r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Sep 07 '22

I am an Ego-Rawlsian

1 Upvotes

It is like normal Rawlsianism, but instead of believing that any unequal distribution of resources is permissible only if it benefits the least well-off person, I believe any unequal distribution of resources is permissible only if it benefits me personally and pleases my ego.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 14 '20

Two new parties for your local council and your nation, all around the political world. Part 1/5?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 30 '20

In defense of Capitalism

0 Upvotes

There seems to be a shift in the United States, maybe even the world. Bernie Sanders, who is proud to call himself a (democratic) socialist is evidence of this. Now, I like Bernie as a person. I truly believe him, and think he believes that he's doing the right thing. I also think Bernie is really good a identifying the problems that exist in our society. That being said, I think his solutions are garbage, but a fundamental lack of economic understanding underpins his popularity. It's as if a house was on fire, Bernie sees the house and points out the problem. However, his solution is to throw more gas on the fire. Republicans seem to just ignore the fire and so Bernie seems to be the only person with a solution (although it's only going to make things worse). I recently responded to a post

https://www.reddit.com/r/CatastrophicFailure/comments/euwgvz/on_28_april_1988_aloha_airlines_flight_243/fftunhb?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

Where u/BeamerTakesManhattan described the problems with capitalism. I had to respond, but I was wayy to late to get any traction. I feel like this little anecdote describes the conversation that needs to be had in society. I've posted my response below.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 25 '24

does west use propaganda and how does westerns view usa?

0 Upvotes

The West relies far more on coercive propaganda than anyone else, because their needs for propaganda are higher. Propaganda exists to sell a story. The West's "story" is that they are innocent, benign actors who always follow the rules and respect the law when engaging with other countries.

If Russia was engaging in Mexico, this would be universally denounced by the West, because Russia should not mess around in the West's neighborhood. But if NATO is active in Russia's neighborhood, this is fine, because the West only has good intentions.

If Russia spends any money to influence Western political campaigns, this is always wrong. If the US spends billions on influencing other countries' politics via NGO's, this is fine, because the West is simply trying to promote good democratic values.

Nobody is nearly as ambitious as the West when it comes to propaganda. There is no lie so big that the West cannot sell it: they can simultaneously do the most to undermine the global "rules based order" while claiming to be its greatest champion. They can invade a country based on a lie, kill a million people, and then - when the lie becomes inconvenient - pretend that the invasion was about something else entirely.

Nobody else is even close to being so audacious with their propaganda.

The Nazis had been experts on propaganda, but even they had limits. They concealed their genocidal activities, and pretended that people were being "resettled to the East". When the Nazis liquidated the Warsaw Ghetto, they didn't pretend it was anything but a wholesale slaughter.

It's quite astounding. Humanity has always been plagued with evil people in positions on f power, but we've never been confronted with such a diabolical cabal - who could steal food off your plate while simultaneously telling you that you're better off, and any shortages are due to somebody on the other side of the world


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 08 '17

#Truth

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Dec 01 '20

A democratic socialist state would inevitably become laissez-faire.

0 Upvotes

To start out, I feel I should define my terms really quickly, just to avoid confusion.

-Laissez-faire: A system of economics with little to no state interference.

-Capitalism: An economic system in which an economic class of non-workers owns the means of production.

-Socialism: An economic system in which the means of production are equally and collectively owned by the workers who use them.

My basic thesis is as such, in a socialist state workers at any given coop would be operating under conditions similar to modern business owners, and because of this they would most likely end up pushing for similar political outcomes, which is to say, deregulation and lower taxes.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 13 '22

The Pro-Life Position is Fundamentally a Liberal Stance

0 Upvotes

This would probably surprise many readers, but I believe the pro-life position is a fundamentally liberal one. I also want to add that this is not a critique per se, and I'm not implying on this basis alone that there's anything wrong with being pro-life or being liberal. However, I think conservatives, ironically, approach abortion from a very liberal worldview.

For what it's worth, I actually do believe life begins at conception. I'm also pro-choice. I think this worldview is very coherent, but I've never heard someone else describe it. Society is not organized to minimize avoidable deaths and avoidable suffering. It's organized, generally speaking, to maximize comfort. To say "It's wrong to kill someone" totally misrepresents society's relationship with death. We tolerate avoidable death and suffering every day. Life obviously doesn't have infinite value.

Lowering the speed limit would save lives, but we don't do this because people want to get places quickly. Abolishing nuts would prevent hundreds of people from dying, but we don't do this because Reese's Pieces taste good.

War is another good example. You could bring up self-defense, but if your goal were to minimize avoidable deaths, you probably wouldn't even fight defensive wars. But some offensive wars are justified. Take the American Civil War, for example. The Union did not invade the Confederacy in self-defense. Also, it knew that its own soldiers would die in the war, and it would have to kill men on the other side. Was this unjustified? No, because we accept that sometimes the sacrifice of innocent life is necessary for us to live in a better world.

The slaughter of animals is another example. Few people believe animal life has the same value as human life. But animal life clearly has some value. We somehow justify the killing of animals that takes place every day, probably because of taste and nutrition. The point is, society accepts death.

The utilitarian case for abortion is pretty simple. It reduces poverty and crime.

But when conservatives make the pro-life case, they just talk about the "killing" of an innocent life. That's not a conservative approach to problem-solving, it's a liberal one. There are four basic reasons, and they're all somewhat related: Being pro-life is (1) universal, (2) rights-based, (3) inconsistent with how the rest of society functions, and (4) doesn't have a pretension of a cost-benefit analysis. I'm going to beg the question that these are liberal traits, but I don't think that's very controversial. I think it's pretty foundational to say that conservatism emphasizes the importance of acting in accordance with societal norms that have developed over time, and being pro-choice fits that description very well. To genuinely value life as much as pro-lifers say they do, you would have to be a vegetarian pacifist, and that obviously doesn't describe most conservatives.

To make my point stronger, it's also important to point at that liberals don't make the pro-choice argument on utilitarian grounds. They always talk about the rights of women. So the abortion debate is a kind of caducean one, with both sides making liberal rights-based arguments.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Dec 06 '23

What do I call myself if I am Nationalist and a Socialist?

0 Upvotes

The resounding issue is that the term I would think of is National Socialist, but obviously thats very linked with a certain fascist ideology.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Feb 22 '21

What if people voted for ideologies instead of candidates?

0 Upvotes

The problems with candidates are numerous:

  1. You have to learn about them

  2. Zero chance they perfectly reflect your views

  3. They are selling solutions to laymans


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jan 31 '13

Question for anyone with a brain who wants to use it, concerning the American political paradigm.

0 Upvotes

I have a question for anybody with a brain who wants to use it: Do you think it is the natural course of the social dynamics of a nation of people to become polarized into two distinct socio-political groups, living together under the same laws and society, but completely alien to each others beliefs and values? Or, to rephrase: is the left-right paradigm of political ignorance, and the hate that often accompanies it, unavoidable?


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Oct 27 '16

Why don't we have a "Peace and Quiet Party"?

2 Upvotes

Isn't that what we all want?


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Dec 09 '16

Is Conservatism inherently stronger than Progressivism?

0 Upvotes

I think it is. The analogy I use is that a confederacy is weaker than a federated form of government. For example, when Jefferson Davis asked the Governor of Georgia for more troops the Governor said no. At this point Davis had no recourse. I don't think this happened to Lincoln. Conservatives tend to stay organized, progressives not so much. Conservatives seem to understand that politics is about doing the most good for the most people. They understand that society will have winners and losers. What do you all think? Am I totally offbase?


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Apr 04 '25

trump is simultaneously destroying and saving our country.

2 Upvotes

this is on a burner account bc i dont like talking about politics on my main.

Donald Trump's character and actions have been widely criticized, with many labeling him inherently a "bad man." However, his 2016 election victory, while deeply divisive, inadvertently exposed deep-seated flaws within the American political and social landscape. Prior to his presidency, a significant portion of the population maintained a degree of faith in the established systems, often operating under the assumption of inherent fairness and impartiality. Trump's ascendance shattered this illusion.

The period following his election, and particularly his inauguration, served as a catalyst for increased scrutiny of governmental institutions. Citizens began to question the integrity of various agencies and branches of government, revealing perceived corruption and systemic biases that had previously remained largely obscured. This heightened awareness wasn't solely a consequence of Trump's policies, but rather a byproduct of the unprecedented nature of his presidency, which challenged long-held norms and expectations.

Furthermore, the Trump era underscored the disproportionate influence of wealth in American society. The perception that substantial financial resources could effectively shield individuals from accountability and enable them to manipulate systems to their advantage became more pronounced. This observation extended beyond partisan lines, leading to broader discussions about income inequality and the potential for wealthy individuals to exert undue influence on political and legal processes.

The exposure of these systemic issues, while arguably a byproduct of a tumultuous presidency, prompted a national reckoning. It forced a reevaluation of the assumptions underlying American democracy and sparked conversations about reform and accountability. The realization that established systems were not as impervious to corruption or as equitable as previously believed led to increased civic engagement and calls for greater transparency. While the value of this exposure is debatable, and the damage done in the process is significant, it cannot be denied that the Trump presidency acted as a harsh, and for some, necessary, wake-up call.

His 2024 win, despite a litany of controversies, further amplifies these concerns, solidifying the argument that the system is deeply compromised. The fact that a candidate facing 34 felony indictments, multiple sexual assault allegations, two impeachment trials, and accusations of inciting an insurrection can still attain the highest office in the land raises profound questions about the integrity of the electoral process and the mechanisms designed to ensure accountability.

The sheer volume and severity of these allegations and actions would, in many contexts, disqualify an individual from holding public office. Yet, Trump's continued political viability underscores the power of wealth, media manipulation, and a deeply polarized electorate to override traditional norms and legal constraints. This outcome suggests that the system may be susceptible to manipulation by those with sufficient resources and influence, reinforcing the perception that money and power can effectively insulate individuals from consequences.

The 2024 election, in this context, becomes more than just a political event; it serves as a stark illustration of the perceived systemic corruption. It reinforces the notion that the rules and norms designed to protect the integrity of the democratic process may be inadequate in the face of determined individuals and powerful interests. The question then becomes: if these circumstances do not demonstrate systemic corruption, what would? This outcome forces a critical examination of the mechanisms designed to ensure accountability and the need for reforms to safeguard the integrity of the democratic process.

if Trump lot the 2024 election, america would have likely ushered in a period of relative peace and reduced societal division. However, this tranquility would have come at a cost: a continued, perhaps even deepened, ignorance of the systemic corruption plaguing American governance. Without the stark, undeniable evidence of his victory despite the overwhelming controversies, the public would likely remain complacent, unaware of the vulnerabilities within the system. The illusion of integrity would persist, masking the underlying issues that require urgent attention. While a less turbulent political landscape is desirable, it would have been built upon a foundation of unaddressed, and potentially worsening, corruption.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Apr 10 '19

Jordan Peterson has no idea what he's talking about

Thumbnail
ontheaside.com
15 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 06 '16

What do you guys think of this political platform?

0 Upvotes

Everyone gets a check in the mail each month for $1000 from the federal government. At the end of the year, that income ($12,000) is added to any other income a person makes (from any source). This is their total income. A person then subtracts $40,000 from their total income to get their taxable income. All taxable income is subject to a 50% flat tax.

So, Basic Income of $12,000 a year for all citizens. $40,000 tax free (including the basic income), then a flat 50% on the remainder. Someone who makes $50,000, for example, would pay $5,000 (10%) in taxes. Someone who makes $100,000 would pay $30,000 (30%). No deductions or exceptions.

Along with this would be a complete cut to all federal assitance programs like food stamps and housing since the basic income would make them obsolete, and the institution of medicare for all, or a single payer heath insurance run by the government.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Apr 02 '20

This may be the totally wrong place, but I have an idea for a political economic system, based heavily in my philosophies that could work

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I'm sorry if this is the inappropriate place to post this.

I came up with an idea for a flat-tax, community service based economic model that I believe could be, if not a solution, at least a decent start towards a prosperous system for most individuals. Challenging the argument that a flat-tax rate would not work in a society due to discrepancies in wage earnings, the bottom-earners having much more to lose than those at the top. To address these issues, I theorize that by allowing community service, charity work and charitable donations to be used as tax deductions, we could build a system that actually works. On paper, a flat-tax rate for all individuals, regardless of income would be, what I believe to be, of the most universally beneficial economic systems. I think that it only makes sense that if everyone is treated fairly and evenly at all levels, then the driving factors of success and innovation would remain intact as well. So by allowing anyone to earn their taxes back, by providing a service to their community, it would benefit the communities around the country, and help to ease the burden of tax dollars being spent on some public programs. If individuals staffing rescue centers, recreational centers, and other similar programs to be discussed later, were able to volunteer their time, while receiving a portion of their taxes back, then I believe that we could see some significant change. My theory is that over time, communities will continue to see benefit as their communities build around them, a society that addresses concerns most affecting their geographic location. Understandably not everyone will be able to benefit fiscally from this system, as there will always be outliers, but they should be able to receive the benefits of a stronger and more tight-knit community. I also think that if this program is successful, then over time one would expect to see most of their society begin to grow, as empathy and understanding begin to develop alongside with some tax savings.

The idea driving this is that everyone should be given a fair chance at life, a universal tax would not diminish the value of effort put in and by allowing those that may have some additional spare time (or make time for it) the chance to either reduce or reimburse themselves by assisting their communities. We have reached a point in time where the threads holding society together are fringed and the consequences of them being lost forever is something that we should try to avoid. Rural parts of the country are experiencing tragic losses due to the opioid crisis, whereas urban city centers are flooded with displaced homeless people. By being able to provide some additional resources to our neighbors, I believe that we could work together to eventually find some type of universal policies that could help everyone have an equal chance of taking on life, without suffering the consequences of multiple failed economic and political systems of the past. If we were to set up community based support systems, youth centers, recreational centers, community gardens, etc. we should be able to help out some of those that we are most able to help, and also probably need it more than anyone.

I think more so, now than ever recently, it has become apparent how desperately needed community is. However, I am relatively uneducated when it comes to economic figures, feasibility of this prospect and what the actual percentages would look like. If I were to throw a number out and say if everyone in a country was taxed at 15% of their income (all sources of income, dividends and capital gains included) I don't know what this figure would be, how it could be used most efficiently, etc. and that's why I'm asking for help.

I figure during this quarantine/pandemic period, someone out there might be bored enough to actually read this. And hell, maybe a person that reads this will actually agree with me or at least be willing to have a conversation. Who knows, maybe someone might actually help me too!

Well if you made it this far, thank you so much for reading this. I have been wracking my brain with this idea for a few months now and have had a lot of anxiety about telling anyone about it.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 19 '19

Social Capital and Social Justice: Why Liberalism Is Essential

Thumbnail journal.apee.org
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • May 07 '22

Why are voting rights not accompanied with obligations?

0 Upvotes

I think it is strange that the power to influence society by voting in elections comes with no cost to the individual. You can vote someone you like into power, yet you suffer no personal consequence for poor reasoning, and you do not have to prove your worth to society. No need to take any responsibility or do any kind of work that furthers society. Democracy feels mostly like a charade to keep appearances up. It could be different though, for example that you need to prove yourself to society before you get the vote.

Has this been tried anywhere? Any ideas of what ways someone would prove themselves? The novel Starship Troopers by Heinlein has an interesting fictional example. That society requires fulfilled military service to be able to vote.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Aug 09 '22

The Termite Philosophy

1 Upvotes

The idea is that society is like a giant ant hill and you collaborate with people who seem to have nothing in common just because you're both tearing away at the system. It's defining society based on a bunch of little cliques that simply eat away at it. While the mafia and Al Qaeda have nothing in common, they share a common desire to cause trouble. Thus there is a lot of infighting with people who actually practice the termite philosophy. It sounds funny but it can actually be practiced. It sounds funny but as per the rules I am actually being serious it just coincidentally is funny.

I'm not sure this post will make it through moderation because it's not about a famous philosopher. It's my own philosophy. But if it doesn't I'll just relocate it.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Aug 30 '21

Is Trump's Rhetorical Technique Drawn from Mein Kampf?

5 Upvotes

In prefix, I am obliged to point out a few rather trivial facts in response to the massive number of people who believe at least some USA Presidents are idiots, and that Hitler was no more than a raving maniac without any intellectual capacity:

  1. An individual does not become the most powerful person in the free world, or start a world war, by being an idiot. In fact, they might choose to appear as idiots, because the assumption they are idiots can greatly enhance their ability to manipulate other people.

  2. Any person who knows they are going to ad lib in speeches and debates, perhaps for up to three hours, first thinks out some reasoning on their opinion.

It's unfortunate I've been obliged to start with that, because most readers decide to vote and write comments after reading even less.

Hitler's Premise: Most People are Morons

Moving on. Hitler thought on rhetoric starts by dividing people into three classes: intellectuals, cynics, and the great masses. The first two groups are shackled by their own indecision and nihilism, Hitler stated, so they can be successfully ignored. The third group has no real interest in the faculty of reason and is instead driven by blind and blunt emotion. This is Hitler's premise, and justification for the premise: the vast majority of the great masses must be morons, because virtually everyone is incapable of exercising reason when it is in conflict with their emotions. Hitler sees no need for substantiation of that, it's presented as a self-evident observation.

To appeal to the all-important 'base' of this third and vastly larger group, Hitler stated, one must therefore design propositions that are understandable to the lowest-common denominator: the emotionally-driven moron. All statements of fact must both appeal to emotion rather than rationality, and also be as simple as possible.

Note that this premise is one basis for leaders to appear idiots. People are more comfortable being led by those they presume to be less intelligent than themselves, because it grants them a false sense of control and superiority.

Hitler on Fake News

When considering communication of his message via news media, Hitler reasons that the majority of those producing media have no choice but to appeal to morons, in order to make a living. Hence, Hitler precisely deduces, all media can do is produce fake news. That is to say, the news may sound factual, but as it must be deliberately written for morons, it must actually elaborate on an emotional state that appeals to the moronic audience, in the guise of being factual.

Hitler reasons that some media creators may sound intelligent. They may even try to sound intelligent, to disguise their deception. Nonetheless, everything they say is necessarily moronic in basis, or they won't stay in business. Their audience is mostly morons, so they have to write moronic things.

Later on, after he wrote Mein Kampf, Hitler found he could get some morons in the news media to say what he wanted. However, the media creators still tried to sound intelligent and add distortions to his intentionally simple message, or just misstate it because they didn't understand him. Hence the best way to persuade the vast masses, Hitler concluded, was to speak to the general public directly, via speeches, and radio broadcasts, and whatever other methods he could find to control precisely the words reaching his audience.

Hitler on Rhetorical Content

Hitler establishes four necessary parameters for all his statements:

  • Statements must first of all be black and white, about what must be true and what must be false--leaving no middle ground for debate as to who is admirably right and who is despicably wrong.

  • Second, those who are wrong are not merely wrong. They are contemptuously wrong. They are inferiors deserving only ridicule, regardless their experience and knowledge.

  • Third, Hitler elaborated that ALL statements must also buttress and reinforce central, common themes, led by simple slogans. The slogans and statements about them must be as short as possible, or the wavering minds of an otherwise vacillating and stupid public will not be able to fix themselves on their purpose.

  • Fourth, the slogans, and variants of them, must be endlessly repeated, to drive the point in and make sure they are not lost in the sloth of the modern mind. By dint of this continuing effort, via endless repetition of simple emotive phrases, the great masses will eventually be unable to consider any alternative interpretation of reality but the one Hitler chooses.

Patriotic Ideals and Victimization

In making emotional appeals, Hitler needed to advocate some heroic idea against clearly defined victims. These are topics well known to most requiring little elaboration. It seems worth noting that advocating Patriotic honor and victimizing members of the nation is logically inconsistent. the victimized groups are members of the nation too, so they should be entitled to the same patriotic honor. By separating one group and declaring it an enemy of the nation, the result is not patriotism. It is party politics. I just note that those engaged in such emotions are rarely aware of the difference.

Some Illustrative Quotations

Almost all the following reasoning is from Chapter 6 of Hitler's MEIN KAMP. It's a very long book, and even Chapter 6 by itself contains long digressions, so I've taken the liberty of excerpting some of the more succinct statements, in reply to those who told me I was wrong without having read the book themselves:

"Propaganda must always address itself to the broad masses of the people. All propaganda must be presented in a popular form and must fix its intellectual level so as not to be above the heads of the least intellectual of those to whom it is directed....

The art of propaganda consists precisely in being able to awaken the imagination of the public through an appeal to their feelings, in finding the appropriate psychological form that will arrest the attention and appeal to the hearts of the national masses. The broad masses of the people are not made up of diplomats or professors of public jurisprudence nor simply of persons who are able to form reasoned judgment in given cases, but a vacillating mass of human children who are constantly wavering between one idea and another. The great majority of a nation is so feminine in its character and outlook that its thought and conduct are ruled by sentiment rather than by sober reasoning. This sentiment, however, is not complex, but simple and consistent. It is not highly differentiated, but HAS ONLY the negative and positive notions of LOVE AND HATRED, RIGHT AND WRONG, TRUTH AND FALSEHOOD....

In the literary effusions which dealt with the theory of Social Democracy there's a display of high-sounding phraseology about liberty and human dignity and beauty, all promulgated with an air of profound wisdom and serene prophetic assurance; a meticulously-woven glitter of words to dazzle and mislead the reader. On the other hand, the daily Press inculcated this new doctrine of human redemption in the most brutal fashion. No means were too base, provided they could be exploited in the campaign of slander. These journalists were real virtuosos in the art of twisting facts and presenting them in a deceptive form. The theoretical literature was intended for the simpletons of the so-distant intellectuals belonging to the middle and, naturally, the upper classes. The newspaper propaganda's intended for the masses....

Propaganda must not investigate the truth objectively and, in so far as it is favorable to the other side, present it according to the theoretical rules of justice; yet it must present only that aspect of the truth which is favorable to its own side....

The receptive powers of the masses are very restricted, and their understanding is feeble. On the other hand, they quickly forget. Such being the case, all effective propaganda must be confined to a few bare essentials and those must be expressed as far as possible in stereotyped formulas. These SLOGANS SHOULD BE PERSISTENTLY REPEATED until the very last individual has come to grasp the idea that has been put forward....

Every change that is made in the subject of a propagandist message must always emphasize the same conclusion. The leading slogan must of course be illustrated in many ways and from several angles, but in the end one must always return to the assertion of the same formula."- Mein Kampf, https://archive.org/details/meinkampf035176mbp/page/n89/mode/2up

Was Hitler's Thinking Original?

A large number have claimed Hitler's above theory was not his own. While it certainly is true that others have distorted and oversimplified the truth, I don't actually know any antecedent to the reasoning I presented above.

Other people have said the most people are morons, although Cicero would not agree, and he is widely accepted as the greatest orator of all time. One could easily construe that no one had previously extended the thinking as Hitler did because so many were more persuaded already by Cicero.

  • Regarding the majority being stupid, most notably perhaps as a precursor is Plato, in the Republic. But Plato goes on to say that others have equally valid skills in other areas, which is the basis of civilization's social contract. And Aristotle agreed on that, which is why all democracies have since granted equal voting power to all citizens, however right or wrong that is.

  • Nietzsche said most people are slaves to their morality, which is often pointed to as a precursor to Nazism. But he doesn't deduce how political leaders should persuade the public as Hitler did.

  • One person claimed Hitler's ideas are from Goebbel's 'principles of propaganda.' However Goebbel didn't even join the Nazi party until after Hitler had written Mein Kampf.

  • Several others have said the ideas are from Le Bon. Le Bon wrote how 'the mob' can be regarded as a primal beast without individual consciousness, which may have inspired Hitler's thought, but is not what Hitler has to say.

Otherwise, I don't know where people derived the assumption that Hitler was not an original thinker. I've reluctantly been driven to the conclusion that Hitler's ideas on the intelligence of a typical person is more correct than I'd prefer to believe.

So, is Trump's Rhetorical Technique drawn from Mein Kampf?

There not being any other clear antecedent for Hitler's reasoning on propaganda, the number of similarities between Hitler's reasoning and Trump's actions appear too numerous to be a coincidence. Their attitudes to 'fake news,' their slogans, their nationalism, their aggressive victimization, and their endless repetition of simple, one-sided emotive statements to reinforce central slogans are all examples.

While the concept is surprising to virtually everyone who've written me, it really does not take a genius to realize that Hitler was incredibly successful at promoting another world war, just after WW1, which was already meant to be the 'war to end all wars.' If one wants to challenge the status quo, like Trump did, Hitler is an obvious person to study.

It astonishes me so many just assume the hypothesis must be wrong, and frequently claim Hitler copied it from someone else, without citing any alternative source to the same method, or being able to provide any substantive comment whatsoever while dismissing the theory on purely emotive grounds. It pains me to say Hitler might have been more right than I'd prefer to believe.


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Feb 27 '14

Is the USA a "totalitarian democracy"? (Link to Wikipedia definition)

Thumbnail en.m.wikipedia.org
2 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Aug 14 '17

Why Communism Never Worked: Productivity

Thumbnail
stateofamericana.com
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 28 '19

Why don’t the 2 parties just rotate executive control? Please help me understand why this isn’t a thing.

1 Upvotes

Why don't the 2 main political parties just switch off executive control every 4 years? It would drastically decrease the toxic ideological warfare during election seasons. It would give the entire presidential race more structure by knowing exactly which years each party would have power. Also, with less focus on the race and the relating drama, the parties will also have more time to strategize what they will do when they own the presidency. It would also cause alliances between the two parties for mutual benefits: for example, a democratic centrist may fund a republican centrist to assure his victory over a more radical republican. It would also put more focus on state elections (winning seats in the other government branches for the public's respective party to better control the designated years of the opposite party).


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Mar 08 '17

So, I just did the political compass test today and I don't really this means I am. Some help would be awesome.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • Jun 14 '19

Identity Politics are being financed by the same people who backed Eugenics and the the Nazi Party…

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes