r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 25 '26

Yes, It’s Fascism

212 Upvotes

​​“Until recently, I resisted using the F-word to describe President Trump,” Jonathan Rauch argues. “For one thing, there were too many elements of classical fascism that didn’t seem to fit. For another, the term has been overused to the point of meaninglessness, especially by left-leaning types who call you a fascist if you oppose abortion or affirmative action. For yet another, the term is hazily defined, even by its adherents.” https://theatln.tc/aGWV2dc9 

But “over Trump’s past year, what originally looked like an effort to make the government his personal plaything has drifted distinctly toward doctrinal and operational fascism,” Rauch argues. “Trump’s appetite for lebensraum, his claim of unlimited power, his support for the global far right, his politicization of the justice system, his deployment of performative brutality, his ostentatious violation of rights, his creation of a national paramilitary police—all of those developments bespeak something more purposeful and sinister than run-of-the-mill greed or gangsterism.”

Fascism “is ideological, aggressive, and, at least in its early stages, revolutionary. It seeks to dominate politics, to crush resistance, and to rewrite the social contract,” Rauch writes. One can object that certain elements of classical European fascism are not found in Trumpism, but the exercise of comparing fascism’s various forms is not precise, Rauch continues: “Trump is building something new on old principles. He is showing us in real time what 21st-century American fascism looks like.”

“Recent events have brought Trump’s governing style into sharper focus. ‘Fascist’ best describes it, and reluctance to use the term has now become perverse,” Rauch continues. “That is not because of any one or two things he and his administration have done but because of the totality. Fascism is not a territory with clearly marked boundaries but a constellation of characteristics. When you view the stars together, the constellation plainly appears.”

Read more: https://theatln.tc/aGWV2dc9 

📸: Tom Brenner / Getty

— Emma Williams, associate editor, audience and engagement, The Atlantic


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jun 02 '21

Why randomly choosing people to serve in government - sortition - may be the best way to select our politicians

133 Upvotes

I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature. Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism. How could we possibly trust ignorant, stupid, normal people to become our leaders?

Democracy by Lottery

Imagine a Congress that actually looks like America. It's filled with nurses, farmers, engineers, waitresses, teachers, accountants, pastors, soldiers, stay-at-home-parents, and retirees. They are conservatives, liberals, and moderates from all parts of the country and all walks of life.

In the most commonly discussed implementation of sortition, lottery would be used to construct a legislature. Random sampling would be used to draw around 100 to 1000 people to form a house of Congress. Service would be voluntary, for a fixed term, and be well paid. From there, the selected people would have the responsibilities and powers of any elected legislature. These sorts of legislatures would have substantial advantages against elected ones:

  • Because of random sampling, a sortition Citizens' Assembly would have superior diversity in every conceivable dimension compared to any elected system, including race, class, sex, religion, ideology, cognitive ability, profession, and anything else you can think of. Sortition is therefore the ultimate method of creating a proportionally representative Congress.

  • Without the threat of elections demanding ideological purity, a sortition assembly is better able to compromise with their fellow citizens and reach consensus.

  • Without the need for elections, legislators no longer need to waste time campaigning but can rather focus their time on their actual job.

  • Legal bribery in the form of campaign donations is eliminated.

  • The nature of lottery creates a more egalitarian Congress ruled by regular people rather than the elites of society.

  • The nature of lottery possibly crushes the formation of political parties - parties that often form due to strategic campaigning needs to win elections.

Real World Evidence

Sortition is not a shower-thought. Sortition is thousands of years old and is the topic of active investigation by political scientists. Hundreds of sortition-based Citizens' Assemblies across the world have already been conducted. The decisions they have come to have been of high quality in my opinion. For example:

  • In Ireland, Citizen Assemblies were instrumental in the legalization of both gay marriage and abortion in a traditionally Catholic country. These assemblies were used to resolve politically volatile subjects so that fearful politicians would not have to.

  • Recent 2019-2020 Citizen Assemblies in Ireland and France reached consensus on sweeping, broad reforms to fight climate change. In Ireland taxes on carbon and meat were broadly approved. In France the People decided to criminalize "ecocide", raise carbon taxes, and introduce regulations in transportation and agriculture. Liberal or conservative, left or right, near unanimous decisions were made on many of these proposals.

  • The BC Columbia Citizens Assembly was tasked with designing a new electoral system to replace the old first-past-the-post (FPTP) system. The organizers brought in university experts. The organizers also allowed citizens, lobbyists, and interest groups to speak and lobby. Assembly members listened to all the sides, and they decided that the lobbyists were mostly bullshit, and they decided that even though the university experts had biases, they were more trustworthy. This assembly ultimately, nearly unanimously decided that Canada ought to switch to a Single-Transferable-Vote style election system. They were also nearly unanimous in that they believed FPTP voting needed to be changed. This assembly demonstrates the ability of normal people to learn and make decisions on complex topics.

The usage of sortition has also been documented in many societies:

  • The greatest known example of sortition is its use in ancient Athens, where lottery was used to select magistrates, legislative councils, and the People's Court.

  • Sortition was also used in combination with elections for the selection of leadership in Renaissance-era Italian City States such as a Venice and Florence.

  • Examples of sortition have also been documented to be used in Indian tribes. In these tribes, sortition results in an egalitarian government where power is shared. When elections were introduced into these societies however, the author observed the rise in power hierarchies and even "toxic masculinity".

In these societies, you will find echoes of the claims I made above. Political parties in these societies are weak. Concentrations of power are reduced.

Comparing to Elections

All electoral methods are a system of choosing a "natural aristocracy" of societal elites. This has been claimed by philosophers such as Aristotle since ancient Greek elections 2400 years ago. Elections are biased in favor of those with wealth, affluence, and power.

Moreover all voters, including you and me, are rationally ignorant. We don't have the time nor resources to adequately monitor and manage our politicians. On average we vote ignorantly, oftentimes solely due to party affiliation, or the name or gender of the candidate, rather than actual qualification. We assume somebody else is doing the monitoring, and hopefully we'd read about it in the news. And yes, it is somebody else. Marketers, advertisers, lobbyists, and specialists pay huge sums of money to influence your opinion and construct your news reality. Every elections is a hope that we can refine our ignorance into competence. IN CONTRAST, in sortition, normal citizens are given the time, resources, and education to become informed using the process of deliberative democracy. Normal citizens are given the opportunity to deliberate with one another and come to compromise. IN CONTRAST, politicians constantly refuse to compromise for fear of upsetting ignorant voters - voters who did not have the time nor opportunity to research the issues in depth. Our modern, shallow, ignorant management of politicians has led to an era of unprecedented polarization, deadlock, and government ineptitude.

Implementations

There are many forms which sortition could take. I list some from least to most extreme:

  • The least extreme is the use of Citizen Assemblies or Deliberative Polling in an advisory capacity for legislatures or referendums. Examples of these have been implemented in Ireland, the UK, France. They have also been implemented in Oregon in the form of "Citizens Initiative Review" (CIR). Here, a random body of Oregonians are tasked with reviewing ballot propositions and giving referendum voters information about the propositions.

  • A hybrid, two-house Congress has been proposed where one house is chosen by lottery while the other remains elected. This system attempts to balance the pro's and con's of both sortition and election, and use both as checks and balances against each other.

  • Rather than have citizens directly govern, random citizens can be used exclusively as intermediaries to elect and fire politicians as a sort of electoral college. The benefit here is that citizens are given the time and resources to deploy a traditional hiring & managing procedure to make political appointments. This system removes the typical criticism that you can't trust normal people to govern and write laws.

  • Most radically, multi-body sortition constructs checks and balances by creating several sortition bodies - one decides on what issues to tackle, one makes proposals, one decides on proposals, one selects the bureaucracy, etc, and completely eliminates elected office.


TLDR: Selecting random people to become legislators might seem ridiculous to some people, but I think it's the best possible system of representation and democracy we can imagine.


References

  1. Reybrouck, David Van. Against Elections. Seven Stories Press, April 2018.

  2. Hansen, Mogens Herman. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes (J.A. Crook trans.). University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.

  3. Dahl, Robert A. On Democracy, 2nd Ed. Yale University Press, 1998.

  4. The End of Politicians - Brett Hennig

  5. Open Democracy - Helene Landemore

  6. TG Bouricious - Democracy through multi-body sortition: Athenian lessons for the modern day

  7. Gastil, Wright - Legislature by lot: envisioning Sortition within a bicameral system

  8. Y Sintomer - From deliberative to radical democracy? Sortition and politics in the twenty-first century

  9. A Shal - What if we selected our leaders by lottery? Democracy by sortition, liberal elections and communist revolutionaries

Resources

Podcasts


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jun 10 '18

The Paradox of Tolerance by Karl Popper

Post image
119 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Aug 08 '19

John Locke an essay concerning human understanding printed in 1690

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 25 '21

Need texts regarding state authority in the wake of pandemics, texts surrounding state authority to limit the conduct of citizens in such/similar circumstances, and other texts which deal with societal ethics/obligations to others in times of crisis.

100 Upvotes

Hello hello, I'm conducting a political philosophy discussion this Friday about the "Politics of COVID-19" and I wanted to engage with various texts regarding state authority in the wake of pandemics, texts surrounding state authority to limit the conduct of citizens in such/similar circumstances, and other texts which deal with societal ethics/obligations to others in times of crisis. Please link any of your thoughts or, ideally, articles that discuss this issue ASAP. Thank you!


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 17 '19

This might belong here...

Post image
98 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 29 '26

MAGA’s War on Empathy by Hillary Rodham Clinton

76 Upvotes

The Trump administration's “war on empathy,” Hillary Clinton writes, “threatens to pave the way for an extreme vision of Christian nationalism that seeks to replace democracy with theocracy in America."

The chaos in Minneapolis revealed “a deeper moral rot at the heart of Trump’s MAGA movement,” Clinton continues. “Whatever you think about immigration policy, how can a person of conscience justify the lack of compassion and empathy for the victims in Minnesota, and for the families torn apart or hiding in fear, for the children separated from their parents or afraid to go to school?”

“That compassion is weak and cruelty is strong has become an article of MAGA faith,” Clinton argues. “The glorification of cruelty and rejection of compassion don’t just shape the Trump administration’s policies. Those values are also at the core of Trump’s own character and worldview. And they have become a rallying cry for a cadre of hard-right ‘Christian influencers’ who are waging a war on empathy.”

“I’ve never been one to wear my faith on my sleeve, but that doesn’t mean it’s not important to me. Quite the opposite: My faith has sustained me, informed me, saved me, chided me, and challenged me. I don’t know who I would be or where I would have ended up without it. So I am not a disinterested observer here,” Clinton writes. “I believe that Christians like me—and people of faith more generally—have a responsibility to stand up to the extremists who use religion to divide our society and undermine our democracy.”

“I know empathy isn’t easy. But neither is Christianity,” Clinton continues. “When Jesus called on us to turn the other cheek and pray for those who persecute us, it was supposed to be hard. We fail more than we succeed—we’re human—but the discipline is to keep trying.”

Read more: https://theatln.tc/7UrwABI6

— Emma Williams, associate editor, audience and engagement, The Atlantic


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 17 '19

How accurate is the following political spectrum?

Post image
73 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Sep 28 '20

Do Libertarians have the most adolescent political philosophy?

68 Upvotes

By "adolescent," I mean "emotionally or intellectually immature" as it is described by Merriam-Webster. I don't think there is a political philosophy more evocative of a vapid freshman dorm room conversation than Libertarianism. My political views are pretty left-wing, but I still think conversations with conservatives happen within real-world parameters. On social issues, conservatives value social cohesion and tradition over tolerance and inclusivity. I think they get everything wrong, but at the very least, they're concerned with how politics will affect society and the individuals in it. Also, their views about the consequences of progressive policies aren't absurd or dissociative. Concerns regarding the coercion of Christian bakers and pastors vis-a-vis gay weddings are well-founded. I believe the practice of equal treatment and inclusivity is more important than the practice of one's religious beliefs, so forcing Christians to bake cakes is justified. However, conservatives believe religion is more important than equality, so they disagree. In any case, we're talking about the real world. On economic issues, conservatives will say tax-cuts and lower public debt will lead to faster growth, rising wages, and greater material well-being for citizens. I do not believe this is the best way to organize an economy (and most economists agree with me), but at least conservative beliefs are concerned with the actual implications of policies.

When I talk to Libertarians or hear them speak, I'm met with nothing but thought experiments, abstractions and reductio ad absurdum. If I describe the benefits of a policy, I get the response, "How nice does a prison have to be for you to give up your liberties?" I really don't know what to do with this. For that matter, I don't know how to respond this refrain: "Taxation is theft." Giving up some of some of one's income to pay for another person's healthcare or law enforcement is a way of optimizing a society's well-being. Sure, we don't individually agree to our marginal tax rates, but what makes a society coherent (and not Neolithic) is the fact that we have certain obligations to one another. A conservative may say taxation is not practical, but I think few would compare it to a crime. There's really no way to talk to a Libertarian — even about less consequential issues — without arriving at an abstract hypothetical about a totally different subject. I can't wrap my head around the thought that violations of liberty are more consequential that making sure people are well-fed, educated, healthy, and ultimately happy. Again, I think conservatives are concerned with happiness and well-being, but their strategies are bad. On the other hand, Libertarians are concerned with the most minor infractions of an abstract ideology, and don't care how practicing their fundamentalist philosophy would change lives. They seem to have no interest in solving any problems, and I ultimately view them all as teenage-caliber thinkers.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Feb 20 '20

AOC: Yeah, I’ve been sitting with this. Genuinely asking, if your candidate - Biden, Buttigieg, Warren, Klobuchar etc - clearly had the most votes and the most delegates, why shouldn’t they be the nominee? And what do folks envision as a fair and just alternative in doing otherwise?

Thumbnail
twitter.com
65 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 07 '17

How to tell the semester is coming to an end.

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Nov 28 '18

What Is ‘Globohomo’? An essay discussing a concept in contemporary Internet culture

Thumbnail
vjmpublishing.nz
58 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 10 '26

What Stephen Miller Gets Wrong About Human Nature, by Gal Beckerman

56 Upvotes

Gal Beckerman: “If you want to know a political leader’s governing philosophy, you could cut through a lot of bluster by just asking them who their guy is: John Locke or Thomas Hobbes? Anyone who’s taken Poli Sci 101 will understand what this means. The 17th-century philosophers each offered a picture of human nature in its rawest form, and they came to different conclusions. Locke, whose ideas were central to the birth of modern democracy, thought that people were capable of reason and moral judgment. Hobbes, on the other hand, believed that we were vicious creatures who needed to be protected from ourselves by a powerful king. Whether a leader is Lockean or Hobbesian really does set the table for the kind of government they want.

“One way to understand the head-spinning nature of being an American over the past couple of decades is that this debate—one that history seemed to have settled in Locke’s favor—is alive again. Barack Obama was a Lockean through and through—insisting, repeatedly, that if citizens were just given accurate information and a fair hearing, they would converge on something like the common good. Then came Donald Trump, Hobbesian extraordinaire, who has often portrayed life under anyone’s leadership but his own much as Hobbes describes the state of nature: ‘solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.’ (Nasty is even one of Trump’s favorite words.)

“Comments this week from Stephen Miller, the influential deputy chief of staff often cast as the president’s ‘brain,’ only reinforced this impression. Miller might have been Hobbes in a skinny tie as he confidently articulated what he understood to be the ‘iron laws of the world since the beginning of time.’ His monologue was like something out of the English philosopher’s 1651 political treatise, Leviathan: ‘We live in a world, in the real world,” he said, “that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power.’

“Miller’s might-makes-right declaration came after Trump’s decision to overthrow the president of Venezuela, and in anticipation of the United States possibly acquiring Greenland from Denmark, perhaps by any means necessary (a notion that Miller’s wife found fit to turn into a meme). The will to dominate, seize other countries’ resources because you can, and generally bully those that can’t fight back is nothing to worry about, Miller reassured Americans: This is the natural state of things. This is how it all works. Power does what it wants. The rest is commentary and toothless United Nations resolutions—or, as he put it, ‘international niceties.’

“Miller might as well etch Hobbes’s words onto a gold plaque ready to hang among other gilded tchotchkes in the Oval Office: ‘During the time men live without a common power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which is called war; and such a war, as is of every man, against every man.’

“Hobbes helps explain the dog-eat-dog worldview of this administration—if you stop reading there. Dive in a little more, though, and you’ll find that he’s not exactly a fan of this state of affairs. By describing our natural condition as fearful, insecure, and frankly pretty terrifying—an existence of constantly watching your back—Hobbes was diagnosing a problem. Left to our own devices, without any institutions or government, we would not have any culture or science or peace. This thought experiment was his starting point, and it also helped fuel the Enlightenment then just under way.”

Read more: https://theatln.tc/ynVTiZyz


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 09 '25

How Hitler Dismantled a Democracy in 53 Days

56 Upvotes

Timothy W. Ryback:  “Ninety-two years ago this month, on Monday morning, January 30, 1933, Adolf Hitler was appointed the 15th chancellor of the Weimar Republic. In one of the most astonishing political transformations in the history of democracy, Hitler set about destroying a constitutional republic through constitutional means. What follows is a step-by-step account of how Hitler systematically disabled and then dismantled his country’s democratic structures and processes in less than two months’ time—specifically, one month, three weeks, two days, eight hours, and 40 minutes. The minutes, as we will see, mattered. https://theatln.tc/0kbestj8

“Hans Frank served as Hitler’s private attorney and chief legal strategist in the early years of the Nazi movement. While later awaiting execution at Nuremberg for his complicity in Nazi atrocities, Frank commented on his client’s uncanny capacity for sensing ‘the potential weakness inherent in every formal form of law’ and then ruthlessly exploiting that weakness. Following his failed Beer Hall Putsch of November 1923, Hitler had renounced trying to overthrow the Weimar Republic by violent means but not his commitment to destroying the country’s democratic system, a determination he reiterated in a Legalitätseid—’legality oath’—before the Constitutional Court in September 1930. Invoking Article 1 of the Weimar constitution, which stated that the government was an expression of the will of the people, Hitler informed the court that once he had achieved power through legal means, he intended to mold the government as he saw fit. It was an astonishingly brazen statement.

“‘So, through constitutional means?’ the presiding judge asked.

“‘Jawohl!’ Hitler replied.

“By January 1933, the fallibilities of the Weimar Republic—whose 181-article constitution framed the structures and processes for its 18 federated states—were as obvious as they were abundant. Having spent a decade in opposition politics, Hitler knew firsthand how easily an ambitious political agenda could be scuttled. He had been co-opting or crushing right-wing competitors and paralyzing legislative processes for years, and for the previous eight months, he had played obstructionist politics, helping to bring down three chancellors and twice forcing the president to dissolve the Reichstag and call for new elections …”

“We have come to perceive Hitler’s appointment as chancellor as part of an inexorable rise to power, an impression resting on generations of postwar scholarship, much of which has necessarily marginalized or disregarded alternatives to the standard narrative of the Nazi seizure of power (Machtergreifung) with its political and social persecutions, its assertion of totalitarian rule (Gleichschaltung) and subsequent aggressions that led to the Second World War and the nightmare of the Holocaust. In researching and writing this piece, I intentionally ignored these ultimate outcomes and instead traced events as they unfolded in real time with their attendant uncertainties and misguided assessments … Both Hitler’s ascendancy to chancellor and his smashing of the constitutional guardrails once he got there, I have come to realize, are stories of political contingency rather than historical inevitability.”

Read more: https://theatln.tc/0kbestj8


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Nov 24 '12

What is on your top 10 list of political philosophy must-reads?

56 Upvotes

Trying to assemble a reading list for myself. I've studied many of the typical ones but I'm trying to find more books to study, with an emphasis on contemporary works.

(Works I've read: Plato's Republic, Hobbes' Leviathan, Nietzche's Geneaology, Machiavelli's Prince, Kant's Universal History, Hegel's Philosophy of Right, Marx's Communist Manifesto & some Locke)

Edit: thank you so much to everyone who added their 2 cents and everyone yet to come :) I now have an excellent list to tackle


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Feb 06 '20

Welcome to /r/PoliticalPhilosophy! Please Read before posting.

55 Upvotes

Lately we've had an influx of posts that aren't directly focused on political philosophy. Political philosophy is a massively broad topic, however, and just about any topic could potentially make a good post. Before deciding to post, please read through the basics.

What is Political Philosophy?

To put it simply, political philosophy is the philosophy of politics and human nature. This is a broad topic, leading to questions about such subjects as ethics, free will, existentialism, and current events. Most political philosophy involves the discussion of political theories/theorists, such as Aristotle, Hobbes, or Rousseau (amongst a million others).

Can anyone post here?

Yes! Even if you have limited experience with political philosophy as a discipline, we still absolutely encourage you to join the conversation. You're allowed to post here with any political leaning. This is a safe place to discuss liberalism, conservatism, libertarianism, etc. With that said, posts and comments that are racist, homophobic, antisemitic, or bigoted will be removed. This does not mean you can't discuss these topics-- it just means we expect discourse to be respectful. On top of this, we expect you to not make accusations of political allegiance. Statements such as "typical liberal", "nazi", "wow you must be a Trumper," etc, are detrimental to good conversation.

What isn't a good fit for this sub

Questions such as;

"Why are you voting Democrat/Republican?"

"Is it wrong to be white?"

"This is why I believe ______"

How these questions can be reframed into a philosophic question

As stated above, in political philosophy most topics are fair game provided you frame them correctly. Looking at the above questions, here's some alternatives to consider before posting, including an explanation as to why it's improved;

"Does liberalism/conservatism accomplish ____ objective?"

Why: A question like this, particularly if it references a work that the readers can engage with provides an answerable question that isn't based on pure anecdotal evidence.

"What are the implications of white supremacy in a political hierarchy?" OR "What would _____ have thought about racial tensions in ______ country?"

Why: This comes on two fronts. It drops the loaded, antagonizing question that references a slogan designed to trigger outrage, and approaches an observable problem. 'Institutional white supremacy' and 'racial tensions' are both observable. With the second prompt, it lends itself to a discussion that's based in political philosophy as a discipline.

"After reading Hobbes argument on the state of nature, I have changed my belief that Rousseau's state of nature is better." OR "After reading Nietzsche's critique of liberalism, I have been questioning X, Y, and Z. What are your thoughts on this?"

Why: This subreddit isn't just about blurbing out your political beliefs to get feedback on how unique you are. Ideally, it's a place where users can discuss different political theories and philosophies. In order to have a good discussion, common ground is important. This can include references a book other users might be familiar with, an established theory others find interesting, or a specific narrative that others find familiar. If your question is focused solely on asking others to judge your belief's, it more than likely won't make a compelling topic.

If you have any questions or thoughts, feel free to leave a comment below or send a message to modmail. Also, please make yourself familiar with the community guidelines before posting.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Nov 10 '22

Why is populism seen as something bad by a lot of people who say that they support democracy?

54 Upvotes

Not only they support democracy, but put an emphasis on political engagement and representation. Yet lot of them dislike populism. What do you think, why is that?

Edit: THANK YOU for your answers


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 20 '21

Why Friedrich Nietzsche disliked the State “A state is called the coldest of all cold monsters. Coldly lieth it also, and this lie creepeth from its mouth: ‘I, the state, am the people.’”

Thumbnail
walden43200.com
53 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Apr 14 '22

“...in respect of riches, no citizen shall ever be wealthy enough to buy another, and none poor enough to be forced to sell himself.” -Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 12 '20

Why is Communism always seen as oppressive or authoritarian and free market capitalism is seen as freedom?

47 Upvotes

I want to start this post off by using the definition of communism.

Communism- "a political theory derived from Karl Marx, advocating class war and leading to a society in which all property is publicly owned and each person works and is paid according to their abilities and needs."

There has never been a communist society in human history and i think if it were to ever happen, i speculate it would be hundreds or thousands of years in the future.

I thought the idea of Communism would seem more oppressive to someone who is rich or has alot of wealth. Karl Marx saw a socialist or communist society as a dictatorship of the proliteriat. By dictatorship he doesn't mean like an autocratic society with one leader. He means the workers and peasants control the society. In feudalism, you had the dictatorship of the nobility, in capitalism we have the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie and in socialism or communism, its the dictatorship of the proliteriat. This was back in the 1840s and its still relative today.

Marx saw the fact that the boss who owns a property or business and hires an individual who sells his or her labor to the boss so he or she can make a profit and only shares very little of the profit with the worker as wages with which the worker requires to fulfill basic needs like food, water and shelter. Marx saw this as inherently oppresive. I think he has a point here. This is something that is basic in our society but when you think of it like that, it makes sense.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Feb 15 '13

Ronald Dworkin, brilliant philosopher of law who put human dignity at the centre of his moral system, is dead at 81

Thumbnail
guardian.co.uk
46 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Oct 29 '12

Obama Says Ayn Rand Is For Teens

Thumbnail
buzzfeed.com
46 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Sep 22 '11

I found audiobooks of some noteworthy works and speeches of political philosophy at LibriVox. Thought I'd share.

46 Upvotes

Some of the links lead to collections (typically collections of speeches), and you may have to scroll down until you find the specified file.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Sep 29 '19

META- Can we do something about the shitposting on this sub?

42 Upvotes

This is my favorite smaller sub, but I feel like over the past few months there's been a serious decline in quality contributions.

Lately I've seen a lot more clear troll posts that don't address any meaningful question. I've also seen more posts that are incoherent or a vehicle for the OP to try and voice their(usually poorly thought out)..."theories". I also feel like I've seen an uptick in posts that come from conservative users looking for a venue to argue in the comments (I'm not remotely opposed to thoughtful discussions about conservatism, but I also don't think flinging propaganda from conservative news sources makes for a thoughtful discussion).

I don't have any great ideas on how to run a sub, but I feel like a few changes in the rules could make a difference. A weekly pinned mega thread for political discussion could go a long way in slowing down the number of blatantly dumb questions that flood the subreddit. Also, limiting self-posts to discussions about specific articles, philosophers, or tailored questions about a text could potentially help control the quality. Setting up some basic rules about what a quality post looks like and employing stronger moderation would also probably go a long way.

I'm interested in hearing what other people in the community think about this, and whether anyone else thinks this is a problem worth addressing. I always think of this sub as having some great discussions, and I'd love to see it continue to grow in a healthy direction.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 16 '19

KGB dude sits and straight up explains how to take over a nation. 30 years ago, but sounds like today.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
42 Upvotes