Part 1:
I work with many clients over the week, and I hear the same comments.. “My dog is stubborn”, “he doesn't listen” “the dog knows he did something wrong” — “they feel guilty”. Most of the time that's not what's going on. The dog is confused, because nobody has given it accountability, clear structure or consistent guidance.
Yes — we love our dogs, and a lot of us treat them like our children.. But love on its own doesn't make a dog stable reliable or confident. Dogs need guidance, and they need it communicated in a way that makes sense to them.
A big misconception I see in dog training — most people begin working on commands (Sit, down, stay) instead of building the relationship + engagement. Engagement teaches the dog to pay attention to you. Many training facilities want you to believe that coming to them and training around other dogs is going to create a confident & focused dog. They will become more confident in their commands. This is far from the truth.
Obedience is really a small piece of it. A dog can have a good sit in the living room, but does that dog continue to remain seated until you release them? When someone walks by? Are you able to deliver the reward to the dog? Can they hold a sit until you get to them — do they lean forward and get up out of the sit when you’re delivering the reward? If you’re unsure— these commands most likely fall apart the moment there's a distraction, a new environment or competing motivator.
Dog owners get frustrated and think the dog is misbehaving. In reality, the dog never learned how to listen, handle pressure, make good choices when it's excited, or stay engaged with the handler out in the real world. These small mistakes turn into big problems for most people.
Most dog problems are created in the beginning of your training program. They begin from the little mistakes we aren’t paying attention to — bolded above.
That's why I put so much emphasis on consistency timing and clarity. When a dog understands your expectations, it gets more confident, and a confident dog is a lot less anxious and impulsive. We call this term “agency” — they understand that their actions lead to consequences. Whether they are good or bad. This is the gold standard.
Part 2.
When you inoculate your dog with incremental amounts of stress they become more resilient to stressful experiences.
Reward based training
Formal handing drills
Leash yielding
Layering leash pressure over commands
Generalizing commands to new environments
5 benefits:
Decreased anxiety
Increased confidence
Deceased cortisol / response
Increased curiosity
Faster recovery (come down) from stressful experiences
One of the biggest lessons I’ve learned from Michael Ellis is that dogs respond best to timely, consistent, and clear communication. Rewards and management are the foundation to a good training program — for a puppy, rescue or even a reactive dog. But equally important is timing, clarity and consistency. Handling drills, negative reinforcement — educating the dog about the leash.
Capture the moment your dog was correct or incorrect so they understand your expectations and why they are getting rewarded. Respond the same way every time, consistency matters… at home or out in public. Step in early, before the jumping, barking or lunging builds momentum. Be preemptive.
Many owners reinforce the wrong behaviors without realizing it. Rewarding late, overshadowing, talking too much, inconsistent reward placement, overreacting, not following through — giving up. Dogs are studying us — they are master pattern recognizers. They read our body language, patterns and inflection or tone of voice. They sense leash tension.
This is why confidence and leadership matters — I don't mean dominance or intimidation. Good leadership is calm, clear and consistent. Holding your dog accountable. When a dog understands that the system is clear and predictable everything improves. You become more clear & predictable.
The other piece I see missing is socialization done the right way. Socialization isn't meeting every dog and person on your walks. Most dogs are over-socialized, we take our dogs everywhere! The goal isn't a dog that's excited about meeting everybody — the goal is a dog that can be neutral around people and dogs while staying connected to you.
There's endless dog training information online, and most of it is misleading. My advice is to stop looking for shortcuts and focus on consistency. Build your relationship and engagement, and work on your timing. There's no magic pill that replaces daily work.
It's really important that we recognize dog training is a holistic approach. I've seen fearful dogs become confident and reactive dogs become neutral, mostly because the owner changed how they communicate with their dog.