and then never again. The 3body gameplay was boring and a clunky way to give background about Trisolaris. There was a long backstory about how a math prodigy figured out solutions to the three body problem and it didn’t seem to have any affect on the rest of the book. None of the storylines felt like they had any stakes and the pacing was terrible.

I could keep going, but I’m just disappointed. I was excited about reading translated sci-fi. I wanted to like it and I gave it a chance. If it hadn’t won an award, at best it’s a mildly entertaining book and I can somewhat understand its popularity. But Hugo winners should be held to a higher standard and it is bad in comparison. I’m tempted to read some of the runners up that year to see if any are better, but I won’t be reading the rest of the trilogy.


r/printSF • • Jan 16 '21

Pioneering sci-fi author Ursula K. Le Guin gets her own US postage stamp

Thumbnail
cnet.com
641 Upvotes

r/printSF • • Oct 13 '25

I downvote every “I am reading <NAME OF CRITICALLY-ACCLAIMED AND FAN-LOVED BOOK> and I think it’s <SYNONYMS FOR BAD>, does it get any better?”

602 Upvotes

I am 99% certain these are BS posts just farming engagement. So I just hit downvote and move on.


r/printSF • • Apr 23 '26

Has Anyone Read Three-Body Problem in Both Chinese and English? The Differences Are Bigger Than I Expected

594 Upvotes

I grew up reading Three-Body Problem in Chinese and recently went through the English translations to compare. I knew there would be some differences but I was genuinely not prepared for how much changed between versions.

The biggest one that nobody talks about: in the Chinese Book 2, Wallfacer Tyler's entire plan is built around ball lightning weapons from Liu Cixin's earlier novel. His real strategy involves quantizing Earth's own soldiers into a ghost army. The English version completely replaces this with a different mosquito fleet kamikaze plan because Ball Lightning hadn't been translated yet when The Dark Forest came out in English. There's a detailed comparison of both versions that goes through it scene by scene and it's honestly like reading two different characters.

The chapter order in Book 1 is different too. The Chinese publisher made Liu Cixin move Ye Wenjie's backstory from the beginning to the middle to reduce political sensitivity. Ken Liu moved it back for the English translation and Liu Cixin immediately agreed because that was his original intent. So the English version actually has the author's preferred structure.

And then there's the second book's English edition where the Tor editor made over 1,000 changes for cultural reasons. Liu Cixin wrote 10,000 extra words trying to preserve his original version but the publisher discarded them. He allowed publication but refused to write a preface.

I'm curious if anyone else here has read both or noticed differences. The two translators had completely opposite relationships with the author which adds another layer to the whole thing.


r/printSF • • Jul 23 '20

I'm reading every Hugo, Nebula, Locus, and World Fantasy Award winner. Here's my reviews of the 1960s.

584 Upvotes

PrintSF doesn't allow linking to blogs, so here are the reviews without blog post links!

There's more discussion of these same reviews on the books subreddit.

Sorted in order of year awarded.

Starship Troopers by Robert A. Heinlein

  • Plot: Welcome to the Mobile Infantry, the military of the future!

  • Page Count: 263

  • Award: 1960 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: Status as classic well earned. A fun space romp even if it heavily glorifies the military. No worrisome grey morality. Compelling protagonist and excellent details keep book moving at remarkable speed.

A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M. Miller Jr.

  • Plot: The Order of Leibowitz does its best to make sure that next time will be different.

  • Page Count: 338

  • Award: 1961 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: I love the first section of this book, greatly enjoy the second, and found the third decent. That said, if it was only the first third, the point of the book would still be clear. Characters are very well written and distinct.

Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert A. Heinlein

  • Plot: Michael Smith, the Man From Mars, struggles to understand Earth culture.

  • Page Count: 408

  • Award: 1962 Hugo

  • Worth a read: No

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: Started out enjoying it, probably to about the halfway mark. Interesting fish-out-of-water tale. And then we went for a BA in religion with a concentration in polyamory, pedophilia, and just a whole bunch of sex - and not a lot more. Grok Count: 487 (1.2/page)

The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick

  • Plot: Turns out it'd be bad if the Axis had won.

  • Page Count: 249

  • Award: 1963 Hugo

  • Worth a read: No, but it hurts to say it

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: I wanted to like this more. Some details are excellent, like people constantly consulting the Tao Te Ching. But the MacGuffin of an in-universe alternate history book seems self-serving, and the actual alt history is not that interesting. The big twist is also a surprise to characters in

Way Station by Clifford D. Simak

  • Plot: Since the Civil War, Enoch Wallace has manned the alien transport hub on Earth.

  • Page Count: 210

  • Award: 1964 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes! As soon as possible.

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Pass

  • Technobabble: Some

  • Review: An exceptional book. Enoch's journals give us peeks at a vast galaxy of different aliens, all distinct. At the center of this vast cosmos is a superb depiction of isolation and loneliness. The writing is poetic yet unpretentious. Read this book.

The Wanderer by Fritz Leiber

  • Plot: A mysterious planet appears out of hyperspace, high jinks ensue.

  • Page Count: 320

  • Award: 1965 Hugo

  • Worth a read: For the love of all you hold dear, No.

  • Primary Driver: (No)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Plenty

  • Review: How do you take a book about a planet of freedom fighting sexy space cats appearing out of hyperspace to devour the moon and make it so boring? So many characters, none of them have personalities except for racial stereotypes. Silly to include multiple comic relief characters when the book itself is a joke. I think I understand book burning now.

Dune by Frank Herbert

  • Plot: The desert planet of Arrakis holds many secrets, possibly enough to shift the outcomes of interplanetary war and political intrigue.

  • Page Count: 610

  • Award: 1966 Hugo and 1966 Nebula

  • Worth a read: Yes, of course.

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Pass

  • Technobabble: Moderate

  • Review: Excellent and epic. Intrigue, cool characters, action. A slow burn at times, and the spice ex machina is a bit overdone. Switching perspectives and characters ramps up tension to superb effect.

This Immortal by Roger Zelazny

  • Plot: A (somewhat) immortal man guides a group (including an alien) on a tour of post-nuclear-war Earth.

  • Page Count: 174

  • Award: 1966 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: This was originally serialized and you can feel it while reading; it does not have a plot so much as a series of events. Narrator is hilarious without being unbearable - worth reading for his excellent commentary.

Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes

  • Plot: An experimental procedure takes Charlie Gordon from mentally handicapped to genius.

  • Page Count: 270

  • Award: 1967 Nebula

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: Superb writing, absolutely heartrending plot. Story told exclusively through Charlie's progress reports; shifts in tone and style throughout the book convey as much as the text itself. Takes a difficult subject and addresses it with tact and grace. All the tears.

Babel-17 by Samuel R. Delaney

  • Plot: A series of attacks by the invaders have only one thing in common: the mysterious language Babel-17

  • Page Count: 173

  • Award: 1967 Nebula. You read that right. This tied with Flowers for Algernon.

  • Worth a read: No

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabel-17: Go big or go home.

  • Review: Boring. Very boring. Just so boring. Is the idea that language dictates thought interesting? Sure. Is it enough to carry a story? Nope. Dull story, tepid characters, belabored central concept. Handful of neat ideas that don't make up for the rest. Nap time in book form.

The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert A. Heinlein

  • Plot: The Moon is ready for a revolution, and only a supercomputer with a sense of humor is smart enough to lead it.

  • Page Count: 380

  • Award: 1967 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Pass

  • Technobabble: Moderate

  • Review: Mike may be a computer, but he is one of Heinlein's most human characters. Snappy dialogue and good characters keep you rooting for Luna every step of the way. Upbeat and fun.

Lord of Light by Roger Zelazny

  • Plot: The Hindu gods have kept the world in the Dark Ages: it is time for them to die.

  • Page Count: 319

  • Award: 1968 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: A fascinating depiction of religion and reincarnation supported by technology. Multiple stories (7) of varying quality come together well, though pacing can be a bit all over. Superb world-building and novel use of Hindu myths.

The Einstein Intersection by Samuel R. Delany

  • Plot: Kid Death has taken Friza and it's up to Lo Lobey to stop him.

  • Page Count: 142

  • Award: 1968 Nebula

  • Worth a read: No

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Fail

  • Technobabble: Moderate

  • Review: A distant post-apocalyptic world (30,000 years in the future) with wildly inconsistent rules is for some reason still referring to the Beatles and Greek myths. Starring an uninteresting first person narrator who stumbles from one event to another.

Rite of Passage by Alexei Panshin

  • Plot: Upon turning 14, everyone aboard the ship must survive 30 days unassisted on one of the colony planets.

  • Page Count: 254

  • Award: 1969 Nebula

  • Worth a read: Yes, but it's YA.

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Pass

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: A coming-of-age story, a clearly YA entry. Good approach to perspective and prejudice by showing what those living on ships think of on planets and vice versa. A number of themes are told a bit on the nose; this makes sense given the younger target audience.

Stand on Zanzibar by John Brunner

  • Plot: 2010 is bleak; overpopulation, eugenics, corporate colonialism, racism, and violence abound.

  • Page Count: 650

  • Award: 1969 Hugo

  • Worth a read: Yes? It's New Wave SF - love it or hate it.

  • Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)

  • Bechdel Test: Pass

  • Technobabble: Minimal

  • Review: Highly experimental in form, this book is a tough read. Detailed world-building depicted in interesting ways. Hated some of it, but felt like it was worth the challenge. Pretty much everything that comes up has a payoff - even if you don't like the book, you have to acknowledge that it's impressive.

I'll continue to post each decade of books when they're done, and do a final master list when through everything, but it's around 200 books, so it'll be a hot minute. I'm also only doing the Novel category for now, though I may do one of the others as well in the future.

If there are other subjects or comments that would be useful to see in future posts, please tell me! I'm trying to keep it concise but informative. I’ve done my best to add things that people requested the first time around.

Any questions or comments? Fire away!

A few folks suggested doing some kind of youtube series or podcast - I can look into that as well, if there’s interest.

Other Notes:

The Bechdel Test is a simple question: do two named female characters converse about something other than a man. Whether or not a book passes is not a condemnation so much as an observation; it was the best binary determination I could find. Seems like a good way to see how writing has evolved over the years. At the suggestion of some folks, I’m loosening it to non-male identified characters to better capture some of the ways that science fiction tackles sex and gender.

Here’s a further explanation from u/Gemmabeta (in a discussion on the previous post)

To everyone below bitching about the Bechdel Test. The test is used as a simple gauge of the aggregate levels of sexism across an entire medium, genre, or time period. It is NOT a judgement on individual books or movies. The test is intentionally designed to be trivially easy to pass with even the most minimum of effort (there are basically no book or film that fails a male version of the Bechdel test; heck, most chick lit and women-centric fiction manages to pass the male Bechdel test--with the possible exception of Pride and Prejudice).
The the fact that such a large percentage of books and movies fail the test is a sign of the general lack of good female characters in literature/film (especially in previous eras) and the females character that did exist tends to only exist to prop up a man--even in many stories where the woman is technically the main character.
PS. The test is also not a measure of the artistic merit of a work or even the feminist credentials of a work (for example, the world's vilest and most misogynistic porno could pass the test simply by having two women talk about pizza for 5 minutes at the beginning), it purely looks at plotting elements and story structure.

Technobabble example!

"There must be intercommunication between all the Bossies. It was not difficult to found the principles on which this would operate. Bossy functioned already by a harmonic vibration needed to be broadcast on the same principle as the radio wave. No new principle was needed. Any cookbook engineer could do it—even those who believe what they read in the textbooks and consider pure assumption to be proved fact. It was not difficult to design the sending and receiving apparatus, nor was extra time consumed since this small alteration was being made contiguous with the production set up time of the rest. The production of countless copies of the brain floss itself was likewise no real problem, no more difficult than using a key-punched master card to duplicate others by the thousands or millions on the old-fashioned hole punch computer system." - They'd Rather Be Right

Cheers, Everyone!

And don't forget to read a book!


r/printSF • • Mar 24 '26

"If people are fighting for an orb you are reading fantasy. If people are fighting for a cube you are reading sci-fi." How well does this hold up?

577 Upvotes

r/printSF • • Mar 31 '26

In Dune, do the Fremen just have really good toilets or does nobody ever talk about it

566 Upvotes

Okay hear me out. The Fremen live in the deep desert. Water is the most precious resource in existence. They recycle everything. Every drop of moisture from dead bodies, from breath, from sweat. They wear stillsuits that capture every bit of water their bodies produce.
So what happens when someone needs to poop. Like seriously. The stillsuit recycles urine into drinking water. Thats mentioned multiple times. But solid waste has water in it too. Are the Fremen just... carrying little bags of dehydrated poop around? Do they have stilltent bathrooms? Is there a secret Fremen composting ritual that Herbert just glossed over.
I mentioned this to my book club and now nobody will look at me. But I think its a valid question. Paul becomes Emperor of the known universe but did he ever have to dig a hole in the sand and bury it like a cat. Someone who knows the extended lore please explain.


r/printSF • • Jun 21 '21

I Read and Ranked Every Hugo Award Winning Novel from the 50's to the 80s

564 Upvotes

So I've read every Hugo Winning Novel from before 1990 (Not including the Retro Hugos) and I've ranked them. Why? Because it's a great way to start conversation. Some of you will agree with me, some of you will hate me and think my ideas are stupid. That is totally fine, I've tried to remain spoiler free while giving an idea of what each novel is about. If you get through all of these thanks for you time and don't forget to agree of disagree with me at the bottom. :)

The list goes from Worst to best in case there is some confusion.

36: The Big Time by Fritz Lieber (1958) - Guests at a temporal guest house attempt to solve a mystery against the clock.  It’s the height of pulp sci-fi set in what can generously be described as a cabaret and at worst a brothel for an epoch spanning time war.  The idea of a place for soldiers of different species from across history to RnR has some merit, but it’s all a little sexist.  Even if we forget that most of the characters are forgettable, the plot isn’t anything special.  That said, it is short so it’s not like I found it a chore to read.  I think someone could take the location and make a damn good tv series out of it, but this execution is not it.

35: Ringworld by Larry Niven (1971) - A crew of adventures discover a massive space artifact and explore it.  I want to start by saying the idea of the Ringworld is wonderful, I enjoyed exploring it and learning about all the technical aspects.  For that alone I’m glad I read it, that said the book is pulp sci-fi and for 1971 almost unforgivably so.  It won the year after Left Hand of Darkness and yet feels like it was written in the 50s, another part of which is that it’s quite sexist and leaves you with the impression Larry might have been a bit of a “nice guy”.  That said, thanks for the Halo franchise!

34: They’d Rather be Right by Clifton and Riley (1955) - A psychic man manipulates those around him to create a computer that purifies people and causes a mass media sensation.  A lot going on here and It’s very much of its time, though it’s enjoyable enough, with an actual overall message about academia.  It’s also in some regards ahead of its time, but some of it is just a bit silly in retrospect to be any higher on the list.  Still if you wanted to get into 1950’s Sci-Fi you could do much worse.

33: A Case of Conscience by James Blish (1959) - Scientists sent to study an alien world bring an alien fetus back so they can learn about us.  Oh what this book could have been.   A book of two halves, the first a wonderful exploration of an alien civilization by a bunch of human scientists studying them and it really does set off at a storming pace.  The second half is back on earth and a bit like the worse bits of Stranger in a strange land.  The 50s were so sure we would take aliens to dinner parties and they would sip cocktails in dinner jackets.  The end is interesting and a bit clever and we this is the first book in the list that looks at Science Fiction and Catholicism.

32: The Wanderer by Fritz Lieber (1965) - An alien planet suddenly appears in the sky over earth and we jump around between multiple perspectives of how it affects people.  Some of this is very solid, the scale of the thing is wonderful, because the story is happy to change perspective rather than sticking to one protagonist.  That said, it’s very pulp SF and a little sexist, gave me Independence Day or The Day After Tomorrow vibes. 

31: A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M Miller (1961) - Monks keep alive parts of technology in a post-apocalyptic world so humanity can once again regain civilization.   I was raised Catholic and loved Babylon 5 which I later found out borrowed part of an episode idea from this book so I was very excited to read this. A lot of people adore this book and I get that, the idea is incredible, but I disliked the writing style and I’m not really sure it goes anywhere.  I think this is just a case of me coming in with high expectations and being left feeling a bit meh.  

30: Starship Troopers by Robert Heinlein (1967) - A look at mechanized warfare and the book that coined the term Space Marine twenty years before Games Workshop got there.  If you’re of a certain age you saw a film loosely based on this book (The Director gave up reading it 20 pages in) The book is a completely different animal.  Interesting ideas and hugely influential, but feels at times like Heinlein is lecturing you about his political beliefs in a classroom setting.  I didn’t read another Heinlein novel for 15 years after this one, which is a shame, but I love the film so much, it was hard for me to appreciate a book with politics I wasn’t ready for in my twenties.

29: The Man in The High Castle by Phillip K Dick (1963) - An alternate history were the Axis powers won the second world war.  It’s enjoyable enough to read and by Philip K Dick standards is incredibly well-written as he sometimes can be accused of great ideas, but a difficult style.  By its very definition the book lacks what I find so interesting about his work, we don’t see a depressing future of humanity that is very much alone in the universe exploring the mind more than the great emptiness of space.  It’s a fine book, but the man wrote better Science Fiction books.

28: Neuromancer by William Gibson (1985) - Hackers and cyberspace and a connected world or something.  Sacrilege to some of you, I’m sure that this book is so low.  Firstly it is hugely influential, essentially inventing the entire cyber punk genre, without it we don’t have The Matrix, words like Cyberspace or the most disappointing game of last year.  That said it isn’t an enjoyable book, it is crammed full of so many ideas that barely anything sticks.  Someone asked me what I remembered of the book a few years ago and I mumbled the phrase Rastafarian Navy, because almost nothing sticks.  It almost certainly meant more when it came out as we’d seen nothing like it before, but in 2021 it is more an artifact of interest than a great book.

27: Stand on Zanzibar by John Brumner (1969) - A book about overpopulation that feels more relevant day by day.  We see a world where our freedoms might be curtailed, because of ever increasing population and it’s genuinely interesting as a think piece.  The book also contains data dumps where we are overloaded with a page of mismatched text from the world that give us more background on the situation with little context.  It’s cool to see and fascinating as a concept, but the story is a bit lacking and it just kind of runs out of steam towards the end.

26: Downbelow Station by CJ Cherryh (1982) - A book portraying a space station as a blue-collar workplace that gets tangled up in an intergalactic conflict.  The book sounds fascinating and I think it very much influences shows like Babylon 5 where there are episodes dedicated to dock strikes and unions etc.  The main issue is the book gets away from that and makes it about space ships and a galactic conflict and feels like she is trying to set up the next book in the series.  The world building is superb, but I didn’t really care for any of the characters and wasn’t even sure who I was supposed to be cheering for until the end.

25: Way Station by Clifford D Simak (1964) - An intergalactic way station in a farm house in the American mid-west.  It’s just really interesting, the aliens never get too silly or pulp.  The story drags you along and frankly like a lot of Simak’s stuff, it would make a really good TV series, but also at times feels like a one-off Twilight Zone episode.  Really enjoyable read once we got going, though maybe a bit slow at the start.

24: This Immortal by Roger Zelazny (1966) - Earth is a post nuclear wasteland and alien tourists visit bits historical bits with human tour guides.  All this is tied in with elements of Greek mythology. Is our main character a God or is a mutant pretending to be?  Similar themes to Lord of Light, but maybe lacking a bit of what made that book so wonderful.  Still it’s enjoyable and full of interesting ideas. 

23: Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein (1962) - A Human is left on mars for several years and then brought back home, but is now more alien than human.  Extremely popular at the time, with the word Grok even entering common parlance.  The book is slow to start off with and bits of it are quite silly in retrospect, other bits either sexist or feminist depending on your viewpoint.  There is definitely something there though.  Certainly not a flawless work, in fact it is very much more flawed than many of the books ranked lower on this list, but there is something that sticks with you about it.  It is massively referenced in pop-culture and just feels important as a novel even if bits will make you cringe.

22: Foundation’s Edge by Isaac Asimov (1983) - Members of the First Foundation search for Earth, but are drawn in a mass mystery that will affect the whole galaxy.  The sequel to his trilogy thirty years later.  It’s well told and a good story, it moves around between perspectives and shows that Asimov had kept up his craft and improved his style.  It’s a bit sexist in parts, but by no means the worst offender on the list.  It was enjoyable, but lacked the ground breaking ideas of most of the higher ranked books on this list.

21: To Your Scattered Bodies Go by Phillip Jose Farmer (1972) - Humans awake after death in a huge alien constructed artifact. I found this enjoyable and a definitely interesting concept driven by an incredibly likeable main character. That said, I get the impression the main character is a hugely controversial figure, which even seems acknowledged in the book. Overall a good book and made me semi interested in reading more.

20: The Gods Themselves by Isaac Asimov (1973) - Humans are sent plans to create a machine from another dimension.  A book of three parts, the pick of which is Asimov creating a truly alien civilization.  Too often aliens aren’t really alien, these really are.  The other parts aren’t bad either, but this book is  often forgotten as most people read his Foundation or Robot series.  If you want to experience strange aliens this is the one for you.

19: The Snow Queen by Joan D Vinge (1981) - A fairy tales set in a futuristic world as an evil snow queen attempts to hold on to power as her reign comes to an end.  Genre spanning, clever and very original.  This book does a lot of interesting things and tells a good story.  It is like nothing else on the list, but is definitely worth checking out if you like books that mix fantasy and science fiction.

18: Double Star by Robert Heinlein (1956) - A look at acting and politics tied into a fast-paced science fiction novel.  A good story that happens to be told in a science fiction setting and it works really well. Much like the next book it stands out compared to other 1950s sci-fi and even the bits that are a little pulpy don’t detract from the overall enjoyability.  It would make a great film.

17: The Demolished Man by Alfred Bester (1953) - A detective story set in a world where psychic powers are common.  Hard to believe this was written in 1953, read other stuff from the early 50s and this is so far ahead of its time.  Influential in so many ways and also just a really good story with a thought-provoking end.   Between this and “The Stars my Destination” he clearly deserves to be remembered on a level with Asimov, Heinlein and Clarke.

16: Gateway by Frederick Pohl (1978) - Alien artifact space station used by humans who don’t really understand it.  The space station is wonderful as both a location for things to happen, a hint at a wider universe and a way to drive the plot along.  Very much building on the themes of Rendezvous with Rama with a great story.

15: The Fountains of Paradise by Arthur C Clarke (1980) - Earth is building its first space elevator.   Like 90% of Clarke’s work very little happens in this book, but it’s very enjoyable to read.  Go on an adventure about a technology that could realistically exist, just don’t expect to be able to recount the plot back to anyone.

14: Cyteen by CJ Cherryh (1989) - Cyteen is a book about political intrigue, cloning and genetic/psychological manipulation.  This book is an absolute masterpiece.  Set in the same universe as Downbelow Station, but full of interesting characters that you like and can empathize with, even when they are doing horrible things to other characters you like.  This should and would be higher, but it’s so very long.  It takes 200 pages for the plot to really start going and while length won’t put some of you off I admire great stories that can tell their story in a more conside manor.  That said if 320,000 words doesn’t put you off, give it a go, especially as it’s free on the author’s website. 

13: Startide Rising by David Brin (1984) - A crew of mostly genetically engineered dolphins struggle to fix their ship while aliens battle in orbit.  Brin has a phenomenal style where every chapter is from a different character’s perspective (Think Game of Thrones).  The universe he created is also super interesting and the situation we enter in median res is excellent and drives the story along wonderfully as we experience this crisis from multiple different crew members.  

12: Dreamsnake by Vonda Mcintyre (1979) - A girl who uses alien snakes to heal people in a post-apocalyptic world.  Well written and a great story, also we delve into more of the lore.  Could have been a fantasy novel, but it isn’t and it stands out because of that.  Original and well written unlike this mini review that keeps using the phrase well-written.

11: Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang by Kate Wilhelm (1977) - Story looking into a society based around cloning and how it could change the way we act and treat each other.  Really beautifully written and again not really like anything else on this list, also the hardest title to remember on the list, I get it wrong literally every time.

10: Lord of Light by Roger Zelazny (1968) - Survivors on a colony world use technology to act like immortal Gods, one of their number fights to stop them.  Beautiful mixture of Buddhism and Hinduism to create a story that blurs the lines between fantasy and science fiction with an excellent protagonist you can’t help but cheer along.  This blew me away the first time I read it.

9: The Uplift War by David Brin (1988) - The follow up to Startide Rising, I spent much of the book thinking, sure it’s ok, but lesser than the book it follows.  By the end though I was totally all in.  Fiben Bolger might be one of the greatest protagonists in all of Science Fiction, stick him on the Mount Rushmore next to Andrew Wiggin and Gully Foyle.  More excellent world exploring and more of his excellent style that tells complicated stories in a fun easy to read manner.

8: Rendezvous with Rama by Arthur C Clarke (1974) - An massive Alien Artifact enters our solar system and a ship is sent to investigate.  Clarke making aliens seem alien and unknowable by not showing them and instead letting us explore a massive artifact.  Coming after so many novels about aliens the real beauty here is what we don’t see.  Clarke is always about restraint and so as mentioned on his previous book, very little actually happens.  Someone flies a hang glider at one point, but that’s about it.  The joy is about the implication, this is the science fiction equivalent of Jaws where the aliens are way stranger because that is left to our imagination.  

7: Forever War by Joe Haldeman (1976) - Soldiers fight in a war that due to time dilation means they watch the world change every time they return home.  The best science fiction is a black mirror in which we can learn about society and ourselves.  Haldeman massively increases how drastically the world changes, but through it you can understand how jarring it must be to return to a world that no longer makes sense, a world you’ve arguably fought to save and now ironically don’t really fit into and so you go on duty again, hoping it will be different next time, but the world becomes more alien every time.

6: Dune by Frank Herbert (1966) - You all know what happens in Dune! Go check a list of Science Fiction written before and after Dune.  It essentially killed pulp science fiction dead overnight, it was almost to my mind the best science fiction book written when it came out.  It literally changed everything and invented space opera on its own.  Everything is so well thought out, it’s like Lord of the Rings for science fiction with its masses of lore that is sometimes only hinted at.  As Hyperion and Blindsight don’t make this list I have little doubt most of you would place this number one.  My only critique is that it can be slow to get going, I found the book really kicked off when Paul gets into the desert and while what he is doing early on is wonderful world building, the books ranked above it never slow down.

5: Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card (1986) - A child genius goes to battle school as humanities last hope.  The battle school is enormously cool, the wargames he plays are great and the whole thing just draws you in.  I guess it’s basically YA fiction for Sci fi kids, but it carries a message and must have felt even more relatable in the 80s with their computer graphics.  

4: Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K Le Guin (1970) - An ambassador lands on a planet hoping to get them to join the galactic empire, but has to come to terms with a society that sees and experiences gender in a very different way.  Le Guin just writes in a way that is incredibly enjoyable.  She is one of science fiction’s most stylized writers this is often considered her masterpiece.  The society we explore is just fascinating and the story is excellent.  The one complaint I’ve heard is that the location and the story are only loosely related, but honestly it doesn’t matter.  The book is somehow more relevant today than when it was written.

3: The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein (1967) - A revolution on the moon.  I thought I understood Heinlein’s politics after reading Starship Troopers, this book showed me I was a fool and he could take on whatever politics the story required.  Heinlein takes us to the moon and thinks about how society would be different there.  He also casually shoots down any claims of sexism from earlier novels as well, while crafting a wonderful story about a revolution, sentient AI and even had time to explore the ideas of polygamy and group marriages.  There is so much going on here and it’s all wonderful and so well written.  Heinlein is more known by boomers for Stranger in a Strange Land and by millennials for Starship Troopers, but this is his true masterpiece.

2: The Dispossessed by Ursula K Le Guin (1975) - Revolution on a moon.  There are artificially similarities between this and the book at number three, but what we have here is a story that alternates between two time periods, which is used wonderfully to drive the story along.  The book is a look at both socialism and capitalism and a critique of the floors in both, but it never passes judgement.  It shows you an alien world and lets you see how similar to our own it is.  There is a story which is very much tied to the setting unlike Left Hand of Darkness and all the while we are given Le Guin’s wonderful style.  

1: Speaker for the Dead by Orson Scott Card (1987) - In a sequel to Ender’s Game humans come into contact with another alien race and hope for a different outcome than the first.  Can I first acknowledge how much Card owes to Le Guin, his universe is all about relativistic space travel and the ansible both of which are straight lifted from her Hamish cycle.  The story he crafts though is nothing short of amazing, it drives along at a phenomenal pace.  We are given many plot points, but a singular focused story based around ideas of assumptions, nature vs nurture, religion and guilt.  Andrew is a very human character, a realistic fleshed out character who is a very different animal than the boy genius at battle school.  That said he is still every bit as brilliant, just more rounded and using his powers to fix people not kill aliens.  The other two novels mixing Catholicism and science fiction in this list were right down the bottom, but this does it wonderfully.  If I was to have a criticism, there is the issue of a white saviour, but honestly everyone is treated with such respect it’s unbelievable the person that wrote this lacks such empathy is the real world.  Still an incredible achievement.