r/ProtonMail • • 16d ago Diamonds are Forever Thanks Helpful Bravo Heartwarming Popcorn

I’m a Proton employee and I'm breaking my silence

7.3k Upvotes

My name is Richard, and I'm a Staff Engineer at Proton, been with the company for many years now.

I’m posting because I’m sick of watching a company and the mission I’ve given years to be hurt by so many things which are out of context and simply not true. Most colleagues I know are very angry at the leakers, particularly after the latest leak.

A few examples.

The "perception vs truth" comment

This one keeps coming up, so here's the actual quote in context (unlike the leakers, I have permission to post this image):

This is not a discussion about code security. The context is that we did PQC better than Tuta, but because of the way we announced it, it looked like we did it worse, when we actually did it better.

"Proton monitors employees' AI code generation"

This is also a distortion. Proton has a tool that labels which code is AI-generated and which is human-written, which is important for many reasons. It can't be used to evaluate how much AI somebody is using. The design document for the tool states this clearly. This document is available to all employees:

The security point

The list goes on and on. Same with the security point. I have access to that chat. Andy never said don't do pen testing. It's true, he used shitty language and he personally apologized to the whole company. However in that same security chat he also said something 404 omitted: "The baseline is, we must do this plus be faster at the same time" in reference to security testing.

He agreed with the additional pen testing, and it was even recently implemented at Proton. What he didn't agree to was it slowing down the pipeline.

About hiring engineers

This quote “this is the last year that we hire engineers” is also out of context. At Proton, the engineering and product management roles are merging and we call this new discipline "Product Engineering". Proton also mostly hires product managers with engineering backgrounds. It means we stop hiring engineers who just code, and hire instead product engineers who also exercise product judgment that AI doesn’t have, not that we don’t hire engineers at all. I know this because I help with hiring for the whole company.

One last thing

I want to put a few words out there that aren't about quotes or screenshots, but about my experience.

To be honest to you, we're all in a bit of a shock after reading the articles written, and some of the criticism hurts me because it described a company I don't recognize. Reading the comments on Reddit hurts me because so many of them do not reflect reality. Proton is not rushing into AI without concern for safety, it is actually being done very carefully.

If you're deciding whether to keep using Proton, I'd just ask that you make that decision after getting the full picture, and not solely on the quotes that have been intentionally taken out of context. Otherwise, you are only hurting the workers that you claim to want to protect.

I'll be back in the comments later and will answer what I can. Just want to get this off my chest.


r/ProtonMail • • Aug 26 '26

Meme/Low Effort Frankfurt datacenter rn

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

/s


r/ProtonMail • • 17d ago Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

Discussion Proton’s CEO Cancels AI ‘Re-Interviews’

Thumbnail
404media.co
5.8k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago This Bravo

Feature Request Yen needs to step down

5.2k Upvotes

If he believes that pushing AI down engineers’ throats and sacrificing the quality/security of Proton’s products is worth it. Yen no longer should be in charge, or anyone else that shares his sentiments.


r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago This Bravo Heartwarming

Discussion Longtime user, extremely disappointed: A Goodbye to Proton

4.8k Upvotes

I haven’t had my coffee yet, so bear with me, or don’t.

Look, I get it. I went to business school, line go up > everything else. AI optimization, adapt or die, blah blah, etc.

Everyone wants to be the next tech bro billionaire, I’m sure you’re the same Andy, hell, in your position I’d probably be doing the same thing.

However, I’m not. You are, you are also missing the fundamental, core reason why so many of us use Proton in the first place. It’s because it’s are NOT a giant techbro company. I guess there’s a (clearly incorrect) assumption that a smaller, more streamlined company, will be laser focused on a quality product.

And I’m sure you’d say Proton IS a quality product, and that everything you do is to further that goal, but you’re fundamentally misunderstanding what your customers want. We don’t want another Google or Microsoft, we want a company that shares our ideals, and Proton was that for many of us, at least in some sense. The customer decides if a product is quality, not the CEO.

After reading about the latest “loser thinking bullshit” coming from the top, as well as how Yen responds here, it’s clear he’s completely lost the plot. If a senior technical employee recommends something, it’s appalling to see leadership dismiss it so disrespectfully.

I have worked for far too many smart, but shitty leaders who treated subordinates this way to continue supporting this loser. This is not leadership, not by a long shot. A classic case of a brilliant person being put in charge, and discovering they are completely unsuited to a leadership role. Unfortunately that person is always the last to find this out.

I’ve recommended Proton for years to privacy-focused customers and friends, but no longer. And after being a loyal customer for many years, I will not be renewing my subscription.

Andy, I’m sure you and your tech bro buddies will make a lot of money taking the company in this direction, but know you’ve forever lost the respect and trust of the customers that built it.

-An incredibly disappointed user.


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 23 '25 Heartwarming

Discussion Proton W

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago Regret Bravo Heartwarming Mindblown

Discussion Manifestos, Fear, and ‘Loser Thinking’: Inside Proton’s AI Reckoning

Thumbnail
404media.co
4.1k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 4d ago Bravo

Discussion Do not produce this on my desktop. Ever.

3.4k Upvotes

I pay for this service. Genuinely. Do not advertise to me if I am already a paying customer.

I will leave and find somewhere else if it happens again because this is extremely uncouth. Do better.

I got this "suggestion" in my desktop application despite having paid. If this happens? It is no better than free options anymore.


r/ProtonMail • • Dec 22 '25

Feature Request Google taught us what not to do

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

Yes, really https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/jr5wtk/are_you_sure_you_want_to_go_back_to_the_old/

You give the option to use something that's not a purple polygon in VPN. How about the rest?


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 25 '25

Discussion Proton Roasts Chrome On Twitter 😭

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Jun 26 '25 This

Discussion Pewdiepie recommended proton

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 21d ago

Discussion NYC Dept of Education bans Proton mail

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Have been dealing with my email being undelivered to staff of New York City school system. Apparently they’ve banned the use of Proton across the entire domain and have yet to confirm a reason.

edit: will attempt using pm.me domain as a workaround


r/ProtonMail • • Jun 08 '26

Discussion Can someone from ProtonMail clarify this matter, please?

Thumbnail gallery
2.3k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Jul 02 '26 WOW Bravo Mindblown

Lovebomb Proton team can into social media

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

Official Statement


r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago

Discussion The Proton Foundation needs to rein in a CEO who thinks prioritizing security is "loser thinking"

2.1k Upvotes

As the sole signatory of the non-profit foundation that ultimately controls Proton, Antonio Gambardella needs to step up and rein in a CEO who thinks prioritizing security over rushed AI code is "loser thinking." Swiss registry documents show Gambardella (who is also the director of the state-supported FONGIT incubator, which holds a stake in Proton and hosts the Foundation's offices) holds sole signing power over the Foundation, while Andy Yen has none. It's time for Gambardella to use his structural authority to protect the core mission.

EDIT: Also hope to see other Proton Foundation board members step up, particularly Sir Tim Berners-Lee (the inventor of the World Wide Web), and Dr. Carissa Véliz, who works at the University of Oxford's Institute for Ethics in AI.


r/ProtonMail • • May 20 '26 Obsessed WOW Wholesome Seal Heartwarming Bravo Popcorn

Discussion I’m the Product Manager on Proton Calendar, here’s what we’re working on and why it’s taking time

2.0k Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m the Product Manager working on Proton Calendar 👋

I wanted to jump in personally because I know Calendar is not where it needs to be today.

And I really do mean personally. I’m one of those slightly obsessive calendar people. My calendar is not just for meetings. It has errands, laundry days, reminders, tasks, focus blocks, etc.. because apparently I enjoy being managed by my past self.

So when Calendar is slow, buggy, missing search/offline/tasks, or generally makes it harder to plan your day, I feel that pain too.

The honest answer is that we are currently rebuilding Proton Calendar from the ground up across iOS, Android, and Web. This is our next-generation Calendar architecture, based on lessons from our previous Mail rewrite. The goal is to fix the foundational shortcomings rather than keep adding patches on top of an experience that needs a stronger base.

The main things we are working toward are:

  • Better performance and offline support, so that actions like creating or editing events can work even without connectivity.

  • Search, so you can find events quickly.

  • A more modern and responsive UI.

  • An improved Agenda / Schedule view.

  • A bunch of other improvements like opening event locations in your preferred maps app.

We are still shipping improvements to the current application where it makes sense. For example, we recently made it possible on Android to set Proton Calendar as your default calendar app on supported devices. We also launched appointment scheduling on Web because it did not require any mobile changes.

But for the biggest pain points the real fix is the next-generation Calendar.

Timelines are always tricky, especially with a rewrite of this scale, so I want to avoid over-promising exact dates. Our current plan is to make the next-generation Calendar available before the end of the year, starting with a beta / early access phase so we can gather feedback before replacing the current experience.

Thank you for bearing with us. I know it has been frustrating, and I really appreciate everyone who continues to give detailed feedback. The team is genuinely passionate about making Proton Calendar a much stronger product, and I’ll try to be more present here to answer questions where I can 😄


r/ProtonMail • • 21d ago

Discussion "Proton To ‘Re-Interview’ Staff About AI To See Who Gets To Keep Their Job" - Can we get a comment on this please?

Thumbnail archive.is
1.9k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Feb 28 '26

Discussion It has begun

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago Bravo

Possible bug Cancelling subscription is only option now

1.9k Upvotes

Im sorry to say that, but I wont give single cent to a company with that kind of CEO, bye.


r/ProtonMail • • Apr 23 '26 This

Discussion Age verification is a Trojan horse for ending online anonymity and Big Tech is lobbying for it

1.9k Upvotes

The push for age verification is ramping up worldwide, and while protecting kids online is a real and valid concern, the scope and approach are unacceptable and we simply can’t afford to get this wrong.

For some it sounds like common sense, until you realize that every adult will have to verify their ID to access the internet. 

You can't prove a child is underage without proving an adult is of age, and that means passports, facial scans, and government IDs flowing into databases held by companies that have already proven they can't keep data safe (Discord leaked 70K+ users' ID photos last year through a third-party vendor).

Meanwhile, Big Tech companies like Apple are volunteering to handle age checks at the device level, which conveniently gives them even more control over who accesses what. And Meta has been lobbying hard for age verification for years, not because they care about kids, but because it shifts responsibility off their platform.

The EU already tried launching an age-verification app. Hackers found critical flaws within hours.

If age verification does happen, the bare minimum should be: client-side checks only, no stored data, end-to-end encryption, open-source code, and zero linkage between the age check and user identity. 

Anything less is building a surveillance system and calling it child safety.

We’d love to hear your thoughts on this. Let us know where you stand on age verification!

Full post: https://proton.me/blog/keep-age-verification-from-killing-anonymity-online 

Stay safe,

The Proton Team


r/ProtonMail • • Jul 25 '25

Discussion Proton is moving most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Who caught this part of the recent Lumo AI announcement?

Because of legal uncertainty around Swiss government proposals(new window) to introduce mass surveillance — proposals that have been outlawed in the EU — Proton is moving most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland. Lumo will be the first product to move.

What do you think?


r/ProtonMail • • Jun 29 '26 Heartwarming Mindblown

Discussion Mullvad founder unveiled as biggest funder of far-right party calling for remigration

Thumbnail
korben.info
1.8k Upvotes

Mullvad co-founder Daniel Berntsson donated 5 million kronor (≈€450,000) which is 72% of Örebropartiet's entire 2025 budget. This single donation enabled the party to enter national politics. Örebropartiet advocates "comprehensive remigration" Their leader Markus Allard publicly called some immigrants "parasites."

Berntsson goes as far as to say: "really bad criminal, immigration and integration policies (and more) have put us in today's miserable situation."

For those that don't know, remigration is a far-right concept referring to ethnic cleansing via mass deportation of non-white, minority populations.


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 05 '25

Discussion Yeah I don't think I will be using that one.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Aug 14 '25

Discussion I take it back. We need Proton Messenger ASAP.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes