In prefix, I am obliged to point out a few rather trivial facts in response to the massive number of people who believe at least some USA Presidents are idiots, and that Hitler was no more than a raving maniac without any intellectual capacity:
An individual does not become the most powerful person in the free world, or start a world war, by being an idiot. In fact, they might choose to appear as idiots, because the assumption they are idiots can greatly enhance their ability to manipulate other people.
Any person who knows they are going to ad lib in speeches and debates, perhaps for up to three hours, first thinks out some reasoning on their opinion.
It's unfortunate I've been obliged to start with that, because most readers decide to vote and write comments after reading even less.
Hitler's Premise: Most People are Morons
Moving on. Hitler thought on rhetoric starts by dividing people into three classes: intellectuals, cynics, and the great masses. The first two groups are shackled by their own indecision and nihilism, Hitler stated, so they can be successfully ignored. The third group has no real interest in the faculty of reason and is instead driven by blind and blunt emotion. This is Hitler's premise, and justification for the premise: the vast majority of the great masses must be morons, because virtually everyone is incapable of exercising reason when it is in conflict with their emotions. Hitler sees no need for substantiation of that, it's presented as a self-evident observation.
To appeal to the all-important 'base' of this third and vastly larger group, Hitler stated, one must therefore design propositions that are understandable to the lowest-common denominator: the emotionally-driven moron. All statements of fact must both appeal to emotion rather than rationality, and also be as simple as possible.
Note that this premise is one basis for leaders to appear idiots. People are more comfortable being led by those they presume to be less intelligent than themselves, because it grants them a false sense of control and superiority.
Hitler on Fake News
When considering communication of his message via news media, Hitler reasons that the majority of those producing media have no choice but to appeal to morons, in order to make a living. Hence, Hitler precisely deduces, all media can do is produce fake news. That is to say, the news may sound factual, but as it must be deliberately written for morons, it must actually elaborate on an emotional state that appeals to the moronic audience, in the guise of being factual.
Hitler reasons that some media creators may sound intelligent. They may even try to sound intelligent, to disguise their deception. Nonetheless, everything they say is necessarily moronic in basis, or they won't stay in business. Their audience is mostly morons, so they have to write moronic things.
Later on, after he wrote Mein Kampf, Hitler found he could get some morons in the news media to say what he wanted. However, the media creators still tried to sound intelligent and add distortions to his intentionally simple message, or just misstate it because they didn't understand him. Hence the best way to persuade the vast masses, Hitler concluded, was to speak to the general public directly, via speeches, and radio broadcasts, and whatever other methods he could find to control precisely the words reaching his audience.
Hitler on Rhetorical Content
Hitler establishes four necessary parameters for all his statements:
Statements must first of all be black and white, about what must be true and what must be false--leaving no middle ground for debate as to who is admirably right and who is despicably wrong.
Second, those who are wrong are not merely wrong. They are contemptuously wrong. They are inferiors deserving only ridicule, regardless their experience and knowledge.
Third, Hitler elaborated that ALL statements must also buttress and reinforce central, common themes, led by simple slogans. The slogans and statements about them must be as short as possible, or the wavering minds of an otherwise vacillating and stupid public will not be able to fix themselves on their purpose.
Fourth, the slogans, and variants of them, must be endlessly repeated, to drive the point in and make sure they are not lost in the sloth of the modern mind. By dint of this continuing effort, via endless repetition of simple emotive phrases, the great masses will eventually be unable to consider any alternative interpretation of reality but the one Hitler chooses.
Patriotic Ideals and Victimization
In making emotional appeals, Hitler needed to advocate some heroic idea against clearly defined victims. These are topics well known to most requiring little elaboration. It seems worth noting that advocating Patriotic honor and victimizing members of the nation is logically inconsistent. the victimized groups are members of the nation too, so they should be entitled to the same patriotic honor. By separating one group and declaring it an enemy of the nation, the result is not patriotism. It is party politics. I just note that those engaged in such emotions are rarely aware of the difference.
Some Illustrative Quotations
Almost all the following reasoning is from Chapter 6 of Hitler's MEIN KAMP. It's a very long book, and even Chapter 6 by itself contains long digressions, so I've taken the liberty of excerpting some of the more succinct statements, in reply to those who told me I was wrong without having read the book themselves:
"Propaganda must always address itself to the broad masses of the people. All propaganda must be presented in a popular form and must fix its intellectual level so as not to be above the heads of the least intellectual of those to whom it is directed....
The art of propaganda consists precisely in being able to awaken the imagination of the public through an appeal to their feelings, in finding the appropriate psychological form that will arrest the attention and appeal to the hearts of the national masses. The broad masses of the people are not made up of diplomats or professors of public jurisprudence nor simply of persons who are able to form reasoned judgment in given cases, but a vacillating mass of human children who are constantly wavering between one idea and another. The great majority of a nation is so feminine in its character and outlook that its thought and conduct are ruled by sentiment rather than by sober reasoning. This sentiment, however, is not complex, but simple and consistent. It is not highly differentiated, but HAS ONLY the negative and positive notions of LOVE AND HATRED, RIGHT AND WRONG, TRUTH AND FALSEHOOD....
In the literary effusions which dealt with the theory of Social Democracy there's a display of high-sounding phraseology about liberty and human dignity and beauty, all promulgated with an air of profound wisdom and serene prophetic assurance; a meticulously-woven glitter of words to dazzle and mislead the reader. On the other hand, the daily Press inculcated this new doctrine of human redemption in the most brutal fashion. No means were too base, provided they could be exploited in the campaign of slander. These journalists were real virtuosos in the art of twisting facts and presenting them in a deceptive form. The theoretical literature was intended for the simpletons of the so-distant intellectuals belonging to the middle and, naturally, the upper classes. The newspaper propaganda's intended for the masses....
Propaganda must not investigate the truth objectively and, in so far as it is favorable to the other side, present it according to the theoretical rules of justice; yet it must present only that aspect of the truth which is favorable to its own side....
The receptive powers of the masses are very restricted, and their understanding is feeble. On the other hand, they quickly forget. Such being the case, all effective propaganda must be confined to a few bare essentials and those must be expressed as far as possible in stereotyped formulas. These SLOGANS SHOULD BE PERSISTENTLY REPEATED until the very last individual has come to grasp the idea that has been put forward....
Every change that is made in the subject of a propagandist message must always emphasize the same conclusion. The leading slogan must of course be illustrated in many ways and from several angles, but in the end one must always return to the assertion of the same formula."- Mein Kampf, https://archive.org/details/meinkampf035176mbp/page/n89/mode/2up
Was Hitler's Thinking Original?
A large number have claimed Hitler's above theory was not his own. While it certainly is true that others have distorted and oversimplified the truth, I don't actually know any antecedent to the reasoning I presented above.
Other people have said the most people are morons, although Cicero would not agree, and he is widely accepted as the greatest orator of all time. One could easily construe that no one had previously extended the thinking as Hitler did because so many were more persuaded already by Cicero.
Regarding the majority being stupid, most notably perhaps as a precursor is Plato, in the Republic. But Plato goes on to say that others have equally valid skills in other areas, which is the basis of civilization's social contract. And Aristotle agreed on that, which is why all democracies have since granted equal voting power to all citizens, however right or wrong that is.
Nietzsche said most people are slaves to their morality, which is often pointed to as a precursor to Nazism. But he doesn't deduce how political leaders should persuade the public as Hitler did.
One person claimed Hitler's ideas are from Goebbel's 'principles of propaganda.' However Goebbel didn't even join the Nazi party until after Hitler had written Mein Kampf.
Several others have said the ideas are from Le Bon. Le Bon wrote how 'the mob' can be regarded as a primal beast without individual consciousness, which may have inspired Hitler's thought, but is not what Hitler has to say.
Otherwise, I don't know where people derived the assumption that Hitler was not an original thinker. I've reluctantly been driven to the conclusion that Hitler's ideas on the intelligence of a typical person is more correct than I'd prefer to believe.
So, is Trump's Rhetorical Technique drawn from Mein Kampf?
There not being any other clear antecedent for Hitler's reasoning on propaganda, the number of similarities between Hitler's reasoning and Trump's actions appear too numerous to be a coincidence. Their attitudes to 'fake news,' their slogans, their nationalism, their aggressive victimization, and their endless repetition of simple, one-sided emotive statements to reinforce central slogans are all examples.
While the concept is surprising to virtually everyone who've written me, it really does not take a genius to realize that Hitler was incredibly successful at promoting another world war, just after WW1, which was already meant to be the 'war to end all wars.' If one wants to challenge the status quo, like Trump did, Hitler is an obvious person to study.
It astonishes me so many just assume the hypothesis must be wrong, and frequently claim Hitler copied it from someone else, without citing any alternative source to the same method, or being able to provide any substantive comment whatsoever while dismissing the theory on purely emotive grounds. It pains me to say Hitler might have been more right than I'd prefer to believe.