r/RWBYcritics • • Sep 01 '25

COMMUNITY I’m Disappointed in This Subs Community

Post image
53 Upvotes

I’m not one for callout posts or anything like that but this is something I need to say. This isn’t directed to the mods specifically though I would appreciate them reading this. This is mostly towards the community in general here.

Basically a user was talking about Catradora here as it was in reference to Bumbleby when the two were compared. They used a slur that’s been used against lesbians and I pointed out casually that hey please don’t use that word. It’s a slur that’s been used against me as a lesbian. Two things happened.

  1. The user never changed or edited their comment. They had posted other comments in other subreddits so it’s not like they weren’t around. They just didn’t care to change it.

  2. And this is important to me, all the downvotes I got when all I did was point out the person was using the slur. There were plenty of other comments in that post and yet not one other person tried to back me up as well. Thankfully at least one of the mods removed the comment after awhile but to say this is disheartening is an understatement.

This is starting to become a problem I’m seeing. It’s no longer just about not liking RWBY or the bees but it’s starting to reflect on values. And from what I can see it seems they’re members in the community that value getting mad over a ship over using a slur. And this is coming from someone who’s been part of this sub since Volume 8 and has had critiques with the bees.

I’m asking all of you to not become the stereotype that fans have of any RWBY critic. That all people who criticize the show are homophobic incels who just get mad over a ship. Because this kind of normalization affects lesbians like me in real life. And it makes this sub look like a cesspool of bigotry. And honestly it just makes me not want to post or come back to this sub. Why would I want to engage with any of you when this is how you treat someone for pointing out a slur is being used? And even if you’re one of those people who don’t consider it a slur it’s still considered in the dictionary a harmful derogatory word. And you’re okay with that? You’re okay with this? You’re okay with being the very thing the fandom accuses you of? Is that word how you see me? Even if it’s not everyone it’s enough of you to be disappointed and not feel welcomed.

I’m going to bed. I’ve said my peace.


r/RWBYcritics • • Jan 23 '25

The banning of twitter links and pictures

0 Upvotes

Greetings everyone, as i am sure many of you are aware, multiple subreddits have decided to disallow links to twitter for multiple reasons including the owner of twitter doing a Nazi salute twice on live television. We are also following the trend and doing the same, quite frankly, there is no reason not to.

Besides the above reason of the owner of the site doing a Nazi salute twice on live television (And a lot of other nonsense) our subreddit doesnt really lose anything by doing this. We already disallow linking of twitter posts due to brigading rules and quite frankly, most of the RWBY stans on twitter are clinically insane, so trying to even parse WTF they are thinking about (Like when they called Adam a rapist because he stabbed someones belly) is an useless venture. So taking pictures of their takes from twitter is just silly.

VIZ media also has its account on BlueSky so there should be no issues in regards to RWBY related news.


r/RWBYcritics • • Nov 11 '23

META The only correct RWBY character tier list

Post image
1 Upvotes

If you disagree with me, sorry to say, but you're objectively incorrect.


r/RWBYcritics • • Feb 25 '26

ANALYSIS Wait, RWBY is (literally) zionist?

12 Upvotes

Some background as to why I got here. Back in November, I decided to write a fanfic imagining how domestic life in Vacuo would be for Blake and Yang. Because it is a "sequel fic," I gave myself a rule: I cannot contradict anything said in the 116 episodes of RWBY that were released before it. Supplementary material can be freely retconned as I see fit.

Nevertheless, I started researching more about RWBY's lore, particularly around faunus, and that's when I found out about "the god of animals," and from there, I realized something. The show might want the faunus to be an allegory for black people, but they accidentally made it an allegory for Jewish people.

Here are the similarities: firstly, the Faunus occupy a place in Remnant where they are both a different race, but also a different religion. The same complicated space judaism ocupies on earth. Unlike most religions from West Africa (where most African slaves came from), which are mostly polytheistic (as in, they believe in multiple gods), the Faunus are monotheists (they believe in only one god, like Judaism)

So far, only conjecture, but that's when Menagerie comes into the picture. According to the lore of RWBY, Menagerie is the land that the God of Animals gave to the first Faunus... A promised land, if you will.

The parallels grow more interesting when you consider that the modern faunus government of Menagerie was established when humans gave the island to the faunus after the Great War as a reward for their participation in it. Just like the Allied powers established a Jewish state as compensation for the holocaust after World War II (although, if you know geopolitics, the real story is a bit different)

The parallels between the Faunus and the Jews are surprisingly uncanny. But a series having elements of Judaism doesn't make it Zionist. What makes it zionist is how the show depicts Menagerie in a good light.

Good people live there, moral people, the good Faunus. Unlike the bad faunus, who join the White Fang and cause problems all over Remnant. Ghira is a benevolent ruler who wants the best for his people. Menagerie itself might not be the permanent solution for Faunus, but it has a right to exist and to defend itself.

It's actually insane to realize that. However, because RWBY often (and badly) takes inspiration from the civil rights movement of the 20th century, I think this was accidental. I think most of the religious aspects of the Faunus can be traced back to one of the most infamous organizations that rose to prominence during that movement: The Nation of Islam (the organization Malcom X was a part of during his rise, although he was killed by members of the organization after leaving it). The Nation of Islam also believes in Black Supremacy, not unlike Corsac and Fennec in RWBY.

I think the religious angle in RWBY came from half-memories of The Nation of Islam. The show just wasn't ready for it to accidentally more resemble Judaism and Zionism.


r/RWBYcritics • • Feb 19 '26

FANFICTION Posting in hopes of someone in the future making a side-fanfic/add it to their story/fanfiction.

Post image
0 Upvotes

So, I had a thought. Zhongli from Genshin Impact is reborn into the world of RWBY — not as a god, but as a mortal man.

Zhongli was born and raised in the quiet village of Kuroyuri, the hometown of Lie Ren. In this new life, he lived as a hunter, a teacher, and a wise leader among his people. Calm, composed, and thoughtful beyond his years, he became a pillar of the village.

When he reached the age of 50, feeling the quiet pull of destiny, he chose to leave home and travel across Remnant.

During his journey, he encountered many—some hostile, others kind. It was not long before he awakened his Semblance: Geomancy, the ability to manipulate the very earth itself. Though insignificant compared to the divine power of his past life, in the world of Remnant, this power was overwhelming.

From the moment his Semblance awakened, his aging slowed dramatically. Aside from perhaps a single streak of white in his hair, his appearance remained unchanged. Even at 70 years old, he looked no different than he had decades prior.

Eventually, he felt it was time to return home.

On his journey back, the air trembled with a screech unlike any he had ever heard. It was a monstrous, centaur-like Grimm—an abomination destined to destroy Kuroyuri.

Zhongli arrived at the brink of catastrophe.

With calm authority, he commanded the earth itself. The Grimm’s attacks were blocked, repelled, or encased in towering walls of stone. Spears of rock impaled it. Sand and boulders crushed and restrained it. The battlefield bent to his will.

To end the beast that had already wrought havoc upon his home, Zhongli embedded it in layers upon layers of stone, sand, and earth—until nothing of it could be seen. Then, with merciless and indiscriminate force, he compressed the entire mass into itself, annihilating it completely. Silence followed.

Li Ren emerged from hiding, carrying his young son, Lie Ren. Staring at Zhongli in disbelief, he asked if it was truly him—the man who had not aged a day in twenty years. Zhongli had once been Ren’s master in combat and hunting.

One by one, the villagers stepped forward. They recognized him. They thanked him. They praised him for saving them.

But in that moment, Zhongli realized something painful—

None of his peers were still alive.
They had all fallen over the years, defending their home from the Grimm. As he quietly sipped from a flask of traditional wine, he murmured, "Osmanthus wine tastes the same as I remember… but where are those who share the memory?"

Zhongli accepted the role of village head and began rebuilding Kuroyuri with his Semblance. Under his guidance, the village grew stronger than before.

He took in several orphans left behind by Grimm attacks or other circumstances, becoming both guardian and master to them. Among those he adopted was Nora Valkyrie.

Powers : Semblance – Geomancer
A near-divine mastery over earth in all its forms—stone, sand, metal-rich soil, and tectonic force. He can shape, compress, elevate, and weaponize the terrain at will. But he his a man not of conquest or great ambition but come as more of a wise hermit.

Aura
His Aura reserve is immense, surpassing nearly every mortal in Remnant. However, this gift carries a cost: each time he draws deeply upon his overwhelming power, his lifespan shortens. The stronger the force he exerts, the closer death inches toward him.

Thus, his strength is both blessing and burden.

Side Note: Nora and the other orphans are aware of Zhongli’s condition and the burden his power places on his life. Refusing to accept the thought of losing the wise old man who rescued, raised, and trained them, they quietly search for a way to save him.

So, in the future I am hoping someone might use this or use something similar to their story.


r/RWBYcritics • • Jan 14 '24

META Yall can be kind of lame at times. Like Criticism is good but...

0 Upvotes

... yall taking screenshots of peoples' posts and then shitting on them and making memes out of people's twitter posts is kind of lame and shitty.

Like the one of Yang staring at Ruby drinking the tea.
I follow that person on twitter and they recently just watched through RWBY for the first time this month. Yet we have people acting like dicks and just going out of way to meme on them for just enjoying the show.

Makes you all look kind of lame. Reminds me of the meme of the guy yelling at people for having fun.

When did this reddit become a place to foster shit like that? Let people who aren't bothering anyone enjoy the show instead of making fun of them. Doing shit like that doesn't help the RWBY community grow and just makes us all look like assholes to outsiders.


r/RWBYcritics • • May 15 '25

ART Happy birthday to the best girl Weiss! I had nothing really new to post for her day but I then remembered I did a race swap of her! for fun ofc. Enjoy. (Sugarstrawb3rysunris3)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Apr 01 '23

MEMING Thank you CRWBY. I HATE HIM WITH PASSION NOW

4 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Apr 19 '23

MEMING Come on, He is terrible

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Feb 24 '25

DISCUSSION Hot take maybe, but if it wasn’t for her semblance the fight would have ended right here

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Apr 17 '26

REVIEW Fixing RWBY by Celtic Phoenix sucks.

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

I genuinely don't understand how people can say this series is better than the main show. There's so much flanderization, replaced many iconic moments with weaker payoffs, and don't get me started on how they really love to make characters too mean spirited to the point the story can only progress if there's drama involved every five seconds.

And not only that, there's so many scenes that are just... questionable. We did not need a hot springs to replace the coffee talk to see everyone naked, we did not need to make Yang an underage drunkard who doesn't help out her friends, we did not need Mercury to not care about if Emerald gonna get herself killed, we did not need to change Hazel's backstory to not make it about his dead sister but instead his brother magnus being a past Oz host from Vol 1-3, we did not need Shade D. Mann to have a one night stand with Raven just so they can have Vernal be their biological daughter, we did not need Blake stop the White Fang by committing extremism while being a hypocrite when bombing them, and we especially did not need to see Adam's mom to be taken advantage of their human landlord because he wants to introduce Faunus heat cycles for no reason and it doesn't even enhance the racism subplot or Adam's character it's just creepy, weird, and too out of place in world like RWBY.

The fat he wants to act like he's better than the people who worked on RWBY makes my stomach churn, his own ego and narcissism is just so annoying to see constantly, especially when he talks about RWBY, it's like he felt the need to insult like their animators because he doesn't like the way they're eating ramen in Volume 5, so he said their artists is better since they made it better visually. The problem isn't that it's different, the problem is that he wants to act like what he's making is superior than the original source material while shaming the people who worked on the show. He's so obnoxious it hurts.


r/RWBYcritics • • Sep 02 '24

ART A RWBY redraw. @Sugarstrawb3rysunris3 on Instagram and Twitter (me)

Post image
3 Upvotes

Did it for fun honestly. Plus I needed an excuse to draw my Yang.


r/RWBYcritics • • Aug 17 '22

ANALYSIS Power Scaling RWBY

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • May 30 '25

ANALYSIS Blacksun is also bad

3 Upvotes

I know this is probably going to ruffle a few feathers, given that Sun is pretty beloved on this sub, and there is a lot of general appreciation for Blacksun over Bumbleby as a great ship. Let's get this out of the way first: Bumbleby is fucking bad. It's a poorly developed romance that somehow feels both dragged out and rushed, does no favour for the characters involved, and seemingly ends up damaging their dynamics with virtually every single other character to push their connection. I don't think it "ruined the show" or "ruined Blake and Yang" (neither of those characters have been good since Volume 3), but it was certainly poorly handled.

Second of all, I would like to say that from Volumes 1-3, Blacksun was a potentially great developing romance that could've done very well for itself. Blake and Sun were strong characters back then, and their bond was something genuinely enjoyable to see.

That being said, I am left scratching my head when people bring up Blacksun as this perfect alternative that would've been great had it been developed from Volume 6 onwards. I've even heard it said plenty of times in this sub that the development of Blake during Volumes 4-5, and her relationship with Sun in those same Volumes is... good? I hate to be a contrarian, but that subplot and "development" is the worst part of the Volumes by far. At least for V4, given that V5 is terrible in so many ways.

Volume 4 marks the point of utter destruction for both Blake and Sun as characters, with the former turning into an unreasonable and abusive dickhead, and the latter being an obsessive little puppy who follows her around. Bumbleby strips away almost every single one of Blake's character traits as well as her relationship with other characters? Yes, that is true. And exactly the same can be said about Sun in Volumes 4-5.

Seriously, can someone name me a single noteworthy interaction that Sun has with anyone outside of Blake in V4-5? Can anyone name me a single new thing that we actually learn about Sun during this arc? Team SSSN have been snapped out of existence, so he gets nothing with any of them. He has basically no established dynamic with Adam or Ilia, the villains of the arc, despite the fact that they share multiple scenes together, and that Ilia very nearly killed him in their first encounter. I suppose Kali likes him while Ghira doesn't, which is something at the very least, but it's not exactly meaningful, is it? His character has become entire defined by his relationship with Blake.

Sun is so poorly developed during this section of the story that during the arc all about the Faunus, we don't even learn what Sun even wants for the Faunus! Whether he thinks there is a level of violence that is justified, what he thinks of Ghira's plan to protect Mantle, the innocent Faunus lives that will inevitably be lost, what he thinks of any of the crimes or injustices faced by the Faunus, even while confronting villains motivated by said atrocities.... we get nothing. The best we can infer about Sun's views on any of these issues is that he agrees with Blake on all of them, which... that just says it all, doesn't it?

Oh, and I've said all this without mentioning that Blake fucking physically abuses him. Let's set the record straight: If a scene comparable to Blake hitting Sun in the face three times in a row for such a small reason happened between her and Yang during their romance arc, it would be OVER. People would go ballistic, and you would never hear the fucking end of it. I know for a fact that this sub specifically would never shut up about it. It is a severe storytelling fuckup that ruins whatever was left of Blake's character, and is never addressed by the narrative with the severity that it deserves.

Bumbleby didn't ruin Blacksun, Blacksun ruined Blacksun. Or rather, the writers attempts to develop Blacksun ruined it, in exactly the same way as the writers attempts to develop Bumbleby ruined that ship. Did their romance have a lot of potential? Yes. Could it have been really well-written? Yes, but that goes for everything. We're not here to discuss stories that don't exist. You could rewrite Bumbleby to have it be really well-written. Theoretically, you could rewrite RWBY so that Professor Port is the greatest character yet created, but that's not a salient argument.

Blacksun is ass, and Bumbleby is ass. They share a lot of the same problems to the point where I don't know what I'd prefer over the other. On the one hand, Blacksun was better developed during the Volumes where these characters were actually good (1-3), but on the other hand, neither Blake nor Yang ever beat the shit out of the other for no good reason in a terrible scene that is never addressed again.

I understand that when a lot of people say they think that Blacksun would've been better, they mean a version of the relationship that continued to build on the strong foundations set by volumes 1-3. That's fine, I probably agree with you. Specifically, I'm adressing this to the people who say that the way their relationship developed during Volumes 4-5 was in any way good, and that Bumbleby undermined anything worthwhile when it started to develop (which if you ask me, was around Volume 6).

Blacksun is a victim of bad writing in the same way that Bumbleby is. The downfalls of both ships are entirely separate affairs that have little to do with one another beyond the fact that both have a lot of the same issues. Neither relationship is bad in concept; the issue is, as always, with the writing. Also, "Blacksun" is a fucking stupid name, and "Eclipse" is way better.

Tl;Dr: Both Blacksun and Bumbleby are bad, and neither is at fault for the other's failure. They were simply poorly handled, and share a lot of the same issues with each other. And Weiss is best girl.


r/RWBYcritics • • Mar 23 '25

DISCUSSION What if Yang and Blake gets Married?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Jan 20 '25

ART Blake redesign (by SomethingMid)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Made this in vroid studio. I didn't make the clothes. This is just a basic idea of how I would have designed Blake. I gave her Kali's skin tone and green eyes, because I like those changes and they further distinguish her from Cinder.


r/RWBYcritics • • Feb 10 '26

DISCUSSION Worshipping Ironwood

2 Upvotes

Why is everyone so desperate to put him on a pedestal and believe he's perfect? The guy can be at fault just like everyone else


r/RWBYcritics • • Aug 02 '26

MEMING Seriously r/RwbyCritics

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Oct 23 '24

DISCUSSION What if RWBY was rebooted as a gritty and edgy show?

6 Upvotes

Hypertheoretically, let's just say that VizMedia completely scraps everything and restarts RWBY as this darker and edgier show. What would be some changes made to fill that quota? I have a few ideas in mind that would be appealing to an older audience.

  • The characters would constantly drop cuss words every few sentences, especially Yang and Qrow.

  • Weiss would be a full-blown racist towards Blake and the faunus. Constantly dropping racial slurs while saying that "their kind" don't belong in the Academies.

  • The White Fang would be a completely unredeemable terrorist group, much more violent than what was shown in the show.

  • Team CRDL would be similar to Weiss where they are racists, and their teasing against Velvet would be full-on hate crimes.

  • Glynda would be shown having an affair with one of the students, and Ozpin would turn a blind eye to it.

  • Instead of coffee, Oobleck would be a cocaine addict trying to kick the habit.

  • Cardin would not only blackmail Jaune, but beat him to a bloody pulp when Jaune stands up to him. He would also cocere Pyrrha into fucking him just for the lulz.

  • Roman and the White Fang goons would rape Ruby when they had her captured.

  • The Fall of Beacon is much more gruesome and hard to watch. Students are ripped apart by Grimm while the White Fang opened fire on any human they saw.

  • Yang sleeps with every male in the academy and have to deal with slut-shaming as a consequence.

  • Winter and Qrow would meet up after their fight and partake in a hardcore sex scene as a make-up for it.


r/RWBYcritics • • Jun 01 '25

ART I'm sorry, I'm starting to like Bumblebee, what is happening to me?! Art by @y8ay8a

Post image
0 Upvotes

Calming down from my previous post, let's talk about Bumblebee.

I don't like how BB has been written in the series. But I do like the couple itself.
In fact, I like that it's canon. I just don't like the execution.

I think it makes sense. They've both supported each other. And they both make a cute couple.

I'd like them both to have children. How? They could go to the banks... you know. Or adopt children.
I feel like Yang would be the one who would get pregnant. I don't know, I feel like she's the one who would want the adventure of being a biological mother.

If you're wondering about the fan art, it's from Twitter so I can't share the link.

For those of you who are fans of the ship, I want you to write, how would you have liked this to be written?


r/RWBYcritics • • May 11 '24

MEMING This WhiteKnight shit needs to stop. 😡

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Sep 24 '24

DISCUSSION Probably one of the stupidest plot points/ideas is qrow with his semblance (image just as a reference)

Post image
0 Upvotes

His semblance is always active and causes misfortune. That is pretty neat idea. What isn't a neat idea id that he is a trained huntsmen and grown man yet he botches about his semblance like it's a curse he can't control. And yet if he stopped whining about it, he could realize that it is a very advantagous ability. If he simply learned to focus it, direct it, or even just let it loose and be extremely adaptable, he could be a monster with it. The image is an example of a similar power done correctly. Felicia Hardy can focus it to jam weapons, cause people to trip, miss attacks, hurt themselves, maybe cause footholds to giveaway. Any of these qrow can easily learn to use. But no he is constantly only seeing it as a curse that it only affects him


r/RWBYcritics • • Oct 29 '25

DISCUSSION Is it controversial to say volume 9 is the best volume after the fall of beacon?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • Mar 23 '26

DISCUSSION I don’t get the massive hate on CRWBY Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Well the title speaks for itself, I honestly don’t understand the extreme hate the writers get for the show. Every time I read a post criticizing the show it starts out being “Oh I get that.” And devolves into “That is the stupidest take I’ve read this week.” And it’s insane to me.

Like I see people hold Volumes 1-3 up as like a biblical text compared to Volumes 4-9. But 1-3 had a metric ton of flaws itself. I’m not saying RWBY is a top 10 anime of all time, or that CRWBY are a gift from god himself. But I feel like people forget they inherited a show with no direction after Volume 3, very little setup, very little background, and with the unfortunate passing of Monty. They really only could drop the show or try to continue it with their own direction, and it seems like people hate every decision they make. And that people criticize every part of it, it’s like nobody is happy when a new Volume of RWBY comes out, I wouldn’t be shocked if Volume 10 never releases from the sheer negativity from all over.

Hell compared to other anime’s, RWBY is really good. Hell compared to Sword Art Online’s few arcs (SAO-ALO-GGO), RWBY Volumes 1-6 (same runtime I think?) is way better, and I’ve rewatched SAO multiple times to try and justify it.

So just curious on why people hate the writers of a show that is trying their best to continue a show we all enjoy?