r/ProtonMail • • 7d ago

Discussion Proton published how they are handling AI and code review/security

417 Upvotes

Sooo, I went in expecting more marketing bullshit and found a decent description of a review process: human approval on every change, crypto changes gated to the crypto team, scanners, design reviews, least-privilege for AI agents, SOC 2 audits, etc. Overall looks like a reasonable AI policy.

The most interesting disclosures imo:

Proton has access to non-public models from OpenAI and Anthropic which they are using to security scan their code. Not sure how I feel about this.

Proton security teams moving fast on AI, they say: "Cybersecurity is an arms race, and the teams working on security at Proton have been some of the earliest adopters of AI, because the safety of your data depends on winning that race." Also not sure how I feel about this.

Proton will undergo another SOC 2 audit in 2027, which will be a third party verification of their policies.

SOC 2 makes me more comfortable. They need to give this to their business customers, and if they deviate from their policies and there is an incident, it is big money legal liability.

Blog confirms that humans review all changes and a human is accountable for all changes, and if confirmed by SOC 2 audit next year, that is at least reassuring.

Link to the post: https://proton.me/blog/how-proton-keeps-your-data-secure


r/ProtonMail • • 7d ago

Discussion [Updated Megathread] Inside Proton's AI changes

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

We have opened this new mega thread, which will have comments enabled in order to keep our sub clean and focused.

This way, the current situation can be discussed while also allowing other product related threads getting their questions answered, without cluttering the front page, until there’s new information from the Proton Team.

As a general reminder about our subreddit rules:

Everyone here can and should feel free to voice their opinion and criticism. However we (volunteer mods team) also want to ask you to stay classy and respectful.

Keep insults or discrimination of any sort (gender, racial, religious etc) towards any other member of the community, fellow moderators or Proton staff out. Anything of the above isn’t welcome here.

Please refrain from hijacking other, non related threads. For example: If someone has a genuine technical question, hijacking said thread with off topic comments will also be removed.

Let’s have a civil discussion. Thank you for keeping this a safe space for everyone.

Former list of mega threads:
General feedback and criticism:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xilgwk/manifestos_fear_and_loser_thinking_inside_protons/

Reversal of decision:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xjklwp/protons_ceo_cancels_ai_reinterviews/

404 Media’s intentions:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xl08c4/is_404_media_intentionally_stirring_up_the_proton/

Regarding the AI Manifesto:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xlfjiv/protons_ai_manifesto_for_software_engineering/

If you want to leave your goodbye’s:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xinep7/longtime_user_extremely_disappointed_a_goodbye_to/

If you want to show your support about AI usage;
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xio49j/why_i_fully_support_protons_ai_agenda_and_their/

If you want to show your support that you’re sticking with Proton:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xln3vr/im_staying_with_proton/

Regarding Proton Leadership:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xipx46/yen_needs_to_step_down/

Regarding alternatives:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xindcn/alternatives_to_proton/
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xjug5x/best_alternative_to_proton/

Employee reactions:
https://reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xkezig/im_a_proton_employee_and_im_breaking_my_silence/


r/ProtonMail • • 36m ago

Lovebomb Proton Mail iOS 🥳🥳 now with searching content

Post image
21 Upvotes

Finally I can search in content :-)), fresh on iOS 🥳


r/ProtonMail • • 2h ago

Solved Feature (finally) added: Login restricted to username

17 Upvotes

I just received a notification on an old post asking about the possibility to restrict the login to the original username/email, so no one can try to login with your secondary addresses. It was the Proton Support Team who wrote confirming they just implemented it under Security and privacy options. This was a must for me and for many, really happy they finally have introduced it.


r/ProtonMail • • 18h ago

comiCSS #268: PR Review

Post image
329 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 3h ago

Proton finally lets us restrict sign-in to one email

15 Upvotes

Just found this feature in settings called “Sign-in protection” that apparently lets us restrict sign-in to a single email, disabling the ability to sign-in with all other Proton email addresses on the account. I was surprised I hadn’t heard anything about this yet. Just tried it out and it works a charm. Have been waiting for this for a long time and happy that Proton finally did it!

https://i.imgur.com/EAeI5uU.jpeg


r/ProtonMail • • 12h ago

Proton pass needs tags

14 Upvotes

Not vaults or folders just tags so u can tag stuff like Email or Social or Work etc while still seeing everything in one container


r/ProtonMail • • 9h ago

Content search on mobile

4 Upvotes

This page says that users can enable content search (within emails) on the mobile apps: https://proton.me/support/search#mobile

However, I use Proton Mail on iOS and I don't see the option to enable content search. I've checked in the App Store to make sure all my apps are updated.

Am I missing something totally obvious? (Apologies if so!)


r/ProtonMail • • 3h ago

Discussion Why doesnt proton mail have passkey option? 🤔

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • 21h ago

Discussion Anyone successfully using Email Categories

10 Upvotes

I've been using this for few months and really wanted it to work, but for me it seems to get about 50% right, and the other 50% is just randomly anywhere, and there is no consistency. For example, I get a newsletter and it is from the same email address. I moved it to newsletter, and 3-4 days a week, that is where it goes. But other days it goes wherever it wants. Today it was in Transactions, last week it was in Promotions.

I feel like my moving things to "train" it is just wasting my time as it will almost certainly go to the wrong category in a few days at most.


r/ProtonMail • • 14h ago

Discussion Currently Proton Pass family. Looking for email: Proton or Fastmail?

3 Upvotes

I'm a family Proton Pass user, and will be moving from Gmail in the next weeks after more than 22 years because they kill the custom domain support.

Considering Proton Mail, and Fastmail. Proton Mail because I'm already using Proton. And Fastmail because :

  • Proton Pass Family + Fastmail Family : 166€ / year

  • Proton Pass + ... wait, if you add anything, you have to add everything: 288€/ year

Yet Proton mail seems behind Fastmail from what I read: only 3 custom domain, the search feature seems less satisfactory.

Any advice or different view from users here?


r/ProtonMail • • 22h ago

No option to delete forwarding

Post image
1 Upvotes

I set up an email account in Proton in an attempt to get away from Google but made the mistake of paying via Google Pay.

Eventually I set up a second Proton account and set the first to forward email to this one.

That first account is now no longer active and if I try to logon I get the following message

"This address has been disabled by the account owner. Please try again with an active address."

In itself this is not a problem as I no longer require this address but what I am left with is a forwarding rule that says send from the first account to the second. It currently says PAUSED but leaves me no option to delete it.

All queries just say click on the 3 dots under actions but that is missing.

Any ideas?


r/ProtonMail • • 21h ago

Discussion Proton Meet

0 Upvotes

I am intrigued by Proton Meet, however I am puzzled by the fact that there isn't a tier available to paying customers of protonmail.

In my case, I'm looking for an option where I can do 90-120 minute meetings with only one other participant once per week (for music lessons), and the free tier obviously won't work for that.

There are free options available elsewhere so I cannot possibly justify paying for Proton Meet (especially at full price), but it's frustrating that I have no viable option here as an already-paying proton customer.

So... to the proton powers that be - please make available some useful options for long time customers. (And note that for two party meetings, the service could be run point to point so there oughtn't even be any real server load.)

Protonmail is not inexpensive. I'm not looking for a free ride. But please improve your value proposition here as alternatives (once my subscription nears expiration) are looking more and more enticing.


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Discussion Proton Calendar on Gnome

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

Is it possible to have ProtonMail's Calendar synced on Gnome?

I am on Fedora if that makes a difference.

I am okay with a bridge as long as is the native Calendar app and not evolution or thunderbird.


r/ProtonMail • • 21h ago

Discussion Costco + Proton Email is an awful experience

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This has been going on for at least a year now Proton. I have tried filing support tickets and nothing gets resolved. See pics. Here are some of the issues I have:

  1. Proton's NetShield blocks all links in Costco Emails - So I can't view any link Costco provides me in emails.

  2. Very slow to load and/or not all product images being displayed properly as seen in the picture

  3. Proton continues to ignore this for what has been an issue for a long time now. I shouldn't have to disable my Netshield just so I can click product links in Costco emails. I think I can speak for the majority of Costco members that we would rather have the ability to click links in Costco emails than to block whatever tracking might be going on.

Would really appreciate it if this would be looked at by Proton Team. Thank you.


r/ProtonMail • • 2d ago

How to get rid of the proton black Friday advertisement in mail

13 Upvotes

I see lots of posts from people who want to get rid of the black Friday or seasonal advertisement that appears in proton mail. Some people may like it, but I prefer no advertisement given I'm already paying for the product.

If you have uBlock, simply Right Click the box (not the text) -> Block element. Then click create in the dialogue. You can also use the element zapper.

Hopefully this helps people who want a cleaner experience.


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Discussion Worth switching from Gmail/Outlook if I lose free Thunderbird access?

4 Upvotes

Right now I use Gmail and Outlook. I really like importing them into Thunderbird because it is fast and super convenient to manage all my emails in one place. I even DONATE to Thunderbird monthly to support them

I want to move to Proton or Tuta for better privacy. But I heard Tuta doesn't support Thunderbird at all, and Proton needs a paid plan for Proton Bridge. Also, most people I email still use Gmail or Outlook

For people who already switched: where are Proton and Tuta actually better than Gmail/Outlook in real life, and is the privacy upgrade worth giving up my Thunderbird setup?


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Proton Unlimited – Can existing customers benefit from Black Friday deals every year?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm considering subscribing to Proton Unlimited for a year, but I have a question about how Black Friday deals work for existing customers.

From what I've understood, you can disable auto-renewal and manually renew your subscription for another year when the next Black Friday deals come around.

However, according to Proton's website, existing customers don't get the same Black Friday offers as new customers. Instead, you have to log in to your account and click on the "Black Friday" section to see the special offers reserved for existing customers.

Could anyone who already has a Proton subscription share what kind of Black Friday offers they are getting this year?

I'd really like to subscribe, but there's one thing holding me back: if existing customers can't get a decent Black Friday deal when renewing their subscription, does that mean I'll eventually have to pay the full price after my first year?

I'm looking at Proton Unlimited as a long-term investment. If I subscribe, it's because I intend to stick with Proton for the next 10 years or so. I don't want to commit to a provider only to find out that renewing becomes significantly more expensive than switching to a competitor every year.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Discussion Proton Family

0 Upvotes

Does Proton Family go on sale for Black Friday?


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Discussion Mail Sync

0 Upvotes

Does the Proton email app sync? Proton Web, MAC Desktop and iPhone mobile? to include attachments?


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

365 Business Basic to Proton Migration

0 Upvotes

As the title suggest, I wish to consider moving my emails, calendar, contacts and Onedrive to Proton, I only have one mailbox(including archive) hundreds of alias in use, using my personal domain name.

Has anyone done this and is there migration tools available??

I also OneNote, so any tips and tricks much appreciated as can't find any videos on this


r/ProtonMail • • 1d ago

Sort mail by received date

0 Upvotes

Loving Proton so far but how do I sort messages by received date instead of created date? Substack does this a lot (intentionally delayed) so my new message from substack goes all the way to the bottom as "unread"

Really annoying feature, wtf


r/ProtonMail • • 2d ago

Discussion How reliable is ProtonMail's support in the event of an account compromise?

16 Upvotes

The recent NIKKE Incident was a wake-up call for me that even as a cautious user of no particular note I'm still within the blast area for getting all of my accounts compromised (not that this wasn't the case before). This became increasingly clear as I looked for any sort of Google customer support, paid or otherwise - all of which don't exist! The only thing appears to be Youtube Support of all things, which is allegedly unintended and offers no further benefit to premium users.

Does ProtonMail have good (dare I say, actually reasonable) customer support options in the event you get cookie hijacked or otherwise hacked? I switched to Brave just last night after finding out that Firefox doesn't have Device Bound Session Credentials, although I'm not particularly impressed the google account versions of DBSC are disabled by default in its flags.

Furthermore, if I forsake my privacy to ProtonMail, would this significantly increase my odds of a positive account recovery experience in this event (e.g. ID, bank statements, other proofs of ownership)? Getting hacked in this day and age is practically inevitable at this point, if not years into future, so I'd rather get on top of it than pretend my personal data is sacred.

As an aside, I suppose I should ask if ProtonMail has the same issues google does with hackers being able to rewrite all of your account recovery options all willy-nilly?


r/ProtonMail • • 2d ago

Moving single event in series of recurring events incredibly slow

1 Upvotes

I work different shift times and have recurring events before each shift. Because of these ever changing shift times, I have to move single recurring events once I know my start time.

Moving a single event in a series of recurring events, however, can take up to 50 seconds from the moment of clicking [Save] to the moment Calendar asks whether to move all future events or just this single event.

This is way too slow!! Please improve this feature so saving the changed event is pretty much immediate but certainly no longer than a couple of seconds. Thanks.