r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 12 '11

Opinion piece on MSNBC concerning Reddit. Looks at the positive and negative of Reddit.

Thumbnail
technolog.msnbc.msn.com
53 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Dec 11 '11

Congratulations everyone, /r/RepublicOfReddit is Subreddit of the Day for December 11, 2011!

50 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 03 '11

The Open Beta has officially begun.

49 Upvotes

It's official, the open beta has begun. The Republic of Reddit is now open to all. If you want a multi-link to dive right in and subscribe, look here. For those not in the loop, think of it as a soft reset on reddit as a whole with a few new rules. It’s a network of subreddits to promote discussion, share articles, news, and other links on reddit, but without the other distractions. There is a collection bin for egos conveniently placed near the door.

In the Republic of Reddit every participant is responsible for the quality of the network; they also follow the republiquette, which our own modified version of the reddiquette. Participants vote to elect mods, remove mods, and make changes to republiquette when necessary. All discussions are held in public and the person who makes any modifications will publish the reason for the change. The Republic of Reddit is designed to provide as much transparency, honesty, and accountability as possible.

Reposts, memes, and drama are expected to be left behind. What will remain is a fairly moderated, cohesive network of subreddits; a network that attempts to emphasize the quality of reddit and minimize off-topic submissions and irrelevant conversation.

The Republic Network is a restricted series of subreddits, this means that all subreddits in the network are publicly available for viewing and commenting, but submissions can only be made by users who have been given approved submitter status. To be added as an approved submitter, an account only needs to be at least three months old, with a moderate level of activity (at least 100 link karma, or at least 30 comments with positive karma made in the subreddit within the last 90 days). That’s all it takes.

The Republic of Reddit, like most things, isn’t going to be everyone’s cup of tea. But if the idea seems a little interesting to you, please stop by and take a look at what we have so far.

More information can be had by looking over the charter and the republiquette. The charter goes in depth on how the Republic will function, as well as its statement of purpose.

If you have any further questions, feel free to ask!


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 03 '11

This is what r/RoR and its sister sites will look like.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
43 Upvotes

r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 03 '11

Local rules for /r/RoPolitics - official thread

42 Upvotes

Local rules of republiquette:

Submissions will be removed by the moderators if:

  • ... the title does not make it immediately and obviously clear that content of the submission is relevant to the subreddit (relevance rule);

  • ... the title attributes to some person a claim (either by direct quotation or paraphrase), unless the link is to the full, original source of that claim (proper source rule);

  • ... the title features descriptive terms, or issues claims, not made in the content of the linked-to article or media (editorial title rule);

  • ...the submission violates any section of the Republiquette (link to the right)

Moderator suggestions for a better subreddit:

  • DO post and up-vote articles that show both sides of a story/argument

  • DON'T post or up-vote 'hearsay' - a submission or comment that claims something about the views of a political figure without providing a quote or source to back it up

  • DON'T post or up-vote stories from Associated Press or Reuters that have been relayed via another news outlet - stick to the original source.

  • DO try to make your submission titles as accurate as possible, and don't up-vote submissions with technically-legal but still misleading titles. We propose the use of tags to indicate the kind of content you are posting:

           [news] for news
    
           [comment] for opinion/commentary
    
           [data] for neutral content that purports to be fact-based (polling data, research,
                   fact-checking, etc.)

Note: If your submission does not clearly fall into one of these three categories, simply leave it untagged.

  • DO make comments which contribute to an atmosphere of respectful, open discussion. To help maintain that standard, please down-vote comments that traffic in insults or other form of polemic, and up-vote comments which contribute positively to the discussion even if you disagree with the views expressed therein.

  • DON'T use your up- or down-votes as ideological statements of principle. Encourage high-quality content, and we'll have a high-quality subreddit.

This is an open thread and these rules/suggestions are not permanent or immutable. Suggestions for improving the subreddit are always welcome.


Edit 1: Added the 'relevance rule' to the list of grounds for submission removals. Discussed in this thread. We are currently in the process of trying to precisely define the scope of the subreddit and make explicit what things are and are not relevant thereto.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 14 '20

Greetings r/RepublicOfReddit, I am u/theghostecho of r/SimDemocracy giving greetings to anyone here who still wishes for a more democratic reddit

35 Upvotes

r/SimDemocracy was a community formed exactly one year ago that is founded on creating a more democratic reddit. We have become essentially an internet country and are currently seeking more communities like us to ally with. We’ve been through a lot this last year, but most recently discovered r/RepublicOfReddit. How exactly does did this work? Where did it go wrong? Can it be revived? So many questions.

I look forward to making potentially wnew friends and allies here.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 06 '11

Don't have anything to contribute, but would still like to help? Browse the new section and upvote new submissions.

35 Upvotes

I have seen several submissions get downvoted fairly quickly with no explanation. More than one of marquis_of_chaos' submissions to /r/RepublicOfNews were downvoted to negative karma, and I only saw them by checking the new queue. I suspect a few trolls are trying to give us a hard time.

Especially while these subreddits are still young and we are still in our open beta phase, please try to browse the network new queue whenever possible and upvote relevant submissions. Thanks!


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 16 '14

Is it safe to say the RepublicOfReddit subs weren't success?

33 Upvotes

It's been a couple of years since I eagerly joined the RepublicOf subreddits in anticipation of a better and more intelligent Reddit. But in that time all that seems to have happened is worse/more immature subreddits have reached default, bringing in an even more immature userbase.

Did everyone just move over to Hacker News, or have people just given up contributing much anymore?

There are still a few good subreddits with strong moderation teams (/r/askhistory for one). But ultimately it seems that areas such as news and gaming both of which had RepublicOf equivalents, just really didn't take off.

/r/republicofgaming - last updated 8 months ago, /r/republicofnews - seems to get updated once or twice a month. I think the only still active one is /r/republicofmusic which I am still subscribed to, but just doesn't seem to get enough discussion going, usually at most 1 or 2 comments and can sometimes go over a week between posts.

What could've worked differently? Was there a time this could've worked better, or was it doomed from the start?

At one point I tried to actively create my own subs that had heavy moderation, and tried to keep only higher quality content, and those too just never caught traction. I'd maybe get a few hundred people joining in protest as a "I quit this default subreddit as the content is too low", but they never contributed, and they never interacted with my own contributions when I was actively submitting to them.

Is there any hope of a system like this within Reddit, is there any alternate way to get a better quality Reddit experience? Or is it simply a job of "put up with the lower quality stuff" and unsubscribe to as many popular subs as possible?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Apr 10 '12

I hereby resign the office of Moderator of Republic of Pics.

33 Upvotes

I have not positively contributed to the Republic in many moons, and I feel that I have not been and am no longer fit nor deserve to serve as a moderator. Other commitments, both on reddit and "IRL" have led me to this decision. RoR is a great experiment that I hope to see succeed.

I have removed myself from moderator in RoPics and RoModeration, and posted in RoModeration accordingly.


Sidenote: the title is based upon Richard Nixon's resignation from President.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 20 '12

I have made a redditrequest for RepublicofLGBT.

33 Upvotes

The sub was nabbed by an inactive squatter throw away jerk face. Man I hate squatters. Anyway, if granted, I would like to immediately bring it into the network and hopefully put an end to mod drama within that community. r/ainbows is an established alternative to r/lgbt, I know, but I would still like to see the republic's charter be used to help their community.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Nov 20 '11

As per our recent vote, this subreddit will be self.posts only from this day forward.

33 Upvotes

Ten days ago we held our first public test of our vote system. This isn't technically an amendment to either the charter or the republiquette; it is a change in the basic structure of this subreddit (moving from text & link submissions to text submissions only). However, it is similar, so I thought it would be a good way to test the system. As stated in the charter:

Before any proposed amendment can be made to the charter or republiquette, it must receive (1) votes from at least 5% of the submitters approved in each of the reddits currently affiliated with the Network, and (2) twice as many votes for as against.

Here are the totals:

  • 23

  • 01

  • 07

This vote needed at least 16 votes to be valid, which it has. It needed more than twice the number of yes votes than no votes, which it has. Unless there are any formal objections, I am going to declare this vote as passed. From today onward, the only types of submissions allowed in this subreddit are self.posts. Furthermore, the on-topic statement for this subreddit states:

For announcements and discussion concerning the Republic of Reddit network. Feel free to use this space to ask questions concerning the network, the charter, or the republiquette. If you have a question concerning a specific network reddit, consider asking it in that reddit first.

Please keep that in mind.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 03 '11

Should we prohibit certain sources for being well-known for bias?

32 Upvotes

Alternet is the example that leaps to the forefront of my mind. It is no better than Fox News for liberals, spinning all its arguments and facts to pander to its base. If we want to keep a reasonable spirit of discussion, it's laughable to allow such biased sources of information dictate the premises of the conversation.

It would be difficult to create an exhaustive list of unacceptable sources, but is our only choice to allow this stuff to creep in?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 09 '12

How do you feel about a blackout regarding SOPA?

29 Upvotes

Many large subreddits will be blacking out to bring attention to SOPA. How would the Republic community feel about this? (It would need a vote to pass, probably)

A very well-said explanation of why this is happening:

It's not about who we're voting for, whether we're republicans, democrats, Christians or Atheists - it's about the sanctity of information and that passing SOPA puts a massive strain on our freedom of information.

~nix0n

More information about SOPA: http://www.reddit.com/r/SOPAprotest/comments/o8jca/a_list_of_subreddits_currently_participating_will/

http://www.reddit.com/help/faqs/sopa

EDIT: Okay, so it's clear that some of the commenters so far think that this would mainly be preaching to the choir, so to speak. Let me clarify a bit: the point of the blackout is not so much for awareness as it is for activity. Most people are aware that such a bill exists, but maybe not fully cognizant of the repercussions; the blackout is meant to make these repercussions a reality, at least for a day. The RoR network would participate because we presumably value the freedom of information, something many say SOPA would limit. I'll leave the comments open for another day or two, then bring it to a vote once the comments wind down.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 06 '12

r/Anarchism made their mod log public. Is that something the Republic of Reddit Network should consider?

29 Upvotes

So this website was brought to my attention and it made me curious as to whether or not making our mod log public in a similar manner as /r/Anarchism.

Is this even feasible? Would it be beneficial. It seems to be in line with RoR principles. What does everyone think?

[Edit] Link not working? Try this: http://transparency.dbzer0.com/modlog/anarchism/


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 21 '12

Status of bots like autotldr

28 Upvotes

I've seen recent summary comments made by the autotldr bot receive multiple reports in a few Republic subreddits. I don't think it breaks any existing rules, but it is clearly an unwelcome influence on the community.

Are bots like this, and bots in general, welcome in the Republic network?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 09 '11

On the posting of Gawker network websites

27 Upvotes

Hey all, first post in the Republic. As someone who produces some of the content that will probably be eventually posted here, I'm excited to see where this concept ends up.

I've been thinking - does the posting of articles from Gawker network sites (like io9, Kotaku, Gizmodo) fit with the Republic's goal of having quality content? Gawker is known for having notoriously bad journalistic practices and ethics, and generally making the rest of us look bad.

Of course, I know that it's not only them who are at fault, but the entire journalistic profession is gaining a reputation for biased and incomplete coverage, even to the point where game developers such as Mojang are having to correct them publicly, even though the facts had been stated before.

I'd just like to note here that I'm not posting this because their articles get more hits than mine: I'm merely interested to hear users' thoughts on this.

To the mods: keep up the good work, guys, this project is looking great.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 05 '11

I will be stepping down as moderator of RoGaming

27 Upvotes

Nothing serious, I just realize I don't have the time during the day to dedicate myself properly to something that needs a careful eye. As much as I would like to help and participate, I find myself with less and less time to use reddit. As such, I will be stepping down. Thank you for the opportunity and if I find myself with nothing to do in the future, I will probably reapply once moderators get cycled.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 09 '12

The Republic of Science is now available and looking for new users, submitters, and subscribers

26 Upvotes

For many months the Republic of Science has been set to private. Thanks to BottleCap42 it is now available and we are attempting to affiliate with the Republic in just under a month from now.

Since the open beta of the Republic of Reddit Network I have seen several calls from users who were interested in a networked subreddit of this sort. So I would like to invite anyone interested in science news and information to subscribe and request approved submitter status.

I would also like the ask the RoReddit community if they have any ideas or suggestions for this subreddit.

What sort of posts would you like to see us encourage? What sort of posts would you like to see us avoid? Should we allow self posts? What advice do you have for the current mods establishing this community? Etc.

The Reddit science community over at r/science is very active and that subreddit is quite large. From my experience it is a good place for news, but it is plagued my some of the problems seen by other large and default subreddits--namely bias, sensationalism, and the users have no say in who mods the community or the rules they are subjected to. So I certainly think RoScience has a lot of potential and stands to be a place that gives users the ultimate say in things.

Thanks in advance for all your help and support.

-TRP


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Jan 26 '12

Republic of LGBTQ has been created, looking for input.

26 Upvotes

/r/RepublicOflLGBTQ

It's my first attempt to throw this much copy pasta at a stylsheet and sidebar, so I really hope it sticks.

If anyone has a free couple minutes and would like to double check my work, that would be pretty cool.

Also, if I made any grave errors in those three posts, please point them out so I don't look too foolish for too long.

Thanks kids!


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 22 '11

Where can we post general knowledge or memory hole articles in the RepublicOfReddit?

25 Upvotes

It's often very instructive to post old articles about things to show how views have changed, or to point out lies and contradictions in current discourse, or even just to highlight interesting information and analysis.

With its emphasis on new articles, I think that the Republic is missing out on a slew of material.

I'd like to see a Republic Reddit for informative articles without any time context. It would perhaps be like /r/wikipedia, but without any source requirements.

Maybe RepublicOfKnowledge or something?


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Oct 17 '13

It is difficult to see what this subreddit is about.

22 Upvotes

This is the main subreddit of the republic but whoever discovers it doesn't see what this subreddit is about. The content is hidden in the sidebar, the 'View the Entire Network' button has the same grey as everything else.

My suggestion: At least add a sticky post to the top with a link to the multi-reddit.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 27 '12

We are having a conversation in RoNews about the state of our subreddit 100 days after the public beta ended. I would like to invite anyone interested to weigh in.

22 Upvotes

You can find the Republic of News link here.

Please feel free to comment with your thoughts and suggestions.

Thanks!


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Feb 03 '12

Republic of Videos

22 Upvotes

Greetings once again, Republic of Reddit.

/r/RepublicOfVids has just reached its one month anniversary. As per the charter, I have sent a message to the Republic Of Moderation asking to be added to the Network, but I thought it would be good to also put some sort of announcement here, where everyone can see it.

So yeah.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Mar 05 '13

What is it you guys do here?

21 Upvotes

I came here from random. I feel like I just walked into a bunch of old people having tea together and talking about politics. So what is your goal as a subreddit? Are you competing against another party, your the republic but is there another group of subreddits who are the Communist? Is this sort of a simulation of society in the Internet?

Thanks for helping me learn in my quest for knowledge through reddit.


r/RepublicOfReddit • • Nov 21 '12

/r/RepublicOfMusic gains over 5,000 subscribers from a link in a top comment of a front-page thread in /r/Music. Could this attention help breathe new life into the Republic Network?

21 Upvotes

Here is the comment responsible for the bump in traffic. Here is the /r/TheoryOfReddit post discussing this topic, which includes traffic stats from the event. I believe this is the first time any Republic subreddit has received front-page attention.

Do you think this is a good thing? Could this attention help breathe new life into the Republic Network?