r/OpenDogTraining • • May 15 '25

I accidentally trained the perfect dog and I can’t seem to do it again

Thumbnail
gallery
8.4k Upvotes

Tbh I think it comes down to personality and some other things. Murray is almost 14, I’ve had him since he was 18 months (I was 20 years old) so no bonding as a puppy but we almost instantly bonded the day I got him. I was told he was a terror and destructive, he’s been an angel since day one together and an off leash hiking partner among other things. He did everything with me a dog could, he passed CGC and therapy dog test with flying colors and we visited schools and nursing homes and camps as a therapy dog. He traveled with me. I didn’t teach him how to be off leash he just never left my side, I could say “Murray wait” and he’d pause in his tracks 10 feet in front of me, he didn’t give a crap about other dogs or people or animals on the trail. 0 prey drive. I taught him everything he knows but we never did training sessions or classes, he just picked up on cues as we worked together. He’s in his final days, we have 4 other dogs and as we go hiking today, I can’t take any of the others. I put more work and effort into all of them, and I actually have a really good bond with one but he’s dog reactive so absolutely no off leash work and when we’re bouldering I just can’t be tethered to a dog, I need my hands free; I’ve tried hands free leashes but sometimes it’s not long enough for me to get him down safely then myself. At the end of the day I’m pretty sure it’s Murray’s personality and temperament that led him to be what he was for me, I know I didn’t intentionally teach him to be this way I just took advantage of a really good dog to make my best friend. I miss my hiking partner.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 9d ago WOW Heartwarming Bravo

UPDATE: Dog training has made me hate my dog.

Post image
6.7k Upvotes

Hello.

A little while ago I posted about how dog training had damaged my relationship with my dog, and how I felt that every walk was a training exercise, and that I could never chill out around the dog.

I got many comments on that post, and to be honest it was a bit of a wake up call. Some commenters mentioned it sounded a bit obsessive, and I was putting too much pressure on both of us. Some comments were pretty blunt. To be honest it’s what I needed.

In that post I mentioned that all I wanted to do was ‘go on an autumnal walk and get a pint in the pub’. Anyway - here’s a big cheers to you all. Thank you for giving me a well needed kick and to stop being so obsessive. We went to the pub, and I had a pint. And my dog lay at my feet and chilled the whole time. He was a delight. Walking home slightly tipsy, I just wanted to say thank you to you all. And cheers 🍻


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jan 22 '26

How can I help my dog understand that the cat is showing affection and not a threat?

5.0k Upvotes

We adopted our dog Nuka about a year ago and have had the cat about 4 years. From the beginning Midnight has been enamored with Nuka and likes to rub up on her occasionally. Over the past year, Nuka has gotten better at accepting her affection but still sometimes gets tense. I don’t have any high expectations of them being best friends or playing, but how can I reinforce that the cat is harmless and that the correct response is to just relax and be neutral towards her?

I try to give them both affection at the same time, and if I give treats they either get them simultaneously or I alternate and reward Nuka for waiting her turn. If Midnight rubs on her and she doesn’t react I give her verbal praise for being nice to the kitty, and if she seems overly uncomfortable I try to redirect the cat. On rare occasions Nuka will get an intense herding-dog stare and I have her lie down or go to her bed until she lets the situation go and then praise her for settling down. Overall she is a very laid-back dog and has been getting better, but I’d just like to know if there’s anything else that I should (or shouldn’t) be doing to help reinforce a calm tolerant relationship between them.

*sorry if this post is a duplicate- it keeps disappearing after I click post and is not showing up in my profile.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Aug 05 '24

Rescued this guy last night. Any idea on breed?

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 15 '26

Realizing that people really don’t know what actually training a dog looks like

Thumbnail
gallery
2.2k Upvotes

Hi! My bf and I got our first puppy a week and a half ago and he’s a 9 week old English lab. We did endless amounts of research on training and preparation for our baby and now that we have him, I’m realizing that many people truly don’t care about training their dogs lol. My mom has been all over me saying that we are too “by the book” or too strict with our regimen for him. We already have him crate trained, he knows his name, how to stay, wait for food to be given an “okay”, sit, down, and a bit more. He sleeps throughout the night with one or two wake ups for potty. We don’t allow him on the couch or bed yet because we are working on establishing boundaries that he has his space and we have ours. Eventually we will create a command for “up” or “off” so we can get him on or off with a command. She thinks it’s absolutely nuts that we don’t let him actively roam the house or have access to every room. We let him explore but supervised. Most of his time is spent in his play pen with toys or his crate for his enforced naps to ensure he gets his 18 hours of sleep a day. He is doing great but I’m so over people giving their two cents saying things like “but it’s normal for him to chew your couch, he’s just a puppy” or “let him jump all over you, he’s just excited!” We’re working on preventing his jumping or not entertaining it when he does jump because eventually he will be around 70lbs and jumping won’t be funny or cute anymore. My mom had our childhood pets overweight, food reactive, and weren’t friendly with other dogs. I loved them to death but I’m realizing she is not in the place to give advice. I remember they tore up our couch one time as puppies because she let them free roam while we left. I guess I’m just ranting to rant about how many people are telling us we are too strict on him and how frustrating it is to hear this just because he has a schedule. Puppies are like babies! They need to have order and structure in their lives. Thoughts


r/OpenDogTraining • • Feb 27 '24

When to justify kicking a dog

Thumbnail
gallery
1.6k Upvotes

Let's talk about what to do when an off leash dog attacks your off leash dog.

Today I had my pack out at a wonderful recreation area in the county (where off-leash is permitted) that's about 400acres of steep hills, pine and juniper trees, large sandstone cliffs and fallen boulders. This is a very common place for people to hike and exercise their dogs (off leash). The etiquette that most park goers follow is to recall their dog and leash it whenever another person is spotted.

So today, we're concluding a very productive hike/roaming training session with e collars and we were making our way down a steep switchback off the main sandstone plateau and the dog pack is about 10 yards ahead of me checking in.

At about the 3/4 mark, I hear some commotion of smalls rocks and trail debris tumbling down the trail behind me and the sound of fast moving feet. My dogs take notice too and turn back and cover the mere 10 yards back to me. So here I am, with a pack of dogs at my back and a large (70-80lbs) pit mix barreling down on us - with no handler in sight.

Immediately I call to my pack, "dogs, leave it! Come!" Dogs performed perfectly. I try to size this dog up and see if I can judge if he's coming in hot friendly-like or not. Dog is closing distance fast and is almost to us and my gut is saying "not friendly." I holler to the incoming dog "Hey! Hey! No!" (Usually this stops most dogs and they kind of second guess themselves). Dog blows right past me and engages with my bigger male and has him by the neck.

I continue hollering and throw a solid kick that connects with a jarring thud and the dog releases my dog and my dog retaliates. I call him off and he complies. Then the attacking dog makes a half-assed lunge towards my dog again and I throw another kick its way. The dog easily dodges my kick but now seems a little less into the fight. I continue hollering for it to go away. I'm thinking, "where the hell is this dog's owner?!"

Then it's like the attacking dog notices my other dogs for the first time and sets its target on my 10mo pup and charges. Again, a kick is thrown as I try to intercept the dog hurtling towards the pup - and again the dog effortlessly dodges the kick.

The little pup breaks commands to save itself and bolts up the steep embankment of pine duff, rocks, and mud. The attacking dog takes chase after the pup but the pup is making distance.

I recall the pup because the top of the embankment leads to a very abrupt sandstone cliff edge. The pup executes its best recall ever and jukes left and is beelining towards me. Pup takes a running jump off an ugly ledge, takes a 10ft fall, and lands hard. The pup is back in its feet fast and bolts behind me to safety. The attacking dog manages the 10ft drop somehow with incredible agility and grace and is charging for the pup hiding behind my leg.

I give the attacking dog the kick of my life right into its face, mid lunge at the pup. The pack is now out of command and ready to join the fight with me. Luckily, the attacking dog decided to back off at this point.

I shout another, "dogs, leave it! Stay!" And they again comply (I'm very proud of them today) and we briefly stand off face-to-face with the dog. Then it just ran off.

As I was checking my dogs for injuries the dog's owner shows up after hearing the commotion. He gets an earful and heads off in the direction his dog ran away.

TLDR: my dogs got attacked by another dog that was off leash and a circus of kicking and hollering ensued

So, how would you have handled the situation?


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jul 13 '24

K H A N - training since a baby

1.6k Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 8d ago LOL Bravo

This is so real 😂🤦🏻‍♂️

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 18 '25

Why does my parent’s dog do this?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

He will sit in front of you and put his front legs on you while his ears are back. Just wondering if anyone knows what this behavior means?


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 27 '24

Burn that energy!

1.2k Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • Oct 01 '23

On the successful use of E-collars with "untrainable"/independent dogs...

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Hi all! New here but not new to training with my personal animals. I've owned dogs all my life and worked with wolfdogs for close to 10 years now.

3.5 years ago, I bought a high content wolfdog from someone who's been raising a very unique line of OFA tested & selectively bred wolfdogs since the late 1980's, and when I explained my goals to her for my dog and lifestyle while going through the application process the year before the litter was born, she reccomended e-collar training. Other breeders I'd approached told me off leash training and living primarily indoors was impossible and if you did teach them to recall, it would no longer be reliable at 2-3 years old. I was told that I wasn't trying anything that hadn't been tried before and that it wouldn't work and I was being naive. I eventually, in researching lines, approached this breeder who, it turns out, had utilized ecollars in the past when training at obedience classes with her wolfdogs (my girl's ancestors and family) and saw a huge amount of potential for what could be accomplished with more routine use of ecollars with these guys in addition to R+ and P- methodology.

I bought an ecollar and learned how to use it, and worked with my current dogs with the help of some awesome trainers to dial in my timing and how to load it and such, so when the time came I was very confident in introducing an ecollar to my wolfdog around 6mo as the teenager phase hit.

Anyways, long story short, I have a fully matured 94% high content wolfdog who has a beautiful recall and checks in off-leash, who also lives indoors and travels with me regularly, and cohabitates with other dogs. And no matter how much I demonstrate the success we've had and show how the ecollar is used and what sort of lifestyle it opens up for my animals, I still get a lot of flack about my choice of training tools and am told I'm "shocking her into submission". But to me, the proof is in the pudding. If more folks were willing to be open-minded about training tools they're unfamiliar with, maybe more folks with wolfdogs or other stubborn and independent dogs could give them a greater level of freedom like mine is able to enjoy :)

Here's some photos of my lovely girl Zephyr on some of our hikes. We hike both public land and private land, hence why sometimes she's wearing a pack and sometimes not!


r/OpenDogTraining • • Sep 16 '25

Went from “prong collars are evil” to “where has this been all my life?” 😂

1.1k Upvotes

So, I was always anti-prong. They looked bulky, medieval, and I’ve literally seen countless people picking pieces of their prong collars that fell apart or got tangled from the floor... that ain't for me

I thought prongs were only for Cujo-level violent or uncontrollable dogs. Fast forward—I adopt a 4-month-old Australian Cattle Dog/Aussie Shepherd mix (aka kangaroo/raptor hybrid). Cute as heck, but showing signs of frustrated greeter syndrome.

I did the “good dog dad” thing:

  • Puppy classes at PetSmart (for the kids).

  • Private training (for the wife and me).

Then…the balls dropped. Growth spurt. Suddenly my flat collar turned into a medieval torture device for me. Switched to martingale, then slip lead. Manageable for me, but my wife and kids were getting rag-dolled by a furry velociraptor on Red Bull.

We leveled up training to the point of working outside with the trainer’s dog. Total chaos. My pup went from “good student” to “parkour audition.” Finally, my trainer pulls out the prong collar. At that point, my back already needed a chiropractor, so I said, “Sure, why not?”

Slapped that bad boy on… game changer.

  • No jerking. No yanking. Just 2–3 fingers of guidance.

  • Dog listens.

  • I’m not dislocating my shoulder.

  • My kids and wife can actually walk him without reenacting scenes from Jurassic Park.

Is he perfect? Nah. He still wants to chase rabbits and skunks, and still locks onto other dogs. But NOW I can actually practice things like leg blocking, direction changes, desensitization, no-reward markers—without being yeeted into orbit.

Best part? Since switching, this dude is getting way more outdoor time (not just dog parks) because walking him is finally enjoyable.

So yeah… this former prong-hater is eating crow. 🐦 Just wanted to share a positive with my little land shark.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Sep 01 '26

I’m doing better now! :)

1.1k Upvotes

a while back last year I asked for help on Reddit with my puppy. I was just lost and felt really incompetent as a dog handler in sport with her first ever dog. safe to say we’re both much closer with one another and we both really enjoy sport together as a team. shes absolutely crazy and has insane energy which i love about her! and she looooves to do retrievals! she’s won a few OB and rallyO comps and loves to swim! Shes also gotten over her fear of other dogs staring at her or barking at her. she comes with me everywhere i go and is very emotionally stable now!

all i wanted to say is, thank you to those that helped me and wished the best for me. Puppies just need time and young handlers need reassurance!


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 21 '25

Prong fit check on my black lab pit mix 🤑

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Before anyone freaks out, he's my baby and he lets me do anything to him. It wasn't tight and he stood there the entire time purring because mama was touching him.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Sep 22 '24

Is it possible for a dog to actually be dumb?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

This is my dog shadow he is a pitbull lab mix at least that's what I guess, he's supposed to be a full-blooded Pitbull but I highly doubt he is he looks exactly like my cousin's pit lab mix anywho, he's dumb as a brick at least what we would consider them I don't know if dogs actually can be dumb or not because I've been yelled at for jokingly calling him dumb , so can dogs actually be dumb? He's a little over a year old not neutered he doesn't learn things very easily at all it takes weeks to teach him very simple things, he's been being tied outside just to use the bathroom of a morning because he has a weak bladder and can't wait for me to use the bathroom before walking him, when I come back to get him he's always got his cable wrapped around his legs his nose his body something there's nothing else for him to get tangled up on, there's also the fact that he will not stop being extremely destructive, I give him toys I play with him I walk him to the point he's exhausted when I get back and he's still destructive, he also never stops eating he will eat anything even if it's not food, he got out of his crate while I was in town a few months ago and 8th an entire 15 lb bag of dog food by himself and was still trying to eat more he actually ate part of the bag itself, I don't know if he is dumb just not good at learning things very easily or I just haven't found the right method of training him yet but I really need some help, he's a sweet dog he's got a very big mouth but he is the sweetest dog and I love him to pieces like he's so sweet he won't even hurt a chicken intentionally he doesn't even try to play with them


r/OpenDogTraining • • Oct 23 '23

Our reactive dog hasn’t been allowed on the balcony in ages

1.0k Upvotes

Yesterday was too nice to stay inside so I put on his ecollar and brought a tub of cheese balls with us. He disengaged like this from EVERY dog that passed over 30 minutes without any direction from me.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 11 '24

What do you all think he is?!

Thumbnail
gallery
869 Upvotes

Meet Leo. A 3 year old 60 pound mix that we just rescued from the shelter two weeks ago. We are doing a DNA test next week but wanted to see if anyone had any good guesses as to what he is first!

Our guess is a Belgian Malinois and Carolina Dog mix.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Jun 22 '26

New dog destroyed crate

Thumbnail
gallery
846 Upvotes

Help! I got a 10 month old dog and she absolutely DESTROYED her crate while I was at work. She was alone for 4 hours.
I tried to practice over the weekend, but she broke out of it too, hence the carabiners.

I’m worried if I a get a more durable crate, she will hurt herself trying to breakout.

She did pee in the house, but nothing was destroyed (except her green toy bag).

I don’t have any help during the day for this. I’ve never had a dog act like this about a crate. I feel like given she was OK after she broke out, I could just leave her out during the day.

Any suggestions??

EDIT:
I got her on Thursday. She was sleeping in the crate with the door open and eating in there. I checked on her at lunch (let her out to pee) and gave her a peanut butter bone and she seemed fine.

I AM A RUNNER! We went three miles this morning!!

UPDATE:
Thank you for all the comments, did not expect to get this much traction. Then again her damage to the crate is out of the ordinary.
I actually was able to get ahold of the vet office I’ll be taking her to next week.
They recommend NOT crating her for a while. With her breeds (corgi, cattle dog, husky, chihuahua, chow chow, etc) she is not a dog that can adjust to confinement at this age.
I have “puppy proofed” my apartment and she will be fine to roam.
I would like to point out a few things.

  1. I am NOT bad dog owner. Am I not allowed to make an error of judgement?

  2. I have been name training, potty training (she goes outside but it takes like an hour), and encouraging sit, lay down, etc.

OFFICIAL UPDATE:

She is going much better with no crate. Some of you people suck ASS


r/OpenDogTraining • • Mar 29 '25

I taught my dog a trick and now she won't stop doing it

846 Upvotes

I made a terrible mistake.

My dog is extremely intelligent, and high energy. Unfortunately she is also extremely reactive, and has very limited time outside the house.

I decided to focus on ✨️enrichment✨️, including training fun tricks. She learns EXTREMELY quickly.

Recently I saw a fun trick of dogs closing doors online, and thought why not. I introduced her to the concept for 5 min before I went to the gym last week. She picked it up really fast, without me using any treats as reinforcment. I did notice she chose to accompany the trick with screaming at the door as she slammed it. 'Oh well,' I think. 'We'll work on delicacy later'.

When I came back from the gym a couple of hours later I noticed every door in the house was closed. Alright, maybe she really gets a kick out of this.

She won't stop. She is constantly slamming doors, and yelling at them as she does. She absolutely LOVES closing doors.

She's worked out how to close doors from both sides (inwards and outwards).

Please. How can I get her to stop? Some doors just need to remain open, and maybe this trick is one door that shouldve remained closed.

EDIT: I don't have any videos of this particular activity of hers (she's when she knows I'm not around and I'm hesitant to encourage her to do again), however I will still dutifully pay the necessary dog tax.

dog tax


r/OpenDogTraining • • Oct 08 '26

Why is she doing this to her sister? It’s happening several times a day while we are at work. I cannot tell if this is meant to be soothing or aggressive?

833 Upvotes

These are my two 10 year old female German shepherds and they have lived together their whole lives. We saw her doing this to her sister occasionally over the past couples of years, but it was rare. We recently got a pet camera and I’ve been watching it over the last couple of months and she does this to her 5 or more times A DAY. Why? If it’s just a soothing action then that’s okay but if the other one is in distress over this, I will not allow them to coexist while we are gone.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Oct 15 '23

Some obedience from my dog who just started her second heat.

828 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • May 03 '24

Does anyone else's dog have an unorthodox training reward? This week I learned that mine likes spray bottles.

811 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • Dec 17 '24

In Laws brought this French bulldog home yesterday and it's already attacked one of their cats.

Thumbnail
gallery
810 Upvotes

I want to first say a few things to paint a picture of the shit show that the situation really is.

1)my mother in law (62) and father in law (82) are both handicapped (dad wheelchair bound with several health issues including stage 4 kidney failure) and mom has horrible knees, hips, back, feet, shoulders, etc etc.

2) they have 2 dogs already. One small daschund who is perfect for them and then later they decided a full-sized pitbull would be a good idea for a household with a wheelchair and the inability to go for walks or even throw a ball in the yard... I advised hard against this of course. They did not listen to me.

3) pitbull quickly becomes overweight, like less than 2 yrs old and already weighs 2x what he should. I can't give the exact number because they are too weak to get him in the car to take him to the vet. He develops behavioral issues because they refuse to train or socialize him.

4) enter mother in law's sister (65) who came to live with them a year ago, is also disabled to a point. She brought a bunch of outdoor cats who bred like bunnies until there were about 20 of them. I advised against this upfront, both having outdoor cats and not spaying/neutering them. They did not listen to me.

So the sister says she's bringing home this almost year old, unsocialized frenchie. Mom and dad in law both say yes, of course, after both me and my partner both STRONGLY advised against this. And of course.. they didn't listen to us.

So the dog is home for less than a full day and this morning, the dog attacks one of the outside cats. Cat does what cat does and is a whirling mass of claws and teeth but the frenchie won't let go. Mom in law was the one outside when this happens and she says she "beat her on the head to get her to let go of the cat" and then later says "I don't even know how bad the cat is hurt".

She then says that she doesn't want me to think she was trying to "hurt the puppy" by hitting her to save the cat. I'm just at a loss at this point.

I've got my own two full sized dogs who are well socialized, well trained and in shape. They all go on about how well behaved they are. So I offered my help socializing, exercising and training the frenchie, but they don't want me taking the frenchie to my house with my structure and well adjusted dogs.

How in the hell are these people going to maintain the work I do when I'm not there??? Does anyone have a "Baby's First Aggressive Dog Training" manual that I don't know about? They can't catch the cats to keep them away from the small yard where the bulldog goes. Their house is far too small to sequester the dog to limit exposure to only when supervised. They have no self control. They have no bearing on correcting bad behavior, much less anticipating bad behavior.

I want to help them but I don't know how the logistics are gonna work.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Mar 16 '25

The little dog is a terrorist when smaller dogs enter the pack, but she acts like this to anyone larger than her. What’s the best way to mitigate her aggression?

708 Upvotes