r/RWBY • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION Rewatching RWBY: How to Save Cinder (+ Other Villain Plots)

Post image

After rewatching RWBY again, I can see why Cinder feels so OFF to me; aside from the overall poor writing of MANY characters, moments, and the insane amount of plot holes. I can tell she has a lot of potential but she's done so...Loosely in a way. But I REALLY want her to shine as who she was for the story.

As I dove deeper into my creative writing studies, I dove deeper into her and the other villains and come across different aspects and angles that would make her feel more like a puzzle piece to the story rather than kind of...Forcing her on screen in a way. This is with a grain of salte—BUT A GOOD GRAIN OF SALT OFF OF THE LOVE OF THE CHARACTER. PUT DOWN THE PITCHFORKS AND TORCHES .

The more I looked into it; I think she would've been a peak bully/rival choice throughout the Beacon story, rather than someone who's spiraled into being connected to a whole criminal mastermind and evil organization. RWBY during its early Volumes of 1 & 2 was really cashing in on that whole "Magical Warrior Academy" Kind of vibe; and where many shows, anime, and series that were out during that time, this would've been a classic refreshing take.

She could've even acted as a alternate point of bullying that Jaune could've related to and empathized with Ruby on after his own arc with Cardin.

...The dive into bullying might be a stretch, but I think it would've eventually paid off into showing Ruby's character growth in my opinion. Especially considering Weiss conflict. Even with that, could you imagine if Ruby was being challenged, rivaled, or even lost to Cinder in a battle, and from there, that's where Weiss actually steps in because she now can fully grasp what her actions looked like from a different point of view?!

Like...We could've even had their rivalry climax be the two of them (Ruby and Cinder) Actually meeting again for the 1v1s in Volume 3 for the tournament (Which I believe we were robbed of honestly) And it could've been the classic "Underdog MC Vs. The Rival Who Boasts Superiority"

[Naruto Uzumaki Vs. Neji Hyuga is a SOLID example]

But instead...We kind of have Cinder popping up on screen and being this "Silky smooth and definitely NOT threatening villain (Who Ozpin never had a personal student meeting with)" With a dash of "...Oh...I know I'm never in any classes or missions, but don't mind me~"

Mind you, we still don't really know what her motives are beyond her nothing burger of a backstory trailer—All we really know about her is "I'm evil and I want what I want." But somehow she has emotional battles sprinkled in there that's supposed to make her standout...I guess? Even then, we don't really get around as to why she is the way she is. Even Salem had a whole in-depth backstory that eventually pushed at least SOME substance in her being evil for evil sake.

I think it would've hit better if the Grimm Attack on Beacon during Volume 3 happened this way with Cinder in mind, follow me on this:

• Cinder's whole Rivalry & Bullying thing with RUBY in Volume 1-2

• Introducing us to her a whole and establishing her at times to have more presence for the story

• Volume 3 tournament arrives

• Ruby & Cinder fight during the tournament

• The fight is either interrupted or Ruby wins (Because MC love, and giving that sense of her overcoming this struggle)

• Cinder's message is actually PRE-RECORDED as the attack begins to happen in the background (Mercury, Neo, and Emerald doing other things. But are suddenly missing.)

• Cinder is now missing too, which causes Ruby to run looking for her as the evacuation begins. She runs into Mercury and THEN they have their hallway 1v1.

• We DON'T kill Penny; considering that Penny was going to die in the later volume anyways. Making her reappearance in Atlas and the whole self-destruction to human death hold WAY more impact. [It'll also hold more impact when we have gone volumes without seeing her and then she pops up as the protector of Mantle way later]

• All the citizens see are Grimm + The White Fang (Which opens up doors to people thinking that the White Fang were behind the attack...Leading into more plot for the lost Faunus substance and Blake's connection. In then, thickening the plot more for later.)

• We let Torchwick and Neo do their thing but don't just randomly die there. Their plans are successful as Beacon falls and Torchwick is released from his prison alongside Neo—REMEMBER THIS.

• Cinder storms the tower to fight Ozpin and Pyrrah like before but she's in disguise and anonymous. (A WAY more convincing disguise than what we saw with her masquerade outfit...Something that's anonymous to both the characters AND the audience.)

• Pyrrah fights and dies because this "Anonymous figure" Uses maiden powers for the first time in the series...Which overpowers Pyrrah (And Ozpin respectively)

• Ruby arrives and sees the death and activates Silver Eyes like normal, but the main question now running through everyone's head is "Who killed Pyrrah?"

• As everyone splits apart, scatters across the world, and leaves Beacon, the "Anonymous figure" Who killed Pyrrah is nowhere to be seen. (Giving Jaune a purpose to become centered on finding the culprit and swearing a vow to Pyrrah that he'll avenge her...More plot thickening.)

• Later when we finally see Salem and her subordinates; we see everyone like normal, but we see Torchwick and Neo there now too. And then as the camera pans, we suddenly see Cinder, Mercury, and Emerald there too...But Cinder has injuries (Of course, from the Silver Eyes and/or the Pyrrah fight).

+ Adam & The White Fang Luitenant will also be at the table; which better gives light to the grasp of what Salem has done and how she's pulling strings in all direction from everywhere slowly. (Plus, it would make sense considering how Cinder eventually got him to round up the White Fang to help with the attack on Beacon to begin with)

+ This will also help with Adam's proper rewrite and development in the same sitting; as his hand is forced into being a part of this group (Like we know) And we can see him questioning a lot as to what he's fighting for. (THUS, inserting his backstory and trailer around this time too. Which will help give substance as to what he's going through.) And this might even give us some quips and maybe even tension between him and Mercury. They both joined with Salem & Cinder simply trying to survive...But have different ideologies. [We'll save Adam for another time though.]

• This NOW pushes the audience to go "Wait...Why tf is Cinder and the other two there?! Was she kidnapped? Was she evil the whole time?" Which allows the audience to theorize and put things together for a while but leaving it up to theory for a while.

• NOW we introduce her backstory; and sprinkle within it, that she was the one behind Beacon's attack. (And because her backstory was still so iffy...We now include that Salem manipulated her while she was young and full of rage, to follow her and to carry out this mission for when the time came to introduce her to Beacon inside of the backstory for better added substance)

• BUT IMPORTANT NOTE; We still don't spoon-feed that she was the one who killed Pyrrah. (Which in turn, allows RWBY to have more longevity as a series and more motivation for Jaune)

• AND THEN, they all meet in Mistral again; like how Volume 5 originally plays out. Only now, Team RWBY is questioning what Cinder and her team are doing there rather than immediately being angry and fighting.

• This is where it's revealed to Team RWBY that Cinder was behind it all...And then after connecting dots, they all collectively find out that Cinder killed Pyrrah. Which allows Jaune to go crazy like the original volume.

• And this will snag questions out of Ruby—Not asking Emerald like in the original, but instead asking CINDER the questions of "Why are you doing this?! And why work for Salem?" As she helps defend Jaune.

• This holds more weight because Ruby is confronting her again, and now paired with Jaune (Who as you remember, empathized with Ruby to overcome her issues with Cinder)...But rather than a supervised tournament fight, it becomes a more deadly fight to the death as Huntresses...Which Ruby wasn't fully prepared for.

• Silver Eyes happen again, this of course causes Cinder to feel the effects like before; but instead of her getting her mask chipped, this is where Jaune instead slashes her eye, which will hold more weight to the eye covers she has later. (Ruby took her atm at Beacon, Jaune took her eye in Mistral)

• Salem intervenes like normal, and the villains get away.

• NOW Cinder is injured from the two students she despised during her time at Beacon. And as she begins to heal, get Salem's Grimm prosthetics and all that...Now her pride becomes her motivation to stay with Salem (On top of the manipulation that we sprinkled into her backstory). Especially after facing off against her in the tournament.

• NOW Cinder's ideology turns into: "I don't care about winning or how I do it...I just need Ruby to lose." Which now provides substance to why Cinder is so dead set on Ruby in later volumes like normal. This now gives her more motivation to thirst for more power like the Cinder we all know, and for Salem to capitalize on way more. Which explains why Cinder still chooses to be with Salem...But now gives substance as to why she acts recklessly and does things her own way, and against Salem's initial orders sometimes (Like how we know her to do).

+ Remember when I said Neo and Torchwick were at Salem's table? Well, with Cinder losing the fight against Raven because she let her pride get the better of her...Salem now orders Neo to find Cinder, because her recklessness put the organization at risk and danger; and it could be seen as treachery or a sense of betrayal by others, Neo including.

• So when she's wandering the world after losing her fight with Raven at the vault, her priority is finding Ruby in her weakened state...Showing how obsessed she is at becoming more powerful.

• Enter the Neo fight at the bar; Dialogue and fight happens like normal...Even with Cinder confused as to why Neo's fighting her like normal. But now it's because Neo believes that Cinder had betrayed them in a way...Which will now give better substance to when she fights Neo in the bar and says "We need to find Ruby. We both want that girl dead." And Neo eventually complies like in the original volume.

+ And because of Neo's mysterious undying loyalty to Torchwick...She is a bit manipulated by Cinder by saying something along the lines of "Ruby was the one who put Torchwick behind bars to begin with...Had it not been for me, he would've been dead at Beacon. With Ruby still out there, you risk him being sent back with a life sentence or worse..."

*+ Which now allows Neo, to now act a bit under Cinder's personal orders a bit more like we've seen. Simply because she values Torchwick that much and doesn't want to risk anything happening to him. Which now gives us a proper contrast of....*Adam joining Salem for the White Fang & Neo joining Cinder for Torchwick (Behind Salem's back of course, in classic Cinder fashion.)

AND NOW...Cinder is saved and given proper inclusion into RWBY (And Ruby's story with her) As a whole. And the rest of the story can continue as normal with Cinder doing classic Cinder-y shenanigans. (...And as far as Torchwick's Death and the others plot points go with the villains, I'd leave that up to your guys' imagination and interpretations. This is mainly just focusing on Cinder.)

...Please, give us a RWBY remake already.

11 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

8

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku 1d ago

My two cents, I’m okay with Cinder getting a comeuppance and perishing, but it do believe it should be handled with protagonists who act as a proper foil and understand why people like Cinder rise in the first place.

Ruby is supposed to be the best foil, but I feel like she hasn’t learned very much about how the world is both good and bad.

5

u/alguien99 1d ago

Ironically I feel like Jaune Is better set up as her nemesis than anyone in rwby.

2

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku 1d ago

That can work too.

4

u/Handro_Dilar "Promises, love and..." 1d ago

You could complement that by also going the other way and give Cinder chances to leave Salem and just live quietly to highlight the opposite that despite it all, she always had the choice to not ruin countless other lives for her own sake.

2

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku 1d ago

Hence, there are options. Cinder learned the wrong lessons from her mentor figures, but said mentors were certainly terrible.

While Ruby certainly had better mentors, they did not teach her how complex the world can be. Remnant is home to the elements that make great heroes who want to save the world, and villains who want it all to burn.

And Ruby really needs to understand the latter.

-4

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago

Which further proves my point as to why I think a RWBY remake as a whole would do the show justice.

Ruby being the one to overcome the odds and eventually defeat Cinder could be a very straightforward scope to the story and her aspect as the MC, but it's really rough to do that where she feels super disconnected. It's gotten to a point where Yang seems more like the leader of RWBY than her...Which eventually equates to Ruby feeling like the little sister of the team, rather than just to Yang.

I personally don't like Cinder, but I can see and understand from a writer perspective that she needs to have more. And in turn, more for Ruby to feed off of to eventually defeat.... Because frankly, I'd lose my mind if Ruby doesn't fight and end Cinder....And I swear if Cinder gets a random redemption or a Steven Universe-Styled "You can change. And start over!" Like how they randomly did with Emerald....Omg.

2

u/Crystal-Witchbloom ⠀"...was I supposed to tie that to something?" 1d ago edited 1d ago

They didn't "randomly" do it with Emerald; she started showing signs of regret towards the end of Volume 3, then the start of Volume 4. She's been questioning things ever since Volume 3, and wasn't even on the side of "evil" once Tyrian dropped the news bomb on her.

2

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago

...And yet she continued to fight without regret against Team RWBY during Volume 4-5, and even rushed to not only help fight with Cinder in Volume 8, But defended her when she was injured by Penny.

I'm not the first fan to mention this, not will I be the last.

3

u/Crystal-Witchbloom ⠀"...was I supposed to tie that to something?" 1d ago

Because that's what an abuse victim does before they break free. They defend their abuser.

It doesn't mean she was malicious, she was just fighting for who she thought was her only saving grace.

4

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku 1d ago

Yeah, Ruby is a flat protagonist and that’s okay. Sometimes, it’s okay to have a totally normal origin story with wholesomeness and hero stories.

However, this stands in contrast to her fellow teammates. Blake and discrimination, Weiss and emotional damage, Yang and abandonment issues. And in contrast to the antagonists. Mercury being the son of an assassin, the profession coming with significant implications; Emerald coming from poverty; Adam and corporate branding; and Cinder being a live-in slave to an anti-Faunus stepmother.

The world is not only the single slice Ruby has been raised on, it can be cruel as much as it is beautiful. But remember when she questioned Roman? She couldn’t comprehend why someone like Roman would do this, how someone like Roman could come to be.

I’m not asking for a jaded grimdark story, I am asking for Ruby to be confronted with the hard questions and face the reality Grimm are not the only threats. If people don’t have hope, they will turn to darker forces in despair.

6

u/Akumu_Oukoku ⠀The White Knight Lady 1d ago

So, after reading this.....

You wanna bend the entire story ass backward... for Cinder.

Cuz there's like... multiple important plots you just basicly ignored or shoved into the shredder that impact EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENS GOING FORWARD.

Like, I understand people who have a very unhealthy attachment to Cinder and who REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY wanna see her survive to the end and be some good guy out of nowhere... but come on. Come oooon.

She is the character of "Some people can't be saved". Which is a true-to-life thing. It's not just "Oh shes evil" - shes evil, and she's WILLFULLY doing so. She is a product of her own choices after freedom. She is a lesson of what NOT to be. Of whom NOT to be. of what NOT to do.

Like, let me be clear - if you wanna go off and make some wild AU - go for it. Clearly you've got a LOT of passion for this character, and clearly you want something other than what the canon narrative can give.....

But as far as a RWBY remake that caters to JUST Cinder for CINDER while eating away at ALL OTHER NARRATIVES? Nah. Nah fam. NAH. Like, I'm actively angry after having read all that. I gotta go for a walk now.

4

u/KurtTingles O what will she do, a soul bitten into with wrong? 1d ago

The best thing CRWBY could've done with Cinder is kill her off at the end of Volume 5 and pass the powers on to someone more interesting. The writers trying their hardest to make Cinder "sympathetic" and "misunderstood" in later volume flashbacks is just cringe.

3

u/Spider-Blood 1d ago

That’s what I think, while I can see why people would expect more from Cinder as a villain, I feel they’re expecting much or WANT too much. Especially since not every villain needs to be complex, have depth and such.

And if you think about it, being the product of her own choices are what makes her a perfect foil to our heroes

-4

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago

I like Cinder, but I'm not rewinding all of RWBY "Just" For Cinder. If anything it's making her plot relevant considering how often and consistent she is thrown into our faces inside of RWBY as a whole.

Frankly, Cinder isn't even in my Top 5 liked characters; but as far as characters who need more substance, a rework (Alongside a RWBY rewrite entirely, which I mentioned) or just some love to make them standout outside of face value...She's definitely one of them.

Velvet, Winter & Whitley, Adam, Sun and Penny are also up there in my prime candidate examples for who would be better to be rewritten for their impacts in the story—Like how I sprinkled in the bits about Penny and Adam (+The White Fang) In the initial post too.

So no. Nobody's "Rewriting all of RWBY and turning time backwards for Cinder." RWBY has flaws in it's writing, and for Cinder to be one of the main focuses, this is my take on how she could've been done better in early volumes alongside the other villains.

Calm down.

4

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

Ok, what if, cinder starts dating Jaune. Arcfurnace subreddit has a way better time explain the concept

3

u/Akumu_Oukoku ⠀The White Knight Lady 1d ago

"Go to Arcfurnance!"

With this guy!?

"I'd rather they commit suicide!" - he says.

I dunno what you guys are on about there, but that's not very nice, and it's not something people should be attracted to. And y'all don't stand up and stop em. So.... No..

Know the people in your group before you keep shilling it out.

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

Respect for your opinion, but if I had to play devils advocate for the tier list thing, I think it’s exaggeration and also it’s talking about the ship and not the literal characters.

4

u/Akumu_Oukoku ⠀The White Knight Lady 1d ago

Oh, hon... no... no he is not. I've been here a lot longer. No... he is absolutely being dead-ass right now. There's a reason folks feel a way about Knightfall. It's fine as an AU and if people wanna have fun with it - but that guy? nah. He's DEAD. ASS. SERIOUS.

2

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago

Funny how you didn't reply to the reply I made to your initial comment...But went on a rabbit hole about shipping rather than the initial caps-filled comment you made instead.

This was never about Jaune and Cinder shipping, nor Cinder praise. But I see that you have your priorities.

4

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

Also sorry… my comment was short and wasn’t supposed to take over the original subject.

3

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nah it's all good no worries; I was going to comment but then I saw the entirety of talking about ships and I left it be—That is NOT my territory, I haven't done shipping of characters since highschool in my hardcore fandom days.

But Akumu did a whole rant in another reply and then when I followed up with it, they went quiet and went onto the shipping talk instead like the initial portion never happened.

It's not aimed at you Jay, you're cool don't worry!

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

👍🏼

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

I think you got the wrong guy, I just checked and you haven’t commented on my comment at all.

4

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

fair enough.

I for one am simply an enjoyer of all the different ships. WhiteKnight, Lancaster, Dragonslayer, Knightfall, and whatever the rest are, I mainly read fanfics and enjoy seeing how people tend to make certain ships happen and the dynamics with them.

Enjoy your life and try not to die

3

u/BrrrrMang ⠀Fight for WhiteKnight Rights 1d ago

What in the world does that last sentence even mean? This is why you're not being convincing in part when you try to play off literally telling groups of people to kill themselves and worse yet its from the owner of the place you're advocating. Just stop already. You also don't need to advertise like this as well like Akumu said...

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

The try not to die thing, is supposed to be my version of good luck, Some people for some reason will take the “try NOT to die” and translate it to “I wish you die”

2

u/BrrrrMang ⠀Fight for WhiteKnight Rights 1d ago

Because it's weird and looks bad in the context of "this guy saying these people should kill themselves is just kidding!!!"

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

Sorry, it’s a thing that I say a lot to people, and is in no way supposed to be related to my first comment.

2

u/Akumu_Oukoku ⠀The White Knight Lady 1d ago

You're a good bean. Please keep loving what you love and spread that love : )

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

Thanks

3

u/its-chocolate 1d ago

>All the guys at the bottom

Of course

2

u/BrrrrMang ⠀Fight for WhiteKnight Rights 1d ago

Let me clarify as well that's the owner of the sub being advertised by JayCafe25 and yes they are quite rude on a consistent basis both on reddit and other places so yes that's why this matters as well.

3

u/Emperor_Luffy 1d ago

Good lord. I don't actually think they should kill themselves. lol. I'm exaggerating for comedic effect.

2

u/JayCafe25 1d ago

I knew it

-2

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku 1d ago

It’s simple really, Cinder is best girl.

3

u/BrrrrMang ⠀Fight for WhiteKnight Rights 1d ago

The perspectives we get on the villains in the early volumes help set the tone for several conflicts like the one between Emerald, Mercury, Cinder and Salem which become important later on. Just advocating for their removal so you can add some strange additional rivalry with Ruby and Cinder (that isn't really needed per se) doesn't seem as needed just for that reason alone. Plus, when its shown that she and the rest are at the table with Salem in V4 and beyond, it would become immediately obvious she was the one responsible for killing Pyrrha, etc. anyways...there isn't that sense of mystery you are claiming you would establish by doing so here.

On the topic of Roman and his early death, yes, it was a bit unfulfilling how he lost and died, but just making him another "crony" of Salem past that point never made sense. Mercury and Emerald follow Cinder to Salem because they have nowhere else to go, Roman and Neo have much more agency and I don't see them falling into line like that, as we saw from Roman in the early volumes. Or the books which explore him and Neo intensively. Hence why Neo even attacks Cinder later on. I think you're just replacing an unsatisfying ending with an even more unsatisfying continuation that results in more needless character bloat and also interferes potentially with how excellently V9 handles the topic of Roman and Neo at the end.

But let's return to Cinder. I again don't see the value of making Cinder "anonymous" (which, again, would make the main characters look stupid and the audience too from how obvious it is) in relation to Jaune since its the same beans either way whether he barely knows her as he does in canon or he does not. It sounds like, rather as well, that you would try to replace additionally the change Jaune undergoes in that fight with Weiss where he realizes the extent of his soul, unlocks his semblance and the path of him being someone that gives rather than takes in revenge is made clear as the one for him. You would be excluding this beat by ignoring it in favor of this and this would be harmful to Jaune quite severely overall frankly.

And I think this theme just saturates your post in general. The idea that RWBY has flaws is not a problem, but you claiming it absolutely needs a rewrite, it has gaping openings, etc. while blatantly not understanding the core purpose of several things that go on in canon or suggesting changes that interfere with plot points later make it clear you don't really have the perspective to be making these claims. And I think in general that's the fault of "fans" like you for instance the maker of FRWBY who "fix" one plotpoint just to sour two others, in effect doing a worse job than CRWBY ever did with RWBY.

Rather than criticize, you should try first to understand what RWBY was setting up at each point before you remove or edit as you try here...

2

u/VoidTorcher For the glory of Atlas, of course! 1d ago

It's often funny to see people complaining about "plot holes" that are mostly just failing/refusing to understand fairly simple plot and tropes, but I can't even see them being brought up here, aw.

1

u/Expert-Swan-1412 🌗Prince of the Eclipse 🌓 1d ago

I mean... you could have just used the original idea from Monty

0

u/B3ll172 1d ago

Hey, I can always appreciate a attempt being made to help the story. This would help Cinder and Ruby out. Since Ruby becomes more involved while helping to alleviate some plot holes.

Sadly, people tend to take your good intentions and yeah you have seen the comments. Try to ignore them. Unless, they do have constructive criticism.

Frankly for me, in my opinion, you would have to re-work all of RWBY from the start. The characters and story have potential. However, you need to go back to the very start of the show and than plan everything from there.

-1

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago edited 1d ago

I can see why people give stories about how weirdly toxic the RWBY fandom is now. I didn't want to believe it after being a fan since the original V1 RWBY trailers...But this only proved the point of the stories I heard.

The RWBY FNDM I remembered used to welcome theories, deep dives, rewrites, AUs, fanart, etc. Openly. From onlines spaces, to RTX, to Tumblr; things like this were so welcomed that people used to support fanmade comics, writings, and even D&D Campaigns that featured "What if" Scenarios...What in the world happened?...How do you all expect to even gain and accept new fans who want to experience the show with this in mind?

Legit all I said was "I'm rewatching RWBY, I'd like Cinder to have more presence as a villain, here's how I would do it and make it flow better with the CURRENT STORY. RWBY has some iffy areas that need fixing, and a remake could help with some of it honestly." And we have people chastising, berating, making it something it's not, and even getting angry and triggered (I guess?...) For me having an open opinion for a character that's not even in my top 5 characters of the series. This is actually insane.

3

u/Handro_Dilar "Promises, love and..." 1d ago edited 1d ago

Honestly, I think you'd get further by simply emphasising how you like the tropes and storytelling that you do rather than approach it with (what I percieve it to be) some aggression and trying to justify it by saying that it's better (bringing up the 'overall poor quality'). It's not about actually being right or wrong, it's more on a mindset where you justify your thoughts by highlighting why you enjoy then rather than base it on a supposedly objective quality.

Or to put it simply, whenever something like this comes up don't bring up the show's quality to (from how I read it) give yourself legitimacy, give yourself legitimacy by just talking about why you like what you're putting up.

Also personally, I roll my eyes when I see talk about a remake that (from what I can see) rather aggressively fixes things rather than celebrate it. I just don't think it's a particularly good mindset to approach a remake.

EDIT: Or to put it even more simply, it might be better to focus on "This is what I'd like and here's why" rather than "This is better"

1

u/TenshiAsakuraVT 1d ago

I hear you...The last thing I wanted this to come off as was overly aggressive or if anything, coming off as destructive to the show and it's entirety. The only reason I mention plot holes and a remake is because I would honestly just like to see more things flushed out beyond the original indie productions of RWBY; especially now that they have a much stronger studio in writing, animation assets, VAs, etc. I believe now RWBY has potential more than ever to iron out the wrinkles from before; maybe even animating the stuff from books and spin-offs!

I could imagine RWBY being something amazing with a remake with their resources...Allowing them to show and do more with what's presented and fill in gaps that some fans wish had more love. Like the full story of the White Fang for example. Hence why I said in both the post and reassurance of the replies in comments that "I'm not looking to rip it out by its roots, do it all over again, erase other character presence...All for Cinder—If anything this is depth for her being one of the main villains that I would think help her fit, all while giving everyone else of the MAIN cast their own respective depths on their arcs."

Some simple characters can do their thing and be as simple as they come without tons of complexity, like FNKI, Neptune, and Professor Port & Ooblek. But others, especially main characters (And the respective main villains like Salem) I would love to see synergize in the story and its entirety. Some characters can be taken as face value like Robyn. But for Cinder...I would've just liked more from the beginning—And I basically was saying "If I wanted a remake, here's what would be cool to flow with."

I love the show and always will, but critiquing early volumes and wanting to have a in-depth love to match the quality and depth of later volumes shouldn't be a problem. Regardless of how it's phrased—Thats the reason I personally say a remake would be nice; because it's clear that there's supposed to be much more going on in Remnant as a whole, but the focus feels off if we focus on V1-3 outside of the giant plot points (Like the Fall of Beacon, Roman + White Fang Rally, etc.). And I think the fans, like myself, as well as alot of the original old fans, would feel better with this in mind.

They were on the right track with Ice Queendom's debut (Debatable on some things to a certain extent...But at least I can see how they were trying, and that's good and refreshing to see for a polishing of early volumes!) And if anything, energy and passion from things like that is what I'm referring to for later iteration(s) For RWBY.