r/RWBYcritics • • 12h ago

DISCUSSION We replace Team RWBY with their Death Battle opponents. How far in the series do they get?

Post image
197 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 56m ago

DISCUSSION If RWBY returns to death Battle what matchup would you like to see most .

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION How has these two never met

Post image
439 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 14h ago

DISCUSSION What happened to them? Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

They never show up in the epilogue.


r/RWBYcritics • • 2h ago

DISCUSSION Let’s say there is as an AU where most of the series is the exact same, but Jaune is a civilian who Ruby befriends no time at beacon as a student. Maybe joins her after the fall maybe not. What kind of non huntsman job do you think he should have?

0 Upvotes

So yeah like I tried to put in the title. Jaune in this idea would be a civilian who Ruby befriends before the fall, what would you make his job be?

I think it’d be neat to have him working at a bakery she likes for cookies. Ruby comes to buy some cookies for herself for whatever Jaune is either manning the counter or helping load things.

Can have how he finds Ruby impressive, can be like a fan , and maybe share his dreams when they two get closer


r/RWBYcritics • • 14h ago

DISCUSSION What of the 14 Monster Hunter Weapons would the main cast use?

6 Upvotes

Between Charge Blade, Hunting Horn, Hammer, Dual Blades, Sword and Shield, Greatsword, Insect Glaive, Bow, Longsword, Light and Heavy Bowguns, Lance, Gunlance, and the Switch Axe, who would pick up what, in your opinions?


r/RWBYcritics • • 19h ago

COMMUNITY Cinder Fall's Magic Circle Glyphs

Post image
11 Upvotes

As a longtime fan of RWBY, I have been searching for the magic glyphs used by Cinder Fall in Volumes 1 and 2. Unfortunately, my efforts have not yielded any results.

Please, does anyone know who has access to these glyphs or know where I could obtain them? If they are not available to you, I would greatly appreciate it if you could put me in contact with someone who might have access to them, or perhaps the artist responsible for their creation.


r/RWBYcritics • • 18h ago

DISCUSSION Who would win?

8 Upvotes

Ghira

vs

Hazel


r/RWBYcritics • • 8h ago

DISCUSSION Other academies of similar "level" as the four Academies?

1 Upvotes

Okay, so we know that Ruby and Yang came from Signal Academy before entering Beacon. We know that Yang specifically graduated from Signal Academy. This implies that Beacon is of a higher level of education to Signal, a tertiary education equivalent with the latter being secondary.

When the Fall of Beacon happens, the books showed that teams like CFVY transferred to Shade to continue their education.

Am I correct in thinking that this means that Beacon (for Vale at any rate) is the only "tertiary" or "college" level education for huntsmen and huntresses? This means that there aren't any other schools of a similar level of education (if there were others, Beacon is just the prestigious/leading school if anything).

Now we know KoV here established the four academies in question. But none else ever popped up? How many huntsmen and huntresses can be produced by these academies?

It's a logistical thing, I know. But I've been thinking about it for a while now.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

COMMUNITY Genuine Question : WTF Happened to FNDM?!...

24 Upvotes

I can see why people give stories about how weirdly toxic the RWBY fandom is now. I didn't want to believe it after being a fan since the original V1 RWBY trailers and of Monty Oum's Dead Fantasy works...But as of recently, the recent interactions only proved the point of the stories I heard.

(I ended up leaving this as a comment on my original post for one of my only posts in r/RWBY and left it keep my peace...You can see the original post here)

The RWBY FNDM I remembered used to welcome theories, deep dives, rewrites, AUs, fanart, etc. Openly. From online spaces, to RTX, to Tumblr; things like this were so welcomed that people used to support fanmade comics, writings, and even D&D Campaigns that featured "What if" Scenarios...What in the world happened?...How do they expect to even gain and accept new fans who want to experience the show with this in mind?

Legit all I said in my post as a TLDR was: "I'm rewatching RWBY, I'd like Cinder to have more presence as a villain, here's how I would do it and make it flow better with the CURRENT STORY. RWBY has some iffy areas that need fixing, and a remake could help with some of it honestly."

And we have people chastising, berating, making it something it's not, and even getting angry and triggered (I guess?...) For me having an open opinion for a character that's not even in my top 5 characters if the series. This is actually insane...I never imagined RWBY's community would turn out like this.


r/RWBYcritics • • 23h ago

ART Maybe in another life, things would have been better... (@acclast)

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

SATIRE What if all of the characters in RWBY were just actors within the show itself?

Post image
106 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION How well would team rwby do if they were Nikkes?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

If I am being honest? They'd do exceptionally well especially if their skills carry over.

Ruby would be an Eylsion Nikke specializing in sniper fire and high speed.

Weiss would be a Missilis Nikke and would be one of the very high ranking families and probably apart of the VTC(if you know you know)

Blake would also be a missilis Nikke but she'd be related to the outer rim likely as an assassin

Yang would be a Tetra Nikke and would be the one of a small handful of hand to hand combat model Nikkes.

Now for those who know Nikke lore, would they be Fairytale/Grimms models? I believe so yes.

Nikke and RWBY share a lot in common and one day I wanna see a crossover with these two.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

ART Venus Adel comm fanart (by jindanjun000 on Twitter)

Post image
72 Upvotes

We finally have a mockup of what scrapped character Venus Adel would've looked like in the show proper!

Art: https://x.com/jindianjun000/status/2123820837933547844


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION What's your favorite weapon in the show? Here my list, personal favorite is Pyrrha's weapon. Spoiler

Post image
7 Upvotes

Pyrrha Nikos has the best weapons with versatility and flexibility, if she got Maiden powers it would completely give advantages to magic.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION Cinder and the myth of agency

5 Upvotes

I know that agency has an extra meaning when discussing fictional characters in a story. If we just define agency as a fictional character's ability to make decisions that drive the plot, it looks like Cinder has a lot of agency. But if we dig deeper into more literal definitions of agency, that illusion of agency for Cinder quickly slips away very quickly.

First, let's start with an obvious fact: Cinder is a fictional character. This means she literally has no free will. All she has is the writers' agenda for her. Every evil and/or self-destructive decision these (mostly) men force this abused female character to make serves their stated agenda of manipulating the audience into hating her and wanting them to do every bad thing they plan to do to her. She is literally denied agency to make better, nuanced, or more believable choices by her 'gods' because that would conflict with the dark plan they have for her.

Another way to decide if a character has agency is to look at their life and see if they have safe access to other choices. This is why it bugs me when those who uncritically accept the way Cinder was written argue that she chose to kill her owners as if that's proof that she chose to be evil. Cinder is a character who has always been denied safe access to good choices, from the time she was being abused in the orphanage to her time with the abusive madam to her time with Salem. It makes me question how much of a choice she really had in joining Salem- something that the uncritical acceptors of Cinder's fate also insist was a choice when we don't even have that part of her backstory yet.

Did Cinder, like Arthur Watts and Hazel, come to Salem as a free and knowing adult with her own agenda? Or did Salem save a (possibly still teenage) Cinder from another bad, potentially deadly situation? Or is the truth somewhere in the middle? It's stated in the story that Salem chose Cinder, not the other way around. So her agency in joining Salem is very questionable. It's ironic that a woman with so little agency in life is associated with the crown of choice.

I think the reason why people struggle to see Cinder's lack of agency is because she causes suffering and as Miles said, she's so mean (never forget though, these dudes made her that way). She is a cruel, destructive abused slave with little to no access to healthy choices. I'm sure that even if the writers do choose to free her from Salem before having her slaughtered and tortured, they'll have her choose destruction and evil to cement her role as a hatesink and drive home their point that some abused women are bad and deserve to have their violent ends celebrated.

Honestly, I think Cinder should have been written to be either a redeemed antiheroine who finds a healthy life or as a tragic but lovable and nuanced villainess who dies and is mourned by the fandom. Either one of those paths would have been better, more on-theme, and less cruel than writing a woman who has been used and abused all her life as a hatesink who we are supposed to celebrate violence toward. The other thing that bothers me about the way Cinder is handled is that the demon queen who groomed her, exploited her, and turned her into a weapon against the world is likely to get a better ending than her despite having the higher kill count. That's my prediction for the end of RWBY.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

SATIRE V9 Episode 6 (Alternate scene)

36 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 21h ago

FANFICTION RWBY Multiverse reactions

0 Upvotes

Can anyone recommend me some RWBY reactions ficts it can be in FF.net Ao3 or Wattpad if it's not in English or is in a different language I'll translated and also no jaune centric no offense to anyone that likes jaune he's cool but seeing him as the main protagonist or main character irritates me alot I rather see other protagonist.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION RWBY Reacts To The RWBY Multiverse-Episode 143: RWBY Chibi Season 4 Episode 8 On YT

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION How would you make Team RWBY stronger?

Post image
32 Upvotes

For me personally I am of two opinions on this matter.

Option A: Maiden powers

Option B: Semblance evolution

Considering where we are in the story right now the first option seems the most likely but I know people aren't a fan of that idea(for some reason) so let's explore option B, semblance evolution and I'll be straight up here team RWBY would need a borderline ridiculous power jump to compete with the likes of Cinder whom I imagine has only gotten more powerful with the time they've all been gone.

Now what could or would a semblance evolution for each of them look like?

Ruby's semblance is based in speed and so an increase to her speed is the most straightforward method to making her stronger but in addition Ruby naturally has magic in the form of her silver eyes.

Now as to how those could be powered up? I feel like a Mangekyo sharingan type awakening of sorts would be the most logical method here and I know some people will hate that because apparently it's okay for RWBY to take inspiration from anime ONLY in certain circumstances.

That being said we've seen already that Ruby's eyes react to her emotions and we still haven't been explained how cinder lost an arm and eye from Ruby's first silver eyes blast.

So if I had to take a guess? The FULL power of a silver eyed warrior essentially allows them to weaponize the light coming out of their eyes.

Weiss is another fairly straightforward character to upgrade/power up. Her summons are her strongest asset in battle but the problem with them is that they take forever to summon and they don't provide much outside of cannon fodder or assistance as a 3rd party.

But what if she could combine the augmenting power of her glyphs and her summoning to create glyphs that provide herself and others more substantial buffs.

For example she could give herself Astral Nevermore wings, Arma gigas armor and then summon a swarm of small Queen lancers.

This would give Weiss more versatile moves with her summons and allow her to power herself and others up in more creative ways.

Then we have Blake who's entire semblance needs an overhaul or a power boost so significant it might a well change how her semblance works. Currently all she can do is what her clones take a hit for her. Useful but eventually your opponent is gonna start learning your patterns and you'll get cooked.

So what do I propose? Two options:

  1. Shadow Mimicry

  2. Shadow/darkness manipulation

The first option is the more likely and believable option based on how we know Blake's powers work. So instead of her shadow simply taking a hit, the shadow can directly mimic Blake's moves or she can bring someone else's shadow to life and have it fight on her behalf.

The second option would essentially give her Megumei's domain expansion allowing her darkness/shadow to consume a localized area and in that localized area you are trapped in a pitch black Hell and Blake is the devil that controls it. You could say the shadows are a manifestation of her negative emotions which she has A LOT of.

Lastly we have Yang and for her it's again very simple. Yangs power is often explosive and flashy however that doesn't exactly fit her semblances name now does it? It's called BURN not combust. So I think what Yang needs to learn how to do is allow that power she builds up to flow through her entire power and primarily through her fists.

The same way Adam used a sword as a conduit for his power, so to does Yang need to use her fists as a conduit for her power but don't let it explode. Let the power flow through you and funnel it directly into your opponent.

Additionally if Yang took up a little bit of martial arts/kung-fu(dragon style specifically) I think that would give her a HUGE leg up against characters like Mercury but that's mainly a personal preference as someone who loves martial arts/kung fu.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION How I’d make Rwby stronger

Post image
15 Upvotes

Semblance evolutions

Ruby already has deity eye powers

2 things for her

1 her semblance evolves to make her intangible when attacked but it consumes more aura and she needs to be tangible to counter attack

2 she can combine with her inner light to become a red and white dragon like the light brother

Weiss
Her glyphs make her an armor like Noelle from black clover

Blake
She gets her justice league shadow manipulation powers but can manipulate others shadows to attack them

Yang
She can conjure a phoenix from
Her hair that can heal damage she is given and heal others (reflecting her maternal behavior)

What you think?


r/RWBYcritics • • 20h ago

DISCUSSION How perfect do you think volume 10 is going to be?

0 Upvotes

I know there haven’t been any updates on it yet, but I’m just concerned about it. Cause truth is, RWBY had inspired me to make my own manga a long time ago.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

ANALYSIS [Rewatching RWBY] Saving Cinder.

Post image
18 Upvotes

After rewatching RWBY again, I can see why Cinder feels so OFF to me; aside from the overall poor writing of MANY characters, moments, and the insane amount of plot holes.

[DISCLAIMER**:** This is acting as both analysis AND a rewrite, I can't add multiple flairs unfortunately**.]**

I think she would've been a peak bully/rival choice throughout the Beacon story, rather than someone who's spiraled into being connected to a whole criminal mastermind and evil organization. RWBY during its early Volumes of 1 & 2 was really cashing in on that whole "Magical Warrior Academy" Kind of vibe; and where many shows, anime, and series that were out during that time, this would've been a classic refreshing take.

She could've even acted as a alternate point of bullying that Jaune could've related to and empathized with Ruby on after his own arc with Cardin.

...The dive into bullying might be a stretch, but I think it would've eventually paid off into showing Ruby's character growth in my opinion. Especially considering Weiss conflict. Even with that, could you imagine if Ruby was being challenged, rivaled, or even lost to Cinder in a battle, and from there, that's where Weiss actually steps in because she now can fully grasp what her actions looked like from a different point of view?!

Like...We could've even had their rivalry climax be the two of them (Ruby and Cinder) Actually meeting again for the 1v1s in Volume 3 for the tournament (Which I believe we were robbed of honestly) And it could've been the classic "Underdog MC Vs. The Rival Who Boasts Superiority"

[Naruto Uzumaki Vs. Neji Hyuga is a SOLID example]

But instead...We kind of have Cinder popping up on screen and being this "Silky smooth and definitely NOT threatening villain (Who Ozpin never had a personal student meeting with)" With a dash of "...Oh...I know I'm never in any classes or missions, but don't mind me~"

Mind you, we still don't really know what her motives are beyond her nothing burger of a backstory trailer—All we really know about her is "I'm evil and I want what I want." But somehow she has emotional battles sprinkled in there that's supposed to make her standout...I guess? Even then, we don't really get around as to why she is the way she is. Even Salem had a whole in-depth backstory that eventually pushed at least SOME substance in her being evil for evil sake.

I think it would've hit better if the Grimm Attack on Beacon during Volume 3 happened this way with Cinder in mind, follow me on this:

• Cinder's whole Rivalry & Bullying thing with RUBY in Volume 1-2

• Introducing us to her a whole and establishing her at times to have more presence for the story

• Volume 3 tournament arrives

• Ruby & Cinder fight

• The fight is either interrupted or Ruby wins (Because MC love, and giving that sense of her overcoming this struggle)

• Cinder's message is actually PRE-RECORDED as the attack begins to happen in the background (Mercury, Neo, and Emerald doing other things. But are suddenly missing.)

• Cinder is now missing too, which causes Ruby to run looking for her as the evacuation begins. She runs into Mercury and THEN they have their hallway 1v1.

• We DON'T kill Penny; considering that Penny was going to die in the later volume anyways. Making her reappearance in Atlas and the whole self-destruction to human death hold WAY more impact. [It'll also hold more impact when we have gone volumes without seeing her and then she pops up as the protector of Mantle way later]

• All the citizens see are Grimm + The White Fang (Which opens up doors to people thinking that the White Fang were behind the attack...Leading into more plot for the lost Faunus substance and Blake's connection. In then, thickening the plot more for later.)

• We let Torchwick and Neo do their thing but don't just randomly die there. Their plans are successful as Beacon falls and Torchwick is released from his prison alongside Neo—REMEMBER THIS.

• Cinder storms the tower to fight Ozpin and Pyrrah like before but she's in disguise and anonymous. (A WAY more convincing disguise than what we saw with her masquerade outfit...Something that's anonymous to both the characters AND the audience.)

• Pyrrah fights and dies because this "Anonymous figure" Uses maiden powers for the first time in the series...Which overpowers Pyrrah (And Ozpin respectively)

• Ruby arrives and sees the death and activates Silver Eyes like normal, but the main question now running through everyone's head is "Who killed Pyrrah?"

• As everyone splits apart, scatters across the world, and leaves Beacon, the "Anonymous figure" Who killed Pyrrah is nowhere to be seen. (Giving Jaune a purpose to become centered on finding the culprit and swearing a vow to Pyrrah that he'll avenge her...More plot thickening.)

• Later when we finally see Salem and her subordinates; we see everyone like normal, but we see Torchwick and Neo there now too. And then as the camera pans, we suddenly see Cinder, Mercury, and Emerald there too...But Cinder has injuries (Of course, from the Silver Eyes and/or the Pyrrah fight).

+ Adam & The White Fang Luitenant will also be at the table*; which better gives light to the grasp of what Salem has done and how she's pulling strings in all direction from everywhere slowly. (Plus, it would make sense considering how Cinder eventually got him to round up the White Fang to help with the attack on Beacon to begin with)*

+ This will also help with Adam's proper rewrite and development in the same sitting; as his hand is forced into being a part of this group (Like we know) And we can see him questioning a lot as to what he's fighting for. (THUS, inserting his backstory and trailer around this time too. Which will help give substance as to what he's going through.) And this might even give us some quips and maybe even tension between him and Mercury. They both joined with Salem & Cinder simply trying to survive...But have different ideologies. [We'll save Adam for another time though.]

• This NOW pushes the audience to go "Wait...Why tf is Cinder and the other two there?! Was she kidnapped? Was she evil the whole time?" Which allows the audience to theorize and put things together for a while but leaving it up to theory for a while.

• NOW we introduce her backstory; and sprinkle within it, that she was the one behind Beacon's attack. (And because her backstory was still so iffy...We now include that Salem manipulated her while she was young and full of rage, to follow her and to carry out this mission for when the time came to introduce her to Beacon inside of the backstory for better added substance)

• BUT IMPORTANT NOTE; We still don't spoon-feed that she was the one who killed Pyrrah. (Which in turn, allows RWBY to have more longevity as a series and more motivation for Jaune)

• AND THEN, they all meet in Mistral again; like how Volume 5 originally plays out. Only now, Team RWBY is questioning what Cinder and her team are doing there rather than immediately being angry and fighting.

• This is where it's revealed to Team RWBY that Cinder was behind it all...And then after connecting dots, they all collectively find out that Cinder killed Pyrrah. Which allows Jaune to go crazy like the original volume.

• And this will snag questions out of Ruby—Not asking Emerald like in the original, but instead asking CINDER the questions of "Why are you doing this?! And why work for Salem?" As she helps defend Jaune.

• This holds more weight because Ruby is confronting her again, and now paired with Jaune (Who as you remember, empathized with Ruby to overcome her issues with Cinder)...But rather than a supervised tournament fight, it becomes a more deadly fight to the death as Huntresses...Which Ruby wasn't fully prepared for.

• Silver Eyes happen again, this of course causes Cinder to feel the effects like before; but instead of her getting her mask chipped, this is where Jaune instead slashes her eye, which will hold more weight to the eye covers she has later. (Ruby took her atm at Beacon, Jaune took her eye in Mistral)

• Salem intervenes like normal, and the villains get away.

• NOW Cinder is injured from the two students she despised during her time at Beacon. And as she begins to heal, get Salem's Grimm prosthetics and all that...Now her pride becomes her motivation to stay with Salem (On top of the manipulation that we sprinkled into her backstory). Especially after facing off against her in the tournament.

• NOW Cinder's ideology turns into: "I don't care about winning or how I do it...I just need Ruby to lose." Which now provides substance to why Cinder is so dead set on Ruby in later volumes like normal. This now gives her more motivation to thirst for more power like the Cinder we all know, and for Salem to capitalize on way more. Which explains why Cinder still chooses to be with Salem...But now gives substance as to why she acts recklessly and does things her own way, and against Salem's initial orders sometimes (Like how we know her to do).

+ Remember when I said Neo and Torchwick were at Salem's table? Well, with Cinder losing the fight against Raven because she let her pride get the better of her...Salem now orders Neo to find Cinder, because her recklessness put the organization at risk and danger; and it could be seen as treachery or a sense of betrayal by others, Neo including.

• So when she's wandering the world after losing her fight with Raven at the vault, her priority is finding Ruby in her weakened state...Showing how obsessed she is at becoming more powerful.

• Enter the Neo fight at the bar; Dialogue and fight happens like normal...Even with Cinder confused as to why Neo's fighting her like normal. But now it's because Neo believes that Cinder had betrayed them in a way...Which will now give better substance to when she fights Neo in the bar and says "We need to find Ruby. We both want that girl dead." And Neo eventually complies like in the original volume.

+ And because of Neo's mysterious undying loyalty to Torchwick...She is a bit manipulated by Cinder by saying something along the lines of "Ruby was the one who put Torchwick behind bars to begin with...Had it not been for me, he would've been dead at Beacon. With Ruby still out there, you risk him being sent back with a life sentence or worse..."

+ Which now allows Neo, to now act a bit under Cinder's personal orders a bit more like we've seen. Simply because she values Torchwick that much and doesn't want to risk anything happening to him. Which now gives us a proper contrast of....Adam joining Salem for the White Fang & Neo joining Cinder for Torchwick (Behind Salem's back of course, in classic Cinder fashion.)

AND NOW...Cinder is saved and given proper inclusion into RWBY (And Ruby's story with her) As a whole. And the rest of the story can continue as normal with Cinder doing classic Cinder-y shenanigans. (...And as far as Torchwick's Death and the others plot points go with the villains, I'd leave that up to your guys' imagination and interpretations. This is mainly just focusing on Cinder.)

...Please, give us a RWBY remake already.


r/RWBYcritics • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION How to make Raven less stupid like Cinder, more logical and rational Bandit Queen. Spoiler

Post image
40 Upvotes

Haven academy lacked any securities like Atlas & Beacon There were no freaking security cameras or guardians underneath vault areas. Raven simply can access the vault of spring Maiden easily, flee without anymore notice like she's literally bird has this ability for escape. Bury the relic underneath Tai's house, or put somewhere else that nobody knows.

Nobody will know the real Maiden also.