r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/englishsoundwave • 31m ago
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/MrSm1lez • Feb 06 '20
Welcome to /r/PoliticalPhilosophy! Please Read before posting.
Lately we've had an influx of posts that aren't directly focused on political philosophy. Political philosophy is a massively broad topic, however, and just about any topic could potentially make a good post. Before deciding to post, please read through the basics.
What is Political Philosophy?
To put it simply, political philosophy is the philosophy of politics and human nature. This is a broad topic, leading to questions about such subjects as ethics, free will, existentialism, and current events. Most political philosophy involves the discussion of political theories/theorists, such as Aristotle, Hobbes, or Rousseau (amongst a million others).
Can anyone post here?
Yes! Even if you have limited experience with political philosophy as a discipline, we still absolutely encourage you to join the conversation. You're allowed to post here with any political leaning. This is a safe place to discuss liberalism, conservatism, libertarianism, etc. With that said, posts and comments that are racist, homophobic, antisemitic, or bigoted will be removed. This does not mean you can't discuss these topics-- it just means we expect discourse to be respectful. On top of this, we expect you to not make accusations of political allegiance. Statements such as "typical liberal", "nazi", "wow you must be a Trumper," etc, are detrimental to good conversation.
What isn't a good fit for this sub
Questions such as;
"Why are you voting Democrat/Republican?"
"Is it wrong to be white?"
"This is why I believe ______"
How these questions can be reframed into a philosophic question
As stated above, in political philosophy most topics are fair game provided you frame them correctly. Looking at the above questions, here's some alternatives to consider before posting, including an explanation as to why it's improved;
"Does liberalism/conservatism accomplish ____ objective?"
Why: A question like this, particularly if it references a work that the readers can engage with provides an answerable question that isn't based on pure anecdotal evidence.
"What are the implications of white supremacy in a political hierarchy?" OR "What would _____ have thought about racial tensions in ______ country?"
Why: This comes on two fronts. It drops the loaded, antagonizing question that references a slogan designed to trigger outrage, and approaches an observable problem. 'Institutional white supremacy' and 'racial tensions' are both observable. With the second prompt, it lends itself to a discussion that's based in political philosophy as a discipline.
"After reading Hobbes argument on the state of nature, I have changed my belief that Rousseau's state of nature is better." OR "After reading Nietzsche's critique of liberalism, I have been questioning X, Y, and Z. What are your thoughts on this?"
Why: This subreddit isn't just about blurbing out your political beliefs to get feedback on how unique you are. Ideally, it's a place where users can discuss different political theories and philosophies. In order to have a good discussion, common ground is important. This can include references a book other users might be familiar with, an established theory others find interesting, or a specific narrative that others find familiar. If your question is focused solely on asking others to judge your belief's, it more than likely won't make a compelling topic.
If you have any questions or thoughts, feel free to leave a comment below or send a message to modmail. Also, please make yourself familiar with the community guidelines before posting.
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/MrSm1lez • Feb 10 '25
Revisiting the question: "What is political philosophy" in 2025
Χαῖρε φιλόσοφος,
There has been a huge uptick in American political posts lately. This in itself is not necessarily a bad thing-- there is currently a lot of room for the examination of concepts like democracy, fascism, oligarchy, moral decline, liberalism, and classical conservatism etc. However, posts need to focus on political philosophy or political theory. I want to take a moment to remind our polity what that means.
First and foremost, this subreddit exists to examine political frameworks and human nature. While it is tempting to be riled up by present circumstances, it is our job to examine dispassionately, and through the lens of past thinkers and historical circumstances. There are plenty of political subreddits designed to vent and argue about the state of the world. This is a respite from that.
To keep conversations fluid and interesting, I have been removing posts that are specifically aimed at soapboxing on the current state of politics when they are devoid of a theoretical undertone. To give an example;
A bad post: "Elon Musk is destroying America"
WHY: The goal of this post is to discuss a political agenda, and not examine the framework around it.
A better post: "Elon Musk, and how unelected officials are destroying democracy"
WHY: This is better, and with a sound argument could be an interesting read. On the surface, it is still is designed to politically agitate as much as it exists to make a cohesive argument.
A good post: "Oligarchy making in historic republics and it's comparison to the present"
WHY: We are now taking our topic and comparing it to past political thought, opening the rhetoric to other opinions, and creating a space where we can discuss and argue positions.
Another point I want to make clear, is that there is ample room to make conservative arguments as well as traditionally liberal ones. As long as your point is intelligent, cohesive, and well structured, it has a home here. A traditionally conservative argument could be in favor of smaller government, or states rights (all with proper citations of course). What it shouldn't be is ranting about your thoughts on the southern border. If you are able to defend it, your opinion is yours to share here.
As always, I am open to suggestions and challenges. Feel free to comment below with any additional insights.
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/PhilosophyTO • 5h ago
Kant’s "Religion Within the Bounds of Mere Reason" (1792) — An online reading & discussion group starting Nov 2026, all welcome
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Fragrant-Function-24 • 10h ago
Do soldiers fighting on opposing sides have equal moral status regardless of the justice of their cause
Arguments for and against the traditional just war theory
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/gayish_boyish • 11h ago
A Liberal Case for Socialism
“Capitalism is dying. It will not, however, disappear on a given day, or in a given month or even year. Its demise will take place as a historic process that could lead to democratic socialism—or to a new kind of collectivist and authoritarian society” (Harrington). With these words, Michael Harrington, a democratic socialist and founder of the Democratic Socialists of America, started the first section of his essay titled “What Socialists Would Do in America–If They Could.” In America today, we are seeing a rise of that latter option, an authoritarian government and president unlike any before him. However, due to the recent elections of more progressive leaders such as Zohran Mamdani, it seems that America is seeing a shift towards democratic socialism, and if America, a country whose core principles center around liberalism, is seemingly proving Harrington’s statement, perhaps liberalism must be more deeply understood.
Liberalism is defined as “a political and economic doctrine that emphasizes individual autonomy, equality of opportunity, and the protection of individual rights”(Ball et al.). Most of the modern world was built upon this belief, and it remains one of the most influential modern doctrines. Democratic socialism is a far harder term to define, but put simply, it is a politically democratic philosophy with both a restricted private market and certain socialist reforms. These policies function as a bridge between the interests of capitalism and socialism while allowing certain enrichment of the overall society from both systems. Liberalism and the utilitarianism that heavily influenced it hold within themselves the seeds of this democratic socialism.
John Stuart Mill was the epitome of a classical liberal, fully enamored by thoughts of freedom of the individual and the great innovation that capitalism promised. Furthermore, as the godson of Jeremy Bentham, he was one of the founding thinkers on utilitarianism. As one of the founding liberal thinkers, Mill set the course for many who followed to shape the liberal world we live in today. His most credited idea was that of his harm principle. This was a principle aimed at discovering true “utility” in government policy and can be summed up in Chapter 1 of On Liberty, where he states, “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others”(Mill 1859). This principle guided all his works as well as shaping much of modern-day ethics and policy decisions. Under this principle, founded both in the belief of liberalism that freedom should be prioritized and in utilitarian thought, Mill believed that close to true utility could be found, utility acting for him as the “ultimate appeal on all ethical questions” (Mill 1859). The harm principle also shaped his path away from other classical liberals, who moved toward laissez-faire capitalism, as it is a fundamentally egalitarian principle, weighing all individuals as morally equal and focusing on the benefit of the community, taking the classic capitalist idea of freedom and showing the hypocrisy within it. Mill says, “The only freedom which deserves the name, is that of pursuing our own good in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, or impede their efforts to obtain it” (Mill,1859). Therefore, in capitalism, the only ones with true freedom, by Mill’s definition, are the upper class, as the working class does not have the freedom to pursue their own good explicitly because of the actions of those above. Within this belief, the idealism of capitalist thinking begins to give way.
Later in life, Mill had cemented some of these anti-capitalist ideas into his book Socialism and, through reading Owen and Fourier, had landed on liberal or democratic socialism as his chosen political affiliation. He arrives at this conclusion by attacking the current capitalist system through the lens of liberalism and his harm principle. In attacking capitalism, he says, “The very idea of distributive justice, or of any proportionality between success and merit, or between success and exertion, is in the present state of society so manifestly chimerical as to be relegated to the regions of romance” (Mill 1879). This attack illuminates a fundamental flaw with capitalism that separates it from the liberal ideal of an equality of opportunity and explicitly goes against the harm principle, as capitalism creates extreme power disparity regardless of individual merit. Mill argues that just as important as the equality of opportunity is the ability of people to exercise said opportunity; this belief, among others–such as the egalitarian views of utilitarianism–shows that distributive justice, being at best an idealistic vision rather than anything tangible, is fundamentally against everything Mill stands for.
The harm principle illuminates why this absence of distributive justice is morally indefensible, for if capitalism’s underlying structures determine who suffers, then that suffering should not be condemned as a personal failing but rather as a systemic institutional one. A truth baked into the ideology of a capitalist society is that the rich work for every cent they have and that the poor are only such due to laziness or lack of talent. Mill pushes sharply against this, saying that “Next to birth the chief cause of success in life is accident and opportunity”(Mill 1879), and even if this belief of those at the bottom of society being inferior in some way was true, “Is weakness a justification of suffering?” (Mill 1879). Does a true utilitarian lose all care for harm when that harm could have theoretically been avoided? These problems are inherent in the system of capitalism; they aren’t bugs; they exist by design, and Mill sees this.
From here, the logical next step is to question why Mill chose democratic socialism over capitalism, because unlike many, Mill did not believe capitalism to be the least bad system by any means. This is due to his unwavering belief in the equal value of all human lives. He could not accept a societal structure that institutionally requires suffering from the lower class. He believed that by bringing up those near the bottom of society, all of society prospers (Mill 1879). In Socialism, Mill argues that though revolutionary socialism is attractive due to its promises of radical change to the status quo, those promises are mostly backed by faith in the system and risk all that capitalism has gained humanity in years past. However, he does not throw away socialism outright; he believes that democratic socialism is where society is going to land, but he is not fundamentally against a socialism similar to Fourierism as long as it is implemented slowly and democratically (Mill 1879). Mill rejected revolutionary socialism because it risked everything capitalism had built in pursuit of an untested ideal, so a gradualist democratic socialism was the only path consistent with his harm principle.
Free-market capitalism, though flawed, does look superficially stable. It has held power over the world for centuries now and has systematically crushed any and all rising anti-capitalist countries in its path. However, this system, Michael Harrington believed, is not in fact stable and rests on a bedrock of contradiction and crawls towards an antisocial ideal. He arrived independently at Mill’s conclusion on democratic socialism as the logical destination and proved its practical necessity. While talking about modern capitalism, he says, “This new guise capitalism remains dangerously and fundamentally antisocial. Capacity is expanded in good times as if there were no tomorrow –-or more precisely, as if the ability of the society to consume were not limited by the very income structure that capitalist production enforces.” (Harrington) This critique is founded on capitalism’s unending urge to grow and expand, its urge to produce and consume all; an urge that, though pleasing, is ecologically unsustainable and socially destabilizing. To expand capitalism efficiently, those at the bottom of society, the workers, must be given barely living wages, going directly against Mill’s harm principle, while the workers end up being the ones paying for expansion by consuming. Those of the capitalist class do not need to worry about any of that due to capitalism placing them in positions where they are “appropriating surplus value in the guise of wages” (Harrington). Effectively taking the value produced by the exploited lower class as wages for themselves. This does not match liberalism’s values of equal opportunity, as, with few exceptions, those at the top were put into that position by their parents or chance. These fundamental contradictions lead to unrest in the public, intermittent crises, and an upper class feeding on the exploitation of those below. This can by no means be called a stable system and, Harrington believes, it is a perfect birthplace for democratic socialism.
America is hailed as the epicenter of free-market capitalism; therefore, it should be the perfect spot for democratic socialism to grow. It is due to this fact that Harrington focused much of his time on the application of his ideas to American society. He believes that “the American liberals (including labor liberals) who unconsciously accept the corporate premise are often also hostile to corporations and in the future could become socialist” (Harrington). This contradiction in American ideals sets up a voting base that is ready for change and ready to move left. However, there are a few problems with regard to the integration of democratic socialism into modern-day America. One problem would be the seemingly infinite patience and belief that American citizens have with the capitalist system, though, as corruption becomes more and more apparent, this belief is being tested. Another would be the issue that in order to produce a democratic socialist state, large systematic changes would have to be put into place. These would be put in slowly as the American system tends to work, and during this transitional phase, “elements of both traditional capitalism and corporate collectivism will coexist with, and threaten, socialist innovations”(Harrington). This means that the powerful, corrupt capitalist powers that benefit from the system would not be exterminated but rather slowly weakened; a thing that they will fight tooth and nail to avoid, leveraging all of the power given to them in our current system. These roadblocks, as well as others, pose a major threat to the possibility of democratic socialism soon, but there are undeniable benefits that will and are being shown to the public that have the power to fundamentally change things.
Democratic socialism presents two benefits that could shift the majority opinion to the left: the effective right to participate in government and the ability to make more use of the opportunity promised to them in a liberal state. This effective right was a major idea that Harrington talked about, saying, “socialism proposes a national planning process in which all the people would have an effective right to participate”(Harrington). Practically, this is saying that the people are given a lot of civic power and responsibility, along with the time and energy to participate fully in it. This would allow for far higher civic engagement and systems that work for the people because they were built by the people, with the people’s interest in mind, through democratic debate. This would mean that likely more egalitarian tax laws would be put in place, the minimum wage would be lifted, the cost of living would go down, and free public services would be a priority. The second benefit is the ability to move towards actualizing this “equality of opportunity” that any truly liberal system should seek to actualize. This would mean that even those at the bottom of the economic ladder would have enough surplus capital and time to use many private and public goods given by the restricted capitalist framework. Without this, all benefits of capitalism are lost as its accomplishments can only be enjoyed by a shrinking few.
These policies, as Harrington and Mill pointed out, must be brought in slowly and democratically, or they will hold no ground, but we are already seeing this happen in America. The American populace is becoming more and more disillusioned with our current system each day. We are a country founded on liberalism, a country falling into the same authoritarianism Harrington warned about, and a country full of voters who are ready for change. Mill believed in capitalism more than most Americans today do, but due to liberal thought and utilitarian principles, he found his way onto the left; this is a shift that many Americans will make in the coming years, and it is a shift that is necessary for this country if we are ever to be a liberal nation.
Works Cited
Ball, Terence, Harry K Girvetz, Richard Dagger, and Kenneth Minogue. 2025. “Liberalism.” In Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/liberalism.
Harrington, Michael . 1978. “What Socialists Would Do in America If They Could.” Dissent. https://dissentmagazine.org/article/what-socialists-would-do-in-america-if-they-could/.
Mill, John Stuart. 1859. On Liberty. London: J. W. Parker and Son.
———. 1879. Socialism.
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Creepy_Career5622 • 13h ago
A chronology of the cultural and philosophical roots of modern political ideologies.
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Stay-Responsible • 22h ago
Political Science is the only degree you can’t actually retire with—because your career doesn't even start until you're 65
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Fuzzy_Client5959 • 1d ago
🪞 Utopian Failure Isn't Proof Against Human Nature—We Lack the Infrastructure to Think Our Way There
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/ItsameFuture_Phoenix • 1d ago
Part Three: The Cost of Power — A Failure of Cooperation
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/No_Mathematician_947 • 2d ago
''The Uniform Entry System''. An economic idea I developed in a conversation with my AI.
I was discussing economic inequality with my AI, Gerty, when an idea occurred to me: What if every generation started from roughly the same economic position, regardless of the wealth or status of their parents?
The idea is simple in principle: people should be free to build wealth during their lifetime, but that wealth should not automatically pass down through generations, creating permanent economic advantages for certain families.
Here is how I imagine it working:
1. Basic rights for everyone
Everyone is guaranteed access to housing, education and healthcare, so nobody has to begin life without the essentials.
2. Freedom to create wealth
People remain free to work, build businesses, innovate, earn money and accumulate as much wealth as they wish during their lifetime. The system does not aim to eliminate ambition or personal success.
3. A 100% tax on inherited wealth
When someone dies, their accumulated wealth returns to the state rather than being passed down to their heirs. Personal belongings, family heirlooms, jewellery and sentimental possessions could still be inherited within reasonable limits.
4. A home for everyone at 18
Every person receives a basic home through a fair allocation system. This home cannot be sold or rented out. Anyone who subsequently accumulates wealth remains free to buy additional properties and rent or sell them.
5. Wealth reinvested in society
The wealth collected through inheritance taxation funds public services, infrastructure, education, healthcare and cultural development.
6. Recognition for giving back
Wealthy individuals could also contribute voluntarily to public projects. Their contributions could be recognised through naming schools, hospitals or cultural institutions after them.
7. Democratic oversight
The system operates within a democracy. Citizens elect their representatives, and public policies remain open to scrutiny and change.
The underlying philosophy
I don't imagine a society where everyone must be equally wealthy or where individual ambition is suppressed.
Some people will want a simple life; others will want to become entrepreneurs, inventors or millionaires. Both should be possible.
The idea is to separate personal achievement from inherited privilege. You can enjoy the wealth you create during your lifetime, but your children should have the same fundamental starting opportunities as everyone else.
The long-term ambition would be to reduce the pressure to accumulate wealth simply to secure your family's future, allowing people to devote more of their lives to creativity, fulfilment and community.
I'm not an economist, and this is certainly not a complete economic model. It's an idea I developed through a conversation with my AI, and I would genuinely like to hear what others think.
Has something similar already been proposed? What practical problems would this system face? What am I overlooking?
I'm particularly interested in criticism, alternative approaches and unanswered questions. I'd like to explore the idea rather than defend it at all costs.
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Rude_Music4572 • 2d ago
Here’s a replacement for the current UN which I believe is obsolete.
The current United Nations is fundamentally broken because it relies on voluntary compliance and gives a handful of superpowers permanent veto power. When a major power—or a well-connected dictator—breaks international law, the UN passes a non-binding resolution and nothing happens.
I’ve been working on a blueprint for an alternative: a conditional Mutual-Aid Union with teeth.
Instead of erasing national borders or creating a global dictatorship that micromanages local taxes and culture, every member state keeps its own domestic laws and sovereignty. However, joining requires signing a binding "Terms of Service" treaty—trading strict compliance with baseline anti-crime and human-rights rules for massive economic,technological, and security benefits.
Here is Version 1.0 of how the system works. I’m posting this open-source so people can stress-test it, point out loopholes, and help make it stronger.
1. The Entry Contract & The "Civilian Dividend"
To join, a nation signs a binding charter pledging 0.01% to 1% of its GDP (tiered between core administration and shared R&D) plus ~20,000 troops and baseline military hardware. In return, member nations and their citizens receive:
Shared Clean Energy & Medical Breakthroughs: Access to a unified global fusion/clean-energy grid and pooled medical R&D.
The Union Space Collective: Most countries can't afford a space agency. The Union runs a single, globally funded space agency staffed by scientists from all member states. Any off-world base, orbital shipyard, or mined rare mineral is mutually shared among all members.
Civilian Baseline Guarantees: Union-backed universal healthcare, food/water security, and housing baselines—making membership an undeniable upgrade in living standards.
2. Governance: Majority Rule (No Superpower Vetoes)
No Vetoes: The Union Council operates on a simple majority vote (50% + 1). If a vote deadlocks at 50/50, it enters a mandatory cooling-off period for negotiation before a re-vote.
Strict Jurisdictional Boundaries: The Union cannot interfere in a country's domestic politics, local taxes, or cultural laws. Its enforcement power is strictly limited to "Red-Line" Crimes Against Humanity: slavery,human/organ trafficking, cross-border cartels, genocide, and wars of aggression.
Pre-Authorized Concurrent Jurisdiction: Because signing the treaty makes the Union Charter supreme treaty law inside a member's borders, Union enforcers have automatic legal authority to arrest warlords, cartel bosses, or corrupt presidents for Red-Line crimes without "invading" or breaking local law.
3. The Military: Denationalized High Command
A joint international army fails if soldiers and generals remain loyal to their home countries.
Renounced Citizenship for Top Brass: The Union's standing army is commanded by a High Command of generals who formally renounce their home citizenship and answer strictly to the Union. No soldier or officer is ever deployed to their country of birth.
10-Year Terms + Vetted Succession: Generals serve fixed 10-year terms. Incoming generals are nominated by sitting generals from decorated Union soldiers and must pass background and ethics vetting by the High Tribunal.
The Peacekeeper Social Contract: To ensure total loyalty, honorable service grants soldiers a global Union passport (the right to live and own housing in any member country after service) plus a Union retirement pension stacked on top of their home-country pension.
4. Justice: Lottery Judges & Total Transparency
To make bribing or intimidating the courts impossible:
Case-by-Case Lottery: Every member nation submits a high-court judge into a global pool, each assigned a number. When a case hits the docket, 6 judge numbers are drawn at random via verifiable public lottery and flown in immediately. Nobody knows who the judges will be until the trial starts (4 of 6 required to convict).
Live Global Broadcasts: Every trial is broadcast live worldwide. The prosecution is required to present all evidence, bank records, shell companies, and money trails publicly—exposing the entire criminal network, not just the figurehead.
Dual-Lock Sovereign Prisons: Convicted leaders and cartel bosses are sent to Union-owned prisons on remote sovereign islands (or landlocked compounds with sovereign Union airstrips for instant air-evacuation). They are guarded internally by Union Peacekeepers and externally by host-nation security—meaning zero local pardons and zero bribes.
5. Strategic Defense & The Exit Penalty
Collective Nuclear Umbrella + The Constellation Pact: The Union owns zero nuclear weapons itself, but an attack on any member triggers collective defense from all nuclear-armed members. This is backed by the Constellation Pact—a Union-funded low-Earth orbit satellite shield designed to detect and intercept ballistic missiles during their boost phase.
The "Hotel California" Exit Clause: If a corrupt president tries to pull their country out of the Union right after absorbing Union tech—or right before being arrested—the country is automatically unplugged from the shared energy grid, cut off from global trade, and hit with asset freezes. Meanwhile, the arrest warrant for the corrupt leader remains active permanently in every Union state.
Try to Break It
I know this is still a rough draft and needs work. If you were a corrupt dictator, a rogue superpower, or a multi-billion-dollar cartel trying to exploit or destroy this Union from the inside or outside, where is the weakest link, and how would you patch it?
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/MatriarchalFinalForm • 2d ago
Starting a conversation. Social and Political Philosophy Topic.
Proposal and thesis:
This paper will be discussing the rise of Christian nationalism in Democratic America and how it got its beginning in our society.
Christian nationalism fundamentally undermines the core principle of religious liberty by using state power to codify a singular theological framework, thereby violating the democratic requirement of state neutrality and threatening the freedom of conscience for religious minorities, racial minorities and non-believers alike. Where do we draw the line between freedom ‘to’ and freedom ‘from’ religious practice in the American civic and every day personal life? Also, we will be analyzing the bible through its Hebrew roots, and its manipulation by white Evangelical Christians in the name of ‘white Jesus’ and white supremacy and where they meet.
Possible Titles:
1. Paparazzi for White Jesus
2. The Least Most of These
3. The Blasphemy of Blasphemy
4. Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Christian Nationalism
5. (WWBJD) What Would Brown Jesus Do?
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/ItsameFuture_Phoenix • 2d ago
Part Two: The Repetition of Humanity
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/SonsuzAsama_1962 • 2d ago
Supranational Unity and the Right to Life for All Beings ( Part 2 of 4 )
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/I_Hate_This_Website9 • 2d ago
Is Coloniality of Power Correct?
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Mister_Ape_1 • 3d ago
Is this Social Democracy or Democratic Socialism ?
I am a self identified Social Democrat, but I feel in a way I am also an Evolutionary Democratic Socialist with Techno Socialist influence.
I believe for present day and likely the next century Capitalism, but with progressively heavier socialistic policies, is the way to go. I believe the state should have a massive role in boosting economics and helping the disadvantaged, and should take the money it needs from taxing the rich. Social programs targeted to the working class, creation of work places, investments, universal free healthcare and decently high minimum salary per hour are paramount to me.
But I also believe that in a distant future some form of scientific, marxian Socialism may become the optimal economic system. I am not quite sure yet about what will we need to get to that point, but very recently I realized that AI and automation might have a huge role into bringing us to the point we will be ready for actual Socialism.
What I am sure about is that every advancement, both within Capitalism and in transitioning from Capitalism to Socialism, MUST be achieved through democracy and reform. I could NEVER justify revolutionary discourse, no matter what, and violence in general.
Even in wolrd politics I am a radical pacifist, but I am also pro European Union and pro United Nations. I am 100% for global diplomacy and cooperation. I am however against NATO and USA imperialism in general.
I am part of the pro AI and pro tech Left. I see most of the Left is environmentalist, and I am quite concerned with climatic change too actually, but for me technological progress should never be halted, especially because I see it as the only actual way to save the environment.
Culturally I am a progressive, and I link it to technological advancement. I see progress as costant improvement in regards of both morals, equality in socio-economic conditions, technological development and scientific knowledge. It makes no sense to progress in some areas and stagnate in others to me. And yet, overall, I am more oriented toward the working class in general rather than toward minorities in the usual sense.
I am generally pro civil rights, with a residual conservative view only when it comes to abortion, and even that is not something I ever actually act upon. I never protest against abortion rights. I am 100% a supporter of civil unions, open to same gender marriage, open to same gender families adopting children, open to gender affirming therapy (even though I believe actual hormone treatment should be considered only for legally adult people), open to legalization of light drugs, open to most LGBTQ+ topics and reforms. But while I am 100% OK with all of that, I think the economic needs of the lower classes are paramount and are a better symbol for the Left as a whole.
At the same time I am also a Catholic of the progressive, 2nd Vatican Council kind. I do not feel at home with pre 1960's Catholicism, or with modern Tradcaths, or with Orthodoxy or any Protestant confessions.
I am extremely pro science, I read the Bible as a metaphorical work written by Iron Age religious men, with everything this entails. I am a huge supporter of Evolution Theory and not even in the "theistic evolution" sense. I fully accept evolutionary science and I also believe in God, without seeing the two as related in any way. I believe we can only be sure of empirical data and I believe in God out of free, personal choice. I do not think we could ever be 100% sure of God's existence and I regard a fully atheistic, fully materialistic model of reality as the most parsimonious explanation, but I reckon theistic monotheism as superior in terms of coherence and parsimony to any other supernatural model, and, to me, the Pascal wager argument makes the pendulum end up swinging toward theistic belief; finally, I see Catholicism as historically the most consistent theistic religion/philosophy. That is why I am a believer and a Catholic.
As a result I never try to convince anyone of my religion, because I reckon we should try to convince people about something only when we are supported by heavy, hard evidence.
In general, religion has basically 0% influence on my politics. I even see Papal bills against Socialism as not eternally valid, but rather as necessarily related to the time they were made.
So, overall I am a self identified Social Democrat, but I have Democratic Socialist tendencies and Techno Socialist influences. I am also more invested in working class struggle than minorities struggle even though I support both, and I am way more pro tech and less environment centric than most modern Left.
Do you think I should keep identifying myself as a Social Democrat, or should I change ?
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Helderheld • 4d ago
Interview with economics professor Nicolaus Tideman on the right to one's self, the land value tax, and other related topics.
Nic is a fourth generation Georgist and done important work on both the land value tax and voting theory. He teaches Economic Justice at Virginia tech, and still writes on political philosophy, more specifically on "the right to one's self" as the first principle to base cooperation and governments on. Enjoy: https://youtu.be/RknB10SG_gw
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/deltaensuper • 4d ago
Can a society be both free and equal? I compared 7 countries to see where each one put the "balance point"
I've been thinking about Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain argument: start with a perfectly equal distribution, let people choose freely, and inequality comes back on its own. If that's right, freedom and equality pull in opposite directions, and every society has to pick a point on the scale.
So I looked at where seven countries actually landed, using Freedom House scores, Gini (before and after taxes), wealth concentration and housing data:
- Denmark: market inequality close to the US before taxes (Gini 0.445), but 0.268 after. Equality "manufactured" after the fact, at the price of a 60.5% top tax rate and the Law of Jante.
- Singapore: 91% home ownership and the freest economy in the Heritage index, but 48/100 on political freedom and ethnic quotas on who can buy your flat.
- Cuba: equality as the founding promise, but the average state salary is ~13 USD/month and 1 in 10 people have left since 2021.
- Russia: neither. Freedom score of 12, and the top 1% holds ~48% of the wealth.
My tentative conclusion: the more useful question isn't how much freedom vs. equality a society has, but who gets to move the balance point. Democracies can vote to change it; one-party states can't even argue about it.
Where would you push back? Is the trade-off framing itself wrong (e.g. capability approach, relational egalitarianism)?
I turned this into a 15-min video essay with fictional characters built from the real numbers, if anyone prefers that format: https://youtu.be/b74k7lTA9Ew
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Original-Bee-3398 • 4d ago
Welcome to r/Onopticon — Start here: questions, concepts and a reading guide
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/Original-Bee-3398 • 5d ago
Welcome to r/Onopticon — Start here: questions, concepts and a reading guide
Welcome. I am Hakkı Tan, an independent researcher in sociology and critical theory and the author of the research discussed here.
This community begins with a question: how much power do people and societies have to change the conditions under which they must decide?
The Reality Paradigm examines how power structures the conditions of recognition, access, participation and refusal before an individual decision takes place. Onopticon investigates compulsory recognition and weak effective contestation, and how connections across domains or feedback sustain the closure of practical alternatives. A database, an algorithm or an inconvenient rule does not, by itself, establish this diagnosis.
Decision health is our shared point of inquiry: the capacity to form purposes, evaluate, act, refuse, revise decisions and reshape common conditions. Related discussions include Homovictimus, corporate constitutive power, state mediation and Cytopolitics.
WHERE TO START
Survival Is Not Living: Power Is Rewriting the Rules of Engagement — an entry into the relationship between survival, power and decision health.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/survival-is-not-living
2. The Cytopolitics Manifesto — organised exposure, bodily conditions and the capacity to disengage.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/cytopolitics-manifesto
3. The Human Relationship with Time — learning, self-questioning and the responsibility to change.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/human-relationship-with-time
For the Onopticon papers and the wider English/Turkish research archive:
HOW TO PARTICIPATE
Bring a question, a documented case, a close reading or a reasoned criticism. Identify the claim you are discussing, cite sources where possible, and distinguish evidence from interpretation. Agreement with my framework is not a condition of participation. Critique arguments without personal attacks, and explain the relevance of links you share.
English and Turkish contributions are welcome. Türkçe ve İngilizce katkılarınızı bekliyorum.
To begin: where have you encountered a formal right to refuse without a workable alternative? What would have made that refusal effective?
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/UpsetHome7097 • 5d ago
“Then institutional evil depends on distance,” Oliver said.
reddit.comr/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/SimplyTesting • 5d ago
Shame And Guilt As Methods Of Social Control
Like shii why did Eve take the apple we could have been a sacred species. Anyway peer pressure and conformity are one way for the pack to maintain control over their members. For the individual these forces are experienced as shame and guilt. By picking at deviant behaviors they can corral the pack and improve cohesion. This is like a liquid flowing in parallel or a highway that is running smoothly. It's nothing personal - except for when it is!
In the past, the populists would embody their values. They wore armbands, adorned their weapons, and held up their flags for all to see. They were united against their enemy. This has nothing to do with today... Now they wear uniforms like a herd of mammals without a home or a future. And it's so upsetting when people choose not to wear the uniform expected of them. This is an offense not only visually but morally. Do you not believe in the pack? And if not the pack, what heresy do you believe in? Spell it out for them to judge.
It's a moral panic. They feel things inside themselves, which they can't vocalize, and which they lack the power to address. But your uniform. Your hair. Your nationality, ethnicity, religion, race... These are a problem that needs resolved, in their eyes and in their hearts. They will fix you and make you right. And if not, they can regress from democracy: the harlot can be burned at the stake, the pauper can be quartered, the gays can be shocked into line. To them this is humane, a way to improve their society when things feel beyond their control. The martyr and scapegoat can always take the fall.
So what starts as a cultural preference very quickly becomes a justification for picking at others. Maybe with jeers, insults, violence, withholding resources, or the weaponization of infrastructure. This structural framework is a cudgel to selectively target certain people while leaning on the false pretense of their public image. All this in service of the collective, for they are successful, they are prideful, they know the ideal way to live, and by god will they force it upon you with or without your cooperation.
There are alternatives: Reform and cooperation. Conversation and connection. Building bridges to burn later. Sending along a trojan horse filled with xmas shaped chocolates. You know, whatever works at the time. JEEZE. I'm not a doomer I promise, I've just seen them do this over and over again throughout history.
For reference those who speak against power structures oft fall victim to Testimonial Injustice via Institutional Complaints. In other words, speaking to current issues will initially be minimized and attributed to your person, such as shooting the messenger via scapegoating. Any deviation in belief or practice can be handled in this way. Ultimately this creates a feedback loop that regresses toward conformity and populism. This ignorance and censorship is an excuse for people to continue to believe misguided things and to impose those misguided beliefs onto others.
r/PoliticalPhilosophy • u/mediamakeryt • 5d ago
Political theory and creative mediums
I recently came across this video by jazz musician, video essayist, and music theory communicator Adam Neely, which critiques recent comments from the front man of the heavy metal band Metallica, James Hetfield basically claiming to "stay" away from politics at any of their performances. Neely argues that as a communal practice, there is an inherent need in music to make decisions within an ensemble, analyzing the systems used in different genres (rock, classical, jazz) and connecting them to some forms of government (majoritarian/consensus democracy, autocracy, and anarchy respectively). Neely also discusses the impact of money and how it many influence (or pervert) these decision-making processes.
I found it to be an interesting (albeit informal) look into the intersection between political theory and music theory, and I wanted hear your thoughts on the ideas presented in this video. I also wanted to know if there are more in-depth or academic examinations connecting political theory with music theory or other fields like film, literary theory, the arts, ludology, the philosophy of sport, etc.