r/Insurance • • Jun 28 '26

Auto Insurance California - At-fault driver showed GEICO insurance card, GEICO later denied coverage because policy wasn't in effect. What are my realistic options?

0 Upvotes

I'm hoping to get some advice from people familiar with California auto insurance or small claims.

Timeline

  • June 8, 2026: My brand-new 2026 Honda CR-V Hybrid was parked and stationary in front of my apartment garage while I was loading my son into the vehicle.

  • I was outside the vehicle, and my son was also outside the vehicle.

  • A neighbor backed his car out of a parking space and struck the side of my CR-V.

  • I have dashcam footage (front and rear cameras) showing much of the incident, including that my vehicle was stationary and that we were outside the vehicle at the time of impact.

  • I also took photos of the damage, the scene, the driver's insurance card, and the vehicle registration.

  • I obtained the driver's phone number and address.

GEICO claim

The driver presented me with a GEICO insurance card that appeared to be current.

I filed a third-party claim with GEICO.

A couple of weeks later, GEICO denied the claim and sent me a written denial letter stating that the policy "was not in effect at the time of the loss."

Progressive claim

I then opened a claim with my own insurer (Progressive).

Progressive completed their investigation and determined that I was not at fault.

However, I only carry liability coverage (no collision or uninsured motorist property damage), so Progressive closed the claim because my policy doesn't provide coverage for my vehicle damage in this situation.

They suggested pursuing the at-fault driver directly through California Small Claims Court or consulting an attorney.

My questions

  1. Is Small Claims Court the most practical next step in California?

  2. Does the fact that the driver handed me what appeared to be a valid insurance card change anything legally, even though GEICO later said the policy wasn't in effect?

  3. Has anyone successfully collected damages from an uninsured at-fault driver after winning in small claims?

  4. Are there any other recovery options I'm overlooking before filing suit?

  5. Would you recommend sending a formal demand letter first?

I have not contacted the driver since the accident because I wanted to understand the proper legal process before doing anything.

Any advice or experiences would be greatly appreciated.


r/Insurance • • Aug 31 '23

Insurance is just a legal ponzi scheme change my mind…

0 Upvotes

To start off I have insurance always have always will actually a big advocate for insurance… but let’s be honest the concept of insurance on paper is just a glorified legal Ponzi scheme that’s heavily regulated by the government… it’s kinda funny tbh


r/Insurance • • Jun 26 '24

Hit by a drunk driver and his car was totaled and Geico cancelled our policy.

1 Upvotes

My son's was hit his by a drunk driver and his car was totalled. We were current on payments. They (GEICO) made the payment for the claim of 13k and that same day our policy was canceled.

They canceled all 3 of our cars. The reason they said was my truck was being used for business. I said I Take it to the dump. The truck had already been approved and insured. They said they sent a letter. Which they might have but I have not opened up their mail been on autopay over 20 years.

This is the most ridiculous thing ever.

Has this happened to anyone else? They didn't tell us or contact and we were driving without insurance for almost a month not knowing

Is there any recourse? Any thoughts?


r/Insurance • • Aug 05 '26

Auto Insurance (TX) Boyfriend got hit by a driver with a permit. Their insurance is refusing to pay.

0 Upvotes

I posted this on a different subreddit and a comment suggested I posted here as well. That post has since been locked so ill give more information below the original text

Location: Texas

My boyfriend was T-boned on March 13 of this year when another driver failed to yield while merging onto his road. The police report clearly states the other driver was at fault. The driver only had a learner's permit, and the owner of the vehicle was in the passenger seat at the time.

My boyfriend unfortunately didn't have insurance. The other driver's insurance denied the claim, saying the driver wasn't listed on the policy, so they aren't covering the damages.

I spoke with a lawyer who believed this could fall under negligent entrustment, but he said pursuing it likely wouldn't be worth the legal fees. He offered to send a letter to the insurance company for free, but after months of trying to reach him again, I haven't been able to get in contact.

His truck has been undrivable since the accident because both passenger-side doors are caved in, so he's been borrowing a family member's vehicle.

I'm hoping to get some advice:

- Should we appeal the insurance denial ourselves before contacting another lawyer?

- Is it worth hiring an attorney if the claim is only for the damage to his truck?

- Would small claims court be an option in Texas if insurance won't pay?

- Since he didn't seek medical treatment at the time because we couldn't afford it, does that hurt our case if he's still having elbow pain?

- Are there any other options we're overlooking?

We're both living paycheck to paycheck. He's currently unemployed, and I'm in college with limited work hours, so we're trying to figure out the most cost-effective path forward.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Extra Info:

My boyfriend is beyond an idiot for driving without insurance. We are both quite aware of that and its led to many arguments. The nail has been hammered into the ground at this point. We just want to know if theres anything that could be done now.

The police report absolutely stated the other driver was at fault:

"The driver of unit #1 failed to yield for the west facing yield sign at the intersection of X and Y and entered the intersection to make a left turn on to Y causing the front of unit #1 to collide with the passenger side of unit #2."

I can post the full censored one if needed but it does not offer much more information than this.

This is NOT my car/truck. My name is not on it. I cannot afford one. I also would have put insurance on my vehicle. This is my boyfriend's mess, I am just trying to seek options.


r/Insurance • • Oct 15 '23

I got into accident with liability insurance, it was my fault, but other vehicle was driving 15mph above the speed limit. Is there chance for me to file a claim to fix my car?

0 Upvotes

I was turning left on green light, I did not see vehicle coming on the way, and it hit me. Waiting for police report, but other vehicle was driving 15mph above the speed limit. Is there any chance to claim an accident report when I have liability insurance only. My car has a total loss, but is there any chance to request any type of aid from insurance’s?


r/Insurance • • Dec 17 '25

Auto Insurance Sue For Pedestrian Fault Car Accident

14 Upvotes

Last year i had a pedestrian dart out in front of my car on a busy 4 lane road with no intersection, crosswalk or traffic control devices present. They ended needing an ambulance and i had damage to my headlight and bumper. I caught the whole incident on my tesla dash cam and also there were a bunch of witnesses. Police ended up finding the pedestrian at fault after reviewing the evidence. I had to pay my deductible and also wait for my car to be repaired during that time. Is there any way to sue them for financial compensation and/or a diminished value claim on my vehicle against the pedestrian? Maybe their health or renter insurance?


r/Insurance • • Jul 28 '25

Just leased my first car & insurance quotes are outrageous. Anyone know how to get it lower?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

So I’m kinda freaking out and hoping someone here might have advice or has gone through something similar. My husband and I just leased our first car, it's a 2025 honda prologue touring but now we’re struggling to find insurance because the quotes are insane.

We got numbers like $400–$450/month for full coverage, and one site even gave us $998/month 😭. We were expecting something closer to $150–$200/month max. Like the entire lease of the car is $450 we don't want to he paying more than the lease.

Here’s a little about our situation: We’re in California, legally married. The lease is under my husband’s name (he's 27) and I’m the cosigner (im 24)

He moved to the U.S. last year (Feb 2024) and got his California license in August 2024 (he was 26 at the time)

He did have a foreign license before that since he was 20. I’ve had my U.S. license for 7+ years, have a clean record, but I’ve always just been an occasional driver on my sister’s policy, never had my own

I’m also a full-time nursing student about to graduate with my bachelor’s degree in December.

My husband recently got his U.S. barber license and is starting his career here.

We’ve tried Progressive, AAA, Geico, and Insurify but still everything’s either way too expensive or unclear. AAA said my husband doesn’t qualify for lower rates yet since he’s had his U.S. license for less than 1.5 years.

We just wanted to know if there any insurance companies that accept newer drivers or foreign license history? If my student my student status or his barber license can help with any kind of discount?

Also, Why does it feel like everyone wants to charge us more just because we haven’t had prior insurance in our own names? Are we missing something obvious here?!

Any advice or recommendations would be helpful, thanks!

******UPDATE: we found a broker, got full coverage insurance for $189 / month for 100/300/50 coverage through progressive. Thank you to those that helped!


r/Insurance • • Oct 08 '24

Homeowners Insurance A massive tree fell, and my shed caught it. Insurance seems to be fucking me. What do I do?

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I’m located in North Carolina, and during Hurricane Helene, two trees were knocked down. One destroyed about 100 feet of my fence, and the other—a massive, completely healthy tree—fell onto my shed, which is now propping it up. Despite the impact, my shed is about 99% intact, with only a small section of the roof ridge caved in, and it shifted several feet off its pad. From the inside, you can barely notice any damage.

The tree is enormous, and only a professional can safely remove it. I’ve been quoted between $6,200 and $7,500 just to remove the tree from my shed.

From what I understand, North Carolina policies only cover up to $1,000 for tree removal.

Am I expected to cover the remaining cost of the removal myself? The shed needs minor touch-ups, but its structure is still solid. Do I have any options?


r/Insurance • • Mar 12 '25

Who the hell actually benefits from NO FAULT insurance??

0 Upvotes

So I got rear ended for the 3rd time in two years today and I'm pissed. The dude had no money and when the cop came he said since I don't have full coverage there's nothing I can do. Last time I managed to get cash from the dude that rear ended me after I replaced my trunk lid but he wouldn't of been required to.

I do wonder if I can still get money from their insurance since I'm in Michigan, and their license plate was Ohio, and license was Illinois.


r/Insurance • • Nov 17 '25

My boyfriend can’t get his car insured (NJ) any advice?

6 Upvotes

Long story short, he was letting his unlicensed brother drive a car that was under his name. His brother was driving with an expired inspection and got stopped. When he got stopped my boyfriend got a ticket for letting an unlicensed driver drive his car. He was using Cure at the time but then they cancelled his car insurance claiming he had committed insurance fraud bc he was letting uninsured driver use a car under his name. He has tried several insurances and they won’t insure his car due to this same issue. Now he doesn’t know what to do. Any advice?

edit: to everyone that actually tried to help, thank you! he made a stupid mistake trying to help his brother and i assure you he knows better now! <3 to all, hope you get the day you deserve, happy monday :)


r/Insurance • • Oct 21 '25

Rates going up a 100.00 a month for 2 cars. No accidents

2 Upvotes

My agent texted me yesterday to set up a call. He then informed me that my policy was due to renew and that it was gonna go up a hundred dollars. He then proceeded to tell me that he was gonna work some discounts for us to get it back down to what we are already paying. I asked how in the world is it 442.00 a month (currently) for two vehicles 7 and 9 years old. I was paying 360 a month a couple years ago for 5 vehicles and a camper. This is getting out of hand. He said he couldn't find any outstanding reason why it was so high. It isn't like I have sports cars, it's literally a Tahoe and a pickup. At this rate I am about ready to put the state minimum on them. Both cars were paid for with cash. Insurance across the board is out of control. I think a quarter of my annual income goes to insurance (medical, auto, and homeowners).

UPDATE: just so you are aware. I already had a call in to another agent before I even made this post. I am the type of person to ask questions and expect proper good answers when things like this happen. My friend is an agent for FB. He got back to me today with a quote for roughly a 120.00 less a month with increased coverage. And that's without even switching my homeowners. If I had the homeowner's insurance added to them, it will drop the payment down to 307 a month. **UPDATE #2 I ended up switching to my friends company. Homeowners was a bit higher, but it actually has much better coverage. And the auto has increased coverage as well. Thank you all for your comments. I do appreciate it. I guess I the end it was more a venting thing for me. It just makes me sick that these rates have got this out of control. They always want to blame all the claims nation wide, but yet still report record profits.


r/Insurance • • Oct 26 '25

Home Insurance Dropped from insurance: 3 Claims in 5 years due to hail

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: Three hail claims in five years (two roofs, one siding). Travelers is dropping us even though all claims were legitimate. Broker’s looking for new coverage. I'm wondering what to expect and whether the new Class 4 roof helps.

We’ve lived in our home for about 5.5 years (first home) in Omaha, NE, and just found out that Travelers is dropping our homeowners coverage. We’ve had three legitimate hail-related claims since moving in.

• ⁠Aug 2021: Hail → new roof (under Travelers). The roof was actually installed in 2020, but our inspection/mortgage paperwork listed “20” as 20 years old, not 2020. Because of that, our insurance rate was higher than it should’ve been from the start. • ⁠June 2022: Hail → new siding (under Nationwide). The siding was original (22 years old). • ⁠Apr 2025: Hail → new roof again. The 2021 shingles turned out to be the cheapest grade available, which likely didn’t help their durability. This time, we installed Class 4 impact-resistant shingles, and I have documentation proving it.

We’ve always gone through an insurance broker, who’s now shopping for new options. We’re not sure what to expect. Will most insurers decline to take us for a while, or just raise premiums significantly? I know some companies only look at the past 5 years of claims, so by 2026 the first one should drop off, but that doesn’t help us much in the short term.

Each claim exceeded $10K, and with how frequent hail and tornado activity have been across Nebraska in recent years, we didn’t feel safe not filing. Still, I’m reading posts on this sub warning against filing anything short of catastrophic, which has me second-guessing our approach.

My questions:

  1. ⁠What’s realistic to expect when trying to get new coverage after being dropped for multiple weather claims?

  2. ⁠Are there carriers that are more flexible in hail-prone states like Nebraska?

  3. ⁠Does the new Class 4 roof help reduce perceived risk in underwriting?

  4. ⁠Should we look into the state FAIR Plan temporarily if we can’t get standard coverage?

Any insight from agents or people who’ve dealt with similar hail-related issues would really help us plan next steps.

EDIT: Thanks to all who provided advice and opened my eyes to what I can expect. I'm working with my broker to see what we can do next. I can come up with a million excuses and explanations for why I have three claims, but it won't matter—what happened, happened. It was a lack of education, and now I know.

I appreciate all the education I received from most of these comments.

EDIT #2: I worked with a broker who found me some options. Travelers (current): $2,355

What my broker found: Auto-Owners (standard deductible): $3,967 (+68%) AO ($5k deductible): $3,553 (+51%) AO ($10k deductible): $3,321 (+41%)

I still shopped around on my own, and spoke with State Farm and getting the exact same coverage, but with a heavy discount for my new shingles.

State Farm: $2,493 (+6%) They found that my previous claims have been “good” when comparing to the area around me, since we’ve had so much hail and storms. So, I still learned that I need to be wary of filing so many claims. However, grateful I was able to find solid coverage without breaking the bank.


r/Insurance • • Sep 01 '24

Auto Insurance State Farm refused to pay me diminished value

0 Upvotes

This happened last year in 2023.

The other party hit me and 100% their fault. I reached out to their insurance State Farm and they paid for my repair which is $18k.

My car is 2018 Subaru bought it new 32K.

I asked diminished value but State Farm said it’s old car so they don’t pay diminished value.

I bought a DV report from appraiser and sent to State Farm email and asked to compensate me otherwise I will sue their client to small claim court, no reply. I called and they insisted not paying

What should I do?

If I go to small claim court and lost what would be my loss? Court fee? The other party’s attorney fee?


r/Insurance • • 5d ago

I'm paying $1,032 higher premiums than I was paying in 2023 for the same coverage!

0 Upvotes

For my 2023 policy year I paid $1,442 for the same thing I'm now paying $2,474! That's a $1,032/year premium increase!

I had AmFam, but switched to Hastings when AmFam's rates increased, then switched to Erie when Hastings rates increased, and now I've switched to NJM, since Erie's rates increased!

Here's my current P&C insurance picture. 60M, 54F, NW Ohio.

Home
$769 Annual (~$64/mo)
511/51.1/306.6/153.3k Coverages
Full Replacement Dwelling, Personal Items, Roof Hail Damage
10k Sewer/Drain Backup
500k Liability, 5k/Person Med Pmt
$2,500 Ded
──
Auto
$1,301 Annual (~$108/mo)
(2024 Corolla LE $627 (~$52/mo); 2016 Civic EX $674 (~$56/mo))
250/500/100k Liability, 10k/Person Med Pmt
250/500k UM/UIM BI
Includes Roadside & Rental
$100 Comp Ded / $1,000 Coll Ded
──
Umbrella
$386 Annual (~$32/mo)
1000k Liab/1000k UM/UIM
──
$769 Home
$1,301 Auto
$386 Umbrella
──────
$2,456 Total Annual NJM Premium (~$205/mo)
-$36.84 1.5% Capital One CC
──────
$2,419.16 Total Annual NJM Net (~$202/mo)

Jewelry
$56.12 Annual brite.co
Full Replacement $6,934 Ring & $2,038 Ring
-$0.84 1.5% Capital One CC
──────
$55.28 Total Annual brite.co Net

$2,419.16 Total Annual Home & Auto & Umbrella
$55.28 Total Annual Jewelry
──────
$2,474.44 Total Annual Home & Auto & Umbrella & Jewelry (~$206/mo)


r/Insurance • • Oct 12 '24

Homeowners Insurance Wife got mad and threw $20K engagement ring. Is this covered by my personal articles policy?

0 Upvotes

So, my wife got pretty mad at me earlier today and, in her anger, took off her engagement ring (I paid $20K for) and her wedding ring, then dramatically threw them across the house.

I’ve managed to find the wedding ring, but the engagement ring is MIA. To make things worse, we live in an old house with heating grates and all kinds of nooks and crannies for it to hide in.

If we can’t find it, does my personal articles insurance policy have me covered? The ring is appraised and listed on the policy, but I just want to be sure.

Also, bonus points to anyone who can offer advice on how to calm down a very hot-tempered wife.

EDIT: Found the ring after 3 days of searching. It was in this big plant sort of cradled in these stems. I had checked the plant many times but never saw it.


r/Insurance • • Oct 23 '25

Rear ended someone with no visible damage at all and he still filed a police report. What should I do? (Georgia)

1 Upvotes

I rear ended someone today, and there was no damage to their bumper since I bumped him at like 1 mile per hour.

After looking at his bumper, he still called the police, who said that there was practically no damage and a police report wasn’t necessary. Despite this, the guy insisted that a police report be made.

What should I do? Should I still contact and tell my insurance?


r/Insurance • • Jul 05 '25

Home Insurance How can I best protect my home from neighbors' fireworks?

0 Upvotes

I've been going over my insurance policy and it seems to cover fires but there's no specific mention of fireworks or arson or anything. My concern is all of my neighbors who constantly set off fireworks everywhere. I'm worried one day one is going to set our house on fire! How common is this and has anyone ever had their homeowner's insurance pay out for fireworks negligence/fire? Do I need a special clause in my insurance to cover this or is this something basically covered under arson?


r/Insurance • • Nov 21 '25

Does insurance cover ICE busting in your window?

0 Upvotes

Been seeing a lot of posts of ICE breaking car windows and wondered what happens to those people afterward. Does insurance cover the damage?


r/Insurance • • Jan 12 '25

Home Insurance Is it true that Governor Newsom has introduced a cap (ceiling) on building insurance premiums in California?

1 Upvotes

r/Insurance • • Apr 15 '26

Insurance dropped

1 Upvotes

My 2 daughters both got in accidents 4 days apart. The first was my brand new driver, but both drivers were assigned fault on that case.

The second was my other daughter, who was definitely part of a staged accident. The driver of the other car stopped short, refused to let her pull over, stole her license and refused to call the police. When I got to the scene I told him he didn’t have to pull over but she was. He moved over, refused to get off the phone with his friend and demanded $3000. I called the cops after he told me he didn’t know the number for the cops. We offered to fix his 16 year old car with 200k miles, which he accepted. He then decided he had too many injuries. He sent a $100k demand letter to my house after our insurance paid out $9000 for his car. He’s still seeking $100k for pain and injuries. I asked the body shop why the $2000 estimate and he said “I don’t know since he was in 6 accidents in the 8 weeks prior all paid out cash”.

What’s annoying is even with all this information, police cam footage, documents the insurance would rather pay out because its easier.

And now- we’ve been dropped so we are looking for a new insurance, my insurance is going to sky rocket 😩.

Any advice? Who has good rates for a mom with 2 teens.


r/Insurance • • May 04 '25

Auto Insurance Car Insurance company attempting to drop me

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I received a letter from my insurance company(Mapfre) today, regarding 3 accidents in 2024 I had.

First was a not at fault accident(2/8), 0$ paid out. Second, they’re stating i was charged with a driving with a suspended license(2/27), and third was an at fault accident.(12/14)

My first question is regarding the first accident. I was in a multi car crash and was rear ended, went through the other parties insurance and ended up having to sue because of medical. despite the 0$, not at fault accident, how would this fall against me?

Secondly, I did have to go to court for the driving with a suspended license, which was due to me forgetting to renew my registration. I also received this charge two times, once due to forgetting to pay and another from the 2/8 accident. I was able to get the first charge dropped but because the second was so close to the first date, the judge felt like “proving a point,” and found me guilty of the second incident despite both incidents essentially being related to the same suspension.

Is there any way I can prevent my insurance from being terminated in this situation?


r/Insurance • • Dec 13 '25

Adding my 17 year old as a driver

3 Upvotes

I will be adding my son to my current StateFarm policy which covers 2 vehicles-full coverage. Can anyone that recently added a teen to their policy let me know how much the cost went up?

Note: No need for the rude comments. I know it depends on different situations. All I asked for was information on the different increases. Merry Christmas


r/Insurance • • May 05 '25

My dad wants me to sue my mom

0 Upvotes

(17M) Me and my mom were in a bad accident recently, she was driving and hydroplaned into a guard rail and totaled the car. We told my dad and he said “let [my name] sue your insurance so you can get paid.”. What will happen to my mom’s insurance if i went through with it?

Edit: I live with my mom, In New Jersey.

Edit2 : the seatbelt around my stomach pulled me and yanked me so whatever happened to me inside happened, but my dad wants me to say i am hurt too get a check, the crash happened yesterday.

Edit 3: i dont really want to go through with it 100% what would happen to my mom’s insurance.

Edit 4: more specifically the pain is where the seatbelt yanked me at, so around my gut area, the pain pulses and sometimes feels like a gas bubble everything else is fine. No visible bruising.


r/Insurance • • Aug 19 '25

I put my boyfriend and I as “married” on our auto insurance 😬

0 Upvotes

I actually am having an anxiety attack thinking about this lol but here we go. My fiancé m21 and I f21 were shopping for auto insurance around the same time as each other and decided to go with the same provider. I called in and got both of us on a plan together but the agent asked if we were married. I responded and said we weren’t married yet but we’re going to be in the next couple months. He said he was just going to put us as married and at the end of the phone call said “just make sure you get married soon”. Well, we postponed our wedding to next June because of some things that came up and the other night I was thinking about the insurance and this HUGE feeling of guilt came over me because of this. I google it and it said that it could be counted as insurance fraud and potentially denied claims. I don’t know what to do!! I feel completely awful about the whole thing and I dont want to call them and make the mess worse 🫥 this has actually been keeping me up at night 😭I NEED ADVICE PLEASE!!!