r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 09 '11

My wife is getting induced in a few hours, she will be giving birth to my daughter Kylie, our first child. As such, I will be taking a brief hiatus from reddit. I trust that things will go on without me in my absence.

6 Upvotes

Working on this project has been very fun, and I'm still going to be checking in from time to time. However, as some of you already know, it's hard to find leisure time when you have a newborn infant in the house. My wife is almost a week past her due date, and her doctor told us that if she hasn't gone into labor by tonight at 8pm EST (five hours from now), we have an appointment at the hospital and they are going to induce her. As we get settled in with our new baby, and my wife recovers from labor (she might possibly need a c-section, we don't know yet), I will gradually have more and more time to devote to reddit. I won't be on much in the next couple of weeks, though.

I'm confident in the abilities of the moderators we currently have in place, as well as our team of approved submitters. This project will never succeed without motivated individuals, and we seem to have plenty of those. Remember, if you want to become an approved submitter, all you have to do is ask!

One thing that I think we need is more subscribers in every subreddit in the network. I've built a lot of subreddits from the ground up, and in my experience, a subreddit doesn't become self-sustainable until around 2,000 to 3,000 subscribers. I imagine that since our subreddits are restricted, that number will be slightly higher. The [1% rule](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule_(Internet_culture)) has proven itself true to me time and time again.

One of the things we need to solve before we end our open beta and finalize the charter & republiquette is the issue of elections. As of yet we haven't been in agreement on the best way to hold elections, without the possibility of voter fraud, or on the other end of the spectrum, voter intimidation. At this point, I think we can simply promote any approved submitter who wants to be a moderator, and elections aren't really necessary yet (if there's no one to run against, why bother holding elections). However, when we reach the point that we have tens of thousands of users across the entire network, elections will be a necessity, or we won't be able to call ourselves a true republic.

I will be checking in from the hospital on my iPad during any downtime, so I won't be completely absent, but on the other hand I won't be on for hours every day like I have in the past.

Good luck, fellow republicans (let's reclaim that word)! It has been an honor and a privilege serving with you. I will return with stories of triumph and plunder.

Salutem plurimam dicit!

Edit: Good news! Looks like she might not need to be induced after all. The doc sent us home and told us to come back in the morning. I'm wired, can't sleep, so I will most likely be hunting for news articles to submit to the network for a few hours.

Edit2: I now am the proud father of a beautiful baby girl, Kylie, born 10/10/11 at 11:09pm, weighing 7lbs 9oz. The wife was in labor for 16 hours, but my daughter didn't want to drop so they had to do a c section. They are both resting comfortably at the moment. I'm not going to have much reddit time for the next two weeks or so. Thank you everyone for all of your kind words.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 16 '11

Occupy Wall Street: Fighting Capitalism, One Food Cart at a Time

Thumbnail
nymag.com
1 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 11 '11

I consider reddit too annoying and immature anymore to surf with enjoyment. I had high hopes for the Republic of Reddits, but, honestly, it's an unfortunate failure.

0 Upvotes

Discuss.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 06 '11

Apparently, we're the new Illuminati. All hail the New Reddit Order!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 04 '11

Chillin' in the ROCannabis

2 Upvotes

I am unsure is it can be added to the network, for now I'm just sitting on the name, http://www.reddit.com/r/RepublicOfCannabis/ and I don't know if the capital O in Of really matters cause I forgot it. :p

I don't know if there are any people who actually partakes in toking in the ROR but it might come in handy after opening day If I don't space on that day.

         ____                   __    ___         ____  ____   ______                        __    _     
        / __ ___  ____  __  __/ /_  / (_)____   / __ \/ __/  / ____/___ _____  ____  ____ _/ /_  (_)____
       / /_/ / _ \/ __ \/ / / / __ \/ / / ___/  / / / / /_   / /   / __ `/ __ \/ __ \/ __ `/ __ \/ / ___/
      / _, _/  __/ /_/ / /_/ / /_/ / / / /__   / /_/ / __/  / /___/ /_/ / / / / / / / /_/ / /_/ / (__  ) 
     /_/ |_|___/ .___/__,_/_.___/_/_/___/   ____/_/     ____/__,_/_/ /_/_/ /_/__,_/_.___/_/____/  
               /_/                                                                                       

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Dec 18 '11

Should there be guidelines on comments in the Republic?

4 Upvotes

There generally aren't many comments on posts in the Republic network. And the ones that are posted are for the most part civil. But the Republic will continue to grow, and as of now the Republiquette only applies to submissions.

Should we start planning comment guidelines? If so, where would we draw the line?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 30 '11

Children and sharing: don't force kids to share

Thumbnail
slate.com
20 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 24 '11

I'm stepping down from every content subreddit in this network except RoAtheism, RoMusic, and RoPics.

13 Upvotes

In keeping with the discussion we had two weeks ago about how many Republic content subreddits a single moderator should be added to, I am stepping down from RoFunny, RoGaming, RoNews and RoPolitics, and limiting myself to the three that I am most active in, RoAtheism, RoMusic and RoPics.

I don't want anyone to think I created this network as some sort of power grab. I am in fact happy to turn the reigns over to individuals who are passionate about this project and would like to see it succeed. I moderate 67 subreddits at the moment, including the SFWPorn Network and ITookAPicture. I have been recently added as a moderator of /r/pics to help enforce the new rules, and as many of you know, I currently have a two-week old daughter.

In other words, I have a lot of responsibilities at the moment, but regardless, this project needs to be a group effort if it is to succeed. There should not a central consolidation of power, on the contrary power should be very distributed and balanced. It is very easy to become an approved submitter. It is also very easy to become a mod. We need to make sure that approved submitter and even mods that do not follow the rules are no longer allowed to be a part of this project.

I'm very glad of the progress this network has made so far. However I do think we are still a long way away from ending the open beta. We still need to come up with a fool-proof method of elections that will scale as the network grows larger. Not to mention, not many people are willing to moderate at the moment, and we needs mods who are active on reddit daily. I think it will be a simple matter of gaining new subscribers. The more users who know about this network and think it is a great idea, we will find more good moderators, and good moderators are really the key to the success of any subreddit.

So please, if you want this network to succeed, spread the word. If you see a conversation about the decline of reddit, drop a link to this network or one of the subreddits in it. Ask related subreddits if they would be willing to add links to their sidebars. Tell your friends! We can make this work if we work together.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Sep 18 '12

I will no longer be a moderator on RoPolitics or RoGaming.

0 Upvotes

After being involved with the Republic since its inception nearly a year ago, I've decided it is time for me to step down and move on.

These really are wonderful, high-quality subreddits. It's a shame that more of mainstream reddit wasn't willing to give us a chance.

Someone can remove me from RoModeration if that is deemed appropriate.

Thank you all for your outstanding efforts to make reddit a better place.

-insomniaclyric


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Aug 09 '19

Venetian Republic

Thumbnail self.hi13245
0 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 14 '11

Under Republiquette v.3 Section A.7 concerning the topicality of submissions, shouldn't "Opinion piece on MSNBC concerning Reddit" be removed from RoR?

9 Upvotes

Republiquette v.3

Link in question

The "stated theme" of RoR is "For announcements and discussion concerning the Republic of Reddit network." That link qualifies for removal under section A.7 by "Fall[ing] outside the stated theme of the reddit to which they were submitted (i.e. off topic)"

I noticed two mods commenting multiple times in that thread, but not as to whether or not it was a valid submission for RoR.

So I'm just wondering under what rule was that submission allowed. You know, for posterity and precedents and such.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Dec 08 '25

Hey, reddit

0 Upvotes

I know no one is going to read this, but it hardly matters. I want to say it.

What’s happening on this platform is absurd, among other things.

The people who run the communities are completely arbitrary. Out of all the times my posts have been removed, only once did I understand why. Every other time—countless times in less than six months—I haven’t been able to figure it out no matter how much I’ve thought about it. Explanations are never given, even when you ask for them politely.

It has even happened that my post was removed and I was permanently banned from a community in less than ONE MINUTE after posting, and without ANY real reason.

It also happens that if enough time passes and I forget that I’m not allowed to participate in one of those communities, and I comment on a post in one of them, it’s interpreted as “ban evasion,” and I get globally and permanently banned.

And if someone uses my device, logs into their own account, and posts or comments in a community where I was banned, their account gets globally and permanently banned because supposedly I tried to “evade the ban.”

Meanwhile, there are indecent posts that never get removed, and I assume their authors’ accounts aren’t banned either. Not long ago I reported TWO posts showing a woman being shot to death, in close-up. You know what you did? You thanked me and hid those posts for me, but they remained completely visible if I logged in with another account or browsed without logging in.

So when your rules say, as rule number one, “Remember the human,” it’s nothing but ridiculous irony.

You profit from people’s need to communicate, and you ABSOLUTELY do not care about any human being. The only thing you care about is making as much money as you can, nothing more.

So no, you’re not better than Facebook, or Twitter, or any other platform. You’re the same crap, just a slightly different color but with the same crappy smell.

And by the way, if you had even a bit of shame, you would have at least improved the mobile app by now, which is by far the worst one I’ve ever used.

Regards.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Nov 10 '11

We are discussing the stated theme of our subreddit over at /r/RepublicOfAtheism. I'd love it if you contributed to the discussion.

10 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/RepublicOfAtheism/comments/m6vcr/id_like_to_discuss_the_stated_theme_of_this/

In the past, I have removed submissions that do not explicitly mention the words 'atheism' or 'atheist' in the body of the submitted media. However, I recently took a brief hiatus from this network due to the birth of my daughter and other personal issues. To make a long story short, my wife and I have to pack all of our belongings and move into a new apartment before December 1st all the while taking care of a month-old infant.

Things have somewhat settled down now, and I have a little more time to devote to reddit again, but I have noticed that a lot of the submissions in the last few weeks do not directly discuss atheism. My first instinct was to start removing all of these submissions, but then I thought, if our active members who are submitting content don't agree with the current relevancy rule, perhaps we should discuss the issue.

I'd like to hear your opinions on this matter, r/RoAtheism. Should we allow anything even tangentially related to atheism (like criticism of theology in general) or should we stick to articles, videos and discussion that is directly related to atheism and mentions it explicitly?

Personally I am leaning towards the latter. What do you think?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 03 '12

A RepublicofReddit first impression.

10 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Dec 02 '11

I'm stepping down from every content subreddit in the network except /r/RepublicOfAtheism.

17 Upvotes

Unfortunately I simply do not have the time to devote to RoPics and RoMusic that I thought I would, and I feel that I am being negligent in my duties as a moderator. Rather than wait for election and then simply declining to run again, I thought it would be best to step down now. We need to get some fresh blood in here and I feel that with all of my other obligations, I am just taking up space in the mod list. Not to mention, since I was recently added as a moderator in /r/pics I felt that it would be a conflict of interest to stay on in RoPics. I try to be active in RoAtheism several times a week, and until/unless /r/atheism cleans up its act (which seems very, very unlikely), I will be active there for the foreseeable future.

If I may be very frank with everyone I think that the elections coming up are pretty pointless when we have only a few active submitters in every subreddit, and some of the subreddits currently in the network are dying a slow death. With the emergence of /r/games I see no huge demand for RoGaming in the near future, and RoFunny has struggled to find its niche from the beginning. On top of that most of the moderators across the network are pretty much inactive when it comes to submitting content and commenting. I know I have been one of the inactive ones in RoPics and RoMusic in the last few weeks which is the main reason I am stepping down. We need mods who are passionate about their respective subreddits and submit content on a daily basis. Active mods are the absolute most important thing a new subreddit needs to thrive... I should know, I've created dozens of them, and the ones that really take off are the ones that I promote heavily and pour my heart & soul into on a daily basis. The ones that I take a largely hands-off approach grow at a snail's pace.

I think we need to hash out a concrete election cycle instead of waiting for the existing mods to volunteer. I don't think anyone wants to be the first to volunteer because it is something new and scary, and no one knows what the results are going to be, or if anyone is even going to vote. The recent policy discussion and vote in RoAtheism didn't receive much attention and still does not have enough votes to reach a conclusion.

In short, I think we need to get some new contributors to every subreddit in the network or we are going to lose our momentum and stagnate. No one is going to subscribe to a subreddit that hasn't had a new submission in days. We have been designing this network to scale, but what works with 10,000 or even 100,000 users doesn't necessarily work with 1,000 users. There's no need for moderator elections if no one is interested in being a moderator in the first place. I'm very disappointed by the level of activity of a lot of the current mods across the board. Moderators should be the top contributors of any new subreddit, and sadly that currently is not the case. We need more subscribers, but above all we need more contributors.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 23 '12

Could the Republic prevent these kinds of problems? (Details inside)

0 Upvotes

I think that the Republic of Reddit Network is poised to increase in size. In fact, I think that a more diverse collection of networked subreddits might help increase the over all numbers across all the communities.

A couple of the subreddits I would like to see included here are r/RepublicofLGBTQ and r/RepublicOfScience.

The latter is what I would like to focus on.

Currently, r/Science is generally good at keeping the right kind of content on their front page so a Republic counter part would really only serve to allow users the option of selecting their mods and ensuring beyond a shadow of a doubt that sensationalism and memes don't hit the front page.

From what I see the biggest problem with r/Science is the comments. This post in r/TheoryofReddit will give you some more context on this issue. Of course, we all know that the Republic does very little to control the quality of comments, but the users (from what I've seen) are quick to downvote off topic comments in order to foster and promote more intelligent discussion.

If something like r/RepublicOfScience were brought into the Republic do you feel the user base alone would be able to curve the type of issues that persist in r/Science?

Would anyone be interested in eventually brining in a subreddit of this type?

Also, on a related note, does anyone know who controls /r/RepublicOfScience? When I go there it shows up as "forbidden."


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 13 '12

Voting Thread I

10 Upvotes

Deadline to have your vote counted: 11:59 PM UST, January 19th, 2012

Number of moderator positions: Five (5)

Eligible Candidates:

  1. syncretic

  2. kjoneslol

  3. davidreiss666

  4. SilvanestitheErudite

  5. news_and_coffee

Seeing as how there are five open positions, and only five approved submitters were nominated, I'm not really sure how to proceed at this point. We didn't address the possibility that there might not be more users nominated than there are open moderator spots. I'm going to satisfy the language in the charter and hold this vote open for the next seven days, but I think at this point it's safe to say that the users you see on the list above you will be the moderation staff in this subreddit for the next six months.

Note: There was a sixth user nominated, bananasncornbread, but that account has not been active for at least three months, and as such is not eligible to become an approved submitter here, nor a moderator.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 08 '11

Attempting to define the scope of /r/RoPolitics

10 Upvotes

Here is the current statement of purpose for /r/RepublicofPolitics:

"The Republic of Politics strives to encourage civil, rational political discussion. We adhere to strict voting reddiquette, please only downvote links that are inappropriate for the subreddit and comments that are overly aggressive or hateful. Editorialized political bias in headlines will be removed, a good rule of thumb is to use the headline of the article itself as your submission title, or a line from the opening paragraph of the article. Above all, please be civil here. All spheres of political thought are welcome, and diversity is encouraged."


Items for discussion:

- We need to update this so that the boundaries of 'inappropriate for the subreddit' are clear to everyone. I'm hoping we can outline some basic criteria that all submissions have to meet to be considered relevant.

- The part about using the headline of the article itself needs to be changed, since we've seen that some sources' own headlines actually violate our local rules.


Regarding relevance:

Our current strategy is to tackle this with another rule for titles that says titles have to themselves make the relevance of the content immediately obvious. This, combined with the 'proper source' and 'no editorializing' rules, makes it virtually impossible for an irrelevant submission to avoid being removed (given how hard it would be to fabricate a relevant title without breaking one of the other two rules).

So what we really need to do here is figure out what themes are going to be included in our subreddit. blackstar9000 suggested the following:

A reddit for links and discussion about the policies used in governance, at both the national and international level, and the relevance of political figures to those policies.

Personally, I agree that the overall emphasis should be on public policy, but I think that concept sits in the middle of a fairly large web. There are things which inform policy that I think we would want to include such as elections, actions by the courts, information about the legislators themselves, etc. I also think there are things we would want to exclude. For example, I don't think anybody cares what my downstairs neighbour puts up on his twitter page, even if he's expressing an opinion about public policy. But maybe I'm being presumptuous about that and the votes should be allowed to decide.

As always, none of this is written in stone. Your input and ideas are greatly appreciated.

-il


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 12 '11

Opinion piece on MSNBC concerning Reddit. Looks at the positive and negative of Reddit.

Thumbnail
technolog.msnbc.msn.com
53 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 09 '11

On the posting of Gawker network websites

27 Upvotes

Hey all, first post in the Republic. As someone who produces some of the content that will probably be eventually posted here, I'm excited to see where this concept ends up.

I've been thinking - does the posting of articles from Gawker network sites (like io9, Kotaku, Gizmodo) fit with the Republic's goal of having quality content? Gawker is known for having notoriously bad journalistic practices and ethics, and generally making the rest of us look bad.

Of course, I know that it's not only them who are at fault, but the entire journalistic profession is gaining a reputation for biased and incomplete coverage, even to the point where game developers such as Mojang are having to correct them publicly, even though the facts had been stated before.

I'd just like to note here that I'm not posting this because their articles get more hits than mine: I'm merely interested to hear users' thoughts on this.

To the mods: keep up the good work, guys, this project is looking great.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Nov 09 '11

Let's test our new vote system. I would like to make this subreddit discussion only, much like /r/TheoryOfReddit, except focused specifically on the Republic of Reddit. If you are an approved submitter, please vote (instructions inside)!

11 Upvotes

To clarify, if this vote passes, I will change this subreddit to self.posts only and it will no longer be possible to submit direct links. If you are an approved submitter, please vote like so:

[](/yes)
[](/no)
[](/abstain)

Your votes will show up like this:



Depending how this vote goes, I might propose giving approved submitters some sort of flair in the future so their votes can stand out (for instance if we have a problem with users who are not yet approved submitters trying to vote). We'll see.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 26 '12

Is it time to open more subreddits?

15 Upvotes

When we first started this project, the vague idea was to mimic the default subreddits, but with a few key twists - no rehosted images or image macros, approved submitters only, and democratic moderator elections. We currently have nine subreddits in the network; there are 20 default subreddits in total. Is it time to add some more subreddits to the network? If so, which ones?

These are the default subreddits that do not yet have a Republic counterpart:

Obviously some of them would not be a good fit (such as /r/AdviceAnimals and /r/aww). What of others such as /r/AskReddit, /r/Science, /r/bestof, etc? Do you think any of those could have a successful Republic counterpart at this time? If so, what rules would you implement to set them apart from their larger default cousins?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jul 29 '12

Republic of Reddit and joining.

15 Upvotes

I see that this sub reddit (and affiliates) in particular is very different is there a process to become part of the sub and to cast votes similar to citizenship or do I simply subscribe to become part of the community?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 13 '11

Anyone here use Twitter?

0 Upvotes

Surely I can't be the only one on Twitter. @stillgray


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Dec 26 '25

I propose that Reddit change their ban policy/formula.

0 Upvotes

Reddit bans for things like normal every day speech. Or mild insults like the use of the work fanboy. I propose we have an actual look at what people are getting banned for and revise it. It’s like the admins are some sort of sad losers sitting behind their computer screens, bored out of their minds. So they find some random person to annoy. Because there is little to no logic behind their banning.