r/Insurance • u/Realistic-Effect5115 • 2h ago
Auto Insurance At-fault accident, GEICO paid negotiated amount, now subrogation company threatening to sue me for remaining $3k. Am I liable?
I was at fault in an accident in PA in November 2025. I had $25k in property damage liability coverage through GEICO. The other vehicle was a Tesla service loaner.
Fleet Response, representing Tesla, originally demanded ~$15k in damages. GEICO reviewed the claim, disputed several repair charges as excessive or unsupported, and paid approximately ~$11k. Fleet Response is now pursuing me personally for the remaining~ $4k.
GEICO confirmed that the remaining amount is disputed, not excluded from coverage. They also recently told me they've received additional documentation from Fleet Response and are reviewing it for possible further payment.
However, Fleet Response left me a voicemail Friday threatening to send the balance to an attorney and add a 35% fee unless I arrange payment by Monday. I've tried contacting GEICO's subrogation department but haven't been able to speak directly with anyone.
There were no other property damage claims from the accident, so my $25k limit wasn't exhausted.
My question: Can Fleet Response successfully pursue me personally for the difference simply because GEICO disputed part of their claim? Shouldn't GEICO continue handling and defending this claim since the total damages are well within my policy limits?