r/OpenDogTraining • u/[deleted] • Aug 06 '25
I think "neglected" outdoor dogs live better lives than "spoiled" city dogs
TLDR; why can't we see that "spoiled" city dogs are neglected?
I lived in Los Angeles for a few years and regularly traveled between some of the ritziest parts of the city and some of the poorer, almost rural, far reaches of LA County. I'm also a working dog handler (protection and detection) and dog trainer whose clients are a mix of chill pet dogs who need help with leash walking and intense working breeds who need serious off-leash control to lead good lives. I use a ton of play in training and love people like Jay Jack and Ivan Balabanov, for context, but I'm open to learning from anyone and everyone who has a cooperative, mutually trusting, joyful relationship with their dogs. I don't think dogs need "alpha leadership" or constant structure; I train dogs to independently make good decisions so they can be free from obedience or micromanagement as much as possible. I walk my working dog on a 26 foot flexi for almost all of our walks and let her sleep in bed with me.
In the rural towns I passed through, many dogs live outside in fenced yards with some toys and a shaded dog house. They do what they please all day and might go for an evening walk with their owners. Some sleep inside, others don't. They eat basic dog food and most get the basic vaccinations. Some bark at you when you pass by.
In wealthy parts of LA, I saw countless dogs taken everywhere, both pet-friendly and not. They have dozens of toys, are fed custom diets accompanied by supplements, and are sent to expensive daycares when they absolutely cannot go somewhere with their owner. I saw a few dog birthday parties that definitely cost more than my rent! People use "animal communicators"
I think the outdoor dogs live better lives. They're given ample free time to engage in dog-specific behaviors rather than being carted (sometimes literally) around the city on a short leash. I think many city dogs are essentially their owners' emotional servants; separation anxiety is crazy prevalent among those dogs because, I think, their owners literally create co-dependence. Dogs are considered helpless "fur babies" who can do no wrong; to inflict any sort of discomfort on them is a grievous sin. The outdoor dogs, on average, have more independence and don't feel helpless without their owners. Their "dog-ness" is respected.
Now, I don't believe that either extreme is ideal. Dogs are profoundly social creatures and do not thrive when they live 100% outdoors. They benefit from more advanced veterinary care and higher quality diets and exploring new places. I believe dogs are highly intelligent creatures with incredible abilities which, in many areas, surpass humans'. I take dogs seriously and strive to improve my skills at communicating with them- the goal of my training is to enrich and expand dogs' lives, thus integrating them more fully into their families. Neither extreme treats dogs as the complex, emotional, intelligent creatures that they truly are.
My hot take is that I think many of these LA fur moms/dads could learn from these outdoor dogs. I don't entirely blame these folks for how they treat their dogs; people have been misled by social media, largely, to see dogs as fragile, infantile beings whose happiness can be measured in the amount of stuff and expensive experiences they're given (the byproduct of LA's rampant consumerism, too).
EDIT to include this part, which I think adds some clarity to my argument (thanks to several commentators who encouraged this!). Those little companion breeds do seem to be the most content with the aforementioned LA lifestyle. In my post, I was more aiming at the broader ideology that underlies the LA lifestyle, one in which dogs are seen as helpless, fragile creatures who should be wholly dependent on humans for every need. I really do believe that even a little Shitzu could benefit from being treated like an outdoor dog a bit more- it is a fundamental drive of any intelligent creature to independently problem solve and master challenges. City dog life takes away almost all meaningful opportunities to do this, and I think that's neglect.
The book Punished by Rewards was instrumental for me- it shows how overreliance on external reward structures destroys humans' natural inclination to challenge themselves for the inherent pleasure of developing new skills and feeling competent.
So basically I think that, by creating co-dependent, bubble-wrapped dogs, this typical LA "spoiled" dog life eliminates every chance dogs get to do this and thus feel a meaningful sense of mastery. I always tell clients that it's fairly simple to achieve this- something like jumping around on a playground, basic scentwork like following a trail of kibble around the park, or playing a raucous game of tug is often enough.
I think trainers like Jay Jack in particular strike a great balance between moving mountains to ensure your dog is baseline fulfilled without telling people that their dog should be the 100% center of their lives.
Many outdoor dogs are indeed neglected, but why can't we see that so many "spoiled" city dogs are neglected too?