r/ProtonMail • • 15d ago Hehehe Heartwarming

Why I’m staying at Proton, and what I think needs to change

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, Laszlo here. Some of you may know me as the PM working on Proton Calendar.

Reading the recent discussions, I wanted to share where I stand. No one asked me to write this. This is my own experience, and I don’t expect others to feel the same way.

I joined Proton because I wanted to work on something I believed in. I took a pay cut to come here (to be fair I worked for Google), and that decision still makes sense to me today. The mission matters to me, and I see how much it matters to the people I work with.

That’s also why I think we should be able to talk openly about what needs to improve.

I was one of the 40 leads who were reinterviewed. It was stressful, and I don’t agree with how it was handled. There were better ways to challenge us and help us adapt.

At the same time, I got something valuable out of it. It made me step back and realise how much the way I worked had changed over the past few months. I started questioning habits I’d taken for granted, and that ultimately helped me become a better PM. I’m genuinely grateful for that, even though I wish the process had been different.

I feel similarly about Andy. I believe in his leadership, and I also think his communication needs to change.

I see someone who cares deeply about building a private internet and feels an enormous urgency to make it happen. But good intentions don’t make every approach acceptable. How you speak to people matters, especially when they’re raising concerns.

In my own interactions, I’ve felt able to disagree with Andy very directly. That’s something I appreciate about working with him. But I know that being comfortable pushing back at your CEO isn’t something you can expect from everyone.

I respect what he and the team have built. Getting Proton to where it is today took persistence and conviction. I still want that in a leader. I also want someone who can listen, recognise mistakes and change. I believe Andy can do that, and I want to see it happen.

I understand why some users are questioning their trust in Proton. The mission is a reason to hold us to a high standard, and we have to live up to it through our actions.

For me, there is still a lot here worth working for. I believe in my colleagues, in the mission, and in our ability to do better.

So I’m staying. I came here to help build the best private time-management apps out there. That’s still what I want to spend my time doing :)


r/ProtonMail • • Jan 15 '25

Discussion Canceling my subscription until something is done about the current situation

0 Upvotes

Enough said.


r/ProtonMail • • Sep 01 '26 Bravo

Possible bug This is unacceptable

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Feb 03 '20

Can anyone please explain why ProtonMail has such a low Privacy Monitor by Osano rating? Only 20 points higher than Facebook and 60 point less than Google. What's going on???

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Jan 15 '25

Discussion Why I'm glad Proton is adopting a non-profit foundation structure, and I feel people need to chill about others (including andy) voicing their own opinions

73 Upvotes

I don't want to comment on the actual political implications of Gail Slater - I'm too unfamiliar with that, but I am shocked by the amount of backlash andy seems to be getting.

But I find it shocking that andy, simply for voicing his own views on a matter, gets so much heat. From my perspective, I don't see clear unilateral support of his for Trump, and I don't see andy expressing racist, sexist, or fascist views.

Even if Gail Slater is not pro privacy (I cannot tell, ask someone better informed than me) - andy, just as anyone else, should be allowed to voice their views.
I do agree that andy being the CEO makes some difference perhaps - for example, should his own personal views influence his actions as CEO in making decisions against Proton's mission of supporting Privacy and Freedom online through their services and actions.
However, I'm also at the same time reassured by Proton's transition to a non-profit Foundation - the Foundation has a clearly set mission, and those are distinct from andy's, or any other potential future ceo's views and motivations.
I do still believe in andy, but should the day come where he or any other future Proton ceo try to make decisions that go against Proton's mission, I expect the remaining Trustees (mind you, this includes one of the fathers of the internet, Sir Tim Berners Lee) to act accordingly to keep Proton on track.

Now, just to be clear regarding my own personal political views, just in case anyone wants to make assumptions regarding them*:* I am not American, I do not identify as either a Democrat or Republic (I find the two-party system rather flawed and strange), I absolutely am not a fan of Trump, I'm a supporter of privacy, and I consider myself left-leaning. Left-leaning on the European scale that is, where apparently the center is already considered left by US standards. That means I've seriously considered voting Communists in my last elections, I've got a track record of voting Social Democrats, I'm a member of a Socialist Political Association, and occasionally I spare some of my free time with Antifa folks.

Now, please keep in mind that that is my own personal political view - feel free to disagree with me, disagree with the people I spend time with, disagree with how I vote.

Regardless of how you see my views however, I do feel like it's objectively important that everyone deserves the right to free speech, and everyone gets to have the freedom to have their own political views and religious views.
Might I disagree with what you say? Sure, I might.
Might I disagree with your political or religious views? Sure, I might.

Still, I do feel you're entitled to your own views.


r/ProtonMail • • 14d ago

Sad to see Naomi Brockwell, long-time advocate for digital privacy, break her silence on the whole Proton scandal only to choose to defend them

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Aug 11 '26

Possible bug Products are so buggy...

0 Upvotes

I've been using Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Lumo, and Proton Drive for one week. I want to see what they're like before migrating my employer from Google to Proton.

I had such high hopes, but the products aren't ready for real-world use.

  • Lumo frequently doesn't load and leaves me with a blank screen.

  • Proton Drive frequently won't upload files.

  • Proton Mail frequently won't send emails (they're stuck in Outbox).

At least the VPN seems to work.

Is this just the way it is?

I'm willing to be tolerant of open source projects having issues, but this is an established company positioning itself as an alternative to Google...

Thanks for any comments.

Edit, for the record, I love what Proton are doing and REALLY do not want these issues.

Edit 2, oh wow, the moderators removed this...

Edit 3, turns out their VPN has issues but why is it only affecting their products?!


r/ProtonMail • • Jun 10 '26 Bravo

Discussion The recent controversy: Is "neutrality" enough?

3 Upvotes

A few days ago, I reached out to Proton Support via email to express my concerns regarding the recent reports of political sponsorships and the alleged deletion of posts on this subreddit. To this day, I have received no response from support.

While I’ve seen the CEO's comments here on Reddit,
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1u15orj/comment/oqnik1q/

I believe there is a gap between a public statement and a corporate policy. "Stated neutrality" is a good start, but without transparency, it is simply a request for us to "trust them." For a company that builds its entire brand on the idea that you shouldn't have to trust people, but should trust encryption/proof, this is a contradiction.

To be clear, my concern isn't about a specific political side, but about consistency.
As a customer, I believe Proton should either maintain strict political neutrality regarding its partnerships or ensure that any collaborations align with the core values of privacy, civil liberties, and freedom of expression that the company was built upon. When partnerships are forged with figures whose views clash with these fundamental values, it creates a dissonance with the ethos that draws so many of us to Proton.

I believe we should be asking for three specific things from Proton:

  1. Clarification: A formal, written statement regarding the current guidelines for sponsorship and partnership activities.

  2. Transparency: A clear explanation as to why posts regarding this controversy were allegedly deleted/buried on the official subreddit, and a commitment to stop doing so.

  3. Reassurance: Concrete proof that Proton is committed to open discourse and will not suppress community feedback when it becomes "uncomfortable."

My Proposal: A Public Sponsorship Transparency Log

I agree with the sentiment expressed by u/Working-Panda-3168 in their recent comment: we need a system of accountability.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1u05xs2/comment/oqhjyy8/

I propose that Proton implements a Public Sponsorship Transparency Log (perhaps integrated into their existing Transparency Reports). This wouldn't need to reveal private contract details, but should include:

  • A list of active influencers/partners paid to promote Proton, including the platforms where these partnerships are active (e.g., YouTube, Reddit, Facebook, etc.).

  • General budget categories (e.g., "Influencer Marketing: approx. €X million per year").

  • A public set of "Ethics Guidelines" that all partners must agree to before receiving funding.

If Proton truly believes in freedom of expression and openness, they should be open about who they are paying to speak on their behalf. This moves the conversation from "Trust us, we are neutral" to "Here is the proof of our neutrality."

I’m a long-time paying customer because I believe in what Proton stands for. I want to keep believing in it, but that requires the company to be as transparent with its business practices as it is with its code.

What do you all think? Would a transparency log be a fair requirement for a company that champions "Freedom"?


r/ProtonMail • • Mar 24 '25

Discussion Proton Drive is still garbage

0 Upvotes

I came back to PD to check it out and am glad to report that there have been *some* improvements recently.

However, Proton drive is still an utter joke. Can't use the "backup" functionality on mac, can't select folders to sync on mac... still can't backup / sync network locations.

Are you guys even trying?


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 01 '21

Discussion Is this true?

Thumbnail
twitter.com
2 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Sep 08 '21

Discussion "Protonmail logs the IP address to the autorities"

1 Upvotes

Stop blaming protonmail for getting IP directions for THE AUTORITIES, i don't want to flame no one, however don't you think its totally logic to see protonmail giving IP addresses to autorities in case of illegal activity? Do you want to let a pedo or a terrorist share illegal things with protonmail? I personally don't want to, and if you know it, protonmail does not give the IP address to no one unless the swiss law wants it.

It is far the case of the echologyst? It is fair to log the IP adress of someone doing illegal activity? Yes.

Personally i like protonmail and i will still using it, i don't make anything illegal so i don't care if they log my IP adress or not, since if you guys want to be totally anonymous, you should use a VPN in a virtual machine inside a cyber so no one can track you.

Regards.


r/ProtonMail • • Jun 16 '26

Discussion Easiest way to move away from proton?

51 Upvotes

I have used proton for a couple of years now on their duo membership currently. Unfortunately to me it isn’t worth the money- most if not all the features i use I can get for free elsewhere and Proton as a whole seems disingenuous to put it mildly. But I won’t go into details here what I was keen to understand was if there is a quick way to migrate away- just thinking re aliases etc do I need to change the email address for every account?


r/ProtonMail • • Jul 02 '26

Discussion I know that you have to treat every customer as a 5 year old forgetful kid with ADHD but at least give us functionality to disable that annoying reminder. I know my password and I don't need any reminder popup...

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Aug 12 '24

Announcement US Justice Dept. sues TikTok, Musk trains AI on user data, and Google deemed a Monopoly. Get caught up here.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Jan 11 '26

Discussion Proton ads are getting worse every day.

4 Upvotes

Proton’s getting way too pushy with the constant upselling. It’s super annoying to log in for privacy and get hit with "Upgrade" pop-ups and cluttered sidebars every five minutes. For a service that’s supposed to be clean and user-first, it’s starting to feel like they’re just spamming their own customers.


r/ProtonMail • • 18d ago

Discussion The new login page is worse

1 Upvotes

Why does enshittification need to happen everywhere? We now have user and password separated from each other. it's going to my password manager one extra time compared to the older UI.

Is there a proper reason why this change happened?


r/ProtonMail • • Sep 05 '26

Discussion Calendar showings as DDMM

Post image
0 Upvotes

New to Proton. When I create a calendar entry, the dates show as DDMM instead of MMDD. How can I change this? I’ve tried looking online and Protons website but couldn’t find anything helpful. Tried looking in settings too, but couldn’t find anything there either.


r/ProtonMail • • Sep 06 '21

Discussion What is the point of using ProtonMail anymore?

2 Upvotes

After PM just handed over data to the authorities, I don’t see a point in using this service anymore. There are better apps that don’t charge a ridiculous amount of money. Seems like their whole product is just to provide a false sense of security. Spin it anyway you want to justify your money being spent. PM just lost a customer.

ah the shills have arrived. keep paying for a shit service.


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 27 '25

Feature Request New Android mail app terrible UI choice.

0 Upvotes

This is a ridiculous waste of precious screen space - these intervals could at least be halved (or made adjustable via app settings).
Please revert it to the good old v5 compact look.
Thank you.


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 11 '22

Discussion Stuff like this, puts Proton in a bad light.

Post image
62 Upvotes

Is there a way to prevent stuff like this? Without hurting privacy?


r/ProtonMail • • Oct 29 '21

Feature Request My favorite feature of ProtonMail

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/ProtonMail • • Dec 23 '20

When you cancel a plan it should go to your card. Not to ‘Credits available’.

3 Upvotes

I have requested Proton support to refund the amount to my card but to no avail. I was in their bundle the last couple of years and it wouldn’t let me use my ‘free’ email account (I had 4 other email addresses) unless I pay for their service (2 years subscription). SO I paid just to get into my account and then I switched over to the free plan which was incredibly hard to switch to. After I do this the amount just sits in my account. I understand they don’t save our credit card details? Is that why? How are they going to refund it back to my card?


r/ProtonMail • • Jan 16 '25

Discussion What is the best way to export all my email

5 Upvotes

Given the current situation I'm looking in to migrating my email over to another service. That will probably be Tuta.

What would be the best way of exporting all my email? I'm thinking about installing a desktop email client and have that download all email. That also gives me an offline backup of all my email. Would that be best or are there better options?

Protonpass I'll move to a self hosted Bitwarden instance. I'm not using Proton for anything else.


r/ProtonMail • • Jul 11 '22

Discussion Too Unreliable. What is a More Reliable Alternative?

0 Upvotes

My email IS my business. Communicate with clients all over the world all day with email. I just can't have a primary email service that goes down for basically an entire business day like PM has for me today.

Can anyone recommend a more reliable alternative? Need something more secure than gmail. TIA!